10/11/13

Who Benefits From India's Diesel Subsidy? By S.G.Vombatkere

Home Printer Friendly Version

Who Benefits From India's Diesel Subsidy? By S.G.Vombatkere 23 January, 2013 Countercurrents.org Government has announced that bulk diesel consumers like railways and state transport corporations have Support Us
Popularise CC Join News Letter CounterSolutions CounterImages CounterVideos Editor's Picks Press Releases Action Alert Feed Burner Read CC In Your Own Language Bradley Manning India Burning Mumbai Terror Financial Crisis Iraq AfPak War Peak Oil Globalisation Localism Alternative Energy Climate Change US Imperialism US Elections Palestine Latin America Communalism Gender/Feminism Dalit Humanrights Economy India-pakistan Kashmir

to purchase diesel at market-determined rates, while diesel purchased at fuel outlets will continue to receive subsidy. Assuming diesel subsidy as Rs.10 per litre, let us examine the effects of the recent government order. Mr.Suresh Kumar (not his real name) living in Bandra, Mumbai, maintains three cars, but we will keep the discussion to the SUV that only he uses. Mr.Kumar's SUV gives him 8 km per litre, and on average he drives about 2,000 km every month. He thus purchases 250 litres of subsidized diesel, and utilizes subsidy of Rs.2,500 (250 litres x Rs.10 per litre) every month, or Rs.30,000 annually, for his SUV. This subsidy is borne by tax payers, which include all citizens including the poor, for whom cost of essentials includes indirect taxes. But for Mr.Kumar, the more he drives around, the more diesel he uses, and the more subsidy he utilizes. On the other hand, domestic worker Sonabai living in a Mumbai chawl, has to travel by BEST bus, spending Rs.30 on bus fare every day to and from work. But BEST, which is a bulk consumer of diesel, has to purchase diesel at market rate, and hikes the bus fare so that Sonabai spends Rs.40 every day instead of Rs.30. That is, Sonabai spends Rs.10 more every day (Rs.3,650 more annually), while Mr.Kumar avails of Rs.30,000 subsidy annually. Let us consider the cost to the environment. Noting that whosoever is responsible for consuming diesel, every litre consumed produces exhaust gases that pollute the environment. Whether Mr.Kumar's SUV carries one passenger or more, it consumes essentially the same quantity of diesel and creates the same quantity of exhaust gases. Mr.Kumar's SUV has a seating capacity of 8 passengers, but usually it has only Mr.Kumar himself. Thus, his SUV is used at 1/8 of its carrying capacity, but the diesel consumed and the consequent pollution caused, is no less. As a single individual, he consumes the diesel that 8 could have used. As assumed earlier, his SUV gives 8 km / litre or, put another way, uses 125 ml / km. Thus, if the SUV had 8 passengers, each passenger would be effectively using 125/8=15.6 ml / km. But since Mr.Kumar's SUV provides transportation only for himself, the per capita diesel consumption of his SUV is 125 ml per km, and produces per capita pollution from burning 125 ml / km. On the other hand, consider Sonabai's bus. It has a seating capacity of 52 and a standing passenger capacity of 24, but when she travels it is rush-hour both ways, and the bus is packed with about 100 passengers. While it costs essentially the same to operate the bus whether it is empty or full, it is obviously most economical when the bus is full or over-full occupancy is a major determinant of the economics of a vehicle. However, economics does not trouble Mr.Kumar when he travels alone in his SUV and fills its tank with subsidized diesel using his credit card. The bus consumes about 0.5-litre of diesel per km @ 2-km per litre. Thus, for every kilometre travelled during rush-hours when the bus carries 100 passengers, each passenger effectively uses 500/100=5 ml of
1/4

diesel, and is responsible for pollution due to burning 5 ml of diesel. That is, the per capita diesel consumption Environment www.countercurrents.org/vombatkere230113.htm

10/11/13

Environment

Who Benefits From India's Diesel Subsidy? By S.G.Vombatkere diesel, and is responsible for pollution due to burning 5 ml of diesel. That is, the per capita diesel consumption

Book Review
Gujarat Pogrom Kandhamal Violence Arts/Culture India Elections Archives Links Submission Policy About Us Disclaimer Fair Use Notice Contact Us Search Our Archive

in a bus is 5 ml per km, producing per capita pollution from burning 5 ml per km. Thus, Mr.Kumar ordinarily consumes 125/5=25 times as much diesel as Sonabai, and is responsible for about 25 times as much exhaust gas pollution as her. And, while she effectively subsidizes his diesel consumption, Sonabai is multiple times more eco-friendly than Mr.Kumar. Finally, consider the traffic congestion on the roads. Mr.Kumar's SUV, like any vehicle, occupies road space when it moves or when it is parked on the roadside. It is true that a SUV is about half the size of a BEST bus, and a bus too occupies road space though only when it is on the move, because it is never parked on the roadside. Nevertheless, the per capita usage of road space has arguments similar to those for diesel consumption, and Mr.Kumar uses much more road space, which is a public good, than Mrs.Sonabai who represents the vast majority of urban poor. Thus Sonabai is far less demanding of civic amenities than Mr.Kumar.

Thus, on a per capita basis, Mr.Kumar uses more road space, consumes more diesel, and causes more pollution than Sonabai, and even gets his subsidized diesel at her cost. Further, there are many lakhs of
Site Search Our Site Web

people like Sonabai and only many hundreds of people like Mr.Kumar, and it does not require rocket science to understand who subsidizes whom, and who is more responsible for diesel consumption, vehicle exhaust pollution and road congestion. Further, at the hiked bus fare, Mrs.Sonabai spends Rs.40 per day or Rs.1,200 per month on transport, 20% of her Rs.6,000 per month wages. But Mr.Kumar spends Rs.13,000 per month (250 litres@Rs.52/litre) on diesel for his SUV and it is less than 1% of his declared monthly income of several lakhs. This discussion indicates who is most responsible for some of the ills of urban living, and hopefully will serve

Subscribe To Our News Letter

Name: E-mail:
Subscribe Unsubscribe
Find us on Facebook

to urge government to adhere to its own National Transport Policy, which incentivizes affordable public transport (not Volvo AC buses that Sonabai cannot afford) and disincentivizes use of private motor vehicles. Contrary to Mr.Moily's assertion, charging market rates for bulk diesel consumers forces those who are already poor, to pay more for their living. Thus, the policy of the present and previous Union governments is arguably pro-wealthy and effectively anti-poor. Major General S.G. Vombatkere retired as the Additional Director General, Discipline & Vigilance in Army HQ, New Delhi. The President of India awarded him the Visishta Seva Medal in 1993 for distinguished service rendered over 5 years in Ladakh. He writes on strategic and development-related issues. Contact ; E-mail: sg9kere@live.com

Countercurrents.org
Like 18,422 people like Countercurrents.org.

Facebook social plugin

Tw eet

17

ShareThis

Comments are moderated

www.countercurrents.org/vombatkere230113.htm

2/4

10/11/13

Who Benefits From India's Diesel Subsidy? By S.G.Vombatkere

Comments (9)
Sort by: Date Rating Last Activity nisha 4 weeks ago totally true. The subsidies will only benefit the rich and not the poor!
Reply

Login

Report 0

ric marash 7 weeks ago run your buses on CNG in mumbai we do it in delhi
Reply

1 reply active 6 weeks ago

Report +1

Shakir 6 weeks ago But that is Not an alternative sir...still the Poor pays the rich..
Reply

Report 0

Achal 7 weeks ago

I totally agree with u sir. But how can u forget, the subsidised rates are for deisel of trucks also and if the prices increase for them,then it will directly help in increasing inflation which will make the government a bigger villian in the present scenario.
Reply

Report +1

homework 36 weeks ago

sir i think you have not taken into account the extra tax that is payed by diesel car owners. the minimum being 1 lakh in the hatch back segment. suv will defintely have much more tax taken on them. so even considering you calculation of 30,000. heel have to run more than 10 years to recover what extra hes speding as tax.
Reply

Report 0

Jayasankar 37 weeks ago

The government is giving crores of rupees to corporates and riches as incentives by stealing money from poor peoples pockets...
Reply

Report 0

Rajeev 37 weeks ago

Good article, government should in-fact increase diesel price for everybody at one go and eliminate fuel subsidies all together. You also forget one thing, government also puts tax on diesel consumption, so the more you consume, the more tax you pay.
Reply

Report +1

Virendra Kumar 37 weeks ago

Very interesting and eye-opening Article. The Govt. should look in to this and make the Diesel subsidy policy propoor.
Reply

Report 0

David Kennedy 37 weeks ago

This is the power of corporate lobbyists. They have the megaphone voices that poor people lack. that is why trades unions (ones that have NOT been infiltrated) are so important in speaking with a collective voice for all of their members.
Reply

Report

Post a new comment

Enter text right here!

C heck Spelling

Comment as a Guest, or login: Name Email Website (optional)

www.countercurrents.org/vombatkere230113.htm

3/4

10/11/13

Who Benefits From India's Diesel Subsidy? By S.G.Vombatkere

Displayed next to your comments. Not displayed publicly. If you have a website, link to it here.

Subscribe to None

Submit Comment

ShareThis

www.countercurrents.org/vombatkere230113.htm

4/4