APPROVED A

Approved without exception

APPROVED WITH COMMENTS AC
Approved Subject to Incorporation of comments
RETURNED FOR CORRECTION RT
Insufficient Information/ Detail
Resubmit for Approval
REJECTED RJ
Complete redesign required
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION I
Returned without comments
RECEIVED FOR INFORMATION IC
Returned with comments
any obligations covered under contract
Engineer:
Discipline:
Date:
Note: Approval or comments does not relieve the Contractor of
Pyry Energy
TWO(2) X 500MW
MONG DUONG 1 THERMAL POWER PLANT
David Langhorne
Senior Mec Engineer
5-Mar-13
Pyry Comment
Two(2) x 500MW Mong Duong 1 Thermal Power Plant Project

Dwg. / Doc. Title
Outline Drawing for HP-6
Low Pressure FWH
Dwg. / Doc. No. MD1-0-V-114-01-00003
HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-1036 Submitted Date 2012.11.02 Rev. B
Pyry TR No. 9A000323-002559 Received Date 2012.11.28
New HDEC DT No. MD1-HDH-EVN-X-2233 Re-Submitted Date 2013.02.05 Rev. C
Status Received for Information Returned with Comments

Page1 / 2
No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action
1 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Please refer to general comments on MD1-0-V-
114-01-00001.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Noted.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Closed.

2 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Steam inlet line having pipe size of DN300mm
(refer to P&ID No. MD1-0-M-110-21-00032 Rev.
0). Therefore, nozzle size should be DN300
instead of nozzle DN550 as shown in the nozzle
data table. Please check and correct.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.
3 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
The steam inlet nozzle material should be
revised as the HMB for VWO condition indicates
a steam temperature of 422 deg C.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.
Steam inlet material has been revised from
A106-B to A335-P11.
4 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Drain inlet from HP-7 FWH having pipe size
DN350 while the heater nozzle size is DN300.
Please clarify.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Nozzle sizes are calculated as per HEC code
and standard. HDEC will use 350 x 300 reducer
at HP #6 drain inlet
5 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
At the key plan, please correct location of HP-6
FWH from Mezzanine floor to Operating floor.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
HP-6 FWH is on the HP heater floor. Please
check the modified key plan.
6 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
According to the Contract requirement, HP
heater tube side shall be designed to withstand
the boiler feed water pump shut off head. Design
pressure of 42 barg does not meet the
requirement. Please correct
<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Boiler Feedwater Pump shut-off pressure is 300
barg. BFP shut-off pressure has been reflected
as tube side design pressure of 300 barg
Page2 / 2

No. Pyrys Comments Contractors Reply / Action

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

7 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Design pressure and temperature of heater shell
side are lower than pressure and temperature of
steam inlet. Please correct.
<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.A>
Reflected.
8 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.A>
Correct the nozzle bevel data table. It appears
to be a cut and paste from MD1-0-V-114-01-
00001.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Closed.

Reflected.
9 <Pyrys Comments on Rev.B>
Any change from the previous version shall be
cloud marked.

<Pyrys Comments on Rev.C>
Closed.

<Contractors Reply / Action on Rev.B>
Reflected