IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE MESSAGE NOTIFICATION TECHNOLOGIES LLC, Plaintiff, v.

ORACLE CORPORATION, Defendant. C.A. No. ____________ JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

COMPLAINT FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT Plaintiff Me a!e Notifi"ation Te"#nolo!ie LLC, $% and t#&o'!# it 'nde& i!ned "o'n el, #e&e$% file t#i o&i!inal "o()laint a!ain t t#e a$ove*na(ed defendant, alle!in!, $a ed on it o+n ,no+led!e +it# &e )e"t to it elf and it o+n a"tion , and $a ed on info&(ation and $elief a to all ot#e& (atte& , a follo+ PARTIES 1. Plaintiff Me a!e Notifi"ation Te"#nolo!ie LLC ./Me a!eTe"#01 i a

li(ited lia$ilit% "o()an% fo&(ed 'nde& t#e la+ of t#e State of Dela+a&e, +it# a )&in"i)al )la"e of $' ine 3. in 2il(in!ton, Dela+a&e.

Defendant O&a"le Co&)o&ation ./O&a"le01 i a Dela+a&e "o&)o&ation +it# a in Califo&nia. O&a"le "an $e e&ved +it# )&o"e $% e&vin! it

)&in"i)al )la"e of $' ine

&e!i te&ed a!ent- Co&)o&ation Se&vi"e Co()an%4 3511 Cente&ville Rd, Ste. 677, 2il(in!ton, DE 18979

JURISDICTION AND VENUE :. T#i i an a"tion fo& inf&in!e(ent of a ;nited State )atent a&i in! 'nde& :< '$?e"t (atte& ?'&i di"tion

;.S.C. == 351, 391, and 396>9<, a(on! ot#e& . T#i Co'&t #a of t#e a"tion 'nde& 39 ;.S.C. = 1::1 and = 1::9.a1. 6.

@en'e i )&o)e& in t#i di t&i"t 'nde& 39 ;.S.C. == 1:81 and 1677.$1. ;)on in

info&(ation and $elief, defendant i in"o&)o&ated in t#i di t&i"t, #a t&an a"ted $' ine

t#i di t&i"t, andAo& #a "o((itted andAo& ind'"ed a"t of )atent inf&in!e(ent in t#i di t&i"t. <. Defendant i '$?e"t to t#i Co'&tB )e"ifi" and !ene&al )e& onal

?'&i di"tion 'nde& d'e )&o"e

andAo& t#e Dela+a&e Lon! A&( Stat'te d'e at lea t to '$ tantial $' ine

defendantB #avin! $een in"o&)o&ated in t#i fo&'( andAo& defendantB

in t#i fo&'(, in"l'din!- .i1 at lea t a )o&tion of t#e inf&in!e(ent alle!ed #e&ein4 and .ii1 &e!'la&l% doin! o& oli"itin! $' ine , en!a!in! in ot#e& )e& i tent "o'& e of "ond'"t, andAo& de&ivin! '$ tantial &even'e f&o( !ood and e&vi"e )&ovided to individ'al in Dela+a&e. COUNT I (INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. PATENT NO. 5,944,786 C. On A'!' t :1, 1888, ;nited State Patent No. <,866,59C ./t#e 59C )atent01

+a d'l% and le!all% i 'ed $% t#e ;nited State Patent and T&ade(a&, Offi"e fo& an invention titled /A'to(ati" Notifi"ation of Re"ei)t of Ele"t&oni" Mail .E*(ail1 via Tele)#one S% te( +it#o't ReD'i&in! Lo!*On to E*(ail Se&ve&.0 5. Me a!eTe"# i t#e o+ne& of t#e 59C )atent +it# all '$ tantive &i!#t in

and to t#at )atent, in"l'din! t#e ole and eE"l' ive &i!#t to )&o e"'te t#i a"tion and

enfo&"e t#e 59C )atent a!ain t inf&in!e& , and to "olle"t da(a!e fo& all &elevant ti(e . A t&'e and "o&&e"t "o)% of t#e 59C )atent i atta"#ed #e&eto a EE#i$it A. 9. O&a"le #ad ,no+led!e of t#e 59C )atent at lea t f&o( t#e filin! date andAo&

e&vi"e date of t#e o&i!inal "o()laint a!ain t it fo& inf&in!e(ent of t#e 59C )atent. 8. O&a"le inf&in!ed one o& (o&e "lai( of t#e 59C )atent and i $ein! a""' ed

of doin! o $ot# di&e"tl% and indi&e"tl%. 17. "' to(e& O&a"le, eit#e& alone andAo& in "on?'n"tion +it# ot#e& , in"l'din! t#ei& andAo& '))lie& , (ade, #ad (ade, ' ed, i()o&ted, )&ovided, '))lied,

di t&i$'ted, old, andAo& offe&ed fo& ale 'nified (e a!in! % te( A)&od'"t A e&vi"e t#at, ')on &e"ei)t of an e(ail, a"t'ate a voi"e (ail % te( to end an e*(ail notifi"ation i!nal to a tele)#one node .in"l'din! at lea t % te( A)&od'"t A e&vi"e 'nde& follo+in!

de i!nation- O&a"le ;nified Co(('ni"ation S'ite1 t#at inf&in!ed one o& (o&e "lai( of t#e 59C )atent. 11. O&a"leB "' to(e& andAo& '))lie& di&e"tl% (ade, #ad (ade, ' ed,

i()o&ted, )&ovided, '))lied, di t&i$'ted, old, andAo& offe&ed fo& ale 'nified (e a!in! % te( A)&od'"t A e&vi"e t#at, ')on &e"ei)t of an e(ail, a"t'ate a voi"e (ail % te( to end an e*(ail notifi"ation i!nal to a tele)#one node .in"l'din! at lea t

% te( A)&od'"t A e&vi"e 'nde& follo+in! de i!nation- O&a"le ;nified Co(('ni"ation S'ite1 t#at inf&in!ed one o& (o&e "lai( of t#e 59C )atent. 13. O&a"le ind'"ed inf&in!e(ent andAo& "ont&i$'ted to t#e inf&in!e(ent of one

o& (o&e of t#e "lai( of t#e 59C )atent $% it "' to(e& andAo& '))lie& . 1:. t#e 59C )atent. O&a"leB inf&in!e(ent +a +illf'l at lea t f&o( t#e date it #ad ,no+led!e of

16.

Me a!eTe"# #a $een da(a!ed a a &e 'lt of t#e inf&in!in! "ond'"t $%

defendant alle!ed a$ove. T#' , defendant i lia$le to Me a!eTe"# in an a(o'nt t#at adeD'atel% "o()en ate Me a!eTe"# fo& '"# inf&in!e(ent , +#i"#, $% la+, "annot $e le t#an a &ea ona$le &o%alt%, to!et#e& +it# inte&e t and "o t a fiEed $% t#i Co'&t 'nde&

:< ;.S.C. = 396. JURY DEMAND Me a!eTe"# #e&e$% &eD'e t a t&ial $% ?'&% on all i 'e PRAYER FOR RELIEF Me a!eTe"# &eD'e t t#at t#e Co'&t find in it favo& and a!ain t t#e defendant and t#at t#e Co'&t !&ant Me a!eTe"# t#e follo+in! &eliefa. F'd!(ent t#at one o& (o&e "lai( of t#e 59C )atent #ave $een inf&in!ed, o t&ia$le $% &i!#t.

eit#e& lite&all% andAo& 'nde& t#e do"t&ine of eD'ivalent , $% defendant andAo& $% ot#e& to +#o e inf&in!e(ent defendant #a "ont&i$'ted andAo& $% ot#e& +#o e inf&in!e(ent #a $een ind'"ed $% defendant4 $. A )e&(anent in?'n"tion en?oinin! defendant and it offi"e& , di&e"to& ,

a!ent , e&vant , affiliate , e()lo%ee , divi ion , $&an"#e , '$ idia&ie , )a&ent , and all ot#e& a"tin! in a"tive "on"e&t t#e&e+it# f&o( inf&in!e(ent, ind'"in! inf&in!e(ent of, o& "ont&i$'tin! to inf&in!e(ent of t#e 59C )atent4 ". F'd!(ent t#at defendant a""o'nt fo& and )a% to Me a!eTe"# all da(a!e

to and "o t in"'&&ed $% Me a!eTe"# $e"a' e of defendantB inf&in!in! a"tivitie and ot#e& "ond'"t "o()lained of #e&ein4

d.

T#at Me a!eTe"# $e !&anted )&e*?'d!(ent and )o t*?'d!(ent inte&e t on

t#e da(a!e "a' ed $% defendantB inf&in!in! a"tivitie and ot#e& "ond'"t "o()lained of #e&ein4 e. T#at t#i Co'&t de"la&e t#i an eE"e)tional "a e and a+a&d Me a!eTe"# it

&ea ona$le atto&ne% B fee and "o t in a""o&dan"e +it# :< ;.S.C. = 39<4 and f. T#at Me a!eTe"# $e !&anted '"# ot#e& and f'&t#e& &elief a t#e Co'&t (a%

dee( ?' t and )&o)e& 'nde& t#e "i&"'( tan"e .

Dated- Nove($e& 11, 371: OF CO;NSELGa"#a&ia# S. Ha&&in!ton Matt#e+ F. Antonelli La&&% D. T#o() on, F&. ANTONELLI, HARRINGTON H THOMPSON LLP 6377 Mont&o e Ilvd., Ste. 6:7 Ho' ton, TJ 5577C .51:1 <91*:777 Ka"La#tla+fi&(."o( (attLa#tla+fi&(."o( la&&%La#tla+fi&(."o(

IAMARD, P.A. /s/ Stephen B. Brauerman Ri"#a&d D. Ni&, .&,78331 Ste)#en I. I&a'e&(an . $68<31 @ane a R. Ti&adente .vt<:891 Sa&a E. I' ie&e . $<53<1 333 Dela+a&e Aven'e, S'ite 877 P.O. IoE 3<1:7 2il(in!ton, DE 18988 .:731 C<<*<777 &,i&,L$a%a&dla+."o( $&a'e&(anL$a%a&dla+."o( vti&adente L$a%a&dla+."o( $' ie&eL$a%a&dla+."o( Attorneys for Message Notification Technologies LLC

<