Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
WASHINGTON H SOUL PATTINSON & COMPANY (SOL) BRICKWORKS (BKW) CGT is $200m. Not $700m.
Results
On 21 March, Brickworks (BKW) and Soul Patts (SOL) released their interim results for FY13. They are summarised in appendix 1. We have updated our numbers for the new disclosure, and a summary of the assets of the combined group is set out in appendix 2, which reveals the importance of New Hope to the group (43% of group assets), and shows how trivial the brick business has become over the decades (4%).
Recommendations
Stock details Price Shares on issue (m) Market capitalisation (m) 52 week range HGIB valuation Current price Upside / (downside) Stock details Price Shares on issue (m) Market capitalisation (m) 52 week range HGIB valuation Current price Upside / (downside) Analyst details Charlie Green cgreen@hgib.com.au +61 74639 1800 Hunter Green Institutional Broking 143 Russell Street Toowoomba QLD 4350 12 month share price performance
$17
Soul Patts ASX300
BUY
SOL $14.00 239.4 $3,351.5 $12.30 - $14.35 $20.13 $14.00 43.8% BKW $12.88 147.6 $1,900.7 $9.70 - $12.94 $16.07 $12.88 24.8%
1H12a
88.7 37.1 17.0 45.8 2.4
1H13a
71.4 29.8 18.0 60.3 2.6
%
-19.5 -19.6 5.9 31.7 -
FY13f
186.6 78.0 49.0 62.8 3.5
$13 $12 Mar $13 $12 $11 $10 $9 Mar Jun Sep Dec Mar
Brickworks ASX300
1H12a
49.5 33.5 13.5 40.2 2.1
1H13a
56.0 37.9 13.5 35.6 2.1
%
13.1 13.1 0.0 -11.6 -
FY13f
93.3 63.0 41.0 65.1 3.2
Jun
Sep
Dec
Mar
gered in the event that key assets such as New Hope were ever sold. (But consider if they were sold, it would most likely be at a premium price sufficient to cover any CGT; to suggest otherwise is to suggest that SOL would sell its controlling New Hope stake at prevailing market prices, which is just absurd). So the reference in the slides to a $700m CGT liability is misleading, and entirely unrelated to the efficacy of a nil premium merger. (The question and scale of unrealised CGT will in time be relevant to the pre and post tax valuations of a merged entity, but then so will a discussion of SOLs $429m, and BKW $151m, franking credit balances, as well as a host of other matters). As the company has therefore failed to damage our NPM thesis, our view remains as follows: pay $200m CGT (or thereabouts) to achieve a $1b plus uplift in asset backing per share. (In lay terms: take nearly half the shares off the table for a cost of $200m CGT and the asset backing per share just about doubles, less the $200m).
Features of a NPM
Our revised calculations for the workings of a NPM are contained in appendix 3. Crucially, following a NPM, the overall high asset quality, and their value, will no longer be clouded by the cross shares, and the post merger shares should trade at least in line with these asset values because of the open register, and transparency, of the merged company, allied with the high quality of the main underlying assets of the merged group (not to mention the $580m in franking credits). Further, the underlying businesses (such as the New Hope investment, the land banks, the brick business, the TPM investment, the share portfolio) have not been disturbed at all, except for a modest cash payment to the ATO. Also, the cash dividends which currently flow within the group should at least be maintained (e.g. there is no reason for the NHC dividends to change at all). But payments of dividends per share to the genuine, look through, non cross share shareholders, will actually increase substantially, owing to the same pot of earnings available for dividends, spread across just over half as many issued shares. And there is nothing in our NPM plans which call for existing control to be disturbed at all.
Page 2
1H12a
$14.4 $13.3 $41.7 -$3.5 $65.9 -$10.8 -$2.8 $52.3 -$2.9 $49.5 $4.6 $54.1
1H13a
$14.0 $37.3 $28.8 -$3.6 $76.5 -$10.5 $0.6 $66.6 -$10.7 $56.0 $0.1 $56.1
% change
-2.8% 180.5% -30.9% 2.9% 16.1% -2.8% -121.4% 27.3% 269.0% 13.1% -97.8% 3.7%
1H12a
1H13a
% change
$60.3 $15.0 $1.5 $2.9 $2.2 $1.2 $0.7 $1.1 $0.7 $13.0 -$13.5 $85.1
$41.1 $21.1 $9.6 $4.0 $2.9 $2.5 $1.4 $0.9 $0.9 $0.7 $0.4 -$16.1 $69.4
-31.8% 40.7% 540.0% 0.0% 13.6% 16.7% 28.6% -18.2% 0.0% -96.9% nm -18.4%
Page 3
BKW Development Land 2% BKW Trust net assets (50/50 JV with GMG) 6%
Source: HGIB using current market values for listed assets, the most recently reported values for some unlisted assets and HGIB estimates of value for the BKW Building and Products business.
Page 4
APPENDIX 3 - CALCULATIONS FOR BKW (Bidco) NIL PREMIUM MERGER WITH SOL (100% SCRIP)
Item # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Calculation Total SOL shares currently on issue Total SOL shares already owned by BKW Total SOL shares owned by non-BKW shareholders Total BKW shares currently on issue Total BKW shares already owned by SOL Total BKW shares owned by non-SOL shareholders BKW shares are currently valued by the market at SOL shares are currently valued by the market at Nil premium merger calculations (100% scrip) BKW would issue 1 BKW share for every Total BKW shares currently on issue Total new BKW shares issued to fund merger Total BKW shares on issue following merger Following the bid BKW cancels Total BKW shares on issue post merger Assets of merged group New Hope Corporation TPG Telecom Total SOL listed share portfolio Total other SOL listed associates Total SOL unlisted investments Other SOL net assets Total SOL (pre-bid) net assets BKW Building Products business BKW Operational Land BKW Development Land BKW Trust net assets (50/50 JV with GMG) Other BKW net assets Total BKW (pre-bid) net assets Total BKW (post-bid) net assets CGT payable on cancelled BKW shares (see item 13) Estimated cost base of BKW shares currently held by SOL Deemed disposal price Profit on each share disposed Total capital gains tax payable at 30% CGT rate BKW net assets following merger and CGT payment Post-merger BKW NAV per share Pre-merger a SOL share was valued by the market at Each SOL share will be converted to Post-merger an equivalent SOL share will have an NAV of 239.395 m 102.258 m (42.7%) 137.137 m (57.3%) 147.818 m 65.645 m (44.4%) 82.173 m (55.6%) $12.70 per share $13.91 per share
9 10 11 12 13 14
0.91 SOL shares it does not already own 147.818 m 150.203 m 298.021 m 65.645 m BKW shares previously owned by SOL 232.376 m
=7/8
=6/9 = 10 + 11
= 12 - 13
15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28
$1,908.431 $639.224 $511.091 $239.583 $283.508 $161.500 $3,743.338 $168.000 $348.000 $74.000 $252.400 -$535.253 $307.147
m (current market price) m (current market price) m (current estimated market value) m (BKI, RHL, API, CLV, KUL:APER) m (CopperChem, Exco, Souls Private Equity, KH Foods) m (net cash and net DTLs at 31 January 2013) m m (HGIB March 2013 estimate) m (BKW 31 January 2013 valuation) m (BKW 31 January 2013 valuation) m (BKW 31 January 2013 valuation) m (BKW 31 January 2013 Balance Sheet) m = 21 + 27
$4,050.485 m
29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37
$3.000 per share $12.700 (current market price) $9.700 $191.027 m $3,859.458 $16.61 30.8% higher than the current BKW share price $13.91 per share 1.10 BKW shares $18.19 30.8% higher than the current SOL share price
= 30 - 29 = 13 * 31 * 30% = 28 - 32 = 33 / 14
=8/7
38 39 40 41
The upside to both BKW and SOL shareholders is Which across pre-merger values is a Which across pre-merger values is a And a total value uplift of
30.8% $587.093 m value uplift for external SOL shareholders $321.186 m value uplift for external BKW shareholders $908.278 m
= 34 / 7 = 37 / 8 = (37 - 8) * 3 = (34 - 7) * 6 = 39 + 40
Page 5
Jan 31 2013 share price Market Cap (AUDm) Current Value As % of listed investments shares owned by SOL
Notes / comments
Listed Associates
Brickw orks TPG Telecom BKI Investments Ruralco Holdings Aust Pharmaceutical Industries Apex Healthcare Berhad Clover Corporation
Building products and land development Telecommunications and internet provider Investment company Rural supplies and services Pharmaceutical w holesaler Pharmaceutical manufacturer and distributor Refinement and processing of natural oil
$4,167.1
$4,165.0
Cloncurry copper producer Copper and gold explorer Investment company Manufacturer of flavours, essences and colours
Removes NHC cash from SOL Balance Sheet Removes NHC term deposits Nets out consolidated NHC DTA's and DTL's
SOTP
Shares on issue Valuation - NAV per share Current SOL share price Upside / (downside) to valuation
$4,519
239.4 $18.87 $14.00 35%
$4,610
239.4 $19.26 $14.00 38%
Listed Investment Company (LIC) Metals and mining Bank Bank Telecommunications Ow ns 12.4% of SOL and 12.0% BKW Financial planning Diversified operations Rural and automotive Laboratory testing Pooling solutions and logistics Manufacture of composite products Recycling Cropping Investment bank Explorer - uranium, potash, phosphate Truck fleet and rural supplier Share registry based in Perth Renew able energy Mineral explorer Base and precious metal producer Contract drilling Assumed to move in line w ith ASX200
Page 6
Investment
Jan 31 2013 share price Market Cap (AUDm) shares owned by BKW
% held
Notes
Listed securities
Washington H Soul Pattinson
SOL
$13.70
42.9%
$1,432
$1,432
Valuation (AUDm)
$224 -$56
(1)
$168
$74
$505
50%
$252
(1)
-$535
$1,739
-9%
$837 -$333
50% 50%
$419 -$166
(1) (1)
Page 7
This report was produced by Hunter Green Institutional Broking Pty Ltd (HGIB), holder of an Australian Financial Services License Number 235259. DISCLAIMER: The information and opinions contained in this report have been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but no representation or warranty, express, or implied, is made that such information is accurate or complete and it should not be relied upon as such. Information and opinions contained in the report are published for the assistance of recipients, but are not to be relied upon as authoritative or taken in substitution for the exercise of judgement by any recipient, and are subject to change without notice. This report is not, and should not be construed as, an offer document or an offer or solicitation to buy or sell any investments. Except to the extent that liability cannot be excluded, HGIB does not accept any liability for any direct or consequential loss arising from any use of material contained in this report. DISCLOSURE: HGIB and/or persons connected with it may effect or have effected a transaction for their own account in the investments referred to in the material contained in this report or any related investment before the material is published to any HGIB clients. On the date of this report, HGIB, persons connected with it and their respective directors and/or representatives and/or employees may have a long or short position in any of the investments mentioned in this report and may purchase and/or sell the investments at any time in the open market or otherwise, in each case either as principal or as agent. Additionally, HGIB within the previous twelve months may have acted as an investment/commercial banker or may have provided significant advice or investment services to the companies or in relation to the investments mentioned in this report. Specifically, the author of this report owns BKW shares.
WARNING: This report is intended to provide general securities advice, and does not purport to make any recommendation that any securities transaction is appropriate for any recipients particular investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs. Prior to making any investment decision, recipients should assess, or seek advice from their advisers, on whether any relevant part of this report is appropriate to their individual circumstances. If a recipient was referred to HGIB by an investment adviser, that adviser may receive a benefit in respect of transactions effected on the recipients behalf, details of which will be available on request in regard to a transaction that involves a personalised securities recommendation. This report may not be reproduced, distributed or published for any purpose, unless authorised by HGIB.
PRIVACY: At HGIB, we take your privacy seriously. If you believe this publication in any way intrudes on your privacy, please contact us and we will ensure you do not receive any similar correspondence in the future.
Page 8