Code Case N-318-5 Lug Attachment Local Stress Evaluation

Project: Perry
Support: E12-H143
Pipe:

Calculation:
Node: 36
DO =

12" Sch 20
B1 =

Stress Indices:

Z=
Material:
Sh =
Lugs:

304 SS
16900 psi
3

Length (in)=

1E12-G007A

12.750

in.

Rev:

T=
B2 =

0.50

A-01

0.250

in.

1.00

I=

1.00

30.68 in
Maximum Temp=
SA= 27725
1.5

Width (in) =

0
275 F

psi

Sy=

23175

Number of Sides Welded:

psi
2

Weld Properties:
Weld type: Fillet = 1, Partial Pen = 2, Full Pen = 3:
1
Weld Size: 0.2500
Kl =
3.6
(3.6 for fillet or part. pen. welds on two or 3 sides, 2.0 for welds on 4 sides or full pen. welds)
2
3
AW= 1.0605 in
Zwd= 0.5303 in
Zwl=

0.7954

Piping Properties:
Do = 12.750
t =
0.250

in3

Zwt=

in
in

g = r/t =
b1 = L1/r =

25.000
0.1200

La = lesser of L2 & t =

b2 = L2/r =

0.2400

Lc = lesser of L1 & L2 =

0.750

Ld = greater of L1 & L2 =

1.500

0.8300

in3

r =
2L1 =

6.2500

in

1.500

in (width)

L1 =

0.750

2L2 =

3.000

in (length)

L2 =

1.500

DO / t =

51.00
b1 <= 0.5

Check:

Piping Parameters:
Load
Thrust
Longitudinal moment
Circumferential moment

(b1) (b2) =

0.029

b2 <= 0.5

(b1)(b2) <= 0.075

DO / t < 100

q (deg.)

A0
2.2
2.0
1.8

Lb = lesser of L1 & t =

40
50
40

0.25
0.25

xo
0
-0.45
-0.75

yo
0.05
-0.55
-0.60

OK
OK

x1
-0.921
-1.371
-1.671

y1
-0.570
-1.170
-1.220

x1 = xo + log10 b1
y1 = yo + log10 b2
h = -(x1 cosq + y1 sinq) - 1/A0 ( x1 sinq - y1 cosq)

CT = 3.82(g)1.64 b1 b2 h1.54 > 1.0

CT =
1.74

CL = 0.26(g)

23.63
b1 (b2)2 h4.74 > 1.0

CL =

6.59
CN = 0.38(g)1.90 (b1)2 b2 h3.40 > 1.0
CN =

6.87

BT = (2/3)CT > 1.0 =

15.75

BL = (2/3)CL > 1.0 =

4.39

BN =(2/3)CN > 1.0 =

4.58

Al = 4L1L2 =

4.500
2

ZlL = (4/3)L1(L2) =

2.250

ZlN = (4/3)(L1)2 L2 =

1.125

h
1.061
1.733
2.053

Loading:
Pdesign=

300

PMax=

psi

300

psi

Normal PrimaryLoads:
Q1 =

lbs

Q2 =

3217

lbs

W=

lbs

Ml= 2412.75 in-lbs

Mn=
0
in-lbs
Mt=
0
in-lbs

Weight Stress =
B2MA/Z=
102

psi

Upset Primary Loads:

Q1 =

lbs

Q2 =

3397

lbs

W=

lbs

Ml= 2547.75 in-lbs

Mn=
0
in-lbs
Mt=
0
in-lbs

Upset Primary Stress =

B2(MA+MB)/Z=
1071
psi

Ml= 2547.75 in-lbs

Mn=
0
in-lbs
Mt=
0
in-lbs

Emergency Primary Stress =

B2(MA+MB)/Z=
1071
psi

Emergency Primary Loads:

Q1 =

lbs

Q2 =

3397

lbs

W=

lbs

Faulted Primary Loads:

Q1 =
Q2 =
W=

lbs

Ml= 2621.625 in-lbs

3495.5

lbs

Mn=

in-lbs

lbs

Mt=

in-lbs

Ml= 2830.125 in-lbs

Mn=
0
in-lbs
Mt=
0
in-lbs

Faulted Primary Stress =

B2(MA+MB)/Z=
1536
psi

Secondary Loads:
Q1 =

lbs

Q2 =

3773.5

lbs

W=

lbs

Normal Primary + Secondary Stress =

.75i(MA/Z)+I(MC/Z)=
3115
psi

Absolute Maximum Loads:

Q1**=
**

Q2 =
W **=

0
4052
0

lbs

Ml**=

3039

in-lbs

lbs

**

Mn =

in-lbs

lbs

Mt**=

in-lbs

MT = greater of MT/LcLd t(1+(Lc/Ld)) or MT/(0.8 + 0.05(Ld/Lc))Lc2Ld

MT =

in-lbs (Normal Primary)

MT =

in-lbs (Upset Primary)

MT =

in-lbs (Emergency Primary)

MT =

in-lbs (Faulted Primary)

MT =

in-lbs (Secondary)

MT** =

in-lbs (Absolute Maximum)

Local Stress Evaluation on Piping:

Equation

Local
Stress
(psi)

Moment
Stress
(psi)

Pressure
Stress
(psi)

Combined
Stress
(psi)

Allowable
Stress
(psi)

Ratio

Normal Primary

Sml=

8998

102

3825

12925

Upset Primary

Sml=

9501

1071

3825

14397

1.5Sh=

25350

0.510

30420

0.473

38025

0.379

lesser of
1.8Sh,1.5Sy=
lesser of

Emergency Primary

Sml=

9501

1071

3825

14397

2.25Sh,1.8Sy=

lesser of

Sml=

9777

1536

3825

15138

3.0Sh,2.0Sy=

46350

0.327

Sml+Spl/2=

32967

3115

3825

39907

Sh+SA=

44625

0.894

Maximum Loading

Snl**=

14299

14299

2.0Sy=

46350

0.308

Maximum Loading

Eq. 6=

5403

5403

1.0Sy=

23175

0.233

Faulted Primary
Normal Prim. + Sec.

Weld Evaluation:
Full Penetration Weld - No Weld Evaluation required
Partial Penetration Weld - Weld Evalution Required as shown below:
Fillet Weld - Weld Evaluation Required as shown below:
Equation

Weld Stress (psi)

Allowable Stress (psi) Ratio

Max. Load Eq. 7

13373

2.0Sy=

46350

0.289

Max. Load Eq. 8

7642

1.0Sy=

23175

0.330

Conclusions:
Local stresses due to the welded attachments meet the Code Case N-318-5 allowable limits.