Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
STORAGE
DECK
BEDROOM 1
BATH
BREEZEWAY
GARAGE
LIVING
DINING
KITCHEN
ENTRY
PORCH
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
BEDROOM 2
BATH
HALL
DN
BEDROOM 3
STUDY
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
South Elevation
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
North Elevation
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
East Elevation
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
West Elevation
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Building Section
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
An Environmental Approach
A Demonstration Eco-Home: Why Now?
Energy: Fossil fuels are a non-renewable source of energy reserves are shrinking rapidly, yet demand is still rising. Most energy used has associated greenhouse gas emissions, contributing to global warming. Global Warming: Climate change is accelerating, greenhouse gas (ghg) emissions are still rising, and the U.S. produces the most greenhouse gas emissions. Market-Driven: Consumer awareness is rising and more potential homebuyers want energy-efcient and green features in a new home. We have the knowledge and availability right now to build to standards that would reduce energy consumption by at least 50%, without drastically changing building materials or methods.
How the Ecological Concepts Translate Into Building Design and Construction
Passive solar design Smaller than average house with a simpler footprint Increased insulation levels and thermal performance of the building envelope Active renewable energy systems: solar photovoltaic (PV) to generate electricity, solar thermal collection for domestic hot water and heating, and a wood stove for additional heating Installation of energy-efcient appliances and lighting Ventilation systems and materials specied to promote a healthy indoor environment for occupants Quantied consumption targets for low-energy building operation
Buildings use fossil fuels: oil, coal, natural gas Building construction and operation account for close to 50% of all U.S. energy use (www.architecture2030. org)
Energy Star has become a well-known entity. Current Energy Star Homes have the target of 15% more efcient than the 2004 International Residential Code (IRC) (www.energystar.gov) The Eco-Home is 65% more efcient than the 2004 IRC It is designed to use about a third of the energy of a conventional new home Energy modeling with REMDesign guided and veried the efciency targets Eco-Home operation: over 15,000 lbs of CO2 emissions can be avoided annually
Ecological Concepts Used to Dene the Overall Approach for the Eco-Home
Resource conservation Human health and comfort Reduced consumption of commercial electricity and natural gas Reduction of greenhouse gases and other emissions Increased use of the sun as a source of renewable, non-polluting energy
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
MN Code Built
R-10 R-10 R-19 R-10 R-38 U-Value = 0.35 None required None required None required None required None required Estimated at 73.1 million Btus 8,772 lbs CO2
MN Energy Star
R-10 R-10 R-24 R-20 R-50 U-Value = 0.33 SHGC minimum 0.3 0.2 cfm/sf @ 50 Pa 76% None required 4000 square feet 51.2 million Btus 30% less than code 6,140 lbs CO2
Eco-Home Duluth
R-20 R-20 R-36 R-31 R-60 U-Value = 0.19 - 0.21 SHGC 0.4 0.6 0.09 cfm/sf @ 50 Pa 90% 9.5 Btu/sf 1800 square feet 25.4 million Btus 65% less than code 3,048 lbs CO2
This table compares the Eco-Home with two recognized guidelines for construction: the MN Energy Code and the MN Energy Star Homes program. LEED for Homes criteria were studied relative to the Eco-Home, but an analysis of features relative to LEED did not easily translate to the features selected in this comparison. However, an independent look at the LEED for Homes Criteria suggests that the Eco-Home would rank as a LEED Gold or LEED Platinum certication. It is rare that any set of building performance guidelines, green or otherwise, seeks to qualify and quantify either building energy consumption or associated greenhouse
gas emissions. One exception to this is the European Passivhaus standard. When dening a building as green, it is important to understand a few things relating to energy consumption, even if the selected green criteria do not require this: 1. What is the fuel source for heating and cooling? 2. What is the estimated fuel consumption for heating and cooling? 3. What is the estimated electrical energy consumption exclusive of heating and cooling? 4. What are the estimated CO2 emissions associated with the above information?
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
1290 square feet rst oor, 750 square feet second oor (2040 ft2 total) 2-car garage with storage room, attached via breezeway Site orientation along true north-south for solar gain One bedroom and full bath on rst oor Two bedrooms, one study, and full bath on second oor
Blown cellulose attic insulation (R-60) Continuous soft and ridge venting Interior gypsum board ceiling w/continuous, sealed polyethylene vapor barrier
2 kW grid-tied solar photovoltaic array, roof mounted 16 tube solar thermal array, integrated with domestic hot water and heating Sub-soil heat exchange ground loop to pre-temper ventilation air Heat recovery mechanical ventilation with winter heated air distribution Efcient wood stove
Foundation Monolithic concrete slab with hydronic tubing and frost protected details 4 XPS (R-20) under the slab and vertically around perimeter 3 XPS (R-15) horizontal wing insulation
Environmentally Preferable Finishes and Materials Porcelain oor tile (long lasting, low toxicity, low impact material extraction) Floating cork oor (natural material harvested without killing the tree) Formaldehyde free MDF cabinet interiors (recycled wood ber, non-toxic) Shetka Stone countertops (recycled, regionally produced product) FSC-certied wood oor (sustainably harvested renewable resource) Low or no-VOC interior paints (low toxicity, no off-gassing) Cellulose insulation (high post-consumer recycled content) Metal roof (recycled content, recyclable) Fiber cement siding (exceptional durability) Reclaimed lumber at porch and interior columns
Exterior Framed Walls 9 1/2 deep double stud walls (2x4 framing) Dense pack cellulose insulation (R-35) Structural berboard exterior sheathing (R-1) Cement ber lap siding over continuous air barrier Interior gypsum board over continuous, sealed polyethylene vapor barrier Insulated rim board (R-13) w/3 closed cell foam insulation (R-18) total R-31 Triple pane windows with insulated berglass frames (avg overall U-value 0.2)
Roof
Standing seam metal roof and ashings, prenished 30# roof felt and ice and water shield over OSB sheathing Engineered trusses with 16 heel height
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Why build an Eco Demonstration home? There were two main goals: rst, to build a market rate home in an existing development that t into the neighborhood but also featured passive solar design, exemplary energy efciency, renewable energy systems, and sustainable (or green) principles and materials. The second goal was to demonstrate to the public that green isnt weird and that environmental building methods are by denition good building practice, especially in todays world where cheap fuel is diminishing and global warming is a concern we can no longer afford to ignore. What makes this house an Eco-Home? An integrated ecological design approach helped accomplish the stated goals. The solutions were for the most part complementary. Briey, heres what was done: 1. The design has a familiar cottage style and a relatively compact building footprint with exible spaces. The main oor space plan and window layout give the interior an open, airy feel, with extensive views to the outside and also between living spaces. A bedroom and bath on the main level increase overall accessibility and allow the upstairs to remain unheated if only one or two people live in the house. 2. The building is oriented to maximize passive solar gain and also south roof exposure for the roof-mounted solar
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
What problems needed to be solved What level of performance would be required to address those needs What other concerns came into play What products, systems and techniques were available to satisfy the items above and how much of them were needed.
Ceilings / roof Rim / band joists Above grade walls Foundation walls Doors Windows / skylights Slab oors Inltration Mechanical ventilation Internal gains (negative number) Total peak load / annual consumption
The environmental impact and ongoing costs related to buildings in our climate are dominated by energy consumption. This includes the energy and other resources embodied in the materials and site work needed to construct the building, as well as the operating energy consumed during its useful life. While we kept an eye on the embodied energy piece we carefully modeled and quantied the operating energy loads using a computer based energy modeling program. All surface areas of the exterior building envelope, the layer that separates conditioned space from the outdoors, were calculated and entered into the program along with the corresponding R-values and U-values of the assemblies of materials used. This modeling process produces a number of results. Most used in this case were the reports that calculated peak heating load of the home as well as the predicted annual heating energy consumption. Each of these results was given as a total as well as broken down by major building envelope area. These areas and components included:
The results of the peak load modeling help us to predict the amount of heat needed in the home and in individual areas. By breaking the load down to various components we are able to enhance the design process by focusing our efforts to increase performance levels to those areas that represent the largest heat loss and most room for improvement. In most new homes air leakage, heat loss through exterior walls and window losses represent the largest loads and so the most room for improvement. Once the computer model is developed it is fairly easy to try changing various insulation and other performance levels to see what impact that has on the results. This is a very powerful tool to help us make decisions about various choices in walls systems, insulation, windows and other components. The annual consumption results help us to quantify operating costs, environmental emissions from heating energy consumption and payback on various measures. As we change systems in the model we can immediately see the impact on annual energy consumption, environmental impact, operating costs and payback of various approaches.
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
At $1.30/Therm= $950/year
We will be carefully monitoring the actual performance of the nished home to compare those real world results with our modeled performance predictions.
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
DC Current
DC Disconnect
Inverter
AC Current
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Pump
Note: Some components not shown to reduce clutter and simplify this diagram.
Control
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Zone 1 - In-oor hydronic radiant heat runs throughout the rst oor slab, and also in the second oor bathroom. Zone 2 - Warm air is heated with a water-to-air heat exchanger and circulated to the second oor bedrooms and study through the heat recovery ventilation system.
Local Renewable Stored Energy A small wood stove in the living room provides additional space heating for the open areas of the rst oor. The addition of space heat on the rst oor provides a quick heat option when occupants want a faster response time than radiant oor heat typically provides. The wood stove alone is capable of heating the entire house.
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Ground Loop
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Wiring has been installed to the attic location for a fan if radon levels rise in the home in the future.
Radon Gas
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007
(66
During winter months the sun is allowed to shine into living areas, resulting in maximum heat gain.
Eco-Home
at Hawk Ridge
A solar model demonstrating energy efficiency, renewable energy and green building
Orient the building and interior space plan for daylight and direct solar gain with major glazed areas within 30 degrees of south Design a compact building form without too many corners Use the solar altitudes (based on latitude) at the summer and winter solstices to size windows and overhangs that allow direct heat gain in winter and block direct solar gain in summer (www.mnpower.com/energyhome/docs/solar.pdf) Determine the optimal sizing, layout, and type of windows and shading devices to allow solar gain but also offer protection from overheating Select glazing that allows solar heat gain (with a high solar heat gain coefcient) but also maintains thermal performance (with a low U-value)
Detailed energy analysis helped guide the choices that maximize winter solar gain without compromising the overall thermal performance of the building The three largest contributors to heat loss in the building envelope are the exterior walls, the envelope air tightness, and the windows, so extra attention was paid to the design and selections in these areas 9 1/2 thick double stud exterior walls reduce thermal bridging, with dense pack cellulose insulation (R-36) Roof trusses have a 16 heel; attic insulation level of R-60 (16 blown cellulose) Frost protected slab on grade foundation with 4 XPS (R-20) underslab insulation Rim insulation R-31, using Emercore insulated rim board (R-13) and 3 of 2-part urethane foam insulation (R-18) sprayed to the interior of the rim Careful air sealing at all seams and building penetrations and continuously sealed interior vapor barrier and air barrier maintain envelope air tightness.
The building form and orientation on the site allow about 6 hours per day of unobstructed solar gain in winter months Open living, dining, and kitchen spaces face south, so that maximum solar gain and comfort occurs in the most frequently occupied areas Insulated slab-on-grade design allows the rst oor slab to store solar gain in daytime and release it back into the house at night The majority of windows (58%) face south and all south-facing windows have roof overhangs sized to allow winter sun in and keep summer sun out The ratio of south glazing to oor area is 12%, which helps avoid overheating
A Window Strategy That Lets the Winter Sun In and Retains the Heat Gained
All windows have insulated berglass frames, triple pane glazing with argon ll, and warm edge spacers (Cardinal XL Edge) www.duxtonwindows.com Choices in solar-selective low-e coatings allowed specication of south glazing with a higher SHGC that still retained good overall thermal performance South windows have a glazing solar heat gain coefcient (SHGC) of 0.63 and a typical overall U-value of 0.21 (one low-e coating - Cardinal 178) North, west, and east windows have a glazing SHGC of 0.41and a typical overall U-value of 0.19 (two low-e coatings - Cardinal 272)
Materials created by Wagner Zaun Architecture and Conservation Technologies under a grant from the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency 2007