SAIL-BSP 7.

0 MTPA EXPANSION 3x150 TPH BOILER PACKAGE ALONG WITH STEAM TURBO-BLOWER BUILDING (EXCLUDING ENABLING WORKS) PKG. NO:- 011-01A COMPLIANCE REPORT ON COMMENTS GIVEN BY BSP/MECON
1. G.T.P OF 6.6kV SWITCHGEAR (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-BE-03002A) [Rev.00] 2. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03301) [Rev.00] 3. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03302) [Rev.00] 4. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03203) [Rev.00] 5. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03204) [Rev.00]

Drg. Title (Doc. No.) [Rev. no.]

Date: 08.07.13

S.No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Comments given on Rev 00 by M/s MECON GTP - 6.6 KV Switchgear Indicate a note stating all make shall be inline with GTS/Contract Indicate values for "Minimum phase to phase & phase to earth clearance" Please submit brief details (Make, Model, Type, Catalogue etc.) of each component inside the board. Busbar sizing calculation to be submitted Temperature rise to be indicated Sl. No. 3.01.03 - Temp. limit : Temp. rise shall be inline with contract/GTS Sl. No. 3.02.00: Mention "Continuous Earth Bus" Sl. No. 3.02.03: Earth Bus Material will be Cu Sl. No. 3.02.05: Extension of earth bus outside switchboard will be Cu CT/PT details & calculation to be submitted Remove the name of "Dinesh Electrical" from the Customer field Pls. indicate/take action on the following in the GTP: a) Mention in the GTP that Applicable standard : IS 12729 - 1988 b) Please submit Type test certificate along with re-submission of this drg. c) Mention in the GTP that Inspection shall be carried out as per approved QAP.

Action Taken/Clarification by M/s Schneider

We have deleted the name of M/s Dinesh Electricals and mentioned SAIL-BSP as "End Customer"

12

13 14 15 16 17 18 19

Sl. No. 1.01.01: Ref. Ambient temp. for design will be 50 C Sl. No. 1.02.01: Rated operation voltage will be 6.6 KV 10 % Sl. No. 1.02.02: Mention highest system voltage instead of Rated Insulation voltage Sl. No. 1.02.09: Delete the exception point for CT (1 sec.) Sl. No. 1.02.10: Internal Arc withstand will be 40 KA for 0.5 sec. Sl. No. 2.01.01: Delete the no. mentioned before switchboard name Sl. No. 2.02.07: Rear access will be hinged/bolted. Please check with design/accessibility Sl. No. 2.02.10, 2.02.11, 2.02.12: AES/FLCL shall check the availability as per the recommended clearances submitted by M/s Schneider Sl. No. 2.03.01: Degree of Protection for enclosure shall be IP52 Mention Termination for XLPE Armoured cable Sl. No.2.04.01: Mention that procedure for paiting will be as per IS standard We have mentioned: End Customer name as "SAIL-BSP" Consultant as "MECON Ltd." EPC Contractor as "FLCL/AES" Manufacturer as "Schneider Electric (Channel Partner: M/s Dinesh Electrical)" AES/FLCL has confirmed that as per approved building layouts in which equipment disposition is shown is as per recommendations of M/s Schneider

20

21 22 23

24

Please check Customer name

25

Please submit catalogues for HWX type Please remove the qty. of panels. Only mention 6.6 KV Switchgear (PBS1), 6.6 KV Switchgear-1 (PBS-2), 6.6 KV Switchgear-2 (PBS-2) Please mention Customer Spec. no. as "Inline with GTS/Contract"

26

27

SAIL-BSP 7.0 MTPA EXPANSION 3x150 TPH BOILER PACKAGE ALONG WITH STEAM TURBO-BLOWER BUILDING (EXCLUDING ENABLING WORKS) PKG. NO:- 011-01A COMPLIANCE REPORT ON COMMENTS GIVEN BY BSP/MECON
1. G.T.P OF 6.6kV SWITCHGEAR (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-BE-03002A) [Rev.00] 2. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03301) [Rev.00] 3. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03302) [Rev.00] 4. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03203) [Rev.00] 5. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03204) [Rev.00]

Drg. Title (Doc. No.) [Rev. no.]

Date: 08.07.13

S.No. 28

Comments given on Rev 00 by M/s MECON Please mention Manufactured "by" Schneider instead of Manufactured "at" Project Drg. No. to be mentioned GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-I Refer Sht. 2 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00757). In panel no. 8 (Incomer from Sec V Ext. Switchboard ASD-7 Feeder), check the CT ratio with approved Main SLD - PBS-1 area

Action Taken/Clarification by M/s Schneider

29

We have deleted the title block from the datasheet. FLCL/AES will enclose & submit the cover page with each document mentioning all the standard details, as done for all other vendors.

FLCL/AES had confirmed that after approval of Main SLD, ID & FD fan ratings have changed due to change in system parameters. Hence, we have considered the rating as per the confirmation given by FLCL/AES. Recently, it has been again confirmed by FLCL/AES, after MECON re-approval on ID/FD fan Refer Sht. 3 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00757). In panel no. 11 (Spare Motor Feeder-2), check the Feeder rating with approved Main SLD sizing calculation few days ago, that ID & FD fan motor rating have been freezed as follows: - PBS-1 area ID fan: 450 KW (Previously 400 KW) FD fan: 220 KW (Previously 200 KW) M/s Schneider has revised the document accordingly. All comments marked for GA, Fdn. Plan & SLD of 6.6 KV Unit Switchgear For compliance against each comment in this document, please for PBS-2 are identically applicable for this unit also. refer our reply in compliance report below for GA, Fdn. Plan & SLD of 6.6 KV Unit Switchgear for PBS-2. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-II Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-GA-00767). Indicate total length of panel Indicate the switchgear name in the title block of every sheet clearly. Remove the no. of panels (15 nos./12 nos./16 nos. etc. etc.) from the title. This comment is applicable for all documents. Refer Sht. 1 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Incomer Feeder : 3rd core of the PT missing Refer Sht. 1 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Incomer Feeder : In CT-1 Core-2, MICOM P-143 shall be communicable to SCADA Refer Sht. 1 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Incomer Feeder : In CT-1 Core-2, MICOM P-143 shall be communicable with SCADA Refer Sht. 1 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Incomer Feeder : In CT-1 Core-1, MFM shall have 4-20 mA feedback to field Refer Sht. 1 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Incomer Feeder : In CT-1 Core-1, MFM shall have feedback to SCADA Refer Sht. 1 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Incomer Feeder : 1 no. spare indication lamp to be provided for future use. Refer Sht. 1 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Incomer Feeder : K32 missing in material list Refer Sht. 2 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Transformer Feeder : MFM shall have 4-20 mA feedback to field Refer Sht. 2 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Transformer Feeder : MFM shall have feedback to SCADA

8 9 10 11

SAIL-BSP 7.0 MTPA EXPANSION 3x150 TPH BOILER PACKAGE ALONG WITH STEAM TURBO-BLOWER BUILDING (EXCLUDING ENABLING WORKS) PKG. NO:- 011-01A COMPLIANCE REPORT ON COMMENTS GIVEN BY BSP/MECON
1. G.T.P OF 6.6kV SWITCHGEAR (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-BE-03002A) [Rev.00] 2. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03301) [Rev.00] 3. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03302) [Rev.00] 4. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03203) [Rev.00] 5. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03204) [Rev.00]

Drg. Title (Doc. No.) [Rev. no.]

Date: 08.07.13

S.No. 12

Comments given on Rev 00 by M/s MECON Refer Sht. 2 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Transformer Feeder : MICOM P-143 shall be communicable with SCADA Refer Sht. 3 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Motor Feeder : Cross-reference of Source to be indicated. This comment is typical for all SLDs. Refer Sht. 3 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Motor Feeder : MFM shall have 4-20 mA feedback to field Refer Sht. 3 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Motor Feeder : MICOM P-143 shall be communicable with SCADA Refer Sht. 3 of 4 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-ML-00756). Motor Feeder : Indicate features available or included in MICOM P-241 Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#1 - Bus PT : Core-3 missing Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Typical comments: Submit CT / PT Sizing Calculation Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#2 - Spare Motor Feeder-1: Annunciator (12 lamps) to be provided (Typical) Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#2 - Spare Motor Feeder-1: Earth Switch to be provided (Typical) Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#3 - Transformer feeder-1: Earth Switch to be provided (Typical) Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#5 - Incomer from MSG Sec-VII: Annunciator (12 lamp) to be provided. Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#5 - Incomer from MSG Sec-VII: PT 3rd core missing

Action Taken/Clarification by M/s Schneider

13

14

15

16 17 18

19

20

21

22

23 24

25

Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Will be discussed during technical meeting & all inputs will be Feeder#5 - Incomer from MSG Sec-VII: AES/FLCL shall ensure details in taken from MECON and will be revised accordingly. line with other end of the CT. Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#5 - Incomer from MSG Sec-VII: Check & Correct Core-1 ratio Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Feeder#5 - Incomer from MSG Sec-VII: Earth switch to be provided Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Drawing title block: Please do not mention no. of panels in the title. Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00769). Drawing title block: This document is for Unit Swgr. PBS-2, not PBS-1. Correct it. Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00781). Feeder#1 - Spare Transformer Feeder#1: Same comments as given for Switchboard#1 Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00781). Feeder#5 - Incomer from Reserve Switchboard: Check CT ratio as per Main SLD and also other end (Reserve Swtichboard). Refer Sht. 2 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00781). Feeder#9 - Bus PT-1: Core-3 missing

27

28

29

30

31

Will be discussed during technical meeting & all inputs will be taken from MECON and will be revised accordingly.

32

SAIL-BSP 7.0 MTPA EXPANSION 3x150 TPH BOILER PACKAGE ALONG WITH STEAM TURBO-BLOWER BUILDING (EXCLUDING ENABLING WORKS) PKG. NO:- 011-01A COMPLIANCE REPORT ON COMMENTS GIVEN BY BSP/MECON
1. G.T.P OF 6.6kV SWITCHGEAR (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-BE-03002A) [Rev.00] 2. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03301) [Rev.00] 3. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03302) [Rev.00] 4. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03203) [Rev.00] 5. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03204) [Rev.00]

Drg. Title (Doc. No.) [Rev. no.]

Date: 08.07.13

S.No. 33 34

Comments given on Rev 00 by M/s MECON Refer Sht. 3 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00781). Feeder#12 - Incomer from Sec-VIII: Check CT details with SLD Refer Sht. 3 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00781). Feeder#12 - Incomer from Sec-VIII: Check CT details with SLD

Action Taken/Clarification by M/s Schneider

35

Refer Sht. 3 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SL-00781). Feeder#13 - Spare Motor Feeder-2: Check the Feeder rating with approved Main SLD - PBS-2 area

FLCL/AES had confirmed that after approval of Main SLD, ID & FD fan ratings have changed due to change in system parameters. Hence, we have considered the rating as per the confirmation given by FLCL/AES. Recently, it has been again confirmed by FLCL/AES, after MECON re-approval on ID/FD fan sizing calculation few days ago, that ID & FD fan motor rating have been freezed as follows: ID fan: 450 KW (Previously 400 KW) FD fan: 220 KW (Previously 200 KW) M/s Schneider has revised the document accordingly.

3 4

PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-I All comments marked for PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. For compliance against each comment in this document, please - PBS-2 are identically applicable for this document also. refer our reply in compliance report below for PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-2 PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-II Refer Sht. 1 of 6 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-BQ-00762). 1,2,3 & 4 mentioned in the right hand top corner in the legend sheet is not understandable. All make shall be as per GTS/Contract. A note shall be added as follows: Any modification/change in make not in line with contract, AES/FLCL shall be responsible for making the change/modification irrespective of the reviewing/approval status of the drawing by customer/consultant. Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-TB-00763). Signal descriptions shall be indicated for all sorts of signals connected to external devices/system. Refer Sht. 1 of 3 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-TB-00763). Atleast 20% spare terminal blocks shall be provided in each case. Refer Sht. 1 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Ammeter : Remove the term "As per SLD". (Typical) Refer Sht. 1 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Ammeter : Mention Range. Refer Sht. 1 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Voltmeter & VSS missing Refer Sht. 1 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). 4-20 mA o/p for remote ammeter/DCS Refer Sht. 2 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Use identification/signal description/contact details for ease for review. (e.g contacts for spring charge, test position, service position, breaker open, close etc. ) [This comment is TYPICAL for all schemes] Sheet 3 of 9 missing. (FLCL/AES observation: Schneider may pls. note that this sheet is missing from the beginning.) Refer Sht. 4 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Trip selector switch missing Refer Sht. 4 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Anti-pumping circuit not shown. Refer Sht. 4 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Please redraw scheme separately for I/c-1, I/c-2 & B/c

7 8 9 10 11

12

13

14 15 16

SAIL-BSP 7.0 MTPA EXPANSION 3x150 TPH BOILER PACKAGE ALONG WITH STEAM TURBO-BLOWER BUILDING (EXCLUDING ENABLING WORKS) PKG. NO:- 011-01A COMPLIANCE REPORT ON COMMENTS GIVEN BY BSP/MECON
1. G.T.P OF 6.6kV SWITCHGEAR (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-BE-03002A) [Rev.00] 2. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03301) [Rev.00] 3. GA, FDN. PLAN & SLD - 6.6kV SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03302) [Rev.00] 4. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-I (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03203) [Rev.00] 5. PROTECTION SCHEME - 6.6 KV UNIT SWGR. - PBS-II (BSP-FLCL-05-011-01A-06-040-29-DE-03204) [Rev.00]

Drg. Title (Doc. No.) [Rev. no.]

Date: 08.07.13

S.No. 17

Comments given on Rev 00 by M/s MECON Refer Sht. 4 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Please submit writeup stating the philosophy of operation for both closing & tripping circuit. Refer Sht. 4 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Submit scheme for distribution of control supply by using 2 nos. control transformers. Refer Sht. 4 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). FBT scheme shall be furnished along with writeup Refer Sht. 7 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). List out the protections available & envisaged in a table specifying type & model no. of relays & the features available. Refer Sht. 7 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Confirm & indicate a note stating that "All relays shall be microprocessor based numerical type having communication facility." Refer Sht. 7 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Submit catalogue for each relay Refer Sht. 7 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). All multiplying contactor shall have atleast 1 NO+1NC spare contacts. Refer Sht. 7 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). All soft communication signals shall be terminated/looped at one point and the same shall be identified for further connection to external device. [Typical comments - Applicable for All] Refer Sht. 7 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Electrical I/O List shall be submitted in 2 distinct categories: a. Hardwired I/o b. Softwire Communication Refer Sht. 9 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00758). Undervoltage relay function missing in MICOM P-143 ? Refer Sht. 1 of 9 (SEIL drg. No. SLO-83087-SC-00759). Identical comments applicable as mentioned for Incomer scheme.

Action Taken/Clarification by M/s Schneider

18 19 20

21

22 23

24

25

26 27