Pugh Chart for Conceptual Design

Concept Importa nt rating 1Vertical flat with air bearing 2. Stack with kinematic coupling 3: Fixed truss 4: L truss with air bearing 5:. Fixed reference flat with air bearing

Design

Accuracy Repeatabili ty Cost Complexity of design Complexity of assembly Lifetime

*****

+ + + +

0 0 + + 0 0

0 0 -

0 + + +

0 + + +
1

*****

** * **

***

X-ray Optics group

2.75 Precision Machine Design