Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
9
producers and small power producers and of the 1. Central
1
4. Noroeste
producer and power self-supplier. Also, the 5. Norte
6. Noreste
electricity network is owned by CFE and 7.
8.
Baja California
Baja California Sur
consequently this utility is the only seller of 9. Peninsular
RAS
PIED
s) -
(Te xa 0M W
ASS MW O 8
LE P ) 10 0 RED
EAG (VFT O LA
UEV
III. CURRENT PROCEDURES AND CFE-
LAR
AEP
EDO
(Te xa s) - N
– F AL
CO N 30MW
e xa s) tB) 15
0M W
ON (T AND (B
METHODOLOGIES FOR TRANSMISSION F ALC ARYL
CFE-SH 120M W
(Texa s)-MATAMOROS
BROWNSVILLE
MANAGEMENT AND EXPANSION PLANNING
The CFE is the electric utility in Mexico responsible for the
public supply of electricity, which includes power system
planning, power generation for public service, and SIMBOLOGÍA
400 KV
process, which in turn defines fuel policies and diversification CFE-GUATEMALA 200MW
strategies to coordinate the execution of alternative projects, Fig. 2. Comision Federal de Electricidad Existing International Cross-Border
such as hydroelectric, geothermal, wind and nuclear power Interconnections.
plants.
Under this process, investments programs are subject to the The main objective in the planning process is to determine
government budget process, which considers economic goals, an optimal expansion plan that meets future electricity demand
financial resources and retail electric rate policies. The and minimizes the investment, operation and loss of load costs,
Mexican government manages the energy sector, including providing adequate levels of reliability and quality under
electricity, through the Secretaria de Energia (SE) and the environmental, financial and energy regulations.
Comision Reguladora de Energia (CRE). Due to the complexity, the problem is solved by
The administration of the national grid is carried out by decomposition in time (long, mid and short term time frames)
CFE through the Centro Nacional de Control de Energia and by geographical hierarchy (generation, bulk transmission,
(CENACE). There are eight control centers that coordinate the regional transmission and distribution networks).
operation at regional level, and a national control center that Additional to the uncertainty of traditional planning
defines the operation policies and the security standards. methods, regarding load forecast, fuel availability, generation
and transmission forced outages rates and hydrological
conditions, CFE has to consider also the uncertainty of private
sector investment under the cogeneration and self-supply
3
LA AMISTAD AMISTAD
TNC
Kendall
Skyline
San Marcos
Zorn
Lytton
GIDEON
Flatonia
Peters
Fleweller
T.H. WHARTON
GREENS
BAYOU
FPP
Area 4 Uvalde
Hondo
(3)
SOMMERS LCRA So. Lane City
Angleton
Columba Center
Mexico RAYBURN S. Lane Cit y
Point
DOW
Piedra
s Creek
Negra Pawnee Carbia
Area 3
appropriate device for this asynchronous interconnection. The CAMARGO
HERCULES
HERCULES
POT LAMPAZOS
Area 5
Zapata
F ALCON
Area 2
FRONTERA Raymondville
FALCON DAM
J.L. BATES
LA PALMA Area 1
ESCOBEDO REYNOSA RIO MATAMOROS
V. GARCIA
BRAVO
( 2)
(2)
(2 )
(2 )
(2) (2 )
( 2)
LAURO
Gulf of Mexico
ANDALUCIA ( 2) VILLAR
GOMEZ ANAHUAC
AEROPUERTO
PALACIO
PV
MONTERREY
HUINALA
PLAZA
TEC
CFE
Area 1 Matamoros-Brownsville
345/400 kV Area 2 Reynosa – McAllen
Railroads substation near Mission, Texas, and links the 230 kV
MONTE MORELOS
CD. VICTORIA
Area 3
Area 4
Nuevo Laredo – Laredo
Piedras Negras – Eagle Pass
138/115 kV
ERCOT grid with CFE, where it has been used to exchange up 69 kV
PTO. ALTAMI RA
ALTAMIRA
Area 5
Area 6
Presa Falcon – Falcon
Ojinaga - Presidio
(2 )
Substation
(Fig. 2) [23].
At the southern border energy is exported to Belize at 115 Fig. 4. Asynchronous Interconnections between ERCOT and CFE.
kV (Fig. 2). Belize has a contract to purchase power from CFE
up to 25 MW of firm capacity. This power flow is achieved In both phases, both high voltage synchronous and
trough a 40MW, 115 kV line. This line originates in Xul-Ha asynchronous transmission transmission interconnections will
substation, which also supplies the local area of Chetumal, and be considered, but the primary effort is focused on
is connected to the major CFE generating station in Merida asynchronous interconnections that utilize Flexible Alternating
area. Current Transmission Systems (FACTS) technology to allow
the scheduling of power transfer between the electrical grids.
C. US/Mexico Interconnection Study
CFE and ERCOT have a long history of emergency V. CROSS-BORDER TRADE IN ELECTRICITY
assistance across the Mexico/US border. In 2003, identified a BETWEEN MEXICO AND CENTRAL AMERICA
mutual benefit in conducting a contemporary study of possible
interconnections between their respective grids [24], to A. Mexico/Guatemala Interconnection
determine the short-term (phase 1) and long-term (phase 2) This interconnection project consists of a 103 km long,
opportunities for interconnection. 400kV transmission line (with 32 km on the Mexican side and
The study was separated into phases as follows: phase 1, 71 km on the Guatemalan side), and involves the expansion of
immediate consideration of support to the transmission system two substations, one in Tapachula (Mexico) and the other in
along the Texas border where older inefficient generation is no Los Brillantes (Guatemala). Fig. 5 shows the
longer economical to operate (Fig. 4). Mexico/Guatemala interconnection [25].
The reliability of both systems has been recently improved,
through two new interconnections using available transmission Sistema de Interconexión Eléctrica Para América Central (SIEPAC)
lines and the advantages of new technology as the VFT and the
Mérida
Te guci galpa
•
On the basis of the contract signed, the utility in Guatemala, cost electricity to consumers. Empresa Propietaria de la Red
INDE, will acquire 120MW of power from CFE, which could (EPR) administers the project.
be expanded to 200MW, since CFE has a surplus that would Construction of this line began in 2006 and was scheduled
make this possible. At the same time, the contract will enable to begin operation by the end of 2009. The line is a single
CFE to purchase energy on the Guatemalan electricity market circuit, at 230 kV, with a rated of 300MW capacity. A second
in the event of a contingency. circuit can be added in the future, for an additional 300MW
This interconnection has helped initiate the integration of capacity.
the Mexican electric system with the CA market and will allow The SIEPAC project not only consist of the construction of
economy energy transactions between both countries and this transmission line, it consist as well of the establishment of
medium and long term bilateral contracts. a regional electricity market, a regional regulator and a
Additionally the tie will help to the control of power flows regional operator in order to reduce the cost of energy and
in Guatemala, reducing losses and improving power reactive rapidly expand energy capacity by attracting private sector
margins. investment.
B. International Power Grid Interconnections in Central
VI. CONCLUSIONS
America
Up to this date, six CA countries have interconnections This paper has described the recent developments on
between themselves: Honduras-Nicaragua (1976), Costa Rica- international power grid interconnections in Mexico with the
Nicaragua (1982), Costa Rica-Panama (1986), El Salvador- US and CA.
Guatemala (1986) and El Salvador- Honduras (2002) [25] The reliability of CFE and ERCOT systems has been
(Fig. 6). These interconnections are at 230 kV voltage level, recently improved through the commissioning of two new
for mutual support in emergency situation, and for interchange interconnections using available transmission lines and the
of surplus of hydro power. advantages of new technology as the VFT and BtB HVDC,
They have a transfer limit of approximately 50MW. allowing better control of the interchange of power and better
control of reactive power and voltage along the border.
Reliability and operational agreements have been signed for
Líneas de transmisión actuales en la región.
Interconexión
the operation of such interconnections and are expected to
México – Belice
(115 KV)
continue growing along with additional joint studies and
Chixoy Belmopan coordination groups.
Mollejón
Planta Hidro San Pedro Sula
!"# $%& '(
!"# The Mexico-Guatemala interconnection projects will
•
Los Brillant es
•
•Cd. Guat emala El Cajón facilitate support during emergencies and increase operation
• • T egucigalpa
•
•
15 de Sep.
reliability. This interconnection has helped initiate the
San Salvador
• Pavana
• Subestaciones
•
•
Fortuna
Panamá
power and energy transactions.
Capitales
Línea Doble
VII. REFERENCES
[1] D. S. Kirshen, R. Bacher, and G. T. Heydt, "The technology of power
system competition," Special Issue in Proceedings of IEEE, February
2000.
Fig. 6. International Power Grid Interconnections in Central America. [2] M. Ilic, F. Galiana, L. H. Fink, Power System Restructuring,
Engineering and Economics. Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1998.
[3] M. A. Avila Rosales, R. O. Mota Palomino, "Issues affecting the
C. Electricity Interconnection System for the Central America electricity transmission and distribution system in Mexico," 2008 IEEE
PES T&D Conference and Exposition, Bogota, Colombia, August 13th
countries to 15th, 2008.
SIEPAC is the Spanish acronym for Electricity [4] M. A. Avila Rosales, J. Gonzales Flores, "Issues affecting the electricity
Interconnection System for the CA countries, and is one of the transmission system in Mexico under a competitive integrated model,"
CIGRE Canada Conference on Power Systems. Paper 498. Winnipeg,
main projects underway to foster regional integration and Manitoba, October 19th to 21st, 2008, Canada.
cooperation between six CA countries: Panama, Costa Rica, [5] M. A. Avila Rosales, L. R. Escalante, A. Escobar, "Transmission
Nicaragua, Honduras, El Salvador and Guatemala. expansion challenges for the electric power industry in Mexico under a
competitive environment". CIGRE 2004. Paper C1-101, Paris, France.
The project will construct a 1,830 km 230 KV transmission [6] M. A. Avila Rosales, L. R. Escalante, A. Escobar, "The Mexican electric
line linking Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Costa Rica, system: system expansion planning and restructuring activities". CIGRE
Nicaragua and Panama (Fig. 5). The new transmission system 2004. Paper C1-102, Paris, France.
interconnection will alleviate the regions periodic power
shortages and decrease operating costs, thereby reducing the
6
[7] F. Aboytes, R. Cristerna, "Planning and operation challenges for the Power System Planning and Development), and was the CIGRE Chairman
electric power industry in Mexico under a competitive environment". National Committee, Mexico, 1999-2007.
CIGRE 1996. Paper 37-109, Paris, France.
[8] Secretaria de Energia, Mexico, "Electricity Sector Outlook 2007-2016".
Available: http:// www.energia.gob.mx
[9] H. G. Sarmiento, M. A. Avila Rosales, "Issues associated with
international power grid interconnections," To be presented at 2010
Hector G Sarmiento Uruchurtu (M’1976,
IEEE PES T&D Conference and Exposition, New Orleans, Louisiana,
SM’1990) graduated from Universidad
April 19th to 22nd, 2010.
Iberoamericana in 1976 (BSc EE), has a Master of
[10] M. A. Avila Rosales, H. G. Sarmiento, D. Leon, "International power
Engineering Degree from Rensselaer Polytechnic
grid interconnections in Mexico". To be presented at CIGRE 2010
Institute (Troy, New York) and a PhD Electrical
Session. Paris, France.
Engineering Degree from Concordia University
[11] M. A. Avila Rosales, H. G. Sarmiento, D. Leon, "Recent developments
(Montreal,PQ). Since 1978, he is a Project Manager
in United States-Mexico-Central America electricity trade". CIGRE
at the Instituto de Investigaciones Electricas (IIE) of
Canada Conference on Power Systems. Toronto, Ontario, October 4th to
Mexico and his main interests are the Analysis and
6th, 2009, Canada.
Design of Transmission Systems.
[12] M. A. Avila Rosales, "United States and Mexico new cross-border
connections," 2008 IEEE PES T&D Conference and Exposition,
Bogota, Colombia, August 13th to 15th, 2008.
[13] M. A. Avila Rosales, G. Galicia Cano, M. A. Islas Martinez, "Recent
developments on cross-border trade in electricity between CFE and
ERCOT". CIGRE 2008. Paper C1-101, Paris, France.
[14] R. Nadira, R. R Austria, C. Dortolina, M. A. Avila Rosales,
"Transmission planning today: a challenging undertaking" The
Electricity Journal, May 2004.
[15] R. Nadira, R. R Austria, C. Dortolina, F. Lecaros, "Transmission
planning in the presence of uncertainties" in Proceedings of IEEE 2003,
Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
[16] R. R. Austria, R. Nadira, L. Cosenza, C. F. Fuentes Estrada, M. A. Avila
Rosales, J. Ramirez Ortiz, "Transmission planning considering power
industry restructuring" International Conference IASTED, Orlando,
Florida, October 27th to 30th , 1977.
[17] J. Islas, U. Geronimo, "The financing of the Mexican electrical sector"
Energy Policy 29.2001.Elsevier Science LTD, pp.965-973.
[18] Ley y Reglamento del Servicio Publico de Energia Electrica. Secretaria
de Energia Minas e Industria Paraestatal. SEMIP. Mexico. 1993.
[19] Programa de Obras e Inversiones del Sector Electrico POISE 2009-
2018. Subdireccion de Programacion. Comision Federal de
Electricidad. Mexico. 2009 Available:http:/ www.cfe.gob.mx
[20] US Agency for International Development. "Study on legal and
regulatory factors affecting the cross-border trade in electricity between
Mexico and US” Final Report.1997.
[21] T. Larsson, A. Petersson, A. A. Edris, D. Kidd, R. Haley, F. Aboytes,
"Eagle-Pass back to back tie: a dual purpose application of voltage
source converter technology" 2001 IEEE PES Summer Meeting,
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
[22] P. E. Marken, J. J.Marczewski, R. D’Aquila, P. Hassink, J. H. Roedel,
R. L. Bodo, "VFT-a smart transmission technology that is compatible
with the existing and future grid" 2009 IEEE PES Power System
Conference and Exposition, March 15 to 18,2009, Seattle, WAS.
[23] M. E. Caskey , "Sharyland Utilities LPDC tie project," Sharyland
Utilities LP.2005
[24] CFE/ERCOT Interconnection Study. December 2003.Available: http//
www.puc.state.tyx.us/electric/projects/20948/20948.cfm
[25] H. G. Sarmiento, M. A. Avila Rosales, "International grid
interconnections in Mexico and Central America" World Energy
Council. WEC Interconnectivity Task Force.
VIII. BIOGRAPHIES