IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

DRAGON INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY, LLC, Plaintiff, v. AT&T SERVICES, INC., Defendant.

C.A. No. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

COMPLAINT FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT Plaintiff D!a"on Intelle#t$al P!o%e!t&, LLC '(D!a"on)) *e!e+& +!in", t*i, a#tion a"ain,t AT&T Se!vi#e,, In#. '(AT&T)) fo! inf!in"e-ent of inf!in"e-ent of United State, Patent No. .,/01,222 '(t*e 3222 %atent)) and alle"e, a, follo4,5 NATURE OF THE ACTION AND PARTIES 6. T*i, i, an a#tion fo! %atent inf!in"e-ent $nde! t*e %atent la4, of t*e United

State, of A-e!i#a. 7. D!a"on i, a li-ited lia+ilit& #o-%an& o!"ani8ed and e9i,tin" $nde! t*e la4, of t*e

State of Dela4a!e. 0. AT&T i, a #o!%o!ation o!"ani8ed and e9i,tin" $nde! t*e la4, of t*e State of

Dela4a!e. AT&T #an +e ,e!ved via it, !e"i,te!ed a"ent, T*e Co!%o!ation T!$,t Co-%an&, Co!%o!ation T!$,t Cente!, 671/ O!an"e St!eet, :il-in"ton, Dela4a!e 6/;16. JURISDICTION 2. T*i, Co$!t *a, ,$+<e#t -atte! <$!i,di#tion ove! t*i, a#tion %$!,$ant to 7; U.S.C.

== 6006 and 600;'a), a, t*i, i, an a#tion a!i,in" $nde! t*e Patent A#t, 0. U.S.C. = 6 et seq.

VENUE .. Ven$e i, %!o%e! in t*i, di,t!i#t %$!,$ant to 7; U.S.C. == 60/6'+) and 6211'+). FACTUAL BACKGROUND ?. T*e 3222 %atent i, entitled (Si-$ltaneo$, Re#o!din" and Pla&+a#@ A%%a!at$,.) A

#o%& of t*e 3222 %atent i, atta#*ed *e!eto a, E9*i+it A. A. T*e invention of t*e 3222 %atent "ene!all& !elate, to a @e&+oa!d eB$i%%ed

a$diovi,$al !e#o!din" and %la&+a#@ devi#e *avin" an in%$t and an o$t%$t ada%ted fo! #onne#tion +et4een a $,e!3, ,i"nal ,o$!#e and di,%la& devi#e, and a -e-o!& $nit 4it* a ,to!a"e -edi$ena+lin" !ando- a##e,, to %!o"!a--in" info!-ation ,to!ed t*e!ein. A @e&+oa!d !e,%on,ive #ont!ol #i!#$it ena+le, -ani%$lation and t!an,fe! of %!o"!a--in" info!-ation +et4een t*e in%$t, o$t%$t, and -e-o!&. S$+,tantiall& ,i-$ltaneo$, !e#o!din" and %la&+a#@ of televi,ion t&%e ,i"nal, i, a#*ieved, t*$, ena+lin" $,e! #ont!olled %!o"!a--in" dela&. ;. T*e a%%li#ation t*at !e,$lted in t*e 3222 %atent 4a, filed on A%!il 7;, 6//2, a, a

#ontin$ation of an a%%li#ation filed on A%!il 70, 6//7. T*e United State, Patent and T!ade-a!@ Offi#e d$l& and le"all& i,,$ed t*e 3222 %atent on C$l& 7A, 6///. COUNT I (INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. PATENT NO. 5,930, /.

D!a"on !ealle"e, and in#o!%o!ate, +& !efe!en#e t*e alle"ation, of %a!a"!a%*, 6>;,

in#l$,ive, a, if f$ll& ,et fo!t* *e!ein. 61. D!a"on o4n, all !i"*t, title, and inte!e,t in t*e 3222 %atent, in#l$din" t*e !i"*t to

!e#ove! da-a"e, fo! inf!in"e-ent of t*e 3222 %atent t*!o$"*o$t t*e %e!iod of t*e inf!in"e-ent #o-%lained of *e!ein. 66. AT&T *a, di!e#tl& inf!in"ed Clai-, 6, 7, 0, 2, A, and ; of t*e 3222 %atent +&

$,in", ,ellin", and offe!in" to ,ell DVR !e#eive!, -an$fa#t$!ed +& Ci,#o S&,te-, and Doto!ola.

>7>

JURY DEMAND D!a"on !eB$e,t, a t!ial +& <$!& fo! all i,,$e, ,o t!ia+le. PRAYER FOR RELIEF D!a"on %!a&, fo! !elief a, follo4,5 6. Co-%en,ato!& da-a"e, in an a-o$nt a##o!din" to %!oof, and in no event le,,

t*an a !ea,ona+le !o&alt&E 7. 0. 2. P!e<$d"-ent inte!e,t on t*e #o-%en,ato!& da-a"e, a4a!ded to D!a"onE Po,t><$d"-ent inte!e,t on all ,$-, a4a!ded to D!a"on f!o- t*e date of <$d"-entE A %!eli-ina!& and %e!-anent in<$n#tion fo!+iddin" AT&T and it, offi#e!,,

a"ent,, ,e!vant,, e-%lo&ee,, and atto!ne&,, and all t*o,e in a#tive #on#e!t o! %a!ti#i%ation 4it* t*e-, f!o- f$!t*e! inf!in"in" t*e 3222 %atentE .. ?. Co,t, of ,$it in#$!!ed *e!einE and An& and all ot*e! !elief t*at t*e Co$!t dee-, <$,t and eB$ita+le.

>0>

Dated5 De#e-+e! 71, 7160 OF COUNSEL5 Ro+e!t E. F!eita, FREITAS TSENG & GAUFDAN LLP 611 Da!ine Pa!@4a&, S$ite 711 Red4ood S*o!e,, CA /21?. '?.1) ./0>?011 !f!eita,Hft@la4.#o-

IAYARD, P.A. /s/ Stephen B. Brauerman Ri#*a!d D. Gi!@ '!@1/77) Ste%*en I. I!a$e!-an ',+2/.7) Vane,,a R. Ti!adente, 'vt.0/;) Sa!a E. I$,,ie!e ',+.A7.) 777 Dela4a!e Aven$e, S$ite /11 P.O. Io9 7.601 :il-in"ton, DE 6/;//>.601 '017) ?..>.111 !@i!@H+a&a!dla4.#o,+!a$e!-anH+a&a!dla4.#ovti!adente,H+a&a!dla4.#o,+$,,ie!eH+a&a!dla4.#oAttorneys for Plaintiff Dragon Intellectual Property, LLC

>2>