THE CITY OF NEW YORK GARY p- SHAFFER

phone: 212-676-2740
MICHAEL A. CARDOZO LAW DEPARTMENT fax:212-788-0367
Corporation Counsel 100 CHURCH gshaffer@law.nyc.gov
NEW YORK, NY 10007

April 19, 2004

BY HAND

Sam Caspersen, Esq.

The National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States
26 Federal Plaza
Suite 13-100
New York, NY 10007

Re: Document Production - City of New York

Dear Mr. Caspersen,

Enclosed please find a videotape taken by N.J. Burkett of WABC-TV on September 11,
2001. Commissioner Frank Gribbon mentioned the existence of this footage during his interview
with NIST and the Commission. As we have discussed, the Fire Department has not received
permission to release this tape to the Commission or for the Commission to use it for any
purpose. However, you have indicated you will make an independent attempt to obtain such
permission and we therefore are providing the tape in an effort to assist the Commission in its
work.

Gary Shaffe^
Assistant Corporation Counsel
 Wooozo

THE CITY OF NEW YORK

MICHAEL A. CARDOZO
DEPARTMENT
J-Fttl' A±t 1 IVIUdM
Corporation Counsel 100 CHURCH STREET KENNETH A. BECKER
NEW YORK, N.Y. 10007-2601 phone: (212) 78g.05]4

Fax:(212)788-0367
kbecker@law.nyc.gov

December 3, 2003

BY HAND

Daniel Marcus, Esq.

General Counsel
National Commission on Terrorist
Attacks Upon the United States
26 Federal Plaza, Suite 13-100
New York, N.Y. 10007

Re: Response to 9-11 Commission Subpoena

Dear Mr. Marcus:

Attached hereto are copies of summaries of interviews conducted by McKinsey &

Co. in preparation of its report for the New York City Fire Department. This submission is in
partial response to the subpoena served on the City by the Commission on November 24, 2003,
requesting, inter alia, records of all interviews conducted in connection with any report, study,
evaluation, critique, summary, review, or historical project relating to the New York City Fire
Department's response to the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center, from September 11,
2001 through September 20, 2001. These interview summaries are provided in their entirety,
without any redactions. They are provided subject to the provisions of the Agreement between
the City of New York and the Commission dated December 3, 2003.

If you have any questions, please feel free to call me.

Very truly yours,

Kenneth A. Becker

www.nyc.gov
Daniel Marcus, Esq.
December 3, 2003
Page 2

cc: John Farmer, Esq.

Joseph Verdon, Esq.

Enc: McKinsey Interview Summaries

 tOV ooo t z.

THE CITY OF NEW YORK

MICHAEL A. CARDOZO LAW DEPARTMENT GARY P. SHAFFER
Corporation Counsel \0 CHURCH phone: 212-676-2740
NEW YORK, NY 10007 fax: 212-788-0367
gshaffer@law.nyc.gov

October 15, 2003

BY HAND

Daniel Marcus, Esq.

John Farmer, Esq.
The National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States
26 Federal Plaza
Suite 13-100
New York, NY 10007

Re: Document Request No. 1 - City of New York

Gentlemen,

In response to the Commission's Document Request No. 1, we are today

providing you with documents, with their contents described further below, provided by the New
York City Department of Health. We will continue to provide additional materials as they
become available. To the extent we have concerns about providing particular items, we will
contact you so such issues can be discussed.

SPECIFIC REQUESTS AND RESPONSES

D. Department of Health Request

16. The following documents, records or raw data pertaining to DOH's response to the 9/11
Attacks: (i) radio communication tapes and transcripts for DOH communications on September
11, 2001; (ii) operational logs for 9/11-9/20, (iii) dispatch records for 9/11-9/20, (iv) internal
and external video footage of the DOH's response from 9/11-9/20 to the 9/11 Attacks, and (v)
staffing and unit location charts for 9/11-9/20.

Response: The following are Department of Health World Trade Center Disaster
Response Daily Summaries in response to the above request:

1. DOH World Trade Center Disaster Response Daily Summaries

• 9/12/01 summary.
• 9/13/01 summary.
• 9/14/01 summary.
• 9/15/01 summary.
• 9/17/01 summary.
• 9/18/01 summary.
• 9/19/01 summary.
• 9/20/01 summary.

Efforts to evaluate these requests and seek responsive materials are continuing and
suiipplemental responses will be supplied.

Very-mily yours,

jary Shaffer
Assistant Corporation Counsel
 THE CITY OF NEW YORK
MICHAEL A. CARDOZO LAW DEPARTMENT GARY P. SHAFFER
Corporation Counsel 100 CHURCH phone: 212-676-2740
NEW YORK, NY 10007 fax: 212-788-0367
gshaffer@law.nyc.gov

October 7, 2003

BY HAND

Daniel Marcus, Esq.

John Farmer, Esq.
The National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States
26 Federal Plaza
Suite 13-100
New York, NY 10007

Re: Document Request No. 1 - City of New York

Gentlemen,

In response to the Commission's Document Request No. 1, we are today

providing you with documents, with their contents described further below, provided by the New
York City Office of Emergency Management. We will continue to provide additional materials
as they become available. To the extent we have concerns about providing particular items, we
will contact you so such issues can be discussed.

SPECIFIC REQUESTS AND RESPONSES

C. Office of Emergency Management Request

14. All after-action reports, summaries, evaluations, reviews, critiques and studies of the
OEM's response from 9/11-9/20 to the 9/11 Attacks, conducted either internally by
OEM or by any external entity.
 Response: The following are Office of Emergency Management Situation
Reports in response to the above request:

1. OEM Situation Reports

• 9/18/01 report prepared at 6:00 A.M.
• 9/18/01 report prepared at 5 :52 P.M.
• 9/19/01 report prepared at 6:16 A.M.
• 9/19/01 report prepared at 5:49 P.M.
• 9/20/01 report prepared at 5:55 A.M.
• 9/20/01 report prepared at 12:52 P.M.

Efforts to evaluate these requests and seek responsive materials are continuing and
supplemental responses will be supplied.

Very/$uly yours,

"* ^x
'Gary Shaffer T
Assistant Corporation Counsel
 NY 08 of 24

Document
Request /
j Date Logged 1 Date of Item Type ltem# Doc# From To Subject

05/28/04 08/20/03 NY 1
00001 Shaffer, Gary Marcus, Dan Response to Document Request No. 1
r
CD containing documents from the New York City Fire Department and
05/28/04 NY 1 00002 EMS

05/28/04 09/26/03 NY 1 00003 Shaffer, Gary Marcus, Dan Response to Document Request No. 1

05/28/04 NY 1 00004 CD : FDNY / External Materials, interviews provided by hand on 9/26/03

05/28/04 08/26/03 NY 1 00005 Shaffer, Gary Marcus, Dan Response to Document Request No. 1

05/28/04 NY 1 000006A FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #1 TRT: 04:10 Part 1 of 2

05/28/04 NY 1 00006B FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #1 TRT: 04:10 Part 2 of 2 j

05/28/04 NY 00007A FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #2 TRT: 03:05 Part 1 of 2

05/28/04 NY 00007B FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #2 TRT: 03:05 Part 2 of 2
~t

05/28/04 NY 00008A FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #3 TRT: 05:45 Part 1 of 2
 NY 08 of 24

• •

05/28/04 NY 00008B FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #3 TRT: 05:45 Part 2 of 2

05/28/04 NY 00009A FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #4TRT: 05:45 Part 1 of 2
|

05/28/04 NY 00009B FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #4 TRT: 05:45 Part 2 of 2

05/28/04 NY 000 10A FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #5 TRT: 3:10 Part 1 of 2

05/28/04 NY 0001 OB FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #5 TRT: 3: 1 0 Part 2 of 2

05/28/04 NY 0001 1A FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #6 TRT: 04:20 Part 2 of 2

05/28/04 NY 0001 18 FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #6 TRT: 04:20 Part 2 of 2

05/28/04 NY 0001 2A FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #7 TRT: 03:51 Part 1 of 3

05/28/04 NY 0001 2B FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #7 TRT: 03:51 Part 2 of 3

05/28/04 NY 0001 2C FDNY WTC raw footage archives Tape #7 TRT: 03:51 Part 3 of 3

05/28/04 NY 00013 Shaffer, Gary Marcus, Dan Response to Document Request No. 1
 NY 08 of 24

New York City Mayor's OEM/Emergency Operations Center Situation

05/28/04 NY 00014 Report #13

New York City Mayor's OEM/Emergency Operations Center Situation

05/28/04 NY 00015 Report #14

New York City Mayor's OEM/Emergency Operations Center Situation

05/28/04 NY 00016 Report #15

New York City Mayor's OEM/Emergency Operations Center Situation

05/28/04 NY 00017 Report #16

!
New York City Mayor's OEM/Emergency Operations Center Situation
j 05/28/04 NY 00018 Report #17

New York City Mayor's OEM/Emergency Operations Center Situation

05/28/04 NY 00019 Report #18

Becker,
05/28/04 12/03/03 NY 00020 Kenneth Marcus, Dan Response to 9-1 1 Commission Subpoena

05/28/04 NY 00021 McKinsey Interview Summaries

Marcus, Dan
05/28/04 10/15/03 NY 00022 Shaffer, Gary Farmer, John Response to Document Request No. 1

World Trade Center Disaster New York City Department of Health -

05/28/04 NY 00023 Clinical Response Team (summary of events) dated 9/12/01

World Trade Center Disaster Response New York City Department of

05/28/04 NY 00024 Health dated 9/13/01
 NY 08 of 24

World Trade Center Disaster Response New York City Department of

05/28/04 NY 00025 Health dated 9/14/01

World Trade Center Disaster Response New York City Department of

05/28/04 NY 00026 Health dated 9/1 5/01

World Trade Center Disaster Response New York City Department of

05/28/04 NY 00027 Health dated 9/1 7/01

j
World Trade Center Disaster Response New York City Department of
05/28/04 NY 00028 Health dated 9/1 8/01

World Trade Center Disaster Response New York City Department of

05/28/04 NY 00029 Health dated 9/1 9/01

World Trade Center Disaster Response New York City Department of

05/28/04 NY 00030 Health dated 9/20/01

05/28/04 04/01/04 NY 00031 Shaffer, Gary Marcus, Dan Transmittal Letter

05/28/04 NY 00032 CD : Location Grid & Log of WTC victims

05/28/04 04/19/04 NY 00033 Shaffer, Gary Marcus, Dan Transmittal Letter

05/28/04 NY 00034 Videotape taken by NJ Burkett of WABC-TV