Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION:
Steam generators, or boilers as they are often called, form an essential part of any power plant
or cogeneration system. The steam-based Rankine cycle has been synonymous with power generation
for centuries. Though steam parameters such as pressure and temperature have been steadily
ncreasing during the last several decades, the function of the boiler remains the same, namely, to
generate steam at the desired conditions efficiently and with low operating costs. Low pressure steam is
used in cogeneration plants for heating or process applications, and high pressure superheated steam
are used for generating power via steam turbines. Steam is used in a variety of ways in process
industries, so boilers form an important part of the plant utilities. In addition to efficiency and operating
costs, another factor that has introduced several changes in the design of boilers and associated systems
is the stringent emission regulations in various parts of the world.
Though pulverized coal–fired boilers form the backbone of utility plants, fluidized bed boilers
are finding increasing application when it comes to handling solid fuels with varying moisture, ash, and
heating values; they also generate lower emissions of NOx and SOx. Oil- and gas-fired fire tube boilers
are widely used in small process plants for generating low pressure saturated steam.
Main uses of these systems are found in:
Generation of power
Process industry like paper, textile etc.
Centrally heating offices/homes.
i. BOILER CLASSIFICATION:
The terms boiler and steam generator are often used in the same context. Boilers may be
classified into several categories as follows:
A) Application:
Utility
Marine or
Industrial boiler.
Utility boilers are the large steam generators used in power plants generating 500–1000MW of
electricity. They are generally fired with pulverized coal, though fluidized bed boilers are popping up in
some plants. Utility boilers generate high pressure, high temperature superheated and reheat steam;
typical parameters are 2400 psig, 1000 F. A few utility boilers generate supercritical steam at pressures
in excess of 3500 psig, 1100 F. Double reheat cycles are also in operation. Industrial boilers used in
cogeneration plants generate low pressure steam at 150 psig to superheated steam at 1500 psig at
temperatures ranging from 700 to 1000 F.
B) Pressure:
Low to medium pressure
High pressure, and
Supercritical pressure.
C) Circulation method:
Natural,
Controlled,
Once-through, or
Combined circulation
Natural circulation is widely used for up to 2400psig steam pressure. There is no operating cost
incurred for ensuring circulation through the furnace tubes, because gravity aids the circulation process.
Controlled and combined circulation boilers use pumps to ensure circulation of a steam–water mixture
through the evaporator tubes. Supercritical boilers are of the once-through type. It may be noted that
once-through designs can be employed at any pressure, whereas supercritical pressure boilers must be
of a once-through design.
D) Firing Methods:
Stoker
cyclone furnace
fluidized bed
register burner
fixed or moving grate
E) Construction:
Field-erected
Shop-assembled
Muhammad Uzair Barry +92-333-4425262
University of engineering and technology, Lahore, Pakistan
Large industrial and utility boilers are field-erected, whereas small packaged fire tube boilers up
to 90,000 lb/h capacity and water tube boilers up to 250,000 lb/h are generally assembled in the shop.
Depending on shipping dimensions, these capacities could vary slightly.
Fire-Tube Boilers:
The firetube boiler requires a “shell” to enclose the
water and steam to complete the pressure vessel portion of the
boiler and that shell is the principal limit on the size of a firetube
boiler.
To understand why the shell is the limiting factor we
have to understand some basics about strength of materials and
how we determine the required thickness of the shell, tubes,
Since the outer shell of a firetube boiler is very large it has to be quite thick. Thicker materials
require more elaborate construction practices in addition to more weight so the price of a boiler
increases proportional to its diameter with sudden large steps in price associated with different
construction rules depending on the thickness and temperature.
A big break point for high pressure boilers come at 1/2 inch thick and 650°F. The increasing
thickness has imposed a normal limit on firetube boilers of 250 psig MAWP (maximum allowable
working pressure). It’s possible to get a firetube boiler for a higher pressure but it’s not a common one.
The other practical limit on the size of a firetube boiler is its diameter. Anything larger than 8 feet 6
inches in diameter will require special permits for transporting it.
2. Locomotive boiler:
A locomotive boiler is a good example of a firetube boiler modified to provide some water
cooling of the furnace. The increased cost of the boiler to create a water jacket around the furnace was
justified for locomotive service because the steel and water were considerably lighter than the
refractory that would be required while providing more heating surface to make the locomotive more
powerful. Stay bolts are used to hold the flat surfaces against the internal pressure and their failure was
one reason many of these boilers are no longer around.
3. Firebox Boiler:
The firebox boiler was the first potential “package” boiler because it only required construction of
an insulated base in the field with all other parts assembled in the factory. A partial form of the boiler was
also built to provide comparable performance at lower construction and shipping costs by requiring
construction of part of the furnace as a brickwork base then setting the boiler on top of that base
The locomotive boiler is a basic single pass design. The flue gases enter the boiler proper and
flow through all the tubes to the outlet of the boiler. The HRT design provided improved heat transfer by
providing two passes, the flue gases are turned and return down a portion of the tubes on their way to
the stack.
Note that a pass consists of a path for flue gas to travel from one extreme end of the flue gas
containing parts of the boiler to another. Neither of these designs required a baffle to direct the flow of
flue gas. Scotch marine designs can have two, three, or four passes. A two pass scotch marine boiler
requires no baffles other than means to separate the burner from the returning flue gas. Three pass
scotch marine construction requires one baffle in the rear of the boiler to separate the first and second
pass turning box from the third pass outlet while four pass boilers require a baffle there plus one at the
front to separate the second and third pass turning box from the fourth pass outlet
Sometimes furnace tubes are called Morrison tubes, and it’s done without distinction. Some
furnace tubes are not Morrison tubes; they’re the ones that are basically a simple cylinder. Morrison is
the guy that realized the furnace tube could be made thinner and still withstands the external pressure
without collapsing if it was corrugated. If the tube is corrugated it’s a Morrison tube and if it’s not it’s
just a furnace tube.
There are many advantages to a scotch marine firetube boiler which includes simplicity in
design. They’re relatively easy to clean completely on the fire side, once you get those heavy doors off.
They can be packaged in most of the sizes, they contain minimal refractory. Tube replacement is less
expensive because all the tubes are straight. They also hold a larger volume of water compared to a
watertube boiler so they absorb load swings a little better.
Water-Tube Boilers:
Water tube boilers just like firetube boilers need a shell to contain the water and steam most
watertube boilers require drums or headers to close off the ends of the tubes, provide a path for the
water and steam to flow into and out of the tubes, and provide a place for steam and water to separate.
The difference between the header and drum is that drums are big and headers are small. That rule
doesn’t always work when it comes to what we call a mud drum which is the lowest drum in a boiler and
has connecting piping for blowoff so the mud can be removed from the boiler.
Waterwalls consist of tubes that may be bent to connect to a steam or mud drum or connect to
a header that is connected to one of the drums with more tubes.
The bottom two rows of tubes are called screen tubes because they form a screen that blocks
the radiant energy from the superheater. They also protect the baffle. The sectional header part of this
boiler involved the forged square headers shown in the detail which were connected to the steam drum
and bottom header by tube nipples (short lengths of tube) and contained hand holes on the side to gain
access to the tube ends so they could be rolled. The headers were forged in a semi-square shape to
provide a uniform surface for rolling the tubes. Drums are normally of sufficient diameter that there is
no problem rolling a tube in them. To gain access to the tube ends to roll them and for other parts the
drums have manholes, usually a 12-inch by 16-inch oval opening.
Water separated from the steam and boiler feedwater mixes in the steam drum (a common
arrangement) then drops down the front header s (which are exposed to the coolest flue gas) and rises
up the sloped tubes going from the front of the boiler to the rear. In those tubes the water is heated to
the point of saturation and starts boiling, changing from water to steam. The steam forms small bubbles
in the water, displacing the heavier water and reducing the density of the steam and water mixture as it
travels along the tube.
A Type boiler:
The A shape is attributed to the single steam drum at the center top and the two mud drums,
commonly called headers, at the bottom. They require a second blow down line and more soot blowers
but provided features like a water cooled furnace from one end to the other and balanced construction
which makes them easy to transport as package boilers.
O Type boiler:
The O type boiler (Figure 9-20) is similar to the A while
eliminating one header by providing a drum in the bottom center
just like the top. The headers required many handholes for rolling
the tubes in an A type boiler so the single drum eliminated that
expense but produced a boiler with a smaller furnace cross
section.
D Type boiler:
The predominant design is the D type (Figure 9-21) which has only one drawback and that’s the
problem with transporting and supporting something with most of the weight on one side. The D tubes
extend out of the drum to form the roof of the furnace, drop to form the furnace side wall, and return under
the furnace to the mud drum. It has one convection bank of tubes centered between the drums to limit
sootblower requirements. This construction makes it possible for the flue gas to leave the boiler via the
front or side.
A more
detailed diagram shows some of the standard features of this construction:
Generally water tube boilers are suitable for large gas flows exceeding millions of pounds per
hour and can handle high steam pressures and temperatures. Fire tubeboilers are suitable for low steam
pressures, generally below 500psig. Table shows the effect of pressure on tube thickness in both types
of boilers, and one can see why fire tube boilers are not suggested for high steam pressure applications.
In water tube boilers, extended surfaces can be used to make them compact if the gas stream is
clean. Flue gas pressure drop will also be lower than for an equivalent fire tube boiler owing to the
compactness of the design. Water tube boilers can be smaller and weigh less, particularly if the gas flow
is large, exceeding 100,000 lb/h. Superheaters can be used in both types. In a water tube boiler they can
be located in an optimum gas temperature zone. A shield screen section or a large convection section
precedes the superheater. In a fire tube boiler, the superheater has to be located at either the gas inlet
or exit, making the design less flexible and vulnerable to slagging or corrosion. If the waste gas is
slagging in nature, a water tube boiler is desired because the surfaces can be cleaned by using
retractable soot blowers.
ii. Drum:
The purpose of the drum is to separate water from steam. Its lower part is full of water. It comes
from the economizer through tubes external to the boiler or if it is missing, directly from the feed
pumps. The upper part is filled with steam instead taken from the main valve. If the superheater is
included, the steam passes through the entry header of the latter instead.
In big radiation units, downcomers are inserted into the lower part of the drum feeding the
steam-generating tubes of the bank (if there is one), as well as the screens of the furnace. Return tubes
coming from the upper headers are inserted laterally into the drum.
iii. Superheaters:
Superheaters may be of
convection type superheater or
radiation type superheater
1. Radiation-type superheaters:
Radiation-type superheaters are those placed along the walls of the furnace. In small
generators, this solution is used at times for superheaters that push up the steam temperature by a few
dozen degrees above the temperature of the saturated steam. The goal is to dry the steam taken from
the drum and to bring it to such a temperature that it reaches the machines it is meant for, still
saturated and dry, regardless of the heat loss occurring in the external piping between generator and
usage. These superheaters are done by substituting some of the steam-generating tubes on the walls of
the furnace with the tubes of the superheater. The location is in the terminal part of the furnace. This
way, the tubes will not see the flame from the front.
Superheaters placed along the walls of the furnace are used even in very large units. In that
case, they represent the first stage of the superheater (primary superheater). This prevents the
temperature of the fluid inside the tubes to increase too much.
Hanging superheaters of radiation-type are called SH platen, if they are placed at the exit of the
furnace and consist of far apart coils (see Fig. 3.35). In fact, in this case, the heat transferred directly
from the flame, or through radiation by the flue gas at high temperature, is greater than the heat
transferred by convection, given the low velocity of the gas and the value of the so-called mean beam
length.
The steam temperature in packaged boilers is often controlled from 60%to 100% load
by using a two-stage superheater design with interstage attemperation as shown in Fig. 3.18. Steam
temperature can also be maintained from 10% to 100%; however, this calls for a much larger
superheater surface area. Demineralized water should be used for attemperation, because it does not
add solids to the steam. The solids in the feedwater used for attemperation should be in the 30–100
ppb. If solids are deposited inside the superheater, the tubes can become overheated, particularly if
operated at high loads and high heat flux conditions. The convective superheaters are generally
oversized at 100% load as explained earlier. The quantity of water spray is larger at higher load. In the
radiant design, the steam temperature remains nearly flat over the load range because the radiant
component of energy increases at lower loads and decreases at higher loads. Thus many radiant
superheaters do not use a two-stage design.
The steam temperature in packaged boilers is often controlled from 60%to 100% load by using a
two-stage superheater design with interstage attemperation as shown in Fig. 3.18. Steam temperature
can also be maintained from 10% to 100%; however, this calls for a much larger superheater surface
area. Demineralized water should be used for attemperation, because it does not add solids to the
steam. The solids in the feedwater used for attemperation should be in the 30–100 ppb. If solids are
deposited inside the superheater, the tubes can become overheated, particularly if operated at high
loads and high heat flux conditions. The convective superheaters are generally oversized at 100% load as
explained earlier. The quantity of water spray is larger at higher load. In the radiant design, the steam
temperature remains nearly flat over the load range because the radiant component of energy increases
at lower loads and decreases at higher loads. Thus many radiant superheaters do not use a two-stage
design.
However, reviewing other concerns such as possible overheating of tubes and higher tube wall
temperatures, the choice is left to the user. When demineralized water is not available, a portion of the
saturated steam from the drum is taken and cooled in a heat exchanger, preheating the feedwater as
shown in Fig. 3.18. The condensed water is then sprayed into the attemperator between the two stages
of the superheater. Often, in order to balance the pressure drops in the two parallel paths, a resistance
is introduced into each path or the exchanger is located vertically up, say 30–40 ft above the boiler, to
provide additional head for the spray water control valve operation.
Spraying downstream of the superheater for steam temperature control is not recommended,
because the steam temperature at the superheater exit increases with load, thus increasing the
superheater tube wall temperature, which can lead to tube failures. For example, if 800_F is the final
steam temperature desired, the steam temperature at the superheater exit may run as high as 875–
925_F, which will diminish the life of the tubes over a period of time. Also, the water droplets may not
evaporate completely in the piping and the steam turbine could end up with water droplets and the
solids present in the water, leading to deposits on turbine blades.
To prevent problems with water depositing in them many superheaters are designed to drain
completely by installing the headers at the bottom with the tubes extending up from the headers. We
call them “drainable” superheaters. Boilers in most utility plants are of a construction that doesn’t drain,
the tubes hang down from the headers into the furnace or flue gas passages and they’re called
“pendant” type superheaters.
Economizer with
steel finned tubes
v. Air Heater:
Air heaters are used in a few waste heat boilers for preheating combustion air. Incineration
plants and reformer furnaces also use preheated air. Like the economizer, the air heater is installed to
reduce the temperature of the flue gas entering the chimney and improve the generator efficiency. Note
that a reduction of 20◦C of this temperature roughly corresponds to an increase in efficiency of 1%. The
air heater cools the flue gas, it also heats the combustion air, this way increasing the heat going into the
furnace. This strongly influences the sizing of the furnace, the amount of heat radiated by the flame, as
well as the exit temperature of the flue gas from the furnace.
Muhammad Uzair Barry +92-333-4425262
University of engineering and technology, Lahore, Pakistan
One of the problems with regenerative air heaters is the leakage of air from the flue gas side
that affects the power consumption and efficiency of the fan. Though the leakage may be low, on the
Once-Through Units:
A once-through HRSG (called an OTSG) does not have a steam drum like a natural or forced
circulation unit (Fig. 2.12). An OTSG is simply made up of serpentine coils like an economizer. Because
water is converted to steam inside the tubes, the water should have nearly zero solids. Otherwise
deposition of solids can occur inside the tubes to the complete evaporation process. This in turn can
lead to overheating of the tubes and consequent tube failure, particularly if the heat flux inside the
tubes is high. Like natural or forced circulation units, these units generate single- or multiple-pressure
saturated or superheated steam. A once-through unit does not have a defined economizer, evaporator,
and superheater section. The location at which boiling starts keeps moving depending upon the gas
flow, inlet gas temperature, and duty. The single-point control for the OTSG is the feedwater control
valve; valve actuation depends on predefined operating conditions that are set through the distributed
control system (DCS). The DCS is connected to a feedforward and feedback control loop, which monitors
the transients in the gas turbine load and steam conditions. If a transient in the gas turbine load is
monitored, the feedforward control sets the feedwater flow to a predicted value based on the turbine
exhaust temperature, producing steady-state superheated steam conditions.
Because there is no steam drum, the water holdup is much less than in drum-type units. Often
Alloy 800 or 825 tubes are used to ensure dry running and also to limit the sensitivity to oxygen in the
water, avoiding the need for active chemical treatment.
SOOT BLOWING
Soot blowing is often resorted to in coal-fired or heavy oil–fired boilers. In packaged boilers,
both steam and air have been used as the blowing media, and both have been effective with heavy oil
firing. Rotary blowers are sometimes used with distillate oil firing. Steam-blowing systems must have a
minimum blowing pressure of 170–200 psig to be effective. The steam system must be warmed up prior
to blowing to minimize condensation. The steam must be dry. Increasing the capacity of a steam system
Muhammad Uzair Barry +92-333-4425262
University of engineering and technology, Lahore, Pakistan
is easier than increasing that of an air system. With an air system, the additional capacity of the
compressor must be considered. Also, because steam has a higher heat transfer coefficient than air,
more air is required for cooling the lances in high gas temperature regions compared to steam.
Moisture droplets in steam can cause erosion of tubes, and often tube shields are required to
protect the tubes. The intensity of the retractable blower jet is more than that of the rotary blower jet,
and its blowing radius is larger, thus cleaning more surface area. However, one must be concerned
about the erosion or wear on the tubes.
Sonic cleaning has been tried on a few boilers. In this system, low frequency high energy sound
waves are produced when compressed air enters a sound generator and forces a diaphragm to flex. The
resulting sound waves cause particulate deposits to resonate and dislodge from the surfaces. Once
dislodged, they are removed by gravity or by the flowing gases. Typical frequencies range from 75 to 33
Hz. Sticky particles are difficult to clean. The nondirectional nature of the sound waves minimizes
accumulation in blind spots where soot blowers are ineffective. Piping work is minimal. Sonic blowers
operate on plant air at 40–90 psi and sound off for 10 s every 10–20 min.