1997 Rules on Civil Procedure 2001 Edition <draft copy. pls.

check for errors>

Rule 42 PETITION FOR REVIEW FRO T!E RE"ION#$ TRI#$ %O&RT' TO T!E %O&RT OF #PPE#$'

Rule 42 Petition for Review From the RTC to the CA

Q: What are the modes of appeal from RTC to the CA? A: Its either ORDINARY APPEAL R!le "#$ or PETITION %OR RE&IEW R!le "'$( R!le "# refers to a) ordi)ar* appeal from the RTC to the CA + *!), )oti-e of appeal( .ere/ the RTC re)dered a de-isio) p!rs!a)t to its ORI0INAL 12RI3DICTION( 4Eto )ama), R!le "' Petitio) for re5ie6$ is the mode of appeal from the RTC to the CA i) -ases de-ided 7* the RTC p!rs!a)t to its APPELLATE 12RI3DICTION( 3o/ the -ase here a-t!all* ori,i)ated i) the 8TC/ the) it 6as appealed to the RTC !)der R!le "9( A)d )o6/ from the RTC/ *o! 6a)t to ,o to the CA( .e)-e/ the mode of appeal is )ot R!le "#$ Noti-e of Appeal 7!t R2LE "' + Petitio) for Re5ie6( %or the first time/ there is )o6 a r!le ,o5er)i), petitio)s for re5ie6 from the RTC to the CA( Prior to 1!l* #/ #::;/ there 6as )o)e( Altho!,h there 6ere ,!ideli)es the) + i) <!rispr!de)-e/ de-ided -ases a)d 3C -ir-!lars( 'ect(o) *. How appeal taken; time for filing. # party des(r()+ to appeal fro, a dec(s(o) of the Re+(o)al Tr(al %ourt re)dered () the e-erc(se of (ts appellate .ur(sd(ct(o) ,ay f(le a /er(f(ed pet(t(o) for re/(e0 0(th the %ourt of #ppeals1 pay()+ at the sa,e t(,e to the clerk of sa(d court the correspo)d()+ docket a)d other la0ful fees1 depos(t()+ the a,ou)t of P233.33 for costs1 a)d fur)(sh()+ the Re+(o)al Tr(al %ourt a)d the ad/erse party 0(th a copy of the pet(t(o). The pet(t(o) shall 4e f(led a)d ser/ed 0(th() f(ftee) 5*26 days fro, )ot(ce of the dec(s(o) sou+ht to 4e re/(e0ed or of the de)(al of pet(t(o)er7s ,ot(o) for )e0 tr(al or reco)s(derat(o) f(led () due t(,e after .ud+,e)t. &po) proper ,ot(o) a)d the pay,e)t of the full a,ou)t of the docket a)d other la0ful fees a)d the depos(t for costs 4efore the e-p(rat(o) of the re+le,e)tary per(od1 the %ourt of #ppeals ,ay +ra)t a) add(t(o)al per(od of f(ftee) 5*26 days o)ly 0(th() 0h(ch to f(le the pet(t(o) for re/(e0. No further e-te)s(o) shall 4e +ra)ted e-cept for the ,ost co,pell()+ reaso) a)d () )o case to e-ceed f(ftee) 5*26 days. 5)6 2)der 3e-tio) #/ a petitio) for re5ie6 !)der R!le "' m!st 7e &ERI%IED( Q: Where 6ill *o! file *o!r petitio) for re5ie6? A: Yo! file it dire-tl* 6ith the CA( Do )ot file it 6ith the trial -o!rt( I) R!le "#/ 6here the appeal is deemed perfe-ted 7* simpl* fili), a )oti-e of appeal/ *o! file *o!r )oti-e of appeal 6ith the RTC( Do )ot file it 6ith the CA( =!t i) R!le "'/ 6here the appeal is 7* petitio) for re5ie6/ *o! file *o!r petitio) dire-tl* 6ith the CA( Do )ot file it 6ith the RTC( Not o)l* that( Of -o!rse/ *o! ha5e to pa* the do->et a)d la6f!l fees pl!s P?99 for -osts( A)d *o! m!st f!r)ish the RTC a)d the ad5erse part* 6ith a -op* of the petitio)( That is a )e6 re@!ireme)t( Q: What is the period to file a petitio) for re5ie6 ? A: The period to file a petitio) for re5ie6 is #? da*s from re-eipt of the RTC <!d,me)t or from the order de)*i), the motio) for re-o)sideratio)( Q: What is the differe)-e i) period to file 7et6ee) R!le "# a)d R!le "' ? A: I) R!le "#/ if *o!r motio) for re-o)sideratio) is de)ied/ *o! -a) still appeal 6ithi) the remai)i), 7ala)-e of the #?Ada* period( I) R!le "'/ the #?Ada* period starts all o5er a,ai) 7e-a!se the la6 sa*s or of the denial. 3o/ a)other fresh #? da*s( This 7e-a!se it is more diffi-!lt to prepare a petitio) for re5ie6( This is more timeA -o)s!mi), tha) a simple )oti-e of appeal( Well ,o to eBamples: PRO=LE8: Lets ,o 7a-> to R2LE "#: Yo! re-ei5e a -op* of the RTC de-isio) o) 8ar-h C#( Yo! file *o!r motio) for re-o)sideratio) o) April #9 + the #9th da*( After t6o 6ee>s/ *o! re-ei5ed order of the -o!rt de)*i), the 8%R(

86

1997 Rules on Civil Procedure 2001 Edition <draft copy. pls. check for errors>

Rule 42 Petition for Review From the RTC to the CA

Q: .o6 ma)* more da*s are left for *o! to file a )oti-e of appeal? A: 3iB D$ da*s( A), 7i)ila), mo/ #A: da*s la),( The #9th da* is i)terr!pted )a( Thats tr!e( PRO=LE8: We 6ill ,o to the same pro7lem appl*i), R!le "'$: The -ase 6as de-ided 7* the 8TC/ appealed to the RTC( A)d the) i) the RTC/ *o! lost a,ai)( Yo! re-ei5e a -op* of the de-isio) o) 8ar-h C#( O) April #9/ *o! file a motio) for re-o)sideratio)( A)d the) o) April '9/ *o! re-ei5e the order de)*i), the 8%R( Q: .o6 ma)* da*s more are left for *o! to file *o!r petitio) for re5ie6? A: E!), sa7ihi) mo D da*s from April '9 or April 'D/ thats %AL3EF The a)s6er is #? da*s all o5er a,ai)( Loo> at the la6: The petition shall be filed and served within fifteen (15) days from noti e of the de ision so!ght to be reviewed or of the denial of petitioner"s motion for new trial or re onsideration. 8ea)i),/ *o! -o!)t a)other #? da*s from the de)ial( 2mpisa )a )ama)F 3o the fili), a motio) for )e6 trial or re-o)sideratio) i) R!le "' does )ot o)l* i)terr!pt the r!))i), of the period 7!t it -omme)-es to r!) all o5er a,ai)( 2)li>e i) R!le "#/ i) ordi)ar* appeal/ 6here the fili), of the motio) for re-o)sideratio) or )e6 trial merel* i)terr!pts the r!))i), of the period to appeal( A)d it -omme)-es to r!) a,ai) from the time *o! are )otified that *o!r motio) is de)ied( 3ee the differe)-e? A-t!all*/ if *o! are )ot serio!s i) *o!r st!d* of appeal/ *o! 6ill )ot see these disti)-tio)s( Yo! 6ill <!st ass!me that the pri)-iples !)der R!le "# a)d R!le "' are the same( Q: 2)der 3e-tio) #/ is the #?Ada* period to file petitio) for re5ie6 eBte)di7le? A: 2)der R!le "#/ the #?Ada* period to file )oti-e of appeal is )ot eBte)di7le + )o eB-eptio)s( =!t i) R!le "'/ the #?Ada* period to file petitio) for re5ie6 is EGTENDI=LE a--ordi), to the last se)te)-e of 3e-tio) #/ pro5ided *o! pa* *o!r do->et a)d other la6f!l fees/ the CA 6ill ,ra)t additio)al #? da*s 6ithi) 6hi-h to file a petitio) for re5ie6( Q: Where 6ill *o! file *o!r motio) for eBte)sio) of time to file petitio) for re5ie6? A: Yo! file *o!r motio) for eBte)sio) to the CA( The CA itself 6ill ,ra)t the eBte)sio)( Q: .o6 ma)* more da*s -a) the CA ,ra)t? A: The CA ma* ,ra)t a)other #? da*s a)d )o f!rther eBte)sio) -a) 7e ,ra)ted e# ept for the most -ompelli), reaso)s( 3o/ ori,i)al eBte)sio) is #? da*s/ a)d a possi7le eBte)sio) of #? da*s H total C9 da*s( These are te-h)i-al poi)ts( A)d ho6 ma)* appealed -ases ha5e 7ee) dismissed simpl* 7e-a!se these fi)er pro5isio)s 6ere )ot 7ee) o7ser5ed 7* la6*ers? I 6o!ld sa* D9I of all appeals are dismissed( E5e) i) Da5ao/ ma<orit* of petitio)s are dismissed 7e-a!se )a>!la),a) ), piso sa do->et fee/ >arami( I pres!me thro!,ho!t the -o!)tr*/ the patter) is the same 7e-a!se the r!les o) appeal are 5er* te-h)i-al a)d 5er* stri-t( Thats 6h* there are la6*ers i) 8a)ila/ e5e) i) Da5ao/ 6ho do )ot 6a)t to ha)dle appealed -ases( The* o)l* ha)dle -ases i) the trial -o!rt( Pa,Aa>*at )a/ )asa CA )a/ petitio) for -ertiorari/ pasa )a sa i7a( =!t there are also 6ho ha5e mastered the r!les o) appeal( %or the p!rpose of spe-ialiJatio)/ trial phase a)d appeal phase( %or p!rposes of the 7ar/ *o! ha5e to >)o6 all the fields i) la6s( O)-e *o! pass the 7ar/ di*a) )a >a*o ma,Aisip >!), a)o a), pipilii) )i)*oK-i5il/ -rimi)al/ la7or/ et-( =!t for p!rposes of the 7ar/ *o! -a))ot sa* dito la), a>o ma,Aaral sa La7or/ 6a, )a sa Ci5il La6( P6ede 7a *a)? Yo! -a))ot do that( Ea*a ),a sa7i )ila/ the people 6ho >)o6 more a7o!t the la6 are those 6ho ha5e <!st ta>e) the 7ar( 'ec. 2. $orm and ontents. The pet(t(o) shall 4e f(led () se/e) 586 le+(4le cop(es1 0(th the or(+()al copy ()te)ded for the court 4e()+ ()d(cated as such 4y the pet(t(o)er1 a)d shall 5a6 state the full )a,es of the part(es to the case1 0(thout (,plead()+ the lo0er courts or .ud+es thereof e(ther as pet(t(o)ers or respo)de)ts9 546 ()d(cate the spec(f(c ,ater(al dates sho0()+ that (t 0as f(led o) t(,e9 5c6 set forth co)c(sely a state,e)t of the ,atters ()/ol/ed1 the (ssues ra(sed1 the spec(f(cat(o) of errors of fact or la01 or 4oth1 alle+edly co,,(tted 4y the Re+(o)al Tr(al %ourt1 a)d the reaso)s or ar+u,e)ts rel(ed upo) for the allo0a)ce of the appeal9 5d6 4e acco,pa)(ed 4y clearly le+(4le dupl(cate or(+()als or true cop(es of the .ud+,e)ts or f()al orders of 4oth lo0er courts1 cert(f(ed correct 4y the clerk of court of the Re+(o)al Tr(al %ourt1 the re:u(s(te )u,4er of pla() cop(es thereof a)d of the

87

1997 Rules on Civil Procedure 2001 Edition <draft copy. pls. check for errors>

Rule 42 Petition for Review From the RTC to the CA

plead()+s a)d other ,ater(al port(o)s of the record as 0ould support the alle+at(o)s of the pet(t(o). The pet(t(o)er shall also su4,(t to+ether 0(th the pet(t(o) a cert(f(cat(o) u)der oath that he has )ot theretofore co,,e)ced a)y other act(o) ()/ol/()+ the sa,e (ssues () the 'upre,e %ourt1 the %ourt of #ppeals or d(ffere)t d(/(s(o)s thereof1 or a)y other tr(4u)al or a+e)cy9 (f there (s such other act(o) or proceed()+1 he ,ust state the status of the sa,e9 a)d (f he should thereafter lear) that a s(,(lar act(o) or proceed()+ has 4ee) f(led or (s pe)d()+ 4efore the 'upre,e %ourt1 the %ourt of #ppeals1 or d(ffere)t d(/(s(o)s thereof1 or a)y other tr(4u)al or a+e)cy1 he u)dertakes to pro,ptly ()for, the aforesa(d courts a)d other tr(4u)al or a+e)cy thereof 0(th() f(/e 526 days therefro,. 5)6 Ta>e )ote of 3e-tio) '( Do )ot implead the lo6er -o!rt or the <!d,e 7e-a!se )asa)a* )a ta*o )a pati 4*!), <!d,e )a,i), defe)da)t or respo)de)t )a( We o)l* do that i) Certiorari !)der R!le D? i) 3pe-ial Ci5il A-tio)s/ 7!t )ot o) appeal( This is the i)fl!e)-e of %!sti e %eria 7e-a!se he has pe))ed ma)* -ases 6hi-h has i)-l!ded the <!d,e as defe)da)t or respo)de)t( 3o/ he said that i) the -ase of &'(( vs. )* LA!,( '?/ #:MDN/ he)-e 6e -a) see his i)fl!e)-e/ si)i),it tala,a )i*a i*a) sa >aso )a *o)( No6/ as to the form Llast para,raphN/ there has to 7e a Certifi-atio) of No)A%or!m 3hoppi),/ fail!re to -ompl* 6ith s!-h 6o!ld mea) the dismissal of the -ase( ORTI; vs. %O&RT OF #PPE#$' 2<< '%R# 83= >*<<=? F#%T': The -ertifi-atio) 6as )ot si,)ed 7* the OrtiJes 7!t 7* their la6*er 6ho has perso)al >)o6led,e of the fa-t a)d -o)te)ded that it sho!ld 7e a--epted as s!7sta)tial -omplia)-e 6ith the r!les( !E$@: The -ertifi-atio) 6as )ot proper( 3tri-t o7ser5a)-e of the r!le is re@!ired( I) this -ase/ )o eBpla)atio) 6as ,i5e)( ORe,retta7l*/ We fi)d that s!7sta)tial -omplia)-e 6ill )ot s!ffi-e i) a matter i)5ol5i), stri-t -omplia)-e( The attestatio) -o)tai)ed i) the -ertifi-atio) o) )o)Afor!m shoppi), re@!ires perso)al >)o6led,e 7* the part* 6ho eBe-!ted the same( To merit the Co!rts -o)sideratio)/ OrtiJes here m!st sho6 reaso)a7le -a!se for fail!re to perso)all* si,) the -ertifi-atio)( The OrtiJes m!st -o)5i)-e the -o!rt that the o!tri,ht dismissal of the petitio) 6o!ld defeat the admi)istratio) of <!sti-e( .o6e5er/ the OrtiJes did )ot ,i5e a)* eBpla)atio) to 6arra)t their eBemptio) from the stri-t appli-atio) of the r!le( 2tter disre,ard of the r!les -a))ot <!stl* 7e ratio)aliJed 7* har>i), o) the poli-* of li7eral -o)str!-tio)(P Q: 2)der para,raph L-N/ 6hat iss!es -a) *o! raise i) the petitio) for re5ie6? A: Errors of fa-t/ errors of la6/ or 7oth + miBed errors of fa-t or la6( 3ome7od* as>ed this Q2E3TION: hi)di 7a >apa, error of law dapat sa 3C *a)? .i)di )a dadaa) sa CA? .o6 do *o! re-o)-ile this 6ith the Co)stit!tio)? A-t!all*/ 6he) the la6 sa*s de isions of the +T) appealable dire tly to the (), it 6as de-ided p!rs!a)t to its ori,i)al <!risdi-tio)( =!t if it is de-ided p!rs!a)t to its appellate <!risdi-tio)/ the appeal sho!ld 7e to the CA e5e) o) p!re @!estio)s of la6 6itho!t pre<!di-e of ,oi), to the 3C later o)( 'ec. A. -ffe t of fail!re to omply with re.!irements . The fa(lure of the pet(t(o)er to co,ply 0(th a)y of the fore+o()+ re:u(re,e)ts re+ard()+ the pay,e)t of the docket a)d other la0ful fees1 the depos(t for costs1 proof of ser/(ce of the pet(t(o)1 a)d the co)te)ts of a)d the docu,e)ts 0h(ch should acco,pa)y the pet(t(o) shall 4e suff(c(e)t +rou)d for the d(s,(ssal thereof. 3e-tio) C( If *o! fail to -ompl* 6ith the re@!ireme)ts/ tapos a), petitio) mo/ dismissF 'ec. 4. * tion on the petition. The %ourt of #ppeals ,ay re:u(re the respo)de)t to f(le a co,,e)t o) the pet(t(o)1 )ot a ,ot(o) to d(s,(ss1 0(th() te) 5*36 days fro, )ot(ce1 or

88

1997 Rules on Civil Procedure 2001 Edition <draft copy. pls. check for errors>

Rule 42 Petition for Review From the RTC to the CA

d(s,(ss the pet(t(o) (f (t f()ds the sa,e to 4e pate)tly 0(thout ,er(t1 prosecuted ,a)(festly for delay1 or that the :uest(o)s ra(sed there() are too u)su4sta)t(al to re:u(re co)s(derat(o). 5)6 'ec. 2. )ontents of omment. The co,,e)t of the respo)de)t shall 4e f(led () se/e) 586 le+(4le cop(es1 acco,pa)(ed 4y cert(f(ed true cop(es of such ,ater(al port(o)s of the record referred to there() to+ether 0(th other support()+ papers a)d shall 5a6 state 0hether or )ot he accepts the state,e)t of ,atters ()/ol/ed () the pet(t(o)9 546 po()t out such ()suff(c(e)c(es or ()accurac(es as he 4el(e/es e-(st () pet(t(o)er7s state,e)t of ,atters ()/ol/ed 4ut 0(thout repet(t(o)9 a)d 5c6 state the reaso)s 0hy the pet(t(o) should )ot 4e +(/e) due course. # copy thereof shall 4e ser/ed o) the pet(t(o)er. 5)6 'ec. B. /!e o!rse. If upo) the f(l()+ of the co,,e)t or such other plead()+s as the court ,ay allo0 or re:u(re1 or after the e-p(rat(o) of the per(od for the f(l()+ thereof 0(thout such co,,e)t or plead()+ ha/()+ 4ee) su4,(tted1 the %ourt of #ppeals f()ds pr(,a fac(e that the lo0er court has co,,(tted a) error of fact or la0 that 0(ll 0arra)t a re/ersal or ,od(f(cat(o) of the appealed dec(s(o)1 (t ,ay accord()+ly +(/e due course to the pet(t(o). 5)6 Q: Whe) *o! file a petitio) for re5ie6 from the RTC to the CA/ is the CA o7li,ed to e)tertai) the petitio)? A: No/ this is dis-retio)ar* !)der 3e-tio) D( The CA ma* or ma* )ot ,i5e d!e -o!rse to the petitio) !)li>e i) ordi)ar* appeal( Ya) a), >ai7aha) ), ordi)ar* appeal a)d petitio) for re5ie6( I) ordi)ar* appeal !)der R!le "#/ 6he) *o! file )oti-e of appeal a)d *o! pa* *o!r do->et fee/ *o!r appeal is a!tomati-all* e)tertai)ed( At least it 6ill 7e heard 7* the CA( =!t i) R!le "'/ it is )ot the same( Whe) *o! ,o there/ 6hether *o!r petitio) for re5ie6 6ill 7e ,i5e) d!e -o!rse or )ot e5e) if *o! ha5e paid the do->et fee( Normall*/ the CA 6ill re@!ired *o! to -omme)t a)d the) -ha)-es are after a)other mo)th a)d after readi), *o!r petitio) a)d *o!r -omme)t/ the CA 6ill ref!se to ,i5e d!e -o!rse to *o!r petitio)/ 0o!r petition is hereby dismissed1 3o/ *o! m!st -o)5i)-e the CA )a ma* merit 7aahF Q: What happe)s 6he) the petitio) for re5ie6 is ,i5e) d!e -o!rse? A: The parties 6ill 7e re@!ired to s!7mit their respe-ti5e memora)da( Ta>e )ote that the RTC is also ,i5e) the po6er to iss!e orders for the prote-tio) of the parties + the same as i) 3e-tio) M/ para,raph L7N( 'ec. 8. -levation of re ord. Whe)e/er the %ourt of #ppeals dee,s (t )ecessary1 (t ,ay order the clerk of court of the Re+(o)al Tr(al %ourt to ele/ate the or(+()al record of the case ()clud()+ the oral a)d docu,e)tary e/(de)ce 0(th() f(ftee) 5*26 days fro, )ot(ce. 5)6 Q: No6/ 6he) is a) appeal 7* petitio) for re5ie6 deemed perfe-ted? A: 3e-tio) M LaN( 3imilar to R!le "#( The same pri)-iple: 'ec. =. 2erfe tion of appeal; effe t thereof. 5a6 &po) the t(,ely f(l()+ of a pet(t(o) for re/(e0 a)d the pay,e)t of the correspo)d()+ docket a)d other la0ful fees1 the appeal (s dee,ed perfected as to the pet(t(o)er. The Re+(o)al Tr(al %ourt loses .ur(sd(ct(o) o/er the case upo) the perfect(o) of the appeals f(led () due t(,e a)d the e-p(rat(o) of the t(,e to appeal of the other part(es. !o0e/er1 4efore the %ourt of #ppeals +(/es due course to the pet(t(o)1 the Re+(o)al Tr(al %ourt ,ay (ssue orders for the protect(o) a)d preser/at(o) of the r(+hts of the part(es 0h(ch do )ot ()/ol/e a)y ,atter l(t(+ated 4y the appeal1 appro/e co,pro,(ses1 per,(t appeals of ()d(+e)t l(t(+a)ts1 order e-ecut(o) pe)d()+ appeal () accorda)ce 0(th sect(o) 2 of Rule A<1 a)d allo0 0(thdra0al of the appeal. 5<a1 R4*6 546 E-cept () c(/(l cases dec(ded u)der the Rule o) 'u,,ary Procedure1 the appeal shall stay the .ud+,e)t or f()al order u)less the %ourt of #ppeals1 the la01 or these Rules shall pro/(de other0(se. 5)6

89

1997 Rules on Civil Procedure 2001 Edition <draft copy. pls. check for errors>

Rule 42 Petition for Review From the RTC to the CA

Q: Does the RTC ha5e the po6er to a-t despite the fa-t that the petitio) for re5ie6 is alread* 7efore the CA? 3!ppose I lost i) the 8TC/ a)d I also lost o) appeal i) the RTC( I file a petitio) for re5ie6( What happe)s to the de-isio)? Ca) the de-isio) 7e e)for-ed? A: NO/ it -a))ot 7e e)for-ed *et 7e-a!se it is )ot *et fi)al( We still ha5e to 6ait for the appeal to 7e dismissed or to 7e e)tertai)ed a)d de)ied later( 2)der para,raph L7N/ the appeal shall stay the 3!dgment or final order 456-(( the )*, the law or these r!les sho!ld provide otherwise. Also/ 7ased o) the ope)i), -la!se of para,raph L7N/ e# ept in ivil ases provided in the +!les on (!mmary 2ro ed!re/ a)* part thereafter appealed to the CA 6ill )ot stop the impleme)tatio) of the RTC de-isio)( 2)der 3e-tio) '# of the 3!mmar* R!les/ 6he) a -ase is started i) the 8TC !)der the 3!mmar* Pro-ed!re/ a)d appealed to the RTC a)d de-ided 7* the RTC/ the de-isio) 7e-omes immediatel* eBe-!tor*( E5e) if 6e file a petitio) for re5ie6/ it is eBe-!tor*( The o)l* 6a* to stop the RTC from e)for-i), that <!d,me)t is to ,et a TRO or a 6rit of prelimi)ar* i)<!)-tio) from the CA( That is the r!le( I ha5e a similar -ase )o6 o) that iss!e( The -ase ori,i)ated from the 8TC for e<e-tme)t( The defe)da)t lost/ a>*at ),a*o) sa RTC/ affirmed( A)d the) a>*at )a )ama) a), defe)da)t sa CA o) petitio) for re5ie6 altho!,h ri,ht )o6/ it has )ot *et 7ee) ,i5e) d!e -o!rse$ 6ith a pra*er for TRO( =!t the CA said that there is )o -ompelli), reaso) to iss!e o)e( I) the mea)time/ I filed a motio) for eBe-!tio)( The defe)da)t opposed o) the ,ro!)d that a <!d,me)t -a))ot 7e eBe-!ted da6 7e-a!se of a pe)di), petitio) for re5ie6( =!t this is !)der the 3!mmar* R!les + e<e-tme)t( This is a) eB-eptio)/ so that 6ill )ot appl*( 'ec. <. (!bmission for de ision. If the pet(t(o) (s +(/e) due course1 the %ourt of #ppeals ,ay set the case for oral ar+u,e)t or re:u(re the part(es to su4,(t ,e,ora)da 0(th() a per(od of f(ftee) 5*26 days fro, )ot(ce. The case shall 4e dee,ed su4,(tted for dec(s(o) upo) the f(l()+ of the last plead()+ or ,e,ora)du, re:u(red 4y these Rules or 4y the court (tself. 5)6 AoOoA

90