Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Infertility is the inability to conceive after at least one year of unprotected intercourse.
Since most people are able to conceive within this time, physicians recommend that
couples unable to do so be assessed for fertility problems.
In men, hormone disorders, illness, reproductive anatomy trauma and obstruction, and
sexual dysfunction can temporarily or permanently affect sperm and prevent conception.
Some disorders become more difficult to treat the longer they persist without treatment.
Because sperm development takes over 2 months, illness that was present during the first
cycle may affect mature sperm, regardless of a man's health at the time of examination.
Common causes for male infertility are impaired sperm production, impaired sperm
delivery, and testosterone deficiency (hypogonadism).
Infertility can result from a condition that is present at birth (congenital) or can develop
later (acquired). Causes for infertility include the following:
• Chemotherapy
• Defect or obstruction in the reproductive system (e.g., cryptorchidism, anorchism)
• Disease (e.g., cystic fibrosis, sickle cell anemia, sexually transmitted disease
[STD])
• Hormone dysfunction (caused by disorder in the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal
axis)
• Infection (e.g., prostatitis, epididymitis, orchitis)
• Injury (e.g., testicular trauma)
• Medications (e.g., to treat high blood pressure, arthritis)
• Metabolic disorders such as hemochromatosis (affects how the body uses and
stores iron)
• Retrograde ejaculation (i.e., condition in which semen flows backwards into the
bladder during ejaculation)
• Systemic disease (e.g., high fever, infection, kidney disease)
• Testicular cancer
• Varicocele
Retrograde ejaculation occurs when impairment of the muscles or nerves of the bladder
neck prohibit it from closing during ejaculation. It may result from bladder surgery, a
congenital defect in the urethra or bladder, or disease that affects the nervous system.
Diminished or "dry" ejaculation and cloudy urine after ejaculation may be signs of this
condition.
Testosterone Deficiency
The most common congenital cause is Klinefelter syndrome. This condition, which is
caused by an extra X chromosome, results in infertility, sparse facial and body hair,
abnormal breast enlargement (gynecomastia), and smaller than normal testes.
Other congenital causes include absence of the testes (anorchism; may also be acquired)
and failure of testicles to descend into scrotum (cryptorchidism).
• Chemotherapy
• Damage to the pituitary gland, hypothalamus, or testes
• Glandular malformation
• Head trauma affecting the hypothalamus
• Infection (e.g., meningitis, syphilis, mumps)
• Isolated LH deficiency (e.g., fertile eunuch syndrome)
• Radiation
• Testicular trauma
• Tumors of the pituitary gland, hypothalamus, or testicles
Diagnosis
The search for the cause of infertility usually begins with the male, because male
examination and testing is less complicated. A thorough examination and a review of the
man's medical and surgical history are necessary, because chronic disease, pelvic injury,
childhood illness, abdominal or reproductive organ surgery, recreational drug use, and
medications can affect fertility. Physical examination may detect testicular irregularities
(e.g., varicocele, absence of vas deferens, tumor), evidence of hormonal disorders (e.g.,
underdeveloped reproductive organs, enlarged breast tissue), or evidence of testosterone
deficiency.
Azoospermia is the absence of sperm in the semen. Men with normal reproductive tracts
and hormone systems can have azoospermia due to a lack of sperm-producing tissue in
the testes or an obstruction. Obstructions can be viewed with x-ray. The World Health
Organization has established criteria for normal sperm concentration, morphology, and
motility. Total motile sperm count, which should be about 40 million, is calculated by
multiplying volume by concentration by motility.
The semen fluid test looks at factors that may impede sperm performance. Abnormally
thick semen may cause sperm to swim more slowly through cervical mucus, obstructing
fertilization. Abnormal sperm shape (i.e., disfigured or multiple heads or tails) usually
indicates poor sperm health. Infertility is likely if 60% or more of sperm in semen is
abnormally shaped.
Other tests are concerned specifically with sperm's ability to swim through cervical
mucus and bind to and penetrate an egg. The postcoital Sims-Huhmer, or sperm-mucus
interaction test, examines whether the sperm are able to swim through the female
reproductive tract. This ability is referred to as forward progression. In the middle of the
menstrual cycle, the cervical mucus becomes watery. Intercourse is recommended during
this time, followed, the next day, with an inspection of the mucus to determine if
The sperm penetration assay (SPA), or sperm-oocyte interaction test, examines the
ability of sperm to penetrate the egg by combining it with a hamster egg. The
immunobead test looks at semen for the presence of antibodies that damage sperm.
Post-ejaculation urinalysis may identify diseases that affect fertility, such as kidney
disease, diabetes, and repeated urinary tract infection (UTI). Blood tests identify
disorders that impair testosterone and sperm production.
Treatment
At least one-half of male fertility problems can be treated so that conception is possible.
There are three categories of treatment for male infertility:
• Assisted reproduction
• Drug therapy
• Surgery
o Electroejaculation
o Sperm retrieval and washing
o In vitro fertilization (IVF)
o Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)
o Gamete intrafallopian transfer (GIFT)
Sperm retrieval This technique is used to obtain sperm from the testes or epididymis
when obstruction, congenital absence of the vas deferens, failed vasectomy reversal, or
inadequate sperm production causes azoospermia. Using a technique called micro
epididymal sperm aspiration (MESA), a surgeon makes an incision in the scrotum and
gathers sperm from the epididymis, the elongated, coiled duct that provides for the
maturation, storage, and passage of sperm from the testes. Percutaneous epididymal
sperm aspiration (PESA, or fine needle aspiration) is similar to MESA but does not
involve microsurgery. A physician uses a needle to penetrate the scrotum and epididymis
and draws sperm into a syringe. Testicular sperm extraction (TESE), the removal of a
small amount of testicular tissue, is used to retrieve sperm from men with impaired sperm
production, or when MESA fails. (see also Testis Biopsy)
These procedures are done under local anesthesia, usually take about 30 minutes, and
may cause pain and swelling.
Sperm washing This procedure isolates and prepares the healthiest sperm for
insemination. Sperm and washing medium are combined and spun rigorously
(centrifuged) and the process is repeated if necessary. The process separates sperm from
white blood cells and fatty acids (prostaglandins) in the semen that may hinder sperm
motility. It also concentrates sperm, which increases the chance for conception.
Sperm retrieved by MESA, PESA, or TESE may be used in in vitro fertilization (IVF)
and intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). IVF involves combining eggs with sperm
in a laboratory, providing proper fertilization conditions, and transferring the resulting
embryos to the uterus. To retrieve an egg, a specialist uses ultrasound to guide a fine
needle through the vaginal wall and into the ovary or makes an incision in the abdomen
to get to the ovary (laparoscopy). Once the eggs are retrieved, they are combined with
prepared sperm in a sterile dish for 2 to 4 days. After fertilization, the embryos are
transferred to the uterus. IVF is used most commonly for infertility caused by female
reproductive abnormalities.
Intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI) may be used with immotile sperm during in
vitro fertilization. Using a tiny glass needle, one sperm is injected directly into a retrieved
mature egg. The egg is incubated and transferred to the uterus.
Fertilization occurs in 50% to 80% of cases and approximately 30% result in a live birth.
The egg may fail to divide or the embryo may arrest at an early stage of development.
Younger patients achieve more favorable results and poor egg quality and advanced
maternal age result in lower success rates.
ICSI does not increase the incidence of multiple pregnancies. Long-term information
about the health and fertility of children conceived through this procedure is not available
because it was first performed in 1992.
While excess sperm from MESA or PESA can usually be frozen for future use, most
TESE-derived sperm are not of sufficient quality or quantity for frozen storage
(cryopreservation). Multiple MESA or PESA procedures are not recommended, since
repetition can lead to scarring.
Drug therapy for male infertility includes medications to improve sperm production,
treat hormonal dysfunction, cure infections that compromise sperm, and fight sperm
antibodies. The administration of testosterone is similar to that used to treat testosterone
deficiency. Tamoxifen (Nolvadex®), an antiestrogen agent, may be used to stimulate
gonadotropin (a male hormone) release, which leads to testosterone production.
Antibiotics, like levofloxacin (Levaquin®) and doxycycline (Periostat®), are used to
treat fertility-impairing infections of the urinary tract, testes, and prostate, and STDs.
Surgery for male infertility is performed to treat reproductive tract obstruction and
varicocele. Vasoepididymostomy is a microsurgical procedure that corrects obstruction
in the coiled tube that connects the testes with the vas deferens (epididymis).
Obstructions commonly result from STDs and also include cysts and tubal closure
(atresia), which is usually genetic. Vericocelectomy, the removal of a varicocele from the
testes, often results in increased sperm count.
Naturopathic Treatment
Naturopathic treatment for male infertility focuses on improving sperm quantity, sperm
quality, and overall male reproductive health. Researchers reported that sperm counts
have fallen almost 50% since the 1930s. Although some dispute these findings, it is
generally accepted that sperm counts are declining. The cause may be environmental and
dietary and lifestyle changes may interfere with men's sperm production. If this is so,
improving diet and making healthy lifestyle choices should positively impact male
reproductive health.
Nutrition
• Eat a natural foods diet that focuses on fresh vegetables, fruits, whole grains, fish,
poultry, legumes, nuts, and seeds.
• Drink 50% of body weight in ounces of water daily (e.g., a 150 lb man would
drink 75 oz of water).
• Eliminate processed and refined foods (e.g., white flour), junk food, sugars,
alcohol, and caffeine.
• Avoid saturated fats and hydrogenated oils (e.g., margarine); use olive oil.
• Pumpkin seeds are naturally high in zinc and essential fatty acids which are vital
to healthy functioning of the male reproductive system. Eat pumpkin seeds to help
maintain a healthy reproductive system.
Supplements
The following supplements may increase sperm count and/or motility. Allow 3-4 months
for the supplements to work.
• Arginine - Take 4 gr daily. Needed to produce sperm. If the sperm count is below
10 million per ml, arginine probably will not provide any benefit.
• Coenzyme Q10 - Take 10 mg daily. Increases sperm count and motility.
• Flaxseed oil - Take 1 tbsp daily. Is a source of essential fatty acids.
• L-carnitine - Take 3-4 grams daily. Required for normal sperm function.
• Multivitamin-mineral - Buy a high-quality product and take one serving size
(differs from brand to brand).
• Selenium - Take 200 mcg daily. Improves sperm motility.
• Vitamin B-12 - Take 1000 mcg daily. A B-12 deficiency reduces sperm motility
and sperm count. Even if no deficiency exists, B-12 supplementation may help
men with a sperm count of less than 20 million per milliliter or a motility rate of
less than 50%
• Vitamin C - Take 500 mg 2 times daily. Is an antioxidant.
• Vitamin E - Take 400 IUs 2 times daily. Is an antioxidant and improves sperms'
ability to impregnate.
• Zinc - Take 30 mg 2 times daily. Required for a healthy male reproductive system
and sperm production.
Herbal Medicine
Herbal remedies usually do not have side effects when used appropriately and at
suggested doses. Occasionally, an herb at the prescribed dose causes stomach upset or
headache. This may reflect the purity of the preparation or added ingredients, such as
synthetic binders or fillers. For this reason, it is recommended that only high-quality
products be used. As with all medications, more is not better and overdosing can lead to
serious illness and death.
The following herbs may be used to treat male infertility:
• Ginseng (Panax ginseng) - Known as a male tonic (an agent that improves
general health) and used to increase testosterone levels and sperm count. Siberian
ginseng (Eleutherococcus senticosus) may also be used.
• Astragalus (Astragalus membranaceus) - Increases sperm motility.
• Sarsaparilla (>Smilax spp.) - Known as a male (and female) tonic.
• Saw palmetto (Serenoa repens) - Used for overall male reproductive health.
Other Recommendations
Semen Analysis
Semen analysis is used to evaluate male fertility—a man's ability to reproduce. This test,
which also is called a sperm count, is used to measure the amount and quality of seminal
fluid or ejaculate. Seminal fluid contains male reproductive cells (semen or sperm) and
normally is expelled through the penis during ejaculation (sexual climax; orgasm).
Semen analysis also can be used to help diagnose Klinefelter's syndrome, which is the
most common congenital (inherited) cause for testosterone deficiency. This condition,
which is caused by an extra X chromosome, results in male infertility (inability to
conceive after one year of unprotected intercourse), sparse facial and body hair, abnormal
breast enlargement (gynecomastia), and small testes. In most cases, at least two sperm
counts are performed following vasectomy to look for sperm in the semen.
Semen analysis usually is performed by a fertility specialist. Seminal fluid can affect
factors such as sperm shape, function, and movement, so the entire ejaculate is examined.
Prior to semen analysis, ejaculation should be avoided for 2–3 days. The semen sample
can be collected in a sterile glass container through masturbation (i.e., sexual stimulation)
or through sexual intercourse using a special type of condom provided by the physician.
The sample must be analyzed within 1–2 hours to provide accurate results. Many
specialists require three different semen samples to account for factors that can affect
results, such as variations in temperature and laboratory errors. It often is recommended
that the results of the tests do not vary by more than 20%.
Normally, seminal fluid is clear to milky white in color, thick and sticky (viscous) in
consistency, has a pH (acidity) level between 7.8 and 8.0, and contains few or no white
blood cells (leukocytes).
The World Health Organization (WHO) has developed the following values for normal
semen analysis:
Although semen analysis often can suggest male infertility, the results may not identify
the cause for the condition. Additionally, some men with low sperm counts are able to
reproduce (i.e., are fertile). In many cases, abnormal semen analysis results require
additional testing.
There are a number of things that can cause low sperm count and a number of things that
can help increase sperm count.
Causes Varicoceles
Varicoceles are dilated veins in the scrotum (just as an individual may have varicose
veins in their legs). These veins are dilated because the blood does not drain properly
from them. These dilated veins allow extra blood to pool in the scrotum, which has a
negative effect on the sperm production. This condition is the most common reversible
cause of male factor infertility and may be corrected by minor outpatient surgery.
Most experts do this microscopically to preserve the arterial supply and lymphatics. A
sub-inguinal incision (about 1 inch above the penis and 1 inch from the midline) is
usually used, as this avoids incising the abdominal muscles and creates less post-
operative pain.
Sperm are stored in sacs called the seminal vesicles and are then deposited in the urethra,
which is the tube through which men urinate and ejaculate. The sperm must pass through
the ejaculatory ducts to get from the seminal vesicles to the urethra. If these are blocked
on both sides, no sperm will come through.
In some situations, the ducts may be repaired or unblocked to allow sperm to flow
through the man's reproductive tract. If this is not possible, the sperm may be harvested to
allow them to flow through the man's reproductive tract. Because they are obtained in
lower numbers, they must be used in conjunction with advanced reproductive techniques
to attempt a pregnancy.
Immunologic Infertility
Men can develop an immunologic response (antibodies) to their own sperm. The causes
for this may include testicular trauma, testicular infection, large varicoceles or testicular
surgery. Sometimes, there are unexplained reasons why this occurs.
These antibodies have a negative effect on fertility, although the exact reason why this is
the case is unclear. Most likely, these antibodies act negatively at several points along the
pathway to fertilization. They make it more difficult for the sperm to penetrate the
partner's cervical mucous and make its way into the uterus. They make it more difficult
for the sperm to bind with the zonapellucida (the external membrane or shell of the egg).
Also, the antibodies make it more difficult for the sperm to fuse with the membrane of the
oocytes (eggs) themselves.
The treatment for anti-sperm antibodies is somewhat controversial. Men may be treated
with corticosteroids. However, this can lead to significant morbidity in the man. The most
significant is aseptic necrosis of the hip (noninfectious destruction of the joint), requiring
hip replacement.
Most of the time, the first level of intervention includes intra-uterine inseminations. If the
couple is planning in-vitro fertilization (IVF) the presence of anti-sperm antibodies is
usually an indication to inject the sperm directly into the egg (ICSI) instead of
conventional IVF.
Testicular Failure
This generally refers to the inability of the sperm-producing part of the testicle (the
seminiferous epithelium) to make adequate numbers of mature sperm. This failure may
occur at any stage in sperm production for a number of reasons. The testicle may
completely lack the cells that divide to become sperm (“Sertoli Cell-Only syndrome”).
There may be an inability of the sperm to complete their development ("maturation
arrest"). Sperm may be made in such low numbers that few, if any, successfully travel
through the ducts and into the ejaculated fluid (hypospermatogeneses). This situation may
be caused by genetic abnormalities, hormonal factors, or varicoceles.
Even in the case where the testes are only producing low numbers of sperm, the sperm
may be harvested and used in conjunction with advanced reproductive techniques to
attempt a pregnancy.
Drugs
There are a number of fairly common drugs, which may have a negative effect on sperm
production and/or function. They include:
Hormonal Abnormalities
The testicles need pituitary hormones to be stimulated to make sperm. If these are absent
or severely decreased, the testes will not maximally produce sperm. Importantly, men
who take androgens (steroids) for body building, either by mouth or injection, shut down
the production of hormones for sperm production.
A hormonal profile must be performed on all men with male factor infertility. This will
help rule out serious medical conditions, give more information on the sperm-producing
ability of the testes, and may reveal situations where hormonal treatment is indicated.
Infections
Men may have infections of their reproductive tract. These may include infections of the
prostate (prostatitis), of the epididymis (epididymitis), or of the testis (orchitis).
Post-pubertal viral infections of the testes may cause significant damage (atrophy) of the
testes and may cause absolute and irreversible infertility. Bacterial infections or sexually
transmitted diseases may cause blockages at the sperm ducts. The patient may have
normal production of sperm, but the ducts carrying it are obstructed.
Active bacterial or viral infections may have a negative effect on sperm production or
sperm function. White blood cells, which are the body's response to infection, may also
have a negative effect on sperm membranes, making them less hearty.
If excessive white blood cells or bacteria (more than 1 million/cc) are seen in a semen
specimen, cultures should be done. This usually includes cultures for commonly
asymptomatic, sexually-transmitted diseases including mycoplasma, ureaplasma and
chlamydia. Also, a general genital culture is usually taken. If the infection and the white
blood cells are persistent, then antibiotics may be considered.
It is important to note that, in most men, the ejaculate is not sterile. In controlled studies,
the average man will culture positive for approximately two organisms. It is therefore
very important to be judicious in the treatment of non-sexually-transmitted organisms
found on cultures.
Genetic Abnormalities
When these conditions are treated, a man will often see a significant improvement in his
semen analysis.
Lifestyle Factors
Cigarette smoking has been shown to significantly affect semen quality.
Regular smoking causes a 23% decrease in sperm density (concentration) and a 13%
decrease in motility (when averages are taken from nine separate studies). To a lesser
extent, smoking causes an increased number of sperm with abnormal morphology
(shape). Smoking causes toxicity to the seminal plasma (the fluid ejaculated with the
sperm). Sperm from non-smokers were adversely affected (had significantly decreased
viability) when placed in the seminal plasma (hormonal) of smokers.
Recreational Drugs
Marijuana
Marijuana often causes a decreased average sperm count, motility, and normal
morphology. It affects the hormonal axis (HPG), causing decreased plasma testosterone.
It may also have a direct negative effect on the Leydig Cells.
Cocaine
Even infrequent cocaine use causes decreased sperm counts, motility and normal
morphology. These effects can be found in men who have used cocaine in the two years
preceding their initial semen analysis.
Cocaine also decreases the ability of sperm to penetrate cervical mucous, making it
difficult for them to enter the uterus.
• The use of anabolic androgenic steroids has reached almost epidemic proportions.
Nearly 7% of 12th grade males use or have used them to build muscle mass and
improve athletic performance. These male hormones suppress the testes ability to
make testosterone. This decreases the intratesticular testosterone level.
• Anabolic steroids depress testicular production of testosterone and thus, levels of
testosterone inside the testes itself. This may cause severely diminished
spermatogenesis or complete absence of sperm (azoospermia).
• When taken, these steroids cause a persistent depression of the hypothalamus and
pituitary, which may be irreversible even when the steroids are stopped.
Alcohol
Moderate alcohol use does not affect male fertility. Excessive alcohol use affects the
hormonal axis and is a direct gonadotoxin. It may cause associated liver dysfunction
and nutritional deficiencies, which are also detrimental for sperm production.
Lubricants
Most vaginal lubricants, including K-Y Jelly, Surgilube, and Lubifax, are toxic to
sperm. Couples should avoid their use during the fertile time of a woman's cycle.
Exercise
Moderate amounts of exercise can only be helpful. However, long distance runners
(men who run greater than 100 miles per week) and distance cyclers (men who ride
greater than 50 miles per week) have decreased spermatogenesis. These activities
should be moderated when a sub-fertile man is attempting conception.
Treatment More than 50% of men will have a treatable cause of low sperm count.
These factors include varicoceles (dilated veins in the scrotum), infections, hormonal
abnormalities, abnormalities in the seminal fluid, ductal blockages, and difficulties
with erections and ejaculation. When these conditions are treated, either through
medication (hormones or antibiotics) or surgery (varicocelectomy, vasal
reconstruction, repair of a blocked ejaculatory duct), a man will often see a significant
improvement in his semen analysis.
Those men with poor semen analyses whose conditions are not treatable may still
have the option of using advanced reproductive techniques to achieve a pregnancy.
Even those men with no sperm in the ejaculate may be able to have some living
sperm procured from them through other methods and achieve a pregnancy using
advanced reproductive techniques. Those few men who produce absolutely no sperm
at all will have this information so that they can explore other options.
Principles
Spermatozoa, after passage through the epididymis, are motile cells. Sperm motility
becomes critical at the time of fertilization because it allows or at least facilitates passage
of the sperm through the zona pellucida. Without technologic intervention, a non-motile
or abnormally-motile sperm is not going to fertilize. Hence, assessing the fraction of a
sperm population that is motile is perhaps the most widely-used measure of semen
quality.
Another term that is sometimes used is "total motility" which refers to the fraction of
sperm that display any type of movement. This concept is rarely used for evaluating
animal semen, but is the norm for describing human sperm motility.
When analyzing motility, it is important to know whether the semen sample has been
abused in any way. Exposure to heat, cold, any kind of residue on collection equipment,
or the wrong pH or osmolality of an extender can adversely affect motility. Motility is
also affected by periods of sexual inactivity - males that have not ejaculated for
prolonged periods often have poor motility on the first ejaculate, but much better motility
for a second ejaculate collected soon thereafter.
There are several means for evaluating motility. Which technique to use depends on
experience of the operator, the desire for precision and repeatability, and availability of
equipment. In almost all cases, motility is reported as the percentage of sperm that
manifest motility (usually progressive motility).
More specifically, a sample of semen is diluted in warm extender or buffered saline, and
about 10 to 20 microliters of this sample is pipetted onto a clean, prewarmed microscope
slide. A coverslip is lowered onto the sample, avoiding formation of air bubbles if
possible, and the slide is examined using a microscope with a 20X objective. At least ten
widely-spaced fields are examined to provide an estimate of the percentage of motile
cells. If estimating motility is a commonly required technique, a microscope warm stage
may be worth purchasing.
A bright field microscope can be used for evaluating motility if the field diaphragm is
closed to enhance contrast and ability to visualize sperm. A much better choice is a phase
contrast microscope or a microscope equipped for differential interference contrast (DIC).
Examine the images above to appreciate the difference in these three types of microscopy
- clearly, unstained sperm are difficult to observe using bright field.
Manual motility estimates are easy to perform and require minimal equipment. In the
hands of an experienced evaluator, manual estimates generally provide good estimates of
motility. The chief limitation of this technique is its subjective nature. Samples with
outstanding motility tend to be scored lower than they should be ("it can't be that good
..") and poor samples tend to be scored higher than they should ("it can't be that bad ..").
Track motility estimates: A wet mount of diluted semen is prepared as described for a
manual estimate, and sperm are photographed using an exposure time long enough for
motile sperm to leave tracks across the image (roughly 0.2 seconds). Using this
technique, non-motile sperm appear .. well .. non-motile, and sperm with non-progressive
motility leave tracks that are circular or otherwise abnormal. If a digital camera is used,
the image can be displayed on a computer monitor for convenient tabulation.
The images below depict the track motility technique. On the left, three progressively
motile sperm (two are marked) are represented by three straight tracks. On the right, a
circular track is seen, representing a non-progressively motile sperm. Non-motile sperm
are seen in both images.
Track motility estimates require more time to perform that manual estimates, but they are
objective and repeatable. Additionally, one can save the images for a permanent record.
For a long time, miscarriage has been presumed to be mostly a woman's issue. While
miscarriages due to chromosomal abnormalities are really just like a bad throw of the
dice other problems which cause miscarriage like hormonal imbalances, incompetent
cervix, fibroids and others all relate directly back to women. Low sperm counts or poor
motility have long been implicated in infertility but it's only recently that men's role in
miscarriage has been examined.
Women are born with all of the eggs they'll ever have. Therefore, if you're thirty-nine
years old, your eggs have been around for thirty-nine years too. Men produce sperm all
the time, so the idea of a male “biological clock” was never really put forth until recently.
Still, there's now evidence that as a man ages, his sperm may be more prone to genetic
mutation. If a sperm with a genetic mutation fertilizes an egg, that pregnancy is more
likely to end in miscarriage due to chromosomal abnormalities.
A study conducted by Carrell et al, published in the June 2003 edition of Obstetrics and
Gynecology, examined the relationship between chromosomally abnormal sperm and
recurrent pregnancy loss. Couples were chosen for the study who'd had at least three
pregnancy losses prior to twenty weeks gestation. The study found that in these couples
who had experienced recurrent pregnancy loss, sperm motility was decreased, percentage
of “normal” sperm was decreased and the amount of tapered sperm was increased.
Wikipedia defines sperm motility as “the ability of sperm to move properly towards an
egg.” According to the Mayo Clinic's website “sperm with large, small, tapered or
crooked heads or kinky, curled or double tails are less likely to fertilize an egg.”
Despite the fact that this study and others show a link between poor sperm quality and
miscarriage, it seems to be a more subjective connection for men than for women. While
women's fertility decreases obviously and measurably as they near menopause, it seems
that some men will have trouble with lowered sperm quality as they age and others will
not. Some men, notably celebrities Charlie Chaplin and Tony Randall, have fathered
children well into their seventies and beyond with no ill effects. In addition to his age, a
man's general health and environmental factors all seem to factor into the quality of
sperm. . In addition to miscarriage, advanced paternal age is may sometimes be a factor
in Down's Syndrome, Schizophrenia and Autism according to MSNBC.com.
Infertility is the inability to get pregnant after a year of unprotected intercourse. About
10% of couples in the United States are affected by infertility. Both men and women can
be infertile. According to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, 1/3 of the
time the diagnosis is due to female infertility, 1/3 of the time it is linked to male infertility
and the remaining 1/3 is due to a combination of factors from both partners. For
approximately 20% of couples the cause can not be determined.
The number of infertile couples rises with increasing age. Women are born with a finite
number of oocytes (eggs). Thus, as the reproductive years progress, the number and
quality of the oocytes diminish. The chances of having a baby decrease by 3-5% per year
after the age of 30. This reduction in fertility is noted to a much greater extent after age
40.
• Damage to fallopian tubes. Damage to the fallopian tubes (which carry the
oocytes from the ovaries to the uterus) can prevent contact between the oocyte
and sperm. Repetitive pelvic infections, endometriosis and multiple pelvic
surgeries may lead to scar formation and fallopian tube damage.
• Hormonal causes. Some women have problems with ovulation. Synchronized
hormonal changes leading to the release of an oocyte from the ovary and the
thickening of the endometrium (lining of the uterus) in preparation for the
fertilized egg do not occur. These problems may be detected using basal body
temperature charts, ovulation predictor kits, and blood tests to detect hormone
levels.
• Cervical causes.A small group of women may have a cervical condition in which
the sperm cannot pass through the cervical canal. Whether due to abnormal mucus
production or a prior cervical surgical procedure, this problem may be treated
with intrauterine inseminations (see below).
• Unexplained infertility. The cause of infertility in approximately 20% of couples
will not be determined using the currently available methods of investigation.
If male infertility is suspected a semen analysis is performed. This test will evaluate the
number and health of his sperm. A blood test can also be performed to check his level of
testosterone and other male hormones.
If female infertility is suspected, your doctor may order several tests, including:
Two diagnostic tests that may be helpful in detecting pelvic adhesions (scar tissue) and
tubal obstruction are hysterosalpingography and laparoscopy.
• Laparoscopy. Women who have been diagnosed with tubal or pelvic disease can
either undergo surgery to reconstruct the reproductive organs or try to conceive
through in vitro fertilization (IVF, see below). Using a laparoscope inserted
through a cut near the bellybutton, scar tissue can be removed, endometriosis
treated, ovarian cysts removed, and blocked tubes opened. A hysteroscope placed
into the uterus through the cervix can be used to remove polyps and fibroid
tumors, divide scar tissue, and open blocked tubes.
• Medical therapy. Women suffering from ovulation problems may be prescribed
medications such as clompiphene citrate (Clomid, Serophene) or gonadotropins
such as Gonal F, Follistim, Humegon and Pregnyl, which can lead to ovulation.
Gonadotropins can induce ovulation when Clomid or Serophene do not work.
These medications also can enhance fertility by causing multiple eggs to ovulate
during the cycle (normally, only one egg is released each month). Gonadotropin
therapy may be offered for unexplained infertility or when other factors have been
corrected without resulting in pregnancy. Metformin (glucophage) is another type
of medication that may restore or normalize ovulation in women who have insulin
resistance and/or PCOS (polycystic ovarian syndrome).
• Intrauterine insemination. Intrauterine insemination refers to an office
procedure in which semen is collected, rinsed with a special solution, and then
placed into the uterus at the time of ovulation. The sperm are deposited into the
uterus through a slender plastic catheter that is inserted through the cervix. This
procedure can be done in combination with the previously listed medications that
stimulate ovulation.
• In vitro fertilization. In vitro fertilization refers to a procedure in which oocytes
(egg cells) are fertilized in a culture dish and placed into the uterus. The woman
takes gonadotropins to stimulate multiple oocyte development. When monitoring
indicates that the oocytes are mature, the oocytes are collected using a vaginal
ultrasound probe with a needle guide. The sperm are collected, washed, and added
to the oocytes in a culture dish. Several days later, approximately 3 embryos
(fertilized oocytes) are returned to the uterus using an intrauterine insemination
catheter. Any extra embryos can be cryo-preserved (frozen) for later use, upon the
consent of the couple.
• Oocyte donation.Oocyte donation helps women who do not have normally
functioning ovaries (but who have a normal uterus) to achieve pregnancy. Oocyte
donation involves the removal of oocytes from the ovary of a donor who has
undergone ovarian stimulation with the use of fertility drugs. The donor's oocytes
are then placed together with the sperm from the recipient's husband for in vitro
fertilization. The resulting fertilized oocytes (embryos) are transferred to the
recipient's uterus.
Medical therapy and in vitro fertilization can increase the chance of pregnancy in women
diagnosed with unexplained infertility.
Overall, women with endometriosis find it harder to become pregnant than women in
general. However, little research has been carried out into this topic, so it is not possible
to give you an accurate indication of how much endometriosis will affect your fertility.
Nevertheless, studies indicate that women with minimal–mild endometriosis take longer
to conceive (become pregnant) and are less likely to conceive than women in general.
It also appears that the more severe the woman’s endometriosis, the more likely it is that
she will have difficulty becoming pregnant. Thus, women with moderate–severe
endometriosis tend to have more difficulty conceiving than women with minimal–mild
endometriosis.
Many women with endometriosis have children without difficulty, and many others
become pregnant eventually — though it may take time, and may require the help of
surgery or assisted reproductive technologies or both.
In one Australian study involving 3895 women with endometriosis, 54% of the women
who tried to become pregnant did not succeed in the first 12 months of trying. However,
70% of them ended up having at least one child [1]*. In comparison, in 1995, the
incidence of infertility in US women was 10.2% [2].
* This study included women who tried to conceive in the 1970s and earlier when assisted reproductive technologies were not available or were
less successful than today. Therefore, the figure of 70% may be an underestimate.
CAUSES
In most cases, it is not understood why it is harder for women with endometriosis to
become pregnant.
The exception to the rule is when the woman’s endometriosis is severe enough to cause
damage to one or more of the organs involved in conception. For example, if the ovaries
are covered in thick adhesions, the egg may not be able to escape from the ovary to be
fertilised. Similarly, if the ovaries or fallopian tubes are stuck in abnormal places by
adhesions, the newly released egg may not be able to ‘find’ the entrance to the fallopian
tube. Such damage is usually found only in some women with moderate or severe
endometriosis [3].
Many theories have been proposed to explain why it is harder for women with
endometriosis to conceive. However, as yet, none have been proven. It is possible that
there are several causes and that different causes are relevant in different women. Some
of the theories include:
• pelvic adhesions inhibit the movement of the egg down the fallopian tube
• chemicals produced by the endometriosis inhibit the movement of the egg down
the fallopian tube
• eggs are not released from the ovaries each month (also known as anovulation,
which may also occur in women without endometroisis [4].
MISCARRIAGE
There is no evidence that endometriosis causes women to have repeated miscarriages [5].
Also, there is no evidence that treating endometriosis results in women having fewer
miscarriages [6, 7].
HORMONAL TREATMENT
Minimal–mild endometriosis
In women with minimal–mild endometriosis, hormonal drugs are not an effective
treatment for endometriosis-related infertility, as none of the drugs leads to better
pregnancy rates. Therefore, they should not be used to improve fertility in women with
minimal–mild endometriosis [8].
Moderate–severe endometriosis
In women with more severe disease, no published studies have looked at the effect of
hormonal treatment on infertility. However, it is assumed that they are not effective, so
they should not be used to improve infertility in women with moderate–severe disease
[9].
SURGICAL TREATMENT
Aim
Minimal–mild endometriosis
Moderate–severe endometriosis
However, three studies seem to suggest that the more severe the endometriosis the lower
the pregnancy rates following surgery [11, 12, 13]. In other words, it seems that women
with severe endometriosis are less likely to become pregnant following surgery than
women with mild or moderate endometriosis.
Nevertheless, some gynaecologists believe that women with the most severe forms of
endometriosis have the greatest improvements in pregnancy rates following surgery [14].
In other words, surgery seems to increase their chances of becoming pregnant
proportionally more than women with less severe endometriosis.
Ovarian endometriomas
There is considerable debate about how large ovarian endometriomas in women with
endometriosis-related infertility should be treated [9]. The three main treatments are:
• draining the endometrioma
• draining and coagulating (burning the lining of) the endometrioma
• excising (remove by cutting out) the endometrioma from the ovary.
Several studies indicate that laparoscopically excising large endometriomas greater than 4
cm in diameter leads to increased pregnancy rates and decreased recurrence rates
compared with draining and coagulating the endometrioma [15, 16, 17, 18].
However, removing an endometrioma may also result in the removal of some of the
adjacent ovarian tissue, including some follicles (potential eggs). This may lead to
decreased functioning of the ovary and occasionally even loss of ovarian function,
particularly in women who have had previous ovarian surgeries [9].
Ovulatory Disorder
Ovulatory dysfunction is a term that describes a
group of disorders in which ovulation fails to
occur, or occurs on an infrequent or irregular
basis.
• FSH blood level - a blood test that measures the amount of follicle stimulating
hormone (FSH) in your blood to see if you are approaching menopause
• Progesterone blood level - a blood test that measures the amount of progesterone
in your blood to diagnose if ovulation has occurred
• Ultrasound - a scan that uses high frequency sound waves to see if follicles in
your ovaries are developing; also used to evaluate ovarian function - for example,
small ovaries with a few small follicles may be a sign of approaching menopause
• Endometrial biopsy - a procedure in which a sample of your endometrial tissue is
examined to determine if it is developed enough to support a pregnancy
Common Questions
The principal features are obesity, anovulation (resulting in irregular menstruation), and
excessive amounts or effects of androgenic (masculinizing) hormones. The symptoms
and severity of the syndrome vary greatly among women. While the causes are unknown,
insulin resistance, diabetes, and obesity are all strongly correlated with PCOS.
Both girls and guys produce sex hormones, but in different amounts. In girls, the ovaries
produce the hormones estrogen and progesterone, and also androgens. These hormones
regulate a girl's menstrual cycle and ovulationovulation. Even though androgens are
sometimes referred to as "male hormones," every female produces them.
In girls with PCOS, the ovaries produce higher than normal amounts of androgens, and
this can interfere with egg development and release. Some of the eggs develop into cysts,
which are little sacs filled with liquid. Instead of being released during ovulation, as an
egg is during a normal menstrual cycle, the cysts build up in the ovaries and may become
enlarged. Because girls with PCOS are not ovulating or releasing an egg each month, it's
common for them to have irregular or missed periods.
Although PCOS (which used to be called Stein-Leventhal syndrome) was first recognized
in the 1930s, doctors can't say for sure what causes it. Research has suggested that PCOS
may be related to increased insulin production in the body. Women with PCOS may
produce too much insulin, which signals their ovaries to release extra male hormones.
PCOS seems to run in families, too, so if someone on your mom's or dad's side of the
family has it, you might be more likely to develop it.
If PCOS is not treated properly, it can put a girl at risk for lots of problems. Girls with
PCOS are more likely to have infertility, excessive hair growth, acne, obesity, diabetes,
heart disease, high blood pressure, abnormal bleeding from the uterus, and cancer.
The good news is that, although there's no cure for PCOS, it can be treated. The most
important step is diagnosing the condition, because getting treatment for PCOS reduces a
girl's chances of having serious side effects.
Tubal Factor Infertility and Reversing Tubal Sterilization
Once the follicles reach maturity, the LH surge occurs, which causes ovulation thirty-six
hours later. The egg(s) is ovulated into the end of the fallopian tube and travels to the
distal end where fertilization occurs. Any condition that impedes, or blocks, egg transport
through the tubes can cause tubal factor infertility. In many of these cases IVF is the
treatment of first choice.
Sometimes endometriosis will attach to the fallopian tubes causing scarring and/or
adhesions"on" the tubes leading to obstruction. In addition, severe pelvic infections
(pelvic inflammatory disease), caused by a variety of microorganisms including
Chlamydia, can severely damage the fallopian tubes.
In other cases, women who previously had their tubes tied, seek to have the procedure
reversed. While this is sometimes possible, tubal sterilization should be considered a
permanent form of birth control.
To begin the evaluation of the tubes and uterus, the specialist orders a
hysterosalpingogram (HSG). In this test, dye is inserted into the uterus and x-rays are
taken as it flows back through the tubes. Blockages are seen as concentrations of dye.
The physician may recommend surgery if the tubal blockage is not severe. This is
dependent upon a number of patient specific variables including age, where, and how, the
tubes were "cut" or damaged, other underlying causes of infertility, etc. Data clearly
demonstrates that in vitro fertilization (IVF) produces higher per cycle success rates than
does tubal reconstruction.
A patient with tubal sterilization may opt for a tubal reversal if she is young and has no
other factors contributing to her infertility. The advantage to tubal reversal, in
appropriately screened cases, is that even though the per cycle success rates are lower
than IVF; numerous natural intercourse cycles can be attempted. Moreover, the patient
may not be able to afford multiple IVF attempts.
IVF is usually recommended as a first line treatment when moderate to severe tubal
damage is present.
Ovulation disorders are a common cause of infertility and are present in up to 30% of
cases. Every month a normally ovulating female recruits eggs that develop to maturity
and are released according to precise timing governed by hormone relationships in the
menstrual cycle. Lack of ovulation is termed "anovulation" and irregular ovulation is
termed "oligoovulation".
The fertility specialist will order numerous tests to assess ovulation that may include FSH
(follicle stimulating hormone), LH (luteinizing hormone), estrogen, progesterone,
androgens, thyroid and adrenal tests. Other tests might include an ultrasound exam to
visualize the ovaries and a clomiphene citrate challenge test.
The hypothalamus signals the pituitary to increase production of FSH during the first few
days of the menstrual cycle. FSH is responsible for stimulating the recruitment of ovarian
follicles, each of which contains an egg, and supporting their growth. As healthy follicles
mature, they begin to produce estrogen, which helps to stimulate the growth of the
endometrium (lining of the uterus). The endometrium must thicken to accept and support
the growth of an embryo.
Estrogen levels are monitored by a part of the brain called the hypothalamus and as they
increase, the hypothalamus signals the pituitary to reduce production of FSH. Once the
hormone levels indicate that the follicles are mature, the hypothalamus signals the
pituitary to release a surge of luteinizing hormone (LH). The spike in LH levels triggers
ovulation approximately 36 hours after the surge. The ovaries begin to produce
progesterone, which also supports the development of the endometrium. Rising levels of
human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG), produced by the placenta, are an indication of
pregnancy. If pregnancy does not occur, the lining of the endometrium breaks down and
is released during menstruation.
There are many causes of oligoovulation (irregular ovulation) and anovulation (no
ovulation) including:
• Ovarian failure as a Cause of Ovulation Failure- Women are born with all the
eggs they will have for a lifetime and one is usually ovulated during each monthly
menstrual cycle. As women age, infertility increases as ovarian function begins to
decline until the menopause, where no more eggs are released and FSH levels are
very high. Ovarian failure means that the ovaries cannot produce eggs that will
normally fertilize and develop. Day 3 FSH levels are elevated in these patients
and response to the clomiphene citrate challenge test is abnormal. Ovarian failure
may occur early in some women and is discussed in detail in our "Age and
Fertility" section. These women are often candidates for our donor egg program.
• Polycystic ovarian syndrome, PCOS- a common condition characterized by
elevated androgens (male hormone), reduced insulin sensitivity, and numerous
cysts on the ovary. Elevated androgens can lead to oligoovulation.
• Thyroid dysfunction- Abnormally high (hyperthyroidism) or low
(hypothyroidism) levels of thyroid hormone can cause irregular ovulation thought
to be due to the high levels of estrogen associated with these conditions.
• Hyperprolactinemia - Prolactin is responsible for breast milk production in
pregnant women. Elevated levels of the hormone, prolactin, can lead to ovulatory
disorders and infertility. Elevated levels in the absence of pregnancy cause
irregular ovulation by reducing the levels of FSH and LH.
• Excessive exercise, stress, and anorexia can lead to irregular ovulation.
• Adrenal dysfunction- Androgens are produced by the adrenal glands and
abnormally elevated levels lead to oligoovulation. Increased androgens are
associated with elevated levels of prolactin, and/or tumors on the ovary, pituitary,
or adrenal gland.
• Unexplained- Sometimes eggs will not fertilize and develop into health embryos
for unexplained reasons. In many cases, these couples achieve pregnancy with
donor egg IVF.
Sometimes a woman will be born with a misshapen uterus, such as the bicornuate or
horned uterus, which will sometimes be corrected surgically. Large polyps and fibroids
can also interfere with fetal growth and are removed usually via the laparoscopy.
When estrogen levels increase prior to ovulation it causes increased mucus production
and the mucus becomes "watery" thus enhancing sperm movement. Certain medications,
such as Clomid can adversely affect the mucus by causing it to thicken.
Sometimes antisperm antibodies are found in the cervical mucus. These are antibodies
produced by the female that mistake sperm for invading pathogens. When these
antibodies are present numerous "dead" or immobile sperm are seen in the post coital test.
Rarely, a man will produce antibodies to his sperm.
Cervical factor infertility is often treated via intrauterine insemination (IUI). Using this
procedure, specially prepared sperm are inserted directly into the uterus using a small
catheter. This avoids exposure of the sperm to the cervical mucus and insures it reaches
the uterus.
Sometimes a woman will be born with a misshapen uterus, such as the bicornuate or
horned uterus, which will sometimes be corrected surgically. Large polyps and fibroids
can also interfere with fetal growth and are removed usually via the laparoscopy.
Sometimes antisperm antibodies are found in the cervical mucus. These are antibodies
produced by the female that mistake sperm for invading pathogens. When these
antibodies are present numerous "dead" or immobile sperm are seen in the post coital test.
Rarely, a man will produce antibodies to his sperm.
Cervical factor infertility is often treated via intrauterine insemination (IUI). Using this
procedure, specially prepared sperm are inserted directly into the uterus using a small
catheter. This avoids exposure of the sperm to the cervical mucus and insures it reaches
the uterus.
Endometriosis
Endometriosis is a common cause of infertility (up to 40%) and pelvic pain in women.
Endometriosis appears to be more common in daughters of women who had
endometriosis suggesting a genetic link. It produces symptoms such as pain during
menstruation, intercourse, bowel movements, or emptying the bladder. It is also often
present with no symptoms.
Endometriosis is caused when the cells that normally line the uterine cavity (the
endometrium) enter the pelvic cavity and attach to various organs. It is commonly seen
on the rectum, ovary, uterus, and tubes, during the laparoscopy. Endometrial lesions
present in many forms including the classical dark blue, dark brown, or black lesions. It
may also present in a "non classical" lesion that may be white, red. or yellow.
Endometriosis occurs when endometrial cells enter the pelvic cavity through a back flow
of blood during the menstrual cycle and attach to internal organs. Menstrual blood is rich
in endometrial cells since it results from a breakdown of the endometrium. Once in the
bloodstream, endometrial cells can travel throughout the body. This explains why
endometrial lesions been documented in many organs distant to the pelvic cavity,
including the lungs and the brain.
If endometriosis has penetrated the fallopian tubes, IVF may be the best treatment option.
Tubal damage may be so severe that surgical treatment may not be a viable option. There
may also be severe damage to the ovaries or other internal organs.
Sometimes endometriosis will attach to the fallopian tubes causing scarring and/or
adhesions"on" the tubes leading to obstruction. In addition, severe pelvic infections
(pelvic inflammatory disease), caused by a variety of microorganisms including
Chlamydia, can severely damage the fallopian tubes.
In other cases, women who previously had their tubes tied, seek to have the procedure
reversed. While this is sometimes possible, tubal sterilization should be considered a
permanent form of birth control.
To begin the evaluation of the tubes and uterus, the specialist orders a
hysterosalpingogram (HSG). In this test, dye is inserted into the uterus and x-rays are
taken as it flows back through the tubes. Blockages are seen as concentrations of dye.
The physician may recommend surgery if the tubal blockage is not severe. This is
dependent upon a number of patient specific variables including age, where, and how, the
tubes were "cut" or damaged, other underlying causes of infertility, etc. Data clearly
demonstrates that in vitro fertilization (IVF) produces higher per cycle success rates than
does tubal reconstruction.
A patient with tubal sterilization may opt for a tubal reversal if she is young and has no
other factors contributing to her infertility. The advantage to tubal reversal, in
appropriately screened cases, is that even though the per cycle success rates are lower
than IVF; numerous natural intercourse cycles can be attempted. Moreover, the patient
may not be able to afford multiple IVF attempts.
IVF is usually recommended as a first line treatment when moderate to severe tubal
damage is present.
There appears to be a direct association between body weight and death from all causes
between the ages of 30-55. When the BMI* exceeds 30, the relative risk of death, as
relates to obesity, increases by 50%. Moreover, there are ethnic differences with a
prevalence of increased obesity in African Americans, Hispanics and Caucasian females
of 50.8, 40.1 & 30.6 respectively.
Being overweight is associated with 400,000 deaths per year with significant increases in
many health related disorders like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, hypertension and
stroke, arthritis, fragile X syndrome, gout, sleep apnea, liver and gallbladder disease and
colon cancer.
Cancer
The incidences of certain types of cancer are significantly increased in the overweight
population. In women, those of the reproductive system are more common.
Epidemiologic studies in the past suggested that populations whose diets were high in fat
have an increased incidence in breast cancer. More recently, there not only appears to be a
relationship between total body fat and breast cancer, but the increase in central (visceral)
body fat assessed by CAT scan, may have a greater impact on the overall risk.
Obstetrical Outcome
A number of studies have shown the relationship between being overweight or obese and
adverse obstetrical outcome. A recent study of 2,459 Danish women, divided into three
groups based on their pre-pregnancy BMI: normal weight (BMI 18.5-24.9), overweight
(BMI 25-29.9), obese (BMI>30) were evaluated in terms of their clinical obstetrical
outcomes. After adjustments for other factors, both overweight and obese subjects were
found to have significant increases in hypertensive complications, caesarian section,
induction of labor and excessive fetal size for gestational age in the presence of a normal
glucose tolerance. An associated byproduct of the increased caesarian rate is the higher
perioperative morbidity, including anesthetic difficulties, infection, problems with wound
healing, blood loss and lengthy hospitalizations. Other studies have shown a direct
relationship with an increased BMI of >30 & >40 both showing increased rates of
gestational diabetes and pregnancy induced hypertension.
Conclusions
The conventional approach in the past has been to carefully monitor patients who have
high-risk pregnancies; e.g. gestational diabetes, multiple gestations, etc. Based on more
recent data, it seems that overweight/obese individuals represent another high-risk group.
Yet, widespread routine high risk screening of obese patients has not become the standard
of care. Additionally, due to the greater incidence of clinical problems in the infertile
obese population, these patients should also be considered high risk and treated
accordingly
To that end point, our initial treatment of the infertile, overweight/obese patient should
include a multidisciplinary approach to weight management that fosters lifestyle change
through proper diet, exercise, behavior modification and stress reduction in concert with
pharmacologic approaches (e.g. Metformin) when indicated.
The decrease in female fecundity beginning after the age of 30 and exaggerated after 40,
is a well documented finding. This age related decline in fertility is the result of several
factors that contribute to overall reproductive failure. Women over 35 require a longer
period to achieve conception than younger individuals, and a higher percentage of older
than younger women will never achieve pregnancy. In addition, the rate of early
pregnancy wastage increases substantially during the 30s, and is over 50% after age 40.
With the aging of the baby boom generation and social trends to delay childbearing, the
treatment of women ³ 40 years of age who desire fertility has become a major challenge
of today's infertility specialists. For many women, the option to exercise other choices
while deferring their reproduction, has resulted in the need to use new reproductive
technologies while treating their infertility.
These technologies include controlled ovarian hyperstimulation (COH), intrauterine
insemination (IUI), and assisted reproductive techniques such as IVF , PGD, and the use
of donor eggs. Though the age related decline in pregnancy is seen in ART, there are few
reports of COH-IUI results with respect to age. I would like to share my report of a large
series of COH-IUI in women 40 years and older.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Over the past 15 years, there has been a surge in the assisted reproductive technologies
available to treat infertility. Huntington Reproductive fertility clinics are at the cutting
edge for all assisted reproductive technologies. Given such a vast array of treatments,
infertility specialists are faced with uncertainty about the optimal technique for an
individual patient with functional fallopian tubes. The optimal choice depends on the IVF
success rates per cycle (cycle fecundity) and costs, as well as the degree of invasiveness
associated with each of these procedures. Recently, some authors have suggested
superovulation with hMG, combined with IUI as an alternative treatment for couples with
non tubal causes of infertility.
Reproductive Technology
Successful pregnancy requires ovulation (when an ovary releases an egg into a fallopian
tube), transport of the egg partway down the fallopian tube, movement of sperm from the
vagina to the fallopian tube, penetration by the sperm of the egg's protective layer, and
implantation of the fertilized egg in the uterus.
There are many causes of infertility. Abnormal semen causes the infertility problems of
about 30 percent of couples seeking treatment. Tubal disease and endometriosis in the
female partner account for another 30 percent. A female partner's failure to ovulate
accounts for 15 percent, and the inability of sperm to penetrate the woman's cervical
mucus accounts for another 10 percent. The final 15 percent of couples seeking treatment
are infertile for reasons that cannot be diagnosed.
In vitro Fertilization
Generally, one attempt at IVF is made per menstrual cycle. The IVF process begins when
couples are first screened. Clinicians first must rule out infertility in the male partner. If
the problem is with the female partner, various courses of treatment may be available.
Generally, couples are expected to try to achieve pregnancy for a year after the initial
screening before intervention is attempted. However, if a woman is in her late thirties or
older, or if she is experiencing irregular menstruation, a clinical investigation may begin
earlier.
In women whose ovaries are capable of generating viable eggs, the first step in IVF is
referred to as "superovulation." To increase the chance of success, the woman's ovaries
are stimulated to develop many follicles. Normally, only one or perhaps two follicles
develop and are released by an ovary during a single menstrual cycle, which is why
usually only one or, on rare occasions, two children are born. In superovulation, a doctor
forces multiple follicles to develop so that many oocytes can be collected.
To stimulate the ovaries to develop many follicles, the woman undergoes the "long
protocol." The action of the pituitary gland is suppressed hormonally, and ten days later
the woman is treated with follicle-stimulating hormone. To see how well her ovaries are
responding to the hormone, doctors measure estrogen blood levels and observe the
ovaries with ultrasound scans. The number and size of the follicles can be visualized.
When the doctors judge that the time is right (that is, when the follicle is enlarged to the
point that it protrudes above the surface of the ovary), they give the woman human
chorionic gonadotropin, wait thirty-six hours, and collect the oocytes from the mature
follicles.
In the past, to collect follicles, doctors performed laparoscopy, in which a thin optical
tube with a light (called a laproscope) is inserted through a very small incision in the
abdominal wall, and the pelvic organs are viewed with fiber optics. Today, the use of a
needle guided by ultrasound makes the procedure much faster. The ovary is visualized,
mature follicles are located, the needle is inserted, and the follicular fluid that contains
the mature oocyte (the unreleased egg) is aspirated. The doctors may collect up to eleven
oocytes from a single patient.
Viable sperm are collected from the man and washed in a special solution that activates
them so they can fertilize the egg. The process of sperm activation is called "capacitation"
and normally occurs when sperm are ejaculated and enter the female reproductive tract.
Capacitation involves activating enzymes in the sperm's acrosomal cap, allowing the
sperm head, which contains the sperm's genetic material, to penetrate the outer and inner
membranes of the egg (zona pellucida and vitelline membrane). For males with
azoospermia, microsurgical or aspiration techniques can directly extract sperm from
either the epididymis or the testicles. Azoospermia is the most severe form of male
infertility, caused by obstructions in the genital tract or by testicular failure.
To allow fertilization to take place, a single egg and about 100,000 sperm are placed
together in special culture medium and incubated for about twenty-four hours. Doctors
then use a microscope to see if there are two pronuclei (one from the egg and one from
the sperm) in the egg, indicating that fertilization occurred. In some cases, the sperm are
unable to penetrate the egg. They may be unable to swim correctly, or they may not have
been capacitated successfully. In the past, the only solution was to use sperm from
another man. Now, however, sperm can be injected directly into the egg's cytoplasm, in a
process called microassisted fertilization.
There are three ways used successfully by doctors and researchers to micro-fertilize the
egg. The first is "zona drilling," in which a hole is punched into the zona pellucida, letting
sperm penetrate the egg. The second method is called "subzonal sperm insertion," in
which a sperm is injected directly under the zona pellucida. A third, related method is
"intracytoplasmic sperm injection," in which a sperm is injected directly into the egg
cytoplasm. The second method is reported to have a higher fertilization success rate
(59%) than the third (13%).
In some women, the drugs used to promote superovulation may cause side effects,
including mood swings. Some investigators have suggested that procedures used in
assisted reproductive technology may not be safe because of the potential for increased
ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome and bone loss from the hormone treatments. Ovarian
hyperstimulation syndrome occurs at mild levels in 23 percent of women undergoing the
treatments, at moderate levels in 3 percent, and at severe levels in 0.1 percent.
Complications also may arise as a result of the surgical procedures involved in egg
retrieval and embryo transfer. Such complications include pelvic and other infections,
which occur in 0.15 percent to 1.2 percent of women, complications from anesthesia,
which occur in 0.2 percent, and internal injuries, which occur in 0.38 percent. Although
the incidence of such complications is low, every chemical or surgical intervention is
associated with risks, and potential patients should be aware of this.
There have been conflicting reports as to whether there is a link between the use of
fertility drugs and ovarian cancer. Overall, results from many studies do not seem to
support such a connection. Some researchers have suggested that the use of the drugs
may increase the risk of ovarian cancer later in life, but this is difficult to prove or
disprove because the techniques have not been around long enough to assess long-term
effects. There have been no reports of any increase in abnormalities in children born
using micro-assisted fertilization, though critics have questioned whether the techniques
might increase the incidence of such abnormalities.
Once the egg is fertilized, the two pronuclei fuse to form the early embryo, or "zygote."
The zygotes are placed in culture media, where they undergo cell division, cleaving
repeatedly and passing through the two-cell, four-cell, and eight-cell stages. Within
seventy-two hours, the zygote develops into the morula, the solid mass of blastomeres
formed by the cleavage of the fertilized ovum (egg). After about three to five days in
culture, the zygote has become a hollow ball of cells called the blastocyst. During normal
embryogenesis, it is the blastocyst that is implanted in the endometrial lining of the
uterus.
While the embryos are in culture, problems in their development may become apparent.
After embryos with evident problems are discarded, one or more cultured embryos are
transferred into the uterus, where, it is hoped, one will become implanted and develop
into a healthy, full-term baby. Embryo transfer replaces the natural process in which the
embryo passes down the fallopian tube and into the uterus, prior to implantation.
Although this transfer is relatively simple and often takes only a few minutes, the rate of
successful implantation is low. Usually, two embryos are transferred, but still only one of
five women become pregnant. Most doctors who perform IVF procedures adhere to the
limit of two embryos per woman to minimize the risk of multiple pregnancies. In most
cases, three embryos are transferred in women older than thirty-five. In the United
Kingdom, it is illegal for an IVF doctor to transfer more than three embryos at a time into
a woman.
A number of factors play a role in whether embryo transfer leads to a baby being born.
Success rate is higher if embryo transfer takes place between forty-eight and seventy-two
hours after oocyte collection. When more than one embryo is transferred at the same
time, the success rate increases, but so does the chance for multiple pregnancies. As noted
above, the maximum number transferred should never exceed three. Probably the single
most important factor determining whether or not a successful embryo implantation will
take place is the donated egg's age. Embryos formed from eggs donated by younger
women have a higher implantation success rate than do embryos formed from eggs
donated by older women. The age of the host uterus appears to have little or no effect on
outcome.
After the transfer is made, doctors have no way of knowing if normal fertilization
actually takes place until an embryo has implanted in the uterine wall. However, the
procedure's success rate (35%) is higher than the success rate for IVF. Another related
technique is zygote intrafallopian transfer, in which the egg is fertilized in vitro and the
zygote is transferred surgically into the fallopian tube. Other techniques include tubal
embryo transfer, in which an embryo already undergoing cleavage is transferred.
Intrauterine Insemination
To help the sperm reach the egg, the female is treated with human chorionic gonadotropin
to induce multiple ovulation. The number of follicles that are induced is monitored by
ultrasound. Washed sperm from the male partner are injected through the cervical
opening, into the uterus. The pregnancy rate using this procedure is about 10 percent.
Donor insemination is used when sperm are incapable of fertilizing the egg. Usually this
occurs if the male produces very little or no sperm. Sometimes, donor sperm is used
when the male partner is the carrier of a genetic disorder that could be transmitted to the
baby. Sperm donors should be between ages eighteen and fifty-five, and all should be
screened for genetic disorders, such as cystic fibrosis, and for various types of
chromosomal abnormalities and infectious disease, including hepatitis, syphilis,
cytomegalovirus, and HIV. As with the use of intrauterine insemination, the female
partner undergoes ovarian stimulation to maximize the number of follicles released
during ovulation. Pregnancy rates resulting from the use of donor insemination are
between 32 percent and 50 percent after ten inseminations.
As with donor insemination, egg donation is used when the woman cannot ovulate or is
the carrier of a genetic disease. Egg donors must be younger than thirty-five years and
must be screened for the same set of conditions as sperm donors. Donors are treated with
drugs to stimulate ovulation, after which the eggs are fertilized with the sperm from the
male partner and the embryos are transferred to the uterus of the female partner (other
procedures can also be used). Growth and development of the embryos then follow the
natural processes.
Surrogacy, in which pregnancy occurs in another woman, can supply a couple with an
alternative if the woman partner cannot carry the baby to term in her own uterus. In some
cases, if the woman cannot supply the egg, sperm from the male partner can be used to
inseminate the surrogate mother, who carries the baby to term. Alternatively, if the female
partner can produce her own egg, sperm from the male partner can be used to fertilize the
egg, and the resulting pre-embryo can be transferred to the uterus of the surrogate mother
to grow and develop. Legal controversies resulting from these arrangements have become
common in the last few years, so the arrangements should be carefully reviewed by all
parties, along with experts in the field, before any final decisions are made.
Frozen sperm and embryos effectively retain their viability for many years. The use of
frozen human blastocysts is associated with a 10 percent successful pregnancy rate.
Oocyte freezing is much less successful, possibly because oocytes may be genetically
damaged or killed in the freezing and thawing. Embryos produced from such
cryopreserved eggs have a high incidence of aneuploidy, and they are slow to cleave and
develop even if they appear to be genetically undamaged. Various research groups are
trying to solve this problem.
Age as a Factor
Age must be taken into account when couples are considering assisted reproductive
technology. In humans, the age of the oocyte, not the age of the uterus, is the main cause
of reproductive failure in IVF and embryo transfer techniques. Embryos formed from
older oocytes demonstrate an increased incidence of aneuploidy. In some other species,
such as in rabbits, an aging uterus can keep an embryo from being implanted. The use of
cryopreservation to circumvent reproductive failure in humans, cattle, and horses has
already been successfully employed and is likely to be developed further.
Sperm generated by older men are capable of successfully producing normal embryos.
However, as sperm age, they are exponentially more likely to contain new gene
mutations. Older oocytes, on the other hand, do not appear to be more likely to contain
new mutations. Scientists are unsure exactly how age affects oocyte integrity. Oocyte
maturation takes place only before birth in the female, so no new oocytes are produced
during the entire reproductive life of the female. This is quite different from
spermatogenesis, which can continue into old age. Thus, oocytes from older women may
be forty or more years old when they are collected and used to form the embryos.
Oocytes must reach full maturity before they can be ovulated normally and before they
can be fertilized, even artificially, to form embryos. If immature oocytes could be
artificially forced to mature in vitro, follicles could be taken from the ovaries of dying or
dead women, or from cancer patients planning on undergoing chemotherapy treatments,
which can damage oocytes. Unlike immature oocytes, immature sperm can effectively be
used in fertilization. Additional research is needed in this area of assisted reproductive
technology.
The use of these powerful techniques to facilitate reproduction in both humans and
animals (the techniques can be used in cattle and pigs, and in the conservation of
endangered wildlife) must be balanced against legal, ethical, and moral concerns. For
example, would it be permissible to revive extinct animal species? Although a Jurassic
Park-like scenario to reanimate extinct dinosaurs is not scientifically credible at this time,
what if it became possible to use this technology to form embryos and clone an extinct
mammoth, or the passenger pigeon? And what if we can do this for extinct humans? Just
because we can develop the capability, would it be acceptable? What are the ethics
involved?
Other concerns include questions about how long embryos should remain frozen and who
owns frozen embryos not used by the parents. What happens if the parents separate,
divorce, or die? What about the legal entanglements involved with surrogacy? Already in
the media there have been a number of such cases reported. With the expected increase of
these procedures in the future, it is likely that such complex questions will only escalate.
Finally, there are basic concerns about helping people sidestep the natural birth process to
bring into the world a new human.