Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Rightnow,theconditionsarehardlyhumane,andtheprisonhashadmajor problemssinceatleastthemid1980s.Weareatacriticalmomentforcomingupwithanewsolution! Manyideashavebeenflyingaroundthepressforhowtofixtheproblem:buildanewfacility,refurbishand expandtheexistingfacility,orgrantparole(earlyrelease)tocurrentinmatestomakemorespace.Every optionhasaproponentandanopponent,andnonewillbeeasytoconvinceacrossthetable.Presentatthe meetingwillbe8differentperspectivesontheissue,eachwiththeirownagenda.Bytheendofthedayon April17,wewillhaveaproposalforhowtoresolvetheproblem,whichwewillreporttoGovernorCorbett. Youneedtofigureouttheinsandoutsofyourpositiononthisissue.Youmustcompletethisplanning worksheettoprepareyourpositionforthedebate.Everyoneplaysarole! Circle/highlightyourrole:
1.Exoneree5.ConstructionContractorhiredtobuildthenewfacility 2.DecarcerationActivist 6.Aresidentoftheneighborhoodoftheproposedprison
3.MayorofPhiladelphia,MichaelNutter7.GraterfordPrisonSuperintendent,MichaelWenerowicz 4.Currentlyincarceratedman/woman8.EducationCoordinatorattheprison
CharacterDevelopment: 1.Whoareyou?Whatisyourpersonalbackground?
2.Whatisyourracialidentity?
(Forthemayorandprisonsuperintendent,thisisbasedonarealcharacterforallothers,youcanchoose.)
DevelopingYourPosition: 1.Doyouthinkthatyourcharacterbelievesthatprisonsarefair&justORunfair&unjust?Why?
2.Ingeneral,whatdoesyourcharacterthinkisthetoppurposeofprisons?
a)deterrence:prisondiscouragespeopleinsocietyfromcommittingcrimes b)punishment:prisonisapenaltyforcriminaloffenses c)rehabilitation:prisonrestoresacriminaltoausefulandmainstreamlife d)publicsafety:prisonprotectssocietyfromdangerouspeople
ExplainWhy!:
3.Ingeneral,whatdoesyourcharacterthinkisthebestsolutionfortheovercrowdingatGraterford?
a)relocateallprisonerstodifferentfacilitiesthatalreadyexist b)buildanewfacilitynearGraterfordforoverflowprisoners c)buildanadditionontoGraterfordandmakerepairstothecurrentbuilding d)other:______________________________________________________
ExplainWhy!:
4.Doesyourcharacterhaveaspecialinterestintheoutcomeofthisdebate?Whyorwhynot?
5.Whoarethe3groupsofpeoplewhoseinterestsyouneedtobeaccountableto?Why?
Example:Ifyouaretheprisonsuperintendent,youareaccountableto1)themayor2)correctionsofficers3)the buildingcompanycontractedtodoconstructionontheprison.IneedtomakesurethatIkeepthemhappybecause...
6.Whodoyouthinkwillbeyouralliesduringthedebate?Circlethem!
1.Exoneree5.ConstructionContractorhiredtobuildthenewfacility 2.DecarcerationActivist 6.Aresidentoftheneighborhoodoftheproposedprison
3.MayorofPhiladelphia,MichaelNutter7.GraterfordPrisonSuperintendent,MichaelWenerowicz 4.Currentlyincarceratedman/woman8.EducationCoordinatorattheprison
7.Whodoyouthinkwillbeyouropponentsduringthedebate?Circlethem!
1.Exoneree5.ConstructionContractorhiredtobuildthenewfacility 2.DecarcerationActivist 6.Aresidentoftheneighborhoodoftheproposedprison
3.MayorofPhiladelphia,MichaelNutter7.GraterfordPrisonSuperintendent,MichaelWenerowicz
4.Currentlyincarceratedman/woman8.EducationCoordinatorattheprison
Onanadditionalpieceofpaper:List10keytermsthatwillhelpyouargueyourperspective,anddescribe whattheymean.
TermsshouldcomefromclassnotesANDarticlesinyourresearchpackets.