Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 5

transportation shapes the ebbs and flows of social currentsit something we all encounter and experience, it involves an aspect

of disjointedness and dislocation from normality unfortunately, our discussions of transportation have followed the same absurd scripts as every other topicbroad, depersonalized, instrumental approaches to a policy area that has tangible on our every day lives this dichotomy between personal and instrumental, micro and macro, impressionistic vs highly technical thinking is one we think is worth exploring in the context of the topic before we expand to a broader discussion of language and knowledge,we begin with a discussion of the topicspecifically, a narrative decription of transportnot the economic or political aspect, simply the individual perspective of being transported
Michel de Certeau in 84 philosopher, founding member of cole Freudienne de Paris alongside Jacques
Lacan ( The Practice of Everyday Life Translated by Steven Rendall UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS Ajones)

TRAVELLING INCARCERATION. Immobile inside the train, seeing immobile things slip by. What AND that could believe itself intact because it was surrounded by glass and iron .

what does it mean to be transported? to me it means a perceptive dislocation from previous spaces. in this sense, personal accounts and narratives literally transport the audience through immersionwe are transportation investment
Green et al 6 - Melanie C. Green (PhD, Ohio State University) is an assistant professor at the University of
Pennsylvania. 2 Timothy C. Brock (PhD, Yale University) is a professor is a graduate student at Ohio State University 3 Geoff Kaufman (PhD, Yale University) is a professor is a graduate student at Ohio State University (Understanding Media Enjoyment: The Role of Transportation Into Narrative Worlds Communication Theory Volume 14, Issue 4, Article first published online: 10 JAN 2006 ajones) Transportation Into Narrative Worlds Transportation into a narrative world has been conceptualized as a

AND
information-seeking needs) and is beyond the scope of this article.

just as other discussions of the topic have ignored its personal aspect out of habit and discomfort, modern knowledge continues its genesis Not just stories of olmypians and titansmythos in the broder, ancient sense. most have heard of logos ethos and pathos, but few encounter mythosthis is no accident. Mythos was the ambiguous, emotional, undefinable force that pervaded society. Socratic and Platonic tradition could not pin it down so they chose to dismiss it. Forgotten, it has served as the defining failure of modern knowledge. elements of mythos pervade all

cultures but remain unconsidered in decisionmaking, tainting the endless search for Truth and disastrously affecting policy. by embracing mythos, we decenter the modern obsession with exclusive rationality and open space for as more holistic conception of knowlege
Anais Spitzer 11 - Visiting Instructor of Mythology at Prescott College. She has also held positions at Hollins University, the University of New Mexico, and the College of Santa Fe Pub. ( Derrida, Myth, and the Impossibility of Philosophy Continuum International Publishing Group 04 Aug 2011 ajones)

Philosophy begins, or so it initially appears, with the dismissal of myth AND reveals that mythos is, in some way, basic to philosophic discourse .

knowledge geared towards specific endpoints is impossibleaccepting mythos brings us to terms with the unknowable
Anais Spitzer 11 - Visiting Instructor of Mythology at Prescott College. She has also held positions at Hollins University, the University of New Mexico, and the College of Santa Fe Pub. ( Derrida, Myth, and the Impossibility of Philosophy Continuum International Publishing Group 04 Aug 2011 ajones) Before continuing further, a few more important qualifications must be made in considering the AND

structuralize), but rather to destabilize that which can never be properly grounded.

as a community of researches and intellectuals we should reject the excessive simplification and naieve predictions of traditional policymaking
Sil and Katzenstein, 2010 Sil is an Associate Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennysylvania while Katzenstein is a Professor of International Studies at Cornell (Rudra and Peter, Analytic Eclecticism in the Study of World Politics: Reconfiguring Problems and Mechanisms across Research Traditions, part of UPenn articles collection, http://www.polisci.upenn.edu/faculty/RSEclectic2010.pdf) Analytic eclecticism does not constitute an alternative model of research. It is an intellectual AND distinctive value added in relating academic debates to concrete matters of policy and practice our transgressive affirmation does not explode limits nor does it simply reinscribe logosit opens logos to the terrifying scraps of philosophy which it seeks to avoid. Anais Spitzer 11 - Visiting Instructor of Mythology at Prescott College. She has also held positions at Hollins
University, the University of New Mexico, and the College of Santa Fe Pub. ( Derrida, Myth, and the Impossibility of Philosophy Continuum International Publishing Group 04 Aug 2011 ajones)

Is it possible to transgress the limitations of logos in a way that does AND


as logos,16 even as they are inextricable aspects of it.17

this type of affirmation is incredibly valuable-- the sense of wonder found in embracing unknowable potentiality is crucial to break down opressive hierarchies
Susan McManus 07 - Lecturer in Political Theory at Queens College (Theorizing Utopian Agency: Two Steps Toward Utopian Techniques of the Self Theory & Event. Baltimore: 2007. Vol. 10, Iss. 3;1 proquest ajones) 51. Jane Bennett,

invoking wonder or enchantment, as a "mood

AND

sense of a world that itself, sometimes, transgresses its "rules."

we dont efface reality or truthwe reformulate knowledge to better understand mythos and chaos MacDonald, 1999
(Department of Political Studies, Queens University, 1999, Eleanor Science & Society 63.2 Ajones) Much of the early critical reception of Derrida's work focused on the appearance of a AND
, which frustrates their usefulness in particular historical contexts or regarding particular discursive instance

The United States federal government should substantially increase its transportation infrastructure investment in the United States contention two is metaphor heres the point of synthesiswe think that our invididualized example of trasportation forms a useful locus for a discussion of knowledge, language, and mythos. excluding personal experience to focus on broad efficiency is an example of logos excluding mythos. paradoxically, this exclusion has resulted in rail policies inadvertently shaped by mythos alone. this unveils conduits by which individual impressions and feelings fundementally shape policymaking, and serves as a broader metaphor for the structure of society. we should affirm the metaphor of transportation to expose the truly mythic nature of decisionmaking.
Jonathan E. D. Richmond 96- University of Sydney, former Fulbright Scholar at the MIT Center for Transportation Studies, from which he received masters and doctoral degrees (The Mythical Conception of Rail Transit in Los Angeles 11 November, 1996 Journal of Architectural and Planning Research http://thetech.mit.edu/~richmond/professional/myth.pdf ajones) CONCLUSION The Los Angeles AND

Long Beach Blue Line light rail service is not the

, however, tackle this problem if we are to make progress in planning the word metaphor comes from the ancient Greek metapherein to transport across. metaphors carry meaning between two symbolic loci, just as a mass transit network carrys people. metaphor is both literal travel and coproductive with the meaning of the journey Michel de Certeau 84 philosopher, founding member of cole Freudienne de Paris alongside Jacques Lacan (
The Practice of Everyday Life Translated by Steven Rendall UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS Ajones)

IN MODERN ATHENS, the vehicles of mass transportation are called metaphorai. To AND enunciative focalizations" (that is, the indication of the body within discourse it doesnt matter if this isnt the normative understanding of transportation thats the point.

by rejecting conventional understandings of language, we break down a system of interpretive authority which causes international conflict Klaus Krippendorff 90 - Professor of Communication at the Annenberg School for Communication, University of
Pennsylvania (Models and Metaphors of Communication 1990 Departmental Papers (ASC) http://repository.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1283&context=asc_papers ajones) Let me start with communication is sharing. I am suggesting that this commonly cherished AND also not be answered while believing that it is the symbols that flow.

the point of the aff is to unsettle faith in ultimate meaning through wordplay, metaphors, extreme rhetoric, parralled and jumbled texts accreted around a centralized textual thesisthis interweaving disturbance is the most just and ethical response to the inevitability of violence and subjectivity of meaning. this renders all other impact systems hollow and unworkable. MacDonald, 1999
(Department of Political Studies, Queens University, 1999, Eleanor Science & Society 63.2 Ajones)
In an unusually direct moment in his article, "Force of Law: The AND of a living present. (Derrida, 1994, 64-5.

we are not a total rejection of rational thought and even our acts of logos provide a metaphorical vehicle for mythoswe are indescribably topical Anais Spitzer 11 - Visiting Instructor of Mythology at Prescott College. She has also held positions at Hollins
University, the University of New Mexico, and the College of Santa Fe Pub. ( Derrida, Myth, and the Impossibility of Philosophy Continuum International Publishing Group 04 Aug 2011 ajones)

Chapter 5 takes up the resulting challenge of understanding the relationship of mythos and logos AND thought, and logos provides mythos a vehicle by which to find expression.

this metaphor in the context of transportation within debate is crucial to disturbing the mythos-logos hierarchy without simply reinscribing it Robert Cooper 89 - Department of Behaviour in Organizations, University of Lancaster, U.K. (Modernism, Post
Modernism and Organizational Analysis 3: The Contribution of Jacques Derrida doi: 10.1177/017084068901000402 Organization Studies October 1989 vol. 10 no. 4 479-502 http://oss.sagepub.com/content/10/4/479.short Ajones)

DeconstructionDerrida starts from the position that human experience is pervaded by an existential 'ambivalence' which AND nature of social life and it is precisely this possibility that Derrida's work offers descriptions are creative by naturefailure to embrace affective narration spirals

into nihilsm
Michel de Certeau 84 philosopher, founding member of cole Freudienne de Paris alongside Jacques Lacan ( The Practice of Everyday Life Translated by Steven Rendall UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS Aj ones) Marking out boundaries As operations on places, stories also play the everyday role

AND

) whose essential narrative figures seem to be the frontier and the bridge.

argueing that we break down truth or science is a non sequiter since it was never there to begin with. uniform, stable conceptions of reality are imposisbleeverything is contextual
Chapman, 04 Jake, renowned systems thinker and former professor of energy systems at the Open University (Preface to the second edition, System failure Why governments must learn to think differently, Second edition, First Published 2002, second edition 2004, Demos, http://www.demos.co.uk/files/systemfailure2.pdf)
In System Failure I argue that the dominant approach to policymaking

was based on mechanistic AND link policy and interventions unambiguously because too many other variables are also changing.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi