Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
A.S. 20 RESTRICTED
OF
June 15, 1950
June 3, 1954
Departmert of Operations
AsD U&& 2
a.UU&
]East
CURRENCY EWUIVALENTS
UNIT
U.S. cents per currency unit Currency units per U.S. dollar
IN1TRODUCTION 1. This report deals with the loan to Iraa cn the 11adi Tharthar Project, Loan No. 26-1cn^ signed June rl, 1950r -It covers the period from that date to April 30, 1954. Following the Vice-President:s visit to the Middle East in l7arch 1949, a Bank mission went to Iraq in Nay of the same year to study the cuun-ry's economic situation, the possiDblitles ior the establishment of a development agency, and the e:dsting plans for flood control projects. After studying the mission!s recommendations, Bank representatives went to London in August 1949 to discuss with British and !raqi officials the f-inancing of flood control measures, and the capital needs of the Iraqi Railways. Shortly thereafter the Export Credits Guarantee Department of thae United hLingdom made a 3 milaion railway development loan to Iraq. After further discussions with the Iraqi Government, the i-adi Tharthar flood control project was considered for Bank assistance. Negotiations were started in jondon in April 1950 and culminated in the signing of the Loan Agreement and two supplementary agreements (an Indenture of Assignment and a Project Funds Agreement) in
T
20
- 9-
A it aI
M tnD
[lir
T n A T Al
LlV2t.LI
5.
Te L,oanl
was
uiaue onl
U1Ue
15,
1950V aLU
Ut,.V
cti-f1eJJV on
July 12, 1951. It is a 15-year loan for 112.8 million and carries an interest rate of 3-3f47, incl-uding 1, sbLaUUU-Y QoIfMllss1n. SemiL-anU1ual payments are due to begin in April, 1956 and will retire the Loan on uctober 1, 56>'. 6,6066,996.93 had been disbursed by April 30, i95I4 and another ,4h,723.35 had been committed under irrevocable letters of credit guaranteed by the Bankc.
6, Schedule 4 of the Loan Agreement designates a part of tne Loan,
Additional data may be found in the followring reports circulated to the Executive Directors: (a) P.5 - Report and Recommendations of the President to the Ekecutive Directvors on the proposed Loan for the 'Wadi Tharthar FLood Control Project of the Kingdom of Iraq, June 12, 1950,(R.g33 4 ). (b)L.85.a-Technical Report on the ladi Tharthar Flood Control -Project in Iraq, June 7, 1950,(R-334).
B.
THE PROJECT
9. The Tigris runs swiftly and rises suddenly. Its annual floods, fed by heavy rains and melting snow from the Zagros Ranges flanlcing southern Turkey, are often uncontrollable. Even a local rainstorm in the Zaeros can produce great changes in the river level in a few hours, and a rise of from 8 to 12 feet in one day is not unusual. At Baghdad the river discharges a minimum of 11;900 cubic feet per second in September and a maximum of 106,650 cubic feet per second in April, with a rise in ltevel of 18 feet, Leves hiiilt to contain peak floods have in the past proved inadequate and, to protect Baghdad from disaster, it has often been necessary to breach the river's eastern banks far upstream, thus flooding valuable crop lands. The Wadi Tharthar Project is designed to+.r protect i~v-,-banare-as and p,%eTrevent crop Incses by, divrtin ptetill ThI~.e+ -r1 -Ja~ F- -~ ,rv-,-E, I,+4-V dangerous floods from the Tigris to thel'Jadi Tharthar depression, a barre o V 11w-1or lyr;rg b-4,^.- +1ho rlgw; -4 +h -,hnA -h^k-+ an o1 v aaa Y -s ul . , ren _l v_ I_ arh. Ep l Ua _ _ u. 60 k iv meters from Samarra and approximately 65 kilometers northwest of Baghdad. 10.
h1ensive IL L cojUIIp1otnen
k
UV
L.J'(4
-o
-lo'JV - -4- L - --
The basic
prUJojecU
d U.1.Ltdg: d(l..UvR ay
the Tigris near Samarra (approximately 100 kilometers upstream from Baghdad) to dam the floods, and a floodway along which the water diverted by the barrage would flow to the 1iadi Tharthar. Ancillary to the dam and floodway were tne necessary levees and training works, an inlet channel with a regulator, and the relocation of the existing roads, railways and structures near Samarra. 11. The diversion of Tigris floods to the wadi Tharthar will reduce the public expenditure on relief and repairs of flood damage. The unusually disastrous floods in the spring of 1954 provide a striking example of the enormous sums that are involved. One and one-half million acres were flooded and the damage from this flood alone has been conservatively estimated as high as ID 20 million. C. PROGRESS OF THE PROJECT
12. The Loan Agreement provides that the Project will be supervised by an engineering consultant or firm, and that the construction work will be carried out by con-tractors in each case satisfactory to the Bank. The preliminary estimates and engineering designs for this project we re carried out by the Irrigation Development Commission which was the agencyiemployed by the Ministry of Public Works to prepare plans for the developmieit of Iraq's water resources. The Government of Iraq engaged Messrs. Coode, Vaughan-Lee, Fran'k a-d Gyther of London as its consulting engineers for the project, This firm was charged with the responsibility of reviewing the preliminary designs, preparing final designs and specifications, Snd supervising both the award of contracts and the work of the contractors.
13. The contract for the first part of the project - the excavating of the channel and the related works - was awarded on the basis of competitive bidding to 11Iessrs. Balfour Beatty & Co, Ltd,of London towrards the end of 1951. Both the consulting engineers and the contracting firm were regarded by the Bank as being entirely satisfactory. Representatives of the Bank have periodically visited Iraq to inspect the progress being made on the project and satisfactory progress reports on the diversion bund and channel have been received by the Bank regularly since the summer of 1952.
WJork on the first nart of' the nroipct. which started in December 1951 advanced more slowly than had been expected as there were considerable delavs in thp dpliverv of Paluinmpnt Followinn' the arrival of the maior part of the plant during the third quarter of 1952, however, some of the lost ti me was made p10 and progress hy the end of that year was felt to be satisfactory although the final items of equipment were not received until well into 1953. lb.
As
+.in opnp-'l
an
nf
.hp.
project have been changed appreciably. The main objective is still the diversionr of flood waters but, as now plare -he brgull be huilt so as to make possible ultimately the irrigation of from 200,000 to 300,000
acres betvwveen
Samarra and BPahi-inda
fror. -LA1t.he
site and
its
height has been increased to create an enlarged storage reservoir. A power intakle st is no -cur ----4ted ln the Aand4 esign -4 e ntv t4--4othe, Ishaqi irrigation canal is to be built into the barrage structure as well.
The unesucso he oirlna design have been eli.-,inated. The capac,t
of both the regulator and the floodway to the Wadi Tharthar have been increased. Although the capacity of the floodwVay has been increased, it has been possible to reduce the size of the excavated channel to the Wadi Tharthar
to tLh.aLt s terequi1red0 toUf-rnish propIe uT raVals for i.B bIuiiu. The crianges
have been made to improve the project and broaden its scope, and at the same bime to reduce the cos=ts of some elements of it. Some of the cnanges have been prompted by the experience gained from the devastating flood in the
sp-Lng of 1,..L4.
.. It
ofr'I
Contract No.1 for the first stage of the project, the excavation of the channel and related works had to be amended on account of the decision to move the site Of the barrage, wnicl IS to be built under Contract No.2. The original plans called for a diversion channel of some 60 Km. with a bund about 50 hm. long, Mioving the barrage dowin stream has made it possible to shorten the channel and bund construction by about 7 Km. and to straighten the aiignment of- the barxrage, regulator, and embankments so as to save a considerable amount of embankment. The work now consists of a bund or embankment and pilot channel with only about 10 Km. of excavated floodway through
high land.
16.
17.
wardred
Zublin, Duisburg, on the basis of international bidding. The decision to relocat.e +.he b'arrag and proriAde for the ul+mate inqt2AAnon of nn-wer was not made until after this contract had been awarded. As a result of this relocatio. it has been possib1e to reduce the len.gth of he barrage and to carry the highway to Samarra over the barrage, regulator and embankmrents, and to ear.Wr a railuygn2
dJirn"oJ^"
overny
+vrO of
+thei e.m19aI,m.ts
andt +
regulator, thus eliminating separate bridges. Also, at the present site the barrage can be built "in the dry"- to the rIght of the main channel an.d a closing bank constructed across the main channel after the barrage is
-1spetd-A T I+ -ua -closi 1 'ne to IA4 1 the ng bar=- before the -floods in the spring of 1956. The present contract will include the intake structure
Por _
.LUs
'
4z_
dD .L
_P _ o_1 V p jJv5LJ.
Z
U Uy
nt
.L.VU
gIIU - -
-.
X_ Liig
UllLUJ
.z-r
e.
11
Vi
capacity. The drawings for the engineering and design of the main dam and associated works ha-ve not yet been compleTed but thI contra2ctor has star;t ed to make borings and carry out other prelimirary work in accordance with general plans.* Revised specifications and cost schedules are also being prepared by the consulting engineers, The elimination of the highway and railway bridges, the shortening of the channel and Dunad the straightening of the alignment of the barrage, regulator, and embankinents, and the elimination of the undersluices of the original design have all affected savings. On the other hand, the addition of the intake structure for the power plant, the increase in the size ofA the regulator and floodwTay, and the raising oI the height of the dam have all increased the cost of the project, The final
cost will be higher than the original estimate of ID 10.22 million.
18. The last visit made to Baghdad by Bank engineers was in the latter part of April 195h. At that time it was found that, although the first part of the project was behind original construction schedules, it was progressing in a reasonably satisfactory manner. It is expected that construction -will have advanced sufficiently to permit diversion of flood waters in the spring of 1956. 19. Disbursements of IBRD funds have thus far been made: (a) for earth-moving equipment required for carrying the first stage, or Contract No.l, the contract for the diversion canal, and (b) for capitalized interest and commitment charges. An amount of 25.7 million is allocated in the List og Goods for the equipment needed for Contract No.1 and over $5.4 million has been disbursed. The Iraqi Government has followed all the requirements of the Project Funds Agreement and has duly paid to the National Bank the T amounts of local currency set out in Schedule 1 of that Agreement. Jp to June 1, 1954, according to the Development Board's Directorate of Accounts, the actual sums paid to the contractors, in Iraqi dinars, were ID 2,646,900 on Contract No.1 and ID 1,219,000 on Contract No,2. 20. The Bank-financed eqLipment, which is being supplied to the contractor and which will become his property on completion of the contract, is being paid for by the contractor by deductions from gross earninps.
were
after.
By the end of December 1953 ID 463,900 had been deductedl, and the
of thet dirllarL equi-J-VcA.LUri VI Ulthe cost of the equiLLz1R,-1iW) V 4,1oUU.iQ-i1
rer,mainder
to about ID 1,660,100, is to be deducted from earnings over the 2-year period to Decel-uber 1955. 21. The amount payable under Contract Tno.2 for the erection of the dam has not been determined because physical quantities have not yet been established and detailed cost estimates have not been prepared. The List of Goods for the project will have to be revised to reflect the several
The changes in
the project are such that the project description in Schedule 2 of the Loan
Agreement should be rewritten and the figures of estimated costs,in Schedule 4 revised. The estimates of dinar costs for Contract No.1 haveinot yet been revised to take account of the new design. Under both contracts the
new designs are expected to result in reductions in local currency expendi-
tures. If these expectations are realized the dinar payments to be made to the National Bank in terms of Schedule l of the Project Funds Agreement (which was set up under the loan agreement to assure the availability of local currency for the project) will prove to be more than are needed.
- 7PART TI
POT.TTT(AT. STT'TATTON
229 Iraq is one of t A 9 the of en the Ottoman Empire. It was originally administered by Britain under a League of ;;ations madate. It has been an independent constitutional monarchy since 1932 and has been fortunate in having had relatively stable government. Iraq is n active mrermber of the Aab T-enage J I+t ; aare of -t strategic importance and has dealt firmly with the local Communist
C.,?
43
ILIU~
d.4
LZ
LJJA.OC14II
-e.Lt. ;
Iiiiuitjer
V-J
LX
UL1idUA:I.LJ
V.Jj
UC.'JUV.LJU0
are elected on the basis of one to every 20,000 male Iraqi subjects; lfJLiUiwhose nuL Luers miia-y notJ exceeIu one-fow-th thU4 nuuUber of 1i L4L e U4 are appointed by the King from among those who "by their acts have,gained
thie
confidence and trust ofi tvhe people and tohose whco have an honorable
past in the service of the Governanent and the country". 24. Dissatisfaction with the slow progress made in i'tplementing development plans springs in part from pUiblic awareness of the recent great increase in oil revenues. At the same tilre a good deal of the criticism levelled at the Government on this score undoubtedly arises from public ignorance of the considerable time that must elapse between the inception of a project and its realization.
PART
III
_ 827. Lf 0
A 11
IIJ1I.L.U
1J4.
-4P
d.fIVJL
has
liiao
enabled 11CLJ4tU
WLi
r--AApid
djJ4-U
4-crs
main.ly su-,plp
au a
a capacity ofla L4
and in September 1953 a 65-mile 24"? pipeline from Basrah to Fao on the Fersiarl Gualf, -. with a capacity of o million tons per year, was compieteao
Also, the marketing of Iraq oil is easier because the coumtry accepts
sterlin.g.
production, it is not expected tnat Iraq would suffer significantly. The increase in world demand should be sufficient to absorb Iranian oil. Iraq output, in fact, could increase still further if' the termmial of the Kirkuk-Haifa pipeline, whlich is now unused because of the irab boycott Of Israel, is moved to Lebanon. 28. The risinR:, revenues have given Iraq large resources with wThich to finance its development program, The Government established a Developmrent Board in 1950 to plan and carry out a program, and originally all of the income from oil was earmarked for tVe Board. In Mlarch 1952, however, new legislation was adopted under which 30% of future revenues were assigned to thle ordinary Government budget. This action has not resulted in a reduction in the funds that had been estimated in 1950 would be available to the Board; oil revenues have increased so rapidly that the 70% remaining to the Board has actually exceeded the total original 1950 estimates. The Board was originally given a large degree of autonomnr, but Ln July 1953, as a result of a reorganization, it was more closely integrated waith Government proper, and a member of the Cabinet, the 1Uinister of TDevelopment, was made in large part responsible for its operations.
... )p Thp Boardl inrow earr-yangf out an imnvrestmentpro> rntmof about ID 155 million covering the 6-year period ending in 1956. About ID 32
millinn r had been nn+.ii,l 1r allrc-ni-ate+d ton the 1it-m theo11,ll + r
3
+Iha fiscral .
ending March 31, 1953. An estimated additional m 35 million was allocatedt+o+he 1,o'nd in 1Q53-54. As of Marcih 31, -QI).g -toa + h,men+s including loans, advances, etc., I 31,327,h30, of which I g million 1ere
was 1.ri+.thdrav.nm for th,e orrinar,rn
hl,e+.. of
+-h "nimore in der
+h-
Tm
million consists of loans to other government departments and agencies sucht-h Bagh.l_d b_l sen-r1ce, as tr o refiney the A ric',,1 e Machinery Administration and various municipalities. It is impossible to
+vhe
say howr
r..uch of
the latter
t+vwrO
nmo,vn-ts
released
to
the C.vA
its
agencies has been actually disbursed. The fact that actual expenditure on development has bencnidrby'ottrr than. the available income is not surprising because it takes time in any country to plan and get longterm proJects u*d-r jay on a sound basis. Iraq has bQeen handicapped in-
va-d
- 930. Expenditures under the capital works item of the extraordinary budget (against the amounts approved by the Development Board for disbursement by the Government) were ID 2.76 million for 1951-52 and ID 4.59 million for 1952-53. The Development Board has approved capital works expenditures of ID 4 million for 1953-54 and ID 6 million for 1954-55. 31. The 30% of oil revenues allocated to the Government since M4arch 31. 1952 have enabled Government expenditures to rise. Regular budget expenditures rose from ID 28 million in 1951-52 to iD 51,227,58h in 1953-54. The 195h-q5 budaet. already apDroved by the Cabinet, amounts to ID 54 million. Expenditures have reached these magnitudes without thus far throwing the hbudget nit nfn bnalan ReGeints in 19q9-0 were swelled by a snecial ID 7.5 million settlement of the Gold Clause dispute with the Iraq Petroleum Company. There hnR even hbpn some reduition nf the internal debt; whilh stnod Pt only ID 7 million as of lMarch 31, 1954. 32. Almost every type of expenditure has been increasing. Outlays for defence and police, for example, were budgeted at ID 18.3 million in 1953-54 as compared with only ID 9.7 million in 1951-52. Expenditures on health, education, agriculture, and public works have risen significantly. Also, the Government has provided out of its regular budget for increases in the capital of government banks, including the Industrial Bank, the Agricultural Bank, and the Chattel ilortgage Bank, and the Realty iHortgage Bank. 33. The rapid increase in oil production and the rapid rise in oil revenues accruing to the country has not yet had much effect on production elsewhere in the economy. Oil production has increased without adding significant numbers to the permanent working force in the industry in Iraq and without requiring a significant volume of subsidiary or ancillary domestic investment. Also, the effects of the increased exports of oil are different from those of increases in exports of other commodities. The oil producers hold concessions from the Government. so that a very large part of Iraq's income from oil exports accrues in the first instance to the Government rather than to the local population. The incomes of
the latter will increase only as the Government spends the oil revenues
locally alnd as outout outside the oil industrv rises as a result of the
combination of both.
the
barley crp may have increased by asnucith as 20% * Date production, however, has tended to fall slightly. The trend of prices has been down, so t-hat incom-.e h-as pnrob%ablvy fallen ansd e iJncorm .rom. Lo-rt gra%J I4ns '-,as also
fallen.
The terms of trade for commodities other than oil have moved
10
35. The value of exports other than oil is now in the neighborhood of ID 20-25 million. By contrast receipts from oil were more than ID
50 million in 1953.
36. Imports have risen markedly since 1950. Imports other than oil company imports were approximately iD 29 million in 1950, rose to about ID 42 million in 1951, to about ID 47 million in 1952 and to ID 5.5r million in 1953, The large increase in imports has been inanced, or course, by the rising oil revenues. It has been made possible by the relaxation of import restrictions. 37. Imports of both conswuption goods and investment goods have risen substantially. The increase in imports of investment goods has been caused principally by the increase in actual investmnent expendituures of the Development Board and the Government itself, and to a lesser extent by the increase in private investment expenditures. These increased investment expenditures, together with tl;e rising expenditures of the Government on defence, internal security, and social services, have resulted in higher employment and enlarged purchasing power for the population as a whole. This increased purchasing power, howJever, has apparently been used alnost as rapidly as it has been created, to purchase imports. The money supply, therefore, has remained remarkably stable over the past 4 years and has only recently shown a tendency to rise. Iraq - Currency, Deposits, Credit and Prices (Mioney values in millions of dinars)
End
1950
End
1951
Fnd 1952
RnM 1953
3h.5
M
.8
32.2 1,,A
11.3
30,0
lJ.g
34.3
I 3
1565
o.0
10.8
Cost of liZrir
b/
103 91
112 98
116 101
96 91
j/
Bills discounted and advances to other than government. 1949 - 100 1949 100, Baghdad
38. It should be noted that, in the volume of commercial bank of the economy, there are as yet Despite the recent rise in money have fallen quite sharply. This
although there was an increase in 1953 credit extended to the -rivate sector no signs of a domestic inflation., supply, wholesale and consumer prices fall in prices is probably accounted for principallv bv the lioeral import policy, tnae.,r wii+h a f * the cost of certain imported consumer goods, as well as by better crops in 1953
i1
39. In spite of the growth of imports Iraq has had very suobstantial surpluses in its ovrerall balance of payments in recent years. In 1952 Iraq's foreign assets increased by approxdmately ID 11 million, and in 1953 by almost ID 23 million. In January 1954 there was a further increase of about ID 10 million. At the end of January 1954 Iraqts foreign assets stood at more than ID 93 million which was about double what they had been four years earlier. 40. It is abundantly clear that thus far at least Iraq's financial resources have increased more rapidly than the country has been able to spend them, The rate of development expenditure is increasing, hcw-. ever, and it remains to be seen whether it will rise to a level at which all oil revenues will be currently used. The economic and financial situation is basically sound. The free iimort policy has kept internal prices down, enabling Iraq thus far to avoid the sort of domestic inflation that might adversely affect the sound development of the non-oil sector of the economy, especially the competitive position of exports,
- 12 -
R A Q
BASIC STPTISTICS Area Population (estimated) Trade statistics (millions of Iraqi dinars) 179000 sq. miles 5 million
1951
50.3 28.7
37.6
66.1
51.0
8.4
8.7
14e4
13e2
1950
Barley 463
1951
440
1952
339
1953
489
Dates Petroleum
211 6,070
339 7,957
24X2 17,701
251 26,869
Balance of payments (milliors of Iraqi dinars) 1950 Transactions oF foreign-owned oil companiies (net foreign exchange surrendered) Other goods and services (net balance) + 7.9 + 1951 + 19-3 1952 4 39.7 - 25.9
.9
809
t 8.8
10.1
+ 13,8
8&2 50.1
9.9
15.3
1807 83.2
505
61.5
Money suppLy (millions of Iraqi dinars) 1950 Currency Deposit monev yVTotal
34.5
-,o
30e
)y l.a
34h3
IIv
A.
Prices
1949
100
192 116
1953
19
-41olesale prices (All goods)
1951 112
103
96
91
98
104
91
1950/5J
Revenue Expenditures Surplus or deficit
1951/52 36.7
2842
+
*
32.2 28.3 +
o.2
8.6
142.3
U.o
5.7
3.9
8.5
Estinates
1951/52
Receipts Planned
1952/53
1953/54
Actual
Disbursements
10.5
8.ei
2065
23.7
33.9
9.4
20o5
2FLJ
Actual
22.0