Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
Close
LODDs
On April 16, 2007, in the Prince William County (VA) Fire Department, Firefighter Kyle Wilson was killed while operating at a structure fire. On arrival, crews encountered fire on the exterior of the home along the back of the house, underneath, and along a rear deck area. The fire had extended into the attic. Wilson and his officer entered the home through the front door into the foyer. A light haze of smoke was visible on the first floor. They proceeded upstairs and encountered smoke that banked down three feet from the ceiling. As they searched the master bedroom for possible victims, the room suddenly became black and then turned orange with flames. The two firefighters became separated. Wilson remained upstairs in flashover conditions and was unable to exit the structure. The coroner listed the cause of death "thermal and inhalational injuries." Did you know that the Sofa Super Store (Charleston, South Carolina) fire originated on the exterior as freeburning trash? The first-arriving company found a rapidly growing fire on a loading dock connecting the showroom to the warehouse. The assistant chief entered the main showroom from the front entrance and did not find any signs of fire or smoke, similar to the conditions that occurred during the Prince William County incident. Often in exterior fires, the conditions on the interior are not indicative of the fire conditions occurring in the attic or on the exterior siding of the structure.
Near Misses
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html 1/9
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
Near misses have occurred by attacking fire from the unburned side, especially fires that originate on or spread to the exterior of the building. For example, the Loudoun County (VA) Meadowood Court fire injured four firefighters, Prince George's County (MD) recently had two separate near-miss incidents that injured firefighters, and Cherokee County (GA) had an incident that injured four firefighters in December 2010. These fires had many other contributing factors, but one has to wonder whether a direct attack from the burned side would have prevented these deaths and injuries. The fact is that in all of the fires mentioned above, the firefighters were doing what they had been trained to do. In the past 20 years, it has become common practice to attack from the unburned side. Think about the last fire you had where you didn't pull the initial attack line to the front door. That's what we typically doa 1-inch line to the front door. Right? We have become complacent because of the repetition of this event. As shown in the fires above, attacking from the unburned side is not always the best plan of attack.
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
Technology, and the National Research Council Canada have performed extensive studies on ventilation, winddriven fires, and fire spread on exterior walls that all pertain to this article. Many of us work in suburban areas where the spreading of deck fires, car fires, or grass fires to the exterior walls of residential structures is commonplace. Our typical fire attack plan is to "cut it off" in the attic. The following case studies will show that an attack from the burned side may have been a better option.
CASE STUDIES
Example: The fire originated on a grill under the rear deck. The first two attack lines were taken through the front door to the attic. The fourth-arriving engine company was assigned to extinguish the fire on the C side (photos 1-2).
(1) This fire originated from a grill under the rear deck. Only a light smoke condition was visible on the A side.
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html
3/9
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
(2) However, the C side had heavy fire conditions. These photos show the vast difference in fire conditions on the same structure at nearly the same time. [Photos courtesy of the Cobb County (GA) Fire and Emergency Services, Fire Investigations Unit, Chief Fire Investigator Rod Sanders.] On these residential fires, a common tactic is to make an aggressive interior attack to knock down the fire in the attic and then pull a second hoseline to extinguish the exterior fire. This sounds good but, in reality, it can be difficult to get water on an exterior fire such as a rear deck, rear porches, or combustible siding with a hoseline operated from the interior of the fire building. Firefighters operating inside the fire building must direct their stream at an extreme angle through windows and doors for it to strike the exterior wall. Conversely, one firefighter positioned at a corner where the side and rear walls meet can rapidly apply water to burning siding, decks, or porches by directing his stream parallel to the rear wall and striking the soffit underside of the eaves. This tactic stops extension into the attic, and water entering soffit vents may affect any fire that has already extended to the attic. Operating a hoseline in this manner also extinguishes exterior siding as water cascades down the walls. Additionally, a stream directed parallel to the rear wall will not oppose streams directed from the inside of the fire building. Although the first hoseline is stretched to the exterior, hoselines must be rapidly advanced into the fire building to protect occupants and to stop extension to the building's interior. Interior and exterior hose streams on these fires are not mutually exclusive; each has its own critical function, and it is practically impossible for one stream to duplicate the function of the other. Hoselines operated from the outside and inside a fire building can be viewed by some as opposing streams or mixing offensive and defensive tactics. This concern, however, is based on textbook theory and not practical fire experience. Example: At this fire (photo 3), I was on the initial hoseline with a probationary firefighter, who was responding to his first fire. As we entered the front door, conditions rapidly deteriorated, and we were able to back out safely. It is apparent to me now that the front door had become a ventilation opening, which caused the conditions to change rapidly in addition to the large volume of fire on the C side. As the backup firefighter that day, I did not get a chance to do a walk-around. Unfortunately, to some people, the 360 walk-around has become a checkbox instead of actually sizing-up and comprehending the fire conditions to create a sound strategic plan. As seen in this fire, the first-arriving officer did not have much of a plan and went with the old "1-inch line to the front door." We could have been injured or killed that day because of repetitive complacency.
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html
4/9
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
(3) This fire also started from a grill on a rear deck. It shows exterior deck fire, C side (heavy fire conditions). Example: Fire started on the exterior deck and spread to the attic, as shown. The initial tactic of the first-due engine was to attack the fire directly with a 2-inch hoseline. In photo 7, you see the second-due engine company deploying a 1-inch hoseline to the attic. Although sound initial tactics were used, poor operations by the first-due engine delayed extinguishing the fire on the exterior, causing significant damage to the structure (photos 4-9).
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html
5/9
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html
6/9
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
(4-9) These photos show the sequence of an exterior fire that was attacked from the interior first. They vividly drive home the point that a fire should be extinguished at its base on the exterior. These fires do not only occur in residential structures. They also exist in commercial and high-rise structures. The Atlantic City (NJ) Fire Prevention Division conducted some tests as part of its investigations after the fire department was challenged by two separate incidents that happened to be exterior-wall fires. It found that a
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html 7/9
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
direct attack on the base of the fire quickly extinguished the fire and decreased interior damage to the building. On commercial and high-rise fires, sometimes the cladding materials used on the structure may burn up before the fire reaches the interior.
Bibliography
Brannigan, Francis L. (2008) Brannigan's Building Construction for the Fire Service, 4th edition. Francis L. Brannigan, Glenn Corbett. Jones and Bartlett Publishers. Norman, John. (2005) Fire Officer's Handbook of Tactics, Third Edition. Fire Engineering. Fredericks, Andrew A. "Little Drops of Water: 50 Years Later, Part 2." Fire Engineering, March 2000, 153:3, 113-36. Part 1 was published in Fire Engineering, February 2000, 153:2, 63-76. Foley, James M., "Modern Building Materials Are Factors in Atlantic City Fires," Fire Engineering, May 2010. "Death in the Line of Duty 2007-12," National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), February 11, 2009. "Death in the Line of Duty 2007-18," NIOSH, May 16, 2008. SEAN GRAY is an 18-year veteran and a fire engineer with Cobb County (GA) Fire and Emergency Services. He is assigned to Station 19 and also works as a part-time firefighter for the Roswell Fire Department. He has an
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html 8/9
09/08/13
Attacking from the Burned Side Can Save Lives - Print this page
associate degree and is a certified paramedic, hazmat technician, and technical rescue technician with Georgia Search and Rescue Task Force 4. More Fire Engineering Issue Articles Fire Engineering Archives
www.fireengineering.com/articles/print/volume-164/issue-11/features/attacking-from-the-burned-side-can-save-lives._printArticle.html
9/9