Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Insider
Community publications need
to distance themselves from
the newspaper crisis
There are newspapers and there are newspapers in crisis.
It’s a them and us. The big guys and then the local
and regional papers, be they weekly or daily, free or
paid. I include shoppers and niche publications.
John C. Peterson
The big guys are in big trouble and we shouldn’t are out at the school board meeting. And yes, we
be, because their problem is our opportunity (I say may have to upset the mayor by asking hard
“we” and “our” because I can’t get the publisher out questions.
of the consultant.).
Give that concept some thought. If you’re doing
I bet I had that conversation a dozen times in the your job you’ve covered all the bases in news and
last few days at the New England Press Association advertising. You’ve provided an updated slice of life
annual convention where I was a speaker. I was in the communities you cover. My grandparents
reassured to find there are a few publishers out there would call it a smorgasbord, something for every
who are doing just fine. Sure, some are hurting, but appetite.
some are only down a few percentage points from
prior year. A handful said they were even up. I believe There was further evidence that local publications
them because I know they put out good products. are healthy in a recent joint study by Suburban
Newspapers of America and the National
If you’re a good local paper doing your job, I’m Newspaper Association. In a survey of papers with
betting you’re going to be stronger when this is over. a total circulation of 10.5 million, here’s what they
You just need to keep doing the things that make reported:
community papers valuable. Stick to your knitting
and mind your P’s and Q’s. And don’t blink. Data collected in 2008 showed a 1.7% decline in
advertising for the third quarter, 2.4% in the second
The franchise for the local paper is the collection quarter and 2.7% in the first quarter (all were
process, news and advertising. Main Street and town measured against the same reporting period from
hall and the local high school are our domain. Ask the prior year.) Fourth quarter results will be available
me to describe the formula for the successful local in late February. These results compare to industry-
newspaper and I’ll say the same thing I’ve said for wide double-digit declines of 18.1% (third quarter
30 years. It’s the owner’s manual for the community. 2008), 15.1% second quarter 2008, and 12.8% (first
“If it’s important to them (the reader), then it needs quarter 2008), as reported by Newspaper
to be important to us,” was the drill for my reporters Association of America.
and editors. That means finding room for every
reasonable press release and staying until the lights (Continued on Page 3)
Page 2
President’s Message
IT’S CONFERENCE TIME AGAIN!!
In these trying times there is no better way to gain that tactical
edge than to attend the CPNE conference. Time is running short so don't
miss the opportunity to interact with your fellow publishers to find out
what’s working and what isn't.
I know for some of you it may seem like unproductive time for you and your staffs. I cannot
think of one conference that I have gone to that I haven't come back with something that would
help me to improve. So I encourage everyone to spend the time interacting at beautiful Mt. Snow.
The room rates are fabulous and it will be money well spent in moving your business forward.
Hope to see you all there.
Ed
Community Papers
of New England
➠
and
Buy New England
Post Office Box 28,
700 Main Street Our new website address is
Willimantic, CT 06226
860-423-6398
Toll Free 877-423-6399
cpne.biz
FAX 860-423-6391
bne@cpne.biz
www.cpne.biz
AUGUST 2009 • • • Page 3
Community publications (Continued from Page 1)
If you’re a weekly, tell advertisers there’s no No one will tell your story if you don’t. If you don't
guesswork about which is the best day to advertise. then people will just think you’re just another one
You create the event and people know when to of those papers in crisis.
look for it. You offer shelf life and that’s the same
thing as frequency. You likely have affordable zones This is no time to hold back, the stakes are
with strong or saturation coverage. You sell proximity too high.
and that's where the people who find it easiest to By John C. Peterson, The Peterson Group
do business with them reside. Web: johncpeterson.com
Blog: communitymediamatters.blogspot.com
Circulation
Verification
Council
Page 4 • • • august 2009
Craig’s mission was that of AFCP, to help its members enhance their
profitability and strengthen the free paper industry, and he did just that.
Craig was a caring person who was a friend to all in the industry, big
papers and small, all valued his way of sharing his knowledge with them.
Beyond the business, Craig had a love for adventure - living life to the
fullest aptly describes him - brave and fearless, he loved everything from
white water rafting to being a member of the renowned “Black Sheep”, his
group of biker friends who will miss him terribly.
Our sincere sympathies to his wife, Marilyn; his children, Matt and
Meaghan, his parents and family members, the “Black Sheep”, and his AFCP
family.
In a Stormy Economy,
Smart Publishers Prepare for Better Days
Reprinted from CVC Newsletter
Despite the big black cloud of a recession overhead, many publishers of community papers, magazines and niche
publications are focusing on the silver lining of this economic storm. And that lining is full of opportunities to prepare for an
eventual turn-around and make new sales right now.
As the economic downturn gained speed, Ray Appen of Appen Newspapers in Alpharetta, Ga., joined fellow publish-
ers in cutting expenses where he could. But Appen, like many publishers, has found himself operating with a budget that
can’t bear any more cuts without hurting his product. In order to attract new clients and maintain a high number of
contracts, Appen started strategically cutting his advertising rates.
Reducing Ad Prices to Build and The publication has also landed new sales from ZIP code
comparisons, according to Aird. He uses his CVC audit and
Maintain Relationships audits from his competitors to create a ZIP code circulation
Lately, he has been offering a business-card-sized ad for comparison. “We hand it to potential advertisers with a map
$10 a week with a 52-week contract. Typically, this ad would and ask, ‘Do you know where your advertising dollars are
cost $40-50 a week. going?’ That’s opened up some more business.”
“What that does is, it lets little businesses, and big In addition to creating ZIP code comparisons, Russell
businesses, at least put something out there that they may Quattlebaum, publisher of Southeast Sun and Daleville Sun
not have otherwise afforded,” Appen said. “It allows them Courier in Enterprise, Ala., is using his receivership score,
to market while spending almost no money. They like it, readership score and purchase intention numbers to drive
and they’ve bought a lot.” new business. (CVC’s handbook, “How To Use Your CVC Audit
Some customers are even upgrading to larger ads at To Increase Revenue” provides details on using these numbers
times during the 52-week period for special sales and to make advertising sales.)
holidays. “A lot of the research that CVC does, that is what helps
The real strategy behind this bold move, according to push customers over,” Quattlebaum said.
Appen, is to take this opportunity to build a base of new He has recently secured advertising contracts with both
relationships with his newspapers so that when the economy Lowe’s and Home Depot. “If we didn’t have a CVC audit, we
improves, his company will be poised for growth. wouldn’t have a chance with a lot of these big companies,”
“As we emerge on the other side of this economy, we’ll he said. Audited circulation figures, including receivership,
have all of these contracts in place and relationships that readership and purchase intention, are must-haves for these
are starting to grow,” he said. “We’re going to be in a really, national advertisers.
really strong position.”
Tom Aird, publisher of the Buyers Guide in Martinsburg,
W.Va., has been able to add new national advertisers and is The Opening in the Clouds
also running 50% off specials to keep existing advertisers in As in all economic downturns, some publications in the
his paper. market will fail, Appen said. He is already seeing competitors
“A lot of people will jump off the ship because they make substantial cuts that provide opportunities for his
think you’re sinking,” he said. “We’ve been able to keep newspapers.
people in the paper.” “We’re in Atlanta, and the Atlanta Journal-Constitution is
the primary big daily. They’re cutting circulation, and cutting
and combining sections,” Appen said. As they’ve done this,
Land New Business Now calls to Appen’s editorial departments have tripled, he said
Aird has also been able to lure new national and regional “They’ve created a vacuum for content and marketing,”
advertisers, including Rite Aid and Pizza Hut, through his Appen said. Any time a competing publication cuts circulation
listing in Standard Rate and Data Service. Media buyers are or content, according to Appen, it’s time to take stock of
increasingly adding community papers to their advertising your own publication and see how you can fill that void
buys, and all CVC-audited publications have two listings in and capture the advertising dollars that remain on the table
SRDS, a listing service used by almost all media buyers. Read – especially during a time when those dollars are so hard to
more about how Aird attracted national advertisers in a come by.
separate article.
Page 6 • • • AUGUST 2009
increased advertising expenditures. Jell-O, Crisco,
Advertising made Hellman´s, Green Giant, McDonalds, and Doritos cut
back on advertising during this period. Predictably
simple, investing in a the first group had showed growth during the re-
cession ranging from 15% to 70%. The second
bad economy group´s sales dropped 26% to 64%
When the economy heads south 75% of U.S. com-
panies respond by cutting back, hunkering down, During our last economic downturn, while aggres-
and trying to "tough out" the tough times. Advertis- sive marketers such as Proctor and Gamble took ad-
ing is the first expense that gets eliminated. vantage of reduced media rates to expand their ad-
vertising program, K-Mart decided to decrease ad-
There are two other advantages to aggressively ad- vertising during September and October, 2001.
vertising during economic recessions.
The result? K-Mart sales dropped a resounding 5%
1) Your "share of voice" becomes multiplied as the during October. By late fall the company had lost far
advertising noise reduces. more in sales than it had saved in marketing expense.
2) Your "share of mind" is often uncontested for At least a dozen other studies ranging from 1923
months at a time. During these times your more timid through 1991 show nearly identical results. Meldrum
competitors will fall behind and likely never catch up. & Fewsmith showed in a series of six studies that, for
all post World War II recessions, those firms that kept
It´s a summary of the McGraw-Hill Research study of advertising aggressively increased profits as well as
the 1981-82 economic recession in the U.S. The study gross sales during the recession.
analyzed 600 companies covering 16 different SIC
industries. Year one on this graph is 1980. Year six is It's important to remember that during a recession
1985. consumers don´t stop buying. They become more
selective. They look much harder for "value" in their
You´ll note that the aggressively competitive compa- purchases. They are going to buy from someone.
nies represented by the black bar had only a slight They're likely to buy from businesses that they know
edge over their competitors in the years leading up and like.
to the recession. Their sales growth was in the middle
of the pack as the recession hit. But while their com- Make sure they know you.
petitors cut back in year one, or year two, or both,
they continued to invest in getting their message out. The more visible you are, the more confidant your
customers and prospects become. The more they are
These firms grew nicely during the recession, but the reminded of your legitimacy and staying power, the
real news happened in the two years following the more they'll be inclined to believe you'll be there for
end of the economic downturn. them tomorrow.
Two years into the recovery, the competitors who did Remember too that during any period of economic
cut back had all stalled out at levels the aggressive downturn your best customers become someone
companies had blown past during the recession. By else´s best prospects. When you stop inviting them
the end of 1985 the companies that didn´t cut back to do business with you, a more aggressive competi-
had grown a whopping 256%. tor may become much more attractive.
During the recessionary period 1989-1991 Kraft salad Excerpt from "Advertising Made Simple Investing in
dressings, Jiff peanut butter, Bud Lite, Coors Lite, Pizza a Bad Economy"
Hut, and Taco bell were in the aggressive group which By Chuck McKay From allbusiness.com.
AUGUST 2009 • • • Page 7
Each chapter ends with suggested "action steps." I
suggest a buying a copy for every member of the ad
Book staff, and using it as a training tool for the coming year.
My only criticism is that it's so darn inexpensive -
only $12.95 on Amazon.com. (or for a $2.95 per book
Corner discount go to http://www.createspace.com/3377962
and enter discount code 26KDPHWE Createspace is
a division of Amazon.com. )
On top of that, proceeds from the book go to a charity
One of the truly good guys in our business has close to Mr. Gay's heart - Camp Courageous, a year-
released a book sure to help newspaper ad round respite care and recreational facility for
representatives sell more, service their valued clients individuals of all ages with disabilities located near
better, and enjoy their jobs while they're at it. Monticello, Iowa. (www.campcourageous.org) His goal
It's titled "Land Standing," authored by Brian Gay, is to raise $5,000 for the camp.
executive director of Midwest Free Community Papers. The book is a gem, a gift from Brian to the industry
The book is easy-to-read and features 52 short chapters he loves as well as Camp Courageous. To order, just
that deal with everything from optimizing the workday - go to Amazon.com, click on books, and enter the title
to how to do your homework before going after that Land Standing - or go to the Createspace address
major account - to how to plan for you success for the noted previously for the $2.95 per book discount.
next 12 months. Thanks and a BIG tip of the hat to Brian Gay.
State Representatives
Connecticut Lisa Miksus, Shore Publishing, CT 203-245-1877 L.Miksus@shorepublishing.com
Maine (at large) Dan Buendo, Reminder Publications, MA 413-525-6662 dbuendo@reminderpublications.com
Massachusetts Cherie MacKinney, Smart Shopper, MA 508-943-5300 cmackinney@smartshopper.com
Rhode Island Peter Stevens, The Reminder, RI 401-821-2216 rireminder@aol.com
Vermont Renée Tassone, Vermont News Guide, VT 413-334-4424 rtassone@hersamacornvt.com
New Hampshire Debra Paul, Nutfield Publishing, NH 603-537-2760 dpaul@nutpub.net
National Affiliations
AFCP Rep. Ed Coats, Vermont Times, Shelburne, VT 802-985-2400 vermonttimes@gmail.com
IFPA Rep. Dan Buendo, Reminder Publications, MA 413-525-6662 dbuendo@reminderpublications.com
PaperChain Rep. Dan Buendo, Reminder Publications, MA 413-525-6662 dbuendo@reminderpublications.com
Page 8 • • • AUGUST 2009
A newly created brochure is the beginning advance the critical and effective role that free
of our effort to provide positive and concise community publications play in the U.S. economy.
marketing materials to media buyers throughout the This is a difficult time, but it is also a time that provides
country. In addition to the brochure, the ad agency our industry an opportunity to help the many
has rebuilt the PaperChain.com website with a struggling businesses that need the exposure that
consistent visual look and message. Take a look when only we can provide. We are committed to getting
you get a chance. that message heard.
We are very pleased with the first steps that I want to thank you for sharing the vision
have been taken to reacquaint advertising buyers to that PaperChain holds. Collectively we can bring
our growing industry. As daily newspapers continue attention to the role our industry plays in the
to see their circulation totals decline, it is all the more national media mix. For decades we have been
important that we distinguish our industry from their recognized as the leaders within our own local
travails. We are proud of our growth and our advertising communities. With your continued
effectiveness in distributing our publications to more support and assistance we will continue to grow
than 65 million households throughout the United our industry’s role at the national level.
States.
As always, I will close with an invitation to
We have begun distribution of the brochures all of you. If you have any interest in working on
now that the website is complete and tested for any of our acting committees please let me know
efficiency and effectiveness. The initial use of the and we will gladly put your enthusiasm and talents
brochures is in a mailing to more than 14,000 media to work for the benefit of the free paper industry.
companies throughout the country. Tim Bingaman,
president of Circulation Verification Council (CVC), Sincerely,
has generously provided his media buyer mailing Dan Holmes – PaperChain Chairman
list to us for this mailing. for the entire PaperChain, LLC Committee
One big change is to Today’s Headlines. This still features all the big news from your chosen
industry, but now you can link directly to the news article instead of finding the article in
AdMall’s Hourly Trade News section!
Also new:
* A Media Sales Today feature from our daily blog for media advertising sales professionals
* Trend of the Day – a daily consumer-spending trend
* Upcoming Webinars – see what webinars are coming up – includes links for registration
The AdMall Minute has your chosen items on Locals, Majors, Automotive or Online Opportuni-
ties, Prospect of the Week for Local accounts, or Anniversary of the Week for Major accounts,
plus the Sales Tip of the Day.
877-4-ADMALL -- AdMall.com
Page 10 August 2009 • • •
TRADE SHOW:
Publishers & Sales Roundtable Our Associate Members bring added value with
”Trading Trade Secrets” information about their products, services and
programs. See what’s new in technology & training.
In this incredibly difficult environment, you’re not Don’t miss the opportunity to talk with them
alone. Jointly discuss struggles and triumphs.
Hear how your peers are reorganizing and Sunday & Monday in the Exhibit Hall
refocusing their efforts for these lean times.
Tim Smith Rob Zarrilli Kevin Slimp Susan Kremers
Keynote Speaker Speaker Graphics Marketing On-Line News
CPNE’s Fall Conference is made possible by the proceeds from the Buy New England Classified Ad Network. Please support the program by selling a classified ad today!
Page 14 • • • AUGUST 2009
In a Stormy Economy, Smart
Publishers Prepare for Better Days
Despite the black cloud of a recession overhead, publications have two listings in SRDS, a listing service used
many publishers of community papers, magazines and by almost all media buyers. Read mor e about how Aird
niche publications are focusing on the silver lining of this attracted national advertisers in a separate article.
economic storm. And that lining is full of opportunities The Buyers Guide publication has also landed new
to pr epare for an eventual turnar ound and make new sales from ZIP code comparisons, accor ding to Aird. He
sales right now. uses his CVC audit and audits from his competitors to create
As the economic downturn gained speed, Ray a ZIP code circulation comparison. "We hand it to potential
Appen of Appen Newspapers in Alpharetta, Ga., joined advertisers with a map and ask, 'Do you know where your
fellow publishers in cutting expenses where he could. But advertising dollars are going?' That's opened up some more
Appen, like many publishers, has found himself business."
operating with a budget that can't bear any mor e cuts In addition to cr eating ZIP code comparisons,
without hurting his product. In order to attract new clients Russell Quattlebaum, publisher of Southeast Sun and
and maintain a high number of contracts, Appen started Daleville Sun Courier in Enterprise, Ala., is using his
strategically cutting his advertising rates. receivership score, readership score and purchase intention
Reducing Ad Prices to Build and Maintain numbers to drive new business. (CVC's handbook, "How
Relationships To Use Your CVC Audit To Incr ease Revenue" pr ovides
Lately, Appen has been offering a business-card-sized ad details on using these numbers to make advertising sales.)
for $10 a week with a 52-week contract. Typically, this ad "A lot of the r esearch that CVC does, that is what
would cost $40-50 a week. helps push customers over," Quattlebaum said.
"What that does is, it lets little businesses, and He has recently secured advertising contracts with
big businesses, at least put something out there that they both Lowe's and Home Depot. "If we didn’t have a CVC
may not have otherwise afforded," Appen said. "It allows audit, we wouldn't have a chance with a lot of these big
them to market while spending almost no money . They companies," he said.Audited circulation figures, including
like it, and they’ve bought a lot." receivership, readership and purchase intention, are must-
Some customers are even upgrading to larger ads haves for these national advertisers.
at times during the 52-week period for special sales and
holidays. The Opening in the Clouds
The r eal strategy behind this bold move, As in all economic downturns, some publications
according to Appen, is to take this opportunity to build a in the market will fail, Appen said. He is alr eady seeing
base of new r elationships with his newspapers so that competitors make substantial cuts that pr ovide
when the economy improves, his company will be poised opportunities for his newspapers.
for growth. "We're in Atlanta, and the Atlanta Journal-
"As we emerge on the other side of this economy, Constitution is the primary big daily . They'r e cutting
we'll have all of these contracts in place and elationships
r circulation, and cutting and combining sections," Appen
that are starting to grow," he said. "We're going to be in a said. As they've done this, calls to Appen's editorial
really, really strong position." departments have tripled, he said.
Tom Aird, publisher of the Buyers Guide in "They've cr eated a vacuum for content and
Martinsburg, W.Va., has been able to add new national marketing," Appen said. Any time a competing publication
advertisers and is also running 50-percent-off specials to cuts circulation or content, according to Appen, it's time to
keep existing advertisers in his paper. take stock of your own publication and see how you can
"A lot of people will jump of f the ship because fill that void and capture the advertising dollars that remain
they think you're sinking," he said. "W e've been able to on the table – especially during a time when those dollars
keep people in the paper." are so hard to come by.
Land New Business Now Proudly display the CVC and PaperChain logos
Aird has also been able to lure new national and on your masthead.
regional advertisers, including Rite Aid and Pizza Hut,
through his listing in Standar d Rate and Data Service. Circulation
Media buyers are increasingly adding community papers Verification
to their advertising buys, and all CVC-audited Council
AUGUST 2009 • • • Page 15
Page 16 • • • AUGUST 2009
Give Advertisers a Choice
Peggy was talking to me about sales. “When I first started selling advertising, I would
come up with one killer ad idea, and then build a presentation around that one concept.
Although I had some success with that approach, I felt like more of my ideas should have
been accepted. Then I bought a sweater.”
A sweater?
“That’s right,” she said. “On a day when one of my best ideas had been rejected by a client, By John Foust
I went to a store after work to buy a blue sweater. As I looked through the various sweater Raleigh, NC
styles and shades of blue, it was like one of those cartoon light bulbs switched on over my
head. I realized that people like to have choices when making a purchase.
“So I tried a little experiment with my next ad presentation. I asked our paper’s creative department to prepare two
versions of the same ad idea. Both layouts had the same copy and the same illustration, but one was vertical and
one was horizontal. When I met with the advertiser, I explained that either choice would work – it was just a matter
of deciding which ad he preferred. Our discussion was a real learning experience. He learned something about ad
copy and design. And I learned something about human nature: people appreciate the opportunity to choose.”
Peggy’s technique has helped her make more sales – and create more knowledgeable advertisers. Here are some
points to keep in mind:
1. Choice is good. “The whole idea is to give an advertiser a degree of ownership in an idea that someone else
– our creative department–– has developed,” Peggy said.”“When he or she takes ownership, there is more
enthusiasm for the idea. And we all know that an advertiser who is genuinely excited about an idea wants to see
it in print as soon as possible.”
2. Too much choice is bad. “Every now and then, I show three options,” she explained. “But most of the time, I
give people two choices. I’ve learned from experience that more than three is likely to muddy the
water.”
3. Stay away from earthshaking decisions. Don’t put an advertiser in a position of making a decision that is likely
to make or break the effectiveness of an ad. Safe choices include things like: Should the format be horizontal or
vertical? Should the second color be red or green? Should the headline be serif or sans serif?
Some things are off limits in this type of presentation. For example, don’t ask an advertiser to make an on-the-spot
choice between two entirely different positioning strategies. Strategy is an integral’– and difficult to change–– part
of the marketing process, and therefore should not be reduced to Option A vs. Option B. Likewise, certain creative
choices (photography vs. cartoon art, for instance) represent such radically different approaches that they need
careful consideration.
“I try to include a simple choice in each one of my presentations,” Peggy concluded. “It makes a big difference in my
selling.”
*Phone __________________
Name on Card
(25 words)
$170.00 for 25 Words - $10.00 each add’l word as of Nov. 1, 2005 Please include payment with your ad or call BNE office.
Ads that do not conform to “Buy New England” guidelines for acceptable ad copy will be rejected by some or possibly all participating papers. Please
check the guidelines before you accept an ad for “Buy New England.” Ads must be submitted on this form. New customers must sign the BNE Terms &
Conditions. 1/07
AUGUST 2009 • • • Page 23
State Representatives
Connecticut Dan Buendo, Reminder Publications, MA 413-525-6662 dbuendo@reminderpublications.com
Maine (at large) Mitchell Shakour, Monadnock Shopper, NH 603-352-5250 mitchell@shoppernews.com
Massachusetts Liz Jusko, Reminder Publications, MA 413-206-0702 ljusko@thereminder.com
Rhode Island Peter Stevens, The Reminder, RI 401-821-2216 rireminder@aol.com
Vermont Debra Paul, Nutfield Publishing, NH 603-537-2760 dpaul@nutpub.net
New Hampshire Cherie MacKinney, Smart Shopper, MA 508-943-5300 cmackinny@smartshopper.com
National Affiliations
AFCP Rep. Paul Sciaraffa, ReminderNews, CT 860-875-3366 psciaraffa@aol.com
IFPA Rep. Dan Buendo, Reminder Publications, MA 413-525-6662 dbuendo@reminderpublications.com
PaperChain Rep. Dan Buendo, Reminder Publications, MA 413-525-6662 dbuendo@reminderpublications.com
Coolerads Rep. John Peterson, The Peterson Group 860-447-9198 consultpub@aol.com