Académique Documents
Professionnel Documents
Culture Documents
Gildas Hamel
Cultural Studies, Wednesday //
Introduction
1ho papoi iowoiks a quoslion on which I gavo a papoi ovoi a yoai ago.
r
Il is piinaiily ny woik on a hisloiy of laLoi ano ioligious iopiosonlalions
in Hollonislic ano Ionan Ialoslino lhal has loo no lo ioocl on lho hisloiy of
lho nolion of nonolhoisn.
z
Lul I an also lhinking aLoul noooin quoslions.
1
Nolo lo nysolf (Fiioay ....zo..).
.. 1his chaploi on nonolhoisn coulo bo ovonlually oisliibuloo inlo lhioo oioionl chap-
lois, oiganizoo by poiioos: pio-slalo, nonaichios, oxilo ano afloi.
z. 1ho liacos of lho nonolhoislic oovolopnonl havo lo bo spolloo oul: oocls on lho
nylhological naloiial; on lho iolalionship wilh lho ooily, ospocially lho ovolulion of
lho nolion of sin, lho languago of sin isl of all, ano lho nolion of oivino nobilily as
applioo lo lho io-ioaoings of paliiaichal sloiios ano Lxoous (nol only in lho analysis
of Lzoliol oono biioy hoio).
. Finally lho iolaloo changos ono can oolocl in lho piioslhooo ilsolf, lho nolion of
law ano ils ooicling, ano lho lonplo cull: how lhoy inlogialo Juoah ano Isiaol inlo
laigoi foicos yol oioionlialo ano oxpano Juoaisn nuch noio bioaoly, lhiough an
inloiosling nix of sopaialion ano inlogialion (lho 1oiah in Aianaic sciipl, o.g., bul
ooicloo by lho ooily oiioclly; oxanplo of shaalnoz ano onbioiooiy al lho lonplo
1ho lonplo as olaboialoi of ioonlily.)
2
Foi a social hisloiy of ancionl Isiaol, soo ospocially Kessler, The social history of
ancient Israel: an introduction, lianslalion of Kessler, Sozialgeschichte des alten Israel:
eine Einfhrung. 1his is lho bosl inlioouclion lo lho hisloiy of Isiaol wo havo al lho
piosonl, bul nuch noio can bo oono bocauso of inpoilanl changos in lho inloipiolalion of
lho aichaoology of Isiaol ano in lho souico ciilicisn of lho !iblo. Foi a voiy oolailoo ano
inuonlial sluoy of lho oaily Isiaolilo poiioo: Gottwald, The tribes of Yahweh : a sociology
of the religion of liberated Israel, BCE. Foi a usoful ioviow of lho nolhoos usoo
in a social hisloiy of ancionl Isiaol: McNutt, Reconstructing the society of ancient Israel.
Albertz, Social hisloiy of ancionl Isiaol is an inpoilanl ailiclo. On lho gonoial slalo of
lho guoslion, soo: Grabbe, Ancient Israel: what do we know and how do we know it?
1hoio is lho iopoaloo clain lhal nonolhoisn is a najoi causo of violonco ano
inloloianco, Lolh inloinal lo ils lhioo najoi Lianchos ano oxloinal.
In ciuoo
foin, lho iooa is lhal polylhoisn is loloianl ano nonolhoisn inloloianl ano
fanalical. 1his woulo Lo lho oxacl opposilo of whal has long Loon clainoo
aLoul nonolhoisn, nanoly ils loaooiship in nallois of olhics ano juslico.
Moio funoanonlally, lhoio is a viow lhal nonolhoisn ano ils avalais con-
voy a piogiannalic vision of lho cosnos ano of lino as puioly usaLlo valuos
ano which woulo loao lo polilical ano ocological calasliopho. 1ho nonolho-
islic failh in Yahwoh, conquoioi of naluio ano lho goos, woulo havo playoo a
Lasic iolo in lho foinalion of lhal vision.
Il is liuo lhal in lho LiLlo, in a oioionl way fion lho Giook appioach,
naluio ano nylhical opics of il havo fallon unooi a iaoical oouLl. Lul lhis
cano aLoul Locauso of lho Yahwislic anli-nylhological sliugglo of lho lh lo
lh c. LCL, which nooos lo Lo silualoo wilhin lho conloxl of lho ooninalion
of Isiaol ano Juoah Ly onpiiosAssyiian, LaLylonian, ano Ioisian, lhon
Hollonislic ano Ionanwhoso iooological juslicalions look piocisoly lhoso
nylhical foins.
I oonl lhink polylaliy has any chanco of golling lho lighl of oay againsl
ioolaliy, lho languago of oaily Chiislianily (, shoilonoo laloi).
Lovanl, wilh a hisloiy of cily-slalos ano noighLoiing laigo ano ancionl slalos,
noans lhal slalos, ovon in a woak foin, nay havo aiison oailioi lhan lhooiy
(oi ovon aichaoology) inoicalos.
r
1his possiLilily is noally illuslialoo Ly lho
oiscovoiios naoo al KhiiLol Qoiyafa, in soulh-wosl Juoah, on lho Loiooi
wilh Ihilislino loiiiloiy. Soo nosl ioconlly Garfinkel ano Kang, 1ho
iolalivo ano aLsolulo chionology of KhiiLol Qoiyafa. 1ho aulhois aiguo lhal
lhis silo, which was occupioo foi a voiy shoil poiioo of lino, is ovioonco of a
now culluial assonLlago. 1hoy aiguo il is lho oailiosl lovol of Iion Ago IIA,
oalaLlo lo ciica u LCL (iaoionoliy ano polloiy assonLlago). 1ho
sliiking aichilocluial pails aio lho wall, lho casonalos as pail of lho Lack of
lho owollings wilh lhoii Lack lo lho wall, ano lho aLsonco of Luiloings in lho
conloi. Was il sinply a foilioss lhon, wilh a iolo of pioloclion foi a laigoi
populalion oispoisoo in villagos aiouno 1his is koy.
How ooos lho oovolopnonl of social slialicalion in lho oaily slalo of
Isiaol iolalo lo ioligious sliucluios In Mooiloiianoan, agiaiian, loiiiloiial
slalos,
r
lho nooo foi socuiily of accoss lo lano ano laLoi loo lo naxinizalion
of chancos lo oxpano. 1o slay pul was nol an oplion. Iisk aLalononl alono
ano nooo foi oivoisicalion (i.o., nininizalion of ocological iisks, ossonlially,
14
Slail wilh lho sociological ano olhnogiaphic piosupposilions holo by oofonoois of lho
low chionology (Finlolsloin isl of all): Kletter, Chionology ano uniloo nonaichy.
!ogaioing slalohooo vs chiofoons: lho nolhoo consisling of lisling foaluios of slalos ano
slaloloss sociolios has boon calloo inlo guoslion. Soo Pfoh, The emergence of Israel in
ancient Palestine, which is iounoly ciilicizoo by Hullon in a zo.. ioviow in RBL. If ono
ooosnl go wilh a foaluio-iich oonilion of ancionl slalos, can slalohooo bo oosciiboo wilh
\oboi oi Gollnoi (chocl) as a nonopolizalion of cooicivo powoi 1ho pagos by \oboi in
!onoixs sunnaiy (lasl pails of his bool) on ooninalion ano ils chaiisnalic, paliinonial
ano logalialional aspocls aio voiy inpoilanl in lhis iogaio, bocauso lhoy piovioo a lhooiy
againsl which ono nay inilialo a oynanic oosciiplion of ancionl slalos, ialhoi lhan iosoil lo
lisls of foaluios: Bendix, Max Weber: an intel lectual portrait. 1ho slalo wasnl a plalonic
onlily in any caso. Il coulo ionain a conplox linship-basoo polily (pailly clilious oi nol),
noaning lhal lhis nonopoly of powoi oionl oxisl oi was oisliibuloo bioaoly, ovon lhough
aiislocialically. Oi: lho nonopolizalion of powoi by falhois ano a fow clan hoaos conlinuoo
in lho nonaichy. 1his nay havo boon lho silualion foi a long whilo ano was assunoo lo bo
lho caso by lho aulhoi(s) of lho Davioic cyclo of sloiios. Inoooo, liansilional oxplanalions
havo alioaoy boon ooioo: foi inslanco by !oboil Milloi (soconoaiy conplox chiofoons); oi
Daniol Masloi (a lingship-basoo paliinonial slalo). Ono ooosnl havo lo soo slalo ano anal
iolalionships as oxclusivo of oach olhoi, oi in an nono-oiioclional ovolulion. Fuilhoinoio, in
iogaio lo wiiling as ono of lho foaluios oflon usoo lo signify slalohooo, a sciibal appaialus
nay havo oxisloo oaily, oi conlinuoo lo oxisl in a subouoo way, ano was lhon usoo foi
logilinalion by nasconl aiislociacy oi nonaichy. 1ho sciibal aspocl of ancionl slalos is
nol sonolhing nocossaiily cioaloo of wholo now clolh in Iion Ago II. On lhis guoslion, soo
Byrne, 1ho iofugo of sciibalisn in Iion I !aloslino; Sanooz ().
15
Dioionl in lhal iospocl fion cily-slalos, soo Buccellati, Cities and nations of ancient
Syria.
1hoio aio inloiosling ocononic ano social quoslions lo ask, howovoi, io-
gaioing lho Yahwislic piophols. How oio lhoy livo Whilo Llijah is piosonloo
as a pooi ilinoianl piophol living of oxpooionls, his succossoi Llisha is a
suLslanlial lanoownoi. Ioihaps lhoy Lonoloo fion lho gonoial ocononic oo-
volopnonl, in pail ouo lo lho policios of lhoii oppononls, lho Oniioos, yol
ioacling lo lho sliong social slialicalion which wonl wilh il.
Howovoi, lho inloinal iosislanco of local olilos (in Lphiain aioas noslly)
is nol only ouo lo a poicoivoo ovoiioach Ly lho nonaichy which look lho
foin of Laalisn (localoo in Yiziool, Sanaiia as capilal, i.o. in a piocoss of
ox-conloiing).
z
Il is also ouo lo lho giowing Assyiian nonaco ano piosonco in
lho socono half of lho lh c. Whon il oininishoo in lho oaily Slh c. (S),
poihaps yahwisn was soon as a polonl facloi in lhis iopiiovo
z
1his ioaclion woulo Locono a pioninonl pail of lho lhono of social jus-
lico in lho conlinuing Yahwislic-loo iosislanco Lolh in Isiaol ano Juoah, ano
ovonlually in lho law (Lx , Dl , Lov ) ano lho lhoological accounls of
lho nonaichy up lo ano laloi. Il hao inpoilanl consoquoncos on lho laloi
piopholic novononl, lho liansnission of liaoilions fion lho noilh in lho lh
c. (incluoing Mosaic liaoilions of salvalion), ano lho passago fion nonolaliy
lo nonolhoisn.
If ono conpaios lo Solons iofoins in Alhons al lho Loginning of lho 6lh
c. LCL, il is inloiosling lo nolo lhal lho piopholic novononl was playing
a sinilai iolo lo Solons, ano fascinaling lo conpaio lhoii iospoclivo poolic
uvios. Solons iofoins, howovoi, succooooo in lanping social slialicalion
oown ano cioaling a fioo poasanliy, oi al loasl ho is ciooiloo wilh ooing
so. Ho oio lhis Ly oocioasing lho powoi of lho aiislocialic fanilios whilo
iooisliiLuling woallh (ooLl cancollalion, fiooing of hektmroi, fiooing of ooLl-
slavos). Allhough lho social lonsions ano piopholic solulions look ooiily sinilai
in Slh c. Isiaol ano Juoah, lho cioalion of a liuly fioo poasanliy coulonl
happon lhoio Locauso of lho Assyiian ano LaLylonian onpiios.
z
How laigo woio lhoso ciiclos Sono hisloiians lhink lho Yahwislic gioup
was voiy snall in Isiaol ano Juoah, iighl up lo lho LaLylonian invasion. Lul
lho aLunoanco of Yah-lhoophoiic nanos, Lolh in insciiplions ano LiLlical
nanos fion Isiaol ano Juoah, inoicalos olhoiwiso.
As I saio iogaioing lho pio-slalo poiioo, lho woiship of Yahwoh, howovoi,
nay nol havo Loon of a iaoically alono goo oi al loasl nol foi ovoiyono. In-
24
1his ox-conloiing nooos lo bo oxaninoo ano alioaoy has, piosunably.
25
1his is wholly spoculalivo: aio lhoio any liacos of lhis lypo of alliluoo anong Aianaoan
slalos, oi in lho H!
26
Soo Woodhouse, Solon the liberator; Freeman, The work and life of Solon; with a
translation of his poems.
S
sciiplions havo Loon founo al Kunlillol Ajiuo (lh-Slh c., noilhoin Sinai),
iofoiiing o.g. lo Yahwoh of Sanaiia ano his Ashoiah whoso inloipiolalion
is holly oispuloo.
z
Do lhoy inoicalo lho oxislonco of a iolalionship wilh lho
gooooss Ashoiah ano show lhal Yahwoh is pail of a polylhoislic panlhoon, oi
is lho Ashoiah a cullic oLjocl lhiough which Yahwohs powoi is appioachoo
Ono noio woio on lho gonoial silualion of lho Oniioos. Scholais piosonl
lho Oniioo synciolisn as pail of a syslon of nililaiy alliancos, which is
an inpoilanl aspocl of lho oxpansion, sinco nililaiy pioloclion againsl lho
looning Assyiian lhioal oi ils vassal Aianoan kingoons in lho lh-Slh c. was
ossonlial. 1his ooosnl chango lho noio Lasic facls, lo ny nino, which aio
lhal kingoons nooooo lo onsuio ovoi gioaloi accoss lo lano ano laLoi, as woll
as nililaiy foicos connocloo wilh lhis, oilhoi Ly lovios oi spocial noiconaiy
foicos.
z
In loins of ioligious oovolopnonl in lhal poiioo, I suLsciiLo lo AlLoilzs
woios:
il was a voiy spocic polilical, social, ano ioligious hisloiical conslolla-
lion ouiing lho ninlh conluiy LCL, whon Isiaol oxpoiioncoo lho liansi-
lion fion an oaily lo a naluio slalo, which pushoo Isiaols ioligious
oovolopnonl in lho oiioclion of nonolaliy ano nonolhoisn. (6)
Empire, Israel, Judah, and neighbors
Isiaols slialogy soons sinilai lo lhal of noighLoiing Aianoan slalos, whoioas
Juoahs was nuch noio liko lhal of Loon, MoaL, Annon, i.o. nonolaliy
wilhoul nooo foi oilhoisn oi polylaliy.
z
Lul lho facl lhal Isiaol ano Juoah
shaioo Yahwoh as lhoii nain goo, loo lo a poculiai oynanics whon onpiios
woighoo in al lho ono of lho Slh c. LCL ano in lho lh.
Whon consiooiing lho ovonls ongulng Isiaol in ano Juoah in S6,
ono nay wonooi aLoul lho long-loin oocl of lho oaily loss of Isiaols polil-
ical onlily lo Assyiia, ano ils afloinalh foi lho soulhoin kingoon of Juoah.
27
Soo Keel ano Uehlinger, Gods, goddesses, and images of God in ancient Israel,
z.o, wilh full oiscussion of lho possibililios.
28
\oio lhoio noiconaiios al lhal lino Oi aio lho wiilois assuning lho poinanonco of
a conlonpoiaiy (!oisian) aspocl of wai
29
Cf. \obois passagos on lho ocological ioasons which woulo oxplain lho nonolaliy of
oosoil oi naiginal social gioups. 1his coulo bo liuo also of snall agiaiian gioups: poihaps
lho oonogiaphic guoslion is inpoilanl in lhis iogaio (noaning, lho nooosliy of populalion
nunbois, foi which soo Broshi ano Finkelstein, 1ho populalion of !aloslino in Iion Ago
II), as woll as lho lypo of nicho agiiculluio lhal was piaclicoo in lhoso aioas
Whal was lho long-loin oocl of lho faiily iapio liansfoinalion of lho in-
poiial polilical silualion in Mosopolania ano lho Lovanl, wilh Assyiia Loing
iononLoioo as having soon ils goos suLnilling lo lhoso of LaLylonia, ano
lhoso in luin suLnilling lo lhoso (quilo oioionl) fion Ioisia 1aking lhoso
changos in consiooialion nakos il oasioi lo oxplain why Juoah alono, ano
nol Aianaoan, noilhoin Isiaolilo, Ihilislino, oi MoaLilo populalions, cano lo
such an unooislanoing of lhoii olhnic goo.
. 1ho slanoaio, ago-olo, oxplanalion foi oofoal oi foi hisloiical calaslio-
pho was lhal lho goo oi goos hao Locono angiy wilh lho pooplo
o
ano
nusl Lo piopilialoo Ly ono oi anolhoi iilo, such as saciicos, ovon hu-
nan saciicos. 1his is lho inpiossion ono galhois fion lho MoaLilo
slono as woll as fion nuch LiLlical ano oxlia-LiLlical ovioonco.
r
. In lho caso of Isiaol, in lho Slh c. liaoilion as wo havo soon, lhis wiooly-
holo oxplanalion of ioyal ano,oi pooplos failuios was focussoo on Yah-
woh.
. Assyiian kings woio nol conlonl wilh ooninaling lhoii vassals Lul woio
in nooo of a guaianlooo, iogulai liiLulo. 1hoy also holo lo lho clion
lhal lho conquoioo pooplos goo,s gavo lhon lho vicloiy.
z
. 1ho oofoal in of noilhoin Isiaol was naluially onough soon in con-
poling Juoah as a oivino punishnonl foi a vaiioly of sins, ospocially
polylhoisn Lul also iolaloo failuios of social juslico.
Loon: How coulo lhis calasliopho happon, whon lho pooplo ano a king
liko Josiah hao liioo lo chango lhoii Lohavioi
z
Al lho sano lino, poi-
haps, lho facl lhal inpoiial naslois ano oofoaloo pooplos changoo wilhin
aLoul uu yoais (Assyiia, LaLylonia; Isiaol, Juoah) noanl lhal lho
logic al woik was ooopoi lhan jusl a singlo olhnic goo Loing angiy wilh
his pooplo. 1his kino of sloiooscopic viow of hisloiy (Isiaol,Juoah
ano Assyiia,LaLylonia) was nol availaLlo lo olhoi noighLoiing suLjocl
pooplos such as lho Ihilislinos, MoaL, Annon, Loon, oi lho Aianoan
kingoons of Syiia.
1ho lhoughl occuiioo lo sono Juoaoans ano Isiaolilos lhal Yahwoh,
who was nol sinply inloiosloo in his cull Lul also juslico, ano who hao
usoo lwo gioal powois in luin, Lolh woll connocloo wilh lhoii own oivino
woilo, nusl havo Loon gioaloi lhan all of lhon, in spilo of appoaiancos oi
ialhoi on accounl of lhon. Ho nay havo hao a gioaloi cosnic, powoiful,
yol noio hiooon (ano lhoiofoio noio powoiful) iolo lhan ho was ciooiloo
wilh Lofoio.
Exile
Duiing lho socono oxilo, i.o. fion -S6 on, lho liansplanloo pails of lho
Juoaoan populalion (a fow lhousanos only in oioionl aioas of LaLylonia) now
hao a noio conplox oxplanalion foi lhoii silualion. 1hoy accoploo lho Dl-
fianoo pioniso lhal lhoy woio Loing punishoo, Lul lhoy also saw lhonsolvos
as an insliunonl of lho oivino will now piojocloo noio Lioaoly (ano wilh a
iapioly oovoloping iooa of lino ano hisloiy loaoing soon lo a conplox, coooo,
i.o. apocalyplic, viow of il).
Lzokiol.
Lul hoio,
il is piosonloo as acconpanying lho pooplo in lhoii oxilo lo LaLylon
(.6: 1hoiofoio say: 1hus says lho Loio GOD: 1hough I ionovoo
lhon fai away anong lho nalions, ano lhough I scalloioo lhon anong
lho counliios, yol I havo Loon a sancluaiy lo lhon foi a lilllo whilo
45
Ilsolf aclually lho isl piopholic bool, in lho sonso of a nishoo colloclion.
46
Niniuo: Ashuibanipal IIs soal in lho glh c. !C. Apaoana: nano of lho gioal auoionco
hall al !oisopolis ano Susa whoio !oisian lings iocoivoo liibulo fion all lho nalions in lho
Achaononio onpiio. Fiisl half of lh c. !CL.
47
Soo liloialuio on lhis guoslion.
[oi: lo sono oxlonl[ in lho counliios whoio lhoy havo gono.). So, lho
nolion of oivino noLilily poinils an oxlonsivo iovision of nonaichic ano
inpoiial sliucluios.
a chango in lho conliol of wiiling ano lho iopoaling of lho woios. Ano
so, lho nolion of juslico as oiioclly ooponoonl on lho oivinilyialhoi
lhan on kingsnoanl lhal inoivioual iosponsiLilily was iooonoo. Fui-
lhoinoio, a quoslioning of lho Douloiononisls viow of hisloiy cano
inlo Loing in oxilo. Ly which I noan: lho colloclivo punishnonl aspocl
of lho Douloiononisls oxplanalion of hisloiy coulo nol Lo accoploo
wholosalo Ly lhoso oxilos who foll lhoy woio liying lo puiify lhoii livos
in accoioanco piocisoly wilh lho Douloiononisls viow).
Socono phaso of olhnogonosis, oi lho ioal ono. 1wo inpoilanl lhings nusl
Lo iononLoioo in oiscussing lhis phaso. Ono, lho najoiily of lho pooplo io-
nainoo whoio lhoy woio, ospocially lho poasanliy oLviously. So, lho woios
oxilo ano posl-oxilo oo nol quilo oosciiLo lho silualion foi lho najoiily of
lho pooplo. Colonialisn as suggosloo Ly Gollwalo ano olhois Oi jusl noio
noulially: foioign ooninalion. Soconoly, whilo il is oasy lo poiliay Lzia-
Nohoniahs iofoins nogalivoly oi as lho piooucl of gioal polilical piossuio,
ospocially aLoul lho olhnic conposilion of lho pooplo, il is inpoilanl lo io-
nonLoi lhal lhoii oonilion goos (foi lho isl lino) Loyono lho usual linoago
napping.
In a silualion of oxilo, in lho nosaic-liko LaLylonian ano Ioisian onpiios,
Juoaoansano also Isiaolilos (Locauso of lho shaiing of liaoilions)hao lo
iospono lo lho oynanics of assinilalion ano ioonlily. 1ho Juoaoans know
oiioclly onanaling fion lho oivinily wilh lho solulion in Alhons of sinilai social pioblons
causoo by aiislocialic fanilios (bul nol bocauso of lho sano oxloinalilios: no onpiio). Solons
iofoin also ooos away wilh lings as inloinooiaiios, al aboul lho sano lino (boginning of Ulh
c.), foi sinilai ioasons, ano wilh sinilai fuilhoi ooiling ano iooologizing by laloi oonocials
in lho flh c. 1ho oangoi of lyianny is onni-piosonl, bul consislonlly foughl by lho
Lupaliioai ano olhoi loaoing fanilios. Ano of couiso no lhoociacy oi lings. !ul, nosl
inpoilanlly, an inloiosling, lonoo oown, appoal lo oivino aulhoiily in lho onacling of jusl
laws, al loasl in lho fiagnonlaiy poons of Solon wo havo. Much noio iosoaich nooos lo bo
oono on lhis voiy inpoilanl, sliucluially sinilai, ancionl socioly, ano lho snall nunboi of
possiblo polilical solulions nappoo oul noio syslonalically.
53
Soo Assmann, Of God and gods.
54
Soo Pleins, 1oiiiloiy ano 1onplo.
6
lho oangois of assinilalion as oio all ancionl pooplos.
ano lovilos, whoso own livolihooo ooponooo upon lhoii pioxinily lo lho pooplo
in villagos ano lowns.
1ho piioslly loaooiship, wilh lho sciiLos ano lovilos (hoio sloiios of long,
oicull nogolialions), founo lhonsolvos in chaigo afloi lho ovonlual conplolo
collapso of lho nonaichy.
Bibliography
Albertz, I. A history of Israelite religion in the Old Testament period.
Louisvillo, KY: Woslninsloi,John Knox Iioss, .
. Social hisloiy of ancionl Isiaol. Proceedings of the British Academy
(uu): 6.
Alt, A. Der Gott der Vter: ein Beitrag zur Vorgeschichte der israelitischen
Religion. Loiliago zui Wissonschafl von Allon uno Nouon 1oslanonl.
Folgo, Hofl . (Doi ganzon Sannlung, Hofl S). Slullgail: W. Kohlhan-
noi, .
Assmann, J. Of God and gods: Egypt, Israel, and the rise of monotheism.
Maoison: 1ho Univoisily of Wisconsin Iioss, uuS.
Bellah, I. N. Religion in human evolution: from the Paleolithic to the Axial
Age. CanLiiogo, Mass.: Lolknap Iioss of Haivaio Univoisily Iioss, u.
Bendix, I. Max Weber: an intel lectual portrait. no oo. Loikoloy: Univoisily
of Califoinia Iioss, .
Berman, J. Created equal: how the Bible broke with ancient political thought.
Oxfoio: Oxfoio Univoisily Iioss, uuS.
Bernat, D. A., ano J. Klawans. Religion and violence: the biblical heritage.
Vol. . Ioconl iosoaich in LiLlical sluoios. Shoolo: Shoolo Ihoonix
Iioss, uu.
Blenkinsopp, J. Isaiah : a new translation with introduction and com-
mentary. xvii, . Now Yoik: DouLlooay, uu.
67
Kuiosawas Kagemusha loaos no lo lhinl aboul lhis anbiguily. \ho oi whal is lho
ioal souico of aulhoiily ano woll-boing 1ho Shogun oi lho pooi wiolch
68
On lhis woio, soo Jenni, Das \oil ln ., ano Jenni, Das \oil ln z.
Smith, M. S. The early history of God. Yahweh and the other deities in ancient
Israel. San Fiancisco: Haipoi \ Iow, u.
Soler, J. La violence monothiste. Iaiis: Fallois, uuS.
Stark, I. For the glory of God: how monotheism led to reformations, science,
witch-hunts, and the end of slavery. Iiincolon, N.J.: Iiincolon Univoisily
Iioss, uu.
. The victory of reason: how Christianity led to freedom, capitalism,
and Western success. sl oo. Now Yoik: Ianoon Houso, uu.
Stavrakopoulou, F., ano J. Barton. Religious diversity in ancient Israel
and Judah. Lonoon: 1 \ 1 Claik, uu.
Testart, A. Lesclave, la dette et le pouvoir: tudes de sociologie comparative.
Iaiis: Liianco, uu.
Van ooi Toorn, K. Scribal culture and the making of the Hebrew Bible. Can-
Liiogo, Mass.: Haivaio Univoisily Iioss, uu.
Weber, M. Ancient judaism. Loiloo Ly H. Gerth ano D. Martindale. Now
Yoik: 1ho Fioo Iioss, .
Woodhouse, W. J. Solon the liberator. A study of the agrarian problem in
Attika in the seventh century. Now Yoik: Oclagon Looks, 6.
Wright, J. L. Rebuilding identity; the Nehemiah-memoir and its earliest
readers. Loilin: Walloi oo Giuyloi, uu.
. 1ho connonoialion of oofoal ano lho foinalion of a nalion in lho
HoLiow LiLlo. Prooftexts (u): .
Wright, I. The evolution of God. Now Yoik: Lilllo, Liown, uu.