Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The review assessed literature on interventions for alcohol and drug dependent mothers. Alcohol
and drug dependence of mothers comprise a persistent problem. A number of interventions have
emerged. However, there is need to assess the relative effectiveness of these interventions for the
group of alcohol and drug dependent mothers to support responsive social work practice. The
presenting the different models together with the theoretical basis and empirical evidence, and
assessing effectiveness. A summary of the results follows together with the implications on
social work practice. The discussion ends with conclusions on the effectiveness assessment
Introduction
2
Alcohol and drug dependence of parents, particularly mothers remain a pressing family
social problem. Statistics do not provide data on the prevalence of alcohol and illicit drug
dependence of mothers but the situation can be gleaned from statistics for the adult age group
and adult females. Alcohol abuse is a problem with the percentage of adults 18 years and older
dependent on alcohol reported at 7.9 percent for both 2005 and 2006. Drug dependence is also a
problem with the percentage of drug dependent adults 18 years and older increasing from 2.6 to
2.7 percent between 2005 and 2006. Alcohol and drug dependence is lower for female adults 18
years and older but the prevalence still indicates a problem. Alcohol dependence remained at 5.1
percent in 2005 and 2006. Drug dependence decreased from 1.9 to 1.7 percent between 2005 and
2006. (Department of Health and Human Services, 2009) These percentages reflect on the
Various intervention and treatment models with varying scopes and targets emerged
(Suchman, 2004) but these faced challenges on effectiveness from lack of continuity or failure to
achieve long-term results. With the recognized impact of alcohol and drug dependence of
mothers on the health, safety and welfare of children and the family, assessing the range of
family practice models is an important step in determining effective intervention models and
ways of improving applied models. The result has implications on the focus and direction of
The literature review considers empirical studies on family intervention for alcohol and
drug dependence to identify the different models applied and to assess the relative effectiveness
of these models in addressing the problem of alcohol and drug dependence of mother. The
Results
3
The empirical studies on intervention for alcohol and drug dependent mothers shows the
shifts in the focus of intervention discourse as well as the bifurcations or deviations in the
Lundgren, Schilling and Peloquin (2005) studied methadone as a treatment for drug-
empirical studies, welfare policies of various states, and articles the results showed no strong
While this treatment is a general treatment for alcohol and drug abuse, there are not studies
indicating its acceptance and effectiveness for substance-dependent parents, particularly mothers.
Moreover, this only focuses on neurobiological aspects and requires integration with other
Loneck, Garrett and Banks (1997) studied high and low intensity groups in an outpatient
alcohol and drug treatment program for women. This approach is based on the concept of social
networking with members of the network providing support in completing the outpatient
program. High intensity referral includes the Johnson Intervention with members of the social
network directly confronting the alcohol or drug dependent woman over her addiction and the
negative effects of the addition together with coerced referral with an ultimatum comprising the
motivation. Low intensity referrals include unrehearsed intervention with a counselor facilitating
the confrontation, unsupervised intervention with the members of the social network conducting
the confrontation on their own, and non-coerced referral. The results from data on 109 women
showed that high-intensity referrals had better impact on engagement and completion. However,
high intensity referrals have varied effect on engagement and completion across age groups,
educational level, employment, and marital status, favoring women in the older age groups,
4
lower educational achievement, part time employment, and unmarried status. This indicates the
limitation of the applicability and effectiveness of high intensity referral for different groups of
women.
Salmon et al. (2000) also studied outpatient drug treatment programs for pregnant women
and mothers with substance abuse problems in terms of the effectiveness of support given by
providers and other sources of social support. The study also considered the aspects of the
program that helped them in maintaining abstinence. The program was based on the social stress
model that explains substance abuse as the effect of the offsetting of stress level and its modifiers
such as social support and resources. The survey of women participating in the program showed
that majority expressed satisfaction towards the support they received relative to their
engagement in the program. The helpful aspects of the program are education, coping
techniques, 12-step guide, resource assistance, and spiritual direction. However, two-thirds of the
women expressed lack of information coming from medical providers over the risk of substance
abuse on their pregnancy. An implication is the need to widen the scope of social support to
effectiveness of outpatient programs strongly depend not only on the existence but also of the
participants over the difficulties and problems caused by substance abuse to influence change in
attitudes and behavior. The clinical trial of 150 patients showed no significant difference in the
level of alcohol consumption, degree of dependence, and problems encountered before and after
the test for those undergoing individual and group psychotherapy. The study recommended
5
difference between the level of alcohol consumption and problems encountered in the pre and
post test of the two groups, the study did not determine whether the level of alcohol consumption
and problems after the psychotherapy indicated significant success of the program. Moreover,
the lack of difference means the possible failure of the program to optimize the benefits of
Relapse Prevention Approach and the Addicted-Self Model in terms of relative effectiveness in
achieving long-term abstinence. The difference between these two programs is the relationship
between self-efficacy and recovery. The Relapse Prevention Approach associates recovery
positively with self-efficacy while the Addicted-Self Model propounds a negative relationship.
The study of 356 outpatients showed that there is higher abstinence with the Addicted-Self
Model because the acceptance of loss of control over the addiction supports the stronger resolve
for long-term abstinence. The study recommended shift to the Addicted-Self Model. However,
the Addicted-Self Model does not predict the levels of relapse or continued use as well as the
factors that reinforce life-long abstinence. This significantly bears down on the effectiveness of
the approach.
Suchman et al. (2004) studied parenting interventions for mothers with drug dependence
intervention for drug dependent mothers. This shifted the intervention process from behavior
management to emotional quality of parent-child relations. This emerged from the failure of
behavioral training programs to influence continued abstinence and support children adjustment.
Data from an outpatient treatment program showed that parenting intervention based on parent-
6
relations. This comprises a promising intervention program specifically for alcohol and drug
dependent mothers albeit there is need to test this intervention in various intervention scenarios
and participants.
parenting interventions integrated into alcohol and drug abuse treatment programs. This
approach improves the quality of the parent-child emotional attachment by training parents to be
emotionally open to the messages from their children, to accurately interpret these messages, and
relations, this encourages and enables mothers to manage their behavior and ensure successes in
child rearing. While this contributes a way of improving cognitive-behavioral outcomes, this
requires highly trained clinicians to assess progress and prevent overwhelming mothers that
could cause relapse. The effectiveness varies according to the situation and cases to imply the
Joanning et al. (2007) compared the effectiveness of three drug dependence treatment
programs targeting young people, which are Family Systems Therapy, Adolescent Group
Therapy and Family Drug Education through controlled outcome experiment. The results
showed that highest level of success of Family Systems Therapy by having two times more
patients abstaining from substance abuse. The success is due to improved communication
between parents and children. However, the intervention showed no difference in influencing
Sun (2004) studied case management as an intervention focused on the role of service
prenatal care, psychiatric treatment, legal advice, social welfare advice on matters such as
housing, nutrition, and training. A comparison with the non-integrative program showed that
case management led to higher levels of completion and lower dropout rates. This comprises an
effective program by targeting multi-dimensional issues causing alcohol and drug dependence
and hindering lifelong abstinence. However, this is beset with challenges in inter-agency
mediation. Social workers are in the best position to negotiate inter-agency collaboration by
Lundgren, Amaro and Ben-Ami (2005) studied the engagement in treatment of Hispanic
women with drug dependence problems. The results showed differences in engagement,
treatment selection, and treatment maintenance. Puerto Rican participants showed preference for
influenced by mental health service use and criminal justice system involvement. An implication
of this study is the effectiveness of treatment programs that focus on specific needs and the role
of social workers in informing women from different ethnic minority background about drug
abuse treatment options and maintain cooperation relations with mental health and criminal
justice workers. This supports the importance of inclusive treatment programs that accommodate
Greenfield et al. (2007) tested the difference between a Women’s Recovery Group
(WRG) and a mixed-gender Group Drug Counseling to assess the importance of interventions
specifically designed for women. After the 12-week treatment, there was no difference in
outcomes. However, the 6-month follow up showed continued reduction in substance use by
8
those in the WRG. There were also higher levels of satisfaction with the WRG. Women-focused
interventions could lead to more long-term results. This is an effective approach that requires
further investigation. The focus on women’s needs would consider comprehensive factors that
determine the success of intervention for alcohol and drug dependent mothers.
Discussion
A number of interventions for alcohol and drug dependence of mothers emerged from the
literature. These can be categorized into a number of classifications. One classification is based
on the underlying principles and operations to include neurobiological (Lundgren, Schilling and
Peloquin, 2005), cognitive-behavioral (Marques & Formigoni, 2001; Fiorentine & Hillhouse,
2003, Suchman et al., 2004; Suchman et al., 2006) and social models (Loneck et al., 1997;
Salmon et al., 2000; Sun, 2004; Lundgren et al., 2005; Greenfield et al., 2007; Joanning et al.,
2007). The second classification is interactive comprised of the interventions based on social
combined with other models that determine the scope of the intervention. Some of the models
were singular approaches such as methadone (Lundgren, Schilling & Peloquin, 2005) and
Addicted-Self Model (Fiorentine & Hillhouse, 2003). Other models involved combination
approaches by emerging from general interventions for alcohol and drug abuse but integrated
with parental substance to incorporate the maternal element such as high and low intensity
groups (Loneck et al, 1997), rational behavior therapy (Marques & Formigoni, 2001), and case
management (Sun, 2004). The remaining combination models emerged particularly for women,
pregnant women, and mothers such as the Relational Approach (Suchman et al., 2006) and
Women’s Recovery Group (Greenfield et al., 2007). From these emerging thematic
9
classifications, the trend is towards combined or mixed principles, services and application that
(Lundgren, Schilling & Peloquin, 2005) but there are limited studies showing the effectiveness
of this method as an intervention for alcohol and drug dependent mothers. Moreover, this only
addresses one aspect of intervention that limits its effectiveness. The limited focus of this
intervention together with lack of empirical support for its application to alcohol and drug
Some of the cognitive-behavioral and social methods that generally apply to different
groups created broader intervention approaches by integrating the parental substance to address
the particular needs of mothers with alcohol and drug dependence problems. There is empirical
evidence over the effectiveness of these interventions in terms of engagement and abstinence.
However, these also have limitations including focus on only a certain phase of the treatment,
dependence on the fit with the circumstances of target groups, reliance on the role of
interventionists or providers, and need for further testing in different and wider groups. These
interventions apply to mothers with alcohol and drug dependence problems but the effectiveness
The comprehensive models such as case management and Women’s Recovery Group
cover various areas of need and adopted or created for women. Case management is generally
applicable to different groups but it is adaptable to alcohol and drug dependent mothers because
of its wide scope. The Women’s Recovery Group fits the needs of mother with alcohol and drug
dependence problems and targets various areas of concern and accommodates diverse sub-
10
groups. These are the most effective programs. However, these require high skills from social
Implications
The review of literature gave rise to a number of implications for family practice. One
implication is the importance of skills and training of social workers in managing the
requirements of comprehensive intervention models. The comprehensive models are the most
effective interventions because these address multi-dimensional issues that contributed to alcohol
and drug dependence and determine the success of interventional models. However, these are
also the most demanding on practitioners. Practitioners need to adapt the intervention according
to the particular needs of mothers with alcohol and drug dependence problems and sub-
groupings such as according to age and ethnic background, monitor the progress to prevent any
negative intervening factors, and implement adjustments as necessary. Social workers also need
to establish and maintain strong working ties with practitioners in other disciplines to achieve the
The greater weight of comprehensive intervention models finds support from empirical
evidence on positive changes in engagement and continuity of abstinence when tested on their
own or in comparison with traditional or single interventions. The studies employed a number of
methods in investigating the application of these intervention models from which the
observation, and analysis of secondary empirical data. This implies directing practice towards
more comprehensive treatments adapted to the needs of mothers with alcohol and drug
dependence problems. However, there is need to draw further evidence on the application and
use of the interventions towards the group of alcohol and drug dependent mothers and the
11
Conclusion
supporting empirical evidence. The developments or shifts in interventions for alcohol and drug
dependent mothers occurred alongside shifts in theories over effective interventions. Theories on
interventions shifted from the singular concepts or ideas targeting specific aspects of alcohol and
concepts that cover multi-dimensional aspects of alcohol and drug abuse interventions.
options but complementary ideas that could be combined to achieve encompassing applications.
Due to this shift, more comprehensive interventions received recognition for better effectiveness
in actual practice. The results of empirical studies support the theoretical shift. An integrative
theoretical basis also results to interventions that accommodate different treatment groups with
are the recommended approaches for social workers in addressing the intervention needs of
alcohol and drug dependent mothers. These are comprehensive in scope and adjustable to
different sub-groups of mothers. Social workers should assess existing practices to determine
The review of empirical studies identified the evidence on interventions for alcohol and
drug dependent mothers and supported the greater effectiveness of more comprehensive
12
interventions. However, the limitations of the interventions comprise the research gap that merits
further investigation.
References
13
Department of Health and Human Services. (2009). 2006 National Survey on Drug Use &
http://www.oas.samhsa.gov/NSDUH/2k6NSDUH/tabs/Sect5peTabs1to56.htm#Tab5.14B
Fiorentine, R., & Hillhouse, M. (2003). The Addicted-Self Model of addictive behavior
cessation: Does it predict recovery for gender, ethnic, age and drug preference
Greenfield, S., Trucco, E., McHugh, K., Lincoln, M., & Gallop, R. (2007). The women's
recovery group study: A stage I trial of women-focused group therapy for substance use
disorders versus mixed-gender group drug counseling. Drug and Alcohol Dependence,
90(1), 39-47.
Joanning, H., Quinn, W., Thomas, F., & Mullen, R. (2007). Treating adolescent drug abuse: A
comparison of family systems therapy, group therapy, and family drug education.
Loneck, B., Garrett, J., & Banks, S. (1997). Engaging and retaining women in outpatient alcohol
and other drug treatment: effect of referral intensity. Health and Social Work, 22(1), 38-
46.
Lundgren, L., Amaro, H., & Ben-Ami, L. (2005). Factors associated with drug treatment entry
patterns among Hispanic women injection drug users seeking treatment. Journal of
Lundgren, L. M., Schilling, R. F., & Peloquin, S. D. (2005). Evidence-based drug treatment
practice and the child welfare system: The example of methadone. Social Work, 50(1),
53-63.
14
Marques, A. C., & Formigoni, M. L. (2001). Comparison of individual and group cognitive-
behavioral therapy for alcohol and/or drug-dependent patients. Addiction, 96, 835-846.
Suchman, N., Mayes, L., Conti, J., Slade, A., & Rounsaville, B. (2004). Rethinking parenting
Salmon, M., Joseph, B., Saylor, C., & Mann, R. (2000). Women's perception of provider, social,
Suchman, N., Mayes, L., Conti, J., Slade, A., & Rounsaville, B. (2004). Rethinking parenting
Suchman, N., Pajulo, M., DeCoste, C., & Mayes, L. (2006). Parenting interventions for drug-
dependent mothers and their young children: The case for an attachment-based approach.
Sun, A. P. (2004). Principles for practice with substance-abusing pregnant women: A framework
based on the five social work intervention roles. Social Work, 49(3), 383.