Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
P i m a C ou n t y Me d i c a l S o c i e t y A p r i l 2012
Home Medical Society of the 17th United States Surgeon-General
MEMBER
The more you know, the safer your money.
MAIN OFFICE | 4400 E. Broadway | Tucson, AZ 85711 | Tel (520) 321-4500 | Fax (520) 321-1956 NORTHWEST OFFICE | 6400 N. Oracle Rd | Tucson, AZ 85704 | Tel: (520) 219-5000 | Fax: (520) 219-1100 www.bankoftucson.com
Vol. 45 No. 4
Neil Clements, MD Michael Connolly, DO Bruce Coull, MD (UA College of Medicine) Alton Hank Hallum, MD Evan Kligman, MD Melissa D. Levine, MD Lorraine L. Mackstaller, MD Clifford Martin, MD Kevin Moynahan, MD Soheila Nouri, MD Jane M. Orient, MD Guruprassad Raju, MD Scott Weiss, MD Victor Sanders, MD (resident) Cambel Berk (student) Christopher Luckow (student) Art Director Alene Randklev, Commercial Printers, Inc. Phone: 623-4775 Fax: 622-8321 E-mail: alene@cptucson.com Printing Commercial Printers, Inc., Andy Charles Phone: 623-4775 E-mail: andy@cptucson.com
Members at Large
Kenneth Sandock, MD Richard Dale, MD
Board of Mediation
Bennet E. Davis, MD Thomas F. Griffin, MD Charles L. Krone, MD Edward J. Schwager, MD Eric B. Whitacre, MD
Publisher Pima County Medical Society Steve Nash, Executive Director 5199 E. Farness Drive, Tucson, AZ 85712 Phone: (520) 795-7985 Fax: (520) 323-9559 E-MAIL: steve5199@simplybits.net Website: pimamedicalsociety.org
SOMBRERO (ISSN 0279-909X) is published monthly except bimonthly June/July and August/ September by the Pima County Medical Society, 5199 E. Farness, Tucson, Ariz. 85712. Annual subscription price is $30. Periodicals paid at Tucson,
Arizona. POSTMASTER: send address changes to Pima County Medical Society, 5199 E. Farness Drive, Tucson, Arizona 85712-2134. Opinions expressed are those of the individuals and do not necessarily represent the opinions or policies of the publisher or the PCMS Board of Directors, Executive Ofcers or the members at large, nor does any product or service advertised carry the endorsement of the society unless expressly stated. Paid advertisements are accepted subject to the approval of the Board of Directors, which retains the right to reject any advertising submitted. Copyright 2012, Pima County Medical Society. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.
.4 acre private lot, 3,121 sq ft, split 4 bdrm, 2.5 bath plan. Large eat-in-kitchen plus adjoining great room with replace. Spacious living/dining rooms. Sparkling pool. 3 car garage.
PRIVATE LOT
$499,000
Stunning southwest contemporary on 3.3 acre lot adjacent to Cornado National Forest, 4,337 sf, 4 bdrm, 3.5 bath, plank & beam ceilings, 3 replaces, Pebble Tec pool/spa, huge 3 car garage +200 sf hobby room.
AWESoME VIEWS
$899,000
Madeline Friedman
ABR, CRS, GRI
Madeline is Your Connection to Tucsons Favorite Neighborhoods! www.tucsonazhomes.com TucsonHomeFinder@aol.com
296-1956 888-296-1956
Vice President
CONTENTS
5 6 7 11 14 20 22
Presidents Page
When EMRs make non-meaningful use.
DEPAR TMEN TS
Conferences & Seminars................ 26 Members Classieds..................... 26
PCMS News
History tour is soon; St. Es needs you.
Membership
A look at Western Neurologys three-year-old partnership in Carondelet Neurological Institute.
Time Capsule
The State of Arizona is 100 years old this year and its birthday was Feb. 14. Also, Dr. Samuel Paplanus recalls The Pus Club. On the Cover
Hobbles Off and Back to Work, by Western and y shing artist Rockwell E. Rock Jackson, M.D., is a modern portrait from a Wyoming cattle ranch in summer, echoing the Old West and some ways that have not changed since. A young cowboy, after taking his chuckwagon break, removes the hobbles from his horse. Hobbles link the forelegs closely enough to stop the horse from running off.
Reality Check
Dr. Michael S. Smith says the United States would be more united if more of us gave back to the country.
Travel
Dr. George Makol reports from his UofA alumni adventure to Antarctica.
Support
To find our way through the wilderness of grief, we often need guides that can provide some direction. It is into this task we have entered to assist others on this difficult journey. Frank Williams
Director of Social Services
Casa de la Luz Hospice offers sensitive medical, emotional, and spiritual support to individuals and their loved ones during the final phase of life. Contact us for more information.
PResIDents paGe
and code level then seem to be the paramount factor in that physicians mind. Similarly, including verbiage from coding in your note is worrisome: I saw Mrs. Smith in a limited problem oriented fashion The Template. This is probably the funniest of notes. EMR systems allow you to build templates of text that are used repeatedly. Just click on a button and the template is incorporated in your note. But it is imperative to pick the right template; otherwise you get the double mastectomy patient with a symmetric breast exam, the male patient whose vault and vagina are clear, or the pediatric patient with a normal prostate exam. The Discharge Document. I have seen examples of hospitals, ERs and skilled nursing facilities simply printing medical administration records from the chart and giving it to the patient as their outpatient medication list. The hospital MARs of course include all kinds PRN meds, laxatives, analgesics, sleepers, and emergency medications not intended for home use. The MAR may also list a medication that is on the hospital formulary, but the patient was taking an alternate brand at home. So on hospital follow up, the patient is taking Nexium and Aciphex at the same time (and spending money on both). Electronic Gibberish. Voice-recognition software such as Dragon Dictation is great for busy physicians needing to put text into a note. I use it myself. It can eliminate transcription costs (tell your kids to not go into transcription as a career!) But it can misunderstand what you are saying and type sound-alike words that are completely unrelated to your meaning. So, if using voice-recognition, careful editing is mandatory. Also, a good idea may be to place a disclaimer at the end of your note: Voice recognition technology used in generating this note. Sound-alike errors may have been missed in editing. The Blank Template. Hospital ERs and urgent-cares are notorious for using visit templates that have a blank for every eventuality. Frequently these are left blank and faxed to me with a hand notation of see dictation. Save my printer ink! Either use the template or simply generate a customary EMR note. Electronic medical records are unquestionably a great advance in record keeping, and I am one of their biggest fans. EMRs have improved things from legibility to reduced liability, yet with every new technology comes a downside. I am worried that buried in all the redundant information is some clinically relevant piece of information I missed by just reading the last paragraph. When every note has exactly the same physical exam, its going to be a problem in court when the plaintiff s attorney claims no actual examination was doneit was just an added template. Plaintiff s attorneys apparently have not caught onto this yet. We as physicians are always pledged to do the best for our patients, and part of that is keeping clear, efcient, and concise medical records. Now that we are in the electronic age, we must keep our records meaningful.
5
pcms neWs
Before retiring, Dr. Richard Switzer would triage patients with suspected urological problems at the clinic. St. Es is hoping to nd another urologist willing to take on this important role. Referrals to specialists ofces can be arranged on a rotating basis or limited by the number of patients seen. St. Es is especially looking to build the pool of neurologists willing to see St. Es patients. Any physician interested in learning more about helping the uninsured patients of St. Elizabeths should call Dr. Mark Schildt at 628.7871.
Looking upway up
Astronomy has long been one of Sombrero columnist Dr. Mike Smiths passions. He notes that on May 20, an annular (ring) eclipse of the sun will be visible from the Grand Canyon, points northwest (Bryce and Zion), and southeast (path goes through Albuquerque and Lubbock). These must be viewed with solar lters, he said, but those are easy to obtain, and the large black disk of the moon in the middle of the sun and obscuring 90 percent of it is a stunning view, especially from the Grand Canyon. On June 5, late afternoon viewing of the exceedingly rare transit of Venus across the disk of the sun takes place. The next one wont be until December 2117, so come see a ltered viewso you dont fry your retinaeof Venus in front of the sun, Dr. Smith said. The three-dimensionality of the view is remarkable, and the transit will be visible until sunset. PCMS plans to host a Venus viewing party on the afternoon of June 5 so watch for details and plan on stopping by.
8
will be in Tucson in November for events, including a dinner lecture for physicians and spouses at the Arizona Inn. The evening is presented by Casa de la Luz Foundation. Dr. Byocks speech topic has not been given, but his book addresses the sorry state of dying in America and argues we must move past politics and our aversion as a society to acknowledge the fact of mortality so we can live emotionally authentic, healthier, more joyful lives. Sombrero will carry details as they are announced, but if you would like to learn more, and get the event on your calendar, you may call 544.9890 and ask for Carol Clark.
Pima County Medical Society, along with Carondelet Health Network and El Rio Health Centers, is in the national organization Just Walk/Walk With A Doc, and started programs for patients to walk with a physician this year. PCMS, CHN and El Rio each host one walk on three different Saturdays every month through May, and probably will throughout the summer and into fall. Each walk is led by a physician who will give a brief overview of the benets of exercise, and answer general questions during the walk. You can send your patients to any of the walks. Sample prescription pads were sent in our newsletter. Walks are open to anyone, and courses are generally at with some small hills. Advise patients to wear comfortableshoes. They may bring a cane or walking stick, and a bottle of water. Patients should be advised that a monthly walk should not be their only physical activity, but we want them to gain condence and a safe place to start walking. Walk schedules are posted at www.pimamedicalsociety.org. PCMS walks continue April 14, May 12, and June 9. Please arrive between 6:30 and 6:50 a.m. Walks will begin at 7 a.m. For any questions, please call 795.7985. The website is www.walkwithadoc.org.
10
memBeRsHIp
Dr. Matt P. Wilson, who specializes in spine and brain surgery, does a leg stretch test as part of a back exam on a patient. He also specializes in stereotactic radiosurgery, a form of tumor therapy focusing powerful X-ray beams of radiation using sub-millimeter precision. We have one of the newest machines for this at St. Josephs, Dr. Robert Goldfarb said. (Carondelet photo by Tom Spitz).
a big addition; it allowed us to see and operate on microscopic structures. He noted that in the 1970s, he helped to bring the rst CT scanner to a local hospital, Tucson Medical Center. EMI made it; they were big in the scanner business, he said. He also helped to bring the rst brain navigation device to TMC in late 1980. (EMIs familiarity to many Americans is because it owned Parlophone Records in England and later Capitol Records here, which manufactured and distributed the Beatles records.) Weve been very busy, Dr. Goldfarb said. The center has continued to grow, and weve expanded programs with sub-specialists. CNI has 54 beds, 12 of which are a neurological care unit, the only one in Southern Arizona, he said The medical director, Dr. Adaeze Onuoha, has fellowship training in neurocritical care neurology. Western/CNIs Southern Arizona innovations include the rst CT scanner in an OR, integration with the latest technology, and the rst hospital in North America to collaborate with Brain Lab and Siemens to fully integrate CT navigation in the OR, Dr. Goldfarb said. He added that CNI has a Joint Commission-certied stroke center and brain and spine tumor center, referring to the federal Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Care Organizations, formerly JACO, begun in 1951 as the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals and now known just as the Joint Commission. We are the rst private hospital in Tucson to have received that status, Dr. Goldfarb said. Dr. Goldfarb graduated from Tulane University School of Medicine in 1962 and interned at Michael Reese Hospital and Medical Center in Chicago. He did his GS residency at PresbyterianSt. Lukes Hospital and neurology residency at University of Illinois
11
Dr. Diana V. Benenati, neurologist who specializes in neuromuscular disorders (and is a PCMS Board of Directors member), does part of an EMG to test a patients nerve conduction time (Carondelet photo by Tom Spitz).
Dr. Goldfarb calls Westerns physicians super-specialists. They are: Neurosurgery Hillel Z. Baldwin, M.D., minimally invasive spine and skull base surgery. Joseph A. Christiano, Jr., M.D., Parkinsons and other movement disorders surgery, chronic pain, brain and spine surgery. Robert P. Goldfarb, M.D., F.A.C.S., consultant in neurology. Eric P. Sipos, M.D., spine and brain surgery, stereotactic radiosurgery. Matt P. Wilson, M.D., spine and brain surgery. Neurology Diana V. Benenati, M.D., neuromuscular disorders, including EMG and general neurology. Hemant S. Kudrimoti, M.D., Ph.D., electrophysiology, epilepsy and general neurology. William B. Lujan, M.D., general neurology and EMG. Cynthia S. Reed, M.D., fellowship-trained movement disorders specialist including Parkinsons, general neurology.
Research Hospitals, both in Chicago. Starting in 2002 he served on the Arizona Medical Board and chaired it in 2006. Physicians are led to specialties by diverse paths. Dr. Goldfarb, who will turn 76 this year, said that during his internship, I became interested in neurosurgery during my rst service in the emergency room. We saw a lot of brain trauma and tumors. Trying to understand now the nervous system works is really a challenge.
David R. Siegel, M.D., general neurology, EMG (PCMS pastpresident). L. Rod Anderson, M.D., fellowship-trained stroke neurologist, vascular and general neurology. Adaeze A. Onuoha, M.D., neuro-intensivist.
2434 N. Pantano
Se Habla Espaol
www.RinconCommunications.com
12 SOMBRERO April 2012
790-2121
Established 1971
520-207-2123 coxbusinessaz.com
SOMBRERO April 2012
tIme capsULe
For the longest time up until the 20 century, Dr. Byrd said, infectious diseases and epidemics were what killed the most people. In the time of Montezuma II, the Aztecs were more advanced than By Stuart Faxon were Europeans in medicinal plants and herbs, as reported back to Happy 100th Birthday to Arizona said Pima County Medical Spain by Cortez. They treated fevers, arthritis, and all manner of Foundation Feb. 14, for as we all know, Arizona statehood began ailments. By nature of what we know about their human sacrices, on Valentines Day 1912. It was a long slog to get there, as Dr. Jim they had signicant knowledge about anatomy. Klein, PCMF president, notes below. In 1519-21, Cortez brought the humoral theory of medicine Nineteen-twelve medicine was not what we would want to dispense when he conquered Mexico. Humoral theory was universally acto patients today. But in a CME presentation, Tucson native and histocepted in Europe, Dr. Byrd said, and in most of the West, and rian Dr. Abraham Rudell Rudy Byrd III, surgeon-general of the Nagoes back as least as far as Hippocrates. tional Society, Sons of the American Revolution, explained the connecIndeed, humoral theory was one of the central principles in Westtions that make Southern Arizona medicine what is was and is. ern medicine through the 19th century. Humoral comes from A wry Dr. Byrd noted that medicine before statehood consists humor, which in this context means uid. The human body was of a mere 12,000 years of human history in Arizona, so all we need thought to contain a mix of the four humors: black bile (also known do is summarize from Paleolithic man to the earliest inhabitants of as melancholy), yellow or red bile, blood, and phlegm. Each individthe Santa Cruz Valley! Nevertheless, this area is the longest continual was supposed to have a particular humoral makeup or constituually human-inhabited place in the U.S., and fossilized feces from tion, and health was dened as the proper humoral balance for that around 1000 B.C. reveal pollen and plant parts including creosote individual. An imbalance of the humors resulted in disease. [1] The bush and ephedra (Mormon tea). These things were not good humors were also used to refer to four individual psychological temor tasty to eat, Dr. Byrd said, so probably they were eaten for meperaments: melancholic, sanguine, choleric, and phlegmatic. This dicinal purposes. Contrary to what we might presume about reects the humoral concept that physical health and individual persemi-arid deserts compared to water-rich places, this areas deserts sonality were part of the same whole. [2] and mountains were rich in ethno-botany. Development of humoral theory is associated originally with Hippocrates (circa 460370 BCE). In the second century CE, Galen elaborated on this theory, which was further developed by Arabic writers beginning in the 9th century and by European writers beginning in the 11th century. [3] While the Spanish were brutal, they were very interested in medicinal use of plants, Dr. Byrd said. They avidly sought to learn about things that had to do with the plants and herbs of New Spain, and they would seek out native medicine men. Francisco Hernandez, court surgeon to Philip II, wrote a treatise on herbal medicine, and he wrote in Nahuatl, the Aztec language. The Spanish Crown suppressed it as subversive, but Simines put out a copied version We are preferred providers in the early 1600s. Many of the physicians who on most insurance plans. eventually came to this area were those kinds of Helping you hear your best physiciansscientists who learned the language of the natives and wrote in it. Janis Wolfe Gasch, Au.D. We appreciate your referrals! Unfortunately, but naturally, Western mans Doctor of Audiology, Founding Director diseases came with the Spanish occupation, 7574 N La Cholla Blvd 6969 E Sunrise Dr, #203 512 E Whitehouse Canyon Rd, #196 and the 16th century had epidemics of smallTucson, AZ 85741 Tucson, AZ 85750 Green Valley, AZ 85614 pox and measles. Dr. Byrd noted that by the 18th 520.742.2845 520.742.2845 520.648.3277 century, smallpox and measles were still deadly www.arizonahearing.com here. Humoral theory started to break down by the late 18th century, but purging, bleeding, or cathartics such as castor oil and jalapenos
th
Statehood medicine
14
Tucson Osteopathic Medical Foundation presents the 21st Annual Southwestern Conference on Medicine, jointly sponsored for CME in conjunction with the University of Arizona College of Medicine at the Arizona Health Sciences Center
hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ
26 AOA Category 1A Credit, 26 AMA PRA Category 1 Credit, 4 Additional Credit Hours Available with Bonus Workshops 2 Additional AOA Category 1A Credits May Be Earned by DOs Completing the Outcomes Assessment After the Conference
SOMBRERO April 2012
nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
To join us, please contact Nicole Struck at (520) 299-4545 or cme@tomf.org Register now at www.tomf.org/cme
15
nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
were still used. George Washington was probably bled to death as well as purged. It was only in the 19th century that scientic knowledge ultimately prevailed over humoral theory. Even so, Dry Byrd noted, bleeding was still mentioned as acceptable treatment in some instances in Sir William Oslers book on principles and practices of medicine in 1923. In the presidio period in Tucson, the nearest doctor was still in Sonora. The only antibiotic was quinine, and it was used for everything. Mexico was unable to maintain the presidio system, but in Tucson 150 years ago we still had a cholera epidemic that killed 1,000 people in the Altar Valley and 25 percent of the people in Tucson. By the 1800s medical colleges were being founded. But in 1836, one John Marsh in California claimed to be a doctor, gave Harvard credentials in Latin, and got away with it because no one around could read Latin. He did have a Harvard B.A., but he only intended to study medicine! With the Gadsden Purchase in 1854, this area became part of the United States. The rst physicians here were likely military surgeons under army contract. In the Civil War,
www.htareit.com
www.theplazaco.com
both the Federal and Confederate governments tried to care for their soldiers, but really it was almost no medical care compared to later, and woefully inadequate by modern standards. When a .58 caliber Minie ball shattered bone, the resulting amputations had a 25 percent mortality rate in the rst 24 hours, 50 percent in two days, and higher later. Everyone was infected and no one had antibiotics. They had ether and chloroform, so it was not that they did not have anestheticsthey simply ran out. Two-thirds died of disease, which was a far lower mortality rate than in previous times, including the Mexican-American War. Cleanliness habits started in the Civil War are still in use today. In the post-Civil War period in Territorial Tucson we had the hot-tempered physician John Handy, who was killed in a street ght with the lawyer who represented his wife in a divorce. But he demanded actual credentialing of doctors by other physicians in the community, Dr. Byrd said. Walter Reed served here, later famed for nding mosquito transmission of yellow fever and malaria. Some of our members are aware of George Goodfellow, who became the gunshot wound expert of his day thanks to the frequent opportunities offered in Tombstone. John Henry Doc Holliday may be our most famous example of climate-based survival. The consumptive Georgia dentist came here and lived 15 more years as a gambler and gunghter. Politicians, businessmen, and quacks promoted Arizona as a cure for pulmonary ailments, but it was valid that the dry and cleaner climate was salutary for asthma, arthritis, and TB, Dr. Byrd said. In the march to today, the Arizona Medical Association was founded in 1892, and in 1897 Arizona began registration of doctors, but did little checking on authenticity. By 1902, doctors had to pass an exam. Southern Arizona physicians today, Dr. Byrd said, are inheritors of an ancient tradition of healers who found in the natural world around them means of relieving pain and suffering.
1,2,3. Contagion. Harvard University Open Collections Program. The President and Fellows of Harvard College 2012.
VALUED VENDOR FOR THE PIMA COUNTY MEDICAL SOCIETY AZ MGMA MEMBER
COVERAGE INCLUDES
I Professional Liability I General Liability & Property I Employee Benefits
866.467.3627
866.467.3611 fax info@desertmountaininsurance.com
www.desertmountaininsurance.com
17
proved by the House of Representatives, but died in a Senate committee. A principal reason for disavowal was that the proposed constitution called for free coinage of silver as legal tender, and thus it ran afoul of those supporting gold as legal tender. 1902-06: Largely because Arizona voted Democratic and New Mexico voted the R epublican ticket, national Republicans, including President Theodore Roosevelt and Republicans in the U.S. Senate, advocated joint statehood for Arizona and New Mexico, meaning admission as one state, with the capital in Santa Fe. By congressional action, the question of jointure was submitted to the voters of Arizona and New Mexico, with the provision that if either rejected jointure, the issue would fail. In the November 1906 referendum, New Mexico approved jointure, but Arizona rejected it. 1910: A statehood Enabling Act, providing for separate admission for Arizona and New Mexico, was signed by President William Howard Taft on June 20. In accordance with the act, a constitutional convention convened in Phoenix on Oct. 10, and completed its work on Dec. 9. In spite of President Tafts known sentiment against recall of judges, a provision for judicial recall was included in the document. 1911: On Feb. 9, Arizona voters approved the new constitu-tion by a margin of more than three to one. Congress approved the statehood constitution, but President Taft vetoed the statehood bill on Aug. 15, citing the provision for recall of judges in his veto message. On Aug. 21, President Taft signed the Flood-Smith Resolution, which promised statehood for Arizona provided that the voters removed the judicial recall provision from its constitution. On Dec. 12, Arizona voters removed judicial recall from the constitution and also elected ofcials for the new state. 1912: The ofcial canvass of votes was not competed until near the end of January, after which time the necessary certication was sent to President Taft. He signed the statehood proclamation document on Feb. 14 at 10:02 A.M. Washington, D.C. time. Arizona became the 48th state. (New Mexico was admitted as the 47th state on Jan. 6 because President Taft approved its constitution without seeking amendment.) President Taft did not sign the proclamation on Feb. 12, L incolns birthday, because it was a federal holiday. He did not sign it on Feb. 13 because he was afraid some might deem the date u nlucky!
Tucson Mayor Jonathan Rothschild and Ron Barber of Rep. Gabby Giffords ofce display the 48-star ag.
Hal Tretbar, M.D. and Barry Friedman, M.D. Jewish History Museum board chairman, proudly show this important piece of Tucson history.
The ag remained in the family until several years ago when they donated it to the Jewish History Museum. When I talked to museum Director Eileen Warshaw at the celebration, she said the ag was in good condition considering its age. She held it closely, saying, I dont let it out of my sight. She was glad that it would not be own, but held by Girl Scouts from Troop 173 during the national anthem. After the ceremony, Warshaw brought the ag Executive Director Eileen Warshaw of the out again, and many digni- Jewish History Museum holds the original taries wanted be photo- ag that ew over Tucson on Statehood graphed with this piece of Day, Feb. 14, 1912. Tucson history. The ag will be returned to the Jewish History Museum to hang from the ceiling of the original synagogue.
SOMBRERO April 2012
19
REALITY CHECK
tions here in America. We can start with infrastructure, so that interstate bridges in Oklahoma and Minnesota dont fall into rivers, and trains dont derail near Kingman because water washed out part of the rail bed. I think we need volunteers/CCC in the public schools, before, during and after school, and on weekends. We need people to help kids get outside and exercise more, as well as to teach good eating habits. That might help with obesity. We need people to actually measure some of these outcomes appropriately, the way I and some PCMS volunteers did for free, so we know what works and what doesnt. Things that dont work are helpful to know, if we learn from the mistakes. I think we need volunteers/CCC in animal shelters, teaching the next generation about care of animals, because animal cruelty by children is a huge red ag for trouble as an adult. Did I mention that leg-hold traps and cockghting used to be legal? Two more words: Michael Vick. We need people who are uent in other languages to help out in public places, be it airports, hospitals, or national parks. One of my dreams is that I will be able to do that adequately in German some day. We need volunteers/CCC to teach people to read, since a frighteningly high percentage of Americans cannot. I think citizen science should count as volunteerism: the annual Christmas Bird Count, more than 110 years old, is one example, where we have learned that the center of the range of three-fths of the species has moved 160 kilometers farther north. Those who volunteer measuring variable stars and those who work in nursing homes reading to the elderly, or just taking them outside, deserve credit. I see volunteers/CCC participants wearing large V or C pins; red, white and blue if they are a veteran, blue otherwise, for justice, since that is what the blue in our ag stands for. Volunteers would earn a star for every 1,000 hours; we would house, feed, and pay the CCC workers. What a great way to spend tax dollars, investing in people and the country simultaneously! Many young people are unclear about their future. Many never see much of America, and many have never taken orders from somebody other than a teacher or parent. Two years of national service would show many their country, teach them to give back, take orders, and learn new skills. It would be benecial. Sen. Jon Kyl (R-Ariz) wrote me and was quite clear he thought this was a bad idea. But the senator cant prevent me from wearing a red, white and blue V pin with four stars. And maybe a few people would ask why. Sombrero columnist Dr. Mike Smiths blog is http://michaelspinnersmith. com, where there are previous Reality Check columns, outdoor writing, descriptions and pictures of National Parks, Alaska hikes, eclipse-chasing, mental arithmetic, op-eds, and two non-technical neurology articles that physicians might enjoy.
SOMBRERO April 2012