Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
SHEET NO.:
DOC. NO.:
DATE:
OF
25
FA9104D-A-11-001
11-Jun-07
REV. NO.:
REVISION LIST
REV. NO.
DATE
PAGE
11-Jun-07
ALL
20-Jul-06
ALL
7-Sep-06
9,10
27-Sep-06
6,7,8,9,10,11
29-Sep-06
ALL
25-Oct-06
14,15,16,17
8-Nov-06
18,19 (Insert)
11-Jun-07
16,17
11-Jun-07
ALL
AS-BUILT
DESCRIPTION
SHEET NO.:
DOC. NO.:
DATE:
OF
25
FA9104D-A-11-001
11-Jun-07
REV. NO.:
ATTACHMENT :
A#1
Page
A#2
Page
A#3
Page
A#4
Page
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
11-Jun-07
Revision:
TPC VINA
Fw or
Fe
O.D.
hc
INPUT DATA:
SOIL INVESTIGATION REPORT
LOADING DATA FROM TANK DESIGNER
ENGINEERING SPECIFICATION FOR CIVIL DESIGN CRITERIA ( SP-C-2, SP-C-3 )
CODES & BOOKS USED:
ACI - 318-95
ASCE-7-02
1.1 DESIGN OF SPHERE TANK FOUNDATION
This Design Checks for the following:
1) Stability Against Sliding & Overturning
2) Capacity of Pile
3) Strength of Concrete Foundation Against Punching & Beam Shear
4) Steel Requirements
1.2 DESIGN CONDITION
Compressive strength of concrete
f'c
density of Concrete
210.00
kg/cm2
2400.00
Vw
38.00
m/s
Wind Pressure
Pw
155.00
kg/m2
Seismic Requirements
Zone 0
fy
3900.00
kg/cm
qs
1800.00
kg/m2
q(allow .)
20000.00
kg/m2
Shape Factor
sphere
kg/m2
=
0.60
P.C.D
26.190
Height of column
hc
16.000
Nc
15
nos.
13.327
4 of 25
N/mm2
382.59
N/mm2
kg/m
20.60
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
Date:
TPC VINA
Revision:
Hp
0.650
Width of pedestal
Wp
1.800
Length of Pedestal
Lp
1.800
Width of Footing
Wf
4.000
Length of Footing
Lf
4.000
Depth of Footing
Hf
1.000
0.050
0.075
d (eff)
0.925
Pile Diameter
Dp
0.500
1.500
0.500
Wtb
0.60
Btb
0.80
Ltb
1.53
Lf
Wf
2
3.0* Pile dia.
z
3
x
A
5 of 25
J-6101
11-Jun-07
3
Project:
Subject:
Project No.
Date:
TPC VINA
Client:
Revision:
We
Wo
Wh
=
=
=
925,607.00
8,952,967.00
11,003,607.00
kg
kg
kg
Fwv
Fwh
P
Wo/15
We/15
=
=
=
=
=
54,830.00
53,000.00
733,600.00
596,864.47
61,707.13
kg
kg
kg
kg
kg
Wf
43,454.40
kg
Tie Beam
1) Weight of tie beam
Wtb
1,762.56
kg
Soil Surcharge
1) Weight of soil surcharge
Ws
8,038.80
kg
kg
1.4.2 Loading Data for each column (from tank strength calculation)
1) Vertical wind load
2) Horizontal wind load
3) Hydrostatic load
4) Operating weight
5) Empty weight
Concrete Foundation
1) Weight of Footing
Load Factor
Total Dead Load
1.4.3 Wind Load
Load Factor
Wind Force
Wind Moment @ bottom of Footing
Fw
Mw
Weight
tons
925607.0
43454.4
kg
kg
969061.4
kg
=
=
1.00
11,802,443.40
=
=
=
1.00
53,000.00
919,550.00
kg
kg
kg-m
kg-m
919,550.00
MR
tons-m
12335564.5
0.0
12335564.5
13.41
M R/M O=
>
2
Hence, ok
FW
W
Resisting force
where, co-efficient of friction
53,000.00
kg
484,530.70
kg
FR/F W =
9.14
0.5
>
1.5
Hence, ok
53,000.00
kg
54,830.00
kg
PILE
rxi
2
r xi
a 1,3
1.5
4.5
b 1,3
1.5
4.5
c 1,3
1.5
4.5
13.5
6 of 25
J-6101
11-Jun-07
3
Project:
Subject:
Project No.
TPC VINA
Client:
EMPTY
OPERATING
HOR. LOADS
WIND
TEST
11-Jun-07
Revision:
VERTICAL LOADS ( kg )
PIER NO.
J-6101
Date:
REMARKS
WIND (kg)
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
2 , 15
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
3 , 14
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
4 , 13
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
5, 12
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
6 , 11
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
7, 10
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
8,9
61,707.13
596,864.47
733,600.00
54,830.00
53,000.00
AT EACH PIER
OPERATION + WIND
704,950.23
kg
87,450.00
kg-m
88,044.47
kg
68,611.14
kg
9.00
1.50
= Fh x ( Hp + Hf )
Mw =
Ri max=
( xi)
n
xi^ 2
Ri min=
( xi)
n
xi^ 2
2) CASE - 2 :
ton/pile
91.4
ton/pile
kg
87.4
ton/pile
122399.78
kg
122.4
ton/pile
91,380.64
kg
91.4
ton/pile
AT EACH PIER
88.0
800,563.26
kg
= Fh x ( Hp + Hf ) x 0.25
21,862.50
kg-m
91,380.64
kg
86,522.31
kg
9.00
1.50
Mw =
( xi)
n
xi^ 2
Ri max=
( xi)
n
xi^ 2
Ri min=
3) CASE - 3 :
1.0
786,855.76
No. of Piles
Reaction/ pile
9.00
87,428.42
n
4) CASE - 4 :
1.4
1,101,598.06 kg
No. of Piles
Ru
Ru
=
=
9.00
n
REMARKS:
1) Max Load on Pile for Case Numbers 1 to 3 only
121,000.00
kg
121.0
ton/pile
270,000.00
kg
270.0
ton/pile
122,399.78
kg
Project:
Subject:
Project No.
TPC VINA
Client:
J-6101
11-Jun-07
Date:
Revision:
Hf/2
Wc
Hf/2
Wf
Hf
V =3*R
a
y
Ru
Vu
Mu
=
=
=
=
=
1.500
m
0.600
m
122,399.78 kg/pile
367,199.35 kg
220,319.61 kg - m
Vu (allow )
463,857.95
Mu
Vud
ACI CODE :
Strength Reduction factor for Shear & torsion for Ultimate Stength Design
Vu (allow) =
0.85
0.85 Vc
where:
Mu = Ultimate Moment
Vu = Flexural Shear Load @ critical section
bw = Length of the Shear surface
d(eff) = effective depth of the shear surface
Mu/Vud = shall be computed @ a critical section midway between support face & the center line of load
Use min
ACI 10.5.4
=
0.0020
8 of 25
kg
1,200,741.89
3,602,225.67
2,161,335,401.57
4,550,446.49
N
N
N-mm
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
Note: Loadings are being distributed unto piles,neglect upward soil pressure on punching area
Strength Reduction factor
0.85
Fp
9,605,935.12
Punching Perimeter
bo
Vp
1.09084 N/mm
2
1.51294 N/mm
vp =
1
3
f 'c
11200
N
mm
2
Ultimate Moment Mu
Mu
0.90
R = Mu / bd^2
0.759
0.00203
(min)
0.00200
0.85 f ' c
2R
1 1
fy
0.85 f ' c
> (min)
Bottom rebar (bothways)
2,161,335,401.57 N-mm
2
N/m
mm
As(req)
25
mm
16.52
nos.
As(req)
8000.00
mm2
25
mm
16.30
nos.
say
17
nos.
say
17
nos.
Main Reinforcement
Secondary Reinforcement Reinforcement
9 of 25
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
11-Jun-07
Revision:
TPC VINA
y
y'
main bar
Hf
Covering
d
b
=
= ( 600*2+1307*1)/3
=
=
=
=
=
=
f'c
600.0 mm.
836.0
25.0
1100.0
75.0
1012.5
4707
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
kg/cm2
210.00
3900.00
kg/cm
fy
y'
Ru
Vu
Mu
=
=
=
=
0.836
m
122,399.78 kg/pile
367,199.35 kg
306,978.66 kg - m
Vu (allow )
394,138.82
20.60
N/mm2
382.59
N/mm2
1,200,741.89
3,602,225.67
3,011,460,659.52
N
N
N-mm
Mu
Vud
( f ' c) +17.237
xbwd
sqrt
3.52.5Vudx0.158
Mu
ACI CODE :
Strength Reduction factor for Shear & torsion for Ultimate Stength Design =
Vu (allow) =
0.85
0.85 Vc
where:
Mu = Ultimate Moment
Vu = Flexural Shear Load @ critical section
bw = Length of the Shear surface
d(eff) = effective depth of the shear surface
Mu/Vud = shall be computed @ a critical section midway between support face & the center line of load
Use min
0.0020
ACI 10.5.4
=
10 of 25
kg
3,866,501.85
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
=
Punching Shear Force
Fp
=
Punching Perimeter
bo
=
Punching Shear Stress (Mpa)
Allowable Punching stress (Mpa)
Vp
vp =
1
3
f 'c
0.85
6,929,742.41
11600
N
mm
2
0.68567 N/mm
2
1.51294 N/mm
Ultimate Moment Mu
Strenth reduction factor
Mu
=
=
R = Mu / bd^2
=
=
(min)
0.85 f ' c
2R
1 1
=
fy
0.85 f ' c
(beam) >
3,011,460,659.52 N-mm
0.90
2
0.693 N/mm
0.00185
0.00200
(min)
As(req)
N
Top rebar (bothways)
As(req)
=
=
=
9,531.68
25
19.42
mm2
=
=
=
9,531.68
25
19.42
mm2
mm
nos.
mm
nos.
say
20
nos.
say
20
nos.
Main Reinforcement
Secondary Reinforcement Reinforcement
11 of 25
Proj. No.
J_6101
Date:
Revision:
11 Jun 07
4
Project:
Subject:
- Width
- Height
- Beam length
- clear cover to reinforcement
- Main re bar dia
- effective depth
- Moment from soil weight
- Moment from wind load
- Sum Moment
1.2 Design
Design moment at Ultimate limit state
f'c
fy
qs
=
=
=
210.00
3900.00
1800.00
kg/cm2
kg/cm2
kg/m2
b
h
l
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
60
80
1.53
5.0
2
74
184.35
34,450.00
34,634.35
cm
cm
m.
cm
cm
cm
kg.m
kg.m
kg.m
48,488.08
14.758
0.0735
0.0040
23.7
17.232
25.12
d
M1
M2
M
provided reinforcement of
8 -
T-20
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
Top bars
provided reinforcement of
6 -
T-20
m
q ={f'c- (f'c2-4x0.59xf'cxm)} / (2x0.59xf'c)
A s required
Min. reinforcement As (10.5.1 of ACI-318)
Mu = 1.4*M
= M/bd2
= q*f'c/fy
= *100*b
= 0.00359Ac
12 of 25
=
=
kg-m
cm2
cm2
cm2
Hence, Okay!
18.84 cm2
Hence, Okay!
tons
34.1 tons
1.73128
Proj. No.
J_6101
Date:
Revision:
11 Jun 07
4
Project:
Subject:
FFW
FFV
=
=
733,600.00
4,000.00
Grade of concrete
Grade of reinforcement steel SD(39)
Reinforcing bar dia.
no of bars
lateral ties dia
dimension of column
dimension of column
Area of steel
f cylinder
fy
dia
n
dia
a
b
As
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
210
3900
25
36
10
1800
1800
17,671.46
Ag
PT
=
=
=
3,240,000.00
0.00545
737,600.00
=
=
0.7
3,606,984.3
kg.
kg.
kg/cm
2
kg/cm
mm
pcs.
mm
mm
mm
mm2
mm
20.60 N/mm
2
382.59 N/mm
kg
kg
Asmin
16,200.00
mm
As
17,671.46
mm
=
=
=
400
480
1800
mm
mm
mm
400
mm
therefore use1800x1800,36DB25Reinforcing
Bars,lateral ties dia10mm spaced at400c/c
13 of 25
176.71 cm
2
32400.00 cm
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
Design
x
35922
34430
32938
35765
34273
32781
35608
34116
32625
Actual
y
98184
98027
97870
99676
99519
99362
101167
101011
100854
x
35873
34445
32956
35749
34322
32806
35625
34147
32649
y
98164
97966
97882
99719
99540
99361
101175
100988
100832
SUM
Max. Deviation =(x^2+y^2)^0.5 =
x(mm.) y(mm.)
49
20
-15
61
-18
-12
16
-43
-49
-21
-25
1
-17
-8
-31
23
-24
22
-114
43
121.84 mm.
y'=722
y=600
y'
main bar
Hf
Covering
d
b
=
=
=
=
=
=
600.0 mm.
722.0
25.0
1000.0
75.0
912.5
4000
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
REMARKS:
91,380.64
kg
91.4
ton/pile
121,000.00
kg
121.0
ton/pile
270,000.00
kg
270.0
ton/pile
122,399.78
kg
f'c
fy
y'
210.00
3900.00
kg/cm2
kg/cm
20.60
N/mm2
382.59
N/mm2
V =3*R
Moment M
0.722
Ru
122,399.78 kg/pile
1,200,741.89
Vu
367,199.35
3,602,225.67
Mu
265,117.93 kg - m
Vu (allow )
377,973.81
kg
2,600,806,933.22 N-mm
Mu
Vud
( f ' c) +17.237
xbwd
3.52.5Vudx0.158sqrt
Mu
ACI CODE :
Strength Reduction factor for Shear & torsion for Ultimate Stength Design
Vu (allow) =
0.85 Vc
14 of 25
0.85
kg
3,707,923.12
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
where:
Mu = Ultimate Moment
Vu = Flexural Shear Load @ critical section
bw = Length of the Shear surface
d(eff) = effective depth of the shear surface
Mu/Vud = shall be computed @ a critical section midway between support face & the center line of load
Use min
0.0020
ACI 10.5.4
=
Punching Shear
Note: Loadings are being distributed unto piles,neglect upward soil pressure on punching area
Strength Reduction factor
0.85
Fp
6,896,260.88
Punching Perimeter
bo
Vp
2
0.78313 N/mm
2
1.51294 N/mm
vp =
1
3
f 'c
11200
N
mm
REBAR REQUIREMENTS
Ultimate Moment Mu
Mu
R = Mu / bd^2
0.00233
(min)
0.00200
0.85 f ' c
1
fy
(beam) >
2R
1
0
.
85
f 'c
2,600,806,933.22 N-mm
0.90
2
0.868 N/mm
(min)
As(req)
8,493.41
mm2
25
mm
17.30
nos.
As(req)
8,000.00
say
18
nos.
say
17
nos.
mm2
25
mm
16.30
nos.
Main Reinforcement
Secondary Reinforcement Reinforcement
15 of 25
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
<< W >>
FOOTING DESIGN F4
<< L >>
1600.0
25.0
1600.0
75.0
1512.5
4707
5707
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
REMARKS:
1) Max Load on Pile for Case Numbers 1 to 3 only
91,380.64
kg
91.4
ton/pile
121,000.00
kg
121.0
ton/pile
270,000.00
kg
270.0
ton/pile
122,399.78
kg
f'c
fy
kg/cm2
210.00
kg/cm
3900.00
20.60
N/mm2
382.59
N/mm2
y'
Ru
125,999.78 kg/pile
1,236,057.89
Vu
377,999.35
3,708,173.67
Mu
604,798.97 kg - m
Vu (allow )
397,257.43
V =3*R
Moment M
1.600
m
kg
5,933,077,870.85 N-mm
Mu
Vud
( f ' c) +17.237
xbwd
3.52.5Vudx0.158sqrt
Mu
ACI CODE :
Strength Reduction factor for Shear & torsion for Ultimate Stength Design
Vu (allow) =
0.85 Vc
where:
Mu = Ultimate Moment
Vu = Flexural Shear Load @ critical section
bw = Length of the Shear surface
d(eff) = effective depth of the shear surface
Mu/Vud = shall be computed @ a critical section midway between support face & the center line of load
Use min
0.0020
ACI 10.5.4
=
16 of 25
0.85
kg
3,897,095.40
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
Punching Shear
Note: Loadings are being distributed unto piles,neglect upward soil pressure on punching area
Strength Reduction factor
0.85
Fp
7,097,169.68
Punching Perimeter
bo
Vp
2
0.40258 N/mm
2
1.51294 N/mm
vp =
1
3
f 'c
13600
N
mm
REBAR REQUIREMENTS
Ultimate Moment Mu
Mu
R = Mu / bd^2
0.00163
(min)
0.00200
0.85 f ' c
1
=
fy
(beam) >
5,933,077,870.85 N-mm
0.90
2
0.612 N/mm
2R
1
0.85 f ' c
(min)
As(req)
14,238.68
mm2
25
mm
29.01
nos.
As(req)
25
mm
29.01
nos.
As(req)
14,238.68
17,263.68
30
nos.
say
30
nos.
say
36
nos.
say
36
nos.
mm2
mm2
25
mm
35.17
nos.
As(req)
17,263.68
say
mm2
25
mm
35.17
nos.
Main Reinforcement
Secondary Reinforcement Reinforcement
17 of 25
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
<< L >>
FOOTING DESIGN F7
<< W >>
y
y'
main bar
Hf
Covering
d
b1
b2
=
= (600*2+1600*1)/3
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
600.0 mm.
933.3
25.0
1200.0
75.0
1112.5
4275
5707
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
mm.
91,380.64
kg
91.4
ton/pile
121,000.00
kg
121.0
ton/pile
270,000.00
kg
270.0
ton/pile
122,399.78
kg
f'c
fy
kg/cm2
210.00
kg/cm
3900.00
20.60
N/mm2
382.59
N/mm2
y'
Ru
125,999.78 kg/pile
1,236,057.89
Vu
377,999.35
3,708,173.67
Mu
352,786.80 kg - m
Vu (allow )
461,864.85
V =3*R
0.933
m
kg
3,460,838,485.54 N-mm
Mu
Vud
ACI CODE :
Strength Reduction factor for Shear & torsion for Ultimate Stength Design
Vu (allow) =
0.85 Vc
where:
Mu = Ultimate Moment
Vu = Flexural Shear Load @ critical section
18 of 25
0.85
kg
4,530,894.17
Project:
Subject:
Client:
Project No.
J-6101
Date:
TPC VINA
11-Jun-07
Revision:
0.85
Fp
6,963,233.75
Punching Perimeter
bo
Vp
2
0.60682 N/mm
2
1.51294 N/mm
vp =
1
3
f 'c
12000
N
mm
REBAR REQUIREMENTS
Ultimate Moment Mu
Mu
R = Mu / bd^2
0.00194
(min)
0.00200
(beam) >
0.85 f ' c
1
fy
2R
1 0.85 f ' c
3,460,838,485.54 N-mm
0.90
2
0.727 N/mm
(min)
As(req)
9,511.88
mm2
25
mm
19.38
nos.
As(req)
9,511.88
25
mm
19.38
nos.
As(req)
nos.
say
20
nos.
say
26
nos.
say
26
nos.
mm2
25
mm
25.87
nos.
As(req)
12,698.08
20
mm2
12,698.08
say
mm2
25
mm
25.87
nos.
Main Reinforcement
Secondary Reinforcement Reinforcement
19 of 25
20 of 25
21 of 25
A#3
22 of 25
10,000 M3 VCM
Pile No
1
5
9
13
17
21
25
29
33
2
6
10
14
18
22
26
30
34
Location design
E
N
16748
112114
18216
112426
19683
112738
17060
110647
18533
110997
19995
111271
17372
109180
18839
109492
20306
109803
22817
24284
25752
22505
23973
25440
22194
23661
25128
location actual
E
N
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
0
18 mm.<
18
112738
112426
112114
111271
110959
110647
109803
109492
109180
29
-16
33
-27
-11
17
-6
-19
-19
-49
-13
-5
-3
46
21
-16
11
40
18190
19638
17077
18533
19998
17404
18820
20348
22846
24268
25785
22478
23962
25457
22188
23642
25109
112439
112786
110668
110997
111274
109206
109522
109824
112689
112413
112109
111268
111005
110668
109787
109503
109220
28456
29799
31063
27752
28962
30211
26846
111842
109975
109073
109634
108746
107851
108417
-3
-30
21
18
15
50
-6
15
17
-3
8
2
-11
5
31
28065
107531
28101
107587
36
56
35
29279
106649
29284
106621
-28
50
33140
33890
34640
31841
32591
33341
30542
106747
105448
104148
105997
104698
103398
105247
33159
33885
34642
31865
32633
33384
30542
106755
105486
104157
105967
104694
103395
105268
19
-5
2
24
42
43
0
8
38
9
-30
-4
-3
21
32
31292
103948
31256
104016
-36
68
36
32042
102648
32056
102609
14
-39
122
35608
35765
35922
34116
34273
101167
99676
98184
101011
99519
35625
35749
35873
34147
34312
101175
99719
98164
100988
99540
17
-16
-49
31
39
8
43
-20
-23
21
57
34430
98027
34445
97966
15
-61
61
65
69
32625
32781
32938
100854
99362
97870
32649
32806
32956
100832
99361
97882
24
25
18
-22
-1
12
38
42
46
50
54
58
62
66
70
35594
35131
34667
34168
33704
33241
32741
32278
31814
95066
93640
92213
95530
94103
92677
95994
94567
93140
35592
35101
34638
34203
33733
33251
32720
32297
31841
95062
93644
92240
95512
94117
92670
96004
94563
93133
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
23 of 25
-2
-30
-29
35
29
10
-21
19
27
4
4.47 mm.<
F-3
37
41
45
49
53
12
13 mm.<
F-2
4
8
12
16
20
24
28
11
13.6 mm.<
F-1
50
111827
109958
109076
109626
108744
107862
108412
12
13.89 mm.<
F-1
28459
29829
31042
27734
28947
30161
26852
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
-2
4.47 mm.<
Fdn.type
50
136
7
11
15
19
23
27
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
TPC VINA
0
13
48
21
0
3
26
30
21
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
N
0
-26
-45
17
0
3
32
-19
42
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
Diffirence
E
F-3
-5
122
-4
4
27
-18
14
-7
10
-4
-7
F-1
2
50
10,000 M3 VCM
Pile No
39
43
47
51
55
59
63
67
71
Location design
E
N
33100
89499
32096
88384
31093
87269
31985
90502
30981
89388
29978
88273
30870
91506
29867
90391
28863
89277
location actual
E
N
33104
89460
32088
88345
31125
87285
32004
90513
30971
89402
29981
88249
30868
91494
29883
90380
28837
89268
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
85383
84816
84251
86795
25
7
35
-19
-44
-1
44
-2
56
26576
86187
26513
86119
-63
-68
60
64
68
72
25206
27336
25966
24596
85577
88168
87557
86947
25226
27350
25984
24613
85537
88168
87546
86976
20
14
18
17
-40
0
-11
29
86555
86555
21214
22779
86516
86591
-36
29
-39
36
116
19750
85055
19766
84980
16
-75
118
21250
85055
21268
85050
18
-5
120
122'
22750
19043
85055
82848
22779
19115
84950
82838
29
72
-105
-10
124
126
21250
22750
83555
83555
21278
22775
83520
83525
28
25
-35
-30
50
15164
16534
17904
14553
15924
88168
87557
86947
86797
86187
15174
16542
17937
14589
15938
88193
87528
86960
86830
86177
10
8
33
36
14
25
-29
13
33
-10
132
17294
85577
17345
85539
51
-38
133
13943
85427
13979
85392
36
-35
134
15314
84817
15250
84741
-64
-76
135
16684
84207
16684
84188
-19
122
11630
12633
91506
90391
11585
12636
91521
90442
-45
3
15
51
113
115
13637
10515
89277
90502
13698
10497
89311
90611
61
-18
34
109
117
119
121
123
11519
12522
9400
10404
89388
88273
89499
88384
11563
12554
9399
10424
89421
88296
89522
88427
44
32
-1
20
33
23
23
43
125
11407
87269
11442
87347
35
78
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
15
47.43 mm.<
80
6014
7369
95520
93640
6086
7246
95585
93731
72
-123
65
91
84
88
7833
8332
92213
95530
7840
8329
92226
95495
7
-3
13
-35
92
8796
94103
8741
94130
-55
27
96
100
104
108
9259
9759
10222
10686
92677
95994
94567
93140
9219
9808
10254
10712
92672
95966
94547
93170
-40
49
32
26
-5
-28
-20
30
24 of 25
-4
15.52 mm.<
F-3
-15
109
111
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
F-7
-29
127
128
129
130
131
76'
12
122
21250
22750
14
20.52 mm.<
F-3
-10
112
114
20
35.23 mm.<
F-1
50
28582
27193
25851
27928
6
11.66 mm.<
Fdn.type
-10
85427
84817
84207
86797
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
11
3
10.44 mm.<
TPC VINA
-39
-39
16
11
14
-24
-12
-11
-9
28557
27186
25816
27947
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
10
N
4
-8
32
19
-10
3
-2
16
-26
40
44
48
52
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
Diffirence
E
F-3
45
122
F-3
15
122
10,000 M3 VCM
Location design
E
N
Pile No
75'
13
14
location actual
E
N
TPC VINA
6364
101921
6313
101933
-51
12
79
83
87
6735
6578
8384
99676
98184
101011
6732
6571
8375
99688
98206
101031
-3
-7
-9
12
22
20
91
8227
99519
8172
99503
-55
-16
95
8070
98027
8020
97990
-50
-37
99'
103'
10870
10713
100749
99257
10749
10614
100758
99280
-121
-99
9
23
107'
10556
97766
10520
97723
-36
-43
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
-48
48 mm.<
106747
105448
104148
105997
104698
103398
9349
8610
7873
10647
9916
9115
106782
105440
104185
105976
104736
103425
-11
0
13
-12
7
-44
35
-8
37
-21
38
27
98
11958
105247
11925
105305
-33
58
102
106
11208
10458
103948
102648
11199
10440
103968
102710
-9
-18
20
62
73
77
81
85
89
93
97
101
105
13885
12671
11458
14766
13553
12339
15648
14435
13221
110839
109958
109076
109626
108744
107862
108412
107531
106649
13913
12715
11433
14745
13578
12289
15698
14454
13270
110890
109960
109102
109623
108789
107890
108455
107547
106724
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
25 of 25
28
44
-25
-21
25
-50
50
19
49
13
33.62 mm.<
F-4
50
9360
8610
7860
10659
9909
9159
-12
30.46 mm.<
Fdn.type
74
78
82
86
90
94
sum/9
Group max. deviation(X^2+Y^2)^0.5
15
Diffirence
E
F-3
28
122
51
2
26
-3
45
28
43
16
75
F-3
31
122