CLAIM INFORMATION

Owner: Insured: Loss Vehicle: VIN: Odometer: Location: Loss Incident Date: Romeo Radulici Radulici 2005 BMW 330i 4 Door Sedan WBAEV53435KM41956 96,013 Strongsville, OH 44136-6256 05/23/2013 Report Reference Number: Claim Reference: Adjuster: Adjuster ID: Claim Submitted Date: Date/Time Last Updated: Policy Number: 49795777 -3 000287021497D01 Fuller, Melissa MFULM 05/30/2013 05/30/2013 03:22 PM 000980825513

VALUATION SUMMARY
Base Vehicle Value Condition Adjustment Refurbishments Adjusted Vehicle Value $ 12,694.00 + 74.00 + 253.00 $ 13,021.00 This CCC ONE Market Valuation Report was prepared for Allstate by CCC Information Services Inc. The CCC ONE Market Valuation Report reflects CCC's opinion as to the value of the loss vehicle. CCC has been preparing market value reports for the insurance industry since 1981. The Base Vehicle Value is derived from comparable vehicle(s) available or recently sold in the marketplace at the time of valuation, with adjustments made to reflect the loss vehicle configuration. 17 comparable vehicle(s) were utilized in this report. The loss vehicle has been valued in the Central region where it was garaged as a older passenger car with 13% less than average mileage of 110,200.

Vehicular Sales Tax 7.75% $ 1,009.13 Sales Tax reflects all applicable state, county, and municipal taxes. License/Fees (if applicable) DMV Fee Value before Deductible Deductible Total $ ______ + 19.50 $ 14,049.63 - 500.00

$ 13,549.63

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 1 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

VEHICLE ALLOWANCES

Vehicle Allowances Odometer Options Automatic Transmission 6 Speed Transmission Message Center CD Player CD Changer/Stacker Electric Glass Roof Rear Spoiler Reported Not Present Reported Not Present Reported Reported Reported + 500.00 - 500.00 + 84.00 - 150.00 + 300.00 + 500.00 + 150.00 96,013 + 1,125.00

Allowances are factors influencing the value of the loss vehicle when compared to a typical vehicle. The typical vehicle is a vehicle of the same year, make, and model as the loss vehicle, including average mileage, and all standard and predominant equipment. These allowances are displayed for illustrative purposes only. The Base Vehicle Value is calculated from the comparable vehicles with adjustments to reflect the loss vehicle configuration.

VEHICLE HISTORY SUMMARY

Experian AutoCheck No Title Problem Found

Insurance Services Organization/ 0 Record Found National Insurance Crime Bureau National Highway Traffic Safety Administration 1 Recall

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 2 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

LOSS VEHICLE COMPONENTS 2005 BMW 330I 4 DOOR SEDAN STRONGSVILLE, OH 44136-6256 VIN: WBAEV53435KM41956
Below are the components of the loss vehicle, provided to CCC by Allstate, included in this valuation. . Odometer 96,013 AM Radio . Transmission Automatic Transmission Power Power Steering Power Brakes Power Windows Power Locks Power Driver Seat Power Passenger Seat Power Mirrors Power Trunk/Gate Release Decor/Convenience Air Conditioning Climate Control Rear Defogger Intermittent Wipers Tilt Wheel Telescopic Wheel Cruise Control Keyless Entry Console/Storage On Board Computer Message Center Memory Package Seating Leather Seats Reclining/Lounge Seats Bucket Seats Radio Reported Reported Standard Standard Reported Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Reported Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Reported FM Radio Stereo Search/Seek CD Changer/Stacker Premium Radio Steering Wheel Touch Controls Wheels Aluminum/Alloy Wheels Roof Electric Glass Roof Safety/Brakes Drivers Side Air Bag Passenger Air Bag Front Side Impact Air Bags Head/Curtain Air Bags Anti-Lock Brakes (4) 4-Wheel Disc Brakes Traction Control Stability Control Exterior/Paint/Glass Clearcoat Paint Rear Spoiler Fog Lamps Body Side Moldings Dual Mirrors Heated Mirrors Other - Cars Xenon Headlamps Bumper Cushions Standard Reported Reported Reported Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Reported Standard Standard Standard Standard Standard Reported Standard Standard

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 3 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

VEHICLE CONDITION / REFURBISHMENTS

Allstate uses condition inspection guidelines to determine the condition of key components of the loss vehicle. These guidelines are based upon geographic region, age, and vehicle type. The guidelines describe physical characteristics for the major vehicle components. Based on these guidelines, Allstate has determined the condition of the vehicle prior to the loss. Inspection Notes reflect additional observations from the appraiser regarding the loss vehicle's condition. CCC makes dollar adjustments that reflect the impact the reported condition has on the value of loss vehicle. These dollar adjustments are based upon interviews with dealerships across the United States. Allstate also identifies the after factory options and upkeep dollars invested into the loss vehicle that were brought to its attention. CCC makes dollar adjustments that reflect the impact these items have on the resale value of the vehicle, not the replacement value of these items. Maintenance work done to the loss vehicle may not necessarily add to the value of the loss vehicle.

COMPONENT
Interior Seats

CONDITION

VALUE IMPACT
$0

INSPECTION NOTES
LEATHER SEATS, SOME WEAR ON DRIVER'S SEAT. NO TEARS OR MAJOR WEAR ON CARPET. NO MAJOR WEAR NO SAGGING OR DAMAGE TO HEADLINER

INSPECTION GUIDELINES

Private owner

Carpets

Private owner

$0

Dashboard Headliner

Private owner Private owner

$0 $0

Exterior Body Private owner $0 SMALL DENT OVER RT WHEEL WELL, NO RUST, NO LARGE DENTS NO CRACKS OR BULL-EYES NO LARGE SCRATCHES OR FADING/PEELING

Glass Paint

Private owner Dealer

$0 $74

Mechanical Engine Private owner $0 SERVICE MAINTAINED - JUST HAD RECENT REPAIR WORK DONE SERVICE MAINTAINED

Transmission Tires Front Tires

Private owner

$0

Private owner

$0

GOOD TREAD LEFT

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 4 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

VEHICLE CONDITION / REFURBISHMENTS (CONTINUED)

Rear Tires Maintenance Item(s)

Private owner (3 months)

$0 $253

GOOD TREAD LEFT ($1,601 purchase price)

Total Adjustments:

$327

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 5 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

VINGUARD VEHICLE IDENTIFICATION

2005 BMW 330I 4 DOOR SEDAN STRONGSVILLE, OH 44136-6256 VIN: WBAEV53435KM41956

Vehicles sold in the United States are required to have a manufacturer assigned Vehicle Identification Number (VIN). This number provides certain specifications of the vehicle. Decoding the VIN, using VINguard, identifies the vehicle for which vehicle value will be determined. Insurer Description Year Make Model/Trim Model Number Body Style Engine Transmission Restraints Curb Weight This vehicle was assembled in MUNICH, GERMANY 2005 BMW 330i EV53 4 Door Sedan 6-3.0L-FI Automatic Transmission* Air Bags (Driver+Pass.) Air Bags(Dr.+Pass.+Side) 3,285 VINguard Analysis 2005 BMW 330 I EV53 4 Door Sedan 6-3.0l-Fi

VINGUARD VEHICLE HISTORY INFORMATION

VINguard Messages: VINguard has decoded this VIN without any errors. ISO Vehicle History: ISO response indicates no history for this VIN, Number of times reported to ISO: 0 ISO's file number: H0203343948

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 6 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

EXPERIAN AUTOCHECK VEHICLE HISTORY REPORT

CCC provides Allstate information reported by Experian regarding the loss vehicle. This data is provided for informational purposes. Unless otherwise noted in this Market Valuation Report, CCC does not adjust the value of the loss vehicle based upon this information. = No Event Found = Event Found = Information Needed REPORT RUN DATE: 05/30/2013 KEY: TITLE CHECK VEHICLE INFORMATION THIS VEHICLE CHECKS OUT. AutoCheck's result for INFORMATION FOUND. AutoCheck found additional information on this vehicle. These records will provide more this 2005 BMW 330i (WBAEV53435KM41956) show history for this 2005 BMW 330i (WBAEV53435KM41956). no significant title events. When found, events often indicate automotive damage or warnings associated with the vehicle. EVENTS CHECKED RESULTS FOUND Abandoned No Abandoned Record Found Damaged Fire Damage Grey Market Hail Damage Insurance Loss Junk Rebuilt Salvage No Damaged Record Found No Fire Damage Record Found No Grey Market Record Found No Hail Damage Record Found No Insurance Loss Record Found No Junk Record Found No Rebuilt Record Found No Salvage Record Found EVENTS CHECKED Accident Corrected Title Driver Education Duplicate Title Emissions Safety Inspection Fire Damage Incident Lease Lien Livery Use Government Use Police Use Fleet Rental Fleet and/or Lease Fleet and/or Rental Repossessed Taxi use Theft RESULTS FOUND No Accident Record Found No Corrected Title Record Found No Driver Education Record Found No Duplicate Title Record Found Emissions Safety Inspection Record(s) Found No Fire Damage Incident Record Found No Lease Record Found Lien Record(s) Found No Livery Use Record Found No Government Use Record Found No Police Use Record Found No Fleet Record Found No Rental Record Found Fleet and/or Lease Record(s) Found No Fleet and/or Rental Record Found No Repossessed Record Found No Taxi use Record Found No Theft Record Found

EVENT CHECK THIS VEHICLE CHECKS OUT. AutoCheck's result for this 2005 BMW 330i (WBAEV53435KM41956) show no
historical events that indicate a significant automotive problem. These problems can indicate past previous car damage, theft, or other significant problems. EVENTS CHECKED RESULTS FOUND NHTSA Crash Test No NHTSA Crash Test Vehicle Vehicle Record Found Frame Damage Major Damage Incident Manufacturer Buyback/ Lemon Odometer Problem Recycled Salvage Auction Water Damage No Frame Damage Record Found No Major Damage Incident Record Found No Manufacturer Buyback/Lemon Record Found No Odometer Problem Record Found No Recycled Record Found No Salvage Auction Record Found No Water Damage Record Found

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 7 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

EXPERIAN AUTOCHECK VEHICLE HISTORY REPORT (CONTINUED)

ODOMETER CHECK
THIS VEHICLE CHECKS OUT. For this 2005 BMW 330i (WBAEV53435KM41956) no indication of odometer rollback or
tampering was found. AutoCheck determines odometer rollbacks by searching for records that indicate odometer readings less than a previously reported value. Other odometer events can report events of tampering, or possible odometer breakage. DATE REPORTED 2005-01-28 2008-01-07 2008-01-09 2008-02-01 2009-02-25 2009-02-25 2011-12-30 2012-10-17 2012-11-06 ODOMETER READING 7 26969 26969 27009 47434 47000Not included in rollback calculation 78000 83005 83032

FULL HISTORY REPORT RUN DATE: 05/30/2013 Below are the historical events for this vehicle listed in chronological order.
Event Date
2005-01-28 2005-01-28 2005-02-09 2006-04-18 2007-04-11 2007-12-19 2008-01-07 2008-01-09 2008-02-01 2009-02-25 2009-02-25 2009-03-09 2009-12-30 2010-12-30 2011-12-30 2011-12-30 2012-10-17 2012-11-06 2012-12-11

Event Location
FL FORT LAUDERDALE, FL FL FORT LAUDERDALE, FL FORT LAUDERDALE, FL WARNER ROBINS, GA GA GA WARNER ROBINS, GA CLEVELAND, OH OH CLEVELAND, OH CLEVELAND, OH CLEVELAND, OH CLEVELAND, OH OH CLEVELAND, OH STRONGSVILLE, OH STRONGSVILLE, OH

Odometer Reading
7

Data Source
Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept.

Event Detail
ODOMETER READING FROM DMV REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL TITLE (Lien Reported) REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL REPORTED AT AUTO AUCTION AUCTION ANNOUNCED AS FLEET/ LEASE TITLE (Lien Reported) TITLE (Lien Reported) PASSED EMISSION INSPECTION REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL PASSED EMISSION INSPECTION TITLE TITLE (Lien Reported) REGISTRATION EVENT/RENEWAL

26969 26969 27009 47434 47000

Auto Auction Auto Auction Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Independent Emission Source Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept.

78000 83005 83032

Independent Emission Source Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept. Motor Vehicle Dept.

AUTOCHECK TERMS AND CONDITIONS: Experian's Reports are compiled from multiple sources. It is not always possible for Experian to obtain complete
discrepancy information on all vehicles; therefore, there may be other title brands, odometer readings or discrepancies that apply to a vehicle that are not reflected on that vehicle's Report. Experian searches data from additional sources where possible, but all discrepancies may not be reflected on the Report.

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 8 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

EXPERIAN AUTOCHECK VEHICLE HISTORY REPORT (CONTINUED)

These Reports are based on information supplied to Experian by external sources believed to be reliable, BUT NO RESPONSIBILITY IS ASSUMED BY EXPERIAN OR ITS AGENTS FOR ERRORS, INACCURACIES OR OMISSIONS. THE REPORTS ARE PROVIDED STRICTLY ON AN "AS IS WHERE IS" BASIS, AND EXPERIAN FURTHER EXPRESSLY DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING ANY IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE REGARDING THIS REPORT. YOU AGREE TO INDEMNIFY EXPERIAN FOR ANY CLAIMS OR LOSSES, INCLUDING COSTS, EXPENSES AND ATTORNEYS FEES, INCURRED BY EXPERIAN ARISING DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY FROM YOUR IMPROPER OR UNAUTHORIZED USE OF AUTOCHECK VEHICLE HISTORY REPORTS. Experian shall not be liable for any delay or failure to provide an accurate report if and to the extent which such delay or failure is caused by events beyond the reasonable control of Experian, including, without limitation, "acts of God", terrorism, or public enemies, labor disputes, equipment malfunctions, material or component shortages, supplier failures, embargoes, rationing, acts of local, state or national governments, or public agencies, utility or communication failures or delays, fire, earthquakes, flood, epidemics, riots and strikes. These terms and the relationship between you and Experian shall be governed by the laws of the State of Illinois (USA) without regard to its conflict of law provisions. You and Experian agree to submit to the personal and exclusive jurisdiction of the courts located within the county of Cook, Illinois.

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 9 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

NHTSA VEHICLE RECALL

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has issued 1 safety related recall notices that may apply to the above valued vehicle.

NHTSA ID: 11V438000 ISSUED: NO. OF VEHICLES: 241,000 Exterior lighting:Turn signal BMW is recalling certain model year 2002-2005 325I, 325XI, 330I, and 330XI Vehicles manufactured from September 1, 2001, through March 1, 2005. Over time, resistance in the electrical contacts may cause one or more rear lamp functions (Tail light, brake light, and/or turn-signal), within the Vehicle's body panel, to stop working. Intermittent light operation reduces the ability to warn other motorists of the Driver's intentions. This could cause a Vehicle crash without warning. BMW will notify owners, and Dealers will repair the Vehicles free of charge. The safety recall is expected to begin during October 2011. Owners may contact BMW Customer relations and services at 1-800-525-7417.

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 10 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

COMPARABLE VEHICLES
LOSS VEHICLE - 2005 BMW 330I 4 DOOR SEDAN STRONGSVILLE, OH 44136-6256 VIN: WBAEV53435KM41956 LOSS VEHICLE 2005 BMW 330I 4 DOOR SEDAN 6-3.0L-FI Options Automatic Transmission 6 Speed Transmission Power Steering Power Brakes Power Windows Power Locks Power Driver Seat Power Passenger Seat Power Mirrors Power Trunk/Gate Release Air Conditioning Climate Control Rear Defogger Intermittent Wipers Tilt Wheel Telescopic Wheel Cruise Control Keyless Entry Console/Storage Wood Interior Trim On Board Computer Message Center Memory Package Cloth Seats Leather Seats Reclining/Lounge Seats Bucket Seats Heated Seats AM Radio FM Radio Stereo Search/Seek CD Player CD Changer/Stacker Premium Radio INSPECTED DEALER COMPARABLE 1 2006 BMW 330I 4 DOOR SEDAN 6-3.0L INSPECTED DEALER COMPARABLE 2 2006 BMW 330I 4 DOOR SEDAN 6-3.0L PRIVATE ADVERTISED COMPARABLE 3 2006 BMW 330I 4 DOOR SEDAN 6-3.0L

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 11 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

COMPARABLE VEHICLES (CONTINUED)

Steering Wheel Touch Controls Auxiliary Audio Connection Aluminum/Alloy Wheels Electric Glass Roof Drivers Side Air Bag Passenger Air Bag Front Side Impact Air Bags Head/Curtain Air Bags Alarm Anti-Lock Brakes (4) 4-Wheel Disc Brakes Traction Control Stability Control Clearcoat Paint Rear Spoiler Fog Lamps Body Side Moldings Dual Mirrors Heated Mirrors Xenon Headlamps Bumper Cushions Miles List Price Take Price Adjustments Model/Trim/Year Options Mileage Baseline Adjustment Adjusted Value Dealership Contact Telephone Stock ID VIN Type/Date Distance from Strongsville, OH

96,013

92,233 $14,990 $14,990 -2,450 +734 +1,119 -1,396 $12,997 Rankl & Ries Motorscars, Inc. Tad Ries 330-479-2000 Stock: 8539 WBAVB33556PS13256 Inspected 5/24/2013 40 Miles Canton, OH

87,942 $18,995 $16,995 -2,450 +528 +736 -1,396 $14,413 Lindsay Acura Tom Kenworthy 614-863-2885 Stock: P15588 WBAVB335X6PS10613

56,000 $17,900

-2,450 +1,284 -1,378 $15,356 Fyiauto.Com

440-876-7506

110 Miles Columbus, OH

Pub Date 5/10/2013 15 Miles Cleveland, OH

> Comparable vehicles used in the determination of the Base Vehicle Value are not intended to be replacement vehicles but are
reflective of the market value.

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 12 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

COMPARABLE VEHICLES (CONTINUED)

> List Price is the sticker price of an inspected dealer vehicle and the advertised price for the advertised vehicle.Take Price is the

amount that the dealership has stated it will accept to sell the inspected dealer vehicle. For advertised vehicles, the Advertised Price is the same as List Price. > Take Price or List Price displayed above (as applicable) may differ from the advertised price where CCC obtains different price information from the seller. > The baseline is defined as the condition of the typical vehicle on the road. Baseline Adjustments are made when a comparable vehicle's condition varies from that condition level. > The Adjusted Value represents the price of the comparable vehicle with the adjustments displayed above. Dollar adjustments are based upon market research. > Distances displayed indicate approximate miles between loss and comparable vehicle locations. Distances are based upon a straight line between these locations. > Some comparable vehicles that were recently available may no longer be available.

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 13 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

ADDITIONAL COMPARABLE VEHICLES

The following comparable vehicles support the Base Vehicle Value of the loss vehicle.

Local Advertisement
Source Taylor IN Lancaster Ad Date: 05/14/2013 (740) 652-2091 Lancaster OH 117 Miles From Strongsville Motorcars Acura Volvo Ad Date: 04/06/2013 (440) 439-8400 Bedford OH 16 Miles From Strongsville Byers Imports Llc Ad Date: 05/14/2013 (614) 864-5180 Columbus OH 108 Miles From Strongsville Prestige Auto Group Ad Date: 03/16/2013 (330) 634-9999 Tallmadge OH 25 Miles From Strongsville Harrison Auto Sales Inc Ad Date: 05/03/2013 (724) 861-8100 Irwin PA 129 Miles From Strongsville Martin Auto Gallery Inc Ad Date: 05/22/2013 (412) 571-2277 Pittsburgh PA 114 Miles From Strongsville Washington Auto Mall Ad Date: 05/08/2013 (724) 222-2213 Washington PA 114 Miles From Strongsville Autotrader.Com Ad Date: 03/27/2013 (678) 333-5150 Verona PA 118 Miles From Strongsville Vehicle 2005 BMW 330i Odometer: 89,998 VIN: WBAEV534X5KM41663 List Price $ 11,978 Adjusted Value $ 11,488

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 55,618 VIN: WBAVB33586PS05880

$ 16,990

$ 12,176

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 78,311 VIN: WBAVB33596KR74823

$ 14,999

$ 11,750

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 113,220 VIN: WBAVB33566KR78392

$ 12,499

$ 11,705

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 67,047 VIN: WBAVB33576KS33604

$ 14,985

$ 11,181

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 76,388 VIN: WBAVB33566KS32234

$ 16,999

$ 14,326

2005 BMW 330i Odometer: 59,000

$ 15,990

$ 13,574

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 75,687

$ 13,990

$ 11,872

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 14 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

Exceptional Motorcars Ltd Ad Date: 05/15/2013 (412) 487-5006 Glenshaw PA 110 Miles From Strongsville Autotrader.Com Ad Date: 04/12/2013 (215) 718-6693 Pittsburgh PA 111 Miles From Strongsville Carsourceauto.Com Ad Date: 04/10/2013 (614) 801-9400 Grove City OH 119 Miles From Strongsville Germain Toyota Ad Date: 04/04/2013 (866) 264-5951 Columbus OH 110 Miles From Strongsville Crown Eurocars of Dublin Ad Date: 05/06/2013 (866) 747-6013 Dublin OH 108 Miles From Strongsville Village Car Store Ad Date: 03/14/2013 (614) 237-8147 Columbus OH 110 Miles From Strongsville

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 62,000 VIN: WBAVB33576KR79079

$ 15,900

$ 12,183

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 49,600

$ 15,900

$ 12,105

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 99,382

$ 13,495

$ 12,652

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 89,962 VIN: WBAVB33576KR76361

$ 13,000

$ 11,349

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 118,216 VIN: WBAVB33536PS06306

$ 12,750

$ 12,862

2006 BMW 330i Odometer: 104,685 VIN: WBAVB33556KR80926

$ 12,970

$ 11,727

VALUATION METHODOLOGY
Allstate has provided CCC the VIN (Vehicle Identification Number) of the loss vehicle and the vehicle owner's zip code, which determine the market(s) that CCC used in the valuation. Using this information, CCC searches its databases to find comparable vehicles in these markets. CCC's database includes vehicles for sale at dealerships that CCC has physically inspected, as well as dealer and private party advertised vehicle information from numerous resources including AutoTrader.com. Allstate has also provided CCC with the configuration of the loss vehicle, including equipment, odometer, condition, maintenance, etc. Vehicles located are compared to the loss vehicle, and adjustments are made for differences such as model/trim, equipment, and odometer. The comparable vehicles are also adjusted for condition to the baseline. Using the adjusted values of the comparable vehicles, CCC calculates the Base Vehicle Value. The Base Vehicle Value is the weighted average of the adjusted values of the comparable vehicles based on the following factors:

> >

Source of the data (such as inspected versus advertised) Similarity (such as equipment, odometer, and year)

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 15 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

> > >

Proximity to the loss vehicle's primary garage location Recency of information Comparable vehicles used in the determination of the vehicle value are not intended to be replacement vehicles, but are reflective of the market value.

The Adjusted Vehicle Value is determined by adjusting the Base Vehicle Value to account for the actual condition of the loss vehicle and its other reported attributes, if any, such as refurbishments, after factory equipment, and unrelated prior damage. Please review the information in this Valuation Detail to confirm the reported mileage, condition and to verify there are no missed options, added equipment or refurbishments, or other aspects of the loss vehicle that may impact the value.

VALUATION NOTES
The following information was provided after the valuation was completed: 05/30 15:22 A refurbishment was added after valuation. Regulations concerning vehicle value include Ohio Administrative Code 3901-1-54.

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 16 of 17

Owner: Romeo Radulici

Claim Reference: 000287021497D01

MARKET DEFINITION

The loss vehicle has been identified to CCC as a 2005 BMW 330i 4 Door Sedan garaged in the ZIP code 44136-6256 Strongsville, OH. Details of the specific markets searched based upon that information follow.

THE STATE OF OHIO is subdivided by CCC into 12 markets. The following 9 markets were used in the preparation of this vehicle Market Valuation Report. CLEVELAND OH - In this market, CCC maintains a database of 4,076 inspected dealer vehicles located at 23 dealerships, and 40,430 dealer advertised, and 2,878 privately advertised vehicles taken from 15 local papers or magazines. AKRON/CANTON OH - In this market, CCC maintains a database of 6,433 inspected dealer vehicles located at 24 dealerships, and 37,899 dealer advertised, and 2,138 privately advertised vehicles taken from 15 local papers or magazines. YOUNGSTOWN OH - In this market, CCC maintains a database of 2,059 inspected dealer vehicles located at 10 dealerships, and 10,548 dealer advertised, and 743 privately advertised vehicles taken from 11 local papers or magazines. Other markets searched - Erie, Mansfield, Toledo, Central Ohio, Zanesville/Newark and Pittsburgh. In these markets, CCC maintains a database of 17,647 inspected dealer vehicles located at 96 dealerships and 135,744 vehicles taken from 70 local newspapers or magazines. From these 9 markets, comparable vehicles were selected based on the year, make, model/trim and body style of the loss vehicle.

(C) Copyright 2013 CCC Information Services Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Page 17 of 17