Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
QED is registered owner of an item of l. Exhibits 1 1 & 13,U.S. Copyright Not controverted by declaration
l.
original artwork related to The Accuser Records; or other written evidence
Heronimus Dec. 15
QED is the registered owner of all right, 2. Exhibits 12 & 13,U.S. Copyright Not controverted by declaration
2.
. title,interest and copyright in certain Records; Heronimus Dec. 15 or other written evidence
animated webisodes of The Accuser
QED is the registered owner of all right, 3. Exhibit 11, U.S. Copyright Record; Not controverted by declaration
3.
title,interest and copyright in certain Heronimus Dec. 15 or other written evidence
animated webisodes of The Drifter
QED is the registered owner of an item 4. Exhibits 11 & 14,U.S. Copyright Not controverted by declaration
4.
of original artwork related to The Records; Heronimus Dec. 15 or other written evidence
Drifter
QED is the registered owner of all right, 5. Exhibit 15,U.S. Copyright Record; Not controverted by declaration
5.
title,interest and copyright in certain Heronimus Dec. 15 or other written evidence
animated webisodes of Stan's Evil
Clone
POW! is the registered owner of the 6. Exhibit 16,U.S.P.T.O. Record; Not controverted by declaration
6.
trademark STAN LEE PRESENTS Heronimus Dec. 15 or other written evidence
POW! is the registered owner of the 7. Exhibit 17,U.S.P.T.O. Record; Not controverted by declaration
7.
trademark EXCELSIOR! Heronimus Dec. 15 or other written evidence
Stan Lee Media, Inc. ("SLMI"), 8. SAC 124 Not controverted by declaration
8.
formerly known as Stan Lee or other written evidence
EXHIBIT
1
.
Entertainment,Inc. ("SLE"),was an
internet-based production and
marketing company co-founded by
Peter Paul and Stan Lee.
There is a purported agreement between 9. Exhibit 9 Opp. Defendants dispute its
9.
Stan Lee Entertainment,Inc. and Stan interpretation,whether it was
Lee with a printed date of October 15, terminated,and whether it is
1998 and a handwritten date of October void,but they are complete
20,1998 (Plaintiffs makes this strangers to the agreement.
statement for the fact of the existence of Additionally,Opp. Defendants
the document,and do not contend it is do not present any evidence in
valid or enforceable). the form of a declaration or other
written evidence to support their
contention.
10
Toward the end of 2000,SLMI failed to 10. SAC �� 45 - 46; Not controverted by declaration
pay Lee any salary,failed to pay for his Exhibit 19,Lee Dec. � 2; Exhibit 10, or other written evidence
life insurance,and failed to pay other Lieberman letter
benefits that were to be paid to Lee
pursuant to the SLE Agreement.
11
As such,on or about January 1,2001, 11. Exhibit 19,Lee Dec. � 2; Exhibit 10, Not controverted by declaration
Stan Lee,through his counsel, tendered Lieberman letter or other written evidence
a letter to SLMI terminating the SLE
Agreement because of these material
breaches as described in # 10 above.
Because of the material breaches,all 12. Exhibit 9,Employment Not controverted by declaration
12
Property and Rights described in the AgreementlRights Assignment or other written evidence
Employment Agreement with SLMI are
2
Stan Lee's.
On February 16, 2001, SLMI filed a 13. Exhibits 1 & 2, Bankruptcy Petitions; Not controverted by declaration
13.
Chapter 11 bankruptcy petition in the Heronimus Dec. "Il 2 or other written evidence
Central District of Califomia, Case No.
SVOI-I I329KL, jointly administered
with Case No. SVOI-II331KL,
(hereinafter the "Bankruptcy Case").
In November 2001, SLMI entered into 14. Exhibit 6, Asset Purchase Agreement; Not controverted by declaration
14.
an agreement ("Asset Purchase Exhibit 20, Kobayashi Dec. "Il 4 or other written evidence
Agreement") to transfer certain assets
of SLMI to a company controlled by
Stan Lee.
The Asset Purchase Agreement 15. Exhibit 6, Asset Purchase Agreement Not controverted by declaration
15.
approved by the Bankruptcy Court or other written evidence
refers to the transferee company as "a
California limited liability company to
be formed and controlled by Stan Lee."
The Asset Purchase Agreement 16. Exhibit 6, Asset Purchase Agreement Not controverted by declaration .
16.
addressed certain of the assets at issue or other written evidence
in this case, including The Accuser, The
Drifter, Stan's Evil Clone, STAN LEE
PRESENTS,STAN LEE'S
SOAPBOX, and Stan Lee & Design.
3
The November 27, 2001 Motion for 17. Exhibit 3, Motion to Approve Sale of Not controverted by declaration
17.
Order to Approve the Sale of Assets Assets; or other written evidence
Free and Clear of Liens specifically Heronimus Dec. � 2
represented to the Court, Stan Lee's
personal involvement in the assets at
issue in this Action was needed to
obtain the highest and best use for the
assets.
SLMI's Motion to Approve the Sale of 18. Exhibit 3, Motion to Approve Sale of Not controverted by declaration
18.
Assets stated the following: Assets; or other written evidence
Heronimus Dec. � 2
a. "[I]n order to exploit the Creative
Assets and generate funds for the
estates,it is crucial that Stan Lee be a
12art of such eX12loitation. The Debtors
believe that the Creative Assets have
minimal or no value without Stan Lee's
involvement." Motion, p. 3, 11. 7-
11(emphasis added).
- - -- ------
4
c. "The Debtors believe that the Not controverted by declaration
Agreement is in the best interest of the or other written evidence
estates in that the Agreement will result
in creating value out of the Creative
Assets, which value,the Debtors
believe, can only be created with the
direct involvement of Stan Lee."
Motion, p. 3, I. 27 - p. 4, I. 5.
Not controverted by declaration
d. "[T ]hrough discussions with such
or other written evidence
third parties,it was clear that . . . any
sale transaction must involve Stan Lee,
personally, and his creative abilities."
Motion,p. 10,I. 22 - p. 11,I.
2(emphasis added).
6
1. "From the outset of the Debtors' Not controverted by declaration
marketing efforts,it was abundantly or other written evidence
clear that without the active
involvement of Stan Lee, the Debtors
will not be able to exploit the value of
the Creative Assets or generate a
return." Motion,p. 21, ll. 5-9
(emphasis added).
Not controverted by declaration
J. "[Wlithout the involvement of
or other written evidence
Stan Lee,the Debtors believe that the
Creative Assets have virtually no
value." Motion, p. 29, 11. 13-15
(emphasis added).
At the hearing on the Motion to 19. Exhibit 4, Transcript of Proceedings Not controverted by declaration
19
Approve the Sale of Assets,Counsel for re Motion to Approve Sale of Assets; or other written evidence
the Creditors' Committee stated the Heronimus Dec. , 4
following:
a. "because this transaction is with
Stan Lee" Transcript of Proceeding re: Not controverted by declaration
Motion to Approve Sale of Assets, p. 4, or other written evidence
1. 5;
8
The critical factor in the transfer 20. Exhibits 3, Motion to Approve Sale Not controverted by declaration
20
approved by the Bankruptcy COUlt in of Assets; 4, Transcript of or other written evidence
SLMI's Bankruptcy Case was Stan Proceedings re Motion to Approve
Lee's personal and direct involvement Sale of Assets; & 5, Order Granting
in the development of the assets. Motion to Approve Sale of Assets
The Asset Purchase Agreement was 2l. Exhibit 5, Order Granting Motion to Not controverted by declaration
21
approved by Order of the Bankruptcy Approve Sale of Assets; or other written evidence
Court on April 11, 2002. Heronimus Dec. � 2
QED was formed and controlled by 22. Exhibit 8, Cert of Fonnation Not controverted by declaration
22
Stan Lee. or other written evidence
POW! and Stan Lee own his name, 23. Exhibits 6, Asset Purchase Not controverted by declaration
23
likeness, signature, persona and certain Agreement and 18, Membership or other written evidence
trademarks. Purchase and Employment
Agreement
SLMI assigned the titles and rights to 24. Exhibits 7, Assignment of Copyright; Not controverted by declaration
24
copyrights of The Drifter, The Accuser & 1 1 - 15, U.S. Copyright Records or other written evidence
and Stan's Evil Clone to QED.
Stan Lee chose to change the entity 25. Exhibit 19, Lee Dec �6 Not controverted by declaration
25
name from "SLC, LLC" to "QED" so or other written evidence
that the new entity would not be
associated with SLML
9
LlTiGATlON/056380 100211 566420.1
EXHIBIT 2
1 MCGUIRE WOODS LLP
DAVIDB. VAN ETTEN #119049
2 LESLIE M. WERLIN #67294
1800 Century Park East, 8 Floor
�
3 Los AngeleS California 90067
Telephone: 310) 315-8200
4 Facsllnile:'()flO) 315-8210
DVanetten@.mclnlirewoods.com
5 L_WerJm@mcl:mrrewoods.com
17 Defendants.
Date: January 5, 2009
18 Time: 1:30 pm
Ctroom: 6
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
EXHIBIT
DECLARATION OF DAVID B. GOLUBCHIK
CASE NO. 07-CV-OO225-SVW (SSx) 2
1 DECLARATION OF DAVID B. GOLUBCIDK
4 in the law firm Levene, Neale, Bender, Rankin & Brill L.L.P. in Los Angeles,
5 California. The facts set forth herein are based on my personal knowledge.
9 with Case No. SV-01-11331-KL ("theBankruptcy Case"). I was one of the attorneys
13 would utilize the active involvement of Stan Lee in order to exploit the value of the
14 Stan Lee created assets being transferred ("the Asset Purchase Agreement").
16 filed on behalf of SLMI a Motion for Order to Approve Sale of Assets Free and Clear
17 of Liens. The purpose of this motion was to obtain Court approval for the sale by
18 SLMI of certain creative assets, including the properties and characters known as The
19 Accuser, The Drifter and Stan's Evil Clone, which are the subject of the Complaint in
20 this case.
21 5. The primary focus of the transfer was that Stan Lee be involved. In fact,
22 as we stated in the Motion, "[I]n order to exploit the Creative Assets and generate
23 funds for the estates,it is crucial that Stan Lee be a part of such exploitation. The
24 Debtors believe that the Creative Assets have minimal or no value without Stan Lee's
25 involvement." The paramount factor was that the transferee entity be creatively
28 Agreement is in the best interest of the estates and that the Agreement will result in
2
DECLARATION OF DAVID B. GOLUBCHIK
r '" c:!'C MA 1)7 ro" nn..,.,.c; c:!"U1 (QC'v)
1 creating value out of the Creative Assets, which value, the Debtors believe, can only
2 be created with the direct involvement of Stan Lee." Thus, any sale transaction must
3 have involved Stan Lee personally as without the involvement of Stan Lee, the
5 7. I believe that the primary factor in the transfer was Stan Lee. In my
6 opinion, the name of the entity acquiring the properties was not important to the
8 8. I believe that it was of no import that SLC, LLC (the company originally
9 referred to in the Asset Purchase Agreement) did not acquire the Creative Assets, but
10 rather QED did. From the bankruptcy estate's perspective, the primary factor was
11 that Stan Lee controlled the entity and was involved with the exploitation of the
12 properties.
13 I declare under penalty of peIjury under the laws of the United States of
14 America that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 1 th day of December,
15 2008.
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
3
DECLARATION OF DAVID B. GOLUBCIDK
,.. It ct:: M('\ "7 ("''' n".,.,,, C"'lT I<.!<.!v'
EXHIBIT 3
1 DECLARATION OF GILL CHAMPION
2 I,
4 (" SLMI" ) , and am asserting certain derivative claims in this case on behalf of SLMI
6 55,000
10 working for another company formed to develop and exploit other Stan Lee-created
11 properties,
14 early 2001 , I was informed that some creditors of SLMI approached Stan Lee and
15 asked if Mr. Lee would take over some of the SLMI projects then in existence
16 because SLMI could not develop the projects without Stan Lee,
18 4. As of N ovember200 1 ,
20 between POW! and Stan Lee for Mr. Lee to be employed by POW! and its
21 subsidiaries,
23 logos,
24 and likeness. A true and correct copy of this agreement is attached· as Exhibit "3"
26 5. QED is a limited purpose company which has been used for the sole
27 purpose of exploiting assets obtained from SLMI pursuant to the Asset Purchase
28 Agreement approved by the court in the Bankruptcy Case. Paragraph 4(b) of the
�-....-"
..
K;\3903-]\PlE\OPPOSTlON TO MOT SUMM JUDG 082901.wpd 30
OPPOSITION TO MSJ EXHIBIT
3
1 Lee-POW! Employment Agreement attached as Exhibit "3 " hereto specifically
2 indicates that QED was formed to receive intellectual property from Stan Lee
3 M edia.
4 6. Shortly after we were informed that the Court in the Bankruptcy Case
5 approved the Asset Purchase Agreement and the Properties were turned over from
6 SLMI to QED, QED actively began attempting to develop and exploit many of the
7 assets. This effort began in 2002. Among other things, Stan Lee and I met with
8 writers and artists, pitched properties to numerous networks, production partners and
10 These efforts continued from 2002 after the approval in the Bankruptcy Case was
12 approval, we focused on developing the Properties and did not focus on the fact that
13 the Asset Purchase Agreement listed a transferee name of"SLC, LLC" instead of
15 7. POW! had a first look agreement with MGM during the period October
16 1,2001 through September 20,2002. After QED obtained the Properties, some of
17 the projects obtained by QED were submitted to MGM for its review in connection
19 Properties.
21 Licensing to develop certain of the Properties, including The Accuser and The
22 Drifter, beginning in February 2003. Attached as Exhibit "4" hereto is a true and
25 connection with the licensing and merchandising of The Accuser and The Drifter.
2 agreed on or about December 21,2004 to provide The Drifter and The Accuser
3 products as mobile phone clips and other mobile phone applications.
4 10. In addition, beginning in 2002, Stan Lee and I and others at QED under
5 my direction met with writers, pitched to networks and studios, and engaged in other
7 from SLMI. The following list reflects some of these meetings and efforts to
15 TRIBUNE-pass.
22 possible, TRIBUNE-pass.
24 DISN EY-pass.
10 secured.
17 conclusion.
20 USA-pass, TRIBUNE-pass.
21 11. In August 2005 , The Drifter and The Accuser were presented to David
25 SLMI intellectual properties for various reasons. These .included the negative
26 publicity associated with SLMI's bankruptcy case and from its association with Peter
27 Paul who "had fled to Brazil, the fact that the "internet bubble had burst," and the fact
28 that many of the Properties had already been distributed on the internet by SLMI.
:x1
:1:@::
!��¢:ih!��4:
,
��:��:��¥�'d.'" .... . .
.
. ' " ',
.M,.
2<1-
,�::'
[1
�$i.
,1"(
�� i
34
4 with writers, meetings with studios and negotiating in connection with the
7 approximately25% of my time.
8 14. I am not aware of any objection made by anyone involved with the
12 IS. QED continued its attempt to develop and exploit the Properties for the
13 benefit of SLMI and SLMI's creditors and shareholders until this lawsuit was filed.
15 the interests of SLMI's shareholders because the Defendants are wrongfully seeking
16 to undermine the asset transfer that all parties associated with SLMI's Bankruptcy
18 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California
19 and the United States of America that the foregoing is true and correct.
21
22
23
GILL CHAMPION
24
25
26
27
28
INTI/OOUCTlO,\,. Stan Lee has caused POW! to be fonued to: enter an agreement
with MGM relating to the development of ideas and other intellectual property created by
and/or under the supervision of Stan Lee, and to develop and capitalize on such
intellectual property. Stan Lee wishes to be employed by POW' and to agree upon the
tenus of his being so employed, and the ' tenus under which Gil Champion ("Champion")
and Arthur Liebemlan ("Liebemlan") will provide services to POW' in connection with
the development and capitalization of such intellectual property.
(d) The Uuvested Units issued to Champion and Liebenuan will be forfeited
to POW! if Champion or Liebemlan cease providing the services provided
in. their respeclive agreements with POW!. However, until any such
divestiture, they shan be entitled to receive all income and exercise all
rights as Members with 'respect to such Units.
(I) U pon issuarice of the foregoing Units, and assuming issuance of the
1,{lOO,OOO Units provided in e., the percentage ownership of POW! will be
"
..\ .
2. EMPLOlMEIVT 01" ST.4N LEE. Stan Lee will serve as Chairman and Chief
Creative Officer of POW!. Stan Lee will be based in Los Angeles, for a teml
commencing on the date hereof and tenuinating with his death [or 10 years if
sooner]. Stan Lees services shall be full-time and exclusive with the exception of
those services pro\�ded under a lifetime agreement with Marvel, which requires
no more than average of 10 - 15 hours per week on its behalf. All other services
perfomled. and intellectual property created for POW! or for any other entity,
which entity shall be approved in writing by POW!, shall inure to the benefit of
POWL Exempt income shall be autographs, book introductions, lectures, fees for
roles and any other honorarium type payments agreed to by the parties.
Stan Lee's services to POW! shall include, but not be limited to, the following;
(b) Act as Co-Executive Producer for all media productions, all fees generated
thereby shall belong to POW! with the exception of Conan and Red Sonja
- Producer fees.
(c) Apply his good faith, best efforts to enhance the brand and good will of
POW!, support and stimulate strategic alliances, joint ventures, sponsors,'
prodnction partners and all direct ..ld ancillary business of POW!.
(d) Serve as spokesman for POW! to all media and assemblies as reasonably
requested by POW!.
(e) Take all actions and' contribute all creative talents within Stan' Lee's
reasonable capability; pnrsuant to his good faith detemlination of his
schedule, as may reasonably be required to advance the interests of POW! .
.3, .5.4LARJe As ·compensation to him for all rights· and services contributed by
you and notwithstanding any disability, POW! shall provide ihe following compensation
.
for life:
(a) A base salary of$250,000 per annum and unless earlier financed
for at le.ast
first two years of POW!' exists and a balloon-payment of the
balance, without interest promptly thereafter.
2
EXHIBIT 3 PAGE \ \"V
(b) Stan Lee will receive prompt reimbursements for all ordinary and
necessary business expenses incurred by him on behalf of POW' in
the past and future,and POW! shall permit his customary first
class,travel with sedan limousine and stay in deluxe hotels. Past is
approximately �'beferred and to be paid after all expenses of
Lieberman, Champion, and Lee is $150.000 of deferred income
dollar for dollar with the deferred income of Liebemlan and
Champion.
4. ASSIGNMENT BY STAN LEE. In consideration for the foregoing Stan Lee agrees
as follows:
(a) To assign, convey and grant 'to POW' forever, all right, title and
iIiterest Stan Lee may have or control, now or in the future, in the
following: Any and all ideas: names, titles, characters, symbols,
logos. designs, likenesses. visual representations, artwork, stories,
plots, scripts, episodes, literary property, and the conceptual
universe related thereto,including my name and likeness (the
"Property") which will or have been in whole or part disclosed in
writing to, published, merchandise, advertised, andlor licensed by
POW!� its affiliates and successor in interests and licensees (which
by agreement inures to POW!'s benefit) or any of them and any
copyrig htS, tradem'arks, statutory rights,common law, goodwill.
nloralrights and any other rights :whatsoever in the Property in any
and all countries and in all media andlor fields, including all rights
to renewal or ext�nsiqns of copyright (the ·'Rights").
(b) Tb assign, convey and grant to POW! forever, all right title and
interest that Stan Lee may have in any income arising [rom the
'OVvnership of a Membership interest in QED Productions LLC
("QED:') or arising ftom the sale of the ownership of such
Membership Interest. . QEp',(o(1ifi'y \lthll(eptnp.'!.!iY§�fQf:ine�}is
f6nn-�li' to. ret"iv¢titeitlte1ledfua:/.priiperiy from St<iilLee Media,
sian Lee represents and wairants that he will not cal.l�e or pemli!
any ownership interest to be issued to any other party without the
consent of Managers of POW! other than Stan Lee.
3
EXHIBIT -3�PAGE \\':)_
' .
(b) Stan Lee agrees that during his employment for POW!. and for a
period of two years thereafter, he will not be employed by. or
provide consulting or other services, directly or indirectly, for any
entity which creates, develops or markets like Property, except foy; �UJ//
- ��
.
�
fulfilling Stan Lee's current agreement with Marvel Comics.
.
6. OPERA n,,'C ACREE1IE.'T. It is a condition to this agreement that Stan Lee,
����.
Liebemlan and Cha�lpion. each sign the Operating Agreement of POW!. The Operating
. Agreement \vill proVide. among other things, that:
(a) Stan Lee and Arthur Liebennan will be the two Managers of
POW'. The Managers orPOW! will make all decisions, including
whether to appoint additional Managers, by the consent or vote of
a majority ofPOW!'s Managers (or of both Managers at such time
as there are only two Managers; and
7. !ll!�·CELL.-L\"£OUS.
(a) This AgreemenL including the assigr1ffie nt set forth herein, shall be
binding upon the parties hereto, their affiliates and subsidiaries,
legal representatives, successors and predecessors in interest heirs
.
and assigns.
(d) All notices under this agreement shall be in writing and shall be sent
to the addresses Illst set forth above, or such other addresses of
which either party notifies the ot her from time. to time.
4
'-'
(e) Tills agreement constitutes U,e entire Agreement among the parties
with respect to the subject matter contained herein and supersedes
all prior agreements, understandings. oral or wriuen� with' respect
to the subject matter contained herein. This Agreement may not be
amended, modified or tenninated except in writing executed by
each of the parties hereto.
Sta�
.By. .
5
E)<HIB!1:3
· }
EXECUTED
Hollywood Licensing, LLC
15821 Ventura Blvd. Suite 110
Encino, CA 91436
Dear Gill:
The following constitutes the agreement (the·Agreemenqbetween you (QED Productions, lLC) and us (Hollywood
Licensing, LLC):
1. ENGAGEMENT: You hereby engage us as yOlJr non-exclusive representative,in connection with all matters
relating to the licensing and merchandising of your Properties:The Accuser, TheDrifter. We hereby accept such
engagement.
3. COMMISSIONS: I n consideration of our entering into this Agreement, and for other good and valuable
consideration, you hereby agree to pay us, as and when applicable gross income is received by you or on your
behalf from any negotiated licenses or agreements, (a)a commission.equal to 35 percent (35%)of allgross
income derived from all revenue generated byus during the term hereof and payable immediately upon of receipt of
any and all license fees; and (b) the same percentage commission of all gross income which you mayreceive or
earnfollowing the expiration of the term hereof in connection with any licenses which began during the term and all
extensions, modifications, renewars and substitutions theroo f
. (Le.in the event an agreement is
continues into the year{s)following the termination of this Agreement aUcommissions are due within 5 days
following the payment of such extensions.) The term -gross income-as used herein shall mean all monies received
by or for you andlor payable to you, wjthout deduction, from any license agreement originally negotiated by us.
Further,any repeat business generated originallybyus through a specific "'client'"during the term of this Agreement
shall be commissioned at the 35 percent ( 35%) fee regardless of whether the second or subsequent request comes
directly to you or us.
4. EXPENSES: You shall be required to pay your own costs for any duplication of materials or otherincidental
expenses whichmay occur related to the possible licensesor merchandising agreements.
5. AUTHORIZATIONS: (a) To collect and receive (during or after the term hereof)all checks and other to rms
of payment representing your gross income that is commtssionable by us hereunder, as well as endorse your name
upon and cash any and all such checks,and deduct and retain therefrom all commissions and expenses to which
we are entitled hereunder. However,if any gross income that is commissionable by us hereunder s I
directly by the third party payor toyour company,business manager or other representative,you will instructsuch
agent, business manager or other representative (as applicable) toimmediately upon receipt deduct from said
gross income and remit directly to us all commissions an�expenses to which we are entitled hereunder. Further,
QED Productions,LLC shall be the signing party on the Agreements generated by us and QED Productions,
shall �ave final approval over all Agreement terms.
6. INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR: This Agreement shall not be construed to create a partnership between you
and us. We are acting h
_ ereunder
7. DEFAULT: Due to the difficulty which you arid we may have in determining the amount of services to which
you may be entttled, we shall not be deemed to be n
i
written notice, by certified
fact:r�li.i(:ed to, render sL!ch serl.c.e hereuh�er� and-ifwe shall fh-ereaftef�have Jailed for.·a" -,penGO oh5 con-sec_otiVe:
blfsiii-ess days to con1mence:ren-ditlon ofthe ·p"i 1F11ctda( $elYlc�'.
,
,
-
'I · .
', c '
!-:
'4iil!ll!liOOi;li
i�A:{;Ibrii i'l,
.
. �j�({!1G,�