Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Obesity can be attributed to complex physiological, genetic, cultural and psychological factors. It
should not be regarded merely as a result of weak will power or other character deficits. This
paper attempts to provide background information on energy balance which is important vis-a-
vis weight control. Weight reduction as a desirable end-point of negative energy balance is best
achieved through a combination of dietary restriction and exercise. Two alternative methods of
weight reduction are proposed and discussed. Nutritional, behavioural changes and careful
monitoring of exercise and diet should be implemented holistically to ensure a successful weight
reduction programme. Individuals also need to be aware of the many myths and misconceptions
surrounding weight control.
181
182 J Hong Kong Med Assoc Vol. 44, No. 3, September 1992
Energy intake Table 1. Typical one day Chinese menu and isocaloric
modified low-fat, high carbohydrate diet.
Quantity
Low-fat,
Obesity has classically been regarded as a problem of Regular diet high carbohydrate diet
disordered eating habits. Most surveys of energy in- (44% of energy as fat) (20% of energy as fat)
take, however, show that in general, obese individuals
Breakfast Breakfast
do not consume more calories than lean individu- Bread: 1 slice Bread: 2 slices
als.14 A recent study15 of 107 males and 109 females Margarine: 1 tbsp Jam: 1 tbsp
ranging in age from 18 to 71 years, showed that the Whole milk: 1/2 cup Skim milk: 1 cup
daily energy intakes of lean and obese adults were
identical when expressed as kJ-kg-1 lean body weight. Lunch Lunch
Stir fried chicken noodle Chicken noodle in soup
Lean individuals actually consumed more energy than Chicken with skin: 3.5 oz Chicken breast: 3.5 oz
obese individuals when daily caloric intake was ex- Cooking oil: 1.5 tsp Cooking oil: 1 tsp
pressed as kJ-kg-1 total body weight. Bamboo shoot: 1/2 cup Corn: 1/2 cup
Egg noodles: 1 cup Egg noodles: 1 cup
Chinese tea Chinese tea
Diet composition
Snack Snack
Nutritionists previously thought that a calorie was a Peanuts: 1/2 oz Crackers: 4 pieces
calorie, but we know now that not all calories are the
same. A forced feeding study showed that prisoners on Dinner Dinner
a high fat diet gained weight more easily than those on Stir fried marbled pork Stir fried lean pork
with pineapple with pineapple
a low fat, high carbohydrate diet.16 Researchers in this Pork chop Pork chop (lean): 3 oz
study cited two probable mechanisms for this observa- (lean and fat): 3 oz Cooking oil: 1.5 tsp
tion. Firstly, extra fat calories contribute more to body Cooking oil: 1.5 tsp Pineapple: 1/2 cup
fat because dietary fat is converted to stored fat with Pineapple: 1/2 cup Rice: 2 cups
97% efficiency. Carbohydrates from a meal, in contrast, Rice: 1 cup Orange: 1
Orange: 1
are converted to body fat with only 77% efficiency.
There is, therefore, an eightfold difference in the amount
of energy wasted. Secondly, the metabolic rate following
a meal (thermic effect of a meal) is much higher when age.18, 19 Since BMR accounts for 70% of total daily
the meal is high in carbohydrates than when it is high in expenditure, this reduction in BMR is a significant
fat. Calories expended in this way contribute to daily difference. This BMR reduction may account in part
energy expenditure, rather than to increasing fat stores. for the 'plateau' reached by most dieters when weight
The relationships linking diet composition, energy intake loss slows and stops even when caloric intake re-
and body fat are illustrated by another study of 216 mains stable. Secondly, as much as 25% of the weight
adult men and women.15 The obese derived a greater lost by dieting alone can have come from lean body
portion of their daily energy intake from fat when com- mass (LBM).20 This loss of LBM is potentially danger-
pared with the lean. Therefore, one should aim for energy ous if the body depletes protein reserves in essential
intake from a high carbohydrate, low fat diet, as diet areas of the body. The percentage of LBM lost de-
composition may be as important as diet energy content creases when exercise is combined with diet. Thirdly,
in the reduction of obesity. A comparison of a typical the energy conservation process resulting from severe
Chinese menu with a low fat, high carbohydrate sample dieting can persist even after the dieting period is
menu is illustrated in Table 1. over. This causes body weight to be regained rapidly
until it reaches the pre-dieting level.21 Studies in ani-
mals and humans have shown that when these
Caloric restriction repeated cycles of weight gain and loss occur, subse-
For a long time, caloric restriction has been regarded quent weight loss can be made more difficult. 22
as the cornerstone of weight-loss regimens. Numer- Research has also shown that when weight is regained
ous low and very low calorie diets have been after dieting, muscle tissue tends to be replaced by
introduced for the treatment of obesity.17 However, fat. This has also been confirmed in a current study
energy-reduced dieting may not be the best weight- on diet manipulation in rats.23
loss therapy because of the many problems associated
with reduced energy consumption. Firstly, severe re- Energy expenditure
striction in energy intake reduces the basal metabolic
rate (BMR) by as much as 30%. This may shift the In the past, the focus of both health professionals and
energy balance back in the direction of energy stor- obese individuals has been on energy intake. Research
184 J Hong Kong Med Assoc Vol. 44. No,
„ 80-
Losing weight Losing weight
2 /
•?. only by severe by exercise and
£f t __
^ limitation of slight limitation
Ji 60 - c^^ m
BOlimuiii« ""^ Variable energy intake of energy intake
(O
O
TJ ..a*"'"^^""^ Cardiovascular
S 40- O*** ^i and pulmonary Decrease Increase
^W function
£
"5 ^^ Nutritional Occurs easily Generally
e 20- \^ deficiency does not occur
O Tv.
o ^^w^ Lean body weight Decrease Increase or
a ^\j unchanged
° 0•
a
Rest 20 40 60 80 100 Level of HDL-C Decrease Increase
% of maximum oxygen uptake Sensitivity of insulin ? Increase
Thermic effect Decrease Increase or
Fig. 2. Relative contribution of fat and carbohydrate as a unchanged
function of exercise intensity, expressed as a Physiological and Under great Improved
percentage of the maximal oxygen uptake (VO2 max). psychological state pressure
Modified from Astrand and Rodahl.32
Physical strength Decrease Increase
Side-effect Metabolic Generally
Exercise and diet disorder none
, .. , . . , . ,. , ., , Plan of losing Difficult to Easy to
A negative energy balance is best achieved through a weight maintain maintain
combination of dietary restriction and exercise. A
convenient means to partition a 500 kcal/day (3,500
kcal/week) energy deficit is to reduce energy intake
by 250 kcal/day and increase energy expenditure by resulting increased caloric intake negates the caloric
250 kcal/day. It is relatively easy to identify food expenditure of the exercise itself. Although it is true
items that can be eliminated or reduced to provide a that increased food intake generally parallels increased
250 kcal/day reduction in intake. A caloric deficit of physical activity, this relationship appears to hold
3,500 kcal/week is equivalent to 0.5 kg weight loss. only with respect to normal activity.
A comparison of two alternative methods of weight In a classical study,34 rats which were exercised daily
reduction is illustrated in Table 2.3 By combining diet for up to one hour showed a decrease in food intake and
and exercise, it is possible to achieve a deficit of 1,000 body weight when compared to sedentary control ani-
calories/day, which is equivalent to approximately 1 mals. When the exercise duration was increased beyond
kg of fat loss per week. While this may appear to be one hour, food intake was increased but only to the
the slow approach to weight loss, it is the most sensi- extent that body weight was maintained. In contrast, at
ble approach. Losses of lean body mass are minimal, exhaustive levels of exercise (i.e. six hours), both body
and fat loss so attained is more likely to be of a per- weight and food intake decreased. The results of this
manent nature.33 classical experiment are shown in Figure 3. Longitudinal
physical conditioning studies in humans also show no
change in calorie intake with mild to moderate intensity
Myths and misconceptions of diet, exercise training.35
exercise and weight control
Rapid weight loss
With the increased popularity of exercise, obese indi-
viduals are often confronted with exercise myths and Most rapid weight loss diets have one feature in com-
misconceptions, along with gimmicks that are pro- mon—they allow only a modest intake of
moted as 'miracle agents' to assist in weight reduction. carbohydrates. Carbohydrates constitute approxi-
mately 60% of a normal mixed diet. When
carbohydrates make up 10% or less of the diet, in
Exercise and appetite addition to an overall reduction in food intake, the
A common misconception of exercise in weight control body starts to utilize its own carbohydrate stores in
is that physical activity stimulates appetite, and the the liver and muscles. Since 3 g of water are stored
188 J Hong Kong Med Assoc Vol.
Conclusion
recently, among A:
as well. The associated health risks and diseases present
a tremendous drain to the economy and affect the quality
of life. Obesity can be attributed to complex physiologi-
cal, genetic, cultural and psychological factors. It should
y as a result of weak will power
ts. The most effective programmes for
losing and maintaining a desirable body weight incor-
porate restrictions in caloric intake, and increases in
2 4 6 8 10
caloric expenditure through exercise. Nutrition, behav-
Duration of exercise (hours) ioural changes, and careful monitoring of exercise and
diet should be implemented holistically to ensure a
Fig. 3. Relationship between food intake, energy successful weight reduction, programme. Individuals
expenditure and body weight in laboratory rats. A, need to be aware of the many myths and misconceptions
sedentary zone; B, range of proportional response surrounding weight control Most 'miracle agents' for
(normal activity); C, exhaustion zone.
34
Modified from " . , ', , *T,' •' Jr •
weight loss do not have a scientific basis.
Mayer et al.
7. Hager A, Sjostrom L, Arvidsson B, et al. Body fat and effects of repeated cycles of weight loss and regain in
adipose tissue cellularity in infants: a longitudinal rats. Physiol Behav 1986; 38: 459-64.
study. Metabolism 1977; 26: 607-14. 23. Dulloo AG, Girardier L. Adaptive changes in energy
8. Mirkin G. Getting thin. Boston: Little, Brown & Com- expenditure during refeeding following a low-calorie
pany, 1983: 79-80. intake: evidence for a specific metabolic component
9. National Institutes of Health Consensus Development favoring fat storage. Am J Clin Nutr 1990; 52: 415-20.
Panel on the Health Implications of Obesity. Health 24. Katch FI, McArdle WD. Nutrition, weight control and
implications of obesity. Ann Intern Med 1985; 103:147- exercise. 3rd ed. Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger, 1988:
51. 108-9.
10. Peiris AN, Hennes MI, Evans DJ, et al. Relationship of 25. Rose HE, Mayer J. Activity, calorie intake, fat storage
anthropometric measurements of body fat distribution and the energy balance of infants. Pediatrics 1969; 41:
to metabolic profile in premenopausal women. Acta 18-29.
Med Scand Suppl 1987; 723: 179-88. 26. Curtis DE, Bradfield RB. Long-term energy intake and
11. Kaplan NM. The deadly quartet: upper-body obesity, expenditure of obese housewives. Am J Clin Nutr 1971;
glucose intolerance, hypertriglyceridemia, and hyper- 24: 1410-7.
tension. Arch Intern Med 1989; 149: 1514-20. 27. Epstein LA, Wing RR. Aerobic exercise and weight.
12. Stamford B. Apples and Pears—where you 'wear' your Addict Behav 1980; 5: 371-88.
fat can affect your health. Phys Sportsmed 1991; 19: 28. American College of Sports Medicine. Resource manual
123-4. for guidelines for exercise testing and prescription.
13. Rebuffe-Scrive M, Enk L, Crona N, et al. Fat cell me- Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger, 1988: 355-61.
tabolism in different regions in women—effect of 29. Lawson S, Webster JD, Pacy PJ, Garrow JS. Effect of a
menstrual cycle, pregnancy, and lactation. J Clin Invest 10 week aerobic exercise programme on metabolic rate,
1985; 75: 1973-6. body composition and fitness in lean sedentary fe-
14. Dreon DM, Frey-Hewitt B, Ellsworth N, Williams PT, males. Br J Clin Pract 1987; 41: 684-8.
Terry RB, Wood PD. Dietary fat: carbohydrate ratio 30. de Vries HA, Gray DE. After effects of exercise upon
and obesity in middle-aged men. Am J Clin Nutr 1988; resting metabolic rate. Res Q Exerc Sport 1963; 34: 314-21.
47: 995-1000. 31. Girandola RN. Body composition change in women:
15. Miller WC, Linderman AK, Wallace J, Niederpruem effects of high and low exercise intensity. Arch Phys
M. Diet composition, energy intake, and exercise in Med Rehabil 1976; 57: 297-300.
relation to body fatness in men and women. Am J Clin 32. Astrand PO, Rodahl K. Textbook of work physiology.
Nutr 1990; 52: 426-30. 3rd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company, 1986:
16. Danforth E. Diet and obesity. Am J Clin Nutr 1985; 41: 543-9.
11-32. 33. Wilmore J. Sensible fitness. Champaign: Human Ki-
17. Atkinson RL. Low and very low calorie diets. Med Clin netics Publishers, 1986: 44-50.
North Am 1989; 73: 203-15. 34. Mayer J, Marshall NB, Vitale JJ, et al. Exercise, food
18. Bray GA. Effect of caloric restriction on energy ex- intake and body weight in normal rats and genetically
penditure in obese patients. Lancet 1969; ii: 397-8. obese adult mice. Am J Physiol 1954; 177: 544-8.
19. Elliot DL, Goldberg L, Kuehl KS, Bennett WM. Sus- 35. Woo R, Garrow JS, Pi-Sunyer FX. Effect of exercise on
tained depression of the resting metabolic ratio after spontaneous calorie intake in obesity. Am J Clin Nutr
massive weight loss. Am J Clin Nutr 1989; 49: 93-6. 1982; 36: 470-7.
20. Zuti NB, Golding IA. Comparing diet and exercise as 36. Gwinup G, Chelvam R, Steinberg T. Thickness of sub-
weight reduction tools. Phys Sportsmed 1976; 4: 49-55. cutaneous fat and activity of underlying muscles. Ann
21. Jen KL. Effects of diet composition of food intake and Intern Med 1971; 74: 408-11.
carcass composition in rats. Physiol Behav 1988; 42: 37. Katch FI, Clarkson PM, McBride T, et al. Preferential
551-6. effects of abdominal exercise training on regional adipose
22. Brownell KD, Greenwood MRC, Stellar E, et al. The cell size [Abstract]. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1980; 12: 96.