Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Archaeological Evaluation
7 May 2003
Data Structure Report – Buckreddan Nursing Home
Overview
This Data Structure Report (DSR) presents the findings of an archaeological evaluation
undertaken in connection with the development of 3.36ha of agricultural ground to the south
of Buckreddan Nursing Home, Kilwinning, North Ayrshire (NGR ref: NS 3103 4293).
There were no known archaeological sites within the development area prior to these works.
However there was a former mining site to the immediate east and the area was assessed
by the West of Scotland Archaeology Service to have the potential for prehistoric and
medieval activity.
North Ayrshire Council attached a condition to the planning consent (N/02/00664/PP)
requiring a staged programme of archaeological work commencing with this evaluation. The
main objective of the evaluation was to determine the location, extent, nature, condition and
significance of any archaeological features that lie within the development area.
Rathmell Archaeology Ltd was appointed to act on behalf of the applicant, Mr A Fitzsimmons,
with regard to the archaeological condition on the planning consent. The terms of the
evaluation were agreed in advance with the West of Scotland Archaeology Service,
archaeological advisor to planning authority, through a Written Scheme of Investigation.
The evaluation failed to identify any significant archaeological features within the
development area. One truncated portion of a straight rig and grooving field system was
located in the southern portion of the site. The whole site was covered by an intensive
system of tile drains, reflecting the impeded drainage on site suggesting that perhaps this
ground was inimical to pre-modern agriculture or settlement. All features recorded are
thought to be post Improvement that is from the nineteenth and twentieth century.
Project Works
The programme of works agreed with the West of Scotland Archaeology Service included an
archaeological desk-based assessment and the intrusive evaluation through machine cut
trenches extending to 5% of the development area. These works were undertaken in keeping
with the submitted Written Scheme of Investigation (WSI) with on-site works running from
25th April 2003 to 29th April 2003.
The exception to this was the evaluation that exceeded specified the 5% sample of the
development area. The WSI specified a need for some 1680m 2, basal dimensions, and the
actual area investigated was 1775m 2.
Mr Paul Robins, West of Scotland Archaeology Service, consented to the applicant
progressing site works in the western third of the development area on the 28th April 2003
after receiving a detailed site update. This enabled the visual inspection of subsoil exposed
by the topsoiling of the access roads along the northern and western boundary (roughly
1200m 2). This is area was inspected in addition to the evaluation area investigated.
All works were conducted in accordance with the Institute of Field Archaeology’s Standards
and Policy Statements and Code of Conduct and Historic Scotland Policy Statements.
catalogued archaeological site is Corsehill Cross (NMRS ref: NS34SW24; SMR ref: 6661;
NGR ref: NS 31 43), the poorly located putative site of a pre-reformation cross that stood
roughly half a mile east of Bridgend. This could place the site of the cross to the north of the
development.
The West of Scotland Archaeological Service identified an additional site to the immediate
east of the development area. This is the extensive industrial complex of Eglinton Colliery
(Ordnance Survey 1858-1860) that incorporated Fireclay Works, Coal Pits, Forges, Kilns and
Railways (Figure 1). This is inferred to be an extension to, or associated with, the Eglinton
Iron Company to the immediate south-west. The Eglinton Iron Company was founded in
1845 by Bairds of Gartsherrie in association with the Earl of Eglinton, taking advantage of the
rich mineral resources and the newly opened (1831) Ardrossan & Johnstone Railway. The
Eglinton Iron Company, after an uncertain start in the 1840s and 1850s, thrived and grew to
a substantial operation until it closed in 1924. This industrial complex was not recorded on
cartographic sources consulted as impinging on the development area.
The Ayrshire Research & Detecting Group has frequently visited the development site over
the past decades under their access agreement with North Ayrshire Council, the former
owners (Mr Watson Morrison pers comm). They regard the field as a rich site producing
quantities of coinage predominantly from the reigns of Victoria, George V and George VI
(1837 to 1947 AD). The earliest coinage recovered was from the reign of George III (1815 to
1820 AD). Assorted other metalwork of comparable date has also been recovered.
Prior to the evaluation the field was being used for grazing cattle, with extensive evidence of
severe poaching especially around the stances for supplementary feeders. The field has
been ploughed every year in recent times and more commonly has been used for arable
crops, such as wheat, with stock only coming on between crops. The field is bounded by post
& wire fences on all sides, frequently with hedgerows, and there are two gates (one in the
north-west and south-east corners). Buckreddan Nursing Home stands to the north, the A737
to the west and a public footpath to the south. To the east is the derelict colliery site, visible
as a south to north climbing embankment or spoil tip that is covered by woodland.
The highest point of the field is in the north-west corner, adjacent to the A737 above the drop
to the River Garnock. The ground generally drops from the western boundary to the eastern,
although there is a slight rise, or levelling out, in the ground to the south-east. The ground
rises steeply to the east, off site.
Figure 4a: West end of Trench 1 looking east, note Figure 4b: West end of Trench 7 looking east
investigation of deep tile drains (Film 1 Neg 15) (Film 1 Neg 17)
Discussion
All the artefacts recorded from the development site during these works have been of
nineteenth and twentieth century date. This corresponds well with the previous findings of the
Ayrshire Research & Detecting Group, based on coin evidence. The fills of the Rig and
Groove field system appeared less artefact rich than the ploughsoil, although the artefacts
noted were of a comparable date.
The Rig and Groove field system is of a character commonly associated with post-
improvement agriculture, and it is notable that the remnants of this field system are
constrained to the south of the internal field boundary shown on the 1st edition Ordnance
Survey (1858-60). Taken with the absence of enclosure on Roy’s Military Survey this
suggests enclosure of the ground in the early nineteenth century with the southern
rectangular field ploughed and managed through a Rig and Groove field system.
At a later date a manuring must have been adopted, probably circa 1840 in conjunction with
the industrialisation of the Eglington Estate. At this stage the field system is inferred to have
been in decline, through the lower levels of artefacts incorporated into its fills.
The earliest tile drain identified is probably that at the north end of Trench 6 which has an
irregular, haphazard character. This would be in keeping with the tile drain having been put in
by hand. The explosion in the sinking of tile drains by hand is recorded in Ayrshire in early
1840s for ‘soils not fertile or productive’ (Campbell 1845, p812). Furthermore the Rev
Campbell’s account notes that
‘… a great part of the parish, from being an extremely tenacious, wet
and unproductive clay … vast improvement by draining, liming and
manuring … indeed, the whole district, at the present rate, will be tile
drained in ten years…’ (1845, p828)
This early tile drain is in the northern triangular field, suggesting this was enclosed separately
as it was still too wet to be brought into productive use. Indeed this is the same area where
the substantial soak-aways were cut. The soak-aways appear machine cut in character, the
material within presumably being derived from the potentially derelict neighbouring Eglington
Colliery site. The made ground in the south-east of the site, Trench 6, also appears to have
derived from the neighbouring Eglington Colliery site, presumably again after its dereliction
and demolition. This would suggest both these sets of features derive from the mid to late
twentieth century attempts to improve the drainage of the lowest, eastern part of the field.
The other two tile drain systems both are very regular and extensive, covering the entire
modern field. This suggests that they were buried by machine, and hence are of relatively
modern date. Clearly there have been prolonged problems with the dampness of the ground
that has led to sustained and substantial investments in improved ground drainage systems.
Conclusion
The evaluation failed to identify any significant archaeological features within the
development area. One truncated portion of a straight rig and grooving field system was
located in the southern portion of the site. The whole site was covered by an intensive
system of tile drains, reflecting the impeded drainage on site suggesting that perhaps this
ground was inimical to pre-modern agriculture or settlement. All features recorded are
thought to be post Improvement that is from the nineteenth and twentieth century
It is a matter for the West of Scotland Archaeology Service, in conjunction with North
Ayrshire Council, to determine what works are required to satisfy the terms of the condition
within the granted planning consent.
Rathmell Archaeology Ltd, on behalf of the applicant, would propose that the case for the
absence of significant archaeological remains within the development area has been made
by this evaluation. Consequently we would suggest that the only appropriate further stage of
work would be the archiving of site records and disposal of materials from this project.
References
Campbell, AB 1845 Parish of Kilwinning in ‘New Statistical Account of
Scotland’
Ordnance Survey 1858-1860 Ayrshire
Pollock, T 1799 Parish of Kilwinning in ‘The Statistical Account of
Scotland’
Roy 1747-55 Military Survey of Scotland, Sheet 04/7d
When lifted the subsoil surface underneath the made ground, and
truncated topsoil, was a smooth continuation of the character in
the trench elsewhere. A number of tile drains were noted
underneath the made ground, and truncated topsoil, at the upper
surface of the subsoil.
Significant features: None
Artefacts: Nineteenth and twentieth century ceramics and glassware from
ploughsoil and made ground.
Trench 7
Drawing Record
No. Title Scale Date Author
1 Plan of Trench 1 1:100 28/4 TR
2 Plan of Trenches 2, 3 and 4 1:100 28/4 TR
3 Plan of Trench 7 1:100 28/4 TR
4 Detail of furrows investigated in Trench 5 & 6 in Plan 1:20 29/4 TR
both Plan and Section Sec 1:10
5 Plan of Trenches 5 and 6 1:100 29/4 TR
Photographic Record
Film No. Description From Date
1 1 Trench 5, post excavation SE 29/4
1 2 Detail of furrows at SE end of Trench 5, pre NW 29/4
investigation
Samples List
No. Type Context No.
Artefacts List
No. Description From
1 General surface collection: Mixture of white ceramic and Topsoil, West of site
glassware
2 General surface collection: Mixture of white ceramic and Topsoil, Centre of
glassware site
3 General surface collection: Mixture of white ceramic and Topsoil, East of site
glassware
Contact Details
Rathmell Archaeology can be contacted at its Registered Office or through the web:
Rathmell Archaeology Ltd
8, Underwood
Kilwinning
Ayrshire
KA13 7HR
www.rathmell-arch.co.uk