Brown 1

Jonathan Brown
English 1102
Adam Padgett
April 8, 2014
The Deceitful Influence of Social Media
Social media is used by almost everyone who has a mobile device or computer. From
children to teenagers to adults, all age groups use it and they are all influenced by it. Although
social media is a great way to network and stay close with friends it can also be very deceitful.
Usually when people post on social media sites they post their opinion through a status or
picture. A common thing that people post are memes:. mMemes are usually made up by a picture
of something or someone and a caption, they are usually created with some kind of alternative
purpose than to just be funny. A lot of these social media statuses and memes consist of people
going all out to support their opinion on a subject. To support these opinions people will say and
post false and insulting information to make the opposing side seem negative or skewed. The
general public would probably see a status could say, The government is just made up of a
bunch of lazy old rich guys who dont even care about anyone. People would read this, and it
would influence them to feel the same way about it. Obviously one hysterical person created this
status to share what they think about the government, when they probably have no idea what is
actually going on inside the government. This opinion based status may seem harmless, but it
will effect anyone else who reads it, then those people will share the status on their social media
pages thus it has the potential to be shared almost exponentially across social media servers.
Suddenly the majority of the country seems to know that the government is made up of lazy,
Comment [AP1]: Compelling title
Comment [AP2]: almost? I think everyone
uses social media via mobile device or
computer.
Comment [AP3]: This meme discussion
doesnt really fit here. it interrupts the flow of
the discussion.
Comment [AP4]: Be careful not to over use
ambiguous language. The word it can be
very unclear.
Brown 2

overpaid, uncaring, old guys who obviously do not have any achievements in life to have earned
their position. I believe that social media is very influential as we know it today and it
negatively affects the public opinion on many different subjects.
Social Media is obviously being used by millions of users for multiple different purposes.
Photographers have their photography business Facebook page, music artists have their band
pages, and celebrities have their promotional pages, but what about politicians and candidates?
By the 2010 midterm elections, 92% of the major party candidates for the U.S. House had
created a campaign website and over three fourths of the candidates had adopted the larger social
media sites such as Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube. (Gulati, Williams) This is a sure sign that
social media is used in the world of politics. An initial review of our data reveals that nearly
every candidate running for the Senate, 64 of the 66 (97%), adopted a Facebook page for 2012.
(Gulati, Williams) By 2012 almost every candidate was using social media to their advantage.
In a democratic society we vote to elect those who represent us. Everyone has their
opinion on who they feel should represent them and who should not. There are two major parties,
the Democrat platform and the Republican platform. Democrats and Rrepublicans often disagree
and argue. What better way do you have to voice your opinion for your party than to do it on a
social media website for people to see? Matthew Kushin says, Persons younger than 30 led the
way, many of whom used the internet to exchange political opinions and post their own political
commentary. There are tons of arguments about politics on social media sites and these
arguments can have a lot of false information because of people who will resort to lying about a
subject to support their opinions. Later in Matthew Kushins article he states Existing empirical
evidence indicates that Internet use is positively associated with political outcomes including
situational political involvement I think he is wrong in this argument for a few reasons. For one,
Comment [AP5]: Yeah I see what youre
saying, but this statement still isnt untrue
Comment [AP6]: Okay, I feel like I get what
your thesis is saying because Ive been closely
watching your idea develop, but I think the
wording here is unclear. What, specifically, do
you mean by negatively affects?
Comment [AP7]: Reconsider the repetition
of the word use here.
Comment [AP8]: Okay, this is all very
interesting, but what is you point? What is the
connection to your thesis?
Brown 3

how can one judge a positive political outcome in elections? Since democracy is based around
an individuals opinion, saying that there is a positive political outcome would only be valid for
the winning candidates supporters. Since the other candidate was not elected he is never given a
chance, so you cannot really be certain that it was a positive outcome or not. In his statement he
says Existing empirical evidence. Empirical: relying on experience or observation alone
often without due regard for system and theory. This is the Websters definition of empirical,
thus you could say empirical evidence is evidence that relies only on experience and observation.
I would not consider this valid evidence that the internet positively effects politics at all.
Memes are personally one of my favorite things about social media. Usually memes are
hysterical pieces of media that individuals create and post to social media websites. They come
in endless quantity and you can find any kind of meme you want, from stick figure memes, to
memes about food, to memes about relationship, and memes about politics. They are usually
always funny and fantastic that is until you are offended. Memes are funny but they can be
very insulting also. One cruel meme about Jesus could upset a Christian. Limor Shifman talks
about a certain video called Leave Brittney Alone where a guy posted a video of him ranting
about Brittney Spears and for the media to leave her alone. The boy was made fun of, his video
was remixed and recorded in cruel ways. The author of this article also states that memes shape
the mindsets, forms of behavior, and actions of social groups. If this kind of insulting behavior
can go on with subjects such as religion and celebrities, which means it must also have an
insulting, false depiction towards politics.
One political based meme is one on Facebook, and probably many other websites. It is
labelled Democrats in the Midwest the picture shows a man standing in snow with two
captions, one above and one below the picture. Before I tell you what the captions say, imagine a
Comment [AP9]: That might depend on
how he uses the word positive
Comment [AP10]: True, but Im getting a
little lost in the what is being meant by
positive still.
Comment [AP11]: Okay, I think that youre
not wrong here. but couldnt you have used a
more current, political example as opposed to
this fairly old one which makes reference to a
celebrity?
Brown 4

simple picture of a man dressed up in warm clothes with a beanie hat on standing in a foot or two
of snow. What can you assume from that picture? Well basically the only things you can assume
is that he is a man with heavy clothing in the snow with his hands in his pockets and nothing else
(you can find the meme at the end of the works cited page). The top caption analyzes the
obvious, it says Wow! Cold. The second caption declares an assumption that is not evident by
any means, it says It was so cold this morning, I actually saw a Democrat with his hands in his
own pockets. By saying this the creator of the meme creates a fabricated idea because he does
not know who the man even is probably or even if he is a Democrat. Memes like this one, and
many others, are deceiving. The meme was probably based around the thought that Democrats
are utilizing taxpayers money in a way that benefits the Democratic supporters through welfare,
medicate, and other kinds of government issued free aid. This could be a decent argument for a
republican such as myself through solid evidence, but to have a meme that shows such an
assumption is a terrible way to show evidence of Democrats taking money from taxpayers, or
you would think so at least. With the exponential spreading tendencies of memes and social
media posts this kind of insulting falsified meme could be seen by millions of people worldwide
and it probably has been seen by millions considering it is also one of the top images on Google
Images when you search political memes. The actions and opinions of people are almost
entirely based around influence and when someone sees a meme like this they can be influenced
to think about a subject entirely wrong by false information. From this inference, if individual
users on social media sites can so easily falsify information then why can politicians not utilize it
in this way? A use of a meme by Senator John McCain on his personal profile (shown below the
works cited page) shows a picture of Orville and Wilbur Wright and their airplane. Obama is in
between them and there is a caption that reads You guys didnt build that! as if Obama is
Comment [AP12]: Yes, but you cant really
see the mans face, plus the photo was likely a
stock photo. The issue isnt really damaging
the reputation of the subject in the meme, it is
the misinformation, right? Also, this meme
sounds no different than political cartoons
that have been in print for hundreds of years.
How is this any different?
Comment [AP13]: How do you know this to
be true? Are you conjecturing here?
Brown 5

downplaying the Wright Brothers achievements. This is an insult towards Obamas campaign.
Just as individuals use these memes as weapons against each others opinions, so do politicians.
Although social media brings people together in a digital community and enhances
political involvement, it can be very deceitful. The spread of viral media can be a fantastic way
to become informed on subjects, but since it can be created by anyone, social media is a very
poor resource to gather information on any subject really. From religion to celebrities to politics,
it can all be insulting and false. Memes can be a great past time to enjoy a laugh or two while
scrolling down the seemingly harmless propaganda it is influencing you in ways you never really
thought possible. These memes and statuses can change your opinion on serious subjects based
around false information and can even leave you insulted.
Jon,
I really like the idea that youre working with here. But Im having difficulty following what
exactly youre trying to say. It seems to me that you are saying political cartoons (more or less)
are bad for public discourse. But Im not seeing deception in any of these examples. Im seeing
rhetoric, which is an important part of public social discourse. So Im not sure what it is exactly
that you are suggesting. But things like misinformation, I feel, is what youre attempting to go
after. I would suggest to check snopes.com or factcheck.org for some examples bad information
floating around the internet (not that you should cite these sources, just that you can find
examples that you can use, if that makes sense).



Comment [AP14]: But this is just classic
rhetoric, right? What is the problem?
Brown 6






Works Cited

"Empirical." Merriam-Webster.com. Merriam-Webster, n.d. Web. 9 Apr. 2014.
<http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/empirical>.
Kushin, Matthew J, and Masahiro Yamamoto. "Did Social Media Really Matter? College
Students' Use of Online Media and Political Decision Making in the 2008
Election." Mass Communication & Society. 13.5 (2010). Print.
Gulati, G.J, and C.B Williams. "Social Media and Campaign 2012: Developments and Trends
for Facebook Adoption." Social Science Computer Review. 31.5 (2013): 577-588. Print.
Gil de Ziga, H., Jung, N. and Valenzuela, S., Social Media Use for News and Individuals'
Social Capital, Civic Engagement and Political Participation. Journal of Computer-
Mediated Communication, April 2012 Ch.17: 319336
Shifman, Limor. "Memes in a Digital World: Reconciling with a Conceptual
Troublemaker."Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication. 18.3 (2013): 362-377.
Print.
Political Memes, Democrats in the Midwest! Credit: leahebae https://www.facebook.com/
(March 11, 2014)
John McCain
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10151097147688707&set=a.1015011371157
8707.294021.6425923706&type=1&theater (4/10/2014)

Brown 7