S Coo..

e-r o= APPGALS
D S V. A LLt.: N .51 AW r- or< I)
A PFt=AL L2. - 2 0 tf II
M 1 f'tCtVJ.. c..t 1 s R ALL<: 1'-.1 ST Ar-J (-o(Z. D I
(!.{)MJLvt-t-f ivtmttt"J- t!.:t 2 USP, I SeY\.t-
-Hu ... sn-' Ct,{C.u(l c:. f!uvj()V$ dc.+.tJ '-+,
12.-ZCttl\, -rJti$ d..
kk-1 S Ma t+..(..IL,
{)y. Z.on .. -:s'UI)(t(: ;t'1s LoW\-d..ts
e"l, OS /VII l.tcop( Ofr..tl \c.+...( ctf+a/t.tt..(7' M?. fo)A:Ju.cz...
V'tPtil.tJ tt l...rt+.tA dc.+.eJ :z:J, m.L"t
C..ffoinfVJ'lt.;\f', ]:. aHa.J...t) c.. C,(/r'1 oj Ails. t<ooRI(:,vt;2,
1
S
.i.df..t/\. +o VJtt..L w.-(Wt Mt<AG-k. 4-
1
2.crt .J.tt-+-t-A +o f-h...c.--
STi-1 'In. lt..A 1-t..+t-.J-? M!. +c) l<.tt.t?
/l1ut as. +o all Jl...r lc.t".to\ -h> vn( l.
I we. '7 -s fA<' c.-t<.t J +o I-t 611. o W\ 1 }J e$+ .. f-".t.;t o 1\.-
tt, 2-o +h.a+ afl-tt;. I is dtA..t +o bo(_ b"ed
J..J ,{h t{..t 5 rJ.t t1 e> IV .Ait.ttAe-"- 1 g Z...o 1 3 No-t- ortlvf
. I I I
w ]: ..vet CAwt:.ll.J- t!)& btd tts

,M_.s /2DT;)/Z.IC
1
UEL kas 5fil/ to VJ-\..L-
ih I e..ntt:l oV.J.A fi-t f.A.I-tpl..cli...L .flu
Case: 12-20411 Document: 00512178966 Page: 1 Date Filed: 03/18/2013
. J:_ kc.V...t OtlSo ):,.iLV\ iYLt"/\W\.tef bl
... 1 +hkt A> ,<'cQ;(I<qoE:Z- htis ltlii:++.(Ll :sL. }ws
. 4oh.< a bSo\Lt t-t.lf N() '-\)OAk. t>h tnf \..
. L. ; s + h
1
-+" bv w 1+k "H... .a/\ c.u ln.r
. C c m lN\. ; 1-vY\-t n. t S. +o W 0 A. I< o 1\J Vhf U 5 ...L ,
.2
. t\,HV\.t./\ l"'- "- O..<Dt:t<. iS.StA.e.J ON Bt:;e 2 2oo9
I
. 5f.-f.ciJ iLt.tl1
1
\' MIC;J-\LY
II
LbM PL.EX. fUM-
\ \
. ()/ Yl'\'1 Cti5...L C.Y<). +-Jv A.Aioui\11' ot:: 015C.6
o- I ,, J -.
. 1/./VPL vo. J- do rt.of fi.. clv..t. 'J M->
. foss.JL5..5..11. s $K; kt;:""d Lc. .. an..
' t:tff.te;,l SIAL" et $ V1A: ;\..,.V. f17 I w ,'}\ d..t 11....(.
ib J. .ftu, A.ts+ &b ill (JA.I>"ILJ Ot:t tifle:-,1(/
/..t+ 6a;A ctnc:.l hOf\es+ de:.
1
iN
, ].. h "' "' b l '1 Co "'"' + fj..._ '" c I Ji'C v IT .,_"A r
. LouAr;,es f<.oDf<l c
7
uG2..- b...t. imVJ'\...e.dit:f..tl/
. t1S bl "3iA1)(1 E 14-IHnt/\.. lJt-t.,(_
. -h, fL_ hi;hl/ 66 Yn( C.a.s...L .:J l\t6u.t.sf"
. I ht. fit.(. (;)ffortitA.n.;+y +o V11..u...t c..
. C. "SA a.ff.t..i\c.t...<. aftoll..t\.t/ tJA st...,L. is a.ffoiVt.+.t.d,
.J. l.Ntndt'f 0111t11bl7 fh..t. 5TH Cltc:.u.-r -1-o vrt&tk..t ...
. a..fftJi,....trvt.lfl. -r J CIA as C{ I +cl/\f\.h+iiJ'J...
. T ud j o+h-4 Y\. -r v D &t.: Hi +t rJ.JA flgu; .-t; J I a f fo r
. YVl..t a, 'Y\..t w l.t ttcl c; f f.L t ...t.- a..t to11. n.L '/. LCt.S +
1
I
. WoUld Os\( +h.t -reo o:<J)tlt
Case: 12-20411 Document: 00512178966 Page: 2 Date Filed: 03/18/2013
3
6 d: 1'\.1 I i _.!...c._ oF l
1
2.oi'3 6fJ7. W\1 c.ppea I
b..( t) fl\t.t d<. bADYh +tv. S TI-t
1
J
1
C!Ylr/
a ?7..LIJ &illn.l L1?dli}l.c..-- c>71.c..L a..
h 12.. w a(J II c. i a ff tJ 11. h...t y b -l-tn a If" /1\. f e d,
'(ov R S
)

Ro8til?i ALLiiN
Case: 12-20411 Document: 00512178966 Page: 3 Date Filed: 03/18/2013