Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 16

K.V.

Reddy
President
All India Prison Officers Association
09849904733 / 09440060055
Email:kvreddydsp@yahoo.com

PROSTITUTION SHOULD BE LEGALISED

From time immemorial, the profession of prostitution has


been in existence and in the primitive days, remained with Devadasis
(Temple dancers) who adopted discreet methods of hiring their bodies to
some of the Rajahs and Maharajas or even off-went land lords as semi-
permanent ‘keeps’ on a mutually agreed remuneration with other perks
for their living, upkeep and lavish life-style. Subsequently, the profession
percolated to the adolescent unmarried girls seeking to saturate their
sexual urge, which of course, is a biological necessity for every human
being male or female. As on age-old profession, it needs to be thoroughly
examined from all angles and steps taken to legalize it. The fundamental
‘right to live’ guaranteed by our constitution has also to be taken into
reckoning which is a sacred preamble envies age by our founding fathers.

People say that prostitution is a social problem.

Prostitution actually helps maintain the family by acting as an


outlet, or safety valve, for those males who want impersonal and
transitory sex. It is an age-old profession and it cannot be destroyed. It is
a widely but secretly accepted profession.

It is a victimless crime. No one is getting injured. The man is


gaining pleasure and the women is earning a living. Men turn to
prostitutes for sexual satisfaction to find sexual variety, both in the sense
of different types of women and unconventional sexual techniques.

At no point of time, this professional of prostitution was treated as a


problem to the guardians if law and order. As generations progressed,
the drowing urge for situating sexual passion and lust took a drastic turn
around among the youth adolescents. This was mainly due to the ‘Idiot
Box’ (television) and movies of romantic dimensions depicting regularly
the imperative need for indulgence in the act of sexual intercourse. This
became a very piquant problem of supply and demand as all other needs
of daily life. The environments, the quality of nutrition, the modern life
style had all played a vital role in the fast developing nations and
particularly the southern part of our country because the been hive for
more sexual activity.
Prostitution is functional. It provides an outlet for
monogamous boredom.

Prostitution is existed everywhere, at every time, from the


beginning of recorded history.

It is being to be noted as ‘Necessary evil” in very society. Hence,


laws were framed only to control the prostitution and not for outright
eradication of prostitutes.

It is a fact that, unmarried men of all ages are more likely than
married men, to seek the services of prostitutes. A study revealed that
most of the visitors are from middle-class or lower middle class families
only.

Statistics reveal that, the northern parts of India – Maharastra, Uttar


Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, West Bengal and some of
the North Eastern states have all earmarked licensed “Red Light” areas
for such a profession in order that those who aspire to ease their sexual
desire can choose to visit them and satisfy their inner urge, or course, on
a mutually agreed fee for the pleasure they secure momentarily.

Prostitution is like any other business. There are innumerable


people making a living by it.

Wherever restless men and money congregates, there are women


seeking, to sell a moment of pleasure. Where there is easy money there
are prostitutes.

The value of religions, the feeling of motherhood for women and


respect for opposite sex are fast diminishing in modern society and
society must rehabilitate, re-establish these valves.

The tension of sex deals young and old, spinsters and bachelor, rich
and poor alike (unmarried women).

Sexual urge cannot, therefore be curbed, by enforcement of law.


The tension of sex deals with the young and old, the spinsters and
bachelors, rich and poor inspective of caste, creed or religion and there is
no demarcated barrier for carrying on this age-old profession. Hence, this
act of prostitution between male and female has taken its roots in all
classes of society due to various factors. Also, the abundant availability
of pornographic literature has rapidly increased the hunger for sex in the
modern society for both males and females. The growing incidents of
prostitution in urban areas have been increasing according to the
unwritten law or supply and demand. In order to meet this demand,
clandestine organizations have mushroomed to lure young and eligible
spinsters with a false promise of providing lucrative employment,
alternately to land into the so called immoral profession of prostitution.
Without a demand there would be no pros. More men can be found
the streets in search of sexual pleasure than women, who seek to sell
their services.

Some causes for women taking to this profession are:-

1. Difficulty or finding employment.


2. Excessive, laborers and it’ll paid work.
3. Harsh treatment of girls at home.
4. Promise and indecent made of living away the overcrowded.
5. The aggregations of people together in large communities &
factories, whereby the yond are into constant contact with
demoralized companions.
6. The example of luxury, silt indulgence and loose manners setup
the rich class.
7. Demoralizing literature and
8. The arts of profligate (seek less) men and theirs agents.
9. Alcohol (10) late marriages (12) Higher Educated for women.
10. Young working women among from Men frequent pro. For the
following reasons.

1. Less effort is necessary to scare a sexual partner


You can simply walk in & out

2. Insufficient marital relations.


3. End of responsibility on payment – pay & garget.
4. Teenagers is experimental stage – They are very longer to know
the secret.
5. Sexually isolated persons – Like RICA Trainees.
6. Leas expensive than non-prostitutes – No following, no film, No
hotels.
7. Due to physical deformity & can only get prostitutes to have
relations with them.
8. Married men with frigid wives.
9. To satisfy desire for sexual deviations
10. Refusal of married partner to engage in deviation
11. Bad company
12. Pimps &
13. primarily because of poverty
14. Due to Decay of traditional morality
15. Due to greater freedom of young women
16. Due to wider knowledge & Sales of contraceptives like pills,
nirogh etc.
17. Due to unhappy experiences of promiscuity (indiscrimination)
pros. is a social problems. Why does a demand exist in the
society for pros? Because, sexual design is part of the very
nature of man.

Pornographic literature has greatly increased the sex hunger in the


modern youth of both sexes.
1. Do the pros like theirs professions? The answer is ‘NO’
2. Do the pros. Love any of theirs clients the answer is ‘Never’

Prostitutions in India

During the Moghal Rule prostitution become more widely spread


than in ancient India.

The SITA/RITA Act, 1956 has failed to decrease the trafficking in


women and girls or induction in the number of prostitutes.

This profession, like any other, operates on a commercial basis,


according to the law of demand and supply.

Commercial pros. has increased to a great extent. Some College


girls are adopting this to “earn for theirs education” some for fun some for
romance and joy etc., which leads them in future, life towards prost. Due
to the dowry system also, girls from middle class families are practicing
this profession, some with the help of their parents some with the help of
their husbands, in order to secure huge sums of money to keeping an
appearance of affluence.

To meet the increasing demand, some organizations are bring


young girls, with a promise to get employment, a chance to act in pictures
etc. some girls were first promised marriage by some crooks and later
were dragged into this immoral profession.

The history of prostitution shows that, it has outlined every social,


economic, ethical & political system. It has had its vicissitudes, problems
etc., but it has existed, proving how deeply it is rooted in human social
life.

There are many factors which guide the destiny of prostitutes


mainly due to poverty, en-employment and other natural desires to which
every human has succumbed from ages. Well-knit domestic families
irrespective of their social and economic status have fallen a prey to this
very stigmatic profession and women who offer their bodies to
indiscriminate sexual orgy and that too on hire, is an act not due to
spontaneity but owing to rigid compulsion of circumstance, be it
economical, physiological, physical, psychological, or socially sex
emotional.

On the other hand, greater wealth and material security have


tended to raise the working class women above the level at which they
might have become prostitutes through destitutions (poverty). But on the
other hand, their rising income has accomplished even outstripped by
rising demands, and greater freedom has given to a large no. of women
the opportunity of adding to theirs earning by casual and private
prostitutions.
Generally, the poor and lower middle class ladies easily come into
open, as they don’t have facilities to carry out the trade escheating.

Ladies of hunger middle class, college girls, workingwomen,


housewives and high class women are succeeding in practice in this
trouble in secret.

The upper class women in India, under the spell of western


influence choose to exploit sex in order to lead luxurious life.

Causes for enlisting in the profession of prostitution are numerous,


but the salient few are social environment, stained relationships with their
kith and kin, frustrations in cumbersome married life, over strict
percentage with the grown-ups and many more “Variety is the spice of
life, hence none can relish the same menu for breakfast, lunch or dinner
everyday in as much as they do not attain pleasure or satisfy their sexual
passion over the same act with the same lady all the time. Hence, the for
getting into the trap of call girls and prostates. Wisdom should prevail on
the powers that be for legalizing the profession, provided a separate zone
or colony for these wage earners, issue them licenses for the profession
subject to periodical medical check-up and allocating a monitor to
supervise their routine. If need be, fixing rates decoding to their
category, complexion and age barrier besides trying a tax in the form of
luxury tax so that the rampant rape criminals are reduced to the minimal
and the courts are freed from their monitory of sitting over such
impregnable and malicious cases of rapists. No informal of law can
eradicate this malaise from the society. Better late than never.

K.V.Reddy
President
All India Prison Officers Association
09849904733 / 09440060055
Email:kvreddydsp@yahoo.com

DEATH SENTENCE

Crime is eternal as eternal as society. Crime is a perennial and


universal problem of all societies. The concept of crime is rooted in man’s
rudimental attempts to distinguish between the right and the wrong.

According to Frank Hunting’s “Social Disorganization” hypothesis


the criminal is a normal human being, but is now living in a disorganized
society, which tends to disorganize it’s individual efforts. He believed that
society is sick and the criminal learns his criminality through a process of
unfortunate and natural happenings.

Capital punishment is the most ancient and by its very nature the
most cruel of all. It must have originated in the primitive society as
reaction to murder and similar grave offences. Jesus Christ repudiated all
sense of vengeance. He would have all sinners including criminals
reformed rather than annihilated. Death sentence seams vindictive in
modern society.

The argument in favour of retaining this form of punishment are:-

A. It is the only way of eliminating the incorrigible enemies of


society. In other modes of punishment the criminal comes back to society
to resume his nefarious activities. Why should society support him with
the constant menace of his release and subsequent depredations?

This argument is, however, easily assailable. After all, how can
society in the present conditions of its knowledge ascertain who is going
to revert to crime and who is not?

The murder by passion is likely to repeat his crime than the thief or
burglar. As a matter of fact, except professional murderers, who are
negligibly few, murderers, if spared the noose would really not commit
similar crime again.

B. It deters as no other form of punishment does.

This argument looks formidable enough in view of the fact that life
is considered to be the most precious and dearest possession. Life, is the
birth right of all human beings. We cannot take whatever we cannot give.
After all, we have not yet perfected our machinery of providing proper
justice, so that, we cannot count upon court pronouncements as infallible.
“To err is human & to Forgive is divine”. Jurisprudence also needs
constant scrutiny and revision.

Human life is the most precious gift of god almighty who is


omnipresent and omnipotent as well (though atheists may differ). Even
when suicidal attempt is punishable under law, no human howsoever high
and mighty he or she may be, has not an iota of right to snatch away
another human’s life, howsoever heinous and grave his or her crime may
be, since unflinching evidence and factual establishment of the crime,
proved beyond any reasonable doubt, will perennially remain beyond the
law of jurisprudence since all these are again the mechanism perpetrated
by the very same human beings. The exalted judiciary.

Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, on assuming charge as the first Prime


Minister of India, very vociferously declared, in his maiden Independence
Day message to the nation, that hoarders and black-marketers would be
hanged to death to the nearest lamp-post (through he did no mean it
literally) and these professions are being carried on unabatedly till today
despite the strictest enforcement of law. If according to Nehru, his
declaration was implemented in its true spirit, India’s population today
would have been whittled down to less than half and there would have
been no need for any family planning program, which has already cost the
public exchequer rather too heavily.

The extreme penalty of passing a death sentence is too primitive


and atrociotely loathsome to think of, in as much as capital punishment is
extremely primitive to the society in which we are living today. The World
Human rights Day is being observed by all the countries around the globe
and ‘Life’ and existence is the birth right of all human beings. Most of the
countries have totally abolished death penalty considering it as barbarian
and inhuman and yet their crime graph indicates that the crime rate has
reduced to the barest minimum. Simple because you eliminate a person
from this mundane world, it does not imply, that similar heinous crime
warranting extreme punishment are reduced even marginally. The
problem of extremists and anti-social elements shall remain on mother
earth as long as the society as a whole is reformed both culturally and
economically.

Tight evidence manufactured by an over zealous party or agency


may secure conviction of an innocent person in the present conditions.
There are instances of innocent men being condemned, although few.

To cite an instance, as reported recently, in the media, a police


informer who had an enmity with a rag picker informed the Police that, he
had seen with his own eyes of the cold blooded murder in the locality, by
the rag picker. The Police arrested the rag picker who was sentenced for
life imprisonment by the judiciary. After the lapse of 11 years, the Police
informer committed suicide and in the suicide note left behind, he
mentioned of the grave error of involving the rag picker falsely of murder
charges (due to his personal enmity) and that he is innocent. A couple of
NGO’s took up the matter with the judiciary on PIL petition and the rag
picker is honorable acquitted and released from prison. What an illogical
faux-paux is infened by erring judgments of such nature where proof or
evidence is a distant ‘cry in wilderness’.

Recently I heard of a case, which occurred in U.S.A. A young person


had been sentenced for 6 years imprisonment for raping a girl. But 2
years, after getting married, the same girl, now a woman, decided to tell
the truth to the world that she was not raped by the person, who is now
undergoing sentence in that case. What, if it happens in the case of a
person, who had been executed had capital punishment been given. Can
we give rebirth or life? No. Then, such a punishment of ‘hanging till
death’ needs to be summarily detested and considered barbaric.

In other cases, however, there remains room for redressal and


even compensating the sufferer, whereas in case of death nothing can be
done to the actual man so condemned.
After a person is executed, there is no initiative on the part of any
one to hunt for evidence, which might establish his posthumous
innocence or the guilt of others. A tongue is eternally silenced. It could
have itself given further clues to a crime.

It is unworthy of civilized men to go by it any more. Undoubtedly,


the person condemned can have no chance of reformation as he perishes
for good.

The criminals usually executed by death are not necessarily


habitual criminals. Death prevents reformation altogether. The barbarity
of capital punishment has a demoralizing effect upon society. It violates
our humanitarian sentiments. Is it not absurd that the laws, which detect
and punish homicide, should in order to prevent murder, publicly commit
murder themselves? The law should not increase the ferocity of mankind
by examples of barbarity. Death penalty is a relic of the old times when
people thought in terms of elimination rather than reformation or
prevention. Death penalty is the most cold blooded and deliberate form
of murder.

Social conditions have greatly changed, since, the time when this
form of punishment was considered absolutely indispensable. Police
protection has become much more efficient and investigation, both in
method and thoroughness has advanced a great deal. Criminals are not
pursued more relentlessly and probably more effectively than before. It is
now possible to choose from a greater variety of penalties and apply the
most suited to the individual concerned. So far, as protection from
ravages of these criminals, if spared, goes, it is now within the bounds of
possible attainment to segregate them so that they can’t do any more
injury.

At present, the death penalty is very uncertain, because, it is


difficult to have Jurys return verdicts of guilty in cases, where, they know
capital sentence will follow. It means that criminals could be more
effectively dealt with under any other punishment than this.

In inflicting this extreme penalty, society deprives innocent


members of their main prop in many cases. This is undoubtedly a great
problem in as much as the family of a man, either detained or executed
does suffer terribly. In the case of death, however, a prop and support is
permanently done away with.

It may be disputed, although, it has been argued, that in all those


countries, where the extreme penalty has been abolished a decrease in
murders has been noticed. Possibly this result is due to other factors as
well, such as growth of culture, a higher standard of life and better police
organization, but it has certainly belied fears of those who had visualized
an orgy of murders as the inevitable consequence of the abolition of the
death penalty. A number of countries have abolished it and do not seem
to have been any work off. It is now known that any country has had to
go back to the old system after having once abolished it. I have
confidence in that other countries following these will also fare as well.

Amnesty International, the best-known International Organization


for human rights is working against the capital punishment. In its
worldwide study it found that only the poor, minorities and ordinary
criminals are getting the capital punishment. At present 67 countries
have abolished capital punishment.

In 1971 and 1977, the United Nations General Assembly has


supported for the abolition of capital punishment. Whipping abolished in
1955. Transportation in 1955. Chekky and Gunny in 1953. Pillory and
display of offender on donkey also. Penal servitude abolished in 1949.
Then why not capital punishment?

The sentence of death stands in the forefront in the category of


punishment. The question, whether the state has the right to take away a
man’s life, has always been agitated and its validity has often been
questioned.

No doubt, the Supreme Court has laid down that the death sentence
is within the ambit of constitution, but it is an issue upon which the
moralist and jurist and Human rights Activists are never likely to agree.
Reformists have always been and are of the view that capital punishment
is inhuman, obnoxious and dastardly.

In, India, no doubt, the death sentence has not yet been abolished
but the Legislature as well as the judiciary have shown its aversion
towards the execution in no uncertain terms.

After the amendment of Sec 367 Cr.P.C. 1898, and enactment of the
new Criminal Procedure 1973, the court has to state the special reasons
for awarding sentence of death, in case of offences, which are also
punishable with lesser sentence of imprisonment.

Sub Sec. 3 of Sec 3564 of Cr.P.C. 1973, provides under:

“When the conviction is for an offence punishable with death or as


an alternative, with the imprisonment for life or imprisonment for a term
of 10 years, the judgment shall state special reasons for the sentence
awarded.

The above provision shows that the legislative emphasis has


modified from the death sentence to that of life imprisonment.

The death sentence in over whelming majority of cases, are reduced


to life imprisonment either by S.C. on appeal or through the presidential
pardon (clemency) (in both cases, mostly the effluent, influential, persons
with political background only escape).
According to A.I.R. 1980 Mr. Justice Bhagwati observed that, Sec.
302 of IPC in so far as it provided for imposition of death penalty, as an
alternative to life sentence, was violative of article 14 & 21 of the
constitution and therefore ultra virus & void. Since the section did not
provide any legislative guidelines as to when life was permitted to be
extinguished by imposition of death sentence. He struck down Sec. 302
of IPC as un-constitutional and void.

In 1974, Justice Krishna Iyer, in Supreme Court said that:

We assume that a better world is one without legal knifing of life.


Our developmental decade must turn benignant eye on lives right to life
as the basic condition of human development and as a problem of 3rd
world within every nation. Do remember that the blow of the Capital
Sentence often falls on the socially, mentally and economically backward
or the brave revolutionaries and desperate on the lowliest and the lost,
and on those who have turned delinquent, because society by is
continued maltreatment, cultural perversion and environmental pollution
has made them so. The villain of the peace, in the larger view, is
psychopathic society itself.

Under the article 72 of the constitution, the power of the president


to grant pardons, reprieves, respites or remissions of punishment, is
coupled with a duty, which must be exercised fairly and reasonably.
Under the constitution, the President is required to give full reasons for
rejecting a mercy petition. Such reasons should b fair and be able to
stand the test of judicial review.

Former Chief Justice Chandrachud observed that, the power of the


president is to be applied equally to all condemned persons. He further
observed that it is only the poor and the illiterate who failed to get
reprieves. An illiterate poor poverty stricken persons, facing the
hangman’s noose, could write only one line asking for mercy, while the
rich and educated could effort lawyers, who cite examples of other cases
in seeking relief.

The inefficacy of death sentence as a deterrent is brought out with


characteristic wit by Dr. Johnson, who noted Pick-picketers plying their
trade in a crowd assembled to see one of their member executed.

The United National Committee on Capital Punishment found that


there is no Co-relation between the existence of Capital punishment and
lower rates of crime. Death sentence does not provide any opportunity
for the reformation and reclamation of the offender. The efforts of re-
socialization are frustrated.

Numerous examples are not wanting where and when the extreme
penalty of death has not lowered crime rates in countries where such a
drastic punishment is prevalent. It also needs careful consideration on
the fact that most of the dependents of condemned prisoners take to
leading the life of criminals as they are deprived of their only bread-
winner, protector and guardian for leading a normal life as any other
peace-loving and law abiding citizen.

Considering all the loopholes and debating over the pros and cons
for the extreme punishment of hanging by the noose, it would be
worthwhile to do away with such a mode of inhuman penalty and provide
the prisoner some succour for reformation by abolishing this scourge
altogether and reduce it to the reasonable and tolerable extent.

“Death is a necessary and inevitable end and will come when it will
come,” said Shakespeare, and so let us not hasten it through unsanctified
hands of humans, howsoever high and mighty they may be. ‘Better late
than never’ to do away with such a ghastly act.

K.V.Reddy
President
All India Prison Officers Association
09849904733 / 09440060055
Email:kvreddydsp@yahoo.com

PRISON SECURITY VISA-VIS THE STAFF

When I commenced presenting a paper on prison security, in


whatever angle I thought to cover, it came back to one spot, that is –
PRISON STAFF & THEIR WELFARE.

Without their whole-hearted assistance, their Co-operation, and Co-


ordination, no useful purpose is served in mooting the idea of
modernization of Prisons or enforcing stringent Prison Security.

Hence, I decided to submit a paper from the vision of prison staff


welfare & their role in providing efficient prison security.

Prison is a highly sensitive and utmost security place, where all


types of anti-social elements are sheltered, to wean them away from
normal society and to provide protection to them for reformation.

Prison is one of the isolated intake center, not only for the entire
criminal justice system, but also an abode of first or last resort for a host
of disguised health, Welfare and social problem cases.

Hence, intensive security of a prison is of utmost importance and


the basic requirement being that the prisoners are protected, so that
peace and tranquility in society is also well protected.
Prison in general shall have four walls and a gate. The staff is
adequately required to function the prison and to oversee watch and ward
duties as per norms and procedures.

What the prison staff has to do? The prison staff has to deal with
violent, difficult, dangerous, hardcore, aggressive, sophisticated, political
influential, insane etc types of prisoners.

Everyone desires to treat the prisoners as normal human beings,


but at the same time every-one is oblivious of the fact that the person to
deal with the so called types of anti-social elements is also a human
being. Discipline, dedication to duty, maintaining the highest standards
of integrity are the watch words to provide security and that too for a
prison taking care of different types of criminals, alleged or otherwise.

A famous adage says “Stone walls do not a prison make nor iron
bars the cage, for minds quiet and innocent take that for a hermitage”.
Prisoners are human beings and the security men to protect them are also
humans.

The higher-ups want to impose their orders on the prison staff and
tell them to follow the rules scrupulously. At the same time they are
unmindful of the fact that these orders have to be carried out by human
beings of different dispositions and certainly not mechanically or by a
robot.

Generally, in almost all the places where prisons exist, be it urban


or rural areas, it is usually understaffed as compared to the vast number
of prisoners lodged under various categories. Many a time, the prisons
are overcrowded depending on the crime rate, but the staff providing
security remain un altered and neglected for years, thereby giving a go-
bye to the stipulated jail manual. The prison staff have a great
responsibility to shoulder and follow rules and regulations with equity,
eandour and unbiasedly.

When a prison is built, it will be planned to lodge a certain No. of


prisoners (i.e. authorized accommodation) and staff allotted to the prison
in commensurate with authorized accommodation.

Infact, the prisons are so over crowded that their population is more
than thrice the authorized accommodation, whereas the staff remains far
below the requirement.

For instance, the authorized accommodation of District Jail,


Mahaboobnagar is only 76, whereas the average lock-up of the jail for the
last decade is between 300 and 400.

The staff allotted for watch and ward duties is 18 Warders and 7
Head Warders for 76 prisoners. Though, the figure remain at an average
of 350 prisoners, the authorities concerned never bothered to increase
the staff strength accordingly.

How is it possible, to keep vigilance on 350 prisoners with a meager


staff of 25, out of which 2 have retired, one absentee and 3 usually on
leave. What a sordid state of affairs.

One can well imagine the stress and strain on the staff, to keep the
prisoners safe and provide them security. Certainly, this situation needs
an in-depth thinking and planning.

In the prison where I have the privilege to be a part of


administration, I am to place on record the salubrious surroundings of
greenery with lovely flora, meticulously manicured by the prisoners
themselves, providing amenities normally required by humans inside a
modern palatial building with an open air theatre for holding cultural
shows to the prisoners, an ultra modern kitchen to serve food for them
and mind you, all these manned by the convicts who are well versed in
their respective fields. The only drawback appears to be the staff pattern.
Staffing is a serious problem. The staff receives inadequate pay, lives in
under privileged conditions, works unmindful of any rewards or
recognition. The over all security staff is far below average due to which
they have to perform their duties round the clock in only two shifts
constrained to bear the additional stress and strain due to lack of third
shift staff and it is surprising that the government is turning a nelsons eye
on the aspect of recruiting additional staff. General facilities, living
conditions and pay and allowances of prison staff has to be increased
enormously. Only them we can expect adequate security and discipline
from them.

Compassionate consideration for the prisoner’s plight is well


understandable but at the same time, the feelings of the over-worked
staff has also to be viewed dispassionately. When the authorities pay full
attention to prison security, the staff security also has to be borne in
mind. All of them do have the regular family responsibilities to be
discharged. Some of the grievances faced by the staff needs to be
redressed at some point to ensure that the prison security remains in safe
hands.

Besides the over worked job, monotony due to the ever-growing


prison work, discontentment due to inadequate pay scales, non payment
of essential allowances, inadequate promotional prospects, lack of
periodical staff welfare programmes, no additional incentives like risk
allowance or reward/recognition for exemplary discharge of duties etc.,
are some of the few problems that deserves special attention by the
Government. If these are taken care of to mutual advantage, it will not
only improve standards of security but provide them job satisfaction.

We are proposed to consider the sentimental feelings of a prisoner,


but not seems to appreciable the feelings of our subordinates. This is
strange & nobody pays any attention to the problems of the prison staff,
though fully aware of.

The prison security cannot be exclusively controlled by the higher-


ups and it should be borne in mind that the role of a Warder in prison
security is much more important than the role played by the higher-ups.
When, we are not paying due attention that is deserved to be given to our
subordinates, we cannot expect the staff to work strictly honestly and as
per norms.

In my opinion, whenever we think of the security of a prison, we


have to think of the security of staff, their problems, their feelings as well
as their welfare.

Prison staff are the only isolated staff in the world, with whom no
well meaning person likes to come close. Nobody wants them, but all we
need them to work. No doubt that, those working in prisons, think that,
they might have committed a great sin in their previous birth, to get a job
to guard prisoners.

Lack of facilities, lack of proper monetary returns, lack of influence,


the prison staff is lagging behind all the other departments in their field of
responsibility.

We want them to over work and still not want to pay them
considerably. We do not pay decent or mentable salary to them, despite
asking them to be sincere, honest and scrupulously efficient.

Security of a prison is mainly in the hands of the field staff. If they


are happy and comfort, feel secure and recognized by the society, then
the prisons will be a secured place for unsocial elements in society.

Without solving the basic needs and problems of the staff, there is
no reasoning in providing mental detectors, Walkie Talkies, Closed Circuit
TVs, Arms and Ammunitions to support the security needs.

Security of staff is the security of the prison.

The following are the salient problems of the prison staff:-

1. Poor pay scales


2. Non payment of some essential allowances like holiday leave
payment, extra Earned Leave, extra casual leave etc.
3. Stagnation and very poor promotional prospects.
4. Absence of basic facilities for the staff.
5. Long hours of duty.
6. Unsatisfactory working conditions.
7. No system of rewards or recognition of good work.
8. Lack of confidence, due to threats by influential and moneyed
prisoners and their supporters.
9. Insufficient staff.
10. Growing prison work.
11. Monotony of job
12. Absence of staff Welfare programmes.
13. No risk allowance, etc.

Needless to say, the duties of prison staff is highly sensitive. They


have to handle a good number of law-breakers from different
backgrounds and to ensure their safety and security. Implementation of
correctional and welfare programmes in a sympathetic and human
manner is essential. For this, they require high discipline, motivation and
industriousness to the core.

It is rather difficult to improve the standards of security and


discipline in the jails as long as, so much discontent, dissatisfaction,
frustration and demoralization prevails among the prison staff. It is
therefore necessary that causes for such anomaly are removed soon, so
that the prisons may become more secure and there will be constructive
and meaningful interaction between the staff and the prisoners so that
jails can be made to function on more scientific and modern lines.

The job of jail staff is difficult fully of hazards and personal risks, and
is unpleasant in nature, bereft of glamour or dignity.

The jail staff are virtually prisoners of duty without any holidays or
freedom. They are expected to maintain good physique and be physically
fit to be able to work, round the clock!

The Police handle criminals hardly for a few days, whereas the jail
staff have to handle them till eternity or the prisoners set free by the
courts of law.

The long pending, unimplemented request of the jail staff has been
and is that they should be paid salaries and allowances on par with the
Police Department. Which is a legitimate request and needs to be
implemented forthwith.

There is lack of constructive relationship and mutual confidence


between the higher executive staff and the lower subordinate staff.
Adequate training has to be given to the staff from top to bottom in this
matter to manage themselves as per demands of duty.

They require time bound rotation transfers, so that none can


acquire roots and develop a vested interest.

Short term training programmes has to be arranged frequently for


all ranks of prison staff, so as to enable them to come out of their routine
work, routine mentality and mechanical life and to gain knowledge in
modern methods of prison administration.
Reforms in jails may be an expensive proposition, but even more
may be the detrimental effects, if reforms are no undertaken as per
demands of today.

Security is the primary but not the sole function of prison system.

Some of the prisons are poorly designed, poorly staffed and


practically programmeless, floating like a rudderless boat.

The proportion of prison staff Visa-Vis the inmates in the prison


should be rationalized and some sort of short term training programmes
are to be conducted to relieve them of routine work monotony. The men,
who are all the time expected to be vigilant to provide security within,
have to be treated at par with the protectors of law and order outside. By
and large, their domestic responsibilities have to be protected to keep
their family and children secure. This is a humble opinion after thorough
analysis and authentic feedbacks, with prejudice to none.