Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 1

QUESTIONS TO AMIR LIQAT:-

AMIR LIAQAT IS A PROBLEMATIC PERSON. HIS VIEWS ARE SOME WHAT ITHNA ASHRI SHITE AND SOME WHAT ZADIAH SHIITE. ABUT SOME PEOPLE THINK THAT HE IS A SUNNI INSPIRED BY SHIITE SECTS OF ZAIDIAH AND ITHNA ASHRIAH . SO WE HAVE SET A NUMBER OF QUESTIONS SO THAT IT MAY BE DECIEDED WITH CERTAINITY WHAT HE ACTUALLY IS.?
1] DO YOU [ O AMIR LIAQAT] BELIEVE THAT HAZRAT MUAAVIAH RADIYALLAHU ANHU WAS A GREAT SAHABI ,INSPITE OF ALL DIFFERENCES FROM HAZRAT ALI RADIYALLAHUANHU AND WAR OF S-FFIN.? 2]DO YOU [O AMIR LIAQAT BELIEVE THAT HAZRAT MUAVIAH RADIYALLAHU ANHU WAS BATIL AGAINST HAZRAT ALI RADI YALLAHU ANHU OR WAS ONLY IN AN ERROR OF IJTIHAAD.? 3]DO YOU BELIEVE THAT SUUIS ARE RIGHT ON THE MATTER OF GARDEN OF F-D-K OR OTHA ASHRI CULT OF SHIITE SECT ARE COORECT ON THE ISSUE OF GARDEN OF F-D-K.? 4] DO YOU THING ALI RADI YALLAH ANHU WAS COMPELLED TO DO BAIT OF HAZRAT ABU BAKR RADI YALLAH ANU OR HE VOLUNTARILY DID IT.? 5]DO YOU [ O AMIR LIAQAT] BELIEVE THAT THE TRADITION WHICH ALLEGES THAT HAZRAT UMAR RADI YALLAHU ANHU DID HURT HAZRAT FAT-MAH RADI YALLAHU ANHA AND THIS CAUSED THE ABORTION OF AN UNBORN CHILD ALLEGEDLY NAMED AS MUHSIN. 6] DO YOU [ O AMIR LIAQAT] BELIEVE IN THE TRADITION OF ABU M-KHN-F WHICH ALLEGES THAT HAZRAT AMT BIN AL AAS RADIYALLAHU ANHU DID DECIEVE HAZRAT ABU MUSA AL ASH ARI IN THE EVENT OF THE TAHKEEM. IN THE CASE [ O AMIR LIAQAT] IF YOU DO BELIEVE, THEN HOW DO YOU INTERPRET THE WHOLE EVENT AT LEAST TO SAVE THE SACREMENTS ,SANCTITY AND SAHAABIAT OF HAZRAT AMR BIN AL AAS RADI YALLAH ANHU.? IN THE CASE YOU ACCEPT THIS TRADITION DO YOU THINK IT WAS AN ERROT OF IJTIHAAD OR NOT? 7]DO YOU BELIEVE [ O AMIR LIAQAT] IN THE TRADITION WHICH ALLEGES THAT THE MOTHER OF HAZRAT AMR BIN AL AAS RADI YALLAHU ANHU WAS OF IMMORAL CHARACTER, AND WHAT DO YOU SAY ABOUT THE INCIRRECT TRADITIONS WHCI ALLEGE THAT HE [RD] WAR NOT A LEGITIMATE CHILD EITHER. [NAUDHU BILLAH]? 8] DO YOU AGREE WITH MAUDUDIS KHILAFATO MULUKIAT ANF MALIK GHULAM ALIS DEFEND OF SHIITE MINDED MAUDIDI (1)OR DO YOU AGREE WITH HAZRAT MUAVIAH RADI YALLAHU ANHU AUR TAREEKHI HAQAIQ OF ALLAMAH TAQI UTHMANI AND MAQAM SAHABAH OF HIS NOBLE FATHER AND GREAT SUNNI SCHOLOR OF PAKISTAN MUFTI SHFI RAHMATULLAH ALAIH. 9] DO YOU BELIEVE IN SAHIH BUKHARI OR USUL E KAFI A AND FARU E KAFI. .? 10] DO YOU THINK THE ITHNA ASHRI BOOK NAHJUL B-LAGHAH [ WRITTEN BY SHREEF RAZIAND SHRIF MURTADA/MURTAZA] AS UNAUTHENTIC OR AUTHENTIC? 11] DO YOU [ O AMIR LIAQAT ] BELIEVE THAT IMAM AHMAD BIN HANBAL RAHMATULLAH ALAIH WAS RIGHT WHEN HE CLAIMED THAT QURAN IS NOT A CREATION OF ALLAH SUBHAANAHU WA TAALAA? 12] a) DO YOU BELIEVE THAT MAHDI IS THE SON OF HAZRAT HASAN ASKARI RAHMATULLAH ALAIH OR THE MADI IS NOT YET BORN. b) DO YOU BELIEVE IN THE SUPER NATURAL EXTENTION OF THE LIFE OF MAHDI OR CONSIDER IT AS PROOFLESS. c) DO YOU [ O AMIR LIAQAT] THAT MAHDI IS AFDAL THAN ANY ONE OF SAHABAH [ RADI YALLAHU ANHU].

NOW WE COME TO A VERY IMPORTANT SET OF QUESTIONS:1] DO YOU BELIEVE [ O AMIR LIAQAT] THAT SAIYADNA UTHMAN\USMAN RADIYALLAHU ANHU IS AFDAL\AFZAL THAN HAZRAT HUSAIN RADI YALLAHU ANHU.? 2]DO YOU BELIEVE THAT KILLERS [QATILUN] OF HAZRAT UTHMAN RADI YALLAHU ANHU ARE WORSE THAN KILLERS OF HAZRAT HUSAIN RADI YALLAHU ANHU OR VICE VERSA OR BOTH ARE EQUALLY BAD. 3] DO YOU [ O AMIR LIAQAT] BELIEVE THAT KILLERS OF HAZRAT UTHMAN RARI YALLAHU ANHU WERE KAFIR OR MUMIN?

MORE QUESTIONS SHALL BE ASKED SOON TO BE CONTINUED.. (1) Maududi was not a Ithna Ashri Shia but it has been established that he was inspired by Zaidiah Sect of Shiah on the issues of Some Sahabah Radi Yallahu Anhu. How ever his defender Malik Ghulam Ali was not a Sunni . He was out of the folds of Sunnism as according to AhlulHadith, Barailvis and Diobandis.[ The name of these sects are written as according to ARABIC ALPHABETICAL ORDER]