BAR EXAMINATIONS 2005

MERCANTILE LAW
18 September 2005 8 A.M. — 12 Noon

INSTRUCTIONS

This questionnaire consists of fifteen (15) numbers

contained in ten (10) pages. Read each question very
carefully. Answer legibly, clearly and concisely. Start each
number on a separate page; an answer to a sub-question
under the same number may be written continuously on the
same and immediately succeeding pages until completed.
Do not repeat the question.

HAND IN YOUR NOTEBOOK WITH THIS QUESTIONNAIRE

GOOD LUCK!!!

____________________________________
CHAIRMAN
2005 BAR EXAMINATION COMMITTEE

PLEASE CHECK THE NUMBER OF PAGES IN THIS SET

WARNING: NOT FOR SALE OR UNAUTHORIZED USE

MERCANTILE LAW Page 1 of 10

MERCANTILE LAW Page 2 of 10

-I-

(1.) What is a negotiable instrument? Give the characteristics

of a negotiable instrument. (2%)

(2.) Distinguish a negotiable document from a negotiable

instrument. (2%)

(3.) State and explain whether the following are negotiable

instruments under the Negotiable Instruments Law:

(i) Postal Money Order;

(ii) A certificate of time deposit which states “This is to certify
that bearer has deposited in this bank the sum of FOUR
THOUSAND PESOS (P4,000.00) only, repayable to the
depositor 200 days after date.”
(iii) Letters of credit;
(iv) Warehouse receipts;
(v) Treasury warrants payable from a specific fund.

(5%)

- II -

(1.) Dagul has a business arrangement with Facundo. The

latter would lend money to another, through Dagul, whose name
would appear in the promissory note as the lender. Dagul would then
immediately indorse the note to Facundo.

Is Dagul an accommodation party? Explain. (2%)

(2.) a) What is a crossed check? What are the effects of

crossing a check? Explain.

b) Distinguish an irregular indorser from a general

indorser.

(3%)
MERCANTILE LAW Page 3 of 10

(3.) Brad was in desperate need of money to pay his debt to

Pete, a loan shark. Pete threatened to take Brad’s life if he failed to
pay. Brad and Pete went to see Señorita Isobel, Brad’s rich cousin,
and asked her if she could sign a promissory note in his favor in the
amount of P10,000.00 to pay Pete. Fearing that Pete would kill Brad,
Señorita Isobel acceded to the request. She affixed her signature on
a piece of paper with the assurance of Brad that he will just fill it up
later. Brad then filled up the blank paper, making a promissory note
for the amount of P100,000.00. He then indorsed and delivered the
same to Pete, who accepted the note as payment of the debt.

What defense or defenses can Señorita Isobel set up against

Pete? Explain. (3%)

- III -

(1.) Under what conditions may a stock corporation acquire its

own shares? (2%)

(2.) Janice rendered some consultancy work for XYZ

Corporation. Her compensation included shares of stock therein.

Can XYZ Corporation issue shares of stock to pay for the

services of Janice as its consultant? Discuss your answer. (2%)

- IV -

Divine Corporation is engaged in the manufacture of garments

for export. In the course of its business, it was able to obtain loans
from individuals and financing institutions. However, due to the drop
in the demand for garments in the international market, Divine
Corporation could not meet its obligations. It decided to sell all its
equipment such as sewing machines, perma-press machines, high
speed sewers, cutting tables, ironing tables, etc., as well as its
supplies and materials to Top Grade Fashion Corporation, its
competitor.

a) How would you classify the transaction?

b) Can Divine Corporation sell the aforesaid items to its

competitor, Top Grade Fashion Corporation? What are the
requirements to validly sell the items? Explain.
MERCANTILE LAW Page 4 of 10

c) How would you protect the interests of the creditors of

Divine Corporation?

d) In case Divine Corporation violated the law, what remedies

are available to Top Grade Fashion Corporation against Divine
Corporation?

(5%)

-V-

(1.) a) Under what circumstances may a corporation declare

dividends? (2%)

b) Distinguish dividend from profit; cash dividend from

stock dividend. (2%)

c) From what funds are cash and stock dividends

sourced? Explain why. (2%)

(2.) A Korean national joined a corporation which is engaged in

the furniture manufacturing business. He was elected to the Board of
Directors. To complement its furniture manufacturing business, the
corporation also engaged in the logging business.

With the additional logging activity, can the Korean national still
be a member of the Board of Directors? Explain. (3%)

- VI -

Jojo deposited several cartons of goods with SN Warehouse

Corporation. The corresponding warehouse receipt was issued to the
order of Jojo. He endorsed the warehouse receipt to EJ who paid the
value of the goods deposited. Before EJ could withdraw the goods,
Melchor informed SN Warehouse Corporation that the goods
belonged to him and were taken by Jojo without his consent. Melchor
wants to get the goods, but EJ also wants to withdraw the same.
MERCANTILE LAW Page 5 of 10

a) Who has a better right to the goods? Why?

b) If SN Warehouse Corporation is uncertain as to who is

entitled to the property, what is the proper recourse of the
corporation? Explain.
(5%)

- VII -

(1.) Briefly discuss the doctrine of corporate opportunity. (2%)

(2.) Malyn, Schiera and Jaz are the directors of Patio

Investments, a close corporation formed to run the Patio Café, an al
fresco coffee shop in Makati City. In 2000, Patio Café began
experiencing financial reverses, consequently, some of the checks it
issued to its beverage distributors and employees bounced.

In October 2003, Schiera informed Malyn that she found a

location for a second café in Taguig City. Malyn objected because of
the dire financial condition of the corporation.

Sometime in April 2004, Malyn learned about Fort Patio Café

located in Taguig City and that its development was undertaken by a
new corporation known as Fort Patio, Inc., where both Schiera and
Jaz are directors. Malyn also found that Schiera and Jaz, on behalf
of Patio Investments, had obtained a loan of P500,000.00, from
PBCom Bank, for the purpose of opening Fort Patio Café. This loan
was secured by the assets of Patio Investments and personally
guaranteed by Schiera and Jaz.

Malyn then filed a corporate derivative action before the

Regional Trial Court of Makati City against Schiera and Jaz, alleging
that the two directors had breached their fiduciary duties by
misappropriating money and assets of Patio Investments in the
operation of Fort Patio Café.

a) Did Schiera and Jaz violate the principle of corporate

opportunity? Explain.

b) Was it proper for Malyn to file a derivative suit with a prayer

for injunctive relief? Explain.

c) Assuming that a derivative suit is proper, may the action

continue if the corporation is dissolved during the pendency of the
suit? Explain.
(5%)
MERCANTILE LAW Page 6 of 10

- VIII -

Aaron, a well-known architect, is suffering from financial

reverses. He has four creditors with a total claim of P26 Million.
Despite his intention to pay these obligations, his current assets are
insufficient to cover all of them. His creditors are about to sue him.
Consequently, he was constrained to file a petition for insolvency.

a) Since Aaron was merely forced by circumstances to petition

the court to declare him insolvent, can the judge properly treat the
petition as one for involuntary insolvency? Explain.

b) If Aaron is declared an insolvent by the court, what would be

the effect, if any, of such declaration on his creditors? Explain.

c) Assuming that Aaron has guarantors for his debts, are the
guarantors released from their obligations once Aaron is discharged
from his debts? Explain.

d) What remedies are available to the guarantors in case they

are made to pay the creditors? Explain.

(5%)

- IX -

(1.) What are the effects of an irrevocable designation of a

beneficiary under the Insurance Code? Explain. (2%)

(2.) Jacob obtained a life insurance policy for P1 Million

designating irrevocably Diwata, a friend, as his beneficiary. Jacob,
however, changed his mind and wants Yob and Jojo, his other
friends, to be included as beneficiaries considering that the proceeds
of the policy are sufficient for the three friends.

Can Jacob still add Yob and Jojo as his beneficiaries? Explain.
(2%)
MERCANTILE LAW Page 7 of 10

-X-

(1.) M/V Pearly Shells, a passenger and cargo vessel, was

insured for P40,000,000.00 against “constructive total loss.” Due to a
typhoon, it sank near Palawan. Luckily, there were no casualties,
only injured passengers. The shipowner sent a notice of
abandonment of his interest over the vessel to the insurance
company which then hired professionals to afloat the vessel for
P900,000.00. When re-floated, the vessel needed repairs estimated
at P2,000,000.00. The insurance company refused to pay the claim
of the shipowner, stating that there was “no constructive total loss.”

a) Was there “constructive total loss” to entitle the shipowner to

recover from the insurance company? Explain.

b) Was it proper for the shipowner to send a notice of

abandonment to the insurance company? Explain.

(5%)

(2.) a) When does double insurance exist? (2%)

b) What is the nature of the liability of the several insurers

in double insurance? Explain. (2%)

- XI -

Ricardo mortgaged his fishpond to AC Bank to secure a P1

Million loan. In a separate transaction, he opened a letter of credit
with the same bank for $500,000.00 in favor of HS Bank, a foreign
bank, to purchase outboard motors. Likewise, Ricardo executed a
Surety Agreement in favor of AC Bank.

The outboard motors arrived and were delivered to Ricardo, but

he was not able to pay the purchase price thereof.

a) Can AC Bank take possession of the outboard motors?

Why?

b) Can AC Bank also foreclose the mortgage over the

fishpond? Explain.

(5%)
MERCANTILE LAW Page 8 of 10

- XII -

Hi Yielding Corporation filed a complaint against five of its

officers for violation of Section 31 of the Corporation Code. The
corporation claimed that the said officers were guilty of advancing
their personal interests to the prejudice of the corporation, and that
they were grossly negligent in handling its affairs. Aside from
documents and contracts, the corporation also submitted in evidence
records of the officers’ U.S. Dollar deposits in several banks overseas
- Boston Bank, Bank of Switzerland, and Bank of New York.

For their part, the officers filed a criminal complaint against the
directors of Hi Yielding Corporation for violation of Republic Act No.
6426, otherwise known as the Foreign Currency Deposit Act of the
Philippines. The officers alleged that their bank deposits were
illegally disclosed for want of a court order, and that such deposits
were not even the subject of the case against them.

a) Will the complaint filed against the directors of Hi Yielding

Corporation prosper? Explain.

b) Was there a violation of the Secrecy of Bank Deposits Law

(Republic Act No. 1405)? Explain.

(5%)

- XIII -

(1.) Discuss the “kabit system” in land transportation and its

legal consequences. (2%)

(2.) Procopio purchased an Isuzu passenger jeepney from

Enteng, a holder of a certificate of public convenience for the
operation of public utility vehicle plying the Calamba-Los Baños route.
While Procopio continued offering the jeepney for public transport
services, he did not have the registration of the vehicle transferred in
his name. Neither did he secure for himself a certificate of public
convenience for its operation. Thus, per the records of the Land
Transportation Franchising and Regulatory Board, Enteng remained
its registered owner and operator. One day, while the jeepney was
traveling southbound, it collided with a ten-wheeler truck owned by
Emmanuel. The driver of the truck admitted responsibility for the
accident, explaining that the truck lost its brakes.
MERCANTILE LAW Page 9 of 10

Procopio sued Emmanuel for damages, but the latter moved to

dismiss the case on the ground that Procopio is not the real party in
interest since he is not the registered owner of the jeepney.

Resolve the motion with reasons. (3%)

(3.) Baldo is a driver of Yellow Cab Company under the

boundary system. While cruising along the South Expressway,
Baldo’s cab figured in a collision, killing his passenger, Pietro. The
heirs of Pietro sued Yellow Cab Company for damages, but the latter
refused to pay the heirs, insisting that it is not liable because Baldo is
not its employee.

Resolve with reasons. (2%)

- XIV -

(1.) On a clear weather, M/V Sundo, carrying insured cargo, left

the port of Manila bound for Cebu. While at sea, the vessel
encountered a strong typhoon forcing the captain to steer the vessel
to the nearest island where it stayed for seven days. The vessel ran
out of provisions for its passengers. Consequently, the vessel
proceeded to Leyte to replenish its supplies.

a) Assuming that the cargo was damaged because of such

deviation, who between the insurance company and the owner of the
cargo bears the loss? Explain.

b) Under what circumstances can a vessel properly proceed to

a port other than its port of destination? Explain.

(4%)

(2.) Star Shipping Lines accepted 100 cartons of sardines from

Master to be delivered to 555 Company in Manila. Only 88 cartons
were delivered, however, these were in bad condition.

555 Company claimed from Star Shipping Lines the value of

the missing goods, as well as the damaged goods. Star Shipping
Lines refused because the former failed to present a bill of lading.

Resolve with reasons the claim of 555 Company. (4%)

MERCANTILE LAW Page 10 of 10

- XV -

(1.) S Development Corporation sued Shangrila Corporation for

using the “S” logo and the tradename “Shangrila”. The former claims
that it was the first to register the logo and the tradename in the
Philippines and that it had been using the same in its restaurant
business.

Shangrila Corporation counters that it is an affiliate of an

international organization which has been using such logo and
tradename “Shangrila” for over 20 years.

However, Shangrila Corporation registered the tradename and

logo in the Philippines only after the suit was filed.

a) Which of the two corporations has a better right to use the

logo and the tradename? Explain.

b) How does the international affiliation of Shangrila

Corporation affect the outcome of the dispute? Explain.

(5%)

(2.) Cezar works in a car manufacturing company owned by

Joab. Cezar is quite innovative and loves to tinker with things. With
the materials and parts of the car, he was able to invent a gas-saving
device that will enable cars to consume less gas. Francis, a co-
worker, saw how Cezar created the device and likewise, came up
with a similar gadget, also using scrap materials and spare parts of
the company. Thereafter, Francis filed an application for registration
of his device with the Bureau of Patents. Eighteen months later,
Cezar filed his application for the registration of his device with the
Bureau of Patents.

a) Is the gas-saving device patentable? Explain.

b) Assuming that it is patentable, who is entitled to the patent?

What, if any, is the remedy of the losing party?

c) Supposing Joab got wind of the inventions of his employees

and also laid claim to the patents, asserting that Cezar and Francis
were using his materials and company time in making the devices,
will his claim prevail over those of his employees? Explain.

(5%)

NOTHING FOLLOWS.