Modis Gujarat: Propaganda masks below-average growth

http://www.deccanherald.com/content/243330/modis-gujarat-propaganda...

Login | Register

Thursday 18 April 2013 News updated at 2:00 PM IST Home News Karnataka polls New Delhi Business Supplements

Search

Weather Max: 36.5C Min : 23.2C

In Bangalore

Partially cloudy

Sports

IPL 6

Entertainment

Videos

Opinion

Archives

Jobs

Bieber's semi-nude artwork makes fans curious No 'Bhajji factor' behind Sreesanth's omission: Dravid Bihar Muslims accuse Nitish Kumar of doublespeak Nepali woman gang-raped in Delhi, dumped on flyover 'Friends' reunion? No way, says TV comedy's co-creator DiCaprio blames career for messing personal life Musharraf flees as court orders his arrest SC cancels Karnataka's 49 mining leases Hrithik's 'Bang Bang' shoot to start May 1 Sensex up 74 points in early trade on smart TCS Q4 nos FBI arrests Mississippi man in ricin letter case Explosion at fertilizer plant rocks US town JD(S) rides piggyback on rebellion in Cong, BJP Nomination flurry in Mysore, mobs frustrate Ambareesh High Court declines to interfere with SC list NIA, forensic teams rush to Bangalore It was a pipe bomb, say experts Cong suspects RSS hand, BJP claims its leaders were target Police not linking blast to polls, says EC Cong rebels in fray in dozen seats They pedal a message on voting City-based firm offers mock CET mobile service Video points to Boston bomb suspect, no arrest yet KJP releases final list Woman slaps BJP rebel NCP fields 18 candidates Yogeeshwara joins SP, files papers CEO website crashes Palike braces for Assembly elections BBMP unearths Rs 523-crore scam Candidates file papers amid fanfare BWSSB makes a mess of water leakages in Sri Vidyanagar Blast puts brakes on campaigning HC notice to Siddaiah on mobile towers Gun-toting college girl robs Rs 2.7 lakh from Dominos Green commercial ventures may be allowed in Western Ghats Former Governor Ramadevi passes away Fake bomb found on bus Of Yuvrajs McEnroe moment and Kohlis questions Four killed in mishap CEO website crashes Congress rebels in fray in dozen seats Tesco quits US as profits fall for first time in 20 years CAD may ease to 3% of GDP, say analysts Tata Teleservices to surrender excess spectrum India capable of protecting foreign investment: FM CMC plans to hire 400 people in fiscal 2014 Dhoni takes off, CSK provided with poor practice pitch Royal win for spirited Rajasthan Rajasthan Royals set 180-run target for Mumbai Indians TCS net profit up 25% to Rs 3,616 crore in Q4 Two-wheelers costlier as HMSI, Bajaj, TVS hike prices Wednesday's explosion is fourth terror attack in Bangalore Indian sentenced to 10 years in jail in UK for raping TV star Bomb blast rocks Bangalore Sonia, Manmohan named among top 5 most influential Asians John lived Manya Surve's life to portray him on-screen NCP leader's minor son's car mows down 2-yr-old girl, detained Tripura girl with swollen head in Gurgaon hospital Shiv Sena warns of Mahabharat over PM issue London comes to a halt for Thatcher's funeral HCL Q3 net jumps 73%, overall headcount dips Mishra googlies floor Warriors After Lamborghini, Dubai cops to have Ferrari car CRPF to purchase high-end defence gear to take on Naxals Indian students' safety in Australia still a concern: Poll 40 killed, 300 injured in Pakistan quake, says official Hydrogen as energy source: Breakthrough in Kolkata lab "All in the family" brothers, father-son spice up poll scene Shinde orders probe into Bangalore blast Don't politicise Bangalore blast: R.P.N. Singh Congress distances itself from leader's tweet, BJP furious Toyota to explore possibility of more hybrid models in India Honda's cheapest bike 'Dream Neo' hits roads for Rs 43,150 On birthday, Vikram sweating it out in China Kim Kardashian to feature in Kanye West's album ? Filmmakers relieved as Dutt gets extension RIL says will give up 56 pc of KG-D6 block Arbaaz won't direct sex comedy Security stepped up in Delhi MHA sends NIA team to assist Bangalore police Indian IT professionals welcome US immigration bill Rampaul made the difference in the end: Kohli NCP leader's minor son held as his car mows down 2-yr-old girl Akshay Kumar is the real 'Khiladi', says Vidyut Jamwal Hyderabad Nizam's pink diamond sells for record $39 million Man arrested for carrying venomous snakes in flight Delhi seek solace, Chennai look to return to winning ways Chaotic scenes at blast site, vehicles in flames Rampaul made the difference in the end: Kohli Candidates make beeline to temples hoping for divine swing Music composer T K Ramamurthy passes away Climate talks slow, individual nations must take action: PM SC grants four weeks more to Sanjay Dutt to surrender Indian American marathoner escapes unhurt in Boston blast Have carved a niche for myself as an actor-singer: Ayushmann Changes in H1B visas to affect Indian IT firms Sensex snaps two-day uptrend, ends 14 pts lower as RIL slides Poison laced letter sent to US senator Roger Wicker Gujarat government to seek death penalty for former Narendra Modi minister The common wealth of crorepatis This auditor in poll fray worth Rs 300 crore HC sets aside CAT stay on DCs transfers Website crash puts EC in a spot of bother Bear mauls National Park guard Union govt moots congestion tax to ease traffic woes Masked men break into realtors home; decamp with valuables worth Rs 6 lakh Throat cancer patients now have a voice Denied tickets, Congmen turn rebels Man carrying 406 gold bangles held Jewels stolen from car of actors wife Muzaffarpur Express cancelled Children falling victims to air pollution in City, says study Arkavathy needs a quick course correction Legislator, corporator trade charges Diagnostic centre fined Polls derail commissioning of double-decker Unorganised workers plea for insurance cover Central Jail sans shrinks BU to decide on BEd colleges in a month Alternative documents for voters ID JD(S) ticket sold for Rs 5 crore, say partymen Kodandaramaiah plans to quit active politics Pursuing political dreams on a wheel-chair Alternative documents for voters identity Rebellion may hit Congress election prospects Having many CM aspirants isnt wrong: Siddu Transgender in fray from Narasimharaja constituency Sangamesh to contest as Independent Modi to campaign in Karnataka Japan joins jet age by making its own plane Karnataka poll: Congress faces rebellion over tickets Kings XI Punjab stun KKR by 4 runs to win their 2nd game Steyn and I would have formed a prolific attack: Donald Pregnant woman stomped on stomach;girl child dies,in-laws held Rajasthan face acid test against mighty Mumbai Indians Boston blasts' eye-witness recalls Mumbai attack Rajasthan face acid test against mighty Mumbai Indians Coloured stone perfect for Indian skin, says Sonam US immigration bill to increase H1B visa, may hit Indian firms Political marches choke City roads Northeasterners cold to enrolling in voters list 30 companies of central forces for poll duty in Blore Act tough against anti-socials, EC tells State Ambi imbroglio gets knottier Bellary tainted mine owners in poll fray again Reddys release more important than polls Skydiver survives 8,000-foot fall after parachutes fail You are here: Home Panorama Modis Gujarat: Propaganda masks below-average growth

Modis Gujarat: Propaganda masks below-average growth

By Neena Vyas, April 20, 2012

Videos

Think of the press as a great keyboard on which the government can play. Joseph Goebbels. Gujarat is poised to lead national reconstruction...promoting growth and development and excellence in all walks of life. www.narendramodi.in. The celebrations have begun. On April 10, it was officially disclosed in court that the Supreme Court-appointed Special Investigation Team has recommended closure of the Gulberg Society massacre case finding no actionable evidence to prosecute Gujarat chief minister Narendra Modi. Immediately, political pundits started predicting Modis ascent to the national political stage. The last hurdle in
DH Video: Bomb blast shocks Bangalore Obama slams US Senate minority for blocking gun reform

1 of 5

4/18/2013 2:21 PM

Modis Gujarat: Propaganda masks below-average growth

http://www.deccanherald.com/content/243330/modis-gujarat-propaganda...

Modis path had been crossed. He could now get on with the task of doing for India what he has already done for Gujarat: make it shine. Modi has been anxious to leave behind the 2002 pogrom and metamorphose into the development man. One could be forgiven for mistaking Modis new mask to be his real face, for had not Time magazines Asian edition cover story on Modi last month endorsed him as the new vikas purush. Indian media institutions have made it a habit to praise Modi for efficient governance, as have corporate honchos, who hail him as the most investor-friendly of all chief ministers. Modi was the winner of best chief minister title in a recent Mood of the Nation survey by India Today-Nielson. He was declared the favourite for the prime ministerial position in 2014. Click www.narendramodi.in to read the long list of awards and accolades he has won over a decade. If in 2005 Advani tried unsuccessfully to play the I love Jinnah, therefore I am secular role in the hope the country would forget his support to 1992 Talibanesque act of razing to the ground the Babri Masjid, Modi has been desperately trying to emerge as the development man, putting behind him the 2002 carnage, even as he repeatedly trips over the many skeletons of encounter killings that pop out of his state cupboard. The question is: has he made Gujarat shine? Is Gujarat shining more than Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Haryana or Karnataka? Has Gujarat under Modi achieved something that no other state has? The hard fact is Gujarat has not been able to bag top position for even one of several key socio-economic indicators: life expectancy, infant mortality, nutrition, literacy and investment although in 2001 when Modi took charge, Gujarat was already a well developed state, holding 4th state rank for per capita net state domestic product in mid-1996. Currently Haryana holds top rank, while Gujarat is at 6th position as it has mostly been since 1970s. Last year, the National Council of Applied Economic Research reached the disturbing conclusion that hunger and malnourishment levels in Gujarat were higher than in Uttar Pradesh. The 61st National Sample Survey established that 44.6 per cent children in Gujarat were malnourished and 66 per cent in 0 to 5 age group were anaemic. A larger percentage of children went to bed hungry in Gujarat than in Uttar Pradesh. Low life expectancy Life expectancy is a good indicator of nutrition and health services. In Gujarat it was two years shorter than the all-India average of 66.1 in 2006-10 (Registrar General of India). The average Gujarati dies two years earlier than the average Indian and ten years before a Keralite, where at 73.9 years, life expectancy is the highest. Several states, including Maharashtra, Punjab and Tamil Nadu, have bettered the national average. In Modis garvi Gujarat, infant mortality rate fell 10 points from 60 to 50 from 2001-08, when the national average IMR fell 13 points from 66 to 53. States that ought to be compared to Gujarat performed better: Maharashtra IMR down 12 points from 45 to 33; Tamil Nadu lower by 18 points to 31 and Karnataka down 13 points to 45. The sample registration system showed mothers in Gujarat fared no better than their newborns. Between 2004 and 2009 maternal mortality rate in Gujarat fell by 12 points from 160 to 148. Many states did out-shine Gujarat: in Kerala MMR was down 14 points from 95 to 81; Tamil Nadu lowered it by 14 points to 97 and Maharashtra 26 points from 130 to 104. The national average came down by 40 points from 254 to 212. These statistics are a telling beam of light that dissipate the fog of Modis propaganda. Take literacy. The latest census figures showed Gujarat dropping one state rank over the decade: from 17th in 2001 to 18th in 2011, a far cry from Modis 2001 vision of a 100 per cent literate Gujarat by 2010. Truth has been the principal casualty of the hyper-active Gujarat state publicity departments.Surely the prize for the most bombastic claims must go to the

NEJM Subscription Offer

NEJM.org Stay Informed on the Latest Medical Developments with NEJM. Act Now.
Pune court to sentence guilty Baig in German bakery case Violence against women has approval of society, says Shabana

Subscribe - Deccan Herald's YouTube channel

more videos

Most Popular Stories now

Most Commented Most Emailed

In reality, what Modi does is not what Modi boasts We will ask people's forgiveness for lapses: Shettar Kumaraswamy, wife, the richest couple in poll fray Playback singer P.B. Srinivas is dead Media demonising Muslim community: Markandey Katju Rash driving snuffs out three young lives Pulse of the Bangalore commuter

Photo Gallery

P Chidambaram speaks during a news conference in New York... more

ZIM vs BAN

RAJ vs MUM PUNE vs HYD

Harare Sports Club, Harare

Zimbabwe vs Bangladesh , 1st Test

ZIM 255/6 (100.1 Ovs)

Day 2: First Session

2 of 5

4/18/2013 2:21 PM

Modis Gujarat: Propaganda masks below-average growth

http://www.deccanherald.com/content/243330/modis-gujarat-propaganda...

website www.vibrantgujrat.com. This site would have us believe billions of dollars worth of foreign direct investment have flowed into Gujarat creating hundreds of thousands of jobs and wiping out hunger and poverty. In the first three Vibrant Gujarat summits: 2003, 2005 and 2007, a total of $186 billion was garnered as MoUs for FDI, the official website claimed. Of these, 84 per cent proposals had been implemented or were under implementation, it said. In the next two biannual events, MoUs worth $240 billion and $450 billion were signed taking the total to a staggering $ 876 billion! If 60 per cent MoUs had materialised -- not 84 per cent as claimed Gujarat would have matched Chinas FDI inflows of $600 billion plus! Such extravagant claims were punctured by the Reserve Bank of India: a total of $7.3 billion was all that flowed into Gujarat in this period, a mere 5 per cent of total Indias total FDI. As against this, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka cornered 6 per cent of the national pie, while neighbouring Maharashtra garnered a massive 35 per cent. The Modi PR machine is skilled at blowing its own trumpet to the orchestral accompaniment of a thrusting Gujarati diaspora. (The writer is a Delhi-based senior journalist)
Go to Top

Like

687

Tweet

52

3 of 5

4/18/2013 2:21 PM

Modis Gujarat: Propaganda masks below-average growth

http://www.deccanherald.com/content/243330/modis-gujarat-propaganda...

13 comments

15

Best

Community

Share

Nagesh Pai

a year ago

Numbers have been shown here in wrong context.. Maharashtra is naturally supposed to get 35% FDI since Mumbai is the financial capital! and most of it is controlled by Gujaratis and even ppl based in that state. With the congress trying to do lot of desperate image building, articles like these and many other paid news can be expected.
16

Reply

Share

Sridhar Pichumani

a year ago

Neena has a purpose. And that is to write against BJP and its ministers. We cant expect a "balanced" article. Imagine someone questioning Manmohan Singh's integrity for the only reason he is in Congress...!! Neena Vyas is doing just that for Modi and has to question the very basic tenet on which Modi platform is standing strong...Sad that these people dont care about India's development.
16

Reply

Share

Indian

> Sridhar Pichumani a year ago

What Neena said in the article is correct...Its natural that BJP supporters like you oppose it....just like the congress supporters when someone writes about the italian mom....Our experience shows that both the congress and the bjp are two sides of the same coin...one plays the minority card and the other the majority card....Corruption,poverty,crime,etc still continues unabated////
19

Reply

Share

Mitul Shah

a year ago

This is not true. Gujarat has moved on & it has picked up pace which other states wont b able to match. I have seen with my eyes how peaceful, secure & economically booming Gujarat is. Yes, ppl wil try to diminish, what Modi is trying to do as v all knw about Paid Media & the numbers r given by central govt, so u can expect them to play politics.
11

Reply

Share

Bhavika Sicka

a year ago

Sour grapes. Modi is truly one of the greatest leaders, visionaries and administrators this country has seen, and will ever see. Gujarat is flourishing; it's infrastructure is growing, it's industry thriving, it's rural programmes and agricultural projects developing. All you pseudo-secular liberals (read: those who align with Congress' ideologies) can keep ranting. As for me, Jai Narendra Modi.
7

Reply

Share

ritesh kumar

> Bhavika Sicka a year ago

yeah, we wont hear facts...rather we''ll change facts to suit our opinions....jai ch00tendra modi
5

Reply

Share

Arihant Zenab

> ritesh kumar 7 months ago

penetrated deep into society.and thats the reason u support congress... or

4 of 5

4/18/2013 2:21 PM

Modis Gujarat: Propaganda masks below-average growth

http://www.deccanherald.com/content/243330/modis-gujarat-propaganda...

About Us | News | Business | Sports | Supplements | Contact Us Copyright 2008, The Printers (Mysore) Private Ltd., 75, M.G Road, Post Box 5331, Bangalore - 560001 Tel: +91 (80) 25880000 Fax No. +91 (80) 25880523

5 of 5

4/18/2013 2:21 PM