A REBUTTAL BY AN ARYA

REGARDING :

Who says no contradictions and errors in Vedas?

Posted in the Hindu Forum

http://www.topix.com/forum/religion/hindu/TTF4DU99P2NODJOPF

FEW SCIENTIFIC ERRORS IN HINDU SCRIPTURES

1.“He who fixed firm the earth that staggered, and set at rest the agitated
mountains, who measured out the air's wide middle region and gave the heaven
support, he men is Indra.” Rig Ved: 2: 12: 2. We all know today that the earth
revolves and rotates and is not fixed.

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION: HE [AUM], WHO SUSTAINS THE MOVING EARTH,

CAUSES THE RAIN CLOUDS TO BE BLOWN HERE AND THERE, TAKES CARE OF THE
SPACE BETWEEN HEAVENLY BODIES AND LIGHT, DESTROYER OF ALL THINGS, IS
WORTH KNOWING.

2.“In the beginning rose Hiranyagarbha, born only Lord of all created beings. He
fixed and holds up the earth and the heaven.” Rig Ved: 10: 121: 1. We all know
today that the earth revolves and rotates and is not fixed.

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION: " In the beginning was Hiranyagarbha - the One Lord
of the creation. He sustains the sun and the earth. We adore Him - the all Blissful
Being=AUM." [SEE ALSO YAJUR VEDA 13: 4].

3. “Firm is the sky and firm is the earth and steadfast are also these hills. Steadfast
is all this living world.....” Rig Ved: 10: 173: 4

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION: “Firm is the sky and firm is the earth and steadfast
are also these hills (ACCORDING TO THE RULES ORDAINED BY AUM). Steadfast is
this entire living world (ACCORDING TO THE RULES ORDAINED BY AUM). LET THIS
KING BE STEADFAST (THE KING SHOULD STICK TO THE RULE OF LAW).

THE SANSKRIT WORD USED IS DHRUVA (STEADFAST) I.E. WE SHULD BE ABLE TO

FOLLOW THE KING IN TERMS OF ADHERENCE TO RULES/LAW OF THE LAND.

ONE SHOULD NOT BE LIKE MOHAMMED WHOSE SO-CALLED NIKAAH WITH ZAINAB
WAS SUPPOSEDLY HELD BY ALLAH HIMSELF SINCE HE COULD NOT JUGAD A QAZI
FOR HIMSELF.WOULD MOHAMMED ALLOW SUCH A THING FOR A COMMON MUSLIM?
NO!

4.“The Bull has supported the sky.” Yajur Ved: 4: 30

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION: THE WORD VRUSHABHAM IN THIS MANTRA MEANS

GLORIOUS, NOT BULL.

IT IS NATURAL FOR AUM TO CREATE AND PERVADE THE SUN, WIND, LIGHT AND
HEAVENLY BODIES LIKE THE EARTH .

5.“God has firmly fixed the earth with pegs around it.” Yajur Ved: 5: 16

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION: [VYASKAMNA = SAMYAK STAMBHAN] AUM SUSTAINS

THE EARTH AND PERVADES IT……….

OBSERVE HOW THE QURAN COPIES THIS CONCEPT FROM THE VEDAS:

QURAN 78:6 Have We not made the earth an expanse,

QURAN 78:7 And the high hills bulwarks?

6. “North West of the heavens.” Yajur Ved: 13: 56, 57

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION: JUST LIKE THE LEARNED MEN ATTAIN THE LIGHT OF
KNOWLEDGE TO OTHERS , I, O WOMAN WILL ATTAIN POWER ALONG WITH YOU.
PASHCHAT TASYA=THE SUN PRESENT IN THE WESTERN DIRECTION WHICH IS
BEHELD BY NETRA=EYES…..

MEN AND WOMEN SHOULD LEARN AT THE FEET OF GURUS. IDAM UTTARAT SWAH=
THE SOURCE OF HAPPINESS/SUKHA IN THE NORTH DIRECTION……

7.“The sky is supported by pillars.” Yajur Ved: 4: 30

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION: IT IS NATURAL FOR AUM TO SUSTAIN THE SUN , THE
SPACE BETWEEN HEAVENLY BODIES, ETC….[ASTAMNAT = DHARAN KARTE, TO
SUSTAIN . IT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH PILLARS]

OBSERVE HOW THIS CONCEPT HAS BEEN COPIED FROM THE VEDAS TO THE QURAN:
"It is God who hath reared the heavens without pillars thou canst behold: [ALLAH
DOES NOT KNOW THAT THE SKY BEING EMPTY SPACE, CANNOT BE SUPPORTED BY
PILLARS ] then mounted His throne [ARSH/THRONE IS LARGER THAN ALLAH. GUESS
WHO IS THE LARGEST IN THE WORLD ?] and imposed laws on the sun and the
moon. And He it is who hath outstretched the earth [ IS THE EARTH FLAT? ]. He
sendeth down the rain from heaven [SO ZANNAT, JAHANNUM AND ARSH/THRONE
ARE ABOVE THE CLOUDS IN THE IONOSPHERE?] ; then flow the torrents in their due
measure." ((QURAN 13: 15)

8.“The Bull has supported the sky.” Yajur Ved: 14:5

THE CORRECT TRANSLATION :THERE IS NO WORD IN THIS MANTRA WHICH MEANS

BULL

CHECK : A FIRANGI TRANSLATION [THIS IS JUST FOR A NEUTRAL VIEW,I PREFER ARYA
TRANSLATORS]

http://www.sacred-texts.com/hin/wyv/wyvbk14.htm

The Texts of the White Yajurveda, tr. Ralph T.H. Griffith, [1899], at sacred-texts.com

YAJURVEDA 14:5 Upon the back of Aditi I lay thee the sky's supporter, pillar

of the Quarters,

Queen over creatures. Wave and drop of waters art thou;

and Visvakarman is thy Rishi.

9.“A lamp kept in windless place does not shake.” Bhagvad Gita: 6: 19 Scientifically
this is not true.

10. Arjun says to Krishna ,“The sun and moon are your eyes.” Bhagvad Gita: 11: 19

THE GITA IS A CONVERSATION BETWEEN ARJUNA AND KRISHNA WHO WERE

MAHAPURUSHA AND NOT GOD . THEREFORE WE WILL NOT DEFEND THEIR
UTTERANCES .

SIMILIARLY THE BIBLE AND QURAN CONTAIN THE LIFE AND DEEDS OF
JESUS AND MOHAMMED. THERE IS NOTHING HEAVENLY REGARDING THEM
AND HENCE CANNOT BE FOLLOWED.
ESPECIALLY ALLAH IS THE MARRIAGE –BROKER OF
MOHAMMED:

http://72.14.235.132/search?q=cache:jU8xsjhXP2EJ:forums.islamicawakening.com/s
howthread.php%3Ft%3D4941+As+for+the+marriage+of+the+Prophet+(peace+be
+upon+him)+to+Zainab,+May+Allah+be+pleased+with+her,+he+proposed+to+
her+after+the+expiry+of+her+%E2%80%98Iddah+(Th&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl
=in&client=firefox-a

“And (remember) when you said to him (Zaid bin Hārithah the freed*slave of the
Prophet SAW) on whom Allāh has bestowed Grace (by guiding him to Islām) and you
(O Muhammad SAW too) have done favour (by manumitting him) "Keep your wife to
yourself, and fear Allāh." But you did hide in yourself (i.e. what Allāh has already
made known to you that He will give her to you in marriage) that which Allāh will
make manifest, you did fear the people (i.e., Muhammad SAW married the divorced
wife of his manumitted slave) whereas Allāh had a better right that you should fear
Him. So when Zaid had accomplished his desire from her (i.e. divorced her), We
gave her to you in marriage, so that (in future) there may be no difficulty to the
believers in respect of (the marriage of) the wives of their adopted sons when the
latter have no desire to keep them (i.e. they have divorced them). And Allāh's
Command must be fulfilled.” (Al-Ahzab 33:37)

As for the marriage of the Prophet (peace be upon him) to Zainab, May
Allah be pleased with her, he proposed to her after the expiry of her
‘Iddah (The prescribed waiting period for a woman following divorce,
during which she may not marry.) following her divorce from Zaid.

Then Allah married him to her, without any Waliy

and without witnesses, for he (peace be upon him) was the guardian of all

; indeed he has more right

the believers

over them than they themselves. Allah,

the Most High says:

“The Prophet is closer to the believers than their ownselves, and his wives are their
(believers') mothers (as regards respect and marriage). And blood relations among
each other have closer personal ties in the Decree of Allâh (regarding inheritance)
than (the brotherhood of) the believers and the Muhajirûn (emigrants from Makkah,
etc.), except that you do kindness to those brothers (when the Prophet SAW joined
them in brotherhood ties). This has been written in the (Allâh's Book of Divine)
Decrees (Al*Lauh Al*Mahfûz)." (Al-Ahzab 33:6)

NAMASTE
http://www.scribd.com/doc/8142696/Official-Challenge-to-Dr-Zakir-Naik-by-
Sarvdeshik-Arya-Pratinidhi-Sabha-