Title Page of The Feueialist vol. 1. N.Y. }ohn Tiebout, 1799. Libiaiy of Congiess Piints & Photogiaphs Bivision. Repiouuction Numbei: LC-0SZ62-7uSu8 Retiieveu fiom: www.loc.govpictuiesitem2uuS6S4698
!"#$% '%(%)* 6-8 A lesson mouule utilizing piimaiy anu seconuaiy souices, close ieauing stiategies anu uocument analysis intenueu to help stuuents builu theii knowleuge anu unueistanuing of Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist uuiing the eaily stages of Ameiican Bemociacy.
Cieateu By: Biian Fuigione SSE 69S8 - Fall Semestei Bi. Scott Waiiing Lesson Nouule
! Stuuents will unueistanu anu be able to explain anu apply the viewpoints of the Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist uuiing the iatification piocess of the 0S Constitution.
4++%-23#) 56%+23,-+
! What weie the viewpoints of the Feueialist in iegaius to the iatification of the 0S Constitution. ! What weie the viewpoints of the Anti-Feueialist in iegaius to the iatification of the 0S Constitution. ! Why uiu the Anti-Feueialist want to incluue a Bill of Rights in the 0S Constitution.
72#-$#"$+ 8$$"%++%$ 932:3- 2:% '%++,-
;%<2 !%-%"#23,- 76-+:3-% 72#2% 72#-$#"$+ 72#-$#"$ ! !!"#"$"%: Bemonstiate an unueistanuing of the oiigins anu puiposes of goveinment, law, anu the Ameiican political system. =%-1:>#"? ! !!"#"$"%"&' Explain the viewpoints of the Feueialists anu the Anti-Feueialists iegaiuing the iatification of the Constitution anu inclusion of a bill of iights.
@,>>,- @,"% 72#2% 72#-$#"$+ A%B C$%#+ #-$ D%2#3)+ ! $$!!")*+,*-./0123"45"6,&"%' Cite specific textual eviuence to suppoit analysis of piimaiy anu seconuaiy souices. ! $$!!")*+,*-./0123"45"6,&"7: Beteimine the cential iueas oi infoimation of a piimaiy oi seconuaiy souice; pioviue an accuiate summaiy of the souice uistinct fiom piioi knowleuge oi opinions. @"#E2 #-$ 72"6126"% ! $$!!")*+,*-./0123"45"6,&"8: Beteimine the meaning of woius anu phiases as they aie useu in a text, incluuing vocabulaiy specific to uomains ielateu to histoiysocial stuuies. ! $$!!")*+,*-./0123"45"6,&"9: Besciibe how a text piesents infoimation (e.g., sequentially, compaiatively, causally). C-2%F"#23,- ,E A-,G)%$F% #-$ C$%#+ ! $$!!")*+,*-./0123"45"6,&"#: Integiate visual infoimation (e.g., in chaits, giaphs, photogiaphs, viueos, oi maps) with othei infoimation in piint anu uigital texts.
Biian Fuigione SSE 69S8 Lesson Nouule Page S @,-2%-2 76>>#"B Buiing the summei of 1787 anu into 1788, the fiameis of the Constitution anu the uelegates of the Constitutional Convention hotly uebateu ovei the size, stiuctuie anu powei of the feueial goveinment. Although appioval was only neeueu fiom nine states to iatify the new Constitution foi all the states, two laige factions of people came out of the iatification piocess: the Feueialist anu the Anti- Feueialist. (The Ratification of the Constitution, 2u1S) Anti-Feueialist weie those who opposeu the iatification of the new Constitution. They believeu that the poweis gianteu to the Feueial uoveinment weie too stiong anu the lack of a bill of iights, which piotecteu the inuiviuual citizen, left too much in the hanus of a cential goveinment. Fiameis like Patiick Beniy, }ames Nonioe anu ueoige Nason began penning letteis that ciiticizeu the new Constitution. These letteis weie publisheu unuei vaiious pen names anu pseuuonyms in local newspapeis to biing attention to anu gainei suppoit foi the Anti-Feueialist cause. (The Feueialist Papeis, 2u1S) Feueialist weie those who favoieu iatification of the new Constitution. The Feueialist believeu the Constitution cieateu a stiong cential goveinment, which the nation lackeu unuei the Aiticles of Confeueiation. Fiameis like Alexanuei Bamilton, }ohn }ay anu }ames Nauison began publishing theii own essays in iesponse to the letteis penneu by the Anti-Feueialist. These letteis became known as "The Feueialist Papeis." These essays weie intenueu to piomote the iuea the Constitution was ieauy to be iatifieu anu answei the ciiticisms of the Anti- Feueialist. (The Feueialist Papeis, 2u1S) In the enu, the new Constitution was iatifieu with the assuiance that a bill of iights woulu be auopteu once the new goveinment began iunning. (The Ratification of the Constitution, 2u1S)
Biian Fuigione SSE 69S8 Lesson Nouule Page 4 D#3)B '%++,- H",1%$6"%+ '%++,- H",1%$6"%+* D#B .-% D#3)B ./0%123(%* !.:;/<.= >-??' ! 0nueistanu the basic piinciples of the Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist. ! Evaluate vaiious piimaiy anu seconuaiy souices to suppoit theii iueas. ! Analyze the peispectives of multiple people fiom vaiious gioups. I#2%"3#)+ ;%%$%$ !====@@@@A B/C0/ B0-.-<D .@/ $E<=.-.:.-E<A viueo Exceipt Images of Key Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist
D#3)B H",1%$6"%+ 1. 5EEF' Stuuents will be askeu to entei the classioom anu take out theii civics-wiiting jouinal. 0n a new page, stuuents will iesponu to a question the question, which will be posteu on the boaiu. The question will be: "A Zombie Apocalypse has left the 0niteu States in shambles. You aie one of the only people left who unueistanus the basics of civics.Woulu you piefei to establish a goveinment which is veiy laige anu poweiful oi veiy small goveinment which leaves a majoiity of the powei to the suivivois of the apocalypse. " 2. Following the piompt, stuuents will be given an oppoitunity to shaie theii iesponses within theii leaining gioups. S. Teachei will solicit whole class iesponses to the wiiting piompt. Each iesponse will be listeu on the boaiu foi the stuuents to evaluate against theii own iesponse. Following whole class iesponses, teachei will ask stuuents to ieevaluate theii iesponses to see if they still piefei theii oiiginal iuea of "big oi small goveinment" oi woulu like to change theii peispective. 4. G-0/2. H<=.0:2.-E<' Teachei access stuuent's piioi knowleuge anu explain that the countiy hau veiy uiffeiing peispectives of what a national goveinment shoulu look like piioi to anu following the iatification of the 0S Constitution. Teachei will explain that people who suppoiteu a laige feueial goveinment weie calleu Feueialist anu those who opposeu a laige feueial goveinment weie calleu Anti-Feueialist. S. Following this biief instiuction peiiou, stuuents will watch a six-minute viueo exceipt fiom !====@@@@A B/C0/ B0-.-<D .@/ $E<=.-.:.-E<AI which oveiviews Feueialist anu Anti- Biian Fuigione SSE 69S8 Lesson Nouule Page S Feueialist views anu beliefs a. viueo can be founu on www.uiscoveiyeuucation.com 6. $?E=-<D: Exit Slip question: what aie the basic views of Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist. 47.' I,$3E31#23,-+ Assistance in heiitage language by utilizing uoogle Tianslate wiuget on website, use visual aius in heiitage language. Auuitional time anu flexible piesentation shoulu be consiueieu foi ES0L stuuents. 4(#)6#23,-J8++%++>%-2 Buiing the fiist class peiiou, stuuents will be evaluateu thiough infoimal assessment anu contiibutions to class anu gioup uiscussions. The exit slip will allow teachei to evaluate which stuuents unueistoou the majoi concepts of the uay.
'%++,- H",1%$6"%+* D#B KG, D#3)B ./0%123(%* !.:;/<.= >-??' ! 0nueistanu anu be able to explain the viewpoints of the Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist. ! Compaie anu Contiast the views of the Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist ! Bevelop an unueistanuing of multiple uiffeient peispectives. ! Evaluate the meaning of infoimational text. I#2%"3#)+ ;%%$%$ Flocabulaiy: 51J-?.E< K" L/MM/0=E< Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist Close Reauing Bocument Feueialists anu Anti-Feueialists uuiuing Questions D#3)B H",1%$6"%+ 1. N/??,4-<D/0' Aftei watching the Flocabulaiy Rap: 51J-?.E< K" L/MM/0=E<, ask they stuuents who woulu you siue with 2. Review vaiious close ieauing stiategies utilizeu uuiing class. S. Pass outhave stuuents uownloau the "Feueialist anu Anti- Feueialist Close Reauing Bocument." a. Bocument couitesy of www.floiiuacitizen.oig 4. Teachei will ieau the uocument to the class as the stuuents follow along. Following the ieau alouu, stuuents will be askeu to highlightunueiline: a. The key points of the Feueialist b. The key points of the Anti-Feueialist c. The iueas that the two gioups uiffeieu on S. Following the ieauing, stuuents will be supplieu with the "Feueialists anu Anti-Feueialists uuiuing Questions" uocument. Explain that stuuents will neeu to complete the Biian Fuigione SSE 69S8 Lesson Nouule Page 6 giaphic oiganizei by suppoiting theii iesponses with text baseu infoimation anu content. 6. Review the mateiials gatheieu utilizing whole class instiuctions anu inuiviuual iesponses fiom stuuents. 7. Collect all mateiials fiom stuuents foi evaluation of unueistanuing. 47.' I,$3E31#23,-+ Assistance in heiitage language by utilizing uoogle Tianslate wiuget on website, use visual aius in heiitage language. Auuitional time anu flexible piesentation shoulu be consiueieu foi ES0L stuuents. 4(#)6#23,-J8++%++>%-2 At the enu of the lesson, stuuents will submit all of theii iesponsesoiganizeis to the teachei foi evaluation.
'%++,- H",1%$6"%+* D#B K:"%% D#3)B ./0%123(%* !.:;/<.= >-??' ! Bevelop a uetaileu unueistanuing of the viewpoint of the Feueialist ! Analyze vaiious iueas poitiayeu by the Feueialist. ! Analyze vaiious piimaiy anu seconuaiy souices I#2%"3#)+ ;%%$%$ Exceipts of vaiious Feueialist Papeis Bocument Analysis Woiksheet Inteinet Access Bighlighteis D#3)B H",1%$6"%+ 1. N/??,0-<D/0' Pioject the image of Alexanuei Bamilton's copy of "The Feueialist: A Collection of Essays" anu ask the stuuents to evaluate the uocument. 2. Following the bell-iingei, explain to them that the uay will be spent walking in the shoes of a Feueialist, in an attempt to fully unueistanu theii peispective anu ieasoning. S. Stations will be set-up aiounu the classioom with vaiious images of key Feueialist anu exceipts fiom the Feueialist Papeis. Stuuents will be askeu to complete an analysis of each exceipt anu examine each image to uevelop theii unueistanuing of the Feueialist Peispective. 4. $?E=-<D: Stuuents will be askeu to wiite a one-paiagiaph entiy in theii wiiting jouinals. The piompt: Fiom the peispective of a Feueialist, wiite a iesponse to the statement "Big goveinment has no place in the newly establisheu 0niteu States." 47.' I,$3E31#23,-+ Assistance in heiitage language by utilizing uoogle Tianslate wiuget on website, use visual aius in heiitage language. Auuitional time anu flexible piesentation shoulu be consiueieu foi ES0L stuuents. Biian Fuigione SSE 69S8 Lesson Nouule Page 7 4(#)6#23,-J8++%++>%-2 In auuition to typical obseivation anu paiticipation uuiing the lesson, stuuents will be evaluateu baseu on theii iesponses within theii wiiting-jouinals.
'%++,- H",1%$6"%+* D#B L,6" D#3)B ./0%123(%* !.:;/<.= >-??' ! Bevelop a uetaileu unueistanuing of the viewpoint of the Anti-Feueialist ! Analyze vaiious iueas poitiayeu by the Anti- Feueialist. ! Analyze vaiious piimaiy anu seconuaiy souices I#2%"3#)+ ;%%$%$ Exceipts of vaiious Anti-Feueialist Papeis Bocument Analysis Woiksheet Inteinet Access Bighlighteis D#3)B H",1%$6"%+ 1. N/??,0-<D/0' Pioject the image of Patiick Beniy anu the quote "As long as we can pieseive oui unalienable iights, we aie in safety." - Patiick Beniy, Anti-Feueialist No. 4" on the boaiu. Ask stuuents to iesponu to the quote in theii civics-wiiting jouinals 2. Following the bell-iingei, explain to that the uay will be spent walking in the shoes of an Anti-Feueialist, in an attempt to fully unueistanu theii peispective anu ieasoning. S. Stations will be set-up aiounu the classioom with vaiious images of key Anti-Feueialist anu exceipts fiom the Anti- Feueialist Papeis. Stuuents will be askeu to complete an analysis of each exceipt anu examine each image to uevelop theii unueistanuing of the Feueialist Peispective. 4. $?E=-<D: Stuuents will be askeu to wiite a one-paiagiaph entiy in theii wiiting jouinals. The piompt: Fiom the peispective of a Anti-Feueialist, wiite a iesponse to the statement "Small goveinment have no place in the newly establisheu 0niteu States" 47.' I,$3E31#23,-+ Assistance in heiitage language by utilizing uoogle Tianslate wiuget on website, use visual aius in heiitage language. Auuitional time anu flexible piesentation shoulu be consiueieu foi ES0L stuuents. 4(#)6#23,-J8++%++>%-2 In auuition to typical obseivation anu paiticipation uuiing the lesson, stuuents will be evaluateu baseu on theii iesponses within theii wiiting-jouinals. Biian Fuigione SSE 69S8 Lesson Nouule Page 8
'%++,- H",1%$6"%+* D#B L3(% D#3)B ./0%123(%* !.:;/<.= >-??' ! Compaie anu contiast the viewpoints of the Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist to vaiious cuiient events. ! 0iganize theii thoughts utilizing multiple moualities ! Cieate mouein uay Feueialist Papeis uepicting cuiient events in ielation to sentiments of the 17uus. I#2%"3#)+ ;%%$%$ Exceipts of vaiious Feueialist anu Anti-Feueialist Papeis Constiuction Papei anu Ait Supplies Inteinet Access D#3)B H",1%$6"%+ 1. N/??,0-<D/0' Pioject a newspapei image of one of the Feueialist Papeis publisheu in 1787. Ask the stuuents to evaluate the image anu uiscuss with theii gioup membeis. 2. Following the intiouuction, stuuents will be taskeu with cieating a mouein uay "Fiont Page" of a newspapei taking on the peispective of a Feueialist oi an Anti-Feueialist on a cuiient event of theii choice: a. 0niveisal Bealthcaie b. Buuget RefoimNational Bebt c. Foieign Policy u. States Rights vs. Feueial Rights S. Stuuent newspapeis will compaie anu contiast the views of both paities as they incoipoiate quotesfacts fiom within theii chosen gioup: Feueialist oi Anti-Feueialist. (Rubiic below) 4. Stuuents will shaie theii cieations with the class at the enu of the peiiou. S. Teachei will collect all newspapeis anu stuuent cieateu woik. 47.' I,$3E31#23,-+ Assistance in heiitage language by utilizing uoogle Tianslate wiuget on website, use visual aius in heiitage language. Auuitional time anu flexible piesentation shoulu be consiueieu foi ES0L stuuents. 4(#)6#23,-J8++%++>%-2 Stuuents will be evaluateu baseu on theii wiiting in theii newspapei aiticles. Auuitionally, stuuents will be evaluateu baseu on theii paiticipation anu collaboiation with othei stuuents.
Bocument Analysis Woik Sheet N0TE: You may choose a numbei of analysis tools, be suie stuuents aie familiai with them anu have the ability to leveiage them piioi to the lesson. Retiieveu fiom: http:www.aichives.goveuucationles sonswoiksheets
Bocument Analysis Woik Sheet N0TE: You may choose a numbei of analysis tools, be suie stuuents aie familiai with them anu have the ability to leveiage them piioi to the lesson. Retiieveu fiom: http:www.aichives.goveuucationles sonswoiksheets
Bocument Analysis Woik Sheet N0TE: You may choose a numbei of analysis tools, be suie stuuents aie familiai with them anu have the ability to leveiage them piioi to the lesson. Retiieveu fiom: http:www.aichives.goveuucationles sonswoiksheets
The Ratification of the Constitution (2u1S) Teaching With Bocuments: National Aichives anu Recoius Auministiation. Retiieveu fiom: http:www.aichives.goveuucationlessonsconstitution- uayiatification.html
76NN)%>%-2#) I#2%"3#)+ P 8$$323,-#) O%+,6"1%+
! L%$%"#)3+2 #-$ 8-23ML%$%"#)3+2* o :22N*JJ)3/"#"BQ2:3-?R6%+2Q,"FJSSTUVJ1"%#23,-JE"#>3-FJE%$+Q:2>)
! L%$%"#)3+2 #-$ 8-23ML%$%"#)3+2 O%+,6"1% W3$%,* o :22N*JJGGGQ0#1?>3))%"1%-2%"Q,"FJVXSVJXUJE%$%"#)3+2+M(M#-23M E%$%"#)3+2+M(3$%,M"%+,6"1%J
! K:% L%$%"#)3+2 H#"2B* o :22N*JJGGGQN/+Q,"FJGF/:J#>%<J$6%)JN%,N)%%(%-2+JN#-$%XTQ:2>)
! @:",-31)% ,E 2:% O%(,)623,-* K:% L%$%"#)3+2 H#N%"+ o :22N*JJGGGQN/+Q,"FJ?21#J)3/%"2BJN,N6NY#-23E%$%"#)3+2Q:2>)
! K:% L%$%"#)3+2J8-23ML%$%"#)3+2 !#>%* o :22N*JJ2%<#+)"%Q,"FJE%$%"#)3+2+YF#>%JE%$%"#)3+2+Q:2>)