Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 10

Solid arguments against the Qur'an??

Arguments from teaching:

- Unlike Bible, Qur'an offers freedom-of-faith (10:108, 6:104, 10:99, 39:41,


11:121, 73:19, 43:88-89, 2:272, 76:29, 18:29, 42:48, 76:3, 3:20, 88:21-22),
freedom-of-religion (2:256, 109:6, 22:67-69, 42:15, 10:41, 2:139, 42:6), and
freedom-of-freethinking (15:3, 17:84, 6:110, 10:11, 11:121, 52:45). But I
don't like too much freedom, you know! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an strongly condemns female infanticide (16:58-59, 81:8-9, 6:137,


6:140, 6:151, 17:31). But I don't like it, as I'm a killer of my daughters!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an strongly opposes terrorists and oppressors (4:75, 22:39-40, 9:13-14,


42:39-43, 2:190-193). But I don't like it, as I'm a terrorist and oppressor!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an strongly condemns unjust killing and suicide (5:32, 2:195, 4:29-30,
4:92-93, 17:31, 17:33, 6:151, 25:68, 3:21). But I don't like it, as I'm a killer
and suicide bomber! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches self-defense and tolerance (60:7-9, 2:190, 6:107-8, 49:11,


39:3, 16:126-128, 73:10, 19:46-47). But I don't like it, as I'm an aggressor
and intolerant person! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches that Islam is for everyone (2:62, 22:17, 21:107, 2:111-112,
5:69, 34:28, 103:1-3, 22:67, 10:47, 35:24, 16:36, 68:52, 49:13, 4:1, 2:213,
10:19, 17:70). But I don't like it, as I'm a racist, nationalist, and communal
minded person! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches love, mercy, kindness, and forgiveness (1:1-2, 85:14,


21:107, 60:7, 4:17, 7:199, 39:53, 16:119, 3:159, 15:85, 16:119, 19:96, 2:160,
2:163, 4:27-28). But I don't like these kinds of teachings, although I don't
know why! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an gives equal status and rights to men and women (4:1, 4:7, 4:124,
3:195, 16:97, 33:35, 49:13, etc.). But I don't believe in equality! Therefore,
Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an strongly condemns priesthood and religious peddlers (2:41, 2:79,


5:44, 3:187, 9:9, 9:31, 9:34, 2:174, 12:104). But I don't like it, as I'm a
religious peddler! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an gives rights to orphans, needy, and widows (2:177, 2:115, 2:220,
2:240-41, 4:2, 4:8, 4:10, 4:36, 9:60, 17:26, 93:9-10, 89:17-18, 107:1-3). But
I don't like these kinds of poor and vulnerable people, you know! Therefore,
Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an strongly forbids eating up others' property (2:188, 4:10, 4:161). But
I don't like it, as I eat up others' property! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an strongly discourages intoxicants and gambling (5:90-91). But I


don't like it, as I'm a drunker and gambler! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches modesty for both men and women (7:26-28, 24:30-31,
33:59, 2:268). But I love nudity and Pornography, you know! Therefore,
Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an encourages men to give dower to women as free gift whom they
marry (4:4). But I don't like it, as I want to take dowry from women!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an protects women's dignity from wicked men (24:4). But I don't
believe in women's dignity, as I'm a rascal! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an prescribes hundred stripes as a symbol of punishment for adultery


and fornication to keep the society healthy (24:2). But I don't like it, as I'm
an adulterer and fornicator! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from
God.

- Qur'an teaches cutting off the hands of the thieves to keep the society
healthy, if they continue their crime without any repentance and amendment
(5:38-39). But I don't like it, as I lead my life on stealing and plundering
others' money and property! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from
God.

- Qur'an encourages people for seeking knowledge and asking question


(17:36, 39:9, 47:24, 25:33, 38:29, 17:85, 21:7, 2:215-220). But I don't like it,
as I'm an ignorant and don't even know how to ask logical question!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches not to ask those types of questions, which may cause you
trouble (5:101). But I don't like it, as I'm an idiot! Therefore, Qur'an cannot
be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches not to follow conjecture (10:36). But I don't like it, as I'm a
pseudo scientist! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches to ask for proof against unsubstantial claim (2:111, 6:143,
6:148, 10:36). But I don't like it, as I'm a blind believer! Therefore, Qur'an
cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an encourages traveling (29:20, 22:46, 6:11, 40:21, 47:10, 30:42,


3:137). But I don't like it, as I'm a frog in well! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be
the revelation from God.

- Qur'an condemns bad magic that may fool some gullible people (2:102).
But I use the same to earn some bucks! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches not to practice monasticism (57:27). But I like celibacy and
monasticism! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches that pre-Qur'anic people will be judged according to their


scriptures (2:134, 17:15, 5:44). But I heard that all the pre-Qur'anic people
will go to hell! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches to strive for good works (2:148). But I don't like it, as I'm
an evil minded person! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an offers practical Golden Rule that can be followed (2:44, 11:88,
41:34, 60:7-9, 61:2-3, 8:61; Sahih Bukhari 8:73:26, 1:2:12). But I don't like
it, as I'm an impractical person! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation
from God.

- Qur'an teaches to be kind, helpful, and respectful to your parents (29:8,


17:23, 46:15, 19:14, 6:151, 4:36, 2:215, 2:83, 71:28). But the Bible teaches
to hate your parents, wife, children, brothers, and sisters to become the
disciple of Jesus (Luke 14:26)! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation
from God.

- Qur'an protects religious temples (22:40). But I don't like religious temples
and I also want to destroy them! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation
from God.

- Qur'an ensures justice in this world and in the hereafter (4:135, 5:8, 4:58,
57:25, 39:69-70, 40:17, 21:47, 36:54, 2:281, 7:29, 16:111, 17:13-15, 20:134-
135). But I don't like justice, as I'm a criminal! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be
the revelation from God.

- Qur'an strongly teaches not to lie and not to mix up truth with falsehood
(45:7, 2:42, 52:11-12, 3:94, 3:71, 39:3). But I don't like it, as I'm a liar and
hypocrite! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an orders Muslim man to beat his innocent wife with hot iron rod
without any reason and without giving her any chance for amendment (4:34-
35). Oh, this sounds to me a barbaric teaching just like innocent widow and
witch burning, although I don't care to read the verse in context and whether
there is any other interpretation of this verse! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be
the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches to invite people to the Way of thy Lord with wisdom and
beautiful preaching; and to reason with them in ways that are best and most
gracious (16:125). But I don't like this kind of logical and rational approach,
you know! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches to argue with the People of the Book in the best way
(29:46). But I have no idea how I do that! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an advises Muslims not to take Jews and Christians as friends and
protectors (5:51). But I don't like it, no matter whether they are terrorist or
intolerant or hypocrite (5:57-61, 60:8-9). Because I love those kinds of
people, you know! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches that Jesus was a human (Acts 2:22; Qur'an 5:75, 25:20) and
a Prophet (Matthew 21:11, Luke 24:19; Qur'an 2:87). But I believe that he
was God or the begotten Son of God! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches not to believe in Trinity (Mark 12:29; Qur'an 4:171, 5:73),
as Jesus himself never preached this kind of absurd doctrine. But I believe in
three-in-one God, you know; although I do not believe in five-in-one God!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches not to believe in Original Sin (Ezekiel 18:20; Qur'an 17:15,
6:164), as Jesus himself never preached this kind of irrational doctrine. But I
believe that I was born with sin! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation
from God.

- Qur'an teaches in various ways to free the slaves that come into possession
as a result of war (90:12-13, 9:60, 5:89, 2:177, 4:3, 4:25, 4:92, 24:33, 58:3,
8:67, 47:4). But I love slavery! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation
from God.

- Qur'an allows man to have sex with slave girls (23:6), if he wishes and of
course not by force (24:33), that he holds temporarily for their protection.
Although I know that it's not any sort of fundamental teaching of Islam yet I
feel that it's immoral to have sex with slave girls, although I don't have any
'yardstick' to measure 'morality' and 'immorality' in the first place! I also
know that I randomly have sex with girls and sometimes even go to pros-
quarters! I just argue for the sake of argument to make Islam look bad, you
know! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an forbids marrying one's mother, daughters, sisters, and many other
close relatives (4:22-23). But I don't like this kind of limitations, you know,
as I'm an insane! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- The suicide bombers of 9-11 event killed more than 3000 innocent people.
They (suicide bombers) are true Muslims. Although dozens of American
Scholars and Professors have rejected the 9-11 commission report based on
many facts and logics yet I never had any doubt about it in my mind! Such a
robot I am, you know! I also never bothered to know that the Qur'an has
strongly condemned killing and suicide (5:32, 4:29-30, 4:92-93, 17:33,
25:68, 3:21, 2:195)! What an ignorant chap I am, you see! Therefore, Qur'an
cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an threats to punish criminal and evil minded kafirs in the hereafter
(47:32, 38:28, 16:88, 47:1, 2:23-24). But I don't like it, as I'm a criminal and
I also love those kinds of people! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation
from God.

- Qur'an teaches to follow the middle and straight path (17:29, 2:143, 23:62,
4:171, 17:9). But I don't like it, as I'm an extremist! Therefore, Qur'an cannot
be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an teaches to believe in the unseen God (2:3, 112:1-4, 67:12, 36:11,
42:51). But I'm a 'logical' person, and as such I can't believe in anything
without seeing with my naked eyes! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Qur'an invites people from the depth of Darkness into Light (14:1, 57:9).
But I prefer Darkness! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Qur'an promises eternal peace and salvation in the hereafter (85:11, 4:122,
14:23, 19:60-61, 32:19, 2:25, 2:112, 16:97, 4:124). But I don't like peace and
salvation, as I don't believe in the life after death in the first place!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

Arguments from the Hadith:

- According to Hadith (not sure whether it's true or not), Muhammad had no
idea where the sun goes at night! LOL! Isn't funny, although I don't know
the difference between Muhammad (Hadith) and God (Qur'an) in the first
place! I never studied the Qur'an to know about this very important fact
either! I probably think from some other religious viewpoint, you know!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- According to Hadith (not sure whether it's true or not), Muhammad had
more than a dozen wives during his lifetime; although I know that all of
them but Khadija came to his house at the end of his life, all of them but
Ayesha were widows, and most of them were forty plus. Therefore, Qur'an
cannot be the revelation from God.
- According to Hadith (not sure whether it's true or not), Muhammad married
Ayesha when she was 9 years old. Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation
from God.

- I can go on and on, you know!

Arguments from the Bible:

- Christian priests in the past have tortured and burned alive some scientists
whose discoveries went directly against their established beliefs that were
based on the Bible. Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- According to Judio-Christian tradition, the earth is only six thousand years


old. But according to established science, the earth is about five billion years
old. Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- I can go on and on, you know!

Arguments from logic:

- Argument from flat earth: Qur'an says, "God hath appointed the earth as a
bed for you (20:53)". Therefore, Qur'an thought that the earth is flat! LOL!
But wait a moment! Although the earth appears to be 'circular' in shape but
my bed is 'rectangular'! So, Qur'an didn't intend to compare the 'shape of the
earth' with the 'shape of my bed' in the first place! Anti-LOL! Therefore,
Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God. Otherwise I will be proven
wrong, unless I have already made a 'circular bed' in my room secretly!
Moreover, I have never read the verse 84:3-4 that talks about the Last Day,
"And when the earth is flattened out and casts forth what is in it and
becomes empty." So, if the earth is already flat, then how would it be
flattened out again and becomes empty? LOL! What a logical person I am,
you see!

- When Qur'an says "Heavens and earth were joined together and We clove
them asunder", it may indicates anything but the concept of Big-Bang.
Because it was plagiarized from pagan belief, as Ali Sinner rightly said. But
when Qur'an says "God hath appointed the earth as a bed for you, God hath
made the earth a wide expanse for you, God hath made for you the earth like
a carpet spread out", it must indicate the flat-shape of the earth, although I
don't bother whether it talks about the 'shape' of the earth in the first place! It
cannot have any other interpretation. Period. Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Other ancient holy books have been proven to be unscientific. Qur'an is an


ancient holy book. Therefore, Qur'an must also be unscientific. I don't bother
what Muslim scholars say about the Qur'an; although I care what Christian
scholars say about the Bible, what Hindu scholars say about their scriptures,
what Darwinists say about evolution theory, what Physicists say about
physics, what Chemists say about chemistry, what Scientists say about
science, and so on. Because Muslim scholars are all dishonest and liar! They
can't be trusted you know, although I have profound faith on Ali Sinner and
Evangelist Christians on this subject!

- I never wrote a book myself and gave full credit to an imaginary deity. Yet
I believe that Muhammad wrote a Book (Qur'an, the only Book) and gave
full credit to an imaginary God! Because he was a liar! Or he was deceived
by Satan! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God. It could be
the revelation from Satan though, as Salman RushDie said.

- America is a rich and technologically developed nation. Majority of


Americans are Christians, although I know for sure that they do not follow
the true teachings of the Bible; otherwise America would have been a real
hell long ago! On the other hand, Afghanistan is a poor and technologically
backward nation. Majority of Afghanis are Muslims, although I know for
sure that they do not follow the true teachings of the Qur'an. Therefore,
Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Christian Missionaries repeatedly say that Islam is false (like Goebbels's


theory), as they are aware of the vitality of Islam! Therefore, Qur'an cannot
be the revelation from God.

- Argument from Ali Sinner: Ali Sinner claims to be ex-Muzlim who left
Izlam. He has been attacking Muhammad and Muslims like a rabid dog from
his rat-hole since 9-11 drama. Many non-Muslims believe that he is a
nightmare of Islam and Muslims, although they have never seen him! He has
also been employed to eradicate Islam and Muslims from the face of the
earth within a span of 25 years. Although, unlike Hirsi Ali, he is a coward;
yet he repeatedly says from his rat-hole that Islam is false, the way he has
been taught. Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.
- Unlike other religious books, Qur'an offers falsification test and challenge
for the skeptics (4:82, 17:88, 2:23-24, 10:37). But I don't think this kind of
logical approach can be offered in an ancient holy book, and I don't like
mental gymnastics either! I would rather believe in the words of my idols
like Ali Sinner and Christian Missionaries! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God.

- Unlike other religious books, Qur'an very emphatically and probably


uniquely claims to be the revelation from the Lord of the Worlds (4:82,
17:88, 2:23-24, 10:37, 32.2, 26.192-4, 16.102, 2:2, etc.). But I can't believe
in this kind of BOLD claim, you know! I would rather believe in a book as
the word of God that doesn't claim to be so in the first place! Therefore,
Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Unlike other religious books, Qur'an offers various logics for the
unbelievers of Creator (22:5, 75:36-40, 22:73, 23:91, 2:28, 17:99, 19:66-67,
21:22, 29:46, 6:99). But it's too heavy for me to shallow, you know!
Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

Special arguments from Atheists:

- Scientists can explain how a watch was manufactured and how it works.
They do not require any 'data' of the maker of the watch to explain all these.
Therefore, the maker of the watch doesn't (?) exist! Similarly, scientists can
(hypothetically) explain how the natural universe came into existence and
how it works. It's then obvious that the Maker of the universe doesn't (?)
exist! Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the revelation from God.

- Oxford Prof. Richard Dawkins is a very logical, rational, and intelligent


man. He says that God doesn't exist. Therefore, Qur'an cannot be the
revelation from God. How could it be in the first place when God Himself
told an Oxford Professor that He doesn't exist? Does it make any sense?

I can go on and on, you know! Yet some people not only believe in God but
also believe in a book as the revelation from God! You see, how deluded
they are! They also believe that this temporal world is a test for the hereafter
(18:7, 67:2, 2:155, 2:214), and each and every individual will be judged
perfectly according to his/her own deeds and actions including Prophet
Muhammad (11:35, 46:9, 36:54, 4:85, 40:17, 21:47, 36:54, 2:281, 7:29,
16:111, 17:13-15, 20:134-135). They even believe that people like Hitler,
Stalin, Pol Pot, Mao, Bush, Saddam, Modi, and all those terrorists, rapists,
killers, and suicide bombers must be judged and punished according to their
own deeds and actions! And these kinds of teachings come from their
ancient Holy Book! Oh my Gosh! You see, how backdated, barbaric,
merciless, and tribal minded people they are! Not only that, they are also
ignorant about Modern Science and Technology, you know! Look at
Afghanistan, for example, and see the truth yourself with your naked eyes
what I'm talking about. Solid evidence, man!

Assalaamu manit taba’al huda (May peace, development and safety from
guile be upon who follow the guidance).

Assalaamu'alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakaatuh (May peace,


development and safety from guile and Allah’s mercy and His blessings be
upon thee).

Centres d'intérêt liés