Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
47
The TIMES of Smithtown Township
Serving Smithtown • St. James • Nesconset • Commack • Hauppauge • Kings Park • Fort Salonga
January 29, 2009 75¢
Presidential perspective
A NAME YOU
Having Problems with those CAN TRUST,
pesky dashboard lights? QUALITY SERVICE
We have all of the latest diagnostic YOU CAN
equipment to service your vehicle! COUNT ON.
CHOOSE US AS AN
ALTERNATIVE TO
10% Off GOING BACK TO
N.Y.S.
Inspection Station
any repair autoworks.com
THE DEALERSHIP
WITH THIS AD www.smithtown • Our talented
technicians are
u rn p ik e
324 Jericho T 8 7
ASE certified.
Smithtown, NY 117 • We can properly
Howard
Do ug diagnose problems
7004263 and repair your
N.Y.S. Registration car in a timely
MOND AY - FR IDAY
HOURS: 8 AM-5:30 PM fashion.
8 AM-12 PM SATURDAY
©84260
Here’s 5
The police reported that the FBI had been 22 said two students were misbehaving
reasons
trict attorney’s office at the intersection of
Any Box of responded to the scene. Route 111 and Nescon-
Valentine Harassment set Highway in Smith-
why...
A resident of Marsh- town. The problem was
Chocolates mallow Drive in Com- resolved before police
mack at 11:35 pm Jan. arrived.
W/coupon 12 said he received sev- A male complain-
Limit 1 en prank phone calls ant at 7:43 pm Jan.
Exp. 2/10/09 from an unknown person and wanted 20 reported smelling what was possibly
Offer may not be these incidents documented. marijuana smoke coming from a down-
TAK E 25% OFF combined A resident of Ponderosa Court in Ne-
sconset at 8 pm Jan. 20 reported receiv-
stairs apartment on Dorado Court in
Hauppauge. Police checked the area with
A ny Valentin ing numerous calls from an unknown negative results.
e number in Nassau County at all hours of A motorist at 3:28 pm Jan. 20 said that
Gif t Item the day. Investigation determined that a
computer was speed dialing her number
while he was driving his Crown Victoria
eastbound on Meadow Road in Kings
W/coupon • Lim in error. Park the engine suddenly burst into flame.
it 1
Exp. 2/10/09 Fire sale The complainant safely escaped the burn-
Offer An employee at a shoe store on Jericho ing vehicle and shortly thereafter Kings
may not be Turnpike in Commack at 7 pm Jan. 21 Park firefighters extinguished the blaze.
combined VALENTINE said she smelled gasoline inside the store. A resident of Avalon Court in Smith-
BALLOON Commack firefighters determined that a
customer looking for shoes had a small
town at 4:14 pm Jan. 21 said his 10-year-
old brother had been missing for almost
BOUQUET amount of gasoline on her clothing. No
police action was necessary.
one hour. When police arrived, the com-
plainant informed them that he had found
$ 99
Mylar &
Latex Mix
W/coupon • Limit 1
3 Assault
A resident of Estate Court in Com-
mack at 8:35 pm Jan. 23 said several
youths were fighting in the street outside
his brother in a gym on the grounds of his
housing complex.
A resident of Peppermint Road in
Commack at 9 pm Jan. 22 said he had
Exp. 2/10/09 her house. The young gladiators were received a call from an unknown person
Offer cannot be gone upon police arrival. asking him to go to a Western Union of-
FF
TAK E 25% nOtin
combined A female resident of Fifth Avenue in
Kings Park at 8:10 pm Jan. 20 said her
fice with $100 and send the cash to an
out-of-state address, for which service the
es
Packaged Vale
landlord threw a shoe at her, which struck complainant would receive a $5,000 grant.
her in the face. The complainant said the offer sounded
e!!
Fun for kids of any ag TAK E Theft
A female complainant at 3 am Jan. 17
fishy, so he called the police.
A female complainant at 5 pm Jan.
W/coupon • Limit 1 said her pocketbook was stolen by an un- 17 on Fifth Avenue in St. James said an
Exp. 2/10/09
Offer may not be
50% OFF known person while she was seated at a ta-
ble in a pub on Terry Road in Nesconset.
unknown person operating a small grey
hatchback sedan was shining a light in
combined
all A manager of a Commack clothing several homes nearby. Police canvassed
Gibson Greeting business at 6:44 pm Jan. 16 said an un- the area with negative results.
Cards
W/coupon • Limit 6 • Exp
. 2/10/09
Inside this week
Offer may not be combin
ed
News
Columns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A19 Obituaries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A15
Redeemable at all Party Hardy Locations! Editorial . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A18 People . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A15
Since 1995 Party Hardy has been family owned and operated. We strive to serve our customers Letters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A18 Sports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A16-A17
with friendly and reliable service. Thank you for your continued business.
Long Island Cares and so does Party Hardy. Leisure Arts & Lifestyles
We are now a permanent collection site for
Art Exhibits. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B2 Father Frank . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B29
donations to The Harry Chapin Food Drive!
Ask the Veterinarian . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B3 Health. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .B2-B13
Business. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B32 Investing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B27
KINGS PARK Main Stree Calendar . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B24-B27 Kids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B29-B32
St
t • Rte 25A
son
60 Main Street
Tho
ve
©53110
nA
y Rt
269-7800
ls o
C nt
C ar
Classifieds
MILLER PLACE • Rte 25A Section C
Rte 83
Rte 25A
474-7400
The TIMES (USPS 003-952) is published Thursdays by TIMES BEACON RECORD
NESCONSET • 145 Smithtown Blvd. Smithtown Blvd. NEWSPAPERS, 185 Route 25A, Setauket, NY 11733. Periodicals postage paid at Setauket, NY and additional
mailing offices. Subscription price $35 annually. Leah S. Dunaief, Publisher. POSTMASTER: Send change of
979-6600 R te
1/4 mi. west
347 of Smithtown Blvd.
address to PO Box 707, Setauket, NY 11733.
JANUARY 29, 2009 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • PAGE A5
Town looks to strengthen financial disclosure laws
BY JOE DARROW of the irregularities on the forms time.” And to enforce punctuali- Gray magnet-mailings case. misconduct. However, the coun-
joedarrow@tbrnewspapers.com he had submitted that summer. ty, the Council must strongly rec- In May 2007 the Ethics Board cilwoman refused to pay. Her
The Town Board is examining The Council immediately voted ommend that the Ethics Board found former Councilwoman lawyer and husband, Larry Gray,
a number of changes to the ethics to suspend Bonerba without pay, — who are volunteers, after all Joanne Gray guilty of using pub- argued that, in addition to Ethics
code that would boost enforce- but said they lacked enough time — meet promptly to ensure the lic resources for private, political members following a flawed and
ment of Smithtown’s financial to investigate or take further pu- filing deadlines have been met, he purposes, and fined her $3,500, biased process in assessing her
disclosure requirements. A public nitive action before his retirement said. The new laws also grant the an amount Ethics said was aimed his wife’s guilt, town code did not
hearing on the new laws has been took effect. Town Council, not just the Ethics at both remunerating the town grant the Ethics Board’s power to
scheduled for Feb. 26, at 7 pm, at Council members would avoid Board, means to enforce disclo- and deterring future similar fine in such matters.
the Smithtown senior center. this pitfall in the future by requir- sure requirements, emphasizing
The proposals come in re- ing the Ethics Board, charged their ability to suspend violators
sponse to a number of financial with collecting and reviewing or whatever other disciplinary
disclosure infractions by town the forms, to promptly notify the action it deems fit.
officials, accord- board when forms Other proposed code lan-
ing to town board are filed late, in- guage would cut in half — from
members. Lesser A hearing on the complete or other- 10 to 5 days — the Ethics Board’s
ethics code viola- wise problematic. permitted response time when
proposed Ethics
tions have included Should an official citizens request to view officials’
officials submitting Code changes has miss the May 15 financial disclosure forms under
their disclosure been scheduled filing deadline or the Freedom of Information Act.
forms months past proffer an incom- Citizens would also be able to
deadline. Argu- for Feb. 26. plete document, obtain a redacted copy of those
ably the most seri- proposed laws forms, according to Town At-
ous infraction in would require that torney Yvonne Liefrigg. This lat-
recent history was former Chief “without undue delay” the Ethics ter provision marks a significant
Building Inspector and Build- Board notify the official of their break from current town law,
ing Department Director Robert 15-day grace period to hand in which Ethics representatives cit-
Bonerba’s refusal to name outside correct forms. If the second dead- ed last year when refusing Town
sources of income in his 2005 fi- line is missed, Ethics members Board disclosure-form copies to
nancial disclosure forms leading would be instructed to notify the civic activist Lenore Cernitz of
up to his December 2006 resig- Town Board as soon as possible. St. James.
nation. Bonerba was indicted last “We didn’t find out [about Another proposed code
year on 42 criminal counts dating Bonerba’s incomplete forms] for change expressly grants the Ethics
to his final years at Smithtown, months,” said Councilman Ed Board the power to “assess an ap- Tomorrow’s engineers
including alleged bribe receiving, Wehrheim. “I always said, from propriate penalty or fine, or take Tyrone Bennett, associate director of the Collegiate Science and
falsifying business records, offi- the beginning, that should be any other appropriate action” af- Technology Entry Program at Hofstra University, recently spoke about
cial misconduct and conspiracy; tightened up on the code.” ter rendering a decision in other bridge design to Hauppauge students. Shown above are fifth-graders
he has pleaded not guilty. “The way to correct it,” Weh- ethics infraction cases. The new Kyle Szwech, MaryKate Smith, center, and Christina Mallano.
The Town Board was not no- rheim added, is “every required language would clear up an am- Courtesy Hauppauge schools
tified until early December 2006 application must be filed in biguity that surfaced in the 2007
83934
PAGE A6 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • JANUARY 29, 2009
$4,970!
OUT OF STATE: $12,870
That’s Stony Brook’s tuition.
(And that’s small!)
76219
JANUARY 29, 2009 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • PAGE A7
H Gymnastics At Its Best At...H
EASTERN GYMNASTICS
H CENTER H H
32 SOUTHERN BLVD., NESCONSET, N.Y. 11767
Between Route 347 & Jericho Tpke.,
H
1 mile west of Smithhaven Mall
REGISTER TODAY!
18 Months to 2-1/2 Years
Photo by Joe Darrow
Smithtown Library Clerk Linda Taurassi, right, swears in new Trustee Carolyn Ciarelli,
One – 45 minute class per week H
elected in October, at the Jan. 20 Board of Trustees meeting. Morning/Afternoon & Saturday classes available
H
Board: Library program 3 Years to 6 Years
1 hour class per week
H
Morning/Afternoon & Saturday classes available
H
PERSONAL TRAVEL
of Stony Brook
HAS MOVED!
Come Visit Us
At Our
New Location
529 Lake Avenue
St. James, NY 11780
(Across from the St. James Train Station) Courtesy Flanagan’s office
631.941.0100 State Sen. John Flanagan congratulates Smithtown High School West student Robert
Bernardini on his selection to be a People to People student ambassador to Japan.
Your Local Travel Agent
With Over 30 Years Experience
Smithtown schools’
Specializing in
:
cruises w ith
ambassador to Japan
Packages and
the personal to
uch w ith no Teen preps for role in People to People International
ice fees.
additional serv
BY KAREN FORMAN School West Principal John Dolan.
• Cruises smithtown@tbrnewspapers.com The Smithtown teen is fascinated
• Honey moons Smithtown High School West student with history and politics and would
als Resorts
• Disney • Sand Robert Bernardini is looking forward to love to be able to “help our country
riding the 200-mile-per-hour bullet train in some way with the economy,” Ber-
and visiting an oxygen room when he goes nardini said. “I think everyone should
to Japan this summer. But this isn’t your pitch in and make a difference.”
©53207
Andrea Horn, Travel Consultant typical summer vacation. Bernardini, 15, He is working to bone up on Japanese
is going to Japan as a student ambassador culture, religion and history before his
for People to People International. trip. As part of LRS, Robert will stay with
People to People International was a host family for three days. He will also
founded by President Dwight Eisenhower study the history and architecture of feu-
Special Offer For The New Year! in 1956, who believed, according to the dal Japan, and the Buddhist and Shinto
People to People website, that direct inter- religions; he is also scheduled to enter the
action between ordinary citizens around oldest temple in Tokyo, practice calligra-
the world can promote cultural under- phy and view an ancient tea ceremony.
standing and world peace. “I have long “My whole family is excited,” Bernar-
Resolve to make believed, as have many before me, that dini said. “Th is is a great opportunity
peaceful relations between for me to meet new people
THIS the year you nations require mutual re- and help promote peace be-
spect between individuals,” ‘This is a great tween the nations.”
Eisenhower had said. Since His father, Ronald, added,
take care of yourself that time, eight U.S. presi- opportunity for “My wife and I would love
dents have served as the hon- me to meet new to crawl inside his luggage.
and stop “pretending” orary chairmen of People to This sounds like it’s going to
People International.
people and help be a wonderful experience
to hear. Th rough People to promote peace for him. Not just the travel ...
People, students in grades between the he’ll be learning so much.”
five through 12 can visit a State Sen. John Flanagan
Call H.E.A.R.S. AUDIOLOGY variety of countries. Pro- nations.’ (R-East Northport) recently
to schedule your hearing evaluation and grams available this year —ROBERT invited Bernardini to his of-
include Traditions of Eu- BERNARDINI fice, to congratulate him on
free consultation. rope (Ireland, Wales, Eng- being selected as a People to
land, France, Belgium and People student ambassador.
the Netherlands), Journey through the “Th is is a great opportunity for Rob-
Ages (Greece, Italy, Germany and Aus- ert to learn about the world from a
Purchase One Hearing Aid & Receive tria), Journey through the South Pa- hands-on perspective and I congratu-
cific (Australia, New Zealand and Fiji), late him on being selected,” Flanagan
Second Hearing Aid at 50% OFF Great Wall and Beyond (China) and stated in a press release. “Being chosen
(Select models only – Wide range to choose from) Andes to Machu Piccu (Peru and Chile) to represent the nation is a great honor
— to name just a few — as well as the and a great reflection on his parents and
Japan program Bernardini will attend, his teachers. I look forward to talking
Land of the Rising Sun. to him again when he returns from his
H.E.A.R.S. Audiology, P.C. LRS is a 14-day program where stu- trip representing our nation and com-
dents in grades nine through 12 travel munity in Japan.”
732 Smithtown Bypass (Rte. 347) Suite 301, Smithtown, NY to Japan in July. According to Bernardi- “It’s interesting that the founder of
ni, about 40 students will be attending People to People was Dwight D. Eisen-
631.360.HEAR (4327) this program out of the more than 100 hower,” Bernardini said. “He wanted to
©53183
teens who were originally selected. promote peace after World War II, after
Many Insurance Plan Benefits Voted Best of L.I. 3 years in a row! The selection process required him fighting Japan. And now I’m going back
Accepted! 100% coverage available to pass an interview, he said; Bernar- to promote peace in Japan.”
for Empire Plan members! dini was the only student chosen in his For more information on People to
Must present this ad to redeem offers. All offers not to be combined with other offers, coupons or discounts. Expires Feb. 28, 2009
region, he added. The 10th-grader was People programs, visit www.peopleto-
nominated for the program by High people.com.
JANUARY 29, 2009 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • PAGE A9
Residents petition to walk pets at KP psych center
BY JOE DARROW “The upper part of the Nisse- trail there is narrower and “in
joedarrow@tbrnewspapers.com quogue River State Park is ideal” the summer it’s completely in-
Hundreds of residents are pe- for dog walking, the petition- undated with poison ivy and
titioning the state to once again ers wrote in a Jan. 22 letter to ticks,” he said. “It’s very steep
allow dog walking at the former this newspaper, “because of the at times, and it just doesn’t lend
Kings Park Psychiatric Center. many wide, paved trails which itself to a family activity.” Kings
The remaining 365 acres of enable the entire family to walk Park portions of the Greenbelt
the closed mental hospital were side-by-side through this scenic Trail are similarly disadvanta-
transferred to the state Parks wonderland virtually free from geous to group travel during the
Office by the outgoing Pataki poison ivy and ticks.” Plus, growing season, he added.
administration in December with the state cutting expenses While dog owners had free
2006. But while Parks police to meet a record-high budget run of the psychiatric center’s last
began providing security for deficit, it’s unlikely to have the 365 acres when the Office of Men-
the property, the state Office resources in the near future to tal Health was taking care of the
of Mental Health continued establish recreational activities land, that may have been due to
to be responsible for the land’s at the park, Weber argued; al- lack of enforcement rather than a
physical maintenance until the lowing dog walking would be more lenient policy. “It’s our un-
beginning of 2009, according an easy, no-cost way to entice Courtesy Steve Weber derstanding that dogs were not
to Parks spokesman George visitors in the meanwhile. As of Jan. 1, residents may no longer walk their dogs through most of officially authorized to walk or be
Gorman. When Parks assumed Over 650 residents have the former Kings Park Psychiatric Center grounds. in Kings Park Psychiatric Center
responsibility for upkeep of all signed the petition, which when it was under the jurisdic-
former hospital grounds Jan. 1, requests the state Parks Of- Weber and a number of dedi- State Park entrance, where they tion of New York State Office of
the agency’s prohibition on pets fice allow that “well-behaved, cated dog walkers, like Kathie presented their petition to park Mental Health,” Parks spokesman
in parks “except where desig- leashed dogs be permitted Plant and Richard Reilly, both officials, according to Weber. Gorman said.
nated” came with it, he said. in designated areas of the of Kings Park, stood in the cold Dog walking is legal on As for the petition, “we are
Prior to the switch, which Nissequogue River State Park outside the Kings Park post office the Greenbelt, which crosses looking at it and we are, at one
was heralded by the erection of providing that all pet owners and area shopping centers dur- through state parkland multiple point, going to examine whether
20-plus “no pets” signs through- clean up after their dogs, limit ing the second week of January times on its 32-mile course. But there is an area or areas within
out the property, Kings Park activity to designated areas to gather 500 signatures. They domestic animals have always Kings Park where dog walking
civic activist and spokesman and use a leash no greater than then posted the petition online, been prohibited on all but a can be authorized,” Gorman
for the petitioners Steve Weber 6 feet at all times.” Weber said which yielded an additional 150 small portion of the Nissequogue said. He emphasized “at one
said, the community had a long the petitioners are asking for as of Thursday, with about 25 or park, according to park Director point,” saying any extension of
tradition of walking their dogs pets to be allowed on the west so additional residents signing Vance Crippen. Dog walking is pet-permitted area would not
down the psychiatric center’s side of the hospital boulevard each day, Weber said. allowed in a small stretch of state come immediately, as the agency
broad roads and trails. Over and in the former Group 4 In a rally held Jan. 19, around land off Old Dock Road near the will focus first on studying the
the past 15 years “quite a fra- area, across the street from 30 dog owners, decked out in boundary of Sunken Meadow costs of remediating the lead-
ternity of families had gathered Old Dock Road, in addition to message-bearing clapboards, State Park, Crippen said. and-asbestos contaminated hos-
to walk their dogs in the park, allowing visitors to walk their walked their pets down the Long But navigating the dog-des- pital grounds. “The health and
and became quite friendly,” he animals from the park’s en- Island Greenbelt Trail from San ignated area is no walk in the safety aspect is going to have to
explained. trances to these locations. Remo to the Nissequogue River park, according to Weber. The be resolved,” he said.
84076
PAGE A10 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • JANUARY 29, 2009
Stony Brook University/SUNY is an affirmative action, equal opportunity educator and employer.
Prostate cancer—words no man wants to hear. When James got his diagnosis, he examined all his options.
His search led him to a nationally recognized surgeon at Stony Brook, who, along with a skilled team, uses
the da Vinci ® S HD™ Surgical System to treat prostate cancer with minimal pain, less blood loss, fewer
complications, and a shorter hospital stay. This procedure also helps spare vital nerve tissue, minimize
side effects, and give patients like James the best chance for a complete recovery. Just one more advantage
you’ll find at Long Island’s only academic medical center. To learn more, visit BestIdeasInMedicine.com. Home of the best ideas in medicine.
76218
JANUARY 29, 2009 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • PAGE A11
Reform teens pick the
brains of public officials
Homelessness, hate crimes, housing
and energy weigh on students’ minds
BY ARLENE GROSS Suzanne Tavolacci, coordinator of the
arlenegross@tbrnewspapers.com SAJES Teen Action Project, ran the six-
A group of local high school students re- week program to encourage civic action
cently had a chance to meet and chat with among teens, she said. Topics included
politicians and ask them (almost) anything homelessness on Long Island, the environ-
they wanted to know about local govern- ment and greater participation in local is-
ment and community. sues.
Sponsored by the Suffolk Association The students and elected officials talked
for Jewish Educational Services of Com- over pizza Dec. 1 at Temple Chaverim in
mack, the Teen Action Project legislative Plainview, one of the participating temples
panel discussion consisted of about 50 stu- of the Hebrew high school. Courtesy D’Amaro’s office
dents from the Community Hebrew High “This was our culminating event … their
School, a consortium of four reform tem- opportunity to actually meet with some lo- Legislator Lou D’Amaro sits with students from Community Hebrew High School, a consortium of
ples in Huntington, Commack, Melville cal lawmakers, people of influence in their four reform temples in Huntington, Commack, Melville and Plainview.
and Plainview, who rotate classes between community whom they could ask ques-
the four buildings. tions of,” Tavolacci said. “It was really nice Simon discussed windmills and alter- homework, he noted. “They were asking
Legislators Lou D’Amaro (D-North because the kids got to sit in small groups native energies with D’Amaro. “It was in- very specific questions … and that was
Babylon), Steve Stern (D-Dix Hills) and to learn why they became legislators.” teresting to see their points of view on the great to see because it shows they are en-
Jon Cooper (D-Lloyd Neck), along with D’Amaro agreed that the only way to topics we all have opinions on.” Simon’s gaged, they are knowledgeable and they
Huntington Town Councilwoman Susan change attitudes and motivate people’s in- avid interest in politics was ignited this actually took the time to get to know a little
Berland were on hand to field the teens’ volvement is to start working with them past summer when she took courses on bit about the people they were going to
questions. at an early age. “And that’s what the Teen international relations, public affairs and speaking with.”
Zach Rotter, 16, of Melville, sat at Coo- Action Project is all about. SAJES does a American politics — her intended major Sitting with Stern was Hilary Ehrlich,
per’s table and learned about the lawmak- wonderful job in working with our youth — at Georgetown University. 16, of Northport, who called the round
er’s civic initiatives as well as how he runs in preparing them to go out into the world Stern said he was impressed with sev- table discussion the highlight of the
his manufacturing business “working with and to be more tolerant of other people in eral of the students. “Many of them were evening. Ehrlich asked his point of view on
environmental agencies to help create prof- other walks of life.” very knowledgeable about local issues, par- programs for the handicapped, mentally
it as well as a beneficial environment.” Rebecca Simon, 16, of Dix Hills, who sat ticularly affordable housing. They wanted challenged and disabled people: “It’s great
It piqued the Walt Whitman High with D’Amaro, loved learning what was go- to know what our ideas were and the kinds to know that someone wants a program
School junior’s interest that Cooper had ing on in the community: “We understood of things we are working on … which is go- that is really empowering and helpful to us
met President Barack Obama; Rotter was how local legislators really affects us a lot ing to affect them.” and enjoyable for my family member and
rooting for Obama in the 2008 election. more than the state government.” A few of the students had done their that he wants to fund it.”
Offers of credit are subject to credit approval. Membership is open to anyone who lives, works, worships, attends school or
Long Island Beauty, M.D.
regularly conducts business in Nassau or Suffolk counties (with the exception of Southampton, East Hampton and Shelter Lisa Makrides, MD
Island). Share account with $5 minimum balance required. Additional restrictions may apply. Federally Insured by NCUA.
25 Main Street, Stony Brook, NY 11790
©84437
www.arthurmurraysuffolk.com
S’town author: Kid games
are key to career choice
CALL NOW FOR YOUR Counselor Susan Gubing to speak at library Feb. 12
INTRODUCTORY LESSON BY JENNIFER CHOI
jenchoi@tbrnewspapers.com
• LATIN • SMOOTH Could your toddler’s proclivity for
• DISCO dolls or building blocks be a clue to
their optimal career path? Absolutely,
• NIGHTCLUB says a Smithtown career counselor
and author, who is scheduled to share
• SWING • BALLROOM her insight on job selection at a Feb-
Couples & Singles ruary lecture.
Susan Gubing, co-author of “Gam-
Welcome!! es2Careers: Career Success is Child’s
Play,” is hosting a book talk Feb. 12
FOR: at the main branch of the Smithtown
• PARTIES Library.
From 7 to 8:30 pm, Gubing will
• VACATIONS share her knowledge about the link
• CRUISES between the games children play and
their career choices. The Smithtown
• BUSINESS EVENTS resident, who retired after working 38
• & MORE years as a career counselor for Smith-
town School District, said she wrote Courtesy Smithtown Library
the book with Karen McKenna to Susan Gubing, author of ‘Games2Careers:
“give parents a tool on how to watch Career Success is Child’s Play,’ shown below.
their children and how to help them
make career decisions.” In addition to toys, participation in
Gift Certificates “People think there is no system in sports also offers clues about a child’s
Available finding a job, but there is a system,” interests, according to the author,
Gubing said, so when library officials whose son always played the position
Hours: Mon. - Fri. 1:30-10:00 pm
Sat: By Appointment
approached her about a book talk, “I of goalie or catcher, both defensive po-
said, ‘Of course. Why not?’” sitions, because he wanted to “protect
©43517
The pets
Park • Fort Salo
nga
75¢
determine how to success- can make good choices.
at these locations: strike
Angel’s Ga back
fully match these interests When young people say, ‘I
BZA decis te appeals
BY JOE
DARR
joedarrow@t
ion in co
OW urt
brnewspape
to the right career paths. don’t know what to do,’ they just don’t
For instance, her son was drawn to know who they are and they don’t
Angel’s rs.com
has appea Gate is taking the town
led to rever
lowing its se the zonin to court. The pet
animals on owners from carin g board’s hospice
SMITHTOWN tificate of
their
antial evide
led
g for
According Fort Salonga prope diseased and disab
Victor LaBr to the petition fi rty.
Court Marc una’s legal counsel by owners Sue Mari
without substh 14, the town “arbitin Suffolk County no and
rarily
decision disal-
toys like G.I. Joe action figures and know their options.”
Town Coun
cilwoman A rockin’ old hospi
pre-existin
g use,” which d [their and
and Ging
er Joanne
Gray, left, good cau ce
town code to remain despite
] claim
would allow for a cer-
sponsors,
ital
their rocki auxiliary volun
ng chair
they and
s Friday
several
se
teers Staci
other town
e
at St. Cath Marsh, center,
erine of
Siena Medi
Photo by
of St. Jame
Nino
s
Ruisi Marino and
lawyers, heade
Greene &
forbidding
LaBruna
it in reside
the 2006
red y
to categorize c from visitors,
complained bono.
joyed building things and “making and old, to study “what they’re doing
CVS Drugs light run of
State bill pitals and animal hospi the Town Counnoise and in-
ces in with cil voted
would exclu
Millennium Diner
forcement y may get a new
tion is being
Red-light
license plate.
arsenal: red-li
by photograph
by the
weapon for
“The
ready to comm
considered ght cameras. Auth its traffic en- said.some levels but I want it yet because
orizing legisl
a- of. There re is a Big Brothto see the evidence,”
’s a lot er aspec
Fitzpatrick of bad drivers out t to it that I’m not
it makes
sense
Fitzpatrick
town code d their request to be town Board of Zonin oned
at Angel’s
chang
“I opposed e.
Gate
this amen
stated Coun and it would invite
the zonin cilwoman Joanne
dment becau
grandfathe
se it was
a lawsuit forlaser-beamed
Smith
g
red in under Ap-
the things different,” Gubing said. As an and how they’re doing it,” the author
the registered A summons is then offender’s added that there.” fond g
week (see code change, in a Gray, the sole vote town,”
adult, he currently works as an auto- continued. And even though she has
owne maile d be safety the justifi news
The bill r of the vehic d to and not reven cation for the came page A10). paper against
In denyi opinion piece
tation Com is in the Assembly’s le. “Clearly we ue. ras
argued that ng Marino and LaBr this
mittee. Transpor- put a don’t have factor una’s
cop on
Smithtown Bagels
“I’d say the resou volved and s such as appeal the
if we put [the odds of passa think that every street corne rces to the BZA had
up ge safety figures r,” he mean that Angel’s Gate’s not-fo large number of
blyman Marcenough pressure,” are] 50/50 dence over
mone should take said. “I use for the
taking care
of animals
r-profit corpo pets in-
motive engineer for Ford in Michigan. retired from the Smithtown school
said Assemblym y that can be raised prece- ration status
of the Trans Alessi (D-Mastic) Assem- neither mentproperty. Further, is more
supportive portation Committe , a member Setauket) an Steve .” animal hospithan a secondary
said he is Englebrigh Council’s ioned nor defined ces, which
see it get of this legislation e. “I’m very cameras. leery about t (D-
eas to begin
action, had in
never been town law prior to the were
throu and I want red-light
Alessi said gh committee.” to “I’m very
But Smith
with, the
zoning board permitted
in residential
Town
red-light and I’m very cautious about
problem in resident can town does not said. ar-
Smithtown Senior Suffolk Counrunning is a majo Photo by aware that Big Broth
“If you’r r Alex Gillam of the state I represent er, own, limit
Angel’s Gates the number
Citizen Center
on on the “Any tial zones
bill. he good thing you can s. would not hospice and exclu the Town Board’s
thing,” Raia do to incre already been have de it
said. “A ase drive breaking been necessary had from residen-
traffic light r safety is a “We feel the zonin Angel’s Gate
came
Continued ra should tor have beenthat these facts demog law.
unfai nstrate that
Middle on page
A8 So, the Ange rly targeted,” Susan
l’s Gate petiti Jackson said in and Vic-
Country
Public
force development,” she said. Gub-
on claims an email.
Mary DeR
Regional Librar y
their
ose Continued “application
For breaki
Page A3 in Kings Park Direcview with Planning
ng news,
tor Frank
Page A5 DeRubeis value to clean-up, fix-up
Time
-up the , ing has since founded a firm, Career
Weinisch’s Deli visi t timeso
fsmithtow
n.com
Insid e
place
Home improvement Lic. #18-817H.I. • www.cappyscarpets.com • Hours: Mon.-Fri. 9-6 PM, Thurs. ‘til 9 PM, Sat. 9:30-5
PAGE A14 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • JANUARY 29, 2009
We Are Paying
TOP DOLLAR
Bring in this ad and get 10% more
For Example: Bring in $100-get an additional $10!
Bring in $400-get an additional $40!
40 Years Experience
Center Gold
A FULL SERVICE JEWELRY STORE
Your Source for Jewelry, Watches & Fine Gifts
JEWELER ON PREMISES • JEWELRY REPAIRS WHILE YOU WAIT
Don't forget
that someone
special for
76379
Valentine's
W e H o st
Je w e lr y Day!
P a r ti e s
At Our Legals
©84458
H o u se !
Notice of Formation of 5395, Hauppauge, NY, 11788, Legal advertisement
FORTUNA ADVISORS LLC. Arts. Purpose: any lawful purpose.
of Org. filed with Secy. of State guidelines
of NY (SSNY) on 01/16/09. Office 25 1/15 6x ts
location: Suffolk County. SSNY Deadline is 12 noon
2340 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720 designated as agent of LLC
upon whom process against it Notice of Formation of RSC
1 week prior to
Across from CVS Pharmacy may be served. SSNY shall mail HAUPPAUGE LLC. Cert. of Con-
publication date.
www.centergold.com process to the LLC, 12 Tinker version filed with Secy. of State
631–467–0400
Bluff Ct., Poquott, NY 11733. of NY (SSNY) on 12/30/08, con- E-mail your text to:
Purpose: Any lawful activity. verting RSC ASSOCIATES to RSC legals@
HAUPPAUGE LLC. Office loca- tbrnewspapers.com
1–800–229–5265 Se Habla
Español
54 1/29 6x ts
Pauline Roche
skevi Greek Orthodox
Church. Interment
followed at Hauppauge
Rural Cemetery.
A funeral Mass was
held at St. Patrick’s
RCC Smithtown. Inter-
ment followed at St.
Prearrangement services
available
Giove
Pauline Roche, age
94, died on Jan. 5.
Arrangements en-
trusted to The Branch
Patrick’s Cemetery.
Arrangements en-
Funeral Home
1000 Middle Country Road • Selden, NY 11784
She was the beloved Funeral Home of trusted to The Branch
aunt of Joanne (Rudy) Smithtown. Funeral Home of 732–1800
Sasura. Smithtown. Family owned & operated for 45 years.
A funeral Mass was
©75520
PAGE A16 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • JANUARY 29, 2009
East wins final four bouts for a come from behind win over Newfield
BY ROBERT LEUNER Earlier in the match Newfield had rallied
katsports@tbrnewspapers.com WRESTLING from a 13-6 deficit, winning four consecutive
Trailing 22-13, the Smithtown East wres- gap to three points as Kevin Cassidy pinned Maroun Ibra- bouts from 152 to 189 pounds to take the lead
tling team won the final four bouts, two by pins, against him with 30 seconds left in the first round at 215 pounds. at 22-13. Shaun Percoco led the Wolverine charge with a
Newfield and turned a nine-point deficit into a 10-point Newfield’s Max Gold followed with a 3-2 upset deci- major decision at 152 pounds followed by a Ryan Scannell
32-22 League III victory on Jan 23. With the win the East sion of Anthony Hirschfield at 103 pounds to tie the win at 160 pounds that tied the match, 13-13. Brandon
Bulls moved into second place in league standings with a match at 22-22. “I thought that was the key bout,” said Henry gave Newfield a three-point lead with a decision at
4-1 record, one game behind league leading and undefeat- Newfield head coach Mike Newell. “We were just a lit- 171 pounds followed by Roman’s pin at 189 pounds that
ed East Islip, while Newfield fell to 3-2. tle bit short today.” lifted the Wolverines to a nine-point led at 22-13.
“We knew it was going to be a tough match,” said Smithtown’s Tyler Vigliarolo then snatched a victory “We were wrestling without two of our starters,” said
Smithtown East head coach Dave Cummings. “We needed over Tom Fenster at 112 pounds with a dynamic take down Newell, indicating the absence of Nick Jones and John
to win the last four bouts to pull it out.” and near fall in the second round to win 10-2. The climax Randaso. “With them in there was a good chance that the
Newfield had taken a 22-13 lead when Hugo Roman to the match was the final bout at 119 pounds where Dylan score would have been different.”
pinned Chris Lambert at 189 pounds with one minute re- Clay pinned Newfield’s Jesse Dilevo with 34 seconds re- The Bulls wrap things up on Jan. 30 when they play host
maining in the third round. But Smithtown East closed the maining in the first round. to Half Hollow Hills East.
Commack girls finish third, boys take fourth West girls take on
BY FRANK DOWD
katsports@tbrnewspapers.com TRACK
Levine is ranked sec-
ond among New York State
League III teams
The Commack boys’ win- weight-throwing competi- GIRLS’ TRACK
ter track team had a very successful day at the League I tors. In this meet, he threw 46-10.50, but his season-best
championship meet last Saturday. With 43 competitors, exceeds 50 feet. BY FRANK DOWD
katsports@tbrnewspapers.com
they were the smallest squad in the league and finished in High jumper Ramin Yesharim won by clearing 6 feet.
fourth place. Ten competitors made the All-league team. His season-best is 6-1. “There was no competition for him,” The Smithtown West girls’ winter track team
Commack coach Steve Lurie is in his 15th season, but said Lurie. After he won the event, he stopped jumping, was ready to take League III by storm in last week-
his team competed in League II for all of the previous so he could run in the 4x200 relay, where his team took end’s championship meet. Smithtown West coach
years. “As a coach, you can’t complain,” he said. “They took fourth. “He always does a nice job,” Lurie said. “He did Kurt Margraf is pleased because his team improves
on the competition and did the best that they can.” what he had to do.” every meet. “I’m very happy with the way that they
Senior Mike Levine, who will be attending Yale next Commack’s number one distance runner David Golub performed during the meet,” he said. “They’re a
year for shot put, discus and hammer/indoor weight, won placed second in one mile run with a time of 4:43. His great group of girls.”
the shot put event. “He is one of the top throwers in New best time for the year, of 4:27, was fifth in the county. In Freshman Victoria Lowe, who was on the squad
York State,” said Lurie. “He had a good meet and did a real the 3,200-meter race, Golub finished third with a time of last year as an eighth-grader, was part of the 4x400-
good job.” Continued on page A16 meter relay. Lowe placed third in the 1,500-meter
run with a time of 5:17 then immediately ran the
3,000-meter run where she came in second with a
Kings Park boys win League VI title time of 11:07, which is a personal best. “They are
difficult to do, but she does it,” Margraf said.
Right behind Lowe in the 3,000-meter run, was
Girls’ team finishes in second place Smithtown West freshman Emily Mancini, who
finished the race in 11:35. She also placed sixth
The Kings Park boys’ track (10:23.45) and teammate in the 1,500-meter run with a time of 5:29. “She’s
team not only won but blew TRACK Chris Harvey came in fifth hard-working and dedicated,” Margraf said.
the competition away in the (10:33.09). In the 1,000 me- In the triple jump, senior Lauren Sprow reached
League IV championships. The Kingsmen scored 145.50 ters, Nolan Rummel and Kieran Harper finished fifth 30-07.25. In the high jump, junior Jen Lowe fin-
points compared to second-place finishers Harborfields (2:51.34) and sixth (2:51.80), respectively. ished third at 4-06.00. “She did well,” said Margraf.
and Huntington, both of which scored 64 points each. East Rob Schenke and Marcin Swieczowski came in third “I am happy about the height that she jumped.”
Hampton came in fourth (39). (8.51) and fourth (9.04), respectively, in the 55-meter hur- Margraf is impressed by the outstanding abili-
Kings Park had seven first-place finishes: Brendan Mc- dles. Brendan Frawley took fourth in the 600-meter run ties of senior captain Stephenie Dickson. Dickson
Gurran won the 1,000-meter run in 2:43.84; Max James (1:32.87). competed in the 300-meter run, 600-meter run,
won the 600-meter run in 1:30.22; Joe Colella took first in In the 1,600-meter run, C.J. Heiser finished second and 4x400-meter relay. “She is an all-around ex-
the shot put, scoring 42-02.75; Bryan Rossi won the triple (4:53.69) and Livote took fifth (5:00.60). James came in cellent athlete,” said Margraf. “She puts her all
jump with a score of 40-01.50; Billy Motherway came in second place in the 300-meter dash (37.84). In the shot put, into it. She is very versatile.”
first in the high jump after clearing 5-10.00; and the team’s Kyle Corcoran came in sixth (38-01.00). Margraf continued, “I look forward to next
4x400-meter relay and 4x800 relay each took first place. Erik LeRoy finished second in the long jump (19-10.00) season. The girls did an awesome job.”
In the 3,200-meter run, Joe Livote placed second Continued on page A16
PAGE A18 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • JANUARY 29, 2009
EDITORIAL OPINION
Compulsion of labor by the
Re: indicted Hail to the chief
Trim the fat S’town nurses,
threat and fact of criminal pros-
ecution and punishment creates
a condition of servitude that the
TO THE EDITOR:
I remember debating my father
As the 21st century opens, government has
taken meaningful, if far from complete, steps
to eliminate toxins in our air, water and earth.
told you so constitution prohibits.
Starting with Bailey v. Ala-
during the 1960 presidential elec-
tion; I argued the country needed a
TO THE EDITOR: bama, I suggest that your appeals change and he countered that Rich-
We’re glad to see them tackle our food now. bureau do further research.
(An open letter to Suffolk ard Nixon had far more experience
Bravo to Suffolk County Legislator Lou Lawrence Gray
County District Attorney Thom- and that Kennedy was the son of a
D’Amaro (D-North Babylon) for introducing a Kings Park
as Spota dated February 2008) “bootlegger and financial swindler.”
bill to ban use of trans fats in county food es-
I read the court’s denial of As we watched the JFK inauguration
tablishments, following the example set by New
the motion to dismiss the case together, I remember Pop saying,
York City, California and a growing number of
localities. If the measure does not pass swiftly
brought by you against the Ava- An end to lingering “I didn’t vote for the guy, but our
lon Gardens contract nurses. It country selected him under a pro-
into law with a minimum of debate, county law-
makers should double-check their science.
was boilerplate. This prosecution political graffiti cess that goes back to the founding
has the earmarks of poor pros- TO THE EDITOR: fathers; he is the president now, and
That’s because trans fats — lipids created
ecutorial judgment. I have a little pet peeve. I needs our respect and support to
by artificially hardening vegetable oils for use
The reckless endangerment can’t stand it when I’m driving lead the country.” I heard the echo
in baked goods or fried foods — are poison,
statute, as currently applied to around town and see old political of my father in the election eve con-
plain and simple. Unlike other foodstuffs hotly
the facts of this case, trenches signage, long after the election is cession speech of John McCain, the
debated in the nutrition community in recent
upon the 13th and 14th Amend- over still pleading “Vote for John farewell address of George W. Bush,
years — saturated fat, complex carbohydrates,
ments. Prosecutorial discretion Smith” or “Re-Elect Jane Adams.” and [Sunday’s] remarks by Barack
even high fructose corn syrup — trans fats have
employed with an evil eye and an This “political graffiti” is un- Obama praising the character of the
no conceivable upside. These man-made fats
uneven hand is a denial of due sightly and a blight on our com- outgoing president.
are foreign to the human body, which is poorly
process of law. munities and our environment. It is always interesting at times of
adapted to handle them. As a result, their con-
While the appearance of the What bothers me the most are presidential transition to watch and
sumption has been linked to increased risk of
statute is fair, its application to bumper stickers permanently listen to both the president leaving
heart disease, insulin resistance, obesity and
these nurses is not. Penal laws affixed to telephone poles, stop office and the one coming in. For
cancer.
are not to be employed to bolster signs or other visible structures. example, Carter interrupted his in-
Some studies show consumption of just 40
one side or the other in a labor Bumper stickers don’t wash auguration speech in 1977 to shake
calories of trans fat — or 4.5 grams — a day can
dispute. I prosecuted elected pub- away, they don’t get mowed over hands with Ford to thank him for
boost the risk of a heart attack by 23 percent,
lic officials and politically wired and they can’t be simply torn “healing this land,” and four years
and a fast-food meal of fried chicken strips and
nursing-home off. If someone wants one taken later he waited anxiously for the call
French fries can easily contain more than 100
In a Feb. operators for down, they have to invest quite that never came on his watch: “Mr.
calories of trans fat, according to D’Amaro.
years. Too a bit of elbow grease and time President, the hostages are free.” It
Some may interpret this as one more unwel- 2008 letter, many of them, to scrape it off and in the end, seemed in 2001 that Clinton had a
come intrusion into personal preference by a
the writer it appears, sticky remnants often remain. tough time leaving the stage while
healthier-than-thou nanny state. For example,
with their This year it has gotten even the day clearly belonged to his suc-
those who criticize Gov. David Paterson’s pro- forecast contributions worse. In one particular ex- cessor. Perhaps the most insightful
posed 18-percent “obesity tax” — on nondiet
the court’s to political ample Lee Zeldin, a candidate in remarks ever made at these times of
sodas or other beverages lacking a certain pro-
office holders the 1st Congressional District, transition were those of Nixon on
portion of natural sugars — at least have an ar- exoneration still have, as the day Gerald Ford replaced him.
gument when they say government should not purchased extra-wide bumper
of the Avalon they say, “one stickers. Now what remain are “Always give your best, never get
be in the business of influencing citizens to
consume one artificially flavored beverage over nursing home foot in the old, large and very unattractive. discouraged, never be petty; always
door.” It should be the responsibil- remember, others may hate you, but
another. employees Were it not ity of the candidate to keep an those who hate you don’t win unless
But a trans-fat ban is not analogous to a vice
indicted for for the em- inventory of where his or her you hate them, and then you destroy
tax. Rather, it more closely parallels the Envi-
ployment con- signage has been placed and yourself.”
ronmental Protection Agency’s efforts to ensure resigning. tracts of these take it down immediately after All our presidents have had
businesses do not contaminate the drinking wa-
nurses there election day. Bumper stickers are successes and failures: JFK had the
ter of nearby residents with trichloroethylene
would not be even a colorable a particularly bad idea because Bay of Pigs and putting a man on
or other toxins. Who among us would demand
linchpin to predicate a legal duty they stay with us, some long out- the moon; Johnson had Vietnam
the choice over whether poison comes out of our
on these nurses to stay on the job living the candidates they tout. and the Civil Rights Act. As I reflect
taps?
whether their shifts ended or not. As an elected official I cer- over the past eight years and various
It’s possible that the market would eliminate
Contract disputes are enforced in tainly understand the impor- letters that have appeared in this
trans fat use on its own. Some major fast-food
civil lawsuits, not criminal pros- tance of name recognition. How- space, it occurs to me that some of
chains, such as Burger King and Wendy’s, forced
ecutions. The county and state ever, in the multiple elections I your readers may have fallen into
to ditch the fats in some localities and sensing
health departments and police have been involved in, I never the same trap that Nixon did. While
that their number is only likely to grow, have
emergency services units have used bumper stickers, and after Nixon knew from painful experi-
chosen to phase out their use.
hot lines. There is also a patient election day I make it a priority ence how hatred destroys judgment
But many restaurants have yet to follow their
abuse reporting statute that ap- to send out campaign workers to and reasoned debate, some that con-
lead, and are unlikely to do so soon of their
plies to health facility owners as pick up my signage. tinue to denigrate our 43rd president
own accord, as trans fats are cheaper and better
much as staff — more so. There I challenge those who ran illustrate the wisdom of Nixon’s last
preservatives in comparison with most natural
are temporary nurse services. in November to clean up what words as president.
animal or plant lipids. The county would be do-
The reckless endangerment remains and those who will run Hail to the chief; welcome
ing every Suffolk consumer a favor by speeding
statute is not a cow-catcher for this November to promise to do President Obama; and thank you
along the retreat from trans fats, even residents
every possible breach of “duty” the same. President Bush for keeping America
who already go out of their way to avoid the
that may have serious repercus- William Lindsay safe the past seven years.
stuff.
sions as may be defined ad hoc Presiding Officer Daniel Basil Kerr
Why? Because in America today, the less
by causation and logic. To bor- Suffolk County Legislature Stony Brook
wealthy the eater, the more likely they are to rely
row from the Supreme Court in
on low-cost, high-volume fast food or packaged
one of its post-Civil War peon-
snacks laden with trans fat. The same demo-
age cases, “We cannot escape the
graphic, unfortunately, is also more likely to lack
conclusion that, although the
health insurance or rely on state-subsidized cov-
erage like Medicaid. So, preventing some disease
[reckless endangerment] statute Letters ...
is to punish [reckless endan- We welcome your letters. They should be no longer than 400
with a virtually cost-free trans-fat ban would,
germent] still its natural and words and may be edited for length, libel, style and good taste.
in addition to the overarching benefit of avoid-
inevitable effect is to expose to We do not publish anonymous letters. Please include a phone
ing human suffering, cut the expense of drugs or
conviction for crime those who number for confirmation. Email letters to joedarrow@tbrnews-
surgery for the uninsured or state-insured that
simply fail or refuse to perform papers.com or mail them to The Times of Smithtown, PO Box
taxpayers would have to bear.
contracts for personal service 707, Setauket, NY 11733.
The Legislature’s Health and Human Services
…” Bailey v. Alabama (1919).
Committee is set to consider the trans-fat ban to-
day, so the bill could be scheduled for a general
vote as early as next Tuesday. Tell your county
representative to send trans fats packing. The opinions of columnists and letter writers are their own. They do not speak for the newspaper.
JANUARY 29, 2009 • TIMES OF SMITHTOWN township • PAGE A19
How the mighty may fall: an autopsy Your turn
Back in 1998, I was working as a appetite for a good deal and a good dessert, in either of their companies were winners.
reporter at Bloomberg News, where any and was the ultimate charmer on Wall Investors believed in the promise of the
story at any hour could and did require Street. He was a hero for turning a collec- merger.
my complete and immediate attention. In tion of financial services businesses into a Soon after the companies combined,
April, I had received a “tip” from an anony- profit-making machine. He had convinced Weill frequently told anyone who would
mous source that Citicorp was going to an- Reed to join forces with him. But even listen that the merger was working and that
nounce a huge merger on Monday. I called that wasn’t the most shocking part of this its record profits soon after the marriage
every source I could think of, pulled every merger. It was something far more basic. were proof of that. Reed cautioned that the
trick out of my reporter’s repertoire, made “Excuse me?” I asked my editor, as he big numbers came from putting together
every personal and professional appeal to raced through the press release to send two big companies. He continued to sug-
every imaginable person who might tell me out as many headlines as he could about gest that everyone had to wait to see how
something to break this big story. a merger heralding a brand new day in it all went. He was, to use a favorite phrase BY DANIEL DUNAIEF
Back then, bankers ascribed to their global finance. from the corporate world, “cautiously
unshakable belief that bigger was better. “WHAT?” he yelled. optimistic.”
They’d serve more of every customer’s need “Isn’t this illegal?” Citigroup did manage to get Glass-
in more places than anyone else. The mar- Without taking his eyes off his screen, Steagall repealed and didn’t have to sell big around the world, maneuvering around
ket was buzzing every day with talk of who he nodded his head. He directed me businesses to make the deal happen. an already heavily regulated industry that
would partner up with back to my seat, where I In less than two years, Weill muscled threatened to require almost as many
whom and what that might needed to turn this press Reed out of the co-CEO role, standing people watching and listening to how one
mean for the remaining The White House was one release into a story. I had alone as the seller of his grand vision for side of the house spoke to the other as it did
players. Bankers described 15 minutes to convert a bigger, better, stronger, faster bank that people trying to make money.
their business as a barbell: of the few places I hadn’t those headlines into could and would do anything but make From day one, Prince seemed a good
there would be a concen- called to try to break the a story, while adding you eggs over easy for breakfast. candidate to handle the regulators, but per-
tration of enormous strong story. Silly me! some background about The big, bad boy that was Citigroup haps a questionable one to make the best
banks on one side and a Citicorp, Travelers, John became big and bad. There were the ugly business decisions for the bank. After all,
collection of tiny banks Reed, Sandy Weill and email exchanges between Sandy Weill he hadn’t spent all that much time running
on the other. Everything the merger trends in and the poster boy for research conflicts a business.
in between would struggle to survive and banking. As the day progressed, we’d find of interest, former telecom analyst Jack With 20/20 hindsight, it’s easy to see
compete — or so the thinking went. experts — lawyers, doctors, Indian chiefs Grubman. how Prince and all the other top CEOs
After a weekend of looking over every — who could all weigh in on whether the An unseemly set of emails showed Weill who made millions stumbled badly when
shoulder and calling in every favor I could deal was legal and could happen. Even in urging Grubman to take another look at the complicated investments they held that
imagine, I got nowhere. Almost getting a the short press release, Weill said he had his rating on AT&T stock — a company were somehow tied to home prices around
story wouldn’t do much for me. I barely contacted the Clinton administration the whose board Weill sat on. There was also the country finally did the unthinkable and
slept that night, anticipating that 4 am night before. The White House was one of a “donation” Citigroup made to the 92nd fell.
call from an angry editor who read a story the few places I hadn’t called to try to break Street Y just as Grubman’s children were Even the regulators didn’t see it coming,
someplace else about the merger and the story. Silly me! applying for kindergarten. or they would have raised more red flags.
demanded I find someone as quickly as Citigroup, as Reed and Weill’s married Crusading Attorney General Eliot And now, 10 years after that day that
possible who could verify that story. Even companies would be called, had some time Spitzer was determined to do whatever marked the beginning of a new era in
though that call never came, I arrived at to repeal the Depression-Era laws called it took to save the small banking, Citigroup is
my desk at 6 am. Glass-Steagall that had separated commer- investor from the un- about to try to break
My editor, a driven, intense, high energy cial and investment banking. If they didn’t derhanded dealings and Even the regulators up into two large pieces
man whose whereabouts in the newsroom change the laws, the combined company dealers on Wall Street. He — even without any new
were always known from his booming would have to sell some of its businesses. would protect Mr. and didn’t see it coming, or laws restricting its busi-
voice and the shoes he clomped around in The press conference that day revealed Mrs. John Q. Public even if they would have raised ness.
as if he were crushing cockroaches, was the just how different these two financial lead- it meant he’d have to ride Is there a lesson in
only other person in the newsroom just as ers were. Weill offered amusing sound bites the publicity he generated more red flags. all this? I’m sure there
the sun started to pour in from over the and off the cuff witticisms straight from his to the governor’s mansion. are a lot of them. How
59th Street bridge. self-made Brooklyn pedigree, while Reed With enough righteous about the conventional
I stared at the public relations newswire, considered his answers, often describing indignation to fill the new and old Shea wisdom — and back then, it was bigger is
ready to write whatever story came in that what he hoped the merger would achieve. and Yankee stadiums, Spitzer laid out better — can be anything but wise. Or, how
morning. I was so concerned about miss- The stock market, which was in great (oops, poor choice of words) exactly how about, even giants — who seem to have an
ing the big moment that I barely took my shape in 1998, fell in love with the deal analysts were being corrupted by their “in” with everyone in power — can fall.
eyes off the screen to talk with my editor. and the sales pitch. Citicorp shares surged ties to investing banking. The investment When they do, they fall farther and harder
Would Citicorp, run by the intellectual, $35.625, or 25 percent, to help the Dow to bankers didn’t want any of their free- than their smaller counterparts.
deliberate and stately John Reed, merge its first close above 9,000. spirited analysts to say bad things about More than a decade later, Sandy Weill
with a foreign bank? Would Reed dare to Numerous print and TV journalists companies that were paying them millions is gone from Citigroup and so are many
merge with, say, a NationsBank, a giant — caught up in the euphoria of this mar- of dollars to sell stocks and bonds to the of the billions made on that first day. As of
bank that had gone from the fourth largest riage — started their “exclusive” interviews public. Jan. 16, Citigroup was worth $20 billion,
bank in North Carolina to one of the larg- with Sandy Weill and John Reed that day Ironically, when federal regulators well below its market cap of $140 billion
est in the nation through the deal making by congratulating them on the merger. revealed Spitzer’s own emails to a prostitu- in April 1998. Many of the millions Weill
of former marine Hugh McColl? Strange as it seems now, at the time, it was tion ring, his career came crashing down. made and then reinvested in the bank have
And then it hit. One of the strangest perfectly normal. It was like the sports But that’s a rise and fall story for a different also disappeared. And John Reed no longer
press releases I’d ever seen. Citicorp was reporters who congratulate the manager day. has to wait and see if Citigroup lived up to
merging with Travelers Group. The value of a team that had won a big game. How Sensing that the world was turning on its promise: it didn’t.
of the deal was $70 billion. could they not have felt and noticed the ex- him and seeing one bad headline after Daniel Dunaief was a business reporter
Sanford “Sandy” Weill ran Travelers. citement? The stock market loved the deal another tied to his name, Weill endorsed for over 14 years. He worked at the New
Weill was the antithesis of John Reed. The and the reporters often used the market’s the company’s top lawyer, Charles Prince, York Daily News, Bloomberg News and the
son of Polish immigrants, Weill shot from reaction as a scorecard. On that day, Weill, as the new CEO. In theory, Prince could American Banker. He is currently trying his
the hip, grew up in Brooklyn, had a hearty Reed and anyone who had money invested handle any legal challenges the bank faced hand as a book author.
76360