LIGHT LIGHT- -FRAMED FRAMED MULTI MULTI- -STORY RESIDENTIAL STORY RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS BUILDINGS Samuel Shiotani, S.E. Samuel Shiotani, S.E. Douglas Hohbach, S.E. Douglas Hohbach, S.E. J oaquim Roberts, S.E. J oaquim Roberts, S.E. Woodworks March Woodworks March 2009 Seminar 2009 Seminar SEISMIC ANALYSIS OF SEISMIC ANALYSIS OF LIGHT LIGHT- -FRAMED FRAMED MULTI MULTI- -STORY RESIDENTIAL STORY RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS BUILDINGS CHALLENGES CHALLENGES Diaphragm behavior Diaphragm behavior ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 & 2007 CBC 05 & 2007 CBC requirements requirements Deformation of Deformation of multi multi- -story shear walls to story shear walls to determine appropriate determine appropriate distribution of lateral distribution of lateral forces and building drift forces and building drift BUILDING BUILDING GEOMETRY GEOMETRY TYPICAL FLOOR PLAN TYPICAL FLOOR PLAN Corridor shear walls Corridor shear walls Party shear walls Party shear walls Exterior shear walls Exterior shear walls TYPICAL FEATURE TYPICAL FEATURE Light framed multi Light framed multi- -story residential buildings story residential buildings often have uniformly distributed shear walls often have uniformly distributed shear walls of approximately equivalent of approximately equivalent stiffnesses stiffnesses except except at exterior at exterior sometimes at first floor sometimes at first floor 2 DIAPHRAGM ASPECT RATIO DIAPHRAGM ASPECT RATIO Shear walls Shear walls Diaphragm aspect ratio Diaphragm aspect ratio DIAPHRAGM ASPECT RATIO DIAPHRAGM ASPECT RATIO Shear walls Shear walls Diaphragm aspect ratio Diaphragm aspect ratio DIAPHRAGM BEHAVIOR DIAPHRAGM BEHAVIOR ASCE 7 Section 12.3.1 ASCE 7 Section 12.3.1 Diaphragm Flexibility Diaphragm Flexibility Flexible Flexible Rigid Rigid Semi Semi- - rigid rigid FLEXIBLE FLEXIBLE DIAPHRAGM DIAPHRAGM ASCE 7 Section 12.3.1.3 ASCE 7 Section 12.3.1.3 Calculated Flexible Diaphragm Condition Calculated Flexible Diaphragm Condition diaphragm diaphragm> >2x 2x shearwall shearwall CBC Section 1613.6.1 CBC Section 1613.6.1 Assumption of flexible diaphragm Assumption of flexible diaphragm Toppings <1 inches thick Toppings <1 inches thick Shear walls satisfy drift requirements Shear walls satisfy drift requirements Wood shear walls (no mixed systems) Wood shear walls (no mixed systems) FLEXIBLE FLEXIBLE DIAPHRAGM DIAPHRAGM CONCERNS CONCERNS Underestimates forces distributed to the Underestimates forces distributed to the corridor walls (long walls) corridor walls (long walls) Overestimates forces distributed to the Overestimates forces distributed to the exterior walls (short walls) exterior walls (short walls) Computation of building drift problematic Computation of building drift problematic RIGID DIAPHRAGM RIGID DIAPHRAGM ASCE 7 ASCE 7 D D / / SW SW =0.6 < 2 (Transverse =0.6 < 2 (Transverse Party walls) Party walls) D D / / SW SW =1.3 < 2 (Longitudinal =1.3 < 2 (Longitudinal Corridor/Ext. walls) Corridor/Ext. walls)
3 BENEFITS OF RIGID BENEFITS OF RIGID DIAPHRAGM ANALYSIS DIAPHRAGM ANALYSIS More accurately distribute lateral forces More accurately distribute lateral forces to corridor and party walls to corridor and party walls Approximate building drift Approximate building drift Build three dimensional computer Build three dimensional computer model for analysis model for analysis OPEN FRONT STRUCTURE OPEN FRONT STRUCTURE Width, W Width, W L e n g t h L e n g t h ,
L L OPEN FRONT STRUCTURE OPEN FRONT STRUCTURE Per CBC 2006 Section Per CBC 2006 Section 2305.2.5 Rigid 2305.2.5 Rigid diaphragms diaphragms Length, L, less than 25 feet Length, L, less than 25 feet L/W less than 0.67 L/W less than 0.67 Exception Exception where calculations show where calculations show that diaphragm deflections can be that diaphragm deflections can be tolerated tolerated NORTHRIDGE EARTHQUAKE NORTHRIDGE EARTHQUAKE DAMAGE DAMAGE OPEN FRONT BUILDINGS OPEN FRONT BUILDINGS CUREE WOODFRAME PROJ ECT CUREE WOODFRAME PROJ ECT OPEN FRONT BUILDINGS OPEN FRONT BUILDINGS FINDINGS FINDINGS Better building performance Better building performance will result when seismic will result when seismic forces are resisted locally forces are resisted locally rather than being rather than being redistributed to other portions redistributed to other portions of the structure of the structure CUREE WOODFRAME PROJ ECT CUREE WOODFRAME PROJ ECT OPEN FRONT BUILDINGS OPEN FRONT BUILDINGS FINDINGS FINDINGS Special design attention is needed for Special design attention is needed for transverse walls resisting torsion. transverse walls resisting torsion. Reduce Reduce torsional torsional response by response by providing additional capacity and providing additional capacity and stiffness in transverse and slender stiffness in transverse and slender elements. elements. 4 SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 Deflection (inches) F o r c e
( p l f ) Double-sided 20' Chord Chord Slip Slip SEMI SEMI- -RIGID DIAPHRAGM RIGID DIAPHRAGM Always acceptable, but difficult to Always acceptable, but difficult to calculate for wood panel construction calculate for wood panel construction due to non due to non- -linear load linear load- -deformation. deformation. Suggest using code diaphragm Suggest using code diaphragm deflection equations, modified as deflection equations, modified as necessary for differing boundary necessary for differing boundary conditions. conditions. Suggest using linear approximation Suggest using linear approximation calibrated to code strength values. calibrated to code strength values. LIGHT LIGHT- -FRAMED MULTI FRAMED MULTI- -STORY STORY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PLAN RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PLAN - - Hypothetical Hypothetical LIGHT LIGHT- -FRAMED MULTI FRAMED MULTI- -STORY STORY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PLAN RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PLAN - - Actual Actual 1997 Uniform Building Code 1997 Uniform Building Code Section 1633 Section 1633 Detailed Systems Design Requirements Detailed Systems Design Requirements 1633.2.5 Ties and continuity All parts of a structure shall be interconnected and the connections shall be capable of transmitting the seismic force induced by the parts being connected. As a minimum, any smaller portion of the building shall be tied to the remainder of the building with elements having at least a strength to resist 0.5 C a I times the weight of the smaller portion 1997 Uniform Building Code 1997 Uniform Building Code Section 1633 Section 1633 Detailed Systems Design Requirements Detailed Systems Design Requirements 1633.2.9 Diaphragms 1633.2.9 Diaphragms 7. 7. In structures in Seismic Zones 3 and 4 having a plan In structures in Seismic Zones 3 and 4 having a plan irregularity of irregularity of Type 2 in Table 16 Type 2 in Table 16- -M, diaphragm chords and M, diaphragm chords and drag members shall be designed considering independent drag members shall be designed considering independent movement of the projecting wings of the structure. Each of movement of the projecting wings of the structure. Each of these diaphragm elements shall be designed for the more these diaphragm elements shall be designed for the more severe of the two following assumptions: severe of the two following assumptions: Motion of the projecting wings in the same direction Motion of the projecting wings in the same direction Motion of the projecting wings in the opposing direction Motion of the projecting wings in the opposing direction Exception: This requirement may be deemed satisfied Exception: This requirement may be deemed satisfied if the procedures of Section 1631 in conjunction with if the procedures of Section 1631 in conjunction with a three a three- -dimensional model have been used to determine dimensional model have been used to determine the lateral seismic forces for design. the lateral seismic forces for design. 5 ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Section 12.12 Section 12.12 Drift and Deformation Drift and Deformation 12.12.3 Building Separation 12.12.3 Building Separation All portions of the structure shall be designed and All portions of the structure shall be designed and constructed constructed to act as an integral unit to act as an integral unit in resisting seismic in resisting seismic forces unless separated structurally by a distance forces unless separated structurally by a distance sufficient to avoid damaging contact under total sufficient to avoid damaging contact under total deflection ( deflection ( x x ) as determined in Section 12.8.6. ) as determined in Section 12.8.6. ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Diaphragms, Chords and Collectors Diaphragms, Chords and Collectors 12.10.2 Collector Elements 12.10.2 Collector Elements Collector elements shall be provided that are Collector elements shall be provided that are capable of capable of transferring transferring the seismic forces originating in other the seismic forces originating in other portions of the structure to the element providing the portions of the structure to the element providing the resistance to those forces. resistance to those forces. ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Diaphragms, Chords and Collectors Diaphragms, Chords and Collectors 12.10.2.1 Collector Elements Requiring Load 12.10.2.1 Collector Elements Requiring Load Combinations with Combinations with Overstrength Overstrength Factor for Seismic Factor for Seismic Design Categories C through F Design Categories C through F In structures assigned to Seismic Design Category C, D, In structures assigned to Seismic Design Category C, D, E, or F, collector elements (see Fig. 12.10 E, or F, collector elements (see Fig. 12.10- -1), splices, 1), splices, and their connections to resisting elements shall resist and their connections to resisting elements shall resist the load combinations with the load combinations with overstrength overstrength of Section of Section 12.4.3.2 12.4.3.2. . Exception Exception: In structures or portions thereof : In structures or portions thereof braced braced entirely by light entirely by light- -frame shear walls, frame shear walls, collector elements, collector elements, splices, and connections to resisting elements need only be splices, and connections to resisting elements need only be designed to resist forces in accordance with Section 12.10.1.1. designed to resist forces in accordance with Section 12.10.1.1. ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Table 12.3 Table 12.3- -1 Horizontal Structural Irregularities 1 Horizontal Structural Irregularities C, D, E, and F B, C, D, E, andF D, E, and F R, C, D, E, andF 12.7.3 Table 12.6-1 Section 16.2.2 Nonparallel Systems-Irregularity is defined to exist where the vertical lateral force-resisting elements are not parallel to or symmetric about the major orthogonal axes of the seismic forceresisting system. 5. D, E, and F B, C, D, E, and F B, C, D, E,and F D, E, and F B, C, D, E,and F 12.3.3.4 12.3.3.3 12.7.3 Table 12.6-1 16.2.2 Out-of-Plane Offsets Irregularity is defined to exist where there are discontinuities in a lateral force-resistance path, such as out-of-plane offsets of the vertical elements. 4. D, E, and F D, E, and F 12.3.3.4 Table 12.6-1 Diaphragm Discontinuity Irregularity is defined to exist where there are diaphragms with abrupt discontinuities or variations in stiffness, including those having cutout or open areas greater than 50%of the gross enclosed diaphragmarea, or changes in effective diaphragmstiffness of more than 50%fromone storyto the next. 3. D, E, and F D, E, and F 12.3.3.4 Table 12.6-1 Reentrant Corner Irregularity is defined to exist where both plan projections of the structure beyond a reentrant corner are greater than 15%of the plan dimension of the structure in the given direction. 2. E and F D B, C, and D C and D C and D D B, C, and D 12.3.3.1 12.3.3.4 12.7.3 12.8.4.3 12.12.1 Table 12.6-1 Section 16.2.2 Extreme Torsional Irregul arity is defined to exist where the maximumstory drift, computed including accidental torsion, at one end of the structure transverse to an axis is more than 1.4 times the average of the storydrifts at the two ends of the structure. Extreme torsional irregularityrequirements in the reference sections applyonlyto structures in which the diaphragms are rigid or semirigid. lb. D, E, and F C, D, E, and F B, C, D, E, and F C, D, E, and F D, E, and F B, C, D, E, and F 12.3.3.4 12.8.4.3 12.7.3 12.12.1 Table 12.6-1 Section 16.2.2 Torsional Irregularity is defined to exist where the maximumstorydrift, computed including accidental torsion, at one end of the structure transverse to an axis is more than 1.2 times the average of the story drifts at the two ends of the structure. Torsional irregularityrequirements in the reference sections apply onlyto structures in which the diaphragms are rigid or semirigid. la. Seismic Design Category Applicati on Reference Section Irregul arity Type and Description ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Table 12.3 Table 12.3- -1 Horizontal Structural Irregularities 1 Horizontal Structural Irregularities D, E, and F D, E, and F D, E, and F D, E, and F 12.3.3.4 12.3.3.4 Table 12.6 Table 12.6- -1 1 DiaphragmDiscontinuity Irregularity is defined to exist DiaphragmDiscontinuity Irregularity is defined to exist where there are diaphragms with abrupt discontinuities where there are diaphragms with abrupt discontinuities or variations in stiffness, including those having cutout or variations in stiffness, including those having cutout or open areas greater than 50% of the or open areas greater than 50% of the gross enclosed gross enclosed diaphragmarea, or changes in effective diaphragm diaphragmarea, or changes in effective diaphragm stiffness of more than 50% fromone story to the next. stiffness of more than 50% fromone story to the next. 3. 3. D, E, and F D, E, and F D, E, and F D, E, and F 12.3.3.4 12.3.3.4 Table 12.6 Table 12.6- -1 1 Reentrant Corner Irregularity is defined to exist where Reentrant Corner Irregularity is defined to exist where both plan projections of the structure beyond a both plan projections of the structure beyond a reentrant corner are greater than 15% of the plan reentrant corner are greater than 15% of the plan dimension of the structure in the given direction. dimension of the structure in the given direction. 2. 2. Seismic Seismic Design Design Category Category Application Application Reference Reference Section Section Irregularity Type and Description Irregularity Type and Description ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Table 12.3 Table 12.3- -1 1 2. 2. Re Re- -entrant Corner Irregularity entrant Corner Irregularity See 12.3.3.4 and Table 12.6 See 12.3.3.4 and Table 12.6- - 1for Seismic 1for Seismic Categories D, E, and F Categories D, E, and F 3. 3. Diaphragm Discontinuity Irregularity Diaphragm Discontinuity Irregularity See 12.3.3.4 and Table 12.6 See 12.3.3.4 and Table 12.6- - 1for Seismic 1for Seismic Categories D, E and F Categories D, E and F 6 ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Section 12.3 Section 12.3 Diaphragm Flexibility, Configuration Diaphragm Flexibility, Configuration Irregularities and Redundancy Irregularities and Redundancy 12.3.3.4 Increase in forces Due to Irregularities for Seismic De 12.3.3.4 Increase in forces Due to Irregularities for Seismic Design sign Categories D through F. Categories D through F. For structures assigned to Seismic Design Category D, E or F and For structures assigned to Seismic Design Category D, E or F and having a horizontal structural irregularity of Type 1a, 1b, 2, 3 having a horizontal structural irregularity of Type 1a, 1b, 2, 3 or 4 in or 4 in Table 12.3 Table 12.3- -1 or a vertical structural irregularity of Type 4 in Table 1 or a vertical structural irregularity of Type 4 in Table 12.3 12.3- -2, the 2, the design forces design forces determined from Section 12.8.1 determined from Section 12.8.1 shall be shall be increased 25 percent for connections of diaphragms to vertical increased 25 percent for connections of diaphragms to vertical elements and to collectors and for connections of collectors to elements and to collectors and for connections of collectors to the the vertical elements. vertical elements. Collectors and their connections also shall be Collectors and their connections also shall be designed for these increased forces unless they are designed for designed for these increased forces unless they are designed for the the load combinations with load combinations with overstrength overstrength factor of Section 12.4.3.2, in factor of Section 12.4.3.2, in accordance with Section 12.10.2.1. accordance with Section 12.10.2.1. ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 12.3.3.4 Increase in forces Due to Irregularities 12.3.3.4 Increase in forces Due to Irregularities for Seismic Design Categories D through F. for Seismic Design Categories D through F. design forces design forces shall be increased 25 percent shall be increased 25 percent for connections of diaphragms to vertical for connections of diaphragms to vertical elements and to collectors and for connections elements and to collectors and for connections of collectors to the vertical elements. of collectors to the vertical elements. ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Table 12.6 Table 12.6- -1 Permitted Analytical Procedures 1 Permitted Analytical Procedures P P NP All other structures P P P Irregular structures with T <3.5T,, and having only horizontal irregularities Type 2, 3, 4, or 5 of Table 12.2-1 or vertical irregularities Type 4, 5a, or 5b of Table 12.3-1 P P P Regular structures with T<3.5t and all structures of light frame construction P P P Other OccupancyCategory I or II buildings not exceeding 2 stories in height P P P OccupancyCategory I or 11 buildings of light-framed construction not exceeding 3 stories in height D, E, F P P P All other structures P P P Other OccupancyCategory I or II buildings not exceeding 2 stories in height P P P OccupancyCategory I or II buildings of light-framed construction not exceeding 3 stories in height B, C Seismic Response History Prcedures Chapter 16 Model Response Spectrum Analysis Section 12.9 Equivalent Lateral Force Analysis Section 12.8 Structural Characteri stics Seismi c Design Catego ry ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Table 12.6 Table 12.6- -1 Permitted Analytical Procedures 1 Permitted Analytical Procedures Static Static Analysis Analysis P P P P NP NP All other structures All other structures P P P P P P Irregular structures with Irregular structures with T <3.5T T <3.5T , , , and having only horizontal , and having only horizontal irregularities Type 2, 3, 4, or 5 of irregularities Type 2, 3, 4, or 5 of Table 12.2 Table 12.2- -1 1 or vertical irregularities Type 4, 5a, or or vertical irregularities Type 4, 5a, or 5b of Table 12.3 5b of Table 12.3- -1 1 P P P P P P Occupancy Category I or II Occupancy Category I or II buildings of light buildings of light- -framed construction framed construction not exceeding 3 stories in height not exceeding 3 stories in height D, E, F D, E, F ASCE 7 ASCE 7- -05 05 Table 12.6 Table 12.6- -1 1 No requirement for dynamic analysis is No requirement for dynamic analysis is triggered for any light framed structure of triggered for any light framed structure of 3 stories or less or any structure not 3 stories or less or any structure not exhibiting exhibiting torsional torsional irregularities. irregularities. SEISMIC J OINT FINDINGS SEISMIC J OINT FINDINGS No seismic joints are required for 3 No seismic joints are required for 3- -story or less light story or less light frame building. frame building. ASCE 7 apparently assumes that light frame buildings ASCE 7 apparently assumes that light frame buildings are laterally braced by evenly distributed shear walls of are laterally braced by evenly distributed shear walls of roughly equivalent stiffness. roughly equivalent stiffness. An analysis incorporating diaphragm rigidity is required An analysis incorporating diaphragm rigidity is required for light frame buildings taller than 3 for light frame buildings taller than 3- -stories to identify stories to identify potential potential torsional torsional irregularity. irregularity. An analysis incorporating diaphragm rigidity should be An analysis incorporating diaphragm rigidity should be used for buildings with non used for buildings with non- -uniform distribution or uniform distribution or stiffness of vertical elements (required by code for mixed stiffness of vertical elements (required by code for mixed systems). systems). 7 LIGHT LIGHT- -FRAMED MULTI FRAMED MULTI- -STORY STORY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PLAN RESIDENTIAL BUILDING PLAN Provide uniform distribution of similar stiffness lateral force resisting elements LIGHT-FRAMED MULTI-STORY RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS DIAPHRAGM ANALYSIS RECOMMENDATION Use rigid diaphragm analysis Use rigid diaphragm analysis (use semi (use semi- -rigid as necessary at large diaphragm rigid as necessary at large diaphragm spans or anomalies) spans or anomalies) SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION CBC Section 2305.3.2 CBC Section 2305.3.2 S S = = 8 8 h h 3 3 + + h h + 0.75he + 0.75he n n + + h h d d a a EAb Gt b EAb Gt b SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 Deflection (inches) F o r c e
( p l f ) Double-sided 20' Idealized Double-sided 20' Chord Chord Slip Slip Strength Capacity (defines linear behavior) SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 0.00 0.10 0.20 0.30 0.40 0.50 0.60 0.70 Deflection (inches) F o r c e
( p l f ) Double-sided 20' Idealized Double-sided 20' Chord Chord Slip Slip Strength Capacity (defines linear behavior) Double-sided w/ finishes STACKED SHEAR WALL STACKED SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION DEFORMATION 8 MULTI MULTI- -STORY SHEAR WALL STORY SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION DEFORMATION MULTI MULTI- -STORY SHEAR WALL STORY SHEAR WALL LENGTHS LENGTHS SEAOC Seismology (2007) SEAOC Seismology (2007) Structures depend on Structures depend on longer shear walls longer shear walls SEAOC Blue Book (1999) SEAOC Blue Book (1999) Aspect ratios >2:1 Aspect ratios >2:1 cannot be adequately cannot be adequately predicted predicted H/L=2, H/L=2, L=15ft min. L=15ft min. H=30ft ? THREE THREE- -DIMENSIONAL DIMENSIONAL MODELING MODELING THREE THREE- -DIMENSIONAL DIMENSIONAL MODELING TECHNIQUES MODELING TECHNIQUES Continuous Continuous Stacked Stacked
i i =V =V i i L L i i 3 3 /3E /3EI I i i
T T = = (Vh (Vh i i 2 2 )(3L )(3L T T - -h h i i )/6E )/6EI I T T L 2 L 3 L 4 h 2 h 3 h 4 L T 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 Deformation (inches) F o r c e
( k i p s ) Continuous Stacked CONTINUOUS VS. STACKED CONTINUOUS VS. STACKED SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION SHEAR WALL DEFORMATION I Iavg avg =1,200 in =1,200 in 4 4 I I =10,000 in =10,000 in 4 4 Conservati ve Conservati ve BENEFITS OF BENEFITS OF THREE THREE- -DIMENSIONAL DIMENSIONAL MODELING MODELING Approximate building drift Approximate building drift Distribute direct and Distribute direct and torsional torsional shear forces shear forces Stiffness of non Stiffness of non- -full height shear walls full height shear walls incorporated correctly incorporated correctly 9 3D MODEL 3D MODEL PLAN VIEW PLAN VIEW 3D MODEL 3D MODEL PLAN VIEW PLAN VIEW Assumptions Plywood Type Plywood Thickness Nailing Pattern Chord Size Hold Down Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 I 1 I 2 I 3 3D MODEL 3D MODEL ISOMETRIC VIEW ISOMETRIC VIEW Roof 4 th flr. 2 nd flr. 1 st flr. 3 rd flr. 3D MODEL 3D MODEL ISOMETRIC VIEW ISOMETRIC VIEW 3D MODEL 3D MODEL ISOMETRIC VIEW ISOMETRIC VIEW Assumptions Plywood Type Plywood Thickness Nailing Pattern Chord Size Hold Down CONCLUSION CONCLUSION The appropriate analysis technique for The appropriate analysis technique for light light- -framed multi framed multi- -story residential story residential buildings is rigid diaphragm analysis buildings is rigid diaphragm analysis incorporating multi incorporating multi- -story shear wall story shear wall deformations via three deformations via three- -dimensional dimensional modeling. modeling. 10 Hohbach Hohbach- - Lewin, Inc. Lewin, Inc. Structural Engineers Structural Engineers