Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Polymers
Polymer production technology Customized foam manufacturing New polymer pilot plant Flexible pumps for polymers Solutions for the plastics industry Efficiency through coated tools Successful polymer analysis Panorama World-famous in motor sports Insightful hot spots
EDITORIAL
About Sulzer
!<3A-9 P<47: Pump technology and solutions !<3A-9 P<47: 6..-9: 7<4715/ :63<;165: )5, 9-3);-, -8<174-5; )5, :-9=1+-:. Customers benefit from intensive research and development in fluid dynamics, process-oriented products, and reliable services. The global manufacturing and service network of Sulzer Pumps ensures high customer proximity.
!<3A-9 M-;+6 Surface technology !<3A-9 M-;+6 -50)5+-: :<9.)+-: >1;0 +6);15/ :63<;165: )5, -8<174-5;. Customers benefit from a uniquely broad range of surface technologies, coating solutions, equipment, materials, and services, as well as specialized machining services and components. The innovative solutions of Sulzer Metco improve performance and increase efficiency and reliability.
!<3A-9 C0-4;-+0 Separation, mixing, and service solutions !<3A-9 C0-4;-+0 6..-9: 796,<+;: )5, :-9=1+-: .69 :-7)9);165, 9-)+;165, )5, 41?15/ ;-+05636/@. Customers benefit from advanced solutions in the fields of process technology, separation equipment, as well as two-component mixing and dispensing systems. The global footprint of Sulzer Chemtech ensures local knowledge and competence.
!<3A-9 "<9*6 !-9=1+-: Service solutions for rotating equipment !<3A-9 "<9*6 !-9=1+-: 6..-9: 9-7)19 )5, 4)15;-5)5+- :-9=1+-: .69 ;<9*64)+015-9@, /-5-9);69:, )5, 46;69:. Customers benefit from reliable and efficient repair and maintenance services for gas and steam turbines, compressors, motors, and generators of any brand. The global network of Sulzer Turbo Services ensures high-quality local service.
Sulzer was founded in 1834 in Winterthur, Switzerland, and today is active in machinery and equipment manufacturing and surface engineering at over 170 locations worldwide. The divisions are global leaders in their respective customer segments, which include the oil and gas, hydrocarbon processing, power generation, water, aviation, and automotive industries. www.sulzer.com
CONTENT
Polymers
4
Flexible foam production
Customized manufacturing of expandable polystyrene
12
14
19
20
Panorama
25
Welcome to Sulzer Metco in Limoges
Sulzer world
26
30 31
Imprint
O5 ;0- +6=-9: A scanning electron micrograph of polystyrene foam shows the air-filled hollow cells that make the material an excellent insulator.
Keystone / Science Photo Library / Eye of Science
POLYMERS
he industrial polymerization of styrene to polystyrene (PS) started in the early 20th century and was followed by the development of expandable PS beads around 60 years ago. EPS is a particle foam made by expanding PS beads that contain a blowing agent usually pentane. Steam heating causes the beads to expand, and the final shape is achieved by molding the pre-expanded beads with steam and pressure. There
are numerous applications for EPS on the market, and block and shape molding are the most important conversion processes currently employed to fabricate foam products from EPS. In particular, by using shape molding, various products can be obtainedfor example, packaging solutions, plaster, or sports equipment many of which profit from customized EPS formulations that add color or mechanical properties.
Sulzers EPS pilot plant allows process optimization, sample production, and feasibility testing for customers.
4376
POLYMERS
Sulzer Chemtech offers a continuous process for producing EPS granulates from PS on an industrial scale of up to 100 000 t per year (see STR 1/2009, p. 6). In this process, the melt is directly impregnated with the blowing agent and the required additives, and it is then sent to an underwater pelletization process. The melt impregnation has several advantages over the conventional suspension process. The product quality is consistent and can be easily controlled, as the additives and the blowing agent are directly injected into the melt.
distribution, can influence the thermalparticular, when connecting the Sulzer insulation properties of EPS foam. The EPS process directly to a polystyrene genuine advantage of EPS foam as insumelt plant, the static mixing approach lation material over competing insulation results in significant energy savings, as the resin does not need to be melted S0(5!-7. )!(/ %),-!#*a/%+* ,-+c!.. %. /$! ba.%. again. This offers the "+- /$! ,-+ 0c/%+* +" ,%#)!*/! EPS. possibility of operatsolutions like polyurethane, mineral ing competitive styrene-to-EPS plants for global-scale production of EPS commodi- wool, or extruded polystyrene foam (XPS) is its low density and, hence, its ties, for example, for innovative insulation relatively low price. However, the insusolutions. In fact, with the introduction lative properties significantly deteriorate of a melt-based EPS process in the late with decreasing density. Three mecha1990s by Sulzer, the technological basis for the production of pigmented, flame- nisms contribute to the thermal conductivity of EPS (see info box): resistant EPS for housing insulation was Conduction established, and this gave rise to the Convection development of a number of innovative Radiation (mainly infrared). materials using different additives. With decreasing EPS density, the share Improving thermal insulation with of infrared radiation strongly increases. pigments This effect can be avoided through pigSeveral parameters, such as foam density, mentation. Pigments, e.g., graphite, carchoice of blowing agent, and cell size bon, or aluminum particles, added to
Low-lambda development
50
40
total
30
20
gas cd
"0- ;0-94)3 +65,<+;1=1;@ 6. EP! +64791:-:: Conduction in polystyrene cell walls and struts (cd) Convection by gas contained in cells (gas) Radiation, mainly infrared (rad) P1/4-5;);165 Added pigments in EPS material absorb and/or reflect heat radiation, so that rad is reduced and thermal insulation is improved.
C647)91:65 6. 15:<3);15/ 4);-91)3: (;0-94)3 +65,<+;1=1;@ 15 %/'4DK():
C65+9-;0.81.28 %01;- EP! 0.0320.044 P1/4-5;-, EP! 0.0290.033
40
38
white EPS
36
34
D 10 20 %
32
10
rad
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
D-5:1;@ (2//43)
pigmented EPS
30
The thermal conductivity or (measured in watts per meter kelvin W/[mK]) describes the ability of materials to conduct heat. Materials of high thermal conductivity transmit heat at a higher rate than materials of low thermal conductivity. Therefore, materials of low thermal conductivity are used as thermal insulation.
28
10
15
D-5:1;@ (2//43)
20
25
1 Adding pigments decreases the heat conductivity and improves the insulative properties of the EPS. This kind of low-lambda development allows access to markets for highperformance insulation materials.
POLYMERS
1 mm
100 m
the EPS can absorb and/or reflect infrared radiation and thus improve thermal insulation 1. This way, the insulative property of low-density EPS can reach the same level as EPS with a density two to three times higher. Using optimized mixing technology as well as the right combination of additives in the process leads to an improved dispersion of the pigments in the final product and helps to lower the additive consumption in the Sulzer process compared to other processes.
A disadvantage of using plastics in construction is their flammability. Polystyrene, in particular, burns readily and EPS foam, unless equipped with flame retardants, does not fulfill common building codes relating to flame spread and smoke development. Therefore, the material has to be either used in combination with an additional flame barrier on the side of the construction method or impregnated with suitable flame retardants. The most Defined distribution of particle sizes widely used additive for this application The EPS quality is not only influenced is hexabromocyclododecane (HBCD), a by the composition of the material but highly brominated flame retardant with more than 70 wt% bromine per molecule. also by the geometry of the molded beads. An even, spherical shape of the beads HBCD has been the flame retardant of choice in EPS for several decades A* !1!*, .,$!-%ca( .$a,! +" /$! b!a . !*.0-!. now, because it is /$! b!./ ,a-/%c(! "0.%+*. very efficient: Typiensures the best particle fusion. The diamcally, HBCD levels between 0.7 % and eter required for the EPS particles 3 %depending on the type of synergist depends on the intended use of the final and process usedare required for product. Different size classes are building insulation to reach the desired typically defined for insulation, packagflame retardancy. In particular, the use ing, food containers, or cups. And an of synergists imposes very efficient optimal mold fill is supported by a temperature and shear control on the narrow, uniform bead size distribution. production process. With decomposition Together with Automatik Pelletizing temperatures as low as 150 C, as is the Systems, part of the MAAG group which case for commonly used peroxide was recently acquired by Dover Corposynergists, it becomes a prerequisite in ration, Sulzer Chemtech has further demelt impregnation to cool and maintain a low temperature and shear profile. veloped the existing underwater pelletization technology for stable production This factor has to be taken into account of uniform EPS, in particular, EPS confor the design of mixers, extruders, and taining pigments and flame retardants. pelletizers. Due to its outstanding sphericity and preFlexible process allows the use of cise pellet size distribution 2, the product HBCD substitutes can be processed like suspension product Recently, the toxicity and the environ- without prior screening or sieving. Due mental impact of HBCD have become to a unique die plate design and efficient matters of concern. Measurements have heating, die freezing can be minimized shown that the material bioaccumulates even for small bead sizes below 1 mm.
and biomagnifies so that several environmental protection agencies have put the chemical on their lists of concerns. This development has prompted the EPS industry to start the search for a substitute for HBCD. Due to its ingenious design and efficient temperature control, the Sulzer EPS process is much more flexible than classic suspension technology as it allows the use of new flame retardants currently in development.
POLYMERS
Premature foaming of the beads is avoided thanks to pressure and temperature control in the closed pelletization water circuit.
Blowing agent Polymer feed (PS, EPS, recyclate) Additives (FR, pigments) EPS micropellets
Gear pump
Underwater pelletizer
3 Sulzers EPS process is suited for small-scale EPS production (5003000 kg/h).
with the renowned German extruder manufacturer Coperion, allows for the economic production of EPS specialties even on scales adapted to the requirements of larger converters. Sulzer supports EPS converters who want to develop their own foam formulations. They can produce and test customized EPS grades with various additives in Sulzers pilot test facilities. The clients benefit from the broad experience that Sulzer Chemtech and its partners have gathered with melt impregnation technology.
Applying the in-depth process expertise From the very beginning, Sulzer has from a decade of EPS process develop- focused its process development on enviment, Sulzer Chemtech has developed ronmentally friendly solutions for EPS a second-generation EPS process suited, S0(5!- C$!)/!c$ !1!(+,. a* +""!-. in particular, to small/!c$*+(+#4 "+- /$! -!c4c(%*# +" EPS. scale production 3. production. This designation encompassUsing a combination of a twin-screw es two major areas: recycling capabilities extruderin which PS or EPS, blowing agent, and all required additives are com- and the use of alternative blowing agents. Because EPS is a lightweight, single-use poundedand Sulzers proprietary melt product with a decomposition time of coolers, the engineers have designed a several thousand years in nature, the simplified manufacturing unit that is end-of-life debate has always had a negattractive for smaller capacities of about ative imprint on the product image. At 5003000 kg per hour. This extruder the same time, the commonly used blowprocess, the result of a joint cooperation
ing agent pentane for foaming EPS has a critical global warming potential and falls under strict regulations in many countries and legislations. While suspension polymerization is rather inflexible in view of addressing these aspects, melt impregnation offers a lot of room for process innovation. Sulzer Chemtech develops and offers technology for the recycling of both unfoamed, impregnated EPS from production (e.g., off-spec material, unsold material from stock, etc.) and compressed foam from consumer recycling or production internal sources (cutoff, blocks, etc.). Those materials can be used as feed stream and be 100 % reutilized for production of virgin EPS resin. By using alternative blowing agents, which do not fall under the regulations of volatile organic compounds (VOC) yet have similar properties to those of pentane, converters can save significant money on pentane abatement systems and VOC taxes that may apply in some countries. Development of these process innovations is currently ongoing within Sulzer Chemtech.
P01317 N1:15/ Sulzer Chemtech Ltd Sulzer-Allee 48 8404 Winterthur Switzerland Phone +41 52 262 50 22 philip.nising@sulzer.com
POLYMERS
Flexible and durable high-efficiency pumps for the chemical process industry
he wide range of processes in the polymer-manufacturing industries leads to an extensive scope of pumping necessities. It is essential to the operation of polymer plants that the process pumps fulfill a variety of requirements. In most polymer plants, pumps generate the majority of energy cost. Therefore, efficiencyof both hydraulics and electrical driveis important. Another, even more crucial, criterion is the reliability
of the pumps, because unplanned interruptions of the often-complex chemical processes can cause significant cost increases and environmental impact.
work with all types of liquids makes this pump range particularly suitable for the challenging pumping operations required in chemical processes. Whereas the basics of pumping are the same in all applicationsmoving a liquid and increasing its pressurethe specific parameters of the liquids to be processed can differ dramatically. The fluids can vary in viscosity or they can contain fibers or solids.
AHLSTAR pumps are designed for safe operation and easy maintenance and service.
4377
POLYMERS
40
66
73 79 84 88 91
35
2
30
25 H-), H (4)
20
15
1 530 mm 2 505 mm
79 73
10
3 485 mm 4 465 mm
5 440 mm
Sulzer engineers had to consider all European standard EN 733 for light those and more boundary conditions industrial processes when they designed the over ten different The metric standard ISO 5199, for impellers that make the AHLSTAR range example, covers the requirements for suited for almost every hydraulic require- pumps of back pullout construction as ment. Whether closed or open, dedicated used primarily in the chemical and petrofor low discharge, or wear-resistant, chemical industries. It includes design impellers make it possible for the features relating to installation, mainteAHLSTAR pumps to work with slurries, nance, and safety. Other codes define clear, or contaminated liquids or fluids main dimensions and operating ranges containing solids of various sizes. These of the pumps. process pumps can work at temperatures The pumps of the AHLSTAR series of up to 260 C and pressures of up to fulfill ISO 5199 and ISO 2858 interna2.5 MPa, which is roughly equivalent to tional standards relating, e.g., to dimenthe pressure 250 m below water. With W%/$ /$! -%#$/ c$+%c! +" )a/!-%a(., the right choice /$! AHLSTAR ,0),. +,!-a/! c+--+.%+* "-!!. of materials, these pumps operate corrosion free even sions of flanges and base plates and, when handling liquids with extreme therefore, do not require special effort pH values from 0 up to 14. to install or maintain within existing pipework. When it comes to performance Exceeding international standards and quality, the pumps of the AHLSTAR International standards define sets of range have extra features exceeding minimum criteria that clients can expect the basic requirements and even surto be fulfilled by standard pumps. pass the international standards Depending on the specification, the governing technical performance and following standards are applied to quality 1. centrifugal pumps: Solutions for liquids with high gas load API 610 (ISO 13709) standard for Conventional centrifugal pumps can handemanding processes in the oil and dle liquids with gas content below 4 %, gas and hydrocarbon industries but gas bubbles collected in the impeller ISO 5199 and ISO 2858 (as well as eye do impair pumping and will reduce American standards ASME73.1) for capacity and head. At a gas content of industrial processes
The shear-thinning behavior of polymers (also known as pseudoplastic behavior) means that the viscosity becomes smaller if the rate of shearing increases. Such changing viscosity coefficients have to be considered in the pump design for polymer manufacturing.
POLYMERS
In conventional centrifugal pumps, the free gas accumulates in front of the impeller.
above 4 %, pumping is very unstable, and, without special measures, it requires excessive overdimensioning of the pump. Sulzer has found a solution to this customer requirement by offering degassing and self-priming units in the AHLSTAR series, which will stabilize centrifugalpump operation with liquids containing
up to 40 % weakly bonded gases or up to 70 % strongly bonded gases. The AHLSTAR pumps can be fitted with selfpriming or degassing units to start the pump with the inlet pipe empty or to help the pump operate with liquid containing high gas content, where conventional centrifugal pumps would lose suction compatibility.
ation, customers benefit from longer pump life, fewer unexpected shutdowns, and lower maintenance costs.
Superior reliability
Centrifugal pumps in industrial applications usually operate over a period of several decades. The design of the AHLSTAR pumps 2 aims to minimize the life cycle costs during the long expected lifetime. Whereas energy comprises the most significant direct cost of the pump, high reliability and easy maintenance help to bring down the indirect cost. The failure of one pump can stop the whole chemical processleading to increased costs and environmental impact
Energy costs make up about 80 % of the life cycle cost of a process pump. Sulzer's engineers have considered this fact when designing the AHLSTAR pump series. Traditionally, pumps are operated with a constant-speed drive motor and a flow control valve to adjust the discharge. AHLSTAR ,0),. +,!-a/! 2%/$ 1a-%ab(! .,!! This operating mode -%1! )a'! !*!-#4 .a1%*#. 0, /+ 60% ,+..%b(!. can be compared to that easily outweigh the lifetime energy always driving a car at full throttle engine cost of the pump. speed and only using the brakes to A design with the goal of achieving control the velocity. If the pump motor low outage costs for the pump has to is operated using an electronic frequency take into consideration two main aspects. converter, it is possible to vary the rotating speed of the impeller and, thus, First, a reliable pump design minimizes the lifetime maintenance costs and to run the pump at high efficiency in a reduces the risk of unscheduled process broad operating range, making energy savings of up to 60 % possible. Further- interruption. Second, the units must be designed to be service friendly to shorten more, when operated with variable downtime whenever maintenance is speed, the pump runs smoothly without required. One example of this approach recirculation and with lower vibration is the innovative impeller mounting, and noise due to the low internal hydraulic loads. With this smoother oper- which allows for easy and quick instal-
POLYMERS
ronment. The Sulzer process pumps sup- leaking. The shaft seals of AHLSTAR port these efforts with various features. require little or no water lubrication and Reliable shaft seals of the pump specifO1!- 90% +" /$! )!/a((%c )a/!-%a( 0.! "+ically selected for )a*0"ac/0-%*# /$! ,0), ca* b! -!c4c(! . pumped liquids and related applications prevent the pumped thus help to further reduce the environMinimal environmental impact liquids from leaking, and reliable shaft mental impact and operation costs. All industries must consider the ecological seals of the bearing unit prevent both Recycled metallic materials, reliable consequences of their processes and the contaminants from coming into con- operation, high energy efficiency, as well reduce the impact of those on the envi- tact with lubricant and lubricants from as few leaks from shaft sealing and bearing additionally minimize the enviSulzer Pumps has a full-scale laboratory in Kotka, Finland, ronmental impact of the units. Furtherand can test the final design options in real operational conditions. more, over 90 % of the metallic material used for manufacturing the pump can be recycled at the end of the pumps lifetime. lation and dismounting of the impeller. The highly standardized modular design of the AHLSTAR range facilitates spare parts service for the large number of pumps installed all around the world in different industrial segments.
INTERVIEW
Lorenzo Ghelfi presents polymer samples from the new pilot plant.
You and your team call the new pilot plant Jolanda. What can Jolanda do? With this facility, we can produce the bioplastic polylactic acid (PLA) on an industrial scale. Jolanda can produce up to 1000 tons of PLA a year. The starting materials for our innovative processes are dimers of lactic acid, which are extracted from natural raw materials such as sugar, starch, or cellulose. What is so innovative about this process? Our polymerization process is characterized by the unique mixing technology. With our static mixer technology and the SMRplus mixing reactor, we can considerably shorten reaction time and nevertheless have very good control over the entire process. Our competitors are using processes in which the polymer is retained in large reactors over much longer time periods. With the increase
in viscosity during the reaction, the dwell time in such reactors cannot be controlled across the complete volume of the tank. Our facility, on the other hand, is equipped with numerous, very efficient heating and cooling zones. As a result, we can precisely control temperature, viscosity, and pressure at every stage of the polymerization process, and we can thereby achieve the desired product properties. How did the idea for the new PLA process arise? Sulzer has already accumulated more than twenty years of experience with lactic acid and derivatives for the production of PLA. At the beginning, our interest was in the preparation and cleaning of lactic acid products through rectification. We then developed the crystallization technique for lactides. Sulzer Chemtech strengthened its expertise in the systems area with the acquisition of the Khni company in 2009. Cooperation with Puracthe world leader in lactic acid and lactide productionand Synbra as our end customer then led to our PLA activities. We thereby used our well-tested mixing and reaction technology as the basis, and we continued to develop the process
specifically for the production of PLA. A first, continuous pilot plant in Winterthur with this new PLA technology delivered such convincing results that a contract to build a large installation at Synbra in Holland came about within a very short time. With the new process, our customer can produce bioplastics with higher quality and tailor-made propertiesand that at a price that can increasingly compete with conventional petrochemical plastics. The new pilot plant now opens up entirely new possibilities. What are the major benefits for the customers? The new PLA facility in Pfffikon is larger and more efficient than the existing pilot system in our test center in Winterthur. We can now also ensure continuous operation with the operational concept of the new plant. We employ nine operators in three shifts in Pfffikon. In addition, we work closely with our development laboratory in Winterthur, where our analysis team is based. The new plant has a variety of functions. It serves as a demonstration plant for future customers and makes it possible to train their employees. It is also used for productionboth for larger
4378
INTERVIEW
product samples for customers and for the development of our own formulations and new PLA products. Why do customers want a demonstration of the technology? Customers invest millions in large-scale production plants, and want to take on as little risk as possible on the technical side. It is therefore understandable that the customers would like to see our polymerization process one-on-one before they make their investment. With our new plant, the customers can precisely check the energy consumption and efficiency of the process, as well as the quality of the product, well in advance.
plants or even complete PLA systems therein the immediate vicinity of the cultivation areasis particularly attractive. More and more companies around the world are becoming interested in PLA. What is the reason for this? Companies increasingly see a strategic advantage in producing products from alternative raw materials instead of mineral oil. At the moment, almost all the products in the plastics market are based on mineral oil and natural gas. The desire to become independent of rising prices and the limited availability of fossil fuels is a major trend.
How would you differentiate this project from the earlier ones that you carried out for Sulzer all over the world? I have worked for Sulzer all around the globe: in Brazil, Argentina, Russia, and the USA. This time, in the new project in Switzerland, there are no difficulties with regard to cultural and language differences. However, the official regulations and specifications for work and environmental protection are dealt with much more strictly here. Why has Sulzer Chemtech decided on the location in Pfffikon? Can production be cost effective in the high-wage country of Switzerland? Customers from all over the world visit us and appreciate the proximity to the sales department of Sulzer Chemtech as well as the easy accessibility via the nearby Zurich International Airport. Switzerland offers an ideal environment for high-tech industry. Furthermore, we also benefit from the proximity to our development department, which supports us in the operation and optimization of the plant. This would not be possible at other locations. And, as we work efficiently following LEAN principles, we are also competitive at the location Switzerland. What is planned for the future? We are planning to operate Jolanda for some years in order to establish the new PLA technology on the market. The significant investment in this polymer system should act as a trigger and lead to the breakthrough of the technology.
Interview: Tnde Kirstein
The production of samples is also an Is the PLA business also a growth important issue for the customers. market for Sulzer? Yes, because the customers carry out Yes, we have ambitious goals. The new their market development in the time PLA technology and our demonstration period from the purchase to the compleW%/$ J+(a* a 2! 2a*/ /+ !./ab(%.$ +0- *!2 PLA tion of a PLA plant /!c$*+(+#4 +* /$! )a-'!/. and there are many plant should considerably increase our risks in marketing. Before you produce the corresponding amounts in the kilo- business with polymers. Thecurrently still smallproportion of polymer ton scale in a large plant, there is always processing technology in the total sales the question of whether the right of Sulzer Chemtech should increase products have been selected, whether significantly in the next few years. the quality meets the requirements of specific applications and whether enough end consumers can be found. You, yourself, have been with Sulzer for more than 30 years. What experiOur customers therefore require PLA ence do you bring to this project? samples to be produced in advance, in What were the greatest challenges? order to be able to manufacture and test I bring experience in engineering and end products such as foils or fibers. With management. Managing a purely chemour facility, we can deliver PLA samples ical production is a new challenge for with various formulations in quantities me. But thanks to my life and professional from 20 to 200 tons and thereby ensure experience, I can comfortably deal with that the later production and sale runs unexpected situations. smoothly for the customers. It has been particularly challenging Who are your customers? to coordinate the teams from three We have received inquiries from major locations and to thereby keep to time plastics producers as well as many and cost schedules. Our colleagues in smaller companies who have cost-effec- Allschwil built the plant. The departtive access to the natural raw materials. ment in Winterthur is responsible for the In many countries in Asia and South engineering, while we in Pfffikon carry America, plants such as sugar cane or out the assembly. Thanks to the great cassava roots are cultivated in large quan- dedication of all our employees, we have tities, so that sugar and starch are easily been able to overcome all these difficulaccessible. The construction of processing ties.
L69-5A6 G0-3.1 studied mechanical engineering at the ZHAW (Zurich University of Applied Sciences), Winterthur, Switzerland. He worked as a project engineer in the field of industrial combustion technology for metallurgy and power plant construction. He has been working for Sulzer Chemtech for more than 30 years in the fields of international sales, project management, and engineering, as well as the production of process equipment for the international construction of chemical plants and oil refineries. During his foreign deployments in managing positions in Argentina, Brazil, Russia, and in the USA, he built up new business units for Sulzer and expanded the global market presence of Sulzer Chemtech. He recently returned to Switzerland following his deployment of several years in Russia and is now managing the buildup and the operation of the polymer pilot plant in Pfffikon.
POLYMERS
he use of surface coatings or treatments has gained acceptance as a way to improve tools in the production of plastics. Depending on the application, different thin-film technologies are used for wear and corrosion protection and for the minimization of friction. Sulzer Metco is a market leader for coating services, and it works together with well-known customers in the plastics industry. For example, the CocaCola Company in China produces all its caps with tools that have been coated by Sulzer Metco. More than 25 % of all beverage caps in the world are produced
with tools that have been coated by Sulzer Metco 1. Surface solutions from Sulzer Metco not only fulfill the high requirements of the food industry, they are also used in the demanding production of medical engineering products. Tools that have been coated by Sulzer Metco produce around 15 % of all medicinal disposable syringes worldwide.
Corrosion, above all, in the form of surface and pitting corrosion Fouling by the smallest particles or coatings on the tools Abrasive wear as a result of particles embedded in the plastic Cavitation (tool-damaging bubbles in the plastic material) through local vapor pressure differences in the flowing medium Adhesive interactions Surface damage when cleaning the tools Additives enhance the wear mechanisms. The additives that are important for plastics can be dyes, plasticizers, or other
More than 25 % of all beverage caps worldwide, including those for Coca-Cola in China, are produced using tools that have been coated by Sulzer Metco.
4379
POLYMERS
Resistance to wear and friction and sliding properties can be improved with the IONIT procedure, which can also be used for high-alloy steels, super alloys, and light metals such as titanium and titanium alloys. Cost savings are possible in both procedures, above all, through the replacement of expensive materials. For example, tempered steels, which are considerably cheaper, can be used in place of stainless steels.
fillings, such as glass fibers or chalk. They are used to influence component properties such as strength, elasticity, and hardness. At the same time, however, these modified plastics place more load on the tools during the production process and increase wear. A coating or heat treatment of the tools can reduce the abovementioned wear, which increases their service life and reduces the maintenance outlay. At the
1 Tools with diamond-like carbon coatings are used in the production of beverage caps.
POLYMERS
control system
2 Circular evaporators 3 Power supplies 4 Coating chamber 5 Process gas 6 Vacuum pump set 7 Window 8 Infrared temperature 3 8 2 7
measurement
9 Substrate holder 10 BIAS power supply (substrate) 10 4
Prevention of slip-stick effects (these arise from a reduced difference between sliding and adhesion friction) Elimination of burner streaking Improvement of the flow behavior of the polymer melt and, thereby, an increase in the transport capacity
C$D 796+-::
In the thermal CVD process energy is supplied in form of heat; in the plasmaassisted CVD process, (see figure) a gas is excited in a plasma.
1 Vacuum pump 2 Substrate 3 Gas supply, e.g. CH4 4 Reactive plasma 5 Plasma generator 3 5 2 4
Thermoplastic synthetics, such as polyetheretherketone (PEEK), and elastomers, such as natural rubber, can be successfully processed. PVD coatings are also successfully used in the extrusion of polyethylene (PE) or polypropylene (PP), among other applications, as well as on polyethylene terephthalate (PET) molding tools.
POLYMERS
molding and extrusion molding. Using Advantages of combined treatment dustry, polishing companies, and tool this method, a scratch-free passive layer manufacturers profit from the consider- The combination of plasma nitration that has a high resistance to corrosion able advantages of a Psolid coating 5. with subsequent coating using PVD or The time savings reduce production and PACVD combines the advantages of both and pitting is formed on the surface of types of surface treatment. Steels that the tools and molds. contain proportions of special alloying The use of a Psolid W%/$ P.+(% c+a/%*#. /$! ,(a./%c. ,-+c!..%*# elements (chrome, aluminum, vanadium, coating on corrosion%* 0./-4 ,-+"%/. "-+) c+*.% !-ab(! /%)! .a1%*#.. molybdenum) can achieve high surface resistant steels or repair costs dramatically, while simulta- hardness and represent an excellent basis cold-working steels with high chromium neously providing a considerable for the subsequent coating. The mechancontent provides hardening without any improvement in the uptime of the tools. ical properties of the material core, such loss in corrosion protection. In the coating of hot- and cold-working steels 5 Matrix blocks for the manufacture of disposable syringes have in particular, the diffusion layer creates cavitation holes on the inside. These cannot be coated with traditional tool surfaces with values up to 1600 HV. coatings with P.+(% , it is unproblematic. With a diffusion depth of 1050 m, coated components nevertheless remain constant in size and shape.
POLYMERS
as toughness and crack resistance, remain unchanged. With the combined treatment, the loadbearing capacity of the surface is decisively improved, so that the infamous eggshell effect does not occur (see infobox). In the processing of glass-fiber-reinforced polymer materials, these kinds of hardened tool surfaces prevent the added hard additives from being pressed into the tool surface at high process pressures. In plastics processing, the tools have to be cleaned at the latest during a production change. Polymer residues are thereby usually removed using scrapers and spatulas made from steel, which
can easily lead to damage to the surface. This damage can be avoided through the supportive effect of nitriding.
6 A 4.5m-long extrusion screw is coated in the Sulzer system for large and long parts.
In the field of thin-film technology, Sulzer Metco has service centers worldwide for the contract treatment of tools and components. In addition to services for surface improvement for various T$! .!-1%c! /!a). +" S0(5!- M!/c+ $a1! )a*4 industrial and appli4!a-. +" !3,!-%!*c! %* !a(%*# 2%/$ ,(a./%c /++(.. cation areas, its own system construction division delivers and 3.18 m3 total volume. Furthermore, extruder screws or wide-slot nozzles up innovative new developments and to lengths of 4500 mm, diameters up to further developments through its own 600 mm, and volumes of 1.27 m3 can be treated 6.
research and development work. The service teams have many years of experience in dealing with plastic tools. The members of staff make use of their extensive experience in the industry to provide the clients with targeted consultation. A special feature is the contract treatment of long and large parts. The maximum dimensions for large-volume parts are: 1800 mm long, 1500 mm diameter,
"064): )<. ,-4 B9152Sulzer Metaplas GmbH Am Bttcherberg 3038 51427 Bergisch-Gladbach Germany Phone +49 2204 299 293 thomas.aufdembrinke@sulzer.com A55-;;- N6915 Am Bttcherberg 3038 51427 Bergisch-Gladbach Germany Phone +49 2204 299 262 annette.norin@sulzer.com
SULZER ANALOGY
he most highly developed examples of the natural silk technique are the webs of cross spiders and other orbweaving spiders. They construct a vertical, two-dimensional web between two anchor points that are relatively far apart. Starting from a first, bridging
can thereby cushion the impact of the collision. If the stretched thread were to then spring back to its original position like a rubber rope, the insect would be catapulted back into freedom as if from a trampoline. But because the web returns only gently after the rapid expansion, the prey remains caught. The trick lies in the sticky water drops. The silk thread is rolled up on the drops through the surface tension of the liquid. The resulting numerous loops cause, like a cable reel, both the rapid extension and the braked rerolling of the thread.
tensile strength of spider silk is around 2500 kg/cm2. Relative to its weight, it is, therefore, five times stronger than steel.
With their silk glands, spiders produce a silk material with exceptional properties.
thread, the spider constructs the basic framework of the orb web with edge threads and spokes and, finally, the catching spiral by means of an auxiliary spiral. Any insect that hits the web will become caught on this catching spiral through a chain of extremely sticky pearl-like drops made up of water and glycol proteins.
Spider silk is a wonder of nature and can even improve the sound of violins.
4375
POLYMERS
ulzer Innotec supports the Sulzer divisions and external clients in polymer analyses with its modern laboratory and its many years of expertise in plastics. The following project examples from Sulzer Innotec show that many factors (such as material composition, component manufacturing, and operating conditions) have to be taken into account in polymer analysis
in order to uncover the causes of shortcomings and to find adequate solutions for them.
various manufacturers. The price of the material plays a central role in the choice of the supplier. The selection is still not easy, however, because the quality differences are often not recognizable at first glance. In order to ensure that the component quality remains the same, even following a change of supplier, it is recommended that buyers carry out a detailed analysis of the
Micrographs clearly illustrate how plastics are composed of different constituents (thin section under polarized light).
4380
POLYMERS
replacement material in advance. Deficiencies occurring in operation can thereby be avoided from the very start.
Comparing suppliers
For an external client, Sulzer Innotec compared carbon-fiber-reinforced modified PEEK materials from two different suppliers. For the end product, which is subjected to high mechanical and tribological loads, the client wanted to replace the feedstock pellets from supplier A with the cheaper pellets from supplier B. Sulzer Innotec was asked to determine whether or not the main components of the two materials were qualitatively and quantitatively the same. To start with, standard laboratory test methods were applied to the problem: Fourier transform infrared spectrometry (FTIR) Thermoanalysis: Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) Dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) Optical microscopy
The results of the FTIR analyses showed an optimal match with the database spectrum of PEEK for both feedstock pellets A and B. No indication of the supposed PTFE lubricant (Teflon) was found in either feedstock by means of FTIR. The results of the thermoanalytical investigations also revealed no obvious differences between the pellets from the although the qualitative and quantitative two suppliers. The two temperature composition of the two materials was peaks at approx. 21 C and 330 C for shown to be the same and although the the two materials clearly indicated the presence of PTFE, however. With addi- fabrication of the end products was carried out using the same processing tional investigations (thermogravimetry and optical microscopy), the relative pro- parameters, the resulting products made portions of PEEK, PTFE, carbon fiber, D!.,%/! a)b%#0+0. /!./ -!.0(/., S0(5!- 2a. and graphite could ab(! /+ /-ac! /$! ca0.!. +" /$! %*.0""%c%!*/ be determined. The )a/!-%a( b!$a1%+-. comparison between using feedstock B exhibited suboptimal the two feedstocks also showed no properties: These parts exhibited sliding differences here. behavior deemed insufficient for the The same, but not the same intended application. According to the analyses, the pellets The material analysts from Sulzer from the two suppliers should have been Innotec were able to discover the cause able to be processed into end products of this discrepancy. Thanks to scanning with equivalent properties. However, electron microscopy (SEM) of the two
1 Only in the scanning electron micrographs can a difference be seen between the pellets: The PTFE filler (light color) in material A (left) has a different distribution from that in material B (right).
10 m
10 m
POLYMERS
pellet types, they were able to detect significant microscale differences between the two materials. While in feedstock A, the PTFE phase (light-colored in Fig. 1) was relatively evenly distributed and took on a spherical form, in feedstock B, the PTFE component appeared as locally concentrated agglomerates looking something like popcorn. The difference concerning the appearance of the PTFE can be traced back to the use of different types of PTFE in the two feedstocks. With this knowledge, the poorer sliding properties could be conclusively explained, and consequently the client decided against a change of supplier.
free of damage
defective
20 mm
3 Two identically manufactured oil scrapers made of PPS behave completely differently in operation.
2 The images of the polystyrene lid taken under polarized light reveal residual stresses in the material, which stem from the manufacturing process.
Injection point
POLYMERS
difference was a first clue answering the question as to whether the breakout was due to the composition of the material, the processing, or the operating conditions.
Specialists from Sulzer Innotec on-site assessment of the situation is difassessed the seal geometry and the ficult, because the causal factors influence O-ring groove on site and found each other and are not obvious. them to be in order, but detected massive Sulzer Innotec investigated defects in damage to the O-rings themselves 5. the seals of water-cooled engines, for which silicone O-rings were used. The deformation of the O-rings and According to the data sheet from the I* ca.! +" a)a#! ca0.! %* +,!-a/%+*, S0(5!material manufactura*a(45!. *+/ +*(4 #!+)!/-%ca( a* )!c$a*%ca( er, the silicone used ,-+,!-/%!., b0/ a(.+ /$!-)+c$!)%ca( ,-+c!..!.. is resistant to water the numerous cracks along the entire and steam at operating temperatures circumference indicated the occurrence below 130 C. However, leaks in the seals of a thermal degradation process. Labowere detected after an operational period ratory tests on unused O-rings were able of only six months 4.
4 First on-site inspections provide only few indications of the causes of defects (e.g., at these O-ring seals in a water-cooled engine).
POLYMERS
10 mm
5 The numerous cracks in the silicone O-rings indicated a thermochemical cause of the failure.
Left, a new silicone seal and, right, a silicone seal aged and embrittled by exposure to water vapor at 140 C.
to show that both material and manufacturing quality could be excluded as causes of the failure.
More-detailed analyses finally led the analysts at Sulzer Innotec onto the right track: The damage to the O-rings was Ba.! +* S0(5!-7. /!./ -!.0(/., a )a&+- )a/!-%a( due to a chemical c$a*#! 2a. %*%/%a/! . decomposition of the silicone as a result of the conditions expe- the operating temperature in the area of the O-rings to below 130 C, or replace rienced in operation. The cause was a damp environment (hydrolysis) at a tem- the silicone with a more suitable elastomer material. Using aging trials perature that was too high (significantly above 130 C). Consequently, the macro- developed and performed out in-house, Sulzer Innotec was able to narrow molecules of the O-ring material were being split chemically, resulting in short- down the choices and recommend the
7 Aging trials for the selection of a suitable sealing material were carried out in the laboratory.
ened molecular chains and the consequent embrittlement of the material. The degeneration process could be reproduced in laboratory trials, since degradation also occured without the mechanical loading typically experienced in operation 6. The client had two options available based on this result: Either reduce
best-possible sealing material 7. Followup checks on the seals in use confirmed the good results from the laboratory. Based on the results from Sulzer Innotec, a major material change to a special fluoroelastomer was initiated.
GC5;-9 DB95-9 Sulzer Innotec Sulzer-Allee 25 8404 Winterthur Switzerland Phone +41 52 262 69 41 guenter.doerner@sulzer.com
SULZER WORLD
hrough the acquisition of Bekaerts DLC division in 2010, Sulzer Metco expanded its technology portfolio in the area of thin-film surface coating. The location in Limoges that is involved in this field has a long history of success with DLC coatings. The first engines were coated with DLC here as long ago as 1995, and the location has experienced active growth in the meantime. This is especially evident from the numerous expansion activities in the production halls in the last few years. Clients can be sure that the 65 employees at the location will guarantee the very best quality at all times.
ticularly suitable for use in motor sport, where every millisecond is crucial. Formula 1 teams worldwide are equipped with DLC coatings. At the Limoges site, the majority of the business is generated in motor sport. Significant and steady growth can, however, also be seen in the fields of plastics, automobiles, engineering, and metalworking. Surface solutions for the semiconductor industry are also being offered in increasing numbers.
T$! /!a) %* L%)+#!. .!/. *!2 ./a* a- . 2%/$ %/. DYLYN6 c+a/%*#..
under realistic production conditions, which makes the rapid transition to a sustainable production process particularly easy. In addition, Limoges is currently working together with the University of Limoges and leading partners from the automobile industry on a research project that will set new standards with its DYLYN coatings. The proximity of the location to the university, which is only 500 meters away, facilitates the continuous cooperation with qualified students and institutes. Sulzer Metco in Limoges stands out through its impressive diversity. In addition to modern coating installations and high-tech equipment, the expert knowledge of the employees is just as important as the wide competence network with industry and research. Through the experience and the broad-based expertise of the employees in Limoges, Sulzer can continue to grow internationally and expand its position as a technology expert.
The location in Limoges is world-famous in motor sports for diamond-like carbon coatings.
4381
PANORAMA
F
1 2 3
inding defects in turbine blades is one important task of the lock-in thermography setup at Sulzer Turbo Services 1. An ultrasound transducer introduces elastic waves (propagating elastic deformations) into the turbine component. In homogeneous material, the reflected waves are evenly distributed. However, at locations where the alloy is
damaged, some of the wave energy is absorbed, and heat is generated. This heat has a different infrared (IR) radiation than its surrounding area and is detected by the IR camera 2 (see infobox).
an amplitude image and a phase image of the turbine component. The amplitude image is a measure for the temperature and is related to the thermal diffusivity. The phase image reveals the size and depth of the defect. The phase is a result of a shift in the output signal with respect to the input signal and is related to the propagation time or depth.
1 Sulzer Turbo Services Venlo uses ultrasonic thermography for turbine inspection and research.
4382
PANORAMA
Thermographic inspection
In thermographic inspection, an infrared (IR) camera measures and visualizes the heat distribution within an object. There are two approaches: In 7)::1=- ;0-946/9)70@, the existing thermal radiation of an object is measured. Common applications are the detection of insulation faults in housing, detection of overheating in power supply stations, and level detection in storage tanks. A+;1=- ;0-946/9)70@ introduces energy into the object and measures the objects response. One method is lock-in thermography, which uses a transducer to introduce ultrasonic waves into the object.
FFT
IR camera
Phase image
2 The detection principle of lockin thermography is based on ultrasonic waves that generate heat at damaged locations inside the turbine part.
Ultrasonic excitation
Lock-in frequency
The bright spots in the phase image need to be inspected in more detail in order to determine whether the hot spot is a real defect. For this reason, the sequence profilewhich is the amount of radiation measured on one spot in time is analyzed. The sequence profile of a defect is different from the profile of other surrounding heat sources, for example, the reflection of a lamp. A defect shows a response curve similar to the modulation frequency of the excitation.
approaches. For instance, fluorescent penetrant inspection cannot detect internal defects and borescopic inspection is time consuming.
the part. If the coating is bonded properly to the base material, no friction heat is observable. Friction between the part and the poorly bonded coating creates a bright thermal signature. Recently, thermographic inspection has been compared with conventional manual ultrasonic inspection with a probe, and a 100 % match of observed indications has been achieved.
The magnified image on the top shows an internal crack; the magnified image on the bottom shows a crack on the surface.
PANORAMA
5 The thermographic measurement of a blade shows open and blocked cooling channels.
National Aerospace Laboratory of the For turbine components, cooling is very Netherlands. This model describes the important to extend and protect compo- heat transfer between combustion gas, nent life 4. During the repair of vanes cooling air, and surface temperature of or blades with cooling channels, it must the part. In order to validate the model, be ensured that all cooling holes are open. Sulzer built a test rig that represents the An IR camera can show at a glance turbine situation, just with inverse whether cooling holes are blocked T$! -!.!a-c$ -!.0(/. 2%(( a((+2 /$! +,/%)%5a/%+* or open. This is +" /$! c++(%*# !""%c%!*c4. achieved by blowing warm air through the component. A ther- thermal conditions. Warm air is guided mal image of the part is recorded in through the cooling channels and cold order to visualize the heating of the com- air flows along the outer surface of the ponent. Figure 5 shows an example of part. The parameters have been scaled such a recording. Open cooling holes down to ensure proper flow regimes and appear in bright yellow because of the flow ratios. heating by the warm air. Blocked cooling Validation of heat transfer model channels are not heated; they appear as The test rig 6 is designed to achieve a a blue-black color. controlled flow of air along the airfoil. Research on the efficiency of cooling For the hot air that flows through the holes vane, a temperature and flow control is Sulzer has started a research project in used. The actual setup consists of a vane order to develop a method of evaluating surrounded by a heating element, cold the efficiency of cooling channels of tur- airflow section, and IR camera. It allows bine blades and vanes. The results of the measurement of the wall temperature this project will provide more information of the component. about how the cooling-hole geometry An example of a measurement is affects the cooling efficiency. shown in Figure 7. The homogeneity of the cooling-hole pattern of four rows of The research is based on a heat transfer ten holes is easily recognizable by the model that has been developed by the
PANORAMA
Frequence regulator
Temperature probe
Pressure probe
Pressure probe
Camera
Fan
Vane
Stilling chamber
6 The test rig is designed to achieve a controlled flow of air along the airfoil.
peak temperatures. These results will be used as input for the model verification in the ongoing research project.
Corrosion in turbine blades Apart from fault detection, ultrasonic Spallation in the coating lock-in thermography is very successful Blocked cooling holes as an R&D instrument that enables Due to the high sensitivity of the IR engineers to increase their knowledge camera, even minor hot spots can be of turbine parts, improve repairs, and detected. A careful analysis by experiW%/$ 0(/-a.+*%c (+c'-%* /$!-)+#-a,$4, !*#%*!!-. enced technicians is %*c-!a.! /$!%- '*+2(! #! +" /0-b%*! ,a-/.. important in order to decide whether small defects are develop new designs to the benefit within allowable limits or whether the of the customers. defects need to be repaired.
7 The thermographic analysis of the cooling holes delivers data to help verify the heat transfer model.
K-3=15 350
340
330
320 330 310 320 310 300 290 280 300 250 300
290
J6: %133-4: Sulzer Turbo Services Venlo B.V. Spikweien 36 NL-5943 AD Lomm The Netherlands Phone +31 77 473 85 16 jos.willems@sulzer.com M)91<: =)5 ,-9 G<5 Sulzer Turbo Services Venlo B.V. Spikweien 36 NL-5943 AD Lomm The Netherlands Phone +31 77 473 86 43 marius.vandergun@sulzer.com
200
150
100
50
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
Sulzer is launching a new website which provides comprehensive information about the full range of products and services. With new functionalities and many additional documents, the website strengthens Sulzers internet presence for all businesses. The customer-focused approach of the website ensures high
Sulzer Tower Field Service is the leading provider of specialized mechanical services to offshore platforms, natural gas plants, oil refineries, and petrochemical plants. Customers benefit from mass transfer equipment services, welding services, plant maintenance, and turnaround projects on a global basis.
4383
IMPRINT
The S0(5!- T!c$*%ca( R!1%!2 (STR) is a customer magazine produced by Sulzer. It is published periodically in English and German and annually in Chinese. The articles are also available at: www.sulzer.com/str 2 /2012 94th year of the STR ISSN 1660-9042 Publisher Sulzer Management Ltd. P.O. Box 8401 Winterthur, Switzerland Editor-in-Chief Tnde Kirstein tuende.kirstein@sulzer.com Editorial Assistant Laura Gasperi sulzertechnicalreview@sulzer.com Advisory Board Mia Claselius Samuel Eckstein Ralf Gerdes Thomas Gerlach Hans-Michael Hhle Ernst Lutz Claudia Prger Heinz Schmid Daniel Schnyder Translations Interserv AG, Zrich Design Typografisches Atelier Felix Muntwyler, Winterthur Printer Mattenbach AG, Winterthur July 2012 Reprints of articles and illustrations are permitted subject to the prior approval of the editor. The S0(5!- T!c$*%ca( R!1%!2 (STR) has been compiled according to the best knowledge and belief of Sulzer Management Ltd. and the authors. However, Sulzer Management Ltd. and the authors cannot assume any responsibility for the quality of the information, and make no representations or warranties, explicit or implied, as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this publication. Circulation: 16 000 copies. Magno Satin 135 g/m2 from sustainably managed forests.
For readers in the United States of America only: The S0(5!- T!c$*%ca( R!1%!2 is published periodically by Sulzer Management Ltd., P.O. Box, 8401 Winterthur, Switzerland. Periodicals postage paid at Folcroft, PA, by US Mail Agent La Poste, 700 Carpenters Crossing, Folcroft PA 19032. Postmaster: Please send address changes to Sulzer Technical Review, P.O. Box 202, Folcroft PA 19032.
!<3A-9 "<9*6 !-9=1+-: Z'rcher !ra e 12 8401 Win!er!h"r S$i!&erland "l&er! @ "l&er.com $$$. "l&er.com