Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
C O N F I D E N T I A L | www.mkm.de
Agenda
MKmetric Methodology Application x-via web Applikation SONAR Examples from former MKmetric studies Results of network simulations for Airport Pozna (POZ)
- Ministry of Infrastructure > Analyses of the Polish air transport system with scenarios (2009/2010) Forecast all airports 2015, 2025, 2035 with simulation of 18 scenarios
For further details please visit our web site: www.mkm.de
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 3
Agenda
MKmetric Method Application x-via web Application SONAR Examples from former MKmetric studies Results of network simulations for Airport Pozna (POZ)
Method The situation of the travellers and their behaviour are the main issue.
Trip yes or no? Where to? Which modality? What carrier? When?
Car, train or plane? STR, FRA or MUC? Departure, when? By Metro to Airport or ...?
decision
Transparency taken from the presentation: Data for network planing in air transport; IVT-Seminar; Dr. Karl Echtermeyer; DLH AG June 2000; ETH Zrich 1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 5
!
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 6
Method Poor data supply background - SITA Trends Survey 2010 (Airline IT)
Today 40,8 % of tickets are direct sales from the airline to the traveller. Thereof - 25,8% by internet - 10,7% by call centre - 4,3% by interlining In 2013 the following targets are envisaged: - 55,1% direct sales whereby - 33,9% are by internet but - call centre and interlining remains stable Increasing activities by airlines using Smartphones features in 2013 for - ticket sales - 70% of all airlines / 85% of the big airlines (today) - flight status information - 86% - mobile online check-in - 80% (today 28%) - mobile electronic boarding pass - 76% - travel offers - 68% Increasing self service up to 2013 - agent check-in reducing from today 50,7% to 28,9% - kiosk check-in remains stable at 20% - kiosk ticket sales - 80% - more kiosks - 47% Introduction of booking portals by airlines up to 2013 - for travel agencies - 84% (today 41%) - for business clients - 82% (today 44%) - social networking functions - 55% (today 21%)
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011
All activities listed will reduce within 2 years further the sample size, coverage and quality of the database used by classical forecast models!
7
100%
Why? - direct sales, e.g. internet - cost reduction - consolidators - GDS (Global Distribution System*)
Trend
Booking data
Up to 1995
Size, type and structure of the market are well known.
Today
Up to 1995
Today
Fragmented market, new products, type, structure, faster shock waves, global drivers, new sales structure, limited rights using airline ticket sales data.
8
Trend based forecasts neither reflect the changes nor cope with the data leakage.
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 9
Method Data background for all MKmetric systems (VIA, SONAR, x-via web)
Volume observations e.g. - detailed Eurostat, national statistics (on flight, on stage) - airport, airline publications, IATA samples, - associations of airports and airlines, - link counting for road - transport figures for rail, ...
Consumer elasticity e.g. - airport surveys across Europe, - DE - KONTIV survey, mobility survey, - DK - national mobility survey, - CH - national travel survey, - EU - Dateline mobility survey, ...
Mode networks e.g. - air schedules (OAG, Cedion, ...), - information from the air transport industry, - surface networks (road, bus), - railway, ferry schedules , - MKm extensions, ...
Regional attractors e.g. - socio-economy (UN, IWF, OECD, EZB, ...), - satellite data (Corine aggregates), - tourist information - land use data, - meteorological data, ...
10
Method The point of view turns from the airport to the region as starting point of the trip decision. Therefore the traditional static view becomes a consumer oriented dynamic one.
11
Method MKmetric system approach MKmetric explains transport in a consistent way. No transport activity appears or vanishes unexplained.
Transport is embedded in its determinants
Model layers
Scenarios Determinants
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 12
Method MKmetric system approach Which modality? - Which mode? - Which route?
Types of modality Forms of modality*
Multimodality
For a trip from Poznan to Brussels use - the plane - the train - the private car or a coach
MultiMultimodality modality
Intermodality
For a trip from Poznan to Brussels by air starting from an airport in Berlin - and use the train to Berlin Zoo (+ Bus) - the private car to Berlin-Tegel
InterIntermodality modality
Intramodality
For a trip from Poznan to Brussels use the plane either on the route - POZ - FRA - BRU or - POZ - WAW - BRU or - WAW - BRU or - THF - BRU or ...
IntraIntramodality modality
MKmetric
13
14
Method MKmetric system approach Display of consumer cost elasticity for a specific route.
15
Method MKmetric system approach Travellers consumer behaviour is non-linear. Thresholds influence the decision and activate changes in product choice. Thus consumers elasticity is a key issue to understand.
16
Method MKmetric system approach Travellers consumer behaviour is non-linear. Thresholds influence the decision and activate changes in product choice. Thus consumers elasticity is a key issue to understand.
Logit
:x
( )
( x k 1) k = ln( x )
k 0 k = 0
i, jCn
P(i) n =
U in U jn j
Point elasticity
Ceteris paribus variation of the demand for alternative i by a 1% change of the characteristic value of alternative i.
Cross elasticity
Ceteris paribus variation of the demand for alternative j by a 1% change of the characteristic value of alternative i.
17
Method MKmetric system approach - Excursus The price elasticity diversified by markets in the year 1991. Travel market (Hamburg base year 1991) research results from 1992/93 World-wide first scientific explanation for LCC- success
Domestic
Hamburg 1991
100% 80% 60% 40%
Europe
Hamburg 1991
Intercontinental
Hamburg 1991
80%
Vacation Vacation
40%
60%
20%
40%
Vacation
0%
20%
Private
20%
0%
0%
Business
-20%
Business
Business
-20% -40% -60% -80%
-20%
-40%
-40%
Private Private
-60%
-60%
-100
-50
50
100
150
-50
50
100
150
-50
50
100
150
200
Price
Method MKmetric system approach Linking the model steps by a quasi-direct format (QDF) in the forecasting system
Each change in one layer of the econometric model will be re-calculated and considered in the next layer.
Generation/distribution
Modal split
Airport choice
Access/egress choice
Slot choice
Method MKmetric system approach MKmetric approach to market investigation using multi level econometric models for simulation. Procedure to establish the reference case and its use for the simulation of scenarios.
Detailed information about the MKmetric System Approach can be found at www.mkm.de
Socioeconomy
Infrastructure
Urbanisation
Transport policy
Scenario definition
Reference Status
System Approach - generation - distribution - mode choice - airport/route choice - assignment
Ex post
20
Generation
Distribution
Modal split
Route choice
Assignment
The calibration is an iterative process where data from various sources and model results are assessed to detect irregularities, inconsistencies and errors. The arrows symbolise the principle process flow but due to the complexity the recursive parts and their nesting can not be displayed.
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 21
Method MKmetric system approach Principle scenario types at the different model stages. Generation of traffic: Socio-economic framework data (e.g. population, structure, GDP) Political decisions (e.g. taxes, security, noise charges) Distribution of traffic : Regional attractivities (e.g. type of region, temperature, sea, mountains) Political decisions (e.g. traffic rights, subsidies) Mode choice: Network / Service characteristics (e.g. time, cost, frequency, transfer, operation days) Political decisions (e.g. PSO, infrastructure investments) Airport / Route choice: Service-Structure (e.g. new route / closure, MCT, airline base, transfer node) Infrastructure (e.g. access / egress by surface modes, inter-modal routes) Assignment: Infrastructure networks (e.g. new airports, new HSR services) and/or changes of network attributes (e.g. capacity, speed, charges, tolls, fees)
Please note that the examples may as well be applicable in other model stages. 1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 22
Method MKmetric system approach Excursus: Complexity and coverage. Regions: Europe on NUTS 3 level World (aggregates of administrative units) Relations: Region to Region demand matrix About 1900 x 1900 relationships Airports: Europe all scheduled services (e.g. delivered by OAG, HAFAS, web sites, own research) World - representative airports with scheduled services for all world regions Surface modes (Feeders / Competitors): Road - network ca. 2,8 Mio. links, up to county road level Rail whole network with real Europe-wide schedule data Alternatives: Intercontinental destinations represented by 16 alternatives per relation European destinations represented by 10 alternatives per relation National destinations represented by 7 alternatives per relation Trip purposes: business non-business (private u. vacation trips)
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 23
Agenda
MKmetric Method MKmetric applications SONAR, x-via web Application x-via web Application SONAR Examples from former MKmetric studies
24
x-via web - Online analyse and simulations tool Approach and focus. MKmetric approach : Best possible consistent reflection of the market based on determined information in an uncertain environment. Understanding of consumer reaction by their elasticities (price, time, frequency, alliance, comfort, ...). Assistance for independent analyses by an easy to use intuitive interface and download of all tables and graphs to the own desktop for further use. Tool optimised for online usage by clients with no browser restrictions, mobile access and fast response time. Focus of the x-via web tool: Concentration on the mode air transport. Coverage of commercial air traffic inbound, outbound, across and within Europe for all air service types (FSC, LCC, Charter carrier). Exploring the problem of intra-modality, the competition in the air transport system. Enhancing the transparency of the air transport market by own data maintenance, harmonisation and processing embedding multiple data sources (socio-economic, survey, mobility data, ...) circumventing GDS gaps e.g. due to internet sales providing full scaled interregional demand matrices matching latest statistics. Analyses of the competition among airports. Analyses of the competition among routes. Flexible scenario definition and conservative simulation. Benchmarking demand effects at the objective reference case displaying a full market picture of the previous year.
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 25
x-via web Scenario definition and simulation. Flexibility in the scenario definition: Add / delete air services. Change flight schedules. Change air service characteristics like time, frequency, day of operation, airline, alliance, aircraft, terminal. Change airport characteristics minimum connecting times in general and detailed. Modulate market volumes by introducing your expertise and ideas. Upload of multiple schedules (network, nodes, waves). Simulation of: non-linear consumer behaviour (consideration of thresholds), demand effects for one route or a network, an airport or market, local and transfer passengers.
26
x-via web The tool allows analyses out of three different point of view; the airport, the region and the route (airline). Region: Airport / Route choice of the traveller by route and trip purpose. Diffusion diagram of competing airports. Accessibility of regions. Airport: Catchment of the airport or a route for OD and transfer travellers. Proportional distribution of the demand in space. Airlines and air services at an airport. Route: Demand by routes at an airport (Spider). Feeder-Information of a flight segment (Sheaf). Top transfer destinations. Data coverage: Analyses available for all European airports with commercial traffic and regions.
27
Technical standard: - Internet access, - Browser - Firefox >=1.5 or Internet Explorer 6+ - or Opera mobile with UMTS. Cooperation between client and customer to benefit the further tool development: - analyses types, simulation types, - tool-handling, format, - content of working processes and / or standard reports, story, - statistics, airport surveys, - response about errors and difficulties. Availability: - 365 days 24 hours, except maintenance time and Force majeure, - assistance during the general working hours, exclusive vacation time.
28
Agenda
MKmetric Method Application x-via web Application SONAR Examples from former MKmetric studies Results of network simulations for Airport Pozna (POZ)
29
SONAR - Scan Of New Air Routes The analyses is structured in four sections and are displayed in a standard format reflecting different point of views. 1. Theory (popular scientific explanation of the system approach) 2. Information and analyses of the airport location in focus - catchment, accessible GDP, population and employment, actual air services 3. Analyses for the identified and selected routes - Network sheaf - graph including successor and predecessor segments - by total pass. - Estimated demand, table - total, local, transfer, business, non-business pass. figures - Technical route information, table - distance, suggestion of airline, aircraft and schedule including corresponding capacity, frequency and load factor - Spatial distribution of passengers, maps - for both airports connected by the route - Top transfer destinations, table - from-via-to airport transfer connections by frequency - Airport choice - graph - identified route and competing alternative routes - Airlines market position at the destination airport, table - market shares of airlines serving the destination airport - European destinations linked by destination airport, status quo, graph - by frequency - Destinations served outside Europe by the destination airport, list of airports 4. Effects upon the airport in focus - catchment and its changes, aircraft movements, passengers, accessibility and its change - summary with recommendations
Examples of analyses displayed by SONAR can be found at www.mkm.de.
31
MKmetric Method Application x-via web Application SONAR Examples from former MKmetric studies Results of network simulations for Airport Pozna (POZ)
32
Berlin Brandenburg International Airport, planned new airport, forecasted in 1993. Hamburg Airport forecasted in 1995. Frankfurt Airport forecasted in 2003.
33
New route POZ-DUB MKmetric forecast for 2006: Airport statistics POZ-DUB (04 - 12.2006):
1)
Forecast for Barcelona BCN scheduled Centralwings. Operation: Barcelona Girona - scheduled Centralwings. Forecast for Paris CDG scheduled Air France or LOT with code share Air France. Operation: Paris Beauvais - scheduled Centralwings. Forecast for Rome FCO scheduled AlItalia or Air One or LOT with code share Air One. Operation: Rome CIA - scheduled Centralwings.
2)
3)
R) Remark:
The charter destinations Antalya, Heraklion and Tenerife (Pax 49.453) in operation show in total the charter potential indicated by the MKm forecast of 51.163 pax for all charter destinations (see next slide with orig. forecast). If vacationists can just select 3 out of 7 destinations the demand concentrates to a certain extent on the services available.
1st Polish Regional Airport Association Conference, Cracow 10-11.03.2011 35
36
37
Stopped 2009, alternative e.g. HRG, ATY Larger A/C and lower frequency as suggested Parallel service to OVD assumed (78000 forecast)
Germanwings will offer 976 seats on 4/7 frequency to FCO Ryanair will offer 756 seats on 2/7 frequency to ALC Ryanair will offer 756 seats on 2/7 frequency Lufthansa will offer 432 seats on weekends
38
MKmetric Method Application x-via web Application SONAR Examples from former MKmetric studies Results of network simulations for Airport Pozna (POZ)
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52