Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
1 Executive Summary.......................................................................... 5
2 Introduction ....................................................................................... 6
2.1 Aims of the project........................................................................................ 6
2.2 Funding of the project................................................................................... 6
3 Background ....................................................................................... 6
3.1 Evidence of Need ......................................................................................... 6
3.2 Circuit Riders................................................................................................ 7
3.3 Other related projects and services in Northamptonshire............................. 7
8 Future work...................................................................................... 16
9 Conclusion....................................................................................... 20
11 Acknowledgements ........................................................................ 22
The ICT support needs of the rural voluntary sector are wide-ranging and varied, but
essentially the same as would be encountered in any under-resourced small to
medium sized business. The key factors in meeting the needs of the rural
community are the difficulty in marketing the service and the extra cost of travel to
reach the groups. As with small business, many of the issues raised are about lack
of time, problems with organisational structures and lack of general understanding
about how prioritising IT and training could relieve some of the time pressures in the
long term.
This pilot Northamptonshire ICT support service can be considered a success, in that
it provided useful lessons and experiences for developing a larger scale long-term
service. There is clearly a demand for such a service and the pilot was only able to
scratch the surface. It is hoped that future funding bids will be successful and it will
be possible to build on the experience of this pilot, develop the good ideas that have
come from it, and enable the local voluntary sector in both urban and rural areas to
make informed and effective use of ICT to support their activities.
The original application was for the project was £17,500, plus a requirement of
raising contribution in kind to the value of £2,080.
3 Background
3.1 Evidence of Need
The "Mapping the rural voluntary sector" (2002) 1 study comparing East
Northamptonshire and Teesdale found that:
Only half (52.6%) of organisations use word processing and/or spreadsheet
software
Slightly more that one organisation in four (26.3%) uses the Internet and
almost one in five (19.3%) has a website
Only 5% of organisations have an ICT budget.
CVS carried out its own research project with a sample of members who had
previously responded that they did not want to receive information from CVS by
email. The results report (March 2003) 4 showed that 85% indicated they would like
to receive training 'in-house' on their own computers and software rather than going
on a course.
The pilot project was inspired by this model and aimed to see if it was possible to set
up a service along these lines in Northamptonshire.
There are increased opportunities for recycling because of the European Directive for
the collection, treatment, recycling and disposal of waste electrical and electronic
Teamwork are aiming to recycle 200 computers per month by the end of the first
year. They have an arrangement with Recycle-IT based in Luton, who have already
established ways of working and markets for older PCs for the developing countries
and local markets for newer PCs. They will be starting the business with equipment
and training from Recycle-IT and Recycle-IT will pay them for machines that they
have cleaned up and are ready to be sold on.
A Steering Group met four times during the six-month period of the project. The
following people were members of the Steering Group:
Mary Hopkins, director, CVS
David Quayle, chief executive, ACRE
Karen Cropper, self employed contractor working for CVS
Rob Stead, self employed contractor working for CVS
Penny Mould, manager, King’ s Cliffe Resource Centre, ACRE
Overall the project was co-ordinated by Karen Cropper. The direct service delivery
was mostly by Rob Stead and Mary Creswell (King’ s Cliffe Resource Centre) with
additional support from Karen Cropper, Penny Mould and 2 other contractors at the
end of the project for one-off pieces of work.
4.2 Marketing
Articles and inserts were placed in CVS’
s Newsfile magazine, which is sent out
monthly to 400-450 voluntary sector organisations in the county (see Appendix B for
examples).
Direct marketing of leaflets and fliers about the service were sent out to
approximately 80 organisations that were selected from various lists, particularly
targeting those organisations that were based in rural areas.
4.4 Co-ordination
The project workers aimed to meet roughly on a monthly basis. In all there were six
co-ordination meetings during the period of the project. These meetings were
informal and very useful for reviewing progress and exchanging ideas about how
best to help each organisation to build its ICT capacity
4.5 Monitoring
The funding body required monthly monitoring of finances and achievements. This
was a very time-consuming process, especially within such a short-term project. The
monitoring related to: project spend, leverage raised, organisations worked with,
number of training weeks (1 training week = 1 person trained for 30 hours) and
number of capacity building initiatives.
82% (9/11) of organisations in the pilot group did not have a budget for IT equipment,
maintenance or training. One organisation used the stationery budget for any
expenses relating to IT. Two of the organisations that did not have a budget had
made grant applications to include this – one was pending, the other was
unsuccessful.
Organisations involved in the pilot had accounts with the following Internet Service
Providers:
Freeserve (4) – dial-up - www.freeserve.co.uk, also do broadband
Tiscali (1) – dial-up - www.tiscali.co.uk, also do broadband
BT Connect (1) – dial up - www.btconnect.com, also do broadband
UK Online (1) – dial-up - www.ukonline.net also do broadband
Netscalibur – broadband - http://www.netscalibur.co.uk/ (1)
Pipex (1) - broadband - www.pipex.net
ZenADSL (1) – broadband - www.zenadsl.co.uk
100% (11/11) of organisations that had Internet used Microsoft Internet Explorer as
their browser.
73% (8/11) of organisations that had Internet access use a dial-up modem through
an ordinary telephone line.
100% (11/11) of organisations that had email use Microsoft Outlook Express as their
email software.
27% (3/11) of organisations either did not have virus protection software or were not
aware that it needed to be updated regularly and that the system needed to be set up
to scan regularly.
It is not only the virus definitions that need updating. All software, including
Windows, needs to be updated regularly so that it doesn’ t include the vulnerabilities
that the viruses exploit. None of the organisations visited had installed the critical
updates made available from Microsoft, for example.
50% (3/6) of organisations that had more than one computer had them networked
and were able to share files. (One of these, though, was so concerned about viruses
that email was only available on one PC not connected to the network, however all
PC’ s could access the Internet.). 50% (3/6) organisations with more than one PC did
not have them networked and in one instance they only had one printer and had to
transfer files by floppy disc between machines in order to print.
36% (4/11) of organisations had a website (includes one group that was a village
group specifically for a village website - we helped them to set it up).
100% (4/4) of organisations with a website had it set up by a person who was either
a volunteer or no longer with the organisation (one of these now has trained staff who
40% (2/5) of organisations that had scanners did not know how to use them.
The following case studies are presented to illustrate the range of issues
encountered on the project.
Comments
The difficulty is, if the organisation consists of one person and one PC, when there is
a problem, there isn’ t a spare machine to use and there is only one person there to
sort it out. A circuit rider project could make life easier for a lot of voluntary sector
organisations that are essentially lone or home-workers by having a helpline and a
call out service to fix issues when they arise, but more importantly providing an
information/awareness raising service that promotes good practice such as health
and safety on setting up the work space, tips about using the PC efficiently, advice
about virus protection and updating software. Commercial hardware suppliers have
a range of warranty services including helplines and on-site or return to base repair.
A local circuit rider project would have the advantage of being more aware of the
background and the opportunity for the individuals to get to know the people who are
helping rather than dealing with face-less contacts in a national office. On the softer
side such a service could provide the feeling of security of a support network.
Comments
Organisations of this size would definitely benefit from longer-term work with a circuit
rider project. There isn’ t a simple one-off fix but needs to be on-going development
starting form assessing their business and how their use of technology fits in with
this, fixing initial obvious faults and problems and then working towards a more
sustainable strategy of routine maintenance that prevent these problems occurring in
the future. From experience elsewhere, it takes at least nine months for people to
get used to and embrace networking.
When the consultant visited the organisation, it was found that the two PCs
concerned were old and had been donated. They did not have a high enough
specification to run Windows 98. The village hall was newly refurbished with
excellent facilities and the contact had ambitions to provide public access to the
Internet and the use of PCs for word-processing, as a service/resource available at
the village hall for the local community and particularly for the younger people.
The project was able to supply two newer second hand PCs plus two legal Windows
98 licences, but because of time was not able to take this organisation to the point of
being able to offer the service they desire.
Comments
This case was an example of where what seemed to be a simple request (upgrading
software) was actually much more involved. If there had been more time and
resources then more could have been done to assist and advise. This is also an
example of not just hardware and software, but a project that requires more thought
than simply setting up some second-hand PCs. The Village Hall will have to consider
organisation issues if they are to offer such a service to young people- for example:
Who will open and lock up the hall?
Will there be restricted times when the facility is open/available?
Will there be anyone there to show people how to use the equipment?
If there is no-one there, what will the insurance implications be (for the building
and personal safety, not necessarily the equipment)?
How will misuse and abuse of equipment be prevented?
This village is able to get broadband, so it would be good to have the speed of
access that broadband offers, but there will be an associated cost. By the time the
organisational issues can be sorted out the second-hand equipment provided, even
though better than what they had, will not really be robust enough for public use.
Scanning the system and removing the viruses and then installing virus protection
software cured the problems. Training on the importance of regularly updating the
software to recognise the latest viruses and regularly running a virus scan on the
system will hopefully provide a long-term benefit.
Comments
The issue of virus protection and the problems caused by virus infection is becoming
more and more apparent as the use of email is increased. The problem of potential
infection is not just for the individual, but can affect any sized organisation.
Protection against viruses comes not only from regularly updating virus protection
software, but also updating all software in order to close vulnerabilities, for example
by installing critical updates issued by Microsoft.
Essentially this case is another example of issues faced by lone or home workers (as
outlined in section 5.2, but has been mentioned separately here since it is also an
example of where a what appears to be a hardware problem turns out to be
something else and could be prevented by awareness raising and information.
The project was contacted to assist with basic use of email and the Internet, in
particular to train on how to open and save attachments and how to add documents
(eg parish council minutes) to an email to circulate them to parish councillors. One-
to-one training was given focusing on the specific difficulties that had been requested
but also giving a little extra in relation to organising emails into folders and how to
empty the deleted items folder.
Comments
The actual training did not take very long and the person benefited in that it got them
over a hurdle. However, in the future, if an ICT support service were to continue, we
would envisage the role of the service to be to emphasis the importance of including
Comments
There is a role for an organisation to provide impartial technical advice about
specifications, reasonable cost, places to buy hardware and software, and what
added extras might be needed (for example carrying cases, spare cables,
warrantees, maintenance contracts, insurance, health and safety and policies for
use).
The support to this group was in the form of 4 training sessions during the six-month
period which took the group from its initial ideas, discussions about the different
options available, providing a grant for a designer to create some initial pages,
assisting them with registering a domain name and sorting out hosting. A content
management system was finally settled on as this didn’ t require any technical
knowledge and could be kept up to date quickly and easily.
Comments
This work demonstrated that the support for a group like this needs to be on-going
and takes time. It is also not just about technical support in relation to using
hardware and software but also requires organisational support – developing a team
approach, developing the roles of individuals and understanding the longer-term
commitment required to sustain the website.
The philosophy of Circuit Riding is more than just identifying training needs. It is
about getting the infrastructure right, promoting the imaginative use of IT by putting
the basics in place. It is only when the network works that you can start training on
file sharing, print sharing and so on. The strength of this type of project is in building
up a relationship with organisations and directing to training available though other
agencies when appropriate.
Many of the voluntary sector organisations recognised that they needed help with
ICT, but were so busy fire-fighting that they did not have the time for training or to
find solutions or did not give ICT sufficient priority to allocate the time. They also did
not prioritise ICT sufficiently to allocate budgets to replacement, maintenance and
training.
A circuit rider type of ICT Support project could raise awareness and standards of
use of ICT in the voluntary and community sector.
The total cost of the pilot was £18,380. Approximately £10,000 was for the direct
delivery of service to the 24 organisations and the remaining £8,380 was for the
evaluation report, monitoring, marketing, admin, management and supervision.
The cost of monitoring was high because monthly monitoring reports were required
for budget and outputs, and the amount of paperwork required to backup the reports
was also considerable.
8 Future work
8.1 Discussions at the Steering Group – “How would this service be different
from a commercial IT Support contract?”
8.1.3 Marketing
It was felt that it is important for the service to have an identity, which comes from a
mission statement, name and logo. Linking to the circuit rider movement can provide
valuable support (from experiences in other parts of the country), the possibility of
benefiting from increased awareness of such initiatives nationally and also favourable
funding.
Experience of the project worker who provides ICT support on a commercial basis in
London is that a ratio of around one IT worker to 22 organisations works well for a
mixture of routine maintenance and fixing problems, but the aim should be to get an
organisation’s system working reliably and consistently so that the majority of the
work is simply routine maintenance.
More detailed business planning is required to assess the realistic costs of a service
to cover all voluntary sector organisations in Northamptonshire and what funding
sources are available (including a model for contribution towards cost from the
organisations receiving the service). A conservative estimate would be that at least 3
workers would be needed to cover the whole county and this would cost at least
£150,000 a year. It should be possible to recover some of this cost through a fee
based membership scheme and income generation.
This is possibly because there isn't one place to find ICT information - is this a role
for the project and is it about having a website presence?
1. The basic level might be to receive an information service that was made up of
paper newsletters, email alerts and website information along the lines used by the
CVS fundraising development service, but targeted at better use of ICT. This would
require a worker to supply this information, act as editor and administer distribution.
2. The next level might be an impartial advice service. Lists of suppliers for buying
new and second-hand hardware, software, people who could offer a maintenance
service, advice on what equipment/software would best meet their needs, what sort
of budget they might need, etc...
3. The next level could be going in to an organisation and doing an IT audit, offering
advice about how they could improve their set up, writing an IT Strategy, having a
network of people who could go in a fix problems (for a charge)...
4. The full service would be in effect a maintenance contract that involved regular
checks to prevent problems, making sure backup routines worked, that the server
and other hardware had enough had disc space and memory, etc, and incorporate
the principles of raising the standards of the organisation.
The issue is about cost benefit analysis. It is a balancing act about how much it
would cost to provide a full maintenance service, bearing in mind the ratio of staff to
organisations served (20-25 organisations per person) compared to being able to
provide a more limited service to more organisations. The charge for each level of
service would need to be considered and researched, in relation to what
organisations would be prepared and able to pay and how much income this would
generate to offset against the overall cost.
One idea is to set up a self-help group. This would need input to find out
which organisations have expertise and are willing to exchange information
and help - so you could end up with a self-help group on particular software.
But this may be very difficult to manage and would be hampered by individual
organisations not having the capacity to support others and it ending up being
a one-way process.
A lot of the service would actually be about training and it may be more cost
effective to promote what training is already available and develop that rather
than trying to be all things to all people. For example making it more widely
known that ITrain will do training in the work place.
Linked to this is the role of advisor rather than fixer. This would be providing
information about things like how to buy a computer, or how to set up a
network, and so on, which could be through various methods such as fact-
sheets, website pages, regular newsletter with handy hints, specific courses.
8.3 Additional services that a circuit rider/ICT Support project can offer
Management Committee Training - to emphasis the importance of including
ICT in the strategic vision of their organisations and budgeting for initial
equipment, maintenance, upgrading and training.
An information pack for organisations that are starting from scratch on what
they should think about for their ICT.
The project will also possibly pilot some form of ICT signposting/information service
(for example website links to useful resources already available on the Internet).
The cost is £10,050 cash + £1,850 leverage. This pays for 40 days of project
worker’
s time, plus management and supervision and book keeping/accounts.
A small steering group will be responsible for the overall direction of the project The
steering group will meet at least bi-monthly. Standard supervision sessions will take
place between the CVS line manager and project worker.
The new project would focus on developing a business plan for more substantial and
complex service. This plan will be the basis for further funding applications
9 Conclusion
This pilot Northamptonshire ICT support service can be considered a success, in that
it provided useful lessons and experiences for developing a larger scale long-term
1 Supporting Rural Voluntary Action, NCVO 2002 - During the autumn and winter of
2001 NCVO undertook research into the scope, activities and support needs of
voluntary organisations in two contrasting rural districts, Teesdale and East
Northamptonshire. The project: Mapping the Rural Voluntary Sector – Establishing
the Baseline, attempted to explore a range of rural environments within which
voluntary organisations operate.
4 ICT Pilot Project Report by Glenn Willis for CVS Northamptonshire March 2003
available from CVS NOrthamptonshire Tel 01604 624121.
Skills Gaps, Training and Workforce Development in the Voluntary Sector: The Rural
Analysis see: http://www.ncvo-vol.org.uk/ Sector Issues/ Rural/ Publications.
Voluntary and Community Sector Infrastructure: A model for the future available from
NCVO at www.ncvo-vol.org.uk or from the policy team on 020 7520 2473.
11 Acknowledgements
This report was written by Karen Cropper.
Other than the project workers and the members of the Steering Group, no other
people have been specifically named. Those people who have contributed their
comments are thanked.
All the organisations that participated in the pilot project are thanked for their
feedback.
Many years ago Richard Stallman (http://www.stallman.org/) formed the free software
movement via the Free Software Foundation and the GNU Project
(http://www.gnu.org/). This was very much a 'political' movement whereby Free
meant 'free speech' rather than 'free beer'. In other words, anyone should be able to
tinker with the source code and improve upon it. This is the hacker tradition (not to be
confused with the derogatory term its now become).
What two main things Richard Stallman did was introduce copyleft
(http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/gpl.html) and make available a C Compiler
(http://gcc.gnu.org/). Copyleft simply places some obligations upon a hacker; the
most important being they can't pass on the work as their own by selling it and any
bug fixes or improvements should be fed back to the 'keepers' of the software.
A C compiler allows anyone who has written some C code to compile it into a
program. This took Richard Stallman seven years to write and by donating it to the
community he freed everyone from the likes of Microsoft. The importance of this can't
be understated.
This is what we now know as Linux, although the proper name should be GNU/Linux
in order to acknowledge Richard Stallman's efforts. The word Linux is simply a
combination of the words Linus and Unix.
Over time lots of people started using Linux and embraced the copyleft principle by
releasing their own software freely to the community.
Also trying to down play the 'political' side of things the term 'Open Source' has been
adopted by many, although not all. The copyleft licence (called GPL) has been
slightly modified by various people, but the principle of a 'community' project persists.
Some licences allow people to sell the software, for example.
The most critical software released to run on Linux using the copyleft principle are:
All the above projects have some method for sharing the task of programming and
debugging. This is usually done over the Internet using some software called CVS
(Concurrent Versions System, http://www.cvshome.org/).
But there are literally thousands of Open Source projects and many are hosted at
Sourceforge (http://sourceforge.net). For example phpMyAdmin allows you to
administer a mySQL database (http://sourceforge.net/projects/phpmyadmin/). You'll
notice on this page there is a link to CVS, which is where anyone can download the
source code.
Of course not everyone wants the hassle of downloading and install all this stuff, let
alone hacking the code, so various companies have been set up to distribute
everything they think people will want. The software is simply downloaded like
everyone else off the Internet. They charge for the CDs and packaging and
compete by doing things in a friendly way.
There are also distributors who market to South America, China, India and Japan.
Open Source is a billion pound industry with IBM, Novell and Sun as the major
players.
Postcode
Address of Organisation
(if different)
Postcode
Rough size of organisation
(how many paid employees?)
How many computers do
0 1 2+ (please circle one)
they have at the moment?
Do they have email? Y N (please circle one)
Email address (if applies)
Once they have registered their details it may be a few weeks before they are
contacted by one of the consultants. They will be contacted to discuss the details of
the service that can be provided and to arrange a day and time for one of the
consultants to come and see them if that is appropriate. If they haven't heard
anything by two weeks from when they rang, they could ring again to see what is
happening.
Organisation Name
Contact Name
Contact Telephone No
Correspondence Address
Postcode
7d Digital cameras?
7e Other?
How were the email accounts set up (did someone in house do it, did they
insert a disc from their ISP, did they pay someone to do it?)
Does anyone have responsibility for setting up new email accounts, and if yes
who?
Organisation Name
Contact Name
Contact Telephone No
Who is visiting?
Organisation Name
Contact Name
Contact Telephone No
Date
Date:
Organisation Name
Contact Name
Contact Telephone No
Date
This pilot project delivered 6.21 training weeks (1 training week = 1 person for 30
hours).
2 Desk Top Publishing workshop training sessions were organised as part of this
project. 6 people attended the workshop at Kings Cliffe Resource Centre on 27th
February 2004 from 5 organisations. 5 people attended the workshop at Great
Houghton Village Hall on 3rd March 2004 from 3 organisations.
learndirect and other learning opportunities. There are five learndirect access
points where you can enrol on learndirect courses in Brixworth, Corby,
Northamptonshire Central, Wellingborough and Weston Favell Libraries. They also
run occasional free IT taster sessions in libraries to help you learn the basics of using
our computers, the Internet and email.
Web: www.northamptonshire.gov.uk then from the menu bar at the side select “Living
and working”then select “Libraries”.
16.5 ITrain
ITrain is a Northampton College initiative supported financially by the European
Social Fund to update and introduce new IT skills into the workplace of small and
medium sized enterprises (which includes voluntary and community sector
organisations). The training is aimed at employed individuals and volunteers to widen
their participation in learning, specifically their IT skills, as part of the Government's
lifelong learning strategy.
Indigo – Have a range of products and services. Can supply new hardware and
maintain networked systems. Their main catchment area is Northamptonshire,
Warwickshire and Leicestershire. Contact Simon Colley Tel 01858 4456225
Email: enquiries@indigo-computing.co.uk
website: www.indigo-computing.co.uk.
Ralph Gray is an independent contractor based in Kettering, but will cover anything
within reasonable travelling distance Tel 01536 484823 mob 07740215947.
Phoenix Software
Telephone 01904 700101
Email debbie-vickery@phoenixs.co.uk
Web www.phoenixs.co.uk
Pugh Computers
Telephone 01974 200 217
Email barry@pugh.co.uk
Web www.pugh.co.uk
Entec
Telephone 01462 499 532
Email jon.steggles@entec.co.uk
Web www.entec.co.uk
The policy in making these grants provides for one donation to an organisation
(including affiliates and branches) every three years.
Abbreviation/ Explanation
Jargon
Information and Communication Technology - an all-
encompassing term for any technology, from paper-based
systems to computer networks, that is used to communicate
ICT with and inform others. Usually these days it is generally
applied to electronic systems, but can also be used for any
filing and/or dissemination of information in paper form,
including post.
A mobile grassroots ICT worker supporting a case load of
Circuit Riders
organisations each too small to have their own IT staff
The ‘ nuts and bolts’of ICT systems. Specifically, the
keyboard, mouse, ‘ main box’and monitor of a computer and
Hardware bits connected to it like printers etc. The physical
components of an apparatus.
Something used or associated with and usually contrasted
with hardware: as the entire set of programs, procedures,
Software and related documentation associated with a system and
especially a computer system; specifically: computer
programs.
A way of connecting bits of hardware together in order to
share information and resources across computers.
Network A formal or informal system of sharing resources,
information and/or support through individuals or
organisations
Device for sending data across a telephone line by
Modem
converting digital signals to noise.
Also known as ADSL and SDSL this is a fast way to access
the internet by sending digital signals down a telephone
Broadband
wire, much in the same way as computers connect to each
in an office.