Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 2

TableofComparisonforductinsulation Features Proposal1 Internallylined FIBERTEXmineral woolboardwith Melinexfacing coveredwith perforatedsteel sheet 25mm 50mm 0.

.034 Proposal2 Internallylined APCoilflex coveredwith perforatedsteel sheet Proposal3 InternallylinedArmaSound RD120coveredwith perforatedsteelsheet Remarks

1.

2.

Thermal insulationat 20C(W/mK) Service temperature

25mm 0.036

50mm

25mm 0.046

50mm Comparable. Thoughslightlyin favoroffiberwool Generallynotan issueforcool insulation

Max850C

Max85C Min20C

Max85C Min20C

3.

Density (kg/m3) Noise reduction Coefficient (seeproduct catalog attached) NRCatlow frequency(500 Hz)(seegraph below)

80

4.

0.60

0.80

Min 50 Max100 0.60 0.70

Min100

0.55

0.70

NRCtoASTMC423

5.

Generallyless than0.6

Generally0.70.8

Generally0.70.8

6.

Moisture absorption

Doesnotabsorb moisture

Low(0.2%by volume)&non wicking Negligible

7.

Watervapor permeability

Negligible

Low(0.2%byvolume)&non wicking Negligible

Foamperformance peaksat500Hz, arguablythemost criticalfrequency inaductsystem. Fibrousinsulation performancepeaks athigher frequency,i.e. ~2000Hz. Noissue

Noissue

I:Mechnical/HVAC/RequisitionEquipment

3/9/2012

8.

Flame/smoke rating(ASTM E84)

9.

Health

10. Surface erosion resistance

11. Fungi& bacteria resistance 12. Installation

13. Costratio Material Installation Total

Resistant.Tested withnobreak away,flakeoff orpeelingat500 m/s Doesnotsupport Fungi&bacteria fungiandbacteria resistancetested growth toASTMG21& G22 Healthconcern Flexibleand duetodustand lightweight. fibergeneration. Easyinstallation Needtowear (pinningto breathing SMACNA respiratorwhile requirement) working. 9 1 1 2.5 3.5 10

ClassO Flame/smoke index5/0 Produceairborne dustduring installation. Handlingcan resultin temporaryitching anddiscomfort. Resistant.

ClassO Flame/smoke 25/50

ClassO Flame/smoke25/50

Infavoroffibre wool

Fiberfreeand nondusting

Fiberfreeandnondusting

Infavorfor elastomericfoam

Resistant.Testedwithno breakaway,flakeoffor peelingat500m/s

Noproblemfor either.Maxdesign airflowvelocityis lessthan20m/s Noissue

Fungi&bacteriaresistance testedtoASTMG21&G22

Flexibleandlightweight. Easyinstallation(pinningto SMACNArequirement)

Installationfor foamiseasier

9 1 10

InputfromKorea vendor

I:Mechnical/HVAC/RequisitionEquipment

3/9/2012