March 30, 2009

Copy not on original to: Chief Minister, West Bengal,India,

With requests: 1. either make a state case file it to the Supreme Court under article 32 of the
Constitution of India. 2. As substantiated in my Writ, undo all wrong/criminal doings by the
Kalyani Municipality, since the imposition of CPI(M) rules in the Municipality. 3. Or help me to
fight out at the Supreme Court of India. And, 4. Initiate a CBI investigation about all
unethical and illegal/criminal activities indulged by the Kalyani Municipality. Like the
Governments in India, as per observation of Supreme Court ruling has lost all
accountability, and judges as such enjoy the unaccountability protection by law so far. As
per the local practice as known to the world, in general (exceptions are yet to be found in
CPI(M) WB) judges in High Court, Kolkata can not afford to give a ruling against the West
Bengal Government or Government bodies in West Bengal. Let the people suffer like the
rest of scenario in WB. Regards,

Hon’ble, Chief Justice,

Kolkata High Court,
Kolkata, India.
Videographic presentation was sent to you by Registered post.
Right to information (valid and logical) and if required to reopen the case to
establish the right of common men.
Dear Hon’ble Mr Chief Justice:

Sub: Indian judiciary and their associates particularly in this case Kolkata
High Court is sending me in circles, as it appears to the world and to me,
that justice is only for the people who can afford to spend billions in spite
of heinous crimes.
Your Honor:,
I am a NRI of more than 70 years old. Having aspired to set up an industry in
West Bengal in 1982 I was jailed, tortured, and what not.
Since Indian system does not maintain a IT based data bank everything needs to
be proven with paper, which you’re more than aware of can be fabricated for few
rupees and or influence.
Please help me in the following circular affair:
b) When no local glorified titled public servant took any remedial measures
and not even had the courtesy of replying my letters, I filed a writ MAT NO.
3140 in 2003 and without going through the contents of the Writ filed
under 226 of the Constirution of India, the writ was disposed of by Justice
PInaki Chandra Ghose without showing any valid reason/s.Appeal W.P.
8826(W) of 2003 was disposed of by Justice Ashim Kumar Banerjee and
Justice Tapas Kumar Giri and the matter was referred to local public
servant, District Magistrate and handed over to me on 20/8/2007.
 Continued from page 1
Hon’ble Chief Justice,
Kolkata High Court,
Kolkata, India

c) Why the matter was referred to District Magistrate when in the first place
as substantiated in my writ that no local glorified titled public servant, DM,
SDO, Transportation Department, Environmental Protection, etc., did give
a damn about my complaints which was also published in the daily English
News paper from Kolkata. DM, Nadia informally intimated that he can do
nothing about it.
d) To my experience and to the experience of thousands of the world Indian
public service hardly provide any service to the public, excepting the
Indian VIPs and their stooges.
e) So, nothing had happened. Criminal activities/illegality, as substantiated
and irrefutably proven, in my above writ along with video
photography as it appears to the world and to me is imbibed in local
society and continues unabated.
f) You are quite aware of the judiciary system of the civilized world and their
effectiveness.
g) Your Honor, I’ve not seen or heard that in civilized countries where there
are no VIPs and what not as in India, Supreme Court of a country hears
bail petitions as is done here. Nor does Supreme Court of High Court of a
country entertain every petition from the proven/unproven criminals.
h) But, as witnessed by me in civilized world, higher/highest court of the
country establishes the right of the common man.
i) The existence of right is thus the foundation of a petition under Article 226
State or Orissa v Ram Chandra Dev, AIR 1964 SC 685, and rights of the
reident of Kalyani have been violated with impunity.
j) The next course opened to me for getting justice by the Indian System is
to file a contempt case and then proceed to Supreme Court. I am afraid,
to my opinion based on the civilized democratic system enough is enough,
and I don't have unaccounted assets like most locals to get it to the
Supreme court of India. I’ve to slog to earn a living and don’t have assets
disproportionate to earning a very much accepted practice locally in India.

Already, locals of India have sucked millions from me in one name or the
other. Your Honor I had worked for a living and don’t have any ill got money
as rampant in India. I survive only on pension from Canada.

May I request you to please intervene and provide justice. Please provide
information that is logical to anybody, not just "judicial independence".

Following is provided to you for your ready reference.

 Continued from page 2

Hon’ble Chief Justice,

Kolkata High Court,
Kolkata, India

Quote: “Writ: MAT 3140 of 2003, and Appeal F.M.A no. 1040 of
2007

k) The judgment of above writ MAT 3140 of 2003 was rejected by

Justice Pinaki Ghosh was rejected and appeal F.M.A. no. 1040 of
2007 was pushed to the District Magistrate by Justice Ashim
Kumar Banerjee and Justice Tapas Kumar Giri J on 27/07/07.

2. Right to live in peace

2(a) Both judgments did not take into consideration of the

safety and peaceful living of NRI Aurovindo Choudhury as
was evident on the writ petition item 3, 4, 5,6,7,8,9,10.
and did not order any protection to the applicant or
compensation for the sufferings and harassment to the
petitioner. No Protection was provided to the petitioner.
3. Environmental pollution and malpractices to create
Environmental hazards by the Kalyani Municipality.

3(a) Item 12, 13, 14, 15,16 are clear intentional violation of
the above acts and many other criminal acts.

4 Arbitrary changing of Master Plan in line with local

practice, presumably for money.

4(a) Item 17,18 are clear examples. In this context the

petitioner’s observation is that Supreme Court of India has
ordered that no master plan can be changed.. (But Calcutta
High Court it appears from their ruling is at liberty to do
whatever they like).
 Continued from page 3

Hon’ble Chief Justice,

Kolkata High Court,
Kolkata, India

Petitioner’s comments:

l) Don’t the Judges of the High Court go through the petitions

put before them for judgment?
m) Why the same was thrown back to the District Magistrate, Nadia
when District Magistrate Nadia took no remedial action as is
evident in item 15 of the writ petition. In the petitioner’s view
even the highest judiciary of the state are in the game of
throwing ball back making endless suffering to the people.

Petitioner:

n) 70 year old NRI.

o) Appeal F.M.A. no. 1040 of 2007 was pushed to the District
Magistrate by Justice Ashim Kumar Banerjee and Justice Tapas
Kumar Giri J on 27/07/07, the petitioner was out of the country.”
And, like most public servants here the DM cut a very sorry
figure. Are not the judges to give judgments/ruling or pass the
buck to the other public servants, Babus in all kinds of local
glorified titles
Unquote, a quote, "power under article 226 is designed to effectuate the
law to enforce the rule of law and to ensure that several authorities and
organs of the state act in accordance with law. Union of India v Kirloskar
Pneumatic Co. Ltd., (1196) 4SCC 453: AIR 1996 SC 3285.

Another quote "No one should be allowed to suffer for act of court State of
M.P. v M.V. Vyasaya & Co., (1997) 1 SCC 156: AIR 1997 SC 993. Another
quote "Writ application is a public law remedy".

I pray to God that justice prevails in India particularly to me.

With kindest regards and salutations,

Yours truly,
Engr. Aurovindo Choudhury, C.Eng., FIE for life,(India, Bangladesh),
VDI(Germany), MBIM(UK & Aust), FInstP(UK), MAACE(US),MCIMM, MCIS(Canada),
etc., Commissioner of Oaths for the province of Quebec with jurisdiction of all the
countries of the world, a grandson of the Her Excellency Shri Shri Ma
Anandamoyee.
Email: ceaurovindo@yahoo.ca Tel: (033)64153255.