Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 8

1NC

Our Statement - Lenny and I stand in solidarity with those negatively affected by ______ which destroy human values and civic liberties The counterplan solves better than the plan 3 internal links Action cannot be taken for the oppressed, action must be taken with the oppressed otherwise resulting in false generosity Freire 1968 (Paulo Freire. Educational Revolutionary. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. Pg 44)
This, then, is the great humanistic and historical task of the oppressed: AND dispensers of false generosity became desperate at the slightest threat to its source.

Oppressors must fight at the side of the oppressed to challenge the system, not use the system to fight their problems Freire 1970 [Paulo, Pedagogy of the Oppressed,
http://www.marxists.org/subject/education/freire/pedagogy/index.htm]

The same is true with respect to the individual oppressor as person. Discovering himself AND do nothing tangible to make this affirmation a reality, is a farce.

Their focus on role-playing in conjunction with things that are bigger then ourselves results in passivity and tyranny Assuming our own agency key

Antonio 1995 [Robert; Professor of Sociology at the University of Kansas; Nietzsches Antisociology: Subjectified Culture and the End of History; American Journal of Sociology; Volume 101, No. 1; July 1995] While modern theorists saw differentiated roles and professions as a matrix of autonomy and reflexivity AND 117-18, 213, 288-89, 303-4).

OV
Being in solidarity with the oppressed accounts for the differences in perspectives and is necessary to effectively combat structural violence Brent R.Henze 2000 Who Says Who Says?: The Epistemological Grounds for Agency in Liberatory Political Projects. Found in
Reclaiming Identity: Realist theory and the predicament of postmodernism. Edited by Paula Moya and Michael Hames-Garcia

Though I argue against efforts to speak for those otherwise able to produce and enact AND most effectively to combat oppression as a systemic yet particular effect of power.

Solves War
War in the modern era exists more in the image of it being fought than in reality; wars are conducted via public opinion polls, the media, and so on, with military action just as an afterthought. To avoid war, we must oppose its simulation to give it authority through images is to make it real Our solidarity with the oppressed deals directly with Structural Violence which is key to stopping the illusion of war Baudrillard in 94 [Jean, The Illusion of the End p. 62-65]
America conducted the Gulf War as though it were a nuclear conflict, and thus AND Where was there simulacrum here, except in the simulacrum of war itself?

Understandings of war as an event are practically and theoretically flawed they rely on antiquated notions of human nature and deflect criticism away from everyday violence. Cuomo 96
Chris J. Cuomo, Professor of Philosophy at the University of Cincinnati, 1996 (War Is Not Just an Event: Reflections on the Significance of Everyday Violence, Hypatia, Volume 11, Number 4, Fall, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via JSTOR, p. 34-35) Peach finds just-war theory's reliance on realism, the notion that human nature AND military violence as isolated, persistent events, are practically and theoretically insufficient.

Fiat Stuff
Ceding personal agency through fiat represents the ultimate tool of this western domination. High school debate calls us to cede our agency to the all-powerful, righteous state. However, this traps us in the cycle of inactivism, never allowing us to critique or confront the state that dominates us, and the other.
Shaffer 2007(Butler teaches at the Southwestern University School of Law. B.S., Law, 1958, University of Nebraska, Lincoln; B.A., Political Science, 1959, and J.D.,
1961, University of Chicago; Member, Colorado and Nebraska State Bars. Identifying With the State June 29th 2007. http://www.lewrockwell.com/shaffer/shaffer159.html)

One of the deadliest practices we engage in is that of identifying ourselves with a AND conflict to a centered, self-directed integrity in our lives.

Assuming our own agency and rejecting role playing as the government is more real-world. Vote affirmative to question the current politics of policy debate and allow for the breakdown of the social hierarchy. Warner 03 [Ede, "Go Homers, Makeovers or Takeovers? A Privilege Analysis of Debate as aGaming Simulation,", 2003]
As part of a radical debate approach that has spent the last three years calling AND determine what measures are just in their pursuit of equality with the foxes.

State Bad
Political actions are merely a form of oppression concealed with the intent of freeing the oppressed Freire, 70. (Pedagogy of the Opressed Chapter 1, Published by the Continuum Publishing Company in 1970)
Indeed, the interests of the oppressors lie in changing the consciousness of the AND , incorporated into the healthy society that they have forsaken.

AT: Perm
Extend our second Freire card Being in solidarity with the oppressed requires rejecting system for personal attachment to those afflicted by poverty The failure to incorporate the lives of those who are oppressed by our politics can only lead to more oppressive politics and eventually the failure of our politics. Paulo Friere gave us insight to why our personalized brand of politics acts as a counter hegemonic means of confronting oppression in the face of such situations when he said Paulo Friere, Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Chapter 1, educator and director of the Department of Cultural Extension of Recife University,1970

For the truly humanist educator and the authentic revolutionary, the object of action is AND people. Such a program constitutes cultural invasion,[11]good intentions notwithstanding

If the aff legitimately believes in the ability of our struggle (which is key to our solvency) then you vote negative. In order for them to authentically join with us they must actually be willing to give the ballot up, instead of putting us on the back burner All of are reasons their method of engaging the oppressed are bad are reasons why this isnt reverse casual
Freire 1968 (Paulo Freire. Educational Revolutionary. Pedagogy of the Oppressed CH AND them; and trusting the people is the indispensable precondition for revolutionary change.

AT: State Good


And speaking in abstraction about what form the world should take through fiat ignores and marginalizes all the people who would be affected.
Nayar in 99 [Jayan, Fall, School of Law, University of Warwick AND whose behalf we might speak. So, what do we do?

Our CP is a prerequisite to making governmental policies Means that absent the CP, the aff can never solve Solvency deficits to the CP also are reasons the case cant solve
RUSSELL-MORRIS 96, GEORGE MASON UNIVERSITY, 2009 (BRIANNE, THE LOGIC AND would come under scrutiny and would be targeted for change (OConnor 2001).

AT: You Dont Do Anything


And we do solve - Assuming our own agency through Micropolitial Movements that are started in the Debate round are key to creating and organizing change outside of the Round Kulynych 97 [Jessica, assistant professor of political science at Winthrop University, Performing Politics, Polity Winter
v.XXX, n.2 pages 336 and 346]

A performative concept of participation as resistance explodes the distinction between public and private, AND organization of the workplace, to the intimacy of daily actions and iterations. (She continues) When we look at the success of citizen initiatives from a performative perspective, we AND commissions continues to defy technical bureaucracy even while their decisions are non binding.

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi