Phil (244-017): Professional Responsibility Fall 2013
Instructor: D. L. Dillard (Don) Contact: ddillar1@utk.edu
1. Course Leader: Adam Cureton Contact: adamcureton@utk.edu 2. Director of Undergraduate Studies: Dr. Clerk Shaw Contact: jshaw15@tennessee.edu Office Location: Hodges Library (next to Starbucks) Office Hours: (TR) 1:10-2:10, or by apt Class Location: (Dabney-Buehler Hall) BU 472 Class Hours: (TR) 2:10-3:25
[I.] INTRODUCTION In many ways, Professionalism is an activity that reinforces the legitimacy of Professions. When an individual who acts as the representative of a given profession acts in a decidedly un-professional way to a patient or client, then there is a real sense in which that oneunprofessional act may taint the entire profession. A reasonable question can be drawn from this: Is there a duty to conduct oneself in a professional way for the sake of preserving the legitimacy of a profession? Or to express this otherwise, does Professional Responsibility entail a duty to other professionals, to the client/patients, or even the profession itself? It is tempting to think that the answer is obvious: of course one ought to act professionally! However, there are many cases where acting professionally may conflict with other moral duties, religious or political beliefs, or ones conscience, and in such cases one may strongly feel morally obliged to act in ways that are un-professional. And here the answer is not so clear: Does professional responsibility always and in every case trump all other considerations? Thus, the aim of this course is to develop a better understanding of what being a Professional entails by exploring the ethical dimensions of such cases, and thereby develop a better and more complete understanding of the self as a future (or current) professional. [II.] Course Description & Prerequisites Prerequisite(s): While students who have taken Philosophy (101) previously will have a slight advantage over those who have not, there are no prerequisites for taking this course. Catalogue Description: Critical analysis of selected classic texts from philosophy, religious studies, and social sciences dealing with responsibility and the nature of professionalism. Theoretical principles and analytical skills applied to selected case studies and other detailed descriptions of professional practice from engineering/architecture, business/accounting, and at least one of law/politics, the helping professions (social work, human services, ministry), or teaching. Levels: Undergraduate (3.000 Credit hours) Schedule Types: Lecture Course Attributes: Satisfies GenEd - Arts/Humanities (AH), GenEd - Oral Communication (OC) [III.] REQUIRED READINGS No textbook required; all readings will be posted on Blackboard (online.utk.edu) [IV.] COURSE OBJECTIVE(S) 1. Because completion of this course may satisfy either the (OC) oral communication or the (AH) arts and humanities General Education requirement, emphasis is placed on oral presentation with respect to the arts and humanities in the context of Professional Responsibility. 2. In this regard, the instructor is not insensitive to the fact that public speaking is very often a source of psychological discomfort (if not horror) for some individuals. Furthermore, because so much Phil (244-017): Professional Responsibility Fall 2013
communication today occurs via electronic media (email, facebook, twitter, etc.), being able to communicate effectively requires proficiency in both the real world and in cyberspace. 3. To this end, the electronic portion of this course (via Blackboard) has a dual role: first, to help you develop effective electronic communication, and second, to help you develop your communication skills in a safe place for your later oral presentation. Thus, you will be evaluated not only with respect to how well you are able to communicate orally, but also with respect to how well you are able to communicate electronically. 4. Finally: As an educational philosophy, I employ the concept of relevance as an educational tool. While epistemic binging and purging (i.e., memorizing for a test then purging it immediately thereafter) is a standard adaptive strategy for students to make the grade, there is a very real sense in which this impoverishes rather than enriches students. Learning and understanding occurs best when the subject matter is relevant to the student as a person which is to say, the phenomenological self which includes the background beliefs, perceptions, desires, and goals of a person as oriented to some future state of Being. Thus, your final project will not be on professional responsibility per se, but on professional responsibility with respect to the kind of person you are(e.g., if your major is psychology, then professional responsibility with respect to psychology, etc.). [V.] CLASSROOM POLICIES, RULES & PROCEDURES 1. Academic Honesty Statement a. Each student is responsible for his/her own personal integrity in academic life. While there is no affirmative duty to report the academic dishonesty of another, each student, given the dictates of his/her own conscience, may choose to act on any violation of the Honor Statement. b. Students are also responsible for any acts of plagiarism. Plagiarism is using the intellectual property of someone else without giving proper credit. The undocumented use of someone elses words or ideas in any medium of communication (unless such information is recognized as common knowledge) is a serious offense, subject to disciplinary action that may include failure in a course and/or dismissal from the university.
Specific examples of plagiarism are o Copying without proper documentation (quotation marks and a citation) written or spoken words, phrases, or sentences from any source. o Summarizing without proper documentation (usually a citation) ideas from another source (unless such information is recognized as common knowledge). o Borrowing facts, statistics, graphs, pictorial representations, or phrases without acknowledging the source (unless such information is recognized as common knowledge). o Collaborating on a graded assignment without instructors approval. o Submitting work, either in whole or part, created by a professional service and used without attribution (e.g., paper, speech, bibliography, or photograph). 2. Classroom Conduct a. Civility concerning classroom discussions o Especially as it regards hypothetical cases which most closely approximate real world issues (e.g., the question of abortion, capital punishment, and so forth), there is a predictable tendency for discussion to become heated. As such, students are expected (indeed, required) to be maximally respectful during discussion of such topics. o This is not to discourage passionate beliefs about certain topics, and rather to encourage a classroom environment conducive to productive, civil dialogue. As Plato and Aristotle insisted, cultivating our capacity for developing the right kind of emotional states (to Love and Hate Well) is equally as important as cultivating reason and intellect. b. Civility concerning peer presentations Phil (244-017): Professional Responsibility Fall 2013
o Because giving oral presentations are always psychologically discomforting, students are expected and required to be maximally respectful during the presentations of their fellow students. While I am flexible with many policies and rules, this particular rule of conduct is a zero tolerance policy such that you will be asked to leave and will not be welcomed back without some form of sincere compensatory act (e.g., an apology to the student and/or class, etc). c. Civility concerning the use of Multimedia Devices o During class you may experience a near overwhelming compulsion to check e-mail, twitter, text message, facebook, myspace, etc., on a laptop or other multimedia device dont panic! Recent studies have indicated that while this is a symptom of habitual rudeness, it is a condition that can nevertheless be reversed by simply resisting the urge. Students who are unableto resist this urge may be asked to leave in order to contemplate appropriate uses of electronic devices. o Cellular devices must be turned to the non-audible mode during class unless there is some extenuating circumstance warranting otherwise (in which case, please inform me prior to class). o Browsing the internet during class is fully inappropriate and inexcusable. o If you are uncertain about appropriate usages of such technologies, please see me 3. Make-ups a. Because life is often unpredictable, and because what happens to us is sometimes beyond our control, missing vital dates or being unable to finish an assignment on time may warrant a make- up at the discretion of the instructor. o In the event that the instructor judges that a make-up is appropriate, the student should be aware that the difficulty of said assignment may be greater than otherwise so as to account for considerations of fairness (e.g., taking a test a week later entails an extra week of study time, which students who took the test on time did not benefit from, and therefore make-up exams may be scaled in difficulty appropriate to such considerations). 4. Disability Statement a. In accordance with the requirements of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, The University of Tennessee affirmatively states that it does not discriminate on the basis of race, sex, or disability in its education programs and activities, and this policy extends to employment by the University. b. Any student who feels s/he may need an accommodation based on the impact of a disability should contact me privately to discuss your specific needs. For more information, contact the Office of Disability Services at 865-974-6087 in 2227 Dunford Hall. 5. Confidentiality, Communication & Student Responsibility a. The student is responsible for Anycommunication and/or instructions provided by the instructor to the student, whether verbally in class, in the hall ways, or during office consultations, whether written on the classroom white/black board, whether written electronically via email or posted online, or whether delivered by archaic means in some possible world such as by carrier pigeon or telegraph. o In other words, I will almost always respond to the utterance I didnt know I had to do that! (or any utterance of the like entailing culpable ignorance) by pointing to the Communication & Student Responsibility portion of the syllabus. Phil (244-017): Professional Responsibility Fall 2013
b. I will regard communication between myself (the instructor) and you (the student) as confidential, providing certain conditions are not in place (e.g., conditions where, in my judgment, you pose a risk of harm to yourself or others, or where rightfully compelled by some suitable authority). o Note: Due to the sensitive nature of grades, I will not discuss particular grades with you via email without a signed release form from you (ideally, you would want to speak with me personally during my office hours). 6. Syllabus Caveat a. This syllabus is, in essence, a contract between you (the student) and me (the instructor). However, while I will make every reasonable effort to provide sufficient notice for changes that are in my judgment ceteris paribus necessary, I nevertheless reserve the right to change the syllabus for any reason at any time. b. The student is responsible for knowing the content of the syllabus c. I will make every reasonable effort to explain your obligations and to leave no requirement unexplained but even so, sometimes things are lost in translation. In such cases it is ultimately the responsibility of the student to ask questions of clarification when unclear. [VI.] GRADING SCALE, DISTRIBUTION, & WEIGHTED TOTALS
GRADING SCALE (out of 400 points) A (375-400) A- (357-374) B+ (348-356) B (332-347) B- (320-331) C+ (308-319) C (292-307) C- (280-291) D+ (268-279) D (252-267) D- (240-251) F (00-239)
Please visit the Philosophy Departments UT website (philosophy.utk.edu), Facebook site, and Blackboard site (online.utk.edu; access limited to current majors) for a variety of resources helpful to those studying Philosophy as well as information about our degree programs (including two new major concentrations: Legal & Political Philosophy, Philosophy of Science & Medicine) and other opportunities for undergraduates including our scholarships, annual essay contest, and Philosophy Club. Phil (244-017): Professional Responsibility Fall 2013
[IX.] CLASS SCHEDULE Date Daily Discussion Topic / Due Dates Daily Discussion Presenter Assignment(s) for next class session EDB Leader EDB Group Aug 22 nd
Thursday Class session #1 Introduction to the course: syllabus, design, & overview Q & A Carnegie & Einswein The Art of Public Speaking (Chapters 1-6) None None Aug 27 th
Tuesday Class session #2 The idea of the Self & the 1 st
Thursday Class session #3 Logic & Sound Argumentation
Lecture Callahan (pp. 1-25) None None Sept 3 rd
Tuesday Class session #4 Moral & Ethical Theory Lecture Newton, Professionalization The Intractable Plurality of Values TBA ________ A1 Sept 5 th
Thursday Class session #5 Professional Responsibility pt. 1 TBA ________
Rowan & Zinach, Professional Ethics; Whitbeck, The Basis and Scope of Professional Responsibility TBA ________ ________ B Sept 10 th
Tuesday Class session #6 Professional Responsibility pt. 2 TBA ________ ________ Faber, Client & Professional; Andre, My Client, My Enemy TBA ________ ________ C Sept 12 th
Thursday Class session #7 Professional Responsibility pt. 3 Due: 1 st Assignment TBA ________ ________ Edwards, Confidentiality & the Professions TBA ________ ________ D Sept 17 th
Tuesday Class session #8 Confidentiality TBA ________ ________ Armstrong, Confidentiality: Comparison across professions TBA ________ A2 Sept 19 th
Thursday Class session #9 Confidentiality TBA ________ Corlett, Collective Moral Responsibility TBA ________
B Sept 24 th
Tuesday Class session #10 Collective Moral Responsibility TBA ________
Merill, Professionalization of Journalism TBA ________ C Sept 26 th
Thursday Class session #11 Professional issues in Journalism TBA ________ Dresser, Professionals, Conformity, and Conscience TBA ________ D Oct 1 st
Tuesday Class session #12 Professional issues in Pharmacy TBA ________ McIntyre, Is the Scientist for Hire? TBA ________ A3 Oct 3 rd
Thursday Class session #13 Professional issues Research Science TBA ________ Nelkin, The experience of American Ecologists TBA ________ ________ B Oct 8 th
Tuesday Class session #14 Professional issues in Applied Science TBA ________ ________ Emanuel & Emanuel, Four- Models of the Physician- Patient Relationship TBA ________ C Oct 10 th
Thursday Class session #15 Professional issues in Medicine TBA ________ May, Politics: The Dispised Profession TBA ________ D Phil (244-017): Professional Responsibility Fall 2013
Oct 15 th
Tuesday Class session #16 Professional Issues in Politics Due: Research Thesis TBA ________ Danforth, The Point of Serving TBA ________ A4 Oct 17 th
Thursday No Class NO CLASS FALL BREAK Oct 22 nd
Tuesday Class session #17 Professional issues in Public Service TBA ________ Tong, Dirty Hands, Many Hands, No Hands TBA ________ B Oct 24 th
Thursday Class session #18 Professional Issues in Policy Making TBA ________ Johnson, The Social and Professional Responsibility of Engineers TBA ________ C Oct 29 th
Tuesday No Class NO CLASS THANKSGIVING BREAK Oct 31 st
Thursday Class session #19 Professional issues in Engineering TBA ________ Stein, Lying and Deception in Counseling TBA ________
D Nov 5 th
Tuesday Class session #20 Professional Issues in Counseling TBA ________
Hamilton, Who is responsible? TBA ________ A5 Nov 7 th
Thursday Class session #21 Professional issues Social Psychology TBA ________ Wolfendale, Professional Integrity & Disobedience in the Military TBA ________ B Nov 12 th
Tuesday Class session #22 Professional issues in Military Service TBA ________ Montrose, Reluctant Soldiers
TBA ________ C Nov 14 th
Thursday Class session #23 Professional issues in Military Service TBA ________ Phillips, Manipulative Advertising TBA ________ D Nov 19 th
Tuesday Class session #24 Professional issues in Advertising Due: Research Draft TBA ________ Statman & Glushkov, The wages of social responsibility TBA ________ A6 Nov 21 st
Thursday Class session #25 Professional issues in Investment Management TBA ________ Freedman, The Professional Obligation to chase ambulances TBA ________ B Nov 26 th
Tuesday Class session #26 Professional issues in Law TBA ________ Leo, Inside the interrogation room TBA ________ C Nov 28 th
Thursday Class session #27 Professional issues Law Enforcement TBA ________ Meilaender, The Ethics of Teaching TBA ________ D Dec 3 rd
Tuesday Class session #28 Professional issues in Education Due: Research Project TBA ________ No assigned readings None None Dec 5 th /12 th FINAL EXAM PERIOD NO CLASS