Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
INVESTORIssue 3 GUIDE
Investor Guide
January 2011
Being rich is having money; being wealthy is having time Margaret Bonnano
History is irrelevant
Just because a scrip traded at a particular level some time ago doesn't give it the right to be back there again. The world is changing rapidly, regulations are driving differential economics and resources are becoming scarcer- and therefore individual companies who had substantial hold earlier in their market spheres are facing a dramatically altered world where their existence may be challenged. In some areas like technology, this is evident immediately while in other industries like FMCG and Pharma, these challenges may be less evident in the short term. Dont make the mistake of missing the broad trends that are shaping industries and therefore, dont make the mistake of assuming history will repeat itself. When an investment sounds at odds with the above five principles, be merciless and exit it without remorse. Holding something that you will not have conviction in , based on your own selection of investment principles, is an investment you should not be making.
Page 2
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 3
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 4
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 5
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 6
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 7
INVESTOR GUIDE
Consensus Opinion
The Stock Screener
2010 was a fairly volatile year, and with the market having its share of volatility stock picking became the key to making money. 2011 promises to be even more volatile, and bottom up stock picking could be the key to making money in the markets. In this issue, we cover what the analyst world things about the BSE 500 space.
Bullish Views
Stocks tracked by 15 analysts or more with 90% or more of them having a Buy reco on the same. Script Ahluwalia Contracts Ltd Usha Martin Ltd Cesc Ltd Patel Engineering Ltd Tulip Telecom Ltd Indiabulls Real Estate Ltd Welspun Corp Ltd Bgr Energy Systems Ltd Allahabad Bank Havells India Ltd Jaiprakash Associates Ltd Ipca Laboratories Ltd Asian Paints Ltd Indusind Bank Ltd Sobha Developers Ltd United Phosphorus Ltd Sector Housing Related Capital Goods Power Housing Related Information Technology Housing Related Metal,Metal Products & Mining Capital Goods Finance Capital Goods Housing Related Healthcare Chemical & Petrochemical Finance Housing Related Agriculture % Buy Recos 100.0% 100.0% 96.2% 96.2% 95.5% 95.2% 95.2% 93.5% 93.3% 93.3% 92.3% 91.3% 90.9% 90.5% 90.0% 90.0% Analyst (Total) 16 16 26 26 22 21 21 31 15 15 26 23 22 21 20 20
Bearish Views
Stocks tracked by 15 analysts or more with 40% or more of them having a Sell recommendation on the same. Script Areva T&D India Ltd National Aluminium Co Ltd Reliance Power Ltd Bajaj Hindusthan Ltd Abb Ltd Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Tata Communications Ltd Ambuja Cements Ltd Punj Lloyd Ltd Nestle India Ltd Ultratech Cement Ltd Hindustan Unilever Ltd India Cements Ltd Acc Ltd Reliance Comm. Ltd Siemens India Ltd Voltamp Transformers Ltd Mindtree Ltd Container Corp Of India Ltd Tech Mahindra Ltd Sector Capital Goods Metal,Metal Products & Mining Power Agriculture Capital Goods Telecom Telecom Housing Related Capital Goods Fmcg Housing Related Fmcg Housing Related Housing Related Telecom Capital Goods Capital Goods Information Technology Transport Services Information Technology Analyst (Total) 15 33 18 16 36 16 15 51 31 30 52 40 40 54 43 21 15 25 19 36 % Sell Recos 93.3% 84.8% 83.3% 81.3% 80.6% 75.0% 66.7% 58.8% 58.1% 56.7% 55.8% 55.0% 55.0% 50.0% 48.8% 47.6% 46.7% 44.0% 42.1% 41.7%
Page 8
INVESTOR GUIDE
Please note that these are statistical data derived from analyst consensus estimates on the BSE 500 companies. This is not a recommendation. Please speak to our investment advisors before taking positions.
Page 9
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 10
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 11
INVESTOR GUIDE
Where's My Money!
Comparing Portfolio Performances in 2011
The BSE Sensex has been very noisy this year - delivering in the teens and creating a buzz as it usually does. But quite a few portfolios have not delivered as well as they might. With Midcaps coming under pressure and Real Estate stocks hammered and PSUs and metals not delivering well year on year, there were quite a few things that did not go well. And so , quite a few investors are still wondering where their money went if the markets are seemingly doing so well! From our analysis, it looks like the Sensex is still trading at below 19500 levels (actual value 20,500 on 31 December 2010) if one looks at the values of the Sensex constituents and when they last reached their current price levels. On an average, the individual scrips have not kept pace with the BSE Sensex - with 10 of the 30 scrips that make up the BSE Sensex trading below the value of the Sensex at that time, when these first reached their current price levels. Major criminals include stocks like Reliance Infrastructure, BHEL and RCOM which are trading at the same prices when the BSE Sensex was trading around 16000 levels and lower. So if your portfolio had these three scrips only, you would have been left confused why your portfolio's not making money when the rest of the world is seeing a 25% return! ONGC, Reliance Industries, Larsen and Toubro, JP Associates have also lagged behind trading around 18000 level equivalent prices. Only the banking , information technology pack and healthcare , apart from M&M, have kept pace with the Sensex and moved ahead with banks, despite recent corrections ahead of the current Sensex levels - with M&M trading at almost 20,800 levels. This points to the intense sector churn that has happened in the previous 3 months - while the BSE Sensex remained within the 20,000 range, the sector fortunes changed dramatically. And may continue doing so into the next year. The first quarter of next year may possibly change the equations as policies around oil and gas become clearer, which affects 18% of the market capitalisation of the BSE Sensex, and the headwinds for financials (23% weight in BSE Sensex), which is looking at an uncertain USD/INR, housing price declines and margin squeezes, may affect individual portfolios even if the BSE Sensex doesn't do much. In fact, on a consensus view, markets seem to have a 10% upside from current levels so returns would have to be generated from a careful stock selection strategy , taking into account specifics of the company as well as a top down view, with substantial difference in performances even within sectors also another given. Another thing that is making it difficult for performance to be judged against the BSE Sensex is the lopsided nature of the index - with half the scrips in the index not even accounting for 30% weightage, similar to the top 3 scrips- this creates a very volatile benchmark against which it is difficult to judge the actual performance of most portfolios as risk preferences and future world views differ. It would therefore be better if clients define their risk preference besides their returns preference versus the chosen index so that the value of diversification and risk reduction is better represented in the meetings with advisors than it would only if returns were compared. On the other hand, aggressive investors should probably benchmark against a broader index and not the BSE Sensex or the S&P Nifty. Another possible option, given the dramatic difference in performances, is that investors look at allocating a definitive percentage to Index funds and ETFs in their portfolios to ensure that they get exposure to the market truly for a certain % of the portfolio. This is especially true for investors who are sensitive to relative performances of stock portfolios and are investing into mutual funds, which are finding it extremely difficult to beat indices. And yes, a careful regular review of the portfolio with the advisor is more important now than ever before! An hour a quarter would bring clarity on performance and why it lags or stays ahead of indices and what risk is embedded into portfolios. And rid you of unnecessary worries when relatives and TV News anchors blare out why most people are making money - because its likely they may not be! If you have selected a quality portfolio , dont worry about markets every second day - remember that most investors who make money in markets are the buy and hold variety and not the daily traders who wish to stay ahead of markets every day and lose several years of savings in the bargain!
Page 12
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 13
INVESTOR GUIDE
Page 14
INVESTOR GUIDE
In our opinion, if an investor follows the following conditions before initiating an SIP , she should be laughing her way to the bank in a few year's time: 1) Should have a fundamental belief that Indian markets will do well in the long term and can be highly volatile in the medium term; 2) 3) Should be willing to continue the SIP no matter how much the markets drop Should be investing into good quality midcap funds, managed by well respected fund managers
Counterintuitive? But True! Total Units Market Value Cost of Investment Returns 37.66 3765.89 3600.00 4.61% 38.02 3801.94 3600.00 5.61% 38.47 3846.63 3600.00 6.85% 33.67 3366.76 3600.00 -6.48%
Page 15
INVESTOR GUIDE
We believe the global economy is not yet completely out of the woods as the data would have to strengthen considerably, especially given headwinds from Europe and the fear of an inflationary bubble keeping the lid on runaway markets. We expect markets to watch post holiday data carefully to gauge whether recoveries were one off and an immediate reaction to the easing programmes or are more sustained in nature. Spikes in interest rates as a function of capital flows / return to risk aversion are therefore not ruled out and we remain negative on long term bonds.
To access our short term tips via SMS or research reports via mail or to unsubscribe from any of our mailing lists, please mail us your request at customer.care@pinc.co.in with your Client ID. For our latest research reports, please visit www.pincmoney.com This publication is for private publication only. Each recipient of this document should make such investigations as it deems necessary to arrive at an independent evaluation of an investment in the securities of companies referred to in this document (including the merits and risks involved), and should consult its own advisors to determine the merits and risks of such an investment. The investment discussed or views expressed may not be suitable for all investors The information contained herein is obtained and collated from sources believed reliable and PINC has not independently verified all the information given in this document. Accordingly, no representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the accuracy, completeness or fairness of the information and opinions contained in this document