Vous êtes sur la page 1sur 14

Highlights in this Issue

Air Berlin Swallows LTU p. 3


Analysis of the LCCs’ Slovakian Market p. 6
SWOT Analysis of European LCCs Industry p. 8
(R)evolution of Ryanair’s Business Model p. 12
The Great Carve Up in the Nordic Sky p. 13
The Low Cost Carriers Analysis Newsletter
AIR SCOOP ANNOUNCEMENTS
EDITORIAL 2007 Ancillary Revenue Airline

I
n the coming months, LCCs’ industry will have many opportu- Conference (ARAC 2007)
nities to meet, exchange ideas and do some networking. Indeed,
this month some of the most influential people in European November 14 and 15 in Frankfurt
low-cost aviation will gather at the French Connect 2007 in La Bau-
le (April 25-27). Then in May, EastEuroLink will bring together key Air Scoop is proud to be media partner of the
players of Air Transport in the region of Central & Eastern Europe ARAC 2007.
in Bratislava (May 4). In June, we will be back in London thanks The Ancillary Revenue Airline Conference
to MarketForce and their annual Low Cost Air Transport Sum- (ARAC) is the first global event in the air-
mit (June 13-14) presenting current issues facing LCCs market and line industry to completely define and deve-
focusing this year on this question: “Where next for the low-cost lop the concept of ancillary revenues. Airline
carriers?” Finally, after the summer break, we will all be back to the Information has teamed up with the leading
World Low Cost Airlines Congress (September 17-19) with a new research consultancy in airline ancillary re-
formula to improve networking. For instance, attendees will know venues, IdeaWorks to produce this ground-
how the climate change debate does affect LCCs industry and what breaking event.
customers really think through live focus groups… At each event,
Air Scoop will be there to discuss with top managers of LCCs, finan- President of IdeaWorks and chairman of
cial analysts, and market journalists. ARAC, Jay Sorensen defines ancillary reve-
nues as “Revenues beyond the sale of tickets
Consolidation of the European LCC market is more than ever on- that are generated by direct sales to passen-
going. The Scandinavian LCC FlyMe had to report bankruptcy and gers, or indirectly as a part of the travel expe-
cancel its flights (p. 13) due to a lack of money to continue opera- rience.” This definition includes the commis-
ting flights. Local competitors such as FlyNordic or Norwegian (p. sions earned by many airlines on the sale of
2) hope to benefit from this collapse and replace some of FlyMe’s hotel accommodations, car rentals and travel
flights. On another market, time is also to strong consolidation: in insurance.
Germany. Air Berlin which already bought its strong partner DBA
last summer has simply swallowed its competitor LTU to become
the fourth airline in Europe (p. 3). On the UK market, FlyBe has
planned a similar growing strategy by acquiring BA Connect, but fa-
ces more concrete difficulties (p. 10). To survive in this highly com-
petitive environment, LCCs have different options. One of them is
to conquer new markets always farer. Central & Eastern Europe is a http://www.airlineinformation.org/confer-
dynamic market, full of opportunities for LCCs, so after the Hun- ences/2007_ARAC/arac_intor.html
garian market (Read Air Scoop March 2007), we have analyzed the
Slovakian market, with its strength and weakness (p. 6). One cur-
rent trend is also to study opportunities of long-haul flights. Many The Budgie Awards 2007
analysts have speculated that Ryanair will offer long-haul flights,
possibly in conjunctions with its Aer Lingus bid. However, such
strategy will definitely affect Ryanair’s business model (p. 12). Ano- The Budgie Awards have been created to
ther issue that will certainly alter LCCs business models is climate recognise the leaders, innovators, creative ta-
change. We notice a clear trend of air travelers changing their flying lents, and pioneers in the global Low Cost
habits because of climate change concerns (p. 14). To get a better vi- Airlines industry.
sion of European LCCs’ market, we have realized of SWOT analysis Due to take place on the evening of the
of it (p. 8). Each month, we will provide a SWOT analysis of a low- World Low Cost Airlines Congress, the
cost carrier, next month we will publish a SWOT of Ryanair). Budgie Awards promises to be a spectacular
event.
http://www.terrapinn.com/2007/budgies

Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
Exclusive Interview of Daniel Skjeldam Daniel Skjeldam
(Director Network and Revenue of Norwegian) Director Network
and Revenue of
Norwegian

Could you please present Norwe- product to it. For instance, we codes-
gian to our readers? What are your hare with other Scandinavian LCC’s
specificities compared to other Eu- on the intra-Scandinavian routes.
ropean LCCs? What do you do bet-
ter than your competitors? Which are the low cost carriers jams at hubs like LHR and FRA and
serving the Scandinavian market? not the least flying with much higher
Norwegian is Scandinavia’s largest Who are your most dangerous com- load factors. Traditional airlines with
LCC with 5,2 million customers in petitors: local LCCs or “Islanders” business cabins and low density sea-
2006 and 22 aircrafts. It is the lar- (Ryanair and easyJet)? ting focus on business-yield Vs filling
gest carrier on international flights and standing in line at LHR for hours
from Norway. We fly a many high The largest LCCs in Scandinavia apart are the worst threat to the Environ-
frequency routes on the domestic from ourselves are Sterling and Fly- ment.
network with up to 14 daily round- Nordic who are Scandinvian-based,
trips. To achieve this, we have built and Ryanair with a base in Stoc- Many LCCs look after extra-reve-
a product with emphasis on an ef- kholm and a number of routes from nues to offset the low price of their
fective airport product. For instance, Norway and Denmark. Air Berlin, tickets. What are the projects of
you can go directly to the gate with easyJet, WizzAir, Sky Europe and Norwegian in terms of Extra-reve-
your creditcard or barcoded travel- Germanwings also operate to Scan- nues?
document on any domestic airport dinavia – but on a smaller scale. On
if you only have a hand-luggage. On the domestic and intra-scandinavian As most LCC’s we sell hotels, rental
the international network, we mainly network, we compete a lot with the cars, insurances and other things on
focus on primary airports, but we fly SAS, whereas on the leisure-routes our website. In addition we have im-
to secondary airports where it’s sui- we compete with a number of car- plemented assigned seating for a fee
table for our customers. We have a riers. Though, having a very strong of EUR 3,5 as well as a luggage fee.
very effective flight-program, with brand in Norway, and operating al- On domestic flights we also take car-
20 minutes turnaround and up to 12 most 90 routes from this market, go on the last flight of the day, where
daily sectors per aircraft. puts us in a very comfortable posi- we have a little more generosity in
tion as opposed to airlines having a the schedule.
You already cover many routes smaller position in the market.
between Norway and European Do you believe that consolidation
main cities. Do you plan to deve- The European Low cost carriers of the market will lead to 2-3 main
lop new routes within the Scandi- market has reached a certain ma- LCCs in Europe, or do you think
navian market; are there sufficient turity which leads to its consolida- there will always be many LCCs on
population catchment areas to open tion. During this transition, what niche markets?
new routes in Scandinavia? If not, are, for you, the greatest threats to
towards which market do you tend European Low cost carriers? Fuel I believe it’s quite difficult to achieve
to? rising? Overcapacity? Evolution of a low cost level with a small number
airports? Regulation?... of aircrafts. For ourselves, we didn’t
Most of our network originates out make profits until we reached 15 air-
of Norway, but we’ve also built a In my opinion the greatest threat craft. I believe there is room for more
base with two aircrafts in Warsaw, towards LCCs in Europe are stupid than 2-3 LCCs in Europe, but not for
and we also fly 4 routes out of Stoc- ideas and regulations from EU that the around 50 LCCs flying in Europe
kholm. The catchment area in Scan- could limit further traffic growth. Of today.
dinavia is smaller than in other Eu- course the Environmental side is an
ropean regions, but population flies issue we need to follow closely, but During last World Low Cost Airli-
more due to both topography of the LCC’s in general should have a huge nes Congress, you expressed your
area and distance from the rest of advantage over traditional airlines, worries about the shortage of pi-
Europe. Though, by having a smaller with LCC’s having newer fleets, hi- lots and crew hitting LCC market?
catchment area you have to adapt the gher seating-density, avoiding traffic- Could you explain us your point

2 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
of view on this situation and what we don’t face any significant challen- our main-airports, with huge cost-sa-
Norwegian does to face such pro- ges at the moment. vings over the old one we used. Ope-
blem? rationally we have hedged part of the
What are the options for Norwegian fuel-purchases for the upcoming pe-
I believe the airline industry will face to transform its business model in riod and are striving towards the 900
the challenge of very low rates of order to make more costs savings? limit for our pilots and cabin-crews.
new pilots trained in the period after Aircraft utilization is now 12 hours
2001, but that supply and demand We have a continuous focus on cost plus in the Summer Program by im-
will take care of this in the longer savings in all areas. Recently we have plementing more red-eye flights to
run. I don’t think the industry faces implemented a new reservation-sys- offset the challenge that many short
a problem regarding cabin crews. For tem that gives us a very competitive sectors flights poses to the utiliza-
ourselves, we have a lot ex-pat pilots distribution-cost. We have also just tion.
wanting to return to the region, and implemented a new DCS-system on

Air Berlin Swallows LTU to Grow Worldwide


Where exactly is Air Berlin flying to? In May 2006, Ger- very competitive European air transport market, growing
many’s first LCC was introduced on the stock exchange quick and big is the best way to survive. This is particu-
to finance its expansion plans. Less than one year later, it larly true in Germany, where the market entered a phase
swallowed two of its challengers in the German air trans- of consolidation. By buying LTU, Hunold not only ma-
port business. First, it was DBA, in august 2006. And now, kes his company the fourth airline in Europe, behind Air
at the end of March 2007, the fifty-years-old charter airline France-KLM, Lufthansa and Ryanair. He also expects
LTU, paid cash 140 million Euros. Air Berlin will soon is- to make important savings - between 70 and 100 million
sue 250 million Euros in new shares and convertible bonds Euros - and to settle down in Düsseldorf (West of Ger-
to finance this operation. The company also plans to buy many), where LTU is based, « the second most important
49% of the small Swiss airline Belair. catchment area in Europe after London », Hunold said.

Last summer, Air Berlin was operating less than 60 air- The takeover of LTU by Air Berlin was a coup de thea-
crafts. They are now more than 100, and at least as many tre in the German sky. At the beginning of March, LTU’s
are on the order form. former main shareholder, the businessman Hans Rudolf
Wöhrl, had rather talked about negotiations with Condor,
By buying DBA, a company it had already a strong par- the other long-haul German charter airline. But a merger
tnership with, Air Berlin’s goal was to grow and strengthen between those two companies would have been compli-
its position on the German market, make savings and pick cated, since one of Condor shareholders is the national
up DBA’s strong business customers - Air Berlin was more airline Lufthansa (more than 300 aircrafts, 53.4 million
tourist-oriented. The purchase of LTU is far more daring. passengers in 2006), which would certainly have tried to
This charter airline, which carried in 2006 5.75 million block the deal.
passengers on its 26 airplanes, is mainly operating long-
distance flights to North American, the Caribbean, Africa, But for Lufthansa, the Air Berlin – LTU merger may not
Southern Asia, Southern Europe... That is to say, world- be a better solution: after this new purchase, Air Berlin
wide. may really become a threat for the national leader. All the
more that Air Berlin concluded a code-sharing agreement
No European LCC is currently flying worldwide. Long- with Condor, even if in return it stopped its code-sharing
haul flights are said to be more profitable, but also harder with TUIfly.
and riskier to manage. And the existing LCC model (quick
turnaround, minimal level of service, no first class...) fits The funny thing about all this is that Hans Rudolf Wöhrl,
more short-haul flights. However, Air Berlin apparently who is a friend of Joachim Hunold, was already the man
prepares to be the first to grow on the intercontinental who sold him DBA last summer. Each time, the scenario
level. Its close European route network will help the com- was the same: Wöhrl bought the airline, improved its fi-
pany to feed long-haul flights. If this strategy succeeds, the nancial situation – even if LTU is still unprofitable – and
competitive advantage for Air Berlin could be significant. sold it to Air Berlin. So, next time Mr. Wöhrl gets interes-
ted in an airline, be careful...
Joachim Hunold, Air Berlin’s CEO, knows that on the

3 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


DOWN TO EARTH
JetStar Clicks its Way to Ancillary Revenues ‘‘IDEAWORKS AISLE’’

Airline marketing innovation in Australia seems to be as


prolific as kangaroos in the Outback. Independent airline
by Jay Sorensen
Virgin Blue, which now claims a 30% domestic market
(President of IdeaWorks)
share, has introduced many innovations such as its Blue
www.IdeaWorksCompany.com
Zone premium seating, the Velocity frequent flier pro-
gram, and a network of fee-based lounges to serve Austra-
lia’s budget-conscious travelers. Not to be outdone in this
race, to delight consumers with amenities and choices, is
the low cost airline started by Qantas Airways. ple travel experience as the consumer moves through
the booking process. Prior to requesting payment, JetStar
JetStar started flying domestically within Australia du- offers its customers the option to pre-purchase various
ring May 2004 and six months later added medium haul services for delivery on board the flight. This is not an
international flights to Asia. The company promises its uncommon practice among a growing number of airlines
customers “a simple and fresh travel experience, with a seeking to boost ancillary revenues. However, JetStar is
vibrant approach toward low cost travel.” JetStar recently unique because of the imaginative branding it has applied
introduced its low fare strategy for long haul international to its online sales process.
operations during November 2006. It is among the first
to apply the low cost model to longer flights. The result encourages travelers to click and buy onboard
amenities through the use of whimsical language, tho-
Supported by its existing domestic network, JetStar be- rough descriptions, and pre-purchase discounts. The fol-
gan flights to Bangkok, Phuket, Ho Chi Minh City, Osaka, lowing offer is displayed after a consumer has selected
Bali, and Honolulu. These six international destinations their flights:
are served from the following key Australian gateways:
Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane. Concurrent with this
expansion, the airline adapted its low fare model to better
serve the needs of long-distance travelers.

JetStar’s innovations focus on three marketing areas: pre-


mium class, passenger fares, and ancillary revenues. The
airline acknowledges the importance of premium class
services by including a new StarClass on its international
long-haul flights. This business class style service encoura-
ges higher income consumers to upgrade to greater com-
fort and amenities. StarClass is promoted on the airline’s
web site and is included as a fare option, along with its
JetSaver and JetFlex coach fares.

Consumers seeking maximum savings are prompted to


choose between JetSaver and JetFlex fares during the
reservation process. The airline’s web site allows easy
comparison between the benefits and restrictions of each
with a pop-up page that displays terms and conditions
in a matrix format. As the branding suggests, JetFlex is
priced higher and offers greater flexibility for refunds and
reservation changes; JetSaver fares sacrifice flexibility for The above prices listed are in U.S. dollars and apply to fli-
maximum savings and do not accrue points in the Qantas ghts operated between Honolulu and Sydney. The origin
Frequent Flyer Program. point of the itinerary determines the currency displayed;
Australian dollars are listed for passengers that begin their
travel in Australia. “Feed me! Comfort me! Entertain
JetStar delivers on its promise to deliver a fresh and sim- me!” instantly conveys the consumer benefits of these

4 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
services and focuses attention on a consumer’s natural desire Pre-purchase extra luggage
for self-gratification. While making your booking, you can pre-purchase addi-
tional baggage.
Clicking on the “What’s Available?” links displays the fol- You can pre-purchase excess checked baggage (in addi-
lowing information: tion to your checked baggage allowance) at up to a 20%
discount. Pre-purchased excess baggage is for checked
Feed me! baggage only. For more information, regarding cabin,
Include this option, and you’ll be served meals twice on your checked and excess baggage, please click here. Purchase
flight. Your choice from an international menu designed to of Excess Baggage is non-refundable and non-transfera-
appeal to all tastes. With a choice of freshly prepared Aus- ble.
tralian and local cuisine to keep your hunger satisfied throu-
gh your journey. A drink will also be included to enjoy with Add an additional 1 item (+$60) to my booking.
your meals.

Comfort me! JetStar may have developed the ideal long-haul expe-
On board comfort, that you can take away and use again and rience that appeals to a wide variety of passenger expec-
again. Packed with a stylish amenity kit, blanket and inflata- tations and levels of affluence. Higher-income passengers
ble neck support, it also includes an eyeshade and socks for seeking maximum comfort can choose a fully bundled
when you just choose to ‘switch off’. premium product with more personal space and better
dining and beverages included in the ticket price. Budget-
Entertain me! minded travelers can choose the convenience of a JetFlex
To stay entertained during your flight, select this option and fare and pre-purchase their food, beverages and enter-
we’ll add the latest video on demand unit to your inflight tainment at the time of booking. Ultra-budget travelers
experience. With a range of new release movies, TV shows, can lock in their travel dates with a JetSaver fare and
music videos and kids programmes. Headsets are also inclu- bring their own snacks on board.
ded in the price. Stop, start, rewind, fast forward. The choice
is yours. The airline delivers these choices through a tasteful and
efficient online process. Simple and uncluttered branding
The JetStar web site also displays a copy of its Inflight Menu. seems to be part of the airline’s DNA. However, JetStar
Consumers realize savings when they pre-purchase items at might consider adding more depth to its branding with
the time of booking. Pre-purchase savings are nearly US$2 images to convey the attractiveness of its service offers.
for each of the Comfort me! and Entertain me! offers; the But the airline has clearly designed a click and buy pro-
Feed me! option yields even greater savings. And of course, cess that likely delivers substantial ancillary revenues and
pre-purchase ensures the delivery of services, regardless of provides consumers with the freedom to design their
demand on the flight. own travel experience.

All economy class passengers are provided a complimen-


tary bottle of water at the time of departure. In addition, a Sources used in this article: Unless otherwise noted, the information
described in this analysis were gathered at JetStar.com during Februa-
water fountain and disposable cups are provided on board
ry and March 2007.
for these passengers. All other items, to include a children’s
activity kit, are available for sale during the flight. IdeaWorks cannot guarantee, and assumes no legal liability or res-
ponsibility for the accuracy, currency or completeness of the infor-
The online click and buy process continues with the presen- mation.
tation of checked baggage options. JetStar provides a free
baggage allowance of 2 pieces per passenger on its Hawaii EVENTS
services. Travelers may increase their allowance by one pie-
ce and save 20% on the fee assessed at the airport through
the pre-purchase option. The following offer is displayed
below the Inflight Extras section:

Ancillary Revenue Airline Conference 2007. Ideaworks


co-organizes the event with Airline Information. ARAC
2007 will be held November 14 and 15 in Frankfurt.

5 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
ANALYST PORTHOLE
Analysis of the Slovakian Low-Cost Air Transport Market

The break-up of former Czechoslovakia in 1993 left Slo- convincing, too. Given the relatively small population of
vakia without a single national air transport company. This Slovakia (5.44 million), domestic demand for international
gap was meant to be filled by Slovak Airlines, established flights is limited while international demand may also be
in 1998. However, one of the most successful Central Eu- relatively restricted. It is not a coincidence therefore, that
ropean low-cost air carriers, Sky Europe has claimed the Sky Europe, which gained first-mover advantage and has
right for this title. Since 2002, when Sky Europe began its established reputation for being a low-cost carrier, is able
operation, the company has been gradually growing and to be a quasi- monopol player in this market. Based on
nowadays is dominating the Slovakian air transport mar- the winter timetable of 2006 and the summer timetable
ket. In this respect, Sky Europe has become the Ryanair of 2007, 26 destinations are served from Bratislava by low-
of Slovakia. This is the reason why the analysis of the Slo- cost carriers, and Sky Europe is not present on only two
vakian low-cost market is inseparable from the discussion of them (Frankfurt-Hahn and Nottingham, served just by
of this low-cost carrier. Ryanair)! Moreover, there are only three routes on which
Sky Europe has to face competition from its single rival in
Currently, there are three international airports in the Slovakia, Ryanair (Milan, Dublin and London-Stansted).
country that are served by a low-cost carrier: Bratislava,
Košice and Poprad-Tatry. Bratislava is by far the most signi- A look at the passenger numbers of the top destinations
ficant of these, since the bulk of the traffic is concentrated in 2006 (Figure 2) clearly shows that there is not much
at this airport. Košice is served only by Sky Europe, daily opportunities left for new entrants on already established
domestic flights connect the city with Bratislava. Similarly, routes (2).
Poprad-Tatry, which is a popular tourist resort, is served
solely by Sky Europe, regular flights are offered to London-
Stansted.

London proved to be the most popular destination with


almost 400 thousand passengers, however, on October 1st,
2006, easyjet had to withdraw its flight on the London-Lu-
ton route, as it was financially not viable, according to the
As a consequence, the capital of Slovakia with approxima- spokesperson of the company. In other words, easyJet was
tely 430 thousand inhabitants almost exclusively attracts not able to bear the fierce competition on this route posed
the whole air traffic to the country. The annual number by Sky Europe and Ryanair even though the 9 months of
of total passengers at Bratislava airport shows a dynamic serving this route in 2006 were enough for the 8th posi-
growth and as Figure 1 suggests, the multiplication of pas- tion in terms of passenger turnover. In this list of top 15
senger turnover after 2002 is mainly due to the entry of destinations, Prague and Munich are those cities which are
the low-cost carriers (1). In 2006, 1.93 million passengers not served by low-cost carriers, although they show quite
landed or departed from Bratislava, 94% of them travel- substantial traffic.
led on international routes. The share of low-cost carriers
from the passengers is very high, Sky Europe carried 48% These routes might be potentially viable for low-cost car-
of total passengers, Ryanair took 24% and lastly, easyJet riers to serve in the future but only if they are able to un-
reached a mere 3.28%. The low-cost carriers, therefore, are dercut the prices of the incumbents.
dominating the Slovakian market, and especially Sky Eu-
rope has taken the lead. Nevertheless, entry to new routes or expansion by the
already present low-cost carriers is still possible. Only 13
However, in spite of the dynamic growth, the size of the European countries are served from Bratislava (25 destina-
market is still small and its potentials are not particularly tions in total) by the two low-cost carriers and out of these

6 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
some are surprisingly underrepresented (Figure 3), while to increase the catchment area of Bratislava airport and the
the number of connections to Central and Eastern Europe domestic flights from Košice to Bratislava are scheduled
are also very limited. Especially Germany, the Scandinavian in a way that all destinations from Bratislava are possible
states and Poland are those markets which could be consi- to reach from Košice as well. Another issue is the proxi-
dered as possible new destinations. mity of Vienna airport (Austria) to Bratislava, which in-
duces rivalry between the two airports. In this respect, it is
a remarkable development that on 19th December, 2006,
Sky Europe opened its fifth operation base in Vienna. The
company will soon offer 16 destinations from the new base.
The big overlap between these destinations and those ser-
ved from Bratislava suggests that a „division of labour” mi-
ght be introduced and certain destinations may be served
only from one of the airports in the future.

At first sight, it seems that Sky Europe is cannibalising its


business by serving the same destinations from rival airports,
thus posing a potential threat of competing away passen-
gers. However, it is also a sensible business decision since
All in all, the relatively small potentials of the Slovakian with this strategic movement, the company will be able
market in terms of domestic and international demand pose to control traffic from Vienna thereby securing the home
a limit to all planned expansions. It is enough to compare market, and at the same time with the shuttle bus service
the passenger turnover data with nearby Budapest: concer- already operating between the airports, the catchment area
ning all flights, the airport of the Hungarian capital served of both airports can be increased or even joined.
8.27 million passengers last year, while, as already mentio-
ned, Bratislava served only 1.93 million passengers. Howe- What seems to be a conclusion from this analyis is that
ver, regarding passengers flying with low-cost carriers, the given the highly concentrated nature and limited demand
difference is not so enormous. This figure for Bratislava in of the Slovakian air transport market, the first-mover Sky
2006 was approximately 1.46 million passengers, while for Europe may be the dominant player in the long run and
Budapest it was 2.2 million. This also clearly demonstrates new low-cost carriers may not find the country attractive
how significant role the low-cost carriers play in the Slova- enough to enter unless they open up new routes and serve
kian market. new destinations.
1. Source: www.airportbratislava.sk/flashContent/default3.html
In spite of this, even for Sky Europe, which is truly the do-
2. Source: www.letiskobratislava.sk/flashContent/prilozene_subo-
minant player in Slovakia, the home market would not be ry/2007-18-01_Prev_vykony_rok-2006.doc
large enough to grow. The airline carried roughly 2.74 mil-
lion passengers in 2006 and out of these only about every
third passenger flew to or from Slovakia (based on market Read our analysis of the
share data). This suggests that the home market may not Hungarian Market in Air Scoop March 2007 and
be the major source of growth for Sky Europe in the long Tcheck Republic LCCs market : Air Scoop May 2007.
run. This is underpinned by the fact that Sky Europe tries

Low-Cost Carriers and Websites Awards


Wanderlust Magazine has honored FlyBe with its 2007 Travel Awards. The
award is based on both readers’ votes and customer satisfaction, and places Fly-
Be above other carriers making it the best airline website in the UK. Mike
Rutter, CCO of FlyBe, commented: «For FlyBe.com to be recognized as the best
airline website is a great honor for us, especially as the awards take customer
satisfaction into account. (…) We look forward to building on this success and
hopefully featuring again in next years awards.»
However, according to Hitwise, a market research firm, easyJet.com website is the most po-
pular travel website in the UK. Hitwise has gathered data from more than 8 million British
Internet users and found easyJet.com to be the 5th most searched-for brand online. In 2006,
more than 98 per cent of total sales of easyJet came through its website. Andrew Berks, Band
communication manager, pointed out that “easyJet is committed to further developing its on-
line products in the future.”
7 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com
BIRD’S EYE VIEW
SWOT Analysis of Low Cost Carrier Industry SWOT TEAM

Air Scoop launches a new range of articles called ‘SWOT Team’. Each month, we will publish a SWOT analysis of an
European low-cost carrier. In this issue, we start with a global SWOT of the market.

Air travel in the 21st century is becoming an economic change their business models. The most significant achieve-
necessity and not a luxury. It has been predicted that by ment for the LCCs, especially in the EU, is that they have
2010, business and leisure passengers will increase to 2.3 brought air travel within easy reach of everyone across Eu-
billion worldwide (from 1.6 billion today) of which a ma- rope and changed people’s leisure and travel habits.
jor share will be enjoyed by the Low Cost Carriers. LCCs
had a share of 17% of the total number of scheduled seats Issues: But the story has not been of continued success.
on offer worldwide in 2006. It was 24% within Europe. Some LCCs suffer from low employee morale. This in
turn leads to poor customer service. LCCs are often ac-
The low-cost model, based on Southwest Airlines’ succes- cused of misleading advertisements, resulting in low cre-
sful formula in the US, has been adopted by leading LCC dibility & image.
players in Europe. The key components of their model
are ticket-less travel, Internet booking, usage of secondary The distinction between LCC and charter services is also
airports, no commission for travel agents, no seat alloca- becoming blurred. Some of them have copied the low
tion or connecting flights, and «no frills» such as in-flight cost airlines by making accommodation, car hire and other
catering (customers pay extra for what they require), no ground services available online through their website, and
business class and lounges. The most profitable routes for effectively unpackaging their own product.
LCCs are less than two hours in duration, allowing maxi-
mum utilization of aircrafts. They started by flying city-
to-city routes but are now increasingly targeting resorts,
although many tend to ignore routes of three hours or lon- SWOT Analysis:
ger. They often out perform the legacy airlines in operating
performance. The SWOT analysis given below will help LCCs to achie-
ve their goals by capitalizing on potential opportunities
Overview of the European LCC market: using their strengths and eliminating their weaknesses &
threats.
Growth: Demand for low cost air services was up 9% in
the last quarter of 2006 and the number of LCC flights in- The goals of a low cost airline can be:
creased by 18%. In a single decade, low-cost carriers (LCCs)
have transformed the European aviation scene beyond re- � Expansion and diversification
cognition. The UK is the largest and most mature market � Long-term growth planning
for low cost carriers in Europe, followed by Germany and � Competitive combats
Spain, which is now seeing the fastest growth. � Development of the most suited business model

The enlargement of the EU to include more nations has Target audiences for this analysis are members of the avia-
given LCCs renewed impetus, with many new services tion industry, such as:
starting in Central and Eastern Europe as a result of the
deregulation that EU membership brings. Central and Eas- � boards of airlines
tern Europe is a key growth area. � airports
� aviation suppliers
Impact: LCCs have opened up direct services between EU � air navigation providers
cities that were not available through the legacy airlines � investment companies, and
and popularized regional airports by breathing life into the � government agencies
otherwise under utilized airports.

They have forced established airlines and tour operators to

8 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW

9 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
Some of the factors mentioned above may not be applica- a decade, as it has happened in the US & UK. Hence, the
ble to all members of the LCC industry. The relevance of LCC players should plan to enter the fast growing markets
these factors will depend on the business models and goals of Middle-East and Asia, at the earliest.
of the players. 4. High employee morale is key to customer retention.
The business philosophy of LCCs should be ‘smile, charge
and serve’. Employee satisfaction and customer loyalty are
Recommendations for Low Cost Carriers: invaluable for any business to succeed in the long term.
5. Cost cutting may be further achieved by applying lean
1. Some innovative schemes should be adopted to attract operating techniques and standardized processes.
the increasing number of small & medium business trave-
lers. This would definitely enhance the market share and
build brand image. It seems inevitable that the growth rates of recent years
2. The LCCs should expand into medium haul routes, with will slow down, except in Central and Eastern Europe
the same “no-frills” formula, thus adopting an offensive where there is still untapped potential. The larger LCCs
strategy rather than a defensive one. This will keep the have an opportunity to expand into new markets and eat
traditional players busy protecting their turf and restrict into the market share of legacy airlines and tour operators.
their encroachment into the LCC market. Some consolidation is likely to happen in the LCC market,
3. The European markets are expected to saturate after at the expense of smaller operators.

How to Get to Go from Edinburgh Now?


When BA Connect is finally disconnected from BA and Passengers on the cancelled flights were offered alterna-
is acquired by FlyBe fellow, Scots are really puzzled with tive flights (some of which will take much longer now)
the future of air travel in their home town, Edinburgh. So or full refund. Anyhow there will be certain destinations
are the townsfolk of Glasgow, Manchester, Birmingham, affected a lot, like Birmingham – Barcelona or Manchester
and Bristol. – Madrid, as well as some domestic flights such as from/to
Edinburgh, for example.
The acquisition project was announced first in Novem-
ber 2006 but due to certain legal difficulties and prepara- BA had cancelled more than 1000 flights before the ac-
tion and legalization of all documentation needed it was tual acquisition was completed to reduce severe losses as
completed in the beginning of March this year. Difficulties soon as possible. However, FlyBe estimates the economic
meant not only legal process and money issue but future capacity of the newly merged airline rather high looking
of personnel affected as well as passengers. That’s why the forward to taking over the regional market in two years.
final date for the acquisition was moved several times. With the acquisition FlyBe got in toto 152 routes which
brings the airline on the top of the list of European regio-
Initiated as a measure of cutting losses on regional routes, nal airlines. The future would be really bright save for two
BA Connect appeared to be a greater loss itself. BA re- things: Ryanair and easyJet. Those are the biggest and
ported to lose approximately £100,000 a day. Offloading triumphant LCCs operating in the region that serve about
the subsidiary to FlyBe has both positive and negative im- 200 destinations all over Europe. Needless to say it makes
pact on BA. Undoubtedly, such a deal is just a weight off really hard for FlyBe to be “original” in this case and open
BA’s mind and pocket. On the other hand, BA is now wi- a competitive route for a competitive price.
thdrawn from regional market and is likely to evolve into a
pure business/first-class long-haul airline. Though expres- BA Connect is not the first regional project that was ter-
sing aggressive expansion strategy, FlyBe decided not re- minated. GO once shared the same fate and was sold off
open some of the routes to smaller UK airports cancelled by BA to 3i company in June 2001.
by BA Connect which means not only passengers affected
by also huge job losses, especially amongst managers and
ground handling personnel. Staff members are offered re-
employment with BA or FlyBe but there is no guarantee
that everyone will get a job. The merge affected about
700 positions which found a critical respond from Trade
Unions. There is a real threat of strike during the Easter.

10 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


DOWN TO EARTH
Airports Growth with LCCs?

Airports roll out no-frills red carpets to lure low-cost car- lection of Skavsta as its ninth Scandinavian base has bene-
riers. What can LCCs do for them? fited the airport to share the growth of LCC. When civil
aviation was still overshadowed in 2003 by September 11,
European aviation sector was struck by yet another Euro- Skavsta already reported positive growth: “it is expected
pean Union queries over suggested illegal state aid. Irish that passenger numbers would jump from 300,000 to 1.5
Independent reported British and Derry governments million in 2003. The airport handled 96,000 passengers in
would be questioned over its deals with Ryanair con- May, up from 86,000 the month before, and expected the
cerning an agreement inked in 1999 guaranteed Ryanair number to rise to 106,000 in June.”
GBP250,000 a year from a consortium of four state-fun-
ded authorities on both sides of the Irish border to pro- Tourism was the first to feel the difference from Skavsta
mote its Derry to London route. receiving Ryanair. The nearby city of Nyköping began to
A range of other taxpayer-subsidiesed benefits included reap the economic benefits of Ryanair’s expansion. This is
free landing, navigation, air control, security, baggage and further confirmed by a report released by Jones LaSalle
passenger charges. All legal issues aside, what ushers in the Hotels in November last year. The report said that since
scene is to what extent LCC is important to an airport’s the introduction of budget airlines in Stockholm in 1997,
operation, status and finances that European airports are figures have shown an upsurge in overnight stays from 5.8
striving to meet the hard-line low-cost tactics. million in 1997 to 7.4 million in 2005. Growth in tourism
was especially strong after the announcement by Ryanair
September 11 changed the equation in civil aviation lands- to open Skavsta airport as their Scandinavian base. Since
cape even in Europe. Many airports lose a significant then, international over night stays have shown an average
amount of traffic since then. Since traditional aviation seg- growth of almost 10% per annum.
ment of full services for major airlines was under pressure,
airports started to shift their attention to grow revenues Although the emergence of LCC does usher in strong
from no-frills segment. In 2003 which was merely two growth in revenues and tourism to the airport and res-
years after the trauma, it was estimated LCC represented pective city, it should be noted that LCC’s blatant cost
a 12% year-on-year increase to 20% of the European air controls can also threaten airport’s growth. Dispute broke
travel market. To be LCC friendly is not only desirable between Ryanair and Skavsta when the airport planned
and, in many ways, necessary for airports’ survival. to levy a new safety charge in 2005. The Jones LaSalle
report also detailed the Swedish Government’s proposal
Since the trend of traveling with LCC is growing among to introduce a new airport tax could possibly slow growth
domestic travelers in Europe, LCC do not only fly on the in tourist numbers and affect the hotel industry which
wings of operational profit and retail revenue to the air- already has several new hotels currently in the pipeline
ports but also tourism to the city and the neighboring re- and expected to open in the next 3 years, as new airport
gion. Sweden’s Stockholm Skavsta Airport is one of the tax means higher cost for the passenger but less profit for
early bloomers capturing the growth of LCC on the conti- LCC.
nent. According to Invest in Sweden Agency, Ryanair’s se-

The 4th French Connect takes place on 25-27th April 2007 in La Baule. This unique event offers you the op-
portunity to network with some of the most influential people in European Low Cost aviation.
French airports, the legislators and Europe’s low cost operators all in one place with first-class conference faci-
lities, superb hotels and dining and a relaxed, entertaining business environment : book your place today!
For further information, please check www.frenchconnect.net

11 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
Exclusive Analysis for Air Scoop

www.airlinebulletin.com
(R)evolution of Ryanair’s Business Model (part 1)
Ryanair has projected ambitious growth targets for the lacked nonstop service to Western Europe. If Ryanair
next five years. By 2012, the airline plans to carry 85 million expanded service in Western Russia, it would likely have
passengers a year, up from 42.5 million in 2006. However, a similar effect on many smaller airports in the country.
in order to meet this target, Ryanair will have to change Ryanair has already adopted some medium-haul routes.
its business model to meet the needs of more travelers. For example, Ryanair started service to Morocco last
Some have speculated that Ryanair will offer long-haul year, where it committed to serving up to 20 routes within
flights, possibly in conjunction with its Aer Lingus bid, five years. While flights between Marseille and Morocco
as well as flights to larger airports closer to city centers. weren’t successful, flights between the UK and Morocco
While Ryanair will probably not fly transatlantic flights, have been. Ryanair also has medium-haul opportunities in
it will need to target longer routes, as well as flights to lar- North and West Africa, the Middle East, including Israel,
ger airports closer to city centers if it wants to meet those and other former Russian non-EU states, such as Ukraine
growth targets. or Georgia.

Many observers believe that Ryanair’s bid for Aer Lingus But, while medium-haul flights would give Ryanair many
is a maneuver to get the company into the long-haul avia- opportunities to expand its services, it could also lead to
tion market. However, Ryanair CEO Michael O’Leary problems. If Ryanair’s planes were flying fewer passengers
recently said in the German newspaper Sueddeutsche per day, then ancillary revenues may decrease. On a ten-
Zeitung that the bid is “rather unlikely” to succeed. Rya- and-a-half-hour round-trip (approximately five hours each
nair is unlikely to deviate from its no-frills business model way with 25-30 minutes turnaround time), Ryanair only
in the coming years, because that enables the carrier to has a potential market of 378 customers for its ancillary
maintain the lowest costs of any airline in Europe. Expan- products (up to 189 passengers each way), while Ryanair
sion into long-haul markets complicates Ryanair’s simple could fly more than two two-hour round-trips in the same
business model, and it would almost certainly increase amount of time, doubling the number of potential custo-
costs. Ryanair’s available seat mile costs would increase mers who could utilize ancillary revenue products. Conse-
because it would have to add a new aircraft type to its quently, this may decrease Ryanair’s revenues per available
fleet, it would likely have to increase seat pitch on long- seat mile, because although longer segments could generate
haul planes, it might have to facilitate connections at bases higher fares, they would decrease the importance one of
such as London Stansted, and it would run into more com- Ryanair’s most profitable revenue source. Also, if Ryanair
petition, particularly if it opened routes already operated flew more medium-haul routes, it would be flying fewer
by charter carriers such as Monarch or First Choice. segments and it would need more planes to increase its
passenger loads to 85 million a year, than if it were just to
But if Ryanair chose not to operate long-haul flights, and focus on shorter segments. But another lingering difficulty
instead focus on medium-haul flights, between 4 and 6 that Ryanair may have in adopting a medium-haul stra-
hours in length, the airline could operate them with its tegy is regulatory issues. Ryanair has been able to expand
737-800 aircraft. While longer flights deviates from Rya- quickly within EU states because it faces few regulatory
nair’s established business model to operate quick 1-3 hurdles when opening a new route. But Ryanair encoun-
hour flights, operating medium-haul flights could allow tered much greater hurdles when entering Morocco, whe-
Ryanair to increase its aircraft utilization. This could be re it took the airline six months of negotiations to reach
accomplished if Ryanair operates many of the flights as an agreement with the Moroccan government. If Ryanair
red-eyes, provided the airline leaves enough time in the expands further into non-EU states, then it could delay the
schedule to make up for any delays or maintenance. This opening of new routes while terms are negotiated. That
model opens up many opportunities for Ryanair to serve could enable competitors to wield their influence with
markets that badly need competition. Ryanair succeeded foreign governments to deny Ryanair’s application, or to
beautifully in Poland where the airline significantly lowed at least stall Ryanair’s arrival, enabling foreign carriers to
fares and expanded service to many smaller markets that adapt to changing passenger needs.
Sam Sellers provides analysis and commentary on the airline industry at his website,
www.airlinebulletin.com, and is the author of Take Control of Booking a Cheap Air-
line Ticket, an ebook for travelers in the United States who are interested in purchasing
cheap airline tickets.

12 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


DOWN TO EARTH
The Great Carve-Up in the Nordic Sky
Friday night, 2 March, Swedish mobile network operators This lack of money has been a hotly debated issue in Swe-
were probably heavily loaded as Swedish low-cost carrier den. Some Swedish periodicals assumed other reasons for
FlyMe was sending more than 2500 SMS to its passen- the unexpected economic failure than just red flights. In
gers reporting of bankruptcy. The airline flights to three September 2005 Christen Ager-Hanssen, FlyMe finan-
domestic and 15 international destinations were cancelled cier and the owner of Cognition, bought out shares in the
though the staff was not aware of it until the first check- company from Iceland’s Fons and basically took over the
in. carrier. He is known as a financial scam artist who has 60
mln SEK of tax liability. And he was that very person who
As explained by the company’s board, FlyMe does not did not comment on FlyMe bankruptcy.
have enough money to continue operating flights. The
whole question is about a considerable sum of money that Interestingly, the airline who announced to replace FlyMe
was to be paid by the LCC to its bank. The airline’s par- flights was Sterling, the one FlyMe wanted to buy once.
tner bank, Handesbank, decided not to continue transac- Sterling promised to take care of passengers and to carry
tions as it had 60 MSEK on blocked accounts as insurance them free of charge within Sweden and at a cut rate of 200
claims from passengers. In case FlyMe had demonstrated SEK within other Europe. The airline did not charge those
payments and closed all the right issues, the bank would who just needed to travel back home.
have resumed operations. Unfortunately, at that moment
FlyMe did not have enough means to pay off. Finn Thau- Obviously, rivals are not that sorry for the company as
low said to Swedish Aftonbladet that the company lacked passengers are. Some of them have already expressed
33,7 mln SEK. Before the deadline set by Handesbank their happy feelings. As reported by Finnish Kauppale-
there were some hopes for certain investments but the hti Online, Maunu von Lueders, FlyNordic CEO, hopes
company did not receive any. Though it was rather pro- to benefit from FlyMe collapse and replace some of its
fitable it had experienced some economic difficulties for flights. Apparently, Mr. von Lueders looks forward to
a long time. Its strategy was to expand as fast as possible. Stockholm-Gothenburg route that was literally in FlyMe
Obviously, those 11 new routes opened in a short period hands. He also expects improvement in the overall situa-
of time did not bring expected profit. That makes us to tion as the cutthroat competition in the region might get
recall that sometimes less is more. The matter of FlyMe less tense after one of the major players left the field.
collapse is now handled by Rickard Ström, an attorney
at Lindahl KB law firm, and is investigated by Swedish Read our Exclusive Interview of Finn Thaulow, CEO of
National Economic Crimes Bureau. FlyMe, in Air Scoop March 2007.

EVENTS
2nd Air Transport Conference for CSEE

Air Scoop is proud to be media partner this year again of the 2nd Air Transport Conference for CSEE.
Following the success of our Inaugural event last year, this year we are continuing in dealing with the issues Air Transport
is facing in this region. This is a unique opportunity to meet face-to-face with Key Players in this sector and discuss what
additional strategies you can easily implement to empower your business development.
http://www.transport.easteurolink.co.uk/air_Upcoming.html

13 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com


BIRD’S EYE VIEW
Air Travelers’ Habits Evolve Due to Climate Changes
John Valentine, an environmental campaigner founded the site www.fli-
ghtpledge.org.uk which invites travelers to take a pledge to stop flying al-
together or restrict themselves to one long-haul or two short-haul flights a
year. So far 1.240 people have given the undertaking, with nearly two-thirds
(776) giving the «gold» pledge not to fly anywhere for a year. John Valentine
said:”There is a need among people to be able to do something positive to
cut their carbon emissions and reducing flying is the most obvious and signi-
ficant way of doing it.” The popularity of this website combined with global
environmental concerns has an impact on air travelers’ habits.

A research for the aviation industry estimates that up to 3% of regular flyers


in Britain have stopped boarding flights because of concerns about the en-
vironmental impact. A previous unpublicized a survey for the British Air
Transport Association (BATA), found that a further 10% of flyers had
decided to reduce their travelling by air because of climate change concerns,
and 35% had changed their flying habits.

Air Scoop is a Registered Trademark of Global Wings Publications.


Subscription to Air Scoop: 290 euros for 1 year (10 issues)
Copyright 2006-2007 - Unauthorized distribution or reproduction is forbidden.
http://www.air-scoop.com ; http://airscoop.blogspot.com (free portal news)

14 Air Scoop - April 2007 www.air-scoop.com

Vous aimerez peut-être aussi