Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Haley Source: American Journal of Archaeology, Vol. 32, No. 2 (Apr. - Jun., 1928), pp. 141-145 Published by: Archaeological Institute of America Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/497578 . Accessed: 01/07/2013 14:38
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Archaeological Institute of America is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to American Journal of Archaeology.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 134.100.17.1 on Mon, 1 Jul 2013 14:38:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
This content downloaded from 134.100.17.1 on Mon, 1 Jul 2013 14:38:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
142
Ionia. Not only is Parnassos shown by root and suffix to be related to place-names in Asia Minor, but the name actually occurs there. However, for the sake of clearness and to avoid confusion, each name is classified under only one group. If the name occurs in Asia Minor it is classified under Group A. Names that are shown by both root and suffix to be connected with Asia Minor are put in Group B, since I regard the suffixes as affording clearer and more satisfactory evidence than the roots. In Group C, therefore, are left those names which are shown only by their roots to be related to place-names in Asia Minor. The existence of a series of place-names in Greece that is identical with a series in Asia Minor clearly indicates, it seems to me, that one is original and the other transferred. Coincidence is out of the question for such a large number of names as those contained in Group A. And the evidence shows, in my opinion, that the transfer was from Asia Minor to Greece rather than that the converse was true. For the number of these names is so large relatively to the Greek names that the Greeks certainly carried to Asia Minor as to make it improbable that these two groups belong together. Furthermore, the geographical distribution of these names in Asia Minor makes it seem improbable that they were brought over by the Greeks. Certainly it is not likely that places so far inland as Hermos, Kadmos, and Skiritis owe their names to Greek influence, to say nothing of Parnassos, which is in the very heart of Asia Minor. When we come to consider Group B the case is even clearer. It is conceivable that whole names might have been transferred from Greece to Asia Minor, but suffixes are out of the question, in view of the fact that these suffixes occur in names that are widely distributed in Asia Minor but are utterly foreign to Greece and to Greek. Kretschmer, Einleitung in die Geschichteder griechischen Sprache, has argued convincingly for the non-Greek character of the two suffixes -nth- (the identity of which with the -nd- suffix in Asia Minor he establishes) and -s(s)- in place-names in Greece. He admits that the first of these suffixes occurs in some words, and the second in a great many that are Greek. The fact, however, that both of these suffixes occur with great frequency in Asia Minor, and that in Greece they occur attached to a great number of place-names the roots of which obviously are not Greek, leads him to think that these placenames originated in Asia Minor. In the case of the -nth- this explains why a suffix which has such a meager existence in Greek apart from place-names occurs with such frequency in them. The suffixes -1-, -m-, -mn-, -n-, -r- and -t- I have included in Group B. I do not mean to imply that such suffixes are always non-Greek and that any place-name with any one of them is without further
This content downloaded from 134.100.17.1 on Mon, 1 Jul 2013 14:38:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
143
ado to be called Anatolian. What I am suggesting is that Kretschmer's arguments for the suffixes -nth- and -s(s)- are applicable to these suffixes also. It is needless to cite examples of these suffixes in Greek words. They all admittedly occur in numerous Greek words. But it may be worth while to cite a few examples of their occurrence in placenames in Asia Minor: -1-: Tmolos, Mykale, Karmalas, Kinolis, Phaselis; -m-: Idyma, Olymos, Sasima, Sidyma, Hyromos; -mn-: Kremna, Larymna, Ordymnos, Methymna, Kalymna; -n-: Adana, Amanos, Dardanos, Lagina, Halasarna, Kyrnos; -r-: Balbura, Gargara, Isaura, Karura, Patara; -t-: Kozanata, Sindata, Othatatis. Since, then, these suffixes occur frequently in Asia Minor, and since place-names with non-Greek roots occur in Greece with these same suffixes, I regard such names as derived from Asia Minor and include them in Group B, though without the underscoring which distinguishes names in -nth- and -s(s). Of the three groups the names in Group C afford the least satisfactory evidence for a connection with Asia Minor. The assumption of identity of roots is bound to be precarious when we are dealing with words in a language about which we know so little as we do about the language of Asia Minor. And since the meaning of the words is not known, we are forced to rely on similarities of sound and spelling, which are no doubt deceptive in some cases. Thus the independent evidence which Group C furnishes is rather weak. It is strengthened, however, by the fact that the distribution of Group C on the map is essentially the same as that of Groups A and B. This would seem to increase the likelihood that in most of the cases the assumption of relationship with names in Asia Minor is correct. The following tables give the names in each of the three groups, alphabetically arranged: GRouP A "AIac MvKaX7w6's KeMvlbpts
r "Aaaos "Eppo. eO)aLL
KopoTo'bs
Aalpw'a A&pvuza
e0pa
'Iap avos
KAcos
AIlov8
AbK auros
Mayvlia Mipyla'aa
Ilyaauos
b~.os S XKetpir T &ppa TEpjqaa6s
Kapla KarraXia
MiXaros
This content downloaded from 134.100.17.1 on Mon, 1 Jul 2013 14:38:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
144
GROUP B
-nth'ApaHpvvpos 'ApaKvv os ' E pb2avOo; BepEKvvoS KIpwtdos
IIappi'tot
HpaLtros lpaotos H
KahvravoP
Ki"POS AE pva
va MEzhd MvKa^vat
2
aplvPtov
LKLVOS
2OVUtLO'
-1'Ao&Ta'X
KapbapalyX
Kl w4Xor
T evLp'vPl Ti Pvo
'TaXwtvov
?aXahuapPa
ZaKVPV0O
MaXXa
Kav&q 2H -r-
'A/.wvtoA 'Ap877Tr6
BivKaoOs Bpeo BptX77rTr6o'
-mObtaos
Ora t
'Etwiavpos "E~pvpa
'IKapla
KvKc7.pc
Fapy'7y1rs 'IXto-6s Kapvtov Kepf KEp77tbs K?7776, Kvwoos Kopltia Aaplrtov Aapartov
AvKaf3r?77Trs
KiK pa Korlpa
II apos II
2-1
-mnAtLKVbla
VipoS
Thyvpa
Mavubs
MvKaXnrlu6s
Ncaor
'OpEUodo'ltot IIa'yauat HotKtXa6abs
Bitpva
BeXIua B'r2 Feprlvia
ibpptra
T aby(erov
This content downloaded from 134.100.17.1 on Mon, 1 Jul 2013 14:38:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
145
GRouP C
'A13la AMiXaa IIplavaov
AElV
I6iv8o0
'Toaal
The following tables contain the rest of the pre-Greek place-names in Greece not included on the map. Group D consists of names that may be related to names in Asia Minor, but which were so uncertain that I did not feel justified in putting them on the map. A -th- and an -En- suffix occur several times each, but I have not been able to establish their connection with Asia Minor. And finally, Group E, the residuum, is a heterogeneous group of pre-Greek place-names for the origins and relationships of which the evidence seems to be lacking. They may or may not be related to place-names in Asia Minor. At any rate I have been unable to find any specific indication of such connection. GROUPD
A1Z6lbos
'A/.bKXat KAvLdos
-thKLKV
W rndos
'Tpeddttov
Oiotrl
"IKOS
A6'
Maao-aX l
rabos
Fbp7Uvs Fbprvv
AKT',
'Io'rphv Kows
Mtbea MtP&6a
Kivatov
A 80wv
Nicata
Pa^KoS
Alp(pvs
Zapa 'Hernv'ela
Aadr
Aff os
,KhVaWta
lovXla T apaypa 'QpobS J. B. HALEY
'H7r,
RANDOLPH-MACON COLLEGE
Al7Xavroiv AlbpKELO
This content downloaded from 134.100.17.1 on Mon, 1 Jul 2013 14:38:22 PM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions