r-i Thu, Apr 17, 2003 12:49 AM

From Bruce Berkowitz *=*

Biay Page 2 of 3

MEMORANDUM
Subject: Proposed Panels to Describe intelligence Community Efforts to Monitor
UBL Threat Prior to September 11

Panel 1: Resources:

Objective: Describe intelligence spending and programmatic decisions during 1991-

2001.
Joan Dempsey, (Deputy Director of Central Intelligence for Community
Management)
Larry Kirisvater, Executive Director for Intelligence Community Affairs
John Hamre, (Former Deputy Secretary of Defense)
Richard Haver (Special Assistant to the Secretary of Defense for Intelligence)
Cheryl Joan Roby, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense (Programs and
Evaluation),
Panel 2: Intelligence Strategy for the Terrorist Threat

Objective: Provide a top-level view of Intelligence Community tasking to assess the

UBL threat, and a top-level view of how intelligence organizations responded.
James Steinberg (Former Deputy National Security Advisor)
Stephen Hadley (Deputy National Security Advisor)
John McLaughlin (Former Deputy Director for Intelligence; Current Deputy
Director of Central Intelligence)
Barbara A. McNamara, (Former Deputy Director, NSA; Current Liaison to
GCHQ)
Panel 3: Counterterrorist Collection

Objective: Examine how the Intelligence Community collected HUMINT, SIGINT, and
other source intelligence. Describe HUMINT and SIGINT strategy, policies and
"tradecraft."
James Pavitt (Deputy Director for Operations)
BillCrumm (Director NSA Data Acquisition)
Charles Allen (Associate Director of Central Intelligence for Collection)
 ,-, Thu, Apr 17, 2003 12:49 AM
From Bruce Berkowitz (4=*
•* Page 3 of 3

Panel 4: Counterterrorist Analysis

Objective: Examine how the Intelligence Community became aware of the UBL threat,
and how it responded at each phase as the threat developed.

Cofer Black (Former Director, Counterterrorist Center)

Winston. Wiley (Former Deputy Director for Intelligence, Former Director,

Counterterrorist Center)

Chris Inglis (Director, NSA Analysis & Production)

Panel 5: Alert & Warning

Objective: Examine White House requests and requirements for intelligence providing
warning of potential terrorist attack, and examine how the intelligence responded.

Richard Clarke (Former Assistant National Security Adviser for

Counterterrorism

Wayne Downing (Former Deputy National Security Adviser For

Counterterrorism)

Robert D. Vickers (National Intelligence Officer for Warning)

Panel 6: Oversight

Objective: Review methods and strategy for implementing oversight.

Porter Goss (Chairman, House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence)

Richard Shelby (Former Chairman and Vice Chairman, Senate Select Committee
on Intelligence)

Bob Graham (Former Chairman and Vice Chairman, Senate Select Committee
on Intelligence)

Bob Kerry (Former Vice Chairman, Senate Select Committee on Intelligence)