Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
School Configuration Committee (SCC) Board Study Session Update II November 13, 2012 (Update VII)
TFR Updates
9/28/11 10/26/11 11/22/11 1/25/12 9/12/12
Study Sessions
4/25/12 11/13/12
Purpose
Agenda
Review Timelines Review Tasks Review Definitions Review Facts, Assumptions, Considerations and Key
Questions 7-12 Pros and Cons DRAFT Costs of Facilities for Each Option In Progress Way Ahead
Committee Membership
Elem School Name First Peggy Philip Sheri Cheri Tim Debbie Greg Denyse Ann Anne Julie Ann Scott Franklyn Steve Jo Laurie Name Last Ellis Wetherby Shipe Mlodzik McNett Allensworth Cleven Hemmersbach Sveen Lunden McKean Hoftiezer Woehrman MacKenzie Coons Conner Moore
Elem School Group Name First Susan Linda Andy Jeremy Carla J. R. Jodie Doyle John Matt Laura Jeanne David Patti Sue Nate Kari Kirstin Katie Name Last Jung Roberts Campbell Faxon Yenko Fernandez Woolf Clouser McGannon Stanford Murray Beckon McVicker Woolf Corey Andrews Clithero Nicholson Coleman Yes Administrator Yes Classified - Sec Yes Certificated - sec Yes Certificated - sec Yes Classified - Sec Yes Parent Yes Adminstrator - Sec Yes Adminstrator - Sec Yes Parent Yes Certificated - sec Yes Parent NO Administrator NO Administrator NO Administrator NO Administrator NO Bargaining Unit NO Bargaining Unit NO Bargaining Unit Yes Administrator
or Sec Affiliation Voting? Group Elem Admin Yes Administrator Elem BR Elem CC Elem PI Elem CV Elem EH Elem EM Elem EM Elem GM Elem JP Elem SR Elem SR Elem EM Sec Admin Sec CKHS Sec CKHS Sec CKHS Yes Certificated - elem Yes Certificated - elem Yes Classified - elem Yes Certificated Yes Certificated - elem Yes Adminstrator - Elem Yes Certificated - elem Yes Parent Yes Parent Yes Adminstrator - Elem Yes Parent Yes Parent Yes Administrator Yes Administrator Yes Classified - sec Yes Parent
or Sec Affiliation Voting? Sec CKJH Sec CKJH Sec FVJH Sec FVJH Sec FVJH Sec FVJH Sec KSS Sec OHS Sec OHS Sec RIJH Sec RIJH n/a Admin n/a Admin n/a Admin n/a Admin n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a Special Ed
SchoolConfigurationWork SY201213
Oct15 712Pros/Cons Facilities Definitions Communication 712Clarification Committee Replacement Nov26 Staffing Dec10 Extracurricular Feb11 Curriculum SpecialPrograms Mar11 Apr22 Analyzeinput June3 ReviewSupt. Recommendation
Oct29 Facilities
KEY
SchoolBoard Staff/CommunityMeeting 6
SchoolConfigurationOtherMajorEvents
CapitalProjectsLevyPhaseOne(20122016)
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
HB2776and 2661Full Implementation
2018
SCCWork
(Oct2012June 2013)
FacilitiesCommittee Work
(Sept2013Jan2015)
PhaseIIElection Planning
(Feb2015Feb2016)
KEY
DistrictEvent CommunityEvent Technology(CPL) RepairsAcrossDistrict(CPL) 7
SCC 2012-13 Tentative Meeting Calendar S 2 9 16 23 30 S 2 9 16 23 30 S 3 10 17 24 31 M 3 10 17 24 Sep-12 T W T 4 11 18 25 5 12 19 26 6 13 20 27 F 7 14 21 28 S 1 8 15 22 29 S 7 14 21 28 M 1 8 15 22 29 Oct-12 T W T 2 3 4 9 10 11 16 17 18 23 24 25 30 31 Jan-13 T W T 1 2 3 8 9 10 15 16 17 22 23 24 29 30 31 Apr-13 T W T 2 3 4 9 10 11 16 17 18 23 24 25 30 F 5 12 19 26 S 6 13 20 27 S 4 11 18 25 30 S 3 10 17 24 M 5 12 19 26 31 M 4 11 18 25 Nov-12 T W T 1 6 7 8 13 14 15 20 21 22 27 28 29 Feb-13 T W T 5 12 19 26 6 13 20 27 7 14 21 28 F 2 9 16 23 30 S 3 10 17 24
M 3 10 17 24 31 M 4 11 18 25
Dec-12 T W T 4 11 18 25 5 12 19 26 6 13 20 27
F 7 14 21 28
S 1 8 15 22 29
S 6 13 20 27
M 7 14 21 28
F 4 11 18 25
S 5 12 19 26
F 1 8 15 22
S 2 9 16 23
Mar-13 T W T 5 12 19 26 6 13 20 27 7 14 21 28
F 1 8 15 22 29
S 2 9 16 23 30
S 7 14 21 28
M 1 8 15 22 29
F 5 12 19 26
S 6 13 20 27
S 12 19 S 2 9
M 13 20 M 3 10
May-13 T W T 14 15 16 21 22 23 Jun-13 T W T 4 5 6 11 12 13
F 17 24 F 7 14
S 18 25 S 8 15
Phase II
Phase III
Phase IV
10
Definitions
Extracurricular is defined as optional non-credit student
connected to a curricular program. Examples are DECA, FCCLA, Choir, Journalism, Newspaper, Yearbook, Band, Drama, The Orchestra Middle Level We will not use Middle School Grades 5-8, 6-8, 7-8 Junior High Grades 7-9
11
Facts
After much study, the School Configuration Committee (SCC) is reviewing three alternate configuration options 9th graders will move up to high school in both all alternate configurations Transitions impact student achievement Current Junior High and High School buildings have additional capacity. Few elementary schools have additional capacity The School Board will make a decision after receiving a recommendation from the Superintendent following review of all data, options, and pros and cons from the SCC including feedback opportunities for community and staff
12
Facts
Implementation of any changes would begin not sooner than 201516 2012 Demographic Study indicates that enrollment will continue to decline slightly for five years and then level-off Other districts have studied configuration, and for the most part have gone to a K-5, 6-8, 9-12 A configuration decision will be required to complete the Facilities Committee work on Phase Two of the Capital Projects Long Range Plan HB 2776 includes recommendations for reductions in K-3 class size and statewide implementation of All Day Kindergarten The Superintendents recommendation is scheduled for June 2013
13
Assumptions
One or more schools may close Over time, reconfiguration will provide a savings In terms of infrastructure and organizational resources,
14
Considerations
Early identification of individual student needs for
support/intervention Maximize options for student achievement Professional Development support and time Emotional impact for students, families, staff Balanced and efficient enrollments Improve feeder system Voter Confidence- timing of 2014 SSL election Implementation plan Grading Model integration Cost integration with Capital Projects Phase Two Time on the bus
15
Considerations
Athletic and activity programs High School Athletic Classifications
(1A, 2A, 3A, 4A) Building start and end times Capacity for gym space, science labs, art classrooms, music performance, special education and specialized Career and Technical Education (CTE) courses Non-District (ND) and Non-School (NS) transfer student data (in and out) along with student data for enrollment in online programs outside the district Grandfathering of current transfers
16
Key Questions
What are optimal building sizes? Elementary 450-500, Middle/JH 700-900, HS 1100-1300 What does the demographic study tell us about our future
enrollment?
Enrollment will continue to slowly decline over the next five years
mostly at the secondary level before leveling out somewhere above 10,000 students.
What is the capacity for each building? See additional worksheets (link) What facility modifications will be required and how will we pay
for them?
Depends upon which configuration is selected. Modifications will
require Capital Projects Funds. Currently, all funds are committed except future Emergent Critical Repairs, which means that modifications would need to be included in Capital Projects Phase II
17
Key Questions
How will configuration meet the need of special education,
including preschool? Does reconfiguration for all schools need to occur simultaneously? Will either option produce potential school closure?
If the current class sizes (or close to current) continue, most
options will produce a potential school closure. If K-3 class size is reduced, this answer could change based on the state funding, configuration selected and Capital Projects Phase II
same bus?
18
Are clean feeders a requirement to our boundaries? Any boundary changes have not been completed. There are benefits for clean feeders, yet this may not be possible when boundaries are redrawn. What impact do NS/ND students have on creating new
boundaries?
None. The option for NS and ND students waivers will be
19
Montessori, Venture, Special Education)? What is the plan for implementation for the transfer/moving process?
The implementation plan will be developed following a determination
20
21
22
23
Summary of Costs
2 2 -1 -1 ,9 ,9 A -8 B -8 E -12 n n n i o 6, 7 i o 5, 6 i o 6, 7 pt pt pt O KO KO KS KS 12 7S KS , 12 6) ls oo h sc ll (a s 12 er 7 - ion ) th d t lo al an ura 2 SS ") -1 fig (K us 10 co n , F -12 mp -9 nt n i o 6, 7 "ca , 7 urre 6 pt K- (c O K- as
MaximizeStudent Achievement
BoardCriteria
Staffing Efficiency
Staffing
Equity
Program Impact
Facilities
Safety
24
Elementary
ClassroomsAvailable ClassroomsNeeded IncreasedStaffingCosts(ADK) IncreasedStaffingCosts(17:1) SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost 10 0
Costs Savings
$0 $0
Elementary
10 4610=36** 14sections+1.0Specialist 46+5=51 None 1smallschool
Costs Savings
$0.00
Budget Impacted
Secondary
ScienceLabsNeeded GymSpaceNeeded Art,Music,SpecialEd,CTEModifications SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost GeneralFundAddedCosts/Savings CapitalProjectsAddedCosts/Savings ScienceLab 1LabCKHS KSS(Phase2)"current" Nonerequired Uptoone(1) 2smallschools
Costs Savings
$300,000
Secondary
1LabCKHS KSS(Phase2)"current" Nonerequired
Costs Savings
Budget Impacted
$1,000,000
Uptoone 2smallschools
$3,900,000 CapitalProj
**Otheroptioninlieuof1823portableswouldbeanotherelementaryschool=approx$27,500,000in2012dollars Ifthisoptionwasselected,thetotalCapitalProjectscostswouldbe$27.5M+$1.8M+$300K=$29,600,000
25
OptionB:K5,68,912,612KSS
Assumptions Current1213ClassSize ADKPaidbyState NoSecBoundaryChanges IncludesSpaceforADK Assumptions K3ClassSize17:1 NoSecBoundChanges ADKPaidbyState IncludesSpaceforADK
Elementary
ClassroomsAvailable ClassroomsNeeded IncreasedStaffingCosts(ADK) IncreasedStaffingCosts(17:1) SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost(noclosure) 41 0 14sections+1.0Specialist 0 Uptotwo(2) 7smallschools
Costs Savings
$0 $0 $75,000 $0 $1,600,000
Elementary
10 4641=5 14sections+1.0Specialist 46+5=51 Uptoone(1)Closure Adds19Portables## 7smallschools
Costs Savings
$0.00
Budget Impacted
Secondary
ScienceLabsNeeded GymSpaceNeeded Art,Music,SpecialEd,CTEModifications SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost GeneralFundAddedCosts/Savings CapitalProjectsAddedCosts/Savings ScienceLab/Gym 1LabCKHS KSSGym** Nonerequired None None(enrollment?)
Costs Savings
$300,000 $3,000,000
Secondary
1LabCKHS KSSGym** Nonerequired None None(enrollment?)
Costs Savings
Budget Impacted
$1,525,000 $3,300,000
$3,700,000 CapitalProj
26
OptionE:K6,712AllBldgs
Assumptions Current1213ClassSize ADKPaidbyState NoElemBoundaryChanges IncludesSpaceforADK Assumptions K3ClassSize17:1 NoElemBoundChanges ADKPaidbyState IncludesSpaceforADK
Elementary
ClassroomsAvailable ClassroomsNeeded IncreasedStaffingCosts(ADK) IncreasedStaffingCosts(17:1) SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost(noclosure) 10 0 14sections+1.0Specialist 0 None 1smallschool
Costs Savings
$0 $0 $75,000 $0 $0
Elementary
10 4610=36** 14sections+1.0Specialist 46+5=51 None 1smallschool
Costs Savings
$0.00
Budget Impacted
Secondary
ScienceLabsNeeded GymSpaceNeeded GymSpaceNeeded Art,Music,SpecialEd,CTEModifications SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost GeneralFundAddedCosts/Savings CapitalProjectsAddedCosts/Savings ScienceLab/Gym 1LabCKHS KSSGym## CKHS,OHS,RTJH## Nonerequired Uptotwo(2) None(enrollment?)
Costs Savings
$300,000 $3,000,000 $9,000,000 $2,000,000
Secondary
1LabCKHS KSSGym** CKHS,OHS,RTJH Nonerequired Uptotwo(2) None(enrollment?)
Costs Savings
$300,000
Budget Impacted
CapitalProj
$3,000,000 CapitalProj $9,000,000 CapitalProj CapitalProj $2,000,000 GenFund GenFund $1,670,000 GenFund
$15,900,000 CapitalProj
27
OptionF:K6,712Campus
Assumptions Current1213ClassSize ADKPaidbyState NoElemBoundaryChanges IncludesSpaceforADK Assumptions K3ClassSize17:1 NoElemBoundChanges ADKPaidbyState IncludesSpaceforADK
Elementary
ClassroomsAvailable ClassroomsNeeded IncreasedStaffingCosts(ADK) IncreasedStaffingCosts(17:1) SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost(noclosure) 10 0 14sections+1.0Specialist 0 None 1smallschool
Costs Savings
$0 $0 $75,000 $0 $0
Elementary
10 4610=36** 14sections+1.0Specialist 46+5=51 None 1smallschool
Costs Savings
$0.00
Budget Impacted
Secondary
ScienceLabsNeeded GymSpaceNeeded Art,Music,SpecialEd,CTEModifications SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost GeneralFundAddedCosts/Savings CapitalProjectsAddedCosts/Savings ScienceLab/Gym 1LabCKHS KSS(PhaseTwo)"current" Nonerequired Uptoone(1) None(enrollment?)
Costs Savings
$300,000
Secondary
1LabCKHS KSS(PhaseTwo)"current" Nonerequired
Costs Savings
$300,000
Budget Impacted
CapitalProj CapitalProj CapitalProj
$1,000,000
Uptoone(1) None(enrollment?)
$1,000,000
GenFund GenFund
$670,000
GenFund
$3,900,000 CapitalProj
28
Current:K6,79,1012,KSS712
Assumptions Current1213ClassSize ADKPaidbyState Elementary ClassroomsAvailable ClassroomsNeeded IncreasedStaffingCosts(ADK) IncreasedStaffingCosts(17:1) SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost(noclosure) JuniorHighSchool ScienceLabsNeeded GymSpaceNeeded Art,Music,SpecialEd,CTEModifications SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost HighSchool ScienceLabsNeeded GymSpaceNeeded Art,Music,SpecialEd,CTEModifications SchoolClosurePotential SmallSchoolCost GeneralFundAddedCosts/Savings CapitalProjectsAddedCosts/Savings ScienceLab/Gym 1LabCKHS KSS(PhaseTwo)"current" Nonerequired None None(enrollment?) $925,000 $300,000 Portables/ScienceLab/Gym $0 None None NoneRequired Uptoone(1) 2smallschools CostsSavings $300,000 $0 $1,000,000 10 0 14sections+1.0Specialist 0 None 1smallschool CostsSavings $0 NoElemBoundaryChanges IncludesSpaceforADK CostsSavings $0 $0 $75,000 $0 $0 K3ClassSize17:1 ADKPaidbyState Elementary 10 4610=36** 14sections+1.0Specialist 46+5=51 None 1smallschool JuniorHighSchool None None NoneRequired Uptoone(1) 2smallschools HighSchool 1LabCKHS KSS(PhaseTwo)"current" Nonerequired None None(enrollment?) $670,000 $3,900,000 $0 CostsSavings $300,000 $0 $1,000,000 CostsSavings $0 Assumptions NoElemBoundChanges IncludesSpaceforADK CostsSavings $0.00 $3,600,000 $75,000 $255,000 $0 CapitalProj GenFund GenFund GenFund GenFund BudgetImpacted CapitalProj CapitalProj CapitalProj GenFund GenFund BudgetImpacted CapitalProj CapitalProj CapitalProj GenFund GenFund GenFund CapitalProj BudgetImpacted
**Otheroptioninlieuof1823elemportableswouldbeanotherelementaryschool=approx$27,500,000in2012dollars Ifthisoptionwasselected,thetotalCapitalProjectscostswouldbe$27.5M+$1.8M+$300K=$29,600,000
29
K3ClassSize17:1 GFAdded Costs/Savings# $670,000 $470,000 $1,670,000 $670,000 $670,000 CPAdded Costs/Savings $3,900,000* $3,700,000 $15,900,000* $3,900,000* $3,900,000*
Includes savings from potential school closure Uses up to 36 portables or requires additional elementary at $27.5M
30